The West is losing

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 гру 2023
  • We used to think that other countries liked the whole liberal-democratic package. Turns out that a lot of them were simply overawed by superior Western arms.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 71

  • @DeadendSatellite
    @DeadendSatellite 7 місяців тому +8

    If only we believed in values of Freedom at home.
    But we've had a succession Authoritarian governments.

  • @peterbrunsden380
    @peterbrunsden380 7 місяців тому +9

    Spot on Dan.If Uk is so awful why does half the world want to come here?

    • @clasifi1
      @clasifi1 7 місяців тому

      Because the rest of the world views the UK as a whore who requires no payment for services rendered. And rightly so...Third worlders invade your country precisely because of "western values". (i.e. open borders, equality, human rightism, diversity, multiculturalism, antiracism, liberalism, tolerance) all synonymous of your civilisation's demise. Less of you, more of "them". The seeds Of your country's own demise are embedded in "western culture".

    • @terencefield3204
      @terencefield3204 7 місяців тому

      Moron, the inhabitants of the worst places on the planet are aspirants to enter ruined England, not too many from serious civilizations arrive, or wish remotely to do so.

    • @erica.5620
      @erica.5620 7 місяців тому

      Cuz 70% of it is shit. A little dog crap is better than bull shit imo.
      Love my falling nation

    • @DanHannanMEP
      @DanHannanMEP  7 місяців тому +5

      The quality of our parliamentary debates?

    • @terencefield3204
      @terencefield3204 7 місяців тому

      You should be on the stage. Oh , hang on, you actually are!!!!!!!@@DanHannanMEP

  • @dmoney8602
    @dmoney8602 3 місяці тому +4

    This is surreal. I remember watching Dan almost 20 years ago debating in the EU parliament

  • @fakenewts4211
    @fakenewts4211 7 місяців тому +5

    In other words, UK politically isolated internationally, not Russia.
    Meanwhile, Ukraine head first up to its ankles in the meat grinder.

  • @Raygun9000
    @Raygun9000 7 місяців тому +3

    At what level of corruption or state curation of a democracy does it ceased to be considered so?

    • @ElseMush
      @ElseMush 7 місяців тому +1

      It's relative. There's a lot of corruption here in the UK, but it's still a democracy. I guess the main difference is whether the country has meaningful elections. I'd like to see proportional representation in this country so we aren't voting between two parties that are the same.

    • @Raygun9000
      @Raygun9000 7 місяців тому +1

      @@ElseMush what extra issue would cross us over the line? We get to vote for an MP that can change party. Some parties allow a leadership vote by the members from the options presented by the elites. And even then they can ignore them and install their leader of choice.

    • @DanHannanMEP
      @DanHannanMEP  3 місяці тому +3

      I'd use the Karl Popper definition. Can the population realistically change its rulers without anyone having to be exiled or shot?

    • @ClassNav
      @ClassNav Місяць тому

      There hasn't been a meaningful democracy in the UK since 1979.

    • @garthkite
      @garthkite Місяць тому

      ​@@DanHannanMEPAmerica isn't looking too peachy with the obvious political persecution of Trump, whatever you think of the man a Rubicon has been crossed.

  • @TXGRunner
    @TXGRunner 2 місяці тому

    I've alway really enjoyed listening to your speeches. You project an image of confident, competent leadership with a clear understanding of where we are, where we're headed, the perils we face, and a vision of where we need to go. I think this is the first time I ever saw a speech given in the House of Lords.

  • @RN-lo6xc
    @RN-lo6xc 7 місяців тому +5

    Lord Hannan diagnoses the issue with precision. Yet, I cannot help but feel that the source of this loss of political credibility abroad comes as a result of cultural collapse at home. Western European and North American electorates have changed - economically, ethnically, culturally. The relatively poor leadership we have is indicative of this. Democratic societies are only as enlightened as their people. When the level of education and the quality of democratic participation are reduced to tribalism, outcomes in a democracy nosedive. This is playing out in real time in England and the US. It is no surprise that when Emirati or Chinese citizens visit London and see addicts, knife crime, shoplifting and violent pro-Palestine marches in the millions, they return home with a much greater conviction in their own system of social ordering. This would never have been the case 20-30 years ago. The road to legitimacy abroad is conditioned on the preservation of Western culture and citizenship, and on the rejection of tribalism.

  • @1986johnnybravo1
    @1986johnnybravo1 7 місяців тому +1

    The term 'global south' used in the House of Lords. Signs that reality is seeping into the the West.

  • @markdennis930
    @markdennis930 7 місяців тому +7

    Dan is one of the very, very few I trust in either House.

    • @terencefield3204
      @terencefield3204 7 місяців тому +3

      Poor you to be so very limited.

    • @DanHannanMEP
      @DanHannanMEP  7 місяців тому

      Thank you.

    • @soutteruk1
      @soutteruk1 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@DanHannanMEP
      Put in any expenses claims recently, my lord?

  • @clasifi1
    @clasifi1 7 місяців тому +3

    Mr Hannan sounds like an eloquent neocon. He reminds me of the late Christopher Hitchens. Only Dan's speeches have a more lyrical structure.

    • @terencefield3204
      @terencefield3204 7 місяців тому +1

      No. Hitches had a real and clever depth of mind, not just the wrapping paper.

    • @erica.5620
      @erica.5620 7 місяців тому

      Could listen to his perspectives and insights for hours.

    • @terencefield3204
      @terencefield3204 7 місяців тому +2

      Poor you@@erica.5620

    • @erica.5620
      @erica.5620 7 місяців тому

      ​@@terencefield3204 What's not to love about sincere alacrity? Exploring and broadening out particular aspects of subject matters to construct sound arguments relative to information available and research done?
      It's why rappers are so popular; it isn't their vulgarity per se, but more so the grip on the tongue permitting lyrical poetry flowing through words and not pitch.
      You'd have to be rather closed minded and silly if you think you have nothing to learn from Lord Hannan (or practically anyone), regardless of whether you disagree on his perspectives or not. 20 years representing the UK in the EU, vast historical and economical knowledge all the while mingling with men of power tends to garner particular insights.
      Remember people have lived their lives just as you have, and reached their own conclusions. The fact you'd rather resort to petty comments online as opposed to trying to understand *why* that perception came about is a testament to your character, or rather lack thereof.
      Have a great day though.

    • @DanHannanMEP
      @DanHannanMEP  7 місяців тому +5

      I'm against most wars that other people seem to back, including Iraq and Afghanistan. Here, we are not at war. But we did make a promise to uphold Ukrainian sovereignty within its existing borders in exchange for its nuclear disarmament in 1994, which means we can't be indifferent either.

  • @Mark-fw8pd
    @Mark-fw8pd 7 місяців тому +1

    Dan, you are clinging to the past. The demise has already occurred. Time for a fresh start. Discard the dead-wood.

  • @rcfokker1630
    @rcfokker1630 7 місяців тому +1

    AFAICS ... the 'rule of Law' IS force. Isn't every Law supported by the threat of violence to the non-compliant?

    • @DanHannanMEP
      @DanHannanMEP  7 місяців тому +1

      The rule of law means that the use of force is monopolised, controlled, limited and directed only at those found by an independent process to have committed crimes.

    • @magnusbrzenk447
      @magnusbrzenk447 7 місяців тому +1

      @@DanHannanMEPyou’re arguing in a circle - as most politicians do

  • @joeevans2365
    @joeevans2365 5 місяців тому

    Reform 🫡🇬🇧

  • @paulsaunders6536
    @paulsaunders6536 26 днів тому

    Wake me up in a thousand years when Hannan actually articulates a single word that is worth listening to. Have a look at the article he penned on the outcomes of Brexit. Deranged and unsubstantiated barely scratches the surface. A man who eschewed oxygen in favour of his own BS. 🙄

  • @davidgifford8112
    @davidgifford8112 7 місяців тому +3

    A rather selective use of recent history. While I condemned and continue to condemn the Russian attack on the Ukraine, it wasn’t unprovoked. Activities by the US, EU and NATO in Ukraine (2014 coup) and the bad faith breaking of the Minsk agreement by the west were interpreted (correctly) as acts of aggression by Moscow. As ever a complete failure to understand mind sets different from your own.

  • @markhayward7400
    @markhayward7400 7 місяців тому +3

    This is from the man who was so wrong about Brexit that he was subsequently forced to admit that the UK would be better off in the Single Market !

  • @ChristinaGaughan-rb7ot
    @ChristinaGaughan-rb7ot 7 місяців тому

    But yes their is a few who yes I question their spirit what there spirit is saying

  • @ribos2762
    @ribos2762 7 місяців тому +4

    Russia also represent the European values

    • @alanbrooke144
      @alanbrooke144 Місяць тому +1

      Yeah, nah. Russia all the way back to the 1600s was distinctly non-Western. From the Russian orthodox church to it’s systems of serfdom and autocratic leadership, Russian society is not Western in any meaningful way.

    • @barrettpendleton3998
      @barrettpendleton3998 Місяць тому

      No they absolutely do not.

  • @terencefield3204
    @terencefield3204 7 місяців тому +2

    lol The oleaginous Politelord has, in my estimation, done much to speed up the process of collapse and real English impoverishment. He actually makes me want to throw up.

  • @chesshooligan1282
    @chesshooligan1282 6 місяців тому

    Hello, Dan, do you have any comments on the recent torture and murder of Gonzalo Lira in the "however imperfect" democratic Ukraine? No? I didn't think so. Ukraine attacked without provocation? You make me sick.

  • @LusoPatriot77
    @LusoPatriot77 7 місяців тому

    A country attacked without provocation...Steadfast Defender 2021, Crimean Platorm, EU/US/UK not recognizing the ilegal seizing of power in Kiev...Stop being such a moralizer. You do not stand on any height, sir