Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.

Ukraine Soldier (Russia's Invasion of Ukraine 1921)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 вер 2024
  • 2nd Channel: / @simplehistorylive
    Become a Simple History member: www.youtube.co...
    Support us on Patreon: / simplehistory
    A look at a Ukraine soldier of the Soviet Ukrainian War 1917-1921
    Copyright: DO NOT translate and re-upload our content on UA-cam or other social media.
    SIMPLE HISTORY MERCHANDISE
    Get the Simple History books on Amazon:
    www.amazon.com...
    T-Shirts
    teespring.com/...
    Simple history gives you the facts, simple!
    See the book collection here:
    Amazon USA
    www.amazon.com/...
    Amazon UK
    www.amazon.co.u...
    / simple-history-5494376...
    / simplehistoryyt
    Credit:
    Created by Daniel Turner (B.A. (Hons) in History, University College London)
    Script: Dejan Milivojevic
    Narrator:
    Bryan 'Lazlo' Beauregard

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,2 тис.

  • @superforresttie1032
    @superforresttie1032 Рік тому +1230

    "Those who do not learn History are doomed to repeat it"

    • @ferdinandc.ashley814
      @ferdinandc.ashley814 Рік тому +120

      Those who read about history are doomed to watch others repeat it.

    • @Burvedys
      @Burvedys Рік тому +21

      And happy are those who are ignorant of a history. :)))

    • @schris3
      @schris3 Рік тому +30

      And those who don't want to learn history, are preparing themselves to repeat it.

    • @Burvedys
      @Burvedys Рік тому +9

      @@schris3 and that's what we see now in Ukraine.

    • @TheEnabledDisabled
      @TheEnabledDisabled Рік тому +14

      @@Burvedys ww2 Russia is calling they want their equipemnt back

  • @mercenarygundam1487
    @mercenarygundam1487 Рік тому +2208

    And history repeats itself

    • @Typhlosion-hx8pv
      @Typhlosion-hx8pv Рік тому +125

      It's repeated itself in Ukraine twice now, with the same result looking pretty clear within the next year or so

    • @iliketrains6235
      @iliketrains6235 Рік тому +182

      Can't wait for 2039

    • @Ruslan-ps9rz
      @Ruslan-ps9rz Рік тому +215

      Yes. But we much more stronger than 100 years ago and have good friends and partners. Now we must broke their forewer.

    • @Strelok762
      @Strelok762 Рік тому +2

      It always does

    • @daniel-johnson_dam
      @daniel-johnson_dam Рік тому +40

      But this time its breaking a promise the newly formed russian republic made ugraine signed a treaty in 1992 so that they give all their nuclear weapons back (there was so many soviet military equipment stocked there that ukraine had the third strongest army in the world

  • @F4Wildcat
    @F4Wildcat Рік тому +658

    As a firearm historic amateur it does Joy to my heart to see the correct rifles in the correct locations & time. The steyr M95's rifle used by infantry and the stutzen's for the cavalry. The gewehr 98 has an UNBLUED reciever, wich is 100% accurate. ww1 gewehr 98's did not had that! The mosin nagant at 4:04 is period correct, as it is not an m91-30. The reciever has its origenal shape! Very good! The bolt however was not blued IIRC

    • @yetanother9127
      @yetanother9127 Рік тому +30

      NEEEEERD! (I say approvingly)

    • @F4Wildcat
      @F4Wildcat Рік тому +14

      @@yetanother9127 Thank you!

    • @Schrodingers_kid
      @Schrodingers_kid Рік тому +3

      I think I saw M44 Mosins...

    • @Real_Mick3y6
      @Real_Mick3y6 Рік тому +4

      I have a question for you. My great grandfather was a Ukrainian conscripted into the Red Army, he lost some of his fingers in an accident while loading his gun I believe. I've been searching for what it could be to no avail and the only thing I've found is the PTRD, but that thing just explodes. I don't know if it was a Mosin, but that seems most likely. Do you have any idea what it would be?

    • @F4Wildcat
      @F4Wildcat Рік тому +8

      @@Real_Mick3y6 Do you think it might be the PTRS? its a semi-auto anti tank rifle, if a cartridge would premature detonate before the bolt closed or he would got his fingers into the action, thats a recipe for losing his fingers.

  • @paleoph6168
    @paleoph6168 Рік тому +597

    It's nice to see Simple History making videos like these again, now with better art and animation.

    • @larochejaquelein3680
      @larochejaquelein3680 Рік тому +10

      Einstein once wrote that history is a wheel, for the nature of man is fundamentally unchanging. What has happened before will perforce happen again, he said. I think of that whenever I contemplate Putin.

    • @SlyCooper1920
      @SlyCooper1920 Рік тому +6

      It's evolving by each video

    • @paleoph6168
      @paleoph6168 Рік тому

      @@larochejaquelein3680 oh no, not you. :/

    • @Yolbosun
      @Yolbosun Рік тому

      @@larochejaquelein3680 most men have ignorance and prejudice
      Easy to rule

    • @Yolbosun
      @Yolbosun Рік тому +4

      Simply propaganda
      Coloring books

  • @cooperwilliams9140
    @cooperwilliams9140 Рік тому +465

    You should really do a video on the Steyr M.95! It's a commonly looked over piece of history, but it has served in just as many wars as the Mosin!

    • @larochejaquelein3680
      @larochejaquelein3680 Рік тому +4

      Einstein once wrote that history is a wheel, for the nature of man is fundamentally unchanging. What has happened before will perforce happen again, he said. I think of that whenever I contemplate Putin.

    • @Mr3344555
      @Mr3344555 Рік тому +18

      @@larochejaquelein3680 bro what? He's talking about a piece of equipement not an ideology or a long gone state. You just wanna type at this point

    • @scottcantdance804
      @scottcantdance804 Рік тому +11

      @@Mr3344555 guarantee he's copy+pasting that BS everywhere

    • @antoine10001
      @antoine10001 Рік тому +4

      @@scottcantdance804 he is unfortunately

    • @DDubb007
      @DDubb007 Рік тому +2

      My buddy has an M95. Your certainly right, I would even be willing to bet there’s one been shot at Russian soldiers or Ukrainian soldiers rather recently. They can literally be found around the world. Personally not a fan of the action but I did shoot one off my back porch… in a neighborhood. I wouldn’t recommend that one.

  • @moch.farisdzulfiqar6123
    @moch.farisdzulfiqar6123 Рік тому +107

    Now I want an RTS game with Simple History's aesthetic 🤤

    • @brendanmorris2679
      @brendanmorris2679 Рік тому +9

      Yeah,funny he chose aoe4 for the inspiration on the rts scene.

  • @steveraybro8769
    @steveraybro8769 Рік тому +193

    This is why we should never forget history, no matter how tragic and horrible it was. If we forget, we’re doomed to repeat it.

    • @FullMetalMudcrab
      @FullMetalMudcrab Рік тому +13

      and in my experience vast majority of people dont care about history and dont want to learn it so no matter what we are doomed to repeat it

    • @doger6531
      @doger6531 Рік тому +2

      @@FullMetalMudcrab Me too

    • @user-ot1rt2gh6q
      @user-ot1rt2gh6q Рік тому

      you are germany in 1941

    • @properjob79
      @properjob79 Рік тому +1

      whenever i see someone type...If we forget, we’re doomed to repeat it. i just want to punch them in the face

    • @FullMetalMudcrab
      @FullMetalMudcrab Рік тому

      @@properjob79 do it

  • @scpfoundation8597
    @scpfoundation8597 Рік тому +145

    Simple history is definitely putting more meme animations in their videos.

    • @Reefer-Rampage69
      @Reefer-Rampage69 Рік тому +10

      As they should

    • @user-jl6dd7sm8c
      @user-jl6dd7sm8c Рік тому

      Украина 👎👎 росия👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

    • @reethardos1798
      @reethardos1798 Рік тому +1

      @@user-jl6dd7sm8c дешево и неубидительно

  • @lucianoosorio5942
    @lucianoosorio5942 Рік тому +232

    “War is where the young and stupid are tricked by the old and bitter into killing each other.” Niko Bellic

    • @AlreadyTakenTag
      @AlreadyTakenTag Рік тому +47

      People tend to say that quotes from video games are stupid. But even they have to admit those quotes are more often than not on point.
      -me just now

    • @Cybersharky_
      @Cybersharky_ Рік тому +21

      Jesus everyone repeats this quote on any video regarding any war. We get it!

    • @mercenary3868
      @mercenary3868 Рік тому +19

      If I could get 1 dollar every time this quote was use I would have 1 million

    • @Chuked
      @Chuked Рік тому

      @@Cybersharky_ ong like they use it too often its a good quote but overused to h£ll

    • @wattsnottaken1
      @wattsnottaken1 Рік тому +2

      That’s a cold hard fact of life. Well said

  • @BHuang92
    @BHuang92 Рік тому +22

    It's insane to think the Maxim M1910 used by the first Ukrainian republic is still in service today!

    • @IspanskiyZjobok
      @IspanskiyZjobok Рік тому +5

      like why not, its cooling system allows to shoot for a very long time

    • @lodidodi9366
      @lodidodi9366 Рік тому +5

      This machine gun helps us back then,and help us now😅

  • @Thomas-rl9xd
    @Thomas-rl9xd Рік тому +53

    Please do a video on the battle of Delville wood. As a South African it would be truly amazing to see our troops remembered on this channel.
    Thanks..

  • @TheUkrainian22
    @TheUkrainian22 Рік тому +54

    It is really nice to know my country's history

    • @artmbeloff5959
      @artmbeloff5959 Рік тому +1

      Вам 30 лет врут...!А вы хавайте эту чушь!Какие же вы дураки...!

    • @ssg9offical
      @ssg9offical Рік тому +4

      Y’all have truly been through so much y’all deserve your independence don’t stop keep going Slava Ukraine. 🇺🇦

    • @VlasneToJeDobre
      @VlasneToJeDobre 9 місяців тому +4

      @@ssg9offical💙💛🇺🇦🔱🦅

  • @retrofrog8191
    @retrofrog8191 Рік тому +20

    Hundred years later, they are back

    • @mikkel066h
      @mikkel066h Рік тому

      Yea. And once again they try and remove their identity, culture and language. While Russia is trying to go on another genocide they are telling themselves they are fighting against Nazis that are trying to remove Russia.

  • @cyanfloy2473
    @cyanfloy2473 Рік тому +144

    Russia:starts second Russo-Ukraine war
    Ukraine:we learn from past mistakes and will not fall again

    • @shayaldwarka7907
      @shayaldwarka7907 Рік тому +4

      That is exactly what is happening. Ukraine failed thanks to the west. As russia is getting away with four regions, which Ukraine tried to get for 8 years.

    • @Q84inHarbin
      @Q84inHarbin Рік тому +76

      @@shayaldwarka7907 wtf are you talking about

    • @stretchygeneral3433
      @stretchygeneral3433 Рік тому +64

      @@shayaldwarka7907 Ukraine is still alive thanks to the Heros of Ukraine and the West

    • @rafaelgomez1200
      @rafaelgomez1200 Рік тому +6

      I tbh dont care about wether ukriane loses or wins

    • @yeboxxxchannel2505
      @yeboxxxchannel2505 Рік тому +15

      @@rafaelgomez1200 Even if I hate to team with Ukraine and it's government, it's good thing so Russia does not expand too much, because if they further expand, they will eventually become a threat.
      And lot of supplies from Ukraine to African countries was shortened due to the war.
      U

  • @CactusJackIV
    @CactusJackIV Рік тому +90

    Keep up the awesome work!! Love the videos!

    • @larochejaquelein3680
      @larochejaquelein3680 Рік тому

      Einstein once wrote that history is a wheel, for the nature of man is fundamentally unchanging. What has happened before will perforce happen again, he said. I think of that whenever I contemplate Putin.

  • @MarshalShayCormac
    @MarshalShayCormac Рік тому +99

    Simple History could you guys make a Video about the Polish Soviet War of 1920 or about the soldiers and equipment of Polish Infantryman?

    • @generalpanzerfaust2387
      @generalpanzerfaust2387 Рік тому +5

      That would be interesting

    • @laikipl1278
      @laikipl1278 Рік тому +2

      Equipment? Almost anything that was available :D

    • @Bolshevik.remover
      @Bolshevik.remover Рік тому +4

      ​@@laikipl1278 there were few formations with distinctive equipment for example legions, greater Poland soldiers, Silesians, Blue army, POW militants and new regular army that was a dumpster fire in terms of equipment but somehow did work.

    • @VolunieProductionsOfficial
      @VolunieProductionsOfficial Рік тому +2

      Poland gained independence only thanks to the Entente

    • @generalpanzerfaust2387
      @generalpanzerfaust2387 Рік тому +3

      @@VolunieProductionsOfficial Yes and no. You see, the majority of Poland (including warsaw) was in Russia, so therefore the Germans surrendering the Russians guaranteed Polands independence because the Germans knew they couldn't hold that part cuz it was majority Polish. So the central powers helped Pilsudski against the Russians.

  • @swinsfrins1851
    @swinsfrins1851 Рік тому +7

    2022: *Vladimir Putin orders Russia to invade Ukraine*
    Vladimir Lenin: Yes yes that's mah boi, follow mah footsteps

  • @EdVarkarion
    @EdVarkarion Рік тому +60

    You should a video on the Polish Soldier during the interwar conflicts (Polish Soviet War, Polish-Ukrainian war, Sileasian Uprising). There was a interesting hodgepodge of uniforms, weapons and overall combat.

    • @OrkosUA
      @OrkosUA Рік тому +1

      That would be a copy paste of French soldier pretty much.

    • @user-bu2wd2rm1s
      @user-bu2wd2rm1s Рік тому

      There was a Polish-Ukrainian war????????

    • @EdVarkarion
      @EdVarkarion Рік тому

      @@user-bu2wd2rm1s yes. It lasted less then a year(1919), and it ended with Poland annexing Galicia.

    • @Nperez1986
      @Nperez1986 11 місяців тому

      Polish Ukranian war should be covered...along with other Polish Lithuania kingdom eras.

  • @SvyatoslavMatsiyovskyy
    @SvyatoslavMatsiyovskyy Рік тому +11

    This time Ukraine is organised and well supplied

  • @OrkosUA
    @OrkosUA Рік тому +22

    Thanks for a video about this often forgotten by the world part of History.

    • @fennydaud6652
      @fennydaud6652 Рік тому +1

      I mean, a lot of history in the world's is forgotten bc most of them is the loser side and as we all know already the history is written by the winner

    • @artmbeloff5959
      @artmbeloff5959 Рік тому +1

      Тут враньё!

    • @user-pk1wn8ol1r
      @user-pk1wn8ol1r Рік тому

      it's just part of the civil war in russia

    • @OrkosUA
      @OrkosUA Рік тому +2

      @@artmbeloff5959 тут правда. Брехня то у вас на москві

    • @OrkosUA
      @OrkosUA Рік тому

      @@user-pk1wn8ol1r Nope, it is Ukrainian war of independence. Civil war was between red and white russians only.

  • @user-ks6tg7gw7r
    @user-ks6tg7gw7r Рік тому +67

    Oh God, referrence to Cossacks 3 was incredible. As Ukrainian I approving this vid, like

  • @mariuszgier...1630
    @mariuszgier...1630 Рік тому +128

    Kolega taty u d walczył teraz na Ukrainie zginą w przedziale 23-25 mają. Panie świeć nad jego duszą. 😣
    Ojczyzna będzie mu to pamiętać.😞
    🇺🇦✌️
    Chwała Ukrainie!!!
    Bohaterom Chwała!!!

    • @hryhoriinikonchuk5004
      @hryhoriinikonchuk5004 Рік тому +10

      I am so sorry to hear that. I appreciate his help

    • @hryhoriinikonchuk5004
      @hryhoriinikonchuk5004 Рік тому +5

      @Egert Roos appreciate your support❤️

    • @hryhoriinikonchuk5004
      @hryhoriinikonchuk5004 Рік тому +7

      @Egert Roos good luck to him! together to the victory!!!

    • @poslinahui
      @poslinahui Рік тому +14

      It looks like Bandera's friends have not finished what they started. How do you like the Volyn holiday? Glory to Ukraine, glory to the heroes?

    • @yaroslavprotsenko4116
      @yaroslavprotsenko4116 Рік тому +18

      Дякую йому за захист! Дякую Польщі і полякам за підтримку, ми захистимо Європу від навали з Азії!

  • @user-vi4pc1mc1z
    @user-vi4pc1mc1z Рік тому +103

    Thank you very much for promoting the history of Ukraine.🙂👍🇺🇦 Fun Fact: There is a 3IRD division based on a real division and it competes against the Russians in FoxHole

    • @hestan723
      @hestan723 Рік тому +3

      Nice to see another Caoivan here

    • @user-vi4pc1mc1z
      @user-vi4pc1mc1z Рік тому +1

      @@hestan723 Caoivan??? Що ти верзеш друже мій?

    • @hestan723
      @hestan723 Рік тому +5

      Im talking about the game "foxhole"

    • @dinosorusmechkiller7960
      @dinosorusmechkiller7960 Рік тому +6

      Most based foxhole players

    • @DML_73
      @DML_73 Рік тому +2

      ​@@user-vi4pc1mc1z Миша (чи то Мише, не впевнений яке звернення тут доречніше), "верзеш" та "друже мій" доволі дивно виглядають в даному контексті. Якщо не розумієш сенс чиїхось слів, не обов'язково одразу переходити на агресію

  • @zubzerostuff
    @zubzerostuff Рік тому +11

    '' I got balls of steel. ''
    -Ghandi

  • @pantheongamer1467
    @pantheongamer1467 Рік тому +19

    You should a video about WW2 Ukraine for example the Ukraine insurgent army was always curious about

    • @viktorias63
      @viktorias63 Рік тому

      There are a lot of movies and documentarian about, but mainly in Ukrainian. People who recently still alive and their experiences, very interesting.

  • @jameshoxworth6447
    @jameshoxworth6447 Рік тому +41

    I hope you continue making videos about a country’s army

  • @Khalidaider
    @Khalidaider Рік тому +59

    Damn thats crazy hope the best for these dudes

    • @larochejaquelein3680
      @larochejaquelein3680 Рік тому +2

      Einstein once wrote that history is a wheel, for the nature of man is fundamentally unchanging. What has happened before will perforce happen again, he said. I think of that whenever I contemplate Putin.

    • @Ftroll
      @Ftroll Рік тому

      Not for ordinary people, but for the rich, just like today. This is a war not for the Motherland, but for money.

  • @Lego_Ukrainian_animations
    @Lego_Ukrainian_animations Рік тому +7

    Ukraine just wants to live freely...

  • @NateDgreat97871
    @NateDgreat97871 Рік тому +7

    Freedom for Ukraine keep supporting Ukraine.

    • @ghitodin2640
      @ghitodin2640 Рік тому

      @Beliomob and freedom for Taiwan

    • @ghgggx
      @ghgggx 4 місяці тому

      Ukraine then exist only 3-4 years, i wonder, how it exists before 2029😂

  • @EnglishScout
    @EnglishScout Рік тому +11

    I was doing a history project and this popped up! thanks for vid

  • @raiwserkoopa2221
    @raiwserkoopa2221 Рік тому +7

    man, reading the newest comments makes me lose brain cells

    • @RandomInternetUser-yi5cc
      @RandomInternetUser-yi5cc Рік тому +7

      It's basically 1/3rd band kids, 1/3rd propogandists, and 1/3rd modern college students. Tankies will do anything to defend communist dictatorships, even going as far as to put atrocities under the rug and deny history.

  • @mykhailomykhailov463
    @mykhailomykhailov463 Рік тому +5

    I'm sorry, but. Don't Ukraine National Republic it's mistake. It is Українська Народна Республіка - Ukraine People's Republic.

  • @timofijosurko
    @timofijosurko Рік тому +36

    Українці й перед цім мали свою державу Військо Запорізьке. Дякую за підтримку.(сам з України)

    • @user-to1cq5wv6y
      @user-to1cq5wv6y Рік тому +4

      Не было такой страны!

    • @timofijosurko
      @timofijosurko Рік тому +14

      @@user-to1cq5wv6y тебе забули попитати🤣🤣🤣

    • @user-un9gg9ds8r
      @user-un9gg9ds8r Рік тому

      @@user-to1cq5wv6y долбоеб)

    • @Lyanguzov1
      @Lyanguzov1 Рік тому +3

      @@timofijosurko вообще-то он прав, такого государства не было.

    • @user-to1cq5wv6y
      @user-to1cq5wv6y Рік тому

      @@user-un9gg9ds8r Это обозначает твоя «Д»? Пиши имя уже полностью😂

  • @NeverBhappy
    @NeverBhappy Рік тому +6

    Thank you for popularizing history of my country, maybe one day people of the west won`t confuse us for russians all the time🥲

  • @XO3AEH
    @XO3AEH Рік тому +4

    Да здравствует СОВЕТСКИЙ СОЮЗ!!!

  • @UcranianoUKR
    @UcranianoUKR Рік тому +4

    Ukraine actually has one of the first constitutions in Europe in 1710, albeit short-lived

    • @Victor-nd2gj
      @Victor-nd2gj Рік тому +1

      It’s older than Russia😂

    • @rtixboi4193
      @rtixboi4193 Рік тому +1

      @@Victor-nd2gj The Kievan Rus was more Russian than Ukrainian

    • @Yuri-ff8hy
      @Yuri-ff8hy Рік тому

      @@rtixboi4193 The Kievan Rus was neither russian or ukrainian, it's like Greece and Ancient Greece and Vyzantine or Egypt and Ancient Egypt and Mamluks

    • @dmitriyalaasniy8442
      @dmitriyalaasniy8442 Рік тому

      А еще, это великие укры черное море создали, и пирамиды создавали, знаем)

  • @HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva
    @HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva Рік тому +4

    Yet another sign that you should never allow the Bolsheviks a millimetre on your territory, regardless of where it may be.

    • @user-xu9ji4dd4e
      @user-xu9ji4dd4e Рік тому

      History, my friend, the Ukrainians were fighting themselves. Trosky took advantage of all this

  • @tasmaniandevil367
    @tasmaniandevil367 Рік тому +7

    Thank you for this great video! In Europe Ukrainian-Russian war 1917-1921 is unknown, most of the people think that it was a part of a Bolshevik revolution, but it wasn’t. Greetings from Ukraine and thank you for this material! 🇺🇦

  • @rommarov
    @rommarov Рік тому +12

    As a Ukrainian i can state that this is untrue. Ukraine was independent before that. Kyivan Rus (Yes, it is Ukraine and Kyiv was it's metropolia whilist Moscow was founded centuries later by the Pricne Dolgorukiy who was born and is buried here in Kyiv. After that comes Kingdom of Galicia and Volynhi and after that Zaporoshia Host (Sich).

    • @alexyuu952
      @alexyuu952 Рік тому +1

      Well yeah, saying it was fist independence isn't correct. But if we are talking in the context of when we've officially renamed ourselves to Ukraine (despite the word itself was used for ages) than this was first independence after long occupation by Russian Empire.

    • @yeboxxxchannel2505
      @yeboxxxchannel2505 Рік тому +1

      That would actually be equivalent of Moravia breaking apart from Czech republic because it was the first nation in lands of modern Czech republic.
      Although makes sense.

    • @Nperez1986
      @Nperez1986 11 місяців тому

      Here we go again. Someone whispers something and no one wrote it down back in the day

  • @Zaebistakurwa
    @Zaebistakurwa Рік тому +7

    "Every generation of Ukrainians goes to the front..."

  • @user-xm6it6ij7e
    @user-xm6it6ij7e Рік тому +12

    Этот канал нужно назвать - "Альтернативная история".

    • @rusikkk7942
      @rusikkk7942 Рік тому +3

      в московии альтернативное видение очевидных фактов?

    • @user-xm6it6ij7e
      @user-xm6it6ij7e Рік тому +2

      @@rusikkk7942 то, что Вы называете "очевидными фактами", любой адекватный историк (не "украинский") назовет анекдотом.

  • @gitrogZG
    @gitrogZG Рік тому +6

    Galatia was a Greek city in modern-day Turkey. Galicia is a region covering much of southern Poland and western Ukraine. They are Galician, not Galatian 😉

  • @OLYMPIANgreek
    @OLYMPIANgreek Рік тому +2

    Slavs trying to gain independence from Slavs.

  • @ugabuga3862
    @ugabuga3862 Рік тому +5

    Сейчас бы гражданскую войну приравнивать к вторжению на территории, которые принадлежали Российской империи. Ну тогда можно ли считать гражданскую войну в США вторжением в тот же Техас?

    • @shipovnik89
      @shipovnik89 Рік тому +3

      И ни словом не заикнулся про иностранную интервенцию, которая стала одной из причин гражданской войны, у него наверное какая-то другая история, альтернативная

  • @cannonball666
    @cannonball666 Рік тому +14

    Ukrainian General: "When we run out of planes, guns, bullets, we must resort to barf warfare"

  • @user-qs6lj3ge9r
    @user-qs6lj3ge9r Рік тому +3

    Запорожские казаки вошли сами в состав России,киевская Русь это та же самая Россия в прошлом

    • @user-qs6lj3ge9r
      @user-qs6lj3ge9r Рік тому

      А вообще запорожские казаки можно сказать при гражданской войне воевали за императора а не за Украину

    • @LoveHammerMan
      @LoveHammerMan Рік тому +3

      Cope Vatnik

  • @makeracistsafraidagain
    @makeracistsafraidagain Рік тому +18

    The Ukrainian flag will fly longer than the Russian flag will.

  • @krasche
    @krasche Рік тому +5

    very interesting review, but I would a bite correct it.
    initially Ukraine was independent (other name is Ruthenia | Rus | Kyivan Rus)
    and later (from 13 to 17 centuries) with Lithuania and in the first Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth - Ukraine (other name is Ruthenia or Rus) was a full-fledged partner, a subject and not the possessions of others.
    during Soviet times, Russian propaganda distorted the history of the Lithuanian-Ruthenia state formation and the first Polish-Lithuanian-Ruthenia Commonwealth. as a result, many international historians who have taken research from Moscow have such a Soviet lens and perspective.

    • @OrkosUA
      @OrkosUA Рік тому

      It was not like that. We were not full fledged partner, all government was in Polish hands so PLC was pretty much mutated into a polish empire.

    • @krasche
      @krasche Рік тому

      @@OrkosUA your words are not true.
      all participants of the formation had their original rights and freedoms.
      The Polish-Lithuanian-Rhutenia Commonwealth was not a Polish state.
      The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth was ruled by the Lithuanian Jagiellonian family for 250 years

    • @krasche
      @krasche Рік тому

      @@OrkosUA цікаві лекції і книги на цю тему у Наталії Старченко - дослідниці Речі Посполитої

  • @os1941
    @os1941 Рік тому +5

    Soviet Union is not Russia stop trying to click bait people

    • @High_rise12
      @High_rise12 Рік тому +2

      This was before the Soviet Union was formed you dope, he’s referring to Russia hat was ruled by the Soviets before the USSR was formed

    • @sulemile5242
      @sulemile5242 Рік тому +1

      it was RUSSIAN SOVIET FEDERATIVE SOCIALIST REPUBLIC or RSFSR

  • @amagicalpotato
    @amagicalpotato Рік тому +8

    Simple History should do an episode about General Wrangel's defense of Crimea!

  • @Spacey_key
    @Spacey_key Рік тому +7

    "Narodna" means "Peoples" not "National", "Natsionalna" means "National"

    • @Walther_Ukraine
      @Walther_Ukraine Рік тому

      We in Ukraine call UNR either narodna, or nationalna.

    • @felzer-viz
      @felzer-viz Рік тому +1

      ​@@Walther_Ukraine Чаще всего слышал что называют народная, впервые слышу про национальную.

  • @barricadedpurifier
    @barricadedpurifier Рік тому +21

    1:24 this was a brilliant part. RTS games in a nutshell.

  • @TheSilliestFellaEver
    @TheSilliestFellaEver Рік тому +10

    He got us in the first half

  • @SlyCooper1920
    @SlyCooper1920 Рік тому +6

    I'm glad that the Obrez mosin nagant pistol has made it's cameo

  • @logger22
    @logger22 Рік тому +89

    Those who don’t learn from Simple History are doomed to miss it

    • @justcause9575
      @justcause9575 Рік тому +6

      Yeah Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria: America keeps repeating itself.

    • @Oxide21
      @Oxide21 Рік тому +2

      @@justcause9575 Whataboutism

    • @zeta1960
      @zeta1960 Рік тому

      @@Oxide21 I mastered Amongus

    • @Oxide21
      @Oxide21 Рік тому

      @@zeta1960 sus

    • @condedooku9750
      @condedooku9750 Рік тому +4

      @@justcause9575 Yeah Afghanistan, Chechnya, Georgia, Syria, Ukriane: Russia keeps repeating itself.

  • @afrikasmith1049
    @afrikasmith1049 Рік тому +39

    And I wouldn't be surprised if this happens again in another 100 years because humans are really good at repeating history.

    • @user-xu9ji4dd4e
      @user-xu9ji4dd4e Рік тому +1

      Damn history, these Slavs are slaves

    • @yaroslavprotsenko4116
      @yaroslavprotsenko4116 Рік тому +9

      We will win this time

    • @tyrantofnagarrond9686
      @tyrantofnagarrond9686 Рік тому

      @@yaroslavprotsenko4116 don't make me laugh)

    • @mitkorotich8543
      @mitkorotich8543 Рік тому +5

      @@tyrantofnagarrond9686 You made me laugh by being born.

    • @mitkorotich8543
      @mitkorotich8543 Рік тому

      This will be repeated until we destroy the cancerous tumor of this planet - russia. But don't be afraid, Ukrainians are already solving this problem

  • @BattalionCommanderMK
    @BattalionCommanderMK Рік тому +4

    Nice documentary!

  • @ulkh604
    @ulkh604 Рік тому +33

    Hope Ukraine hold their independence.

    • @JakubKas
      @JakubKas Рік тому +12

      @@dompdompdomp bot spotted

    • @kiwiprouddavids724
      @kiwiprouddavids724 Рік тому

      Ukraine isn't going to win

    • @JakubKas
      @JakubKas Рік тому +4

      @@kiwiprouddavids724 And Russia isn't going to either

    • @kiwiprouddavids724
      @kiwiprouddavids724 Рік тому +2

      @@JakubKas it already has

    • @VMan29397
      @VMan29397 Рік тому

      @@dompdompdomp you know only 10-20% are nazis

  • @vadim.3949
    @vadim.3949 Рік тому +7

    Ваши познания а истории вопроса мало похожи на правду..

    • @user-xv2kx3hv9l
      @user-xv2kx3hv9l Рік тому +3

      Это не история. Это политика направленная на нагнетании русофобии и развязывании войны между украинцами и русскими.

    • @MrAlternatemundum
      @MrAlternatemundum Рік тому +5

      It is history

    • @vadim.3949
      @vadim.3949 Рік тому +2

      @@MrAlternatemundum это сказки, а не история..

    • @MrAlternatemundum
      @MrAlternatemundum Рік тому +5

      @@vadim.3949 they are history

    • @vadim.3949
      @vadim.3949 Рік тому +1

      @@MrAlternatemundum ну не рассказывай сказки милая пани.. мы отлично знаем как создавалась украинство..

  • @kid-history-and-latin
    @kid-history-and-latin Рік тому +5

    i hope ukraine wins against russia i wonder if russia lost in this one

  • @dionesvaldez088
    @dionesvaldez088 7 місяців тому +1

    “Those Who Do Not Learn From History Are Doomed To Repeat It."
    - Winston Churchill

  • @VolunieProductionsOfficial
    @VolunieProductionsOfficial Рік тому +13

    You said that before the Ukrainian People's Republic Ukraine did not have independence, but there was a Hetmanship, Kyivan Rus and the Galicia-Volyn State, and Ukraine had a significant share in the Grand Duchy of Lithuania

    • @DelijeSerbia
      @DelijeSerbia Рік тому +7

      Thats not Ukraine, those are independent "countries" in the location of modern
      Ukraine.
      Ukraine is a relatively modern concept...

    • @hryhoriinikonchuk5004
      @hryhoriinikonchuk5004 Рік тому +14

      @@DelijeSerbia then you can call more than a half of modern European countries a “modern concept”. Stupid logic

    • @rplanet_ua
      @rplanet_ua Рік тому

      @@hryhoriinikonchuk5004 +

    • @condedooku9750
      @condedooku9750 Рік тому +5

      @@DelijeSerbia That's dumb

    • @TheForklifter
      @TheForklifter Рік тому +2

      @@hryhoriinikonchuk5004 you can make that argument very easily. Our modern perception of Italy and Germany as we know it only existed until the 19th century. Before then it was a wide assortment of different kingdoms many of the times often fighting each other. Speaking languages, while similar, are different enough. As kingdoms unify, the languages also unify. What at one point many different languages and dialects, one dominates. In Spain for example, the Castelian dominated and became what we know as Spanish despite the many many related languages and dialects.
      Sometimes these languages are extremely different from their modern day counterparts they evolved into.
      Unfortunately history is never cut and dry. Sometimes the ancient civilizations that settled in the soil you live on today are completely unrelated to you or sometimes can be determined to be your direct ancestors. Sometimes you can be related to them, but so can a lot of other nations in the region.
      Kievan/Kyivan Rus is related to Russia and Belarus as it is to Ukraine despite it being located in the general geographic area of modern day Ukraine. Even the Finnish and the Swedes can claim some sort of relation and decendance from the Kievan/Kyivan Rus.

  • @PrusskiyMir
    @PrusskiyMir Рік тому +3

    Great video, but one thing has been bothering me for a long time
    It's not "Ukrainian National Republic", but "Ukrainian People's Republic". I guess it's a common mistake because of the abriviation "UNR" where N stands for Ukrainian word "Narodna" (People's), not the ''Natsional'na' (National).

  • @mr.mandude7542
    @mr.mandude7542 Рік тому +5

    1:25 Loved that Command and conquer/RTS reference

  • @user-or9gg8hm4c
    @user-or9gg8hm4c Рік тому +11

    Это альтернативная история придуманная англосаксами🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @artemjetr
    @artemjetr Рік тому +8

    Приємно, що такі великі англомовні канали не оминають нашу історію тих часів

  • @tristinkirby
    @tristinkirby Рік тому +55

    You've guys done a wonderful job on this. 🥰

    • @kiwiprouddavids724
      @kiwiprouddavids724 Рік тому

      Ukraine isn't going to win against Russia,if it wasn't for NATO they'd already be part of Russia. Ukraine isn't winning anything except for corruption and lies

    • @space4166
      @space4166 Рік тому +7

      Cringe username
      Call me supporting Russia but I hate people who act like they support ukraine like online on tiktok

    • @kiwiprouddavids724
      @kiwiprouddavids724 Рік тому

      @@space4166 all anyone has to do is ask themselves if Ukraine would do anything to support you or your country if you were invaded, the answer is NO they wouldn't they were one of the most corrupt countries in the world before this and all they were known for was a bunch of slutty women on the internet tricking men out of money with lies and promises of a life together,that's all they had

    • @kiwiprouddavids724
      @kiwiprouddavids724 Рік тому

      Looking at the polls more than 60 % of the populations of the country supporting Ukraine don't want anything to do with it.and no nuclear countries are prepared to nuke Russia if they use tactical nukes in Ukraine . Ukraine doesn't have nukes do they ? Ukraine is losing support fast and no one is prepared to back them with nukes , Ukraine has already lost

    • @space4166
      @space4166 Рік тому +1

      @@kiwiprouddavids724 ok Russian supporter,

  • @Nikerin89
    @Nikerin89 Рік тому +6

    А ничего что до этого Украина была в составе Российской Империи?
    Интересно, как в Америке гражданская война называлась, "вторжение севера на южные штаты"?
    Смотреть противно это видео, Украина далее была в составе СССР, вполне себе нормально жили. Вот вторжение немцев в 1941 имело последствия, а вы пытаетесь русских выставить негодяями. Если вам за это деньги платят, это одно, если вы сами в это верите, мне вас жаль, лучше занимайтесь своей историей, надеюсь её вы знаете лучше чем чужую.

    • @bennittotheburrito9606
      @bennittotheburrito9606 Рік тому +3

      Holodomer

    • @finalMadfox
      @finalMadfox Рік тому +1

      Russia legit under the Tsar and the Soviets oppressed Ukrainian identity and Nationalism under russification and no Austria Hungary also controlled parts of Ukraine, mainly Western Ukraine and its funny you bring a lost cause myth into the argument showing that you legit are a white supremacist

    • @mihel1640
      @mihel1640 Рік тому +1

      Are you seriously confunding the eastern front of ww2 with ukranian independence movements in the 20's?
      Also, some southerners call the american civil war "the war of northern agression".The video clearly states"ukraine was partitioned between the russian empire and austria-hungary".

    • @Nikerin89
      @Nikerin89 Рік тому

      @@mihel1640 мы до революции 1917 года были одной страной, ей же и остались после гражданской войны. Во время 2 мировой войны была смята или ассимилирована почти вся Европа. Немцы, взяли Польшу, Францию, прошли Украину и встали у Москвы, их выбили обратно, Советский Союз это сделал, не только одна Россия. Сила была в единстве, вместе же освободили свою страну, и восточную Европу от фашистов. Это были советские люди, и дальше большая страна жила нормально. Та же Польша или Франция что то в космос не летала.
      Вот и сейчас, проблема в каких то клоунах, которые думают что они особенные, и страна у них лучше чем у других, и сами они лучше чем соседи.
      Наша славянская сила в единстве, и это надо понять. То что происходит на Украине, уничтожение нашего общего славного прошлого с Россией, это плевок на своё прошлое, своих родителей которые жили в СССР. И вот от этих негодяев надо избавляться.
      Вы не славянин, не лезьте в этот конфликт, вы его не понимаете. Многие украинцы перебежали в Россию, не только в Европу.

    • @xxvxxv5588
      @xxvxxv5588 Рік тому +2

      ​@@Nikerin89
      Твои спекуляции на тему славянства не уместные. На России к Цыганам или к Африканцам относятся лучше чем к Украинцам.

  • @fungunsun1
    @fungunsun1 Рік тому +13

    You should do a video on Kholodniy Yar rebels (Cold Pit)

  • @themissingpeace7956
    @themissingpeace7956 Рік тому +5

    Now do a video about Stepan Bandera, I dare you.

  • @aeternus_puer
    @aeternus_puer Рік тому +4

    Украинские солдаты с каббалистической символикой,что вы несёте.

  • @punishedlatvian5710
    @punishedlatvian5710 Рік тому +6

    You should make a video about very similar topic which would be Latvian/Lithuanian/Estonian independence wars 1918-1920

    • @PUARockstar
      @PUARockstar Рік тому

      And ussr annexation in 1940

    • @user-xu9ji4dd4e
      @user-xu9ji4dd4e Рік тому

      @@PUARockstar History What are you one country since the era of the Vikings, the Scythians and the Iranian Sarmatians

  • @dimitrov1640
    @dimitrov1640 Рік тому +12

    Great video! You have shown even the uniforms and personal armaments. Congratulations!

  • @gmanawesome5773
    @gmanawesome5773 Рік тому +4

    YET AGAIN HISTORY REPEAT.

  • @v.emiltheii-nd.8094
    @v.emiltheii-nd.8094 Рік тому +9

    "Slavă Ucrainei!"
    - From Romania with love

  • @ElSadeS.
    @ElSadeS. Рік тому +6

    ¿Ukraine War In 1920?

  • @budulai6258
    @budulai6258 Рік тому +29

    Thank you. I appreciate your work dedicated to this topic. People from the West usually don't know anything about this period of Ukrainian history. That's why some people unfortunately think that Ukraine is a historical part of russia and this sad fact bring lot's of problem in informational space nowadays, during modern ukrainain war for independence. We had our own government of UPR, national flag, army, orders... But we were occupied by moscow bolsheviks than, we lost our independence but it will never happen again. Greetings from Ukraine 🇺🇦

    • @human7136
      @human7136 Рік тому +1

      Тут как бы ничего не объясняли из того что Украина "древнее государство"...

    • @budulai6258
      @budulai6258 Рік тому +10

      @@human7136 конкретно тут я не згадував, що українська державність давня, я згадав події 100-річної давнини, уважно читай, дядя

    • @alex14228
      @alex14228 Рік тому +5

      @@budulai6258 ДНР и ЛНР существовали гораздо дольше, чем ЗУНР и УНР в свое время. Надо чтить их государственность тоже xD

    • @budulai6258
      @budulai6258 Рік тому +9

      @@alex14228 до чого тут довше чи не довше. Цікаво, визнала б рф Чеченську Республіку Ічкерія незалежною, якби вона проіснувала ще б рік-півтора?) Судячи з твоєї ави, стає зрозуміло, що в тебе розуму малувато. Ми маємо керуватися міжнародним правом в першу чергу, неважливо скільки існує бананова республіка, якщо вона бананова, рік-два, а то й всі 10 - вона лишається тією ж самою банановою республікою, яку ні одна цивілізована країна не визнає

    • @alex14228
      @alex14228 Рік тому +3

      @@budulai6258 судя по твоему языку, становится ясно, что у тебя ума маловато 🤣 на основании какого права образовались УНР и ЗУНР? Их образование вообще радикально противоречило международному праву того времени xDDD
      ДНР и ЛНР хотя бы образовались на основании права народов на самоопределение, которое только после 1945 сформировалось xD

  • @eziocusenza5650
    @eziocusenza5650 Рік тому +51

    Can you make a video about the never found Saddam Hussain''s destructive weapons? (Which caused the Us to invade Iraq?)

  • @Lungolords
    @Lungolords Рік тому +7

    Love the Age or Empires reference

  • @ilkormwilkorwm2132
    @ilkormwilkorwm2132 Рік тому +7

    Ну и бред

  • @user-so4cj9qc2j
    @user-so4cj9qc2j Рік тому +5

    Такого бреда я давно не слышал

    • @zefirkaa9917
      @zefirkaa9917 Рік тому

      включи телевизор, похлеще будет

    • @user-so4cj9qc2j
      @user-so4cj9qc2j Рік тому +2

      @@zefirkaa9917 нет, тут ярко говорится о не существующей истории

    • @zefirkaa9917
      @zefirkaa9917 Рік тому

      @@user-so4cj9qc2j ну и в чем же это проявляется?

    • @user-so4cj9qc2j
      @user-so4cj9qc2j Рік тому

      @@zefirkaa9917 ты переведи текст

    • @LoveHammerMan
      @LoveHammerMan Рік тому +4

      Cope Vatnik

  • @carmikulasii.gulasovski242
    @carmikulasii.gulasovski242 Рік тому +9

    Ukropbots and russian bots flooding comments.

  • @leomarsubala115
    @leomarsubala115 Рік тому +12

    Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦, Slava Ayuria/Avinia from MH Stories.

  • @user-hv1ch5uc5d
    @user-hv1ch5uc5d Рік тому +3

    absolutely mediocre interpretation of events, you wouldn’t climb here, son

  • @marioalexanderski9598
    @marioalexanderski9598 Рік тому +2

    History usually rhymes, but here, it repeats itself.

  • @longnightofsolace4983
    @longnightofsolace4983 Рік тому +1

    Ukraine Exists
    Russia & Austria-Hungary: Mine
    Russia & Austria-Hungary: Are you sure about that!!

  • @DonVigaDeFierro
    @DonVigaDeFierro Рік тому +9

    History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes.

  • @smtoonentertainment
    @smtoonentertainment Рік тому +4

    When history repeats itself 101 years later

  • @patron8597
    @patron8597 Рік тому +6

    Beware of vatnik cope.

  • @user-gv7jg4eh3f
    @user-gv7jg4eh3f Рік тому +2

    Lenin was the first who gave Ukraine real independence

    • @bochonka9331
      @bochonka9331 Рік тому

      Bogdan Khmelnytsky was the first who gave Ukraine REAL independence.

  • @Portugalisbased
    @Portugalisbased Рік тому +2

    this video isn't aging well

    • @darthplagueis3488
      @darthplagueis3488 Рік тому

      @@Portugalisbased that’s not the real simplehistory. Sometimes scammers imitate large UA-camrs and create spamming bots so they appear on every other comment. I also encountered this spam also portraying to be pewdiepie on a pewdiepie video.

    • @Portugalisbased
      @Portugalisbased Рік тому +1

      @@darthplagueis3488 i was being sarcastic 💀

  • @DannyHeywood
    @DannyHeywood Рік тому +4

    That Typhous annimation made me laugh! haha

  • @Тёмный_Механик
    @Тёмный_Механик Рік тому +6

    Что за бред я сейчас посмотрел?

    • @garand274
      @garand274 Рік тому +2

      +

    • @patron5626
      @patron5626 Рік тому +3

      Типичную западную пропаганду

  • @Normal934
    @Normal934 Рік тому +6

    Ukraine was not a country that day

  • @artyom1264
    @artyom1264 Рік тому +1

    101 years later…

  • @Kaiser_behind_the_slaughter
    @Kaiser_behind_the_slaughter Рік тому +4

    Meanwhile everyone who forgets about 1918-1919 and ww2 ukrainians crimes:

  • @andreylyubavin1211
    @andreylyubavin1211 Рік тому +4

    Invasion? Civil war, maybe the author heard something about it

  • @ww2fromthefields872
    @ww2fromthefields872 Рік тому +6

    I was wondering maybe there can be a video about Leonard F. Mason the soldier who sacrificed his life to take down two Japanese Machine Gun Nests in the Battle of Guam WWII he later died succumbed to his wounds was earned the Medal of Honor and has a ship named after him if you need time learning about him look up on him in Wikipedia

  • @Hakarishmoovin
    @Hakarishmoovin Рік тому +3

    Ukraine: how many times we gotta teach you this lesson old man?!

  • @user-lf6qm8yn1k
    @user-lf6qm8yn1k Рік тому +15

    In Russia we have a joke:
    Three Russians - a party.
    Three Jews - a business.
    Three Belorussians - a partisan detachment.
    Three Ukranians - a partisan detachment with a traitor.

    • @IspanskiyZjobok
      @IspanskiyZjobok Рік тому

      Зрада підкралась звідки не чекали

    • @amogusgaming8550
      @amogusgaming8550 Рік тому +13

      Угу , стандартное мышление болотного...
      Все вокруг плохие , особенно мы , потому что воюем сейчас. И одни вы - хорошие

    • @amogusgaming8550
      @amogusgaming8550 Рік тому +1

      @@nebula9683 есть вариант либо вообще ни на кого ни гнать , либо на всех гнать. А не делать "плохие" и "хорошие" народы...

    • @amogusgaming8550
      @amogusgaming8550 Рік тому

      @@nebula9683 скорее к государству чем к народу. Блть, народ - это вполне себе штучная штука , про такую херню как нация я промолчу ...