I would willingly give serious cash to a Go Fund Me account for a fully restored version of Dune 1984, complete with ALL deleted scenes restored..the running time doesn't matter if Lynch's own version is finally realized.
@@henryb.little3399 I just got got back from shopping with my stiff bristled floor broom from Home Depot. FAAAATHEEERRRR, the SWEEEPER has AWAKENED!!!!!
David Lynch’s Dune is a masterpiece! Unfinished and not fully realized is still epic. I still watch it and I always will. He did a great job with what he had.
You were in once scene, with no dialogue, at the end of the movie in the room where Feyd and Paul have their duel. When I saw you there standing with the two Fremen children, I always wondered if you were playing Harah. It's nice to finally have confirmation of this and to see your performance on display.
That is one of my favorite scenes from the novel were Harah speaks about Alia to Jessica and I NEVER expected that David Lynch have filmed it!! Thanks for sharing this gem with all the Dune fans!!
@@jessicagudino8461 My unrealizable cinematic dream would be to see a director's cut of Dune with all the scenes that David Lynch filmed. Unfortunately, I fear that this will never happen given several statements from David Lynch when asked about this issue. I think it would be something truly EPIC.
They never should have changed her voice either. She's so unnerving here. The dub voice is meme quality. This is such an important scene. I can only imagine how much more tense the finale when she enters with the Baron and Emperor would be, them not knowing what a little psycho and how powerful she is until she slaps Helen around with her mind bullets. Jamis and Harah are so important to the character arc of Paul. It's disappointing that Denis only left half of their influence in his version.
@@SeanCC I miss Alia SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH in the Denis Villeneuve film!!! It's one of the most disappointing things see the character reduced to that cameo that only last a few seconds...
@@leandrodarko3721 Yeah, I was disappointed as well. It's effective cinematically, and removes dependence on finding a young enough kid that can actually act and pull it off without becoming unintentionally camp. Some decisions I have to divorce myself from what I know of the book for it to make sense. I have to believe he's making something for people who didn't read the book and who likely never will, which is most of the audience. Still, the Spicediver edit is the most complete telling of the story in the first book, even more so than that goofy Syfy miniseries (though they got better with Children of Dune, a little).
OMG, I've watched Lynch's version 100s of times over the decades, know every scene and line by heart. What a gem to find this after all these years. Sad Lynch cut it...should have at least included it as an "extra', in the subsequent releases. Thank you for providing this.
@@patreekotime4578the studio cut Allot of what Lynch filmed. He was a very unique director. His personal visions were not liked by most (not all) his peers.
@@FIDreams It wasnt about style. Mostly it was cut for time because the movie theatres were demanding shorter run times in those days to maximize profits. Just Part Two of the new film is as long as the entire long Lynch cut would have been.
I was disappointed at Harah's absence in the 1984 version. Her character arc offered detail about Fremen culture without someone having to voiceover-explain it. This clip seems to have Alicia Witt's actual voice, which is nice. Mr. Lynch was right; I can't picture anyone else as Harah. Thank you.
@@sid2112 I suppose you could see it that way, but I don't recall any mention of her consciousness being invaded by past egos at that point, more so that she was just aware of those past lives and experiences. She was still "her," and it was later after her own spice overdosing that she lost herself.
@@AllenSmithe At first, it was a cacophony of voices. After the Baron died, his voice became the primary. But the voices were always there. Remember, she was born with it, and this scene shows how the children find her unnatural. She even cows the Fremen lady with her voice as if trained it it for a lifetime. That's because she was, by numerous Reverend Mothers in contact with her. The voice is a trained thing, it's not naturally occurring. Herbert even made it a point in the books to write out different personalities manifesting through her life, the last manifestation being her own, when she died.
Before Lynch's version came out, I bought the book The Making of Dune and pored over it for every scrap of information I could find. I remember Molly Wryn being mentioned several times. She tried out the blue eye drops that were the first option considered for the Fremen characters, but I think they gave her a bad reaction. The book has pictures of her in various scenes, and I was looking forward to seeing her in the movie. When I saw that she'd been cut out almost entirely, I felt bad for her. I hope she feels a sense of victory in giving us this long-lost clip.
This version of Dune has a more spiritual vibe and can become better with all fully restored deleted scenes. Please, somebody do that. At the time people didn’t like much but in all this time 2:37 it became better and better like a real classic movie, which it actually is.
@@mikcnmvedmsfonoteka Yes, I did. But we clearly feel that there appears to be a big problem with rhythm in this non-professional edit... In the end, although interesting for the sake of cinematic curiosity, I still prefer the cinema version even though it was rejected by D Lynch. Kind regards, Antoine.
Wow, what a bummer. David Lynch's Dune was an awesome movie that got butchered to cut the time down. I wish it could be released how Lynch really wanted it to be.
I'm not sure it is a good movie. David lynch is a good director but never had huge love for the source material. Also he inserted some real weird stuff.
It’s too bad that the adaptations all leave Harah out - in the book, after Paul kills Jamis he leaves childhood behind completely and the fact that he “inherits” Harah and her kids makes that very clear.
Thank you for sharing both the story and the restored footage with us, gods it would have been better with this scene left in…..it ties so much together in a direct way.
Thank you Max Every! When DUNE was originally released in 1984, I saw it twice opening weekend. I was sixteen years old. I've always felt like I saw a different film than anyone else. No one liked it, or had no interest in seeing it. After The Elephant Man, I knew David Lynch was a genius. Dune proved it. And after all these years, you and SPICEDRIVER have gone above and beyond to show the world the truth of Lynch's vision. Please continue the crusade!
Such an awesome find! Max, your book is AMAZING and one of the best "making of" books I've ever read! As a life-long fan of this film, THANK YOU! Thank you for the book and for its leading to uncovering this footage as well as Lynch's Dune 2 script outline! You are the Kwisatz Haderach for us Dune fans!
They have to make an official Spicedediver cut in true 4k.Even his cut feels like a clipshow in the 3rd act due to further missing scenes. A release and comic adaptation with actors likenesses of the half completed Dune Messiah script would also be killer. Both for Herbert and Lynch fans.
Yes! When I saw this cut scene my first thought was how awesome it would be if someone could do another SpiceDiver edit and include this, and other cut scenes that have surfaced over time. With today's technology I'm sure they could make an AWESOME version of Lynch's film. I'm even pretty sure, using advanced AI, they may even be able to "create" some missing scenes (i.e. banquet, Fenring, etc.)
Thank you for bringing this to us. When I see films of grand scope, I want every character to have their own film all to themselves. Your story and Alia's would share this scene.
While I am grateful I can see the restored footage, I am watching this just after watching the Spicediver cut for the first time.... and it makes me feel sad. I felt like even Spicediver's cut was missing something, and this confirms that there is even more cut footage out there. It's possible that the legendary 4 hour cut was real. I would much rather see what all the cast and crewmembers worked so hard on than Jodorowsky's Dune. This feels like lost media.
A travest that this was cut. It's inexcusable here and also in the Villeneuve version to have erased the story of Jamis' family. Pointless and stupid. So glad I found this video!
The scene with Harrah and Alia in the novel is the most emotional in the entire series or anything I’ve read IMO. How Harrah loves Alia unconditionally and how the other Fremen don’t understand and Alia knowing she’s strange. This clip only had a portion of that. I don’t think the new films will have the scene either which is a shame.
They rewrote quite a bit in the new movie. It was visually interesting, but disappointing otherwise. I'll take the Lynch and ScyFy adaptions over Villaneuve's.
@@ThomB1031 What was disapointing? Lynch's version does not work at all! Sure, the ambience is amazing but it's a mess of a movie. The TV adaption was the best but it's budget was limited. The new version is great, he had to cut a lot but otherwise it wouldn't flow or make sense to teh audience. That's just the nature of not making it a 10 hour movie
@@chrispekel5709 saying he had to cut stuff would be a valid excuse if he was the first to adapt Dune, or if Lynch and the TV series had failed to include the same things in their adaptions. As it is, DV's adaption has nice visuals, but otherwise falls short of the previous adaptions.
As someone that's seen both versions of the movie at least 100 times, thank you for sharing. This is truly a lost scene and not cheap click bait. I always thought that the extra plot thread of Jamis, his wife, and the ramifications/relationship to Paul should have stayed.
Wow, thank you for sharing your powerful story and sadly deleted scene but to see it here now restored gives one hope that with today’s technology anything really is possible and David Lynch could ultimately have his final creative cut, something, all those who cherish DUNE 1984 would want.
Let the haters hate...I will ALWAYS respect & love this version of Dune! It was a real eye opener to this then 14 year old kid, although some time went by before I read the main trilogy & even then I did a re-watch & still enjoy it to this day. Each successive Director since has done well with their respective 'visions' & I also rate them high. The novels are indeed complex & diverse with themes of power, politics, religion, violence, etc. So ANY attempt to be 100% faithful would be difficult unless the budget is there...IMO
Man everyone involved actually did a very good job in this, it's going to have to go into the spicedriver edit somewhere. Glad to see you obtained it somehow, I don't think the boys editing the spicedriver version had it. If you have any more please do be sure to post them for posterity.
Thank you for sharing this. Even though there are many jerks who complain about good movies like this version of Dune, but I absolutely loved it. I liked all the versions, but this is the one that inspired me to read the novels.
I've always wanted to learn more about Harah and felt she needed to be in more of the film, heartbreaking indeed that her screen time was so cut out. Most beautiful woman in the movie in my opinion.
So we only have this because they probably gave it to her for a professional 'reel'... like a video resume for actors. I suspect Dino had the negatives destroyed that was not included in the theatrical cut done by his daughter. Lot of stuff cut out that actors didn't even get to keep. Coming into the city. The palace garden. So sad.
Amazing to see this after such a long time, I presume the sound effects would have been added over Alia's voice, this was raw audio. Max Evry's book indicates Lynch's preferred edit would have been about 3 hours. Come on David, we are all waiting. I wonder if there is any existing footage of Rabban in the bathtub. Its not clear if they got a usable shot due to Paul Smith's nervousness about getting electrocuted after smashing an oil filled light bulb above him. It's detailed on the late Kit West's website.
To all fans of Alicia Witt(Alia), she appears in season five of Justified. She is Wendy Crowe, the redheaded paralegal who is Daryl Crowe's sister, part of the Dewey Crow clan. She did great. Loved seeing the little Dune character all grown up. For those who don't know, Harah was the wife of Jamis, the Fremen Paul killed as part of being accepted by the Fremen. She became Paul's responsibility when Paul killed Jamis. I found it hard to understand what Alia was saying. I think she said the following: "Would they deny me that which is mine? Would they deny me the use of spice?"
This would be more complete if the same audio effect was applied to Alia when she shouts the word “VOICE” as was applied to Paul / Muad'Dib when he shouts “Traitor” after killing Feyd in the OG movie. (And also same overall effect on her whole lines as Jessica had when saying “Release my bonds” etc in the ornithopter).
TY both Max and Molly ! I'm the same as many others here - saw the original release 11 times in theatres, and likely hundreds more on all home video formats, as well as Spice Diver's cut. Read anything I could get my hands on - including a 2nd draft script. This gives me hope that more "workprint" footage may yet surface. If only the studio would get behind a proper restoration - Max, do you think enough WP footage still exists to warrant it ?
As arguably flawed as this version was, it’s still in many ways closer to the original story than some others, including the latest adaptation. And now when scenes like this come to light, I’m even more convinced of it.
Thank you for adding this. It was an incredible shame this role was all but cut from the release, other than appearing in the final great hall scene (without explanation). And then a few of the other deleted scenes when Jamis was also included. I was surprised the role was not included in the Dune 2, especially as Jamis had a far greater role in the new Dune even compared to the Lynch uncut version. Would love to see a full version with EVERYTHING that Lynch shot.
Sadly, when you make a 4 hour movie and the Studio steps in and cuts it to fit into a 2 hour run time, somebody's going to end up on the cutting room floor. The Extended version of David Lynch's Dune helps to make more sense of the narrative, but it's just a lengthy story. To her credit, there's more emotional weight in this one scene, than all of these latest CGIfests. And A greater range of visual design and especially COLOR.
Had the pleasure of seeing the film in the theatre last month... such a jewel of a film on the big screen! Is this for a fan edit restoration? I hope some audio work will be done... alot of cleanup needs to happen to get this up to parr.
Me too! Nostalgia thrill despite the short running time. Having seen the longer versions, the shorter version was still fun because I could "fill in the blanks".
@@caronstout354 pretty sure it's wife or slave, release was only after a year iirc. Could be misrememboring that though. He chooses slave and she's upset because she protests that she's still young enough to be desireable.
Don’t remember this being in Spicediver’s extended edit. Could work if the audio on Alia’s voice was effected in Adobe Audition. Spicediver’s cut is 12 years old now. With all the advances in deepfake, AI, and powerful consumer fx suites, it’s time for a Extended Redux.
So cool! Thank you for this fascinating glimpse behind the scenes and this scene in particular. I love the new adaptations but really miss the eerie tiny Alia freaking the Bene Gesserit and Harkonens out! Getting to see Molly Wryn and Alicia Witt in some new footage is awesome.
Thanks for sharing! Read the tantalizing mentions of seeing Molly's deleted scene(s) in your book and I'm so happy we're able to see this! Are there any more deleted scenes she has, or is this the only one? I assume this is Alicia's actual voice from production? Surprised that she's so commanding, though the last part with "spiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice!" is a bit much. :)
Alicia was a bit too young for the part in fairness. Harah is literally you in my mind from reading the books, an elven faced beauty unblemished by grief and hardship. A fierce and loyal woman to her tribe.
The Fremen woman and the two children...the Pug! Is there a relationship? As a child seeing this on UK TV in the late 80s, I was drawn to the two children and the woman standing behind them in the final scene of the film. I didn't understand their significance, but I knew they were important because they were closer to the center of the room than the other Fremen, and about as close as the villians - and one of the children was holding an Atredies Pug, which the Duke himself was holding earlier in the film. Even to this day I'm convinced that the Pugs are key to everything in Dune!
The spice must flow, and they who control the spice of the deleted scenes, all together with the original film and all those that follow, control the Dune movie universe.
I would willingly give serious cash to a Go Fund Me account for a fully restored version of Dune 1984, complete with ALL deleted scenes restored..the running time doesn't matter if Lynch's own version is finally realized.
Unfortunately, there never will be a full length David Lynch version. The theatrical cut is the only version that will ever have his name on it.
The closest is the spicedivers edit. Its available on youtube for free!
@Coobacca it may not have his name, but the spicediver edit is pretty close i believe to the original vision
@@thomasel9171 yeah it's good it's probably as close as we'll ever get.
The Third Stage fan edit was really good.
Best version. Hands down. Would love to see a director's cut that was 6 hours long.
Look up Dune 1984 Spice Diver edit on UA-cam. It's a fan project that is the most complete version of Dune you'll find. It's 3 hours long.
this version is pretty complete
ua-cam.com/video/vJykw3H4PDw/v-deo.html
Those who possess the workprint VHS, control the universe.
Those who control the splice control the universe!
@@henryb.little3399 I just got got back from shopping with my stiff bristled floor broom from Home Depot.
FAAAATHEEERRRR, the SWEEEPER has AWAKENED!!!!!
David Lynch’s Dune is a masterpiece! Unfinished and not fully realized is still epic. I still watch it and I always will. He did a great job with what he had.
I still love the atmosphere of this version. The scene with Jessica and Harah, what a shame it was cut.
Have you seen Spicediver's edit?
You were in once scene, with no dialogue, at the end of the movie in the room where Feyd and Paul have their duel. When I saw you there standing with the two Fremen children, I always wondered if you were playing Harah. It's nice to finally have confirmation of this and to see your performance on display.
@InhumanCondition-gh2qj Which 4 hour version? I've never seen a 4 hour version.
@@LMD2915look for the spicediver edit here on UA-cam in 4k
That is one of my favorite scenes from the novel were Harah speaks about Alia to Jessica and I NEVER expected that David Lynch have filmed it!! Thanks for sharing this gem with all the Dune fans!!
Lynch really tried to respected herbert novel, is a shame that the Dilaurentis didnt have the vision to divide in 2 parts the movie
@@jessicagudino8461 My unrealizable cinematic dream would be to see a director's cut of Dune with all the scenes that David Lynch filmed. Unfortunately, I fear that this will never happen given several statements from David Lynch when asked about this issue. I think it would be something truly EPIC.
They never should have changed her voice either. She's so unnerving here. The dub voice is meme quality. This is such an important scene. I can only imagine how much more tense the finale when she enters with the Baron and Emperor would be, them not knowing what a little psycho and how powerful she is until she slaps Helen around with her mind bullets.
Jamis and Harah are so important to the character arc of Paul. It's disappointing that Denis only left half of their influence in his version.
@@SeanCC I miss Alia SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH in the Denis Villeneuve film!!! It's one of the most disappointing things see the character reduced to that cameo that only last a few seconds...
@@leandrodarko3721 Yeah, I was disappointed as well. It's effective cinematically, and removes dependence on finding a young enough kid that can actually act and pull it off without becoming unintentionally camp.
Some decisions I have to divorce myself from what I know of the book for it to make sense. I have to believe he's making something for people who didn't read the book and who likely never will, which is most of the audience. Still, the Spicediver edit is the most complete telling of the story in the first book, even more so than that goofy Syfy miniseries (though they got better with Children of Dune, a little).
Molly is terrific! It's such a shame she was cut but I'm glad we finally got to see her vulnerable performance in this.
I agree! She has an ethereal presence.
OMG, I've watched Lynch's version 100s of times over the decades, know every scene and line by heart. What a gem to find this after all these years. Sad Lynch cut it...should have at least included it as an "extra', in the subsequent releases. Thank you for providing this.
Lynch didn't do the cut. The studio did.
Glad you liked it!
@@patreekotime4578Butchers!
@@patreekotime4578the studio cut Allot of what Lynch filmed.
He was a very unique director. His personal visions were not liked by most (not all) his peers.
@@FIDreams It wasnt about style. Mostly it was cut for time because the movie theatres were demanding shorter run times in those days to maximize profits. Just Part Two of the new film is as long as the entire long Lynch cut would have been.
I was disappointed at Harah's absence in the 1984 version. Her character arc offered detail about Fremen culture without someone having to voiceover-explain it.
This clip seems to have Alicia Witt's actual voice, which is nice. Mr. Lynch was right; I can't picture anyone else as Harah. Thank you.
I keep seeing more and more deleted scenes from this movie on UA-cam. I hope they bring it all together one day.
I am so sorry your scenes were cut, especially this one.
That's cool. It defines a bit of Alia from the book, how she was beginning to be taken over by the abomination.
She wasn't taken over by this point in the story tho
@@AllenSmithe That process started before she was born and culminated in her possession by the Baron. It began to manifest almost immediately.
@@sid2112 I suppose you could see it that way, but I don't recall any mention of her consciousness being invaded by past egos at that point, more so that she was just aware of those past lives and experiences. She was still "her," and it was later after her own spice overdosing that she lost herself.
@@AllenSmithe At first, it was a cacophony of voices. After the Baron died, his voice became the primary. But the voices were always there. Remember, she was born with it, and this scene shows how the children find her unnatural. She even cows the Fremen lady with her voice as if trained it it for a lifetime. That's because she was, by numerous Reverend Mothers in contact with her. The voice is a trained thing, it's not naturally occurring. Herbert even made it a point in the books to write out different personalities manifesting through her life, the last manifestation being her own, when she died.
@@sid2112 that doesn't happen until Children. And the scrambling doesn't happen until after spice overdose.
Before Lynch's version came out, I bought the book The Making of Dune and pored over it for every scrap of information I could find. I remember Molly Wryn being mentioned several times. She tried out the blue eye drops that were the first option considered for the Fremen characters, but I think they gave her a bad reaction. The book has pictures of her in various scenes, and I was looking forward to seeing her in the movie. When I saw that she'd been cut out almost entirely, I felt bad for her. I hope she feels a sense of victory in giving us this long-lost clip.
I love it when any lost media is found and restored to full state.
Spicediver dune edit! Search, it is here on UA-cam It is a real treasure!
Forgot how much I loved this score.
It's so good. It's on internet archive for free.
I listen to the extended version often. It is one of my favourites, up there with Blade Runner and Gladiator.
This score is beautiful
Hands Zimmer himself would be proud. This is almost as great as the Hans Zimmer Soundtrack.
I love the 84 score. Still listening to it.
This version of Dune has a more spiritual vibe and can become better with all fully restored deleted scenes. Please, somebody do that. At the time people didn’t like much but in all this time 2:37 it became better and better like a real classic movie, which it actually is.
Did you saw the spicediver edit here on UA-cam?
I am a Dune's fan and it's crazy to finally discover these footage come back to life... Thank you !
Have you seen Spicediver edit !?
@@mikcnmvedmsfonoteka Yes, I did. But we clearly feel that there appears to be a big problem with rhythm in this non-professional edit... In the end, although interesting for the sake of cinematic curiosity, I still prefer the cinema version even though it was rejected by D Lynch. Kind regards, Antoine.
Wow, what a bummer. David Lynch's Dune was an awesome movie that got butchered to cut the time down. I wish it could be released how Lynch really wanted it to be.
Lynch hates the movie, and will never do a directors cut.
I'm not sure it is a good movie. David lynch is a good director but never had huge love for the source material. Also he inserted some real weird stuff.
@@murphy7801OTOH, a lot of the weird stuff was straight from the novel.
Lynch was the wrong director for Dune. His narratives never match a Dune type story so was the wrong type of director.
Search for the Dune Spicediver edit here on UA-cam !
Whoah this is intense. To have Alia scream at you must have been terrifying. So happy this exists. Dune 1984 is the most beautiful movie ever made.
It’s too bad that the adaptations all leave Harah out - in the book, after Paul kills Jamis he leaves childhood behind completely and the fact that he “inherits” Harah and her kids makes that very clear.
Thank you for sharing both the story and the restored footage with us, gods it would have been better with this scene left in…..it ties so much together in a direct way.
Thank you Max Every! When DUNE was originally released in 1984, I saw it twice opening weekend. I was sixteen years old. I've always felt like I saw a different film than anyone else. No one liked it, or had no interest in seeing it. After The Elephant Man, I knew David Lynch was a genius. Dune proved it. And after all these years, you and SPICEDRIVER have gone above and beyond to show the world the truth of Lynch's vision. Please continue the crusade!
The vision for this movie was amazing. I wish Lynch had been able to put it all together.
This scene looks so LYNCHIAN, moreso than some scenes in the final cut.
Such an awesome find! Max, your book is AMAZING and one of the best "making of" books I've ever read! As a life-long fan of this film, THANK YOU! Thank you for the book and for its leading to uncovering this footage as well as Lynch's Dune 2 script outline! You are the Kwisatz Haderach for us Dune fans!
Amazing to see this, I loved this movie since I was a child and it is still my favorite version of Dune
Lynch understood and captured the inherent strangeness of Herbert's Dune universe.
That is an amazing scene... I need a fully restored version of Dune, Thank you for sharing this !!!!❤
Todos necesitamos ver la version completa de david linch hagamos algo para que eso ocurra algo tenemos que hacer si nunca la vamos a ver completa
They have to make an official Spicedediver cut in true 4k.Even his cut feels like a clipshow in the 3rd act due to further missing scenes. A release and comic adaptation with actors likenesses of the half completed Dune Messiah script would also be killer. Both for Herbert and Lynch fans.
Yes! When I saw this cut scene my first thought was how awesome it would be if someone could do another SpiceDiver edit and include this, and other cut scenes that have surfaced over time. With today's technology I'm sure they could make an AWESOME version of Lynch's film. I'm even pretty sure, using advanced AI, they may even be able to "create" some missing scenes (i.e. banquet, Fenring, etc.)
Thank you for bringing this to us. When I see films of grand scope, I want every character to have their own film all to themselves. Your story and Alia's would share this scene.
You're welcome!
While I am grateful I can see the restored footage, I am watching this just after watching the Spicediver cut for the first time.... and it makes me feel sad. I felt like even Spicediver's cut was missing something, and this confirms that there is even more cut footage out there. It's possible that the legendary 4 hour cut was real. I would much rather see what all the cast and crewmembers worked so hard on than Jodorowsky's Dune. This feels like lost media.
Thanks I didn't expect that. Her voice startled me, but it was cool, I love it.
I guess it was meant to be modified in post...
A travest that this was cut. It's inexcusable here and also in the Villeneuve version to have erased the story of Jamis' family. Pointless and stupid. So glad I found this video!
The scene with Harrah and Alia in the novel is the most emotional in the entire series or anything I’ve read IMO. How Harrah loves Alia unconditionally and how the other Fremen don’t understand and Alia knowing she’s strange. This clip only had a portion of that. I don’t think the new films will have the scene either which is a shame.
SPOILER ALERT: Nope, not in the new film.
They rewrote quite a bit in the new movie. It was visually interesting, but disappointing otherwise. I'll take the Lynch and ScyFy adaptions over Villaneuve's.
@@ThomB1031 What was disapointing? Lynch's version does not work at all! Sure, the ambience is amazing but it's a mess of a movie. The TV adaption was the best but it's budget was limited. The new version is great, he had to cut a lot but otherwise it wouldn't flow or make sense to teh audience. That's just the nature of not making it a 10 hour movie
@@chrispekel5709 saying he had to cut stuff would be a valid excuse if he was the first to adapt Dune, or if Lynch and the TV series had failed to include the same things in their adaptions. As it is, DV's adaption has nice visuals, but otherwise falls short of the previous adaptions.
As someone that's seen both versions of the movie at least 100 times, thank you for sharing. This is truly a lost scene and not cheap click bait.
I always thought that the extra plot thread of Jamis, his wife, and the ramifications/relationship to Paul should have stayed.
Wow, thank you for sharing your powerful story and sadly deleted scene but to see it here now restored gives one hope that with today’s technology anything really is possible and David Lynch could ultimately have his final creative cut, something, all those who cherish DUNE 1984 would want.
Thank you very much for sharing. Delighted to see your scenes.
Brilliant performances in an extraordinary scene. Bravo!!!
Wow....I have never seen this before. Thanks for posting this.
This is amazing! It's so unfair they cut Molly Wryn's scenes. She is great as Harah. And this scene is really good!
Let the haters hate...I will ALWAYS respect & love this version of Dune!
It was a real eye opener to this then 14 year old kid, although some time went by before I read the main trilogy & even then I did a re-watch & still enjoy it to this day.
Each successive Director since has done well with their respective 'visions' & I also rate them high.
The novels are indeed complex & diverse with themes of power, politics, religion, violence, etc.
So ANY attempt to be 100% faithful would be difficult unless the budget is there...IMO
This was a marvelous surprise! Thank you for sharing. 💕
Man everyone involved actually did a very good job in this, it's going to have to go into the spicedriver edit somewhere. Glad to see you obtained it somehow, I don't think the boys editing the spicedriver version had it. If you have any more please do be sure to post them for posterity.
Powerful scene! Thank you for sharing ❤️
Wonderful scene!!! Thank you!!!!
Excellent work!
Thank you for sharing this. Even though there are many jerks who complain about good movies like this version of Dune, but I absolutely loved it. I liked all the versions, but this is the one that inspired me to read the novels.
What a nice treat. Thank you for sharing!
Thanks you for you work Molly Wryn. Also thank you to jessica and Alia. *The film make more sense with your work.*
Very exquisite performance!!! ❤❤❤❤
Thanks for sharing that! I’m a huge film of the 1984 film and have seen every ‘cut’ available. Never seen this scene before! A treat. Thanks.
This scene is amazing!!
I've always wanted to learn more about Harah and felt she needed to be in more of the film, heartbreaking indeed that her screen time was so cut out. Most beautiful woman in the movie in my opinion.
Wonderful scene, thank you.
This was super fun, great job everyone.
I was wondering what to watch tonight.
Spicediver Dune it is!
I hope more scenes can come to light and be included in further re-edits.
Alicia was jaw-dropping. She truly portrayed an adult person (persons) in a little girl's body.
This is great. It reminds of all the great things in the movie.
She was a great Hara. The moments of brilliance in the Dune 1984 taken together are vastly superior to both new Dune movies combined.
Wish we could get the ultimate Lynch version
So we only have this because they probably gave it to her for a professional 'reel'... like a video resume for actors. I suspect Dino had the negatives destroyed that was not included in the theatrical cut done by his daughter. Lot of stuff cut out that actors didn't even get to keep. Coming into the city. The palace garden. So sad.
Amazing to see this after such a long time, I presume the sound effects would have been added over Alia's voice, this was raw audio. Max Evry's book indicates Lynch's preferred edit would have been about 3 hours. Come on David, we are all waiting. I wonder if there is any existing footage of Rabban in the bathtub. Its not clear if they got a usable shot due to Paul Smith's nervousness about getting electrocuted after smashing an oil filled light bulb above him. It's detailed on the late Kit West's website.
To all fans of Alicia Witt(Alia), she appears in season five of Justified. She is Wendy Crowe, the redheaded paralegal who is Daryl Crowe's sister, part of the Dewey Crow clan. She did great. Loved seeing the little Dune character all grown up. For those who don't know, Harah was the wife of Jamis, the Fremen Paul killed as part of being accepted by the Fremen. She became Paul's responsibility when Paul killed Jamis. I found it hard to understand what Alia was saying. I think she said the following: "Would they deny me that which is mine? Would they deny me the use of spice?"
I wish the original Dune was redone with this scene WITH Molly and all of Molly's deleted scene work along with everything else.
This would be more complete if the same audio effect was applied to Alia when she shouts the word “VOICE” as was applied to Paul / Muad'Dib when he shouts “Traitor” after killing Feyd in the OG movie. (And also same overall effect on her whole lines as Jessica had when saying “Release my bonds” etc in the ornithopter).
She is the perfect Harrah
You can tell she still feels sad that all of her scenes were cut. I'm glad these scenes can be seen now.
Just when you think that you know everything there is to know about Dune...you realize...you never will...
Best dune movie. It should be better restored every single missing scene.
TY both Max and Molly ! I'm the same as many others here - saw the original release 11 times in theatres, and likely hundreds more on all home video formats, as well as Spice Diver's cut. Read anything I could get my hands on - including a 2nd draft script. This gives me hope that more "workprint" footage may yet surface. If only the studio would get behind a proper restoration - Max, do you think enough WP footage still exists to warrant it ?
As arguably flawed as this version was, it’s still in many ways closer to the original story than some others, including the latest adaptation. And now when scenes like this come to light, I’m even more convinced of it.
Love it! Disturbing and amazing at the same time
Thank you for adding this. It was an incredible shame this role was all but cut from the release, other than appearing in the final great hall scene (without explanation). And then a few of the other deleted scenes when Jamis was also included. I was surprised the role was not included in the Dune 2, especially as Jamis had a far greater role in the new Dune even compared to the Lynch uncut version. Would love to see a full version with EVERYTHING that Lynch shot.
Wow that's awesome 🙇☺️
Sadly, when you make a 4 hour movie and the Studio steps in and cuts it to fit into a 2 hour run time, somebody's going to end up on the cutting room floor. The Extended version of David Lynch's Dune helps to make more sense of the narrative, but it's just a lengthy story. To her credit, there's more emotional weight in this one scene, than all of these latest CGIfests. And A greater range of visual design and especially COLOR.
Had the pleasure of seeing the film in the theatre last month... such a jewel of a film on the big screen! Is this for a fan edit restoration? I hope some audio work will be done... alot of cleanup needs to happen to get this up to parr.
Me too! Nostalgia thrill despite the short running time. Having seen the longer versions, the shorter version was still fun because I could "fill in the blanks".
Is Harah the widow of Jamis, who Paul takes under his wing along with their children?
Yes; the same one. You see more of her in the TV version
She was the wife of Jamis, now Paul's..he has a period of time to decide if he wishes to keep her as his wife or release her.
@@caronstout354 pretty sure it's wife or slave, release was only after a year iirc. Could be misrememboring that though. He chooses slave and she's upset because she protests that she's still young enough to be desireable.
pretty sure he has the option of marrying her or taking her as his slave, and chose the later
I am not surprised this scene was cut, absolutely horrific.
I always thought she would have made a better Chani than Sean Young.
She looks a bit too old
@@chrispekel5709Lol whut??? TF are you talking about? No way she looks too old.
@@flybeep1661 she's supposed to be 14 in the books.
@@flybeep1661 actually, I'm wrong. Chani in the books was in her 20's apparently. My memory sucks, my bad
Love the film just adore it
Wow! The more that is revealed the better it gets
Fantastic!❤
Don’t remember this being in Spicediver’s extended edit. Could work if the audio on Alia’s voice was effected in Adobe Audition. Spicediver’s cut is 12 years old now. With all the advances in deepfake, AI, and powerful consumer fx suites, it’s time for a Extended Redux.
Thank you for sharing this wrongfully deleted scene! Ms Molly, you're hot!
I appreciate to this piece of knowledge from this movie. Who knows how many more they had it hidden or tossed in the editing room.
So cool! Thank you for this fascinating glimpse behind the scenes and this scene in particular. I love the new adaptations but really miss the eerie tiny Alia freaking the Bene Gesserit and Harkonens out! Getting to see Molly Wryn and Alicia Witt in some new footage is awesome.
Thanks for sharing! Read the tantalizing mentions of seeing Molly's deleted scene(s) in your book and I'm so happy we're able to see this! Are there any more deleted scenes she has, or is this the only one?
I assume this is Alicia's actual voice from production? Surprised that she's so commanding, though the last part with "spiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice!" is a bit much. :)
So Sad this scene was cut! Wow! I wonder if it's in Spicediver's edition.
She’s definitely in the director’s cut!!!! The version I like best!!!!!
What a beauty...
Soooo cool!!!
It's a shame that the studio cut it. They basically cut hours from the movie.
Alicia was a bit too young for the part in fairness. Harah is literally you in my mind from reading the books, an elven faced beauty unblemished by grief and hardship. A fierce and loyal woman to her tribe.
The cut scenes must flow.
We need it restored in a directors issue!!!
The Fremen woman and the two children...the Pug! Is there a relationship?
As a child seeing this on UK TV in the late 80s, I was drawn to the two children and the woman standing behind them in the final scene of the film. I didn't understand their significance, but I knew they were important because they were closer to the center of the room than the other Fremen, and about as close as the villians - and one of the children was holding an Atredies Pug, which the Duke himself was holding earlier in the film.
Even to this day I'm convinced that the Pugs are key to everything in Dune!
We have two and they have some very special powers, the most notable are eating and farting.
based, maybe they can get that in the next spicedriver edited 4k version.
I'd pay good money to get this movie with all scenes 4k restored just name the price.
The spice must flow, and they who control the spice of the deleted scenes, all together with the original film and all those that follow, control the Dune movie universe.