@Mr Olsen Sir. Your comment seems to be knee jerk sarcasm based solely on emotion rather than any evidence, explanation or logic. Hannan has been a centrist pro-democracy, anti-collectivist and anti-plutocratic all his adult life, and made quite clear his disapproval of Putin's methods to gaining omnipotency. He has even used the Russian government fake parliament, fake representation and dictatorial model as as an analogy for the evils of the EU Commission! So, please do explain, of what exactly are you accusing him?
Every time I listen to Hannan I'm astounded. What a lecturer, how erudite, and how not like a politician. Pity - he really should be the next prime minister.
Peter Bradley. From what I read and hear, plus what I view on UA-cam, Mr. Farage is unlikely to lose many points to any of those present in Strausberg, since their arguments cluster toward repetitive, and remain unconvincing. Besides, it clearly is difficult for them to dredge up the testosterone needed for another showdown with Mr. Farage, after having been outdrawn and outshot so consistently. Glazed grins just don't make up for intellectual inertia. It is a little surprising, though, that Mrs. Merkel seems unable to see why the remaining nation-states of Europe are somehow underimpressed with the charm of Germany's drive to bully the rest of Europe into speaking German. Can't think why. Look how trustworthy Volkswagen has turned out to be. Ta.
Hannan’s comments are a heinous affront to Gaia and Communism as well as being intolerant hate speech. For The People™ nothing is more important than stringent Party orthodoxy. They must be taught to denounce all class enemies as well as their parents, friends, educators and other assorted reactionary dogs for crimes committed against the state. Furthermore, a consensus has been formed; the science has been settled, the debate is over. Deniers must be burned at the stake for heresy, apostasy, and treason to the scientific consensus.
Hannan was very voiciferous during the referendum campaign. he appeared in many discussion programmes on TV and Radio, and in the EU parliament of course.. After that, almost silence, WHY ? Only once have I seen him speaking in the house on Brexit issues.
This man is one of the best speakers in the English-speaking world. Even when he's answering questions, that is when he speaks without previous preparation.
What sets this man apart from most other politicians is that he is a deep thinker, worth hearing whichever part of the political spectrum you occupy. Where most politicians are superficial, dishonest careerists with nothing to offer but fear-mongering and obfuscation, he possesses the power to ignite his audiences with a new passion for politics and, most importantly, with hope. He can inspire us with a will to retake control of our own destiny, the only sure foundation upon which to build a brighter future. We must never allow our democratic rights and political engagement to be whittled away by the faceless Brussels bureaucrats.
His major political project (Brexit) has weakened UK more than any other policy the last 200 years. Which is why a big and increasingly bigger majority of the UK population considers Brexit a mistake. The talent of Hannan is purely oratory, but sadly a talent strong enough to make ludicrous propositions sound like the only sensible course of action. The political wisdom of nations are generally inversely proportional to the number of "Daniel Hannan analysts" in action.
Wonderful speech, both in content and delivery. This quote in particular is so pithy i'll have to write it down: "When you take the demos out of democracy, you're left only with the cratos - with the power of a system that must compel by law, what it dare not ask in the name of civic patriotism". A federalist EU is anti-Europe. The deliberate, manipulative attempts by many politicians to conflate the EU and Europe in the public mind should be called out on every occasion. If the EU is to exist, it should be minimalist, and be contained in that state by strong constitutional laws.
I love this man, I really do. An outspoken, eloquent British version of Peter Schiff. These are the voices we need to be hearing from, not the likes of Obama or labour.
577666 Hes exceptional isnt he. I particularly enjoyed his presentation on why socialism does not work at the Oxford Union. Hes almost irrefutable! Hannan has more charisma than the entire Labour party combined! He should run for leadership, I would rather him than Boris.
Absolutely! This man speaks out of genuine conviction and principles, and I can only respect that. How many other politicians really mean what they say? How many really think deep at all? The majority only lie and squirm to build themselves a well-paid career. Dan is for the people.
He sure is eloquent, but so was Goebbels. It only becomes a good trait if you use it to convince people of your cause, not manipulate them into believing it. Also you should not think he is different from any other politician. They all say exactly what their voters want to hear and not even the most compelling facts can push them out of their comfort zone. He lies as much as left wing politicians, bending the facts to match his agenda and all only to build themselves a well-paid career
FarmerSchinken have you ever pondered that it might be possible that Geobbels and Hitler actually spoke the Truth? Truthful propaganda? Or would you say that the Jews who were in Germany at the time spoke the truth in thier newspapers before they were forced out?
@TheMadScotsman mckay Well said Mad Mac ! We have been sold the lie of "shared sovereignty, sometimes they call it " pooled sovereignty" again, a lie. Sovereignty cannot by the definition of sovereignty be shared. To lose, or give away sovereignty is to abolish ones nation. To accept laws imposed by a foreign power is to accept the abolition of ones nation. To remove borders, eventually also removing them from maps as national demarcation lines, replaced by outlines of administrative areas, is to accept the abolition of ones country. We want it back, so that we can cooperate in areas of mutual benefit, but be free to make our own treaties, our own trading arrangements, our own laws instead of ,as currently approximately 2/3 of our laws emanating from Russell's with EU law taking supremacy over the laws we have made ourselves. Tied as we are to the EU, we are not free to adopt good ideas from other countries, unless 27 other EU members agree. That is not progress, except towards the dreary harmful one size fits all of the Orwellian super state. To hell with it. No one needs it. Europe will be better when we are all free nations once again rather than the soon to be monolith Europa. Nations that make their own laws, trade where and when they will in friendly cooperation.
@@barryfullick7981 Yeah lets get back to the first half of the 20th century when Europe consisted of separate states it was all love, peace and prosperity. Or perhaps you would like to go back to the 19th century or the 18th, take you pick. Try looking up at the sky it appears every day our sovereignty is being infringed with aeroplanes flying over, landing etc from scores of different countries. Why the hell don't we stop them infringing our sovereignty? Or how about the American Forces that are stationed in the UK or even our immigrations officers station in Calais Just some examples of your so called sovereignty in the real world.
A truly remarkable orator, such speech making can only come from true conviction and belief. Agree with him or not you have to admire his ability to truly captive an audience.
@@samuelolaogun9044 To be quite honest.... you can do your own votums. Sadly enough the scottish independence vote is for EU or for britain which is bad vote as scotland could just choose not to be part of either.
You said it Ralf. There is only one way to wealth.....work, save, and invest. I don't care what hole you find yourself in but you can dig out. It may not even be you who sees the fruits of those labors. It may be your grandchildren. The Irish and Italians came to America and worked 7 days a week and smiled, glad to be in a free market country where they would someday see the fruits of their labor, and they did.
@@euan7166 buzzzzz.....wrong....they had a semblance of a free market controlled by powerful land holders and rulers who hob nobbed with the rich and powerful and did their bidding. This left the lower people impoverished. Go read some history.
My grandpa was full blooded German. He worked 70 hours a week all of his life. His fruits included a big house and a red barn on ten acres. You know what he did for a living? He drove a belly dump truck, but he kept working and pinching pennies. Anyone today can do what my grandpa did, if they want to work to get it. There's no free lunch. A lot of people are caught up into this dream world of working 40 hours a week and becoming rich. Nonsense. That might work for a small select category of very talented people, but even they had to knuckle down and work their butts off at some point.
Bollocks mate. For a start there are more people than jobs. Then there is the fact that govts make working so many hours illegal. And then theres the fact that the the price of houses and land relative to wages has doubled or tripled or quadrupled.
David Sharp we are free to work as much or as little as we wish in the USA....We like to work....Money is !! (Freedom to do what you want ,when you want) Europe has lost its way,it does not even value children....That's why the birthrates,have been sub replacement for decades....
Probably explains why Hague never won the general election. I recall him banging on about saving the pound and nobody at the time was suggesting otherwise certainly not Brown the then Chancellor.
I don't think it is directly pro German propaganda. What is wrong with a German exit from the EU or a British exit from the EU for that matter. Why should young Germans feel guilty about WWII? He is saying what many have already seen. I took part in the Schalke International Military Tattoo earlier this year. We (a British band) were conversing with a German band, and they were looking at the medals on our uniforms. One asked a question: "Which war is that medal from?" Another German said (in comically forgetful tone): "Vat War, vat war? Then all together with the John Cleese classic. "Don't mention ze var!" Laughing, smiling and in good humour. They have put the past behind them and want to move forward in peace.
falcons1988 He should be really, his views probably align more with UKIP than the conservatives of today. UKIP represent a lot of the traditional conservative attitudes that modern conservatives abandoned to win power. I think hes smart enough to see though that its better to stick with the oldest political party in the world than jump ship to the very recent and not that well established phenomenon that is UKIP.
It is a little frustrating that some of these comments on political matters are disabled. The opportunity for astute comments to be heard are being missed.
We do not have the population groth that the usa has. Germany had 1974 78Million, in 2011 it had 80 Million; The UK grow in the same period from 56 to 63 Million of Population. The USA grew from 213M to 310M; Thats 45% vs. 12% or 3% (!); But pop grow indicated GDP grow is not wealth grow. The GDP per pop matters!
Honestly, me, as an Austrian, must admit: An eloquent & profound gentleman. It truly makes sense, indeed. If we could only come to understand his statements.As we like to say in German: "Er hat den Nagel auf den Kopf getroffen!" We truly appreciate this 😊
Yes and I voted for it, but it was never the intention for it to only be trading. Besides, who needs a trading community - Britain traded with the whole world for hundreds of years before this little plan.
Brilliant guy .... pity he forgot to mention that its is financial institutions that are being bailed out and not southern european states .... I wonder how a bright guy like him managed not to mention that?
Hannan, is the most eloquent speaker in parliament, imagine him together with farage in one party, together they can create the downfall of european dictatorship, showing to their voters that the EU is just a money consumming monster with no feelings at all about europe
wingingninja Nope, nowadays the source of all mass action is propaganda. If his statements have been being duplicated and publicised in mainstream media few times a day it would take effect. But while his oppinion is sinking in only some more aware minds...Well, an individual can't change the direction of policy, unless he is very rich or influential.
Centralization is anathema to freedom and justice! Power that isn't local is despotic! We MUST specify the limitations of cooperation and leave as much freedom to the individual as is possible!
It's amusing to consider that the Brits fought French unification of Europe twice under Napoleon, and fought German unification of Europe twice. Now they are fighting the unification of Europe under both France and Germany.
Just "Whoa". Great Speech. I cant remember listening to a "british" Speaker to which i could agree more. Splendid speech, thank you, Mr. Daniel Hannan!
You just cannot deny David Hannan's intellect on these issues. It's pretty obvious that anyone debating against David here would fall flat when it comes to the people and how disenfranchised they are right now. David really strikes a chord that is ringing so true to the common man and no pro EU bureaucrat can put forward a better argument for European centralisation. You can have great trade deals without centralisation of power.
Majority vote to the EU .... Have you been living on another planet ? ... The majority vote was to ' LEAVE ' ..... Yes Leave , You really need to take your head out of the sand and join us all in the real world !
Listening to this speech in 2020 it is clear that it was not about Germany and Europe, it was about Britain and Europe. Why should Germany not need Europe anymore? The EU is not about Germany writing the cheques, it is about nations pooling tasks and sovereignty to achieve more together than they can alone. Does Germany need Europe? Of course it does.
@@SNORKYMEDIA A matter of perpective. If you see which parts of your country contribute and which receive, you would not even start to think about exiting the UK as - let´s say - London. Why? Because in a greater entity there will always be receiving and contributing regions.
Be glad they are. With such hostility directed against us it would be a dereliction of duty not to do so. Do you imagine that so called friendly powers do not spy on us? Anyone who does, lives in an imaginary world that has never existed. Ignorance of the intentions of those around us can only lead to trust misplaced and catastrophic mistakes. Btw that also applies to your everyday life, though of course not with the ruthless inquisitiveness of the security services, but an awareness of the realities around you will not do you any harm. A wisely applied, scepticism can be a faithful protector. Knowledge is power, the power to survive, to prosper, and to thrive.
We are still, actually now we are 16 principalities. The Bundesrat can block any legislation and the Ministerpräsidenten der Länder are absolutly capable of standing up to Berlin and getting their will.
Germany today is so strong and rich like no other nation in the world. The future of the world goes germany! Even the germans did not know what should they do with so much money! So the germans do what they always do: working! Becasue this is the real sense of life! Today you have the best cars in germany, the best autobahns, you have the best culture and technology in germany, the best football teams, a agreat history and a glorious past and a great nation of all time. No other nation can claim this! If you are born in germany today you are a winner and never a loser. All - what you want is all what you find here in germany - today you live your dreams only in germany - the most beautifull country of all countries. Germany needs no europe - germany is europe! germany is the world today! A land of hope and glory! And God is here!
***** But Narania - tell me a great country that had no crimes in history???? So - now your position is very very weak! Germany is today a great country with a glorious past in spite of all evil that germany had brought in the world - germany today is a land of hope and glory!
***** Hello narania - germany is so small you cant find on globe! How can so a small country opressive, 90% right-wing, xenophobic, nationalistic Authoritarianism who is still trying to take over Europe??????????????? Impossible! But germany is unblieveable rich country - why we can not make today europe and the world more german??? The Theory germany would taje over europe is only a myth! Better for europe if germany could take over! No other country and nation is better than germany today - even you cant compare your country with germany!
Ehrlich, jetz beruhigense sich mal, Herr Rath. Sie reden wie ein 14-Jähriger. Nee, ich bin kein roter/grüner "Gutmensch" und wir müssen uns nicht alle Respektlosigkeiten gefallen lassen. Aber Ihre nicht enden wollenden völlig naiven "Deutschland-über-alles"-Aufsätze unter allen möglichen UA-cam-Videos sind echt peinlich.
If Europe and continents in general fare better diverse, decentralised, and as a multitude of nationalites then why doesn't Germany deunite into the multitude of German states that made up Germany before 1871? By that logic it will do much better than it does now.
A decentralized germany is harder to control. Don't forget, that European Nations used, and to some extent still see germany as a huge threat. Lagarde herself called the savings of the German people the biggest threat to the European economy. German ppl are very resourceful, other nations aren't as competitive. Too bad the Germans are always doomed with bad governments.
k4yser, Good points. Germans are a resourceful and intelligent people......except when it comes to picking their leaders. Then they have the brains of a sack of rocks. That's why they chose maniac Idiot leaders like Bismarck, Hitler and Merkel. SMH
@@richardharris3423 The same ur country ! The difference is our Leaders succeed when it comes to wealth while ur country is full of Homeless people and will collapse soon
@@richardharris3423 Bismarck and Merkel are /were alot smarter than whatever leader you had during those times. agree on Hitler but that guy was austrian.
Dodge Mustang The problem lies with our politicians spending the money, not with other countries. What started 70 years ago as loans to help rebuild, turned into a carrot and stick of control. This country is ignorant of European & Asian cultures, and we have plenty of concerns in this hemisphere to focus on.
The second you guys leave your global presence in EU, the russians will dominate the EU oil market. Chinese will get all good trade deals in EU. The great united states will look at it's former glory. The US depend on europe. Slava Rossya!
LaSiMuSi You are probably right based on the mindset of US policy makers over the past 50 years. I'm simply saying let the market decide who sells where. I'm glad to see the old communist economies of China and the former Soviet Union modify to market driven economies and for nearly 2 billion new customers to open up to the EU and the rest of the world. I simply want the US to get out of the way and let the best man win. We need to stop spending money to defend a part of the world that doesn't want us there to begin with.
"... you would assume that the Chinese would be the ones who sail around Africa and discover Portugal, rather than the other way around..." Mai nada Caralho!!! Proud Portuguese over here!
And this was five years before the Brexit referendum.......... I thought he sounded just a tad like Sir Humphry at the end....but excellent !!!! Les Griffiths Australia
Patriotism has to do with, keeping the country in good heart, the community Governed with justice and mercy, These will enlist loyalty and courage often. And sacrifice sometimes even martyrdom, Bear these eventualities in mind also, they will concern you for ever, But at this moment bear in mind these dead. Bear in mind these dead, I can find no plainer words, I dare not risk using that loaded word, Remember........
@conspiracytheory1066 Bah, helping is far from the thoughts of nearly every politician, not just the euro ones. I'm american, and we damn well need this guy over here.
I don't suppose its occurred to Hannan that in the first half of the 20th century that Europe spent most of the time tearing each other to bits which is why Germany and France got together after the 2nd such bout and decided to stop that happening ever again thus the European Union was born. As for Asia, I guess Hannan has never heard of ASEAN founded in 1967 which brings together now 10 countries of SE East Asia. Also perhaps he would like to explain China which is a Communist country, they seem to be doing rather well trade wise apparently according to Hannan that isn't supposed to happen.
Simply, the most articulate, intelligent, elegant and clear thinking true British gentleman I have ever heard... Bravo, sir!
Wouldn't it be wonderful if we could manage to elect such exceptionally qualified and considerate people as our leaders?
@Mr Olsen Sir. Your comment seems to be knee jerk sarcasm based solely on emotion rather than any evidence, explanation or logic.
Hannan has been a centrist pro-democracy, anti-collectivist and anti-plutocratic all his adult life, and made quite clear his disapproval of Putin's methods to gaining omnipotency.
He has even used the Russian government fake parliament, fake representation and dictatorial model as as an analogy for the evils of the EU Commission!
So, please do explain, of what exactly are you accusing him?
@Dick Head Would that be ad hominem perfectly illustrating presumptive plebeian envy? How's that publishing career going for you sir?
@Dick Head Presumably you mean nob? Get it together.
@Dick Head Way off beam. If you are going to criticise others, at least get your facts right. Such as correct spelling.
Every time I listen to Hannan I'm astounded. What a lecturer, how erudite, and how not like a politician. Pity - he really should be the next prime minister.
One to put Merkel to shame on any stage, in any contest, by any standard.
Same here. Hearing him for 5 years. Amazing
Clever guy! He'll never be invited on the bbc!
Peter Bradley.
From what I read and hear, plus what I view on UA-cam, Mr. Farage is unlikely to lose many points to any of those present in Strausberg, since their arguments cluster toward repetitive, and remain unconvincing. Besides, it clearly is difficult for them to dredge up the testosterone needed for another showdown with Mr. Farage, after having been outdrawn and outshot so consistently. Glazed grins just don't make up for intellectual inertia. It is a little surprising, though, that Mrs. Merkel seems unable to see why the remaining nation-states of Europe are somehow underimpressed with the charm of Germany's drive to bully the rest of Europe into speaking German. Can't think why. Look how trustworthy Volkswagen has turned out to be.
Ta.
Actually he is regularly on Any Questions on radio 4
@jrb designer alliance ''6'
Wow - He is the greatest speaker I have ever heard . Intellect on a level I could only dream of... Respect !
Hannan’s comments are a heinous affront to Gaia and Communism as well as being intolerant hate speech.
For The People™ nothing is more important than stringent Party orthodoxy. They must be taught to denounce all class enemies as well as their parents, friends, educators and other assorted reactionary dogs for crimes committed against the state.
Furthermore, a consensus has been formed; the science has been settled, the debate is over. Deniers must be burned at the stake for heresy, apostasy, and treason to the scientific consensus.
he is just talking trash
his books are amazing!
Like Hitler's early speeches.
What a delivery, marvelous speech, well done sir well done
Hannan was very voiciferous during the referendum campaign. he appeared in many discussion programmes on TV and Radio, and in the EU parliament of course.. After that, almost silence, WHY ? Only once have I seen him speaking in the house on Brexit issues.
This guy is brilliant at stating the truth.
*this guy is brilliant at articulating ideas that you agree with better than you could
Both!
meandmymouth yes.
meandmymouth
where have you been, he’s been around for some time. Have you just realised what a great speaker he is. Get involved.
The final words were excellent and so true. Pass the message on. Brilliant presentation.
Röpke rules!
This man is one of the best speakers in the English-speaking world. Even when he's answering questions, that is when he speaks without previous preparation.
This man is something else. Outstanding!
There must be something wrong here - he's talking common sense.
Don't worry no one is listening.
@zulfiqar Tareen ---- You really mean guys like him are a stumbling block to the establishment of the Mxslim dream of Pan Eurabia
@zulfiqar Tareen "He who is friend to all is friend to none."
He is brilliant thank God we have him to speak up for the British people
My goodness he is eloquent!
What's he like with a few beers in him haha
@@frantrictantric He'll lose his straight walk way before he loses his straight talk.
@@christiank1251 Its called composure aussi git.
What sets this man apart from most other politicians is that he is a deep thinker, worth hearing whichever part of the political spectrum you occupy. Where most politicians are superficial, dishonest careerists with nothing to offer but fear-mongering and obfuscation, he possesses the power to ignite his audiences with a new passion for politics and, most importantly, with hope. He can inspire us with a will to retake control of our own destiny, the only sure foundation upon which to build a brighter future. We must never allow our democratic rights and political engagement to be whittled away by the faceless Brussels bureaucrats.
His major political project (Brexit) has weakened UK more than any other policy the last 200 years. Which is why a big and increasingly bigger majority of the UK population considers Brexit a mistake. The talent of Hannan is purely oratory, but sadly a talent strong enough to make ludicrous propositions sound like the only sensible course of action. The political wisdom of nations are generally inversely proportional to the number of "Daniel Hannan analysts" in action.
What a speech and so true. Especially at this time.
Ha ha nice one
Never heard of him, but I have now - brilliant.
Wonderful speech, both in content and delivery. This quote in particular is so pithy i'll have to write it down: "When you take the demos out of democracy, you're left only with the cratos - with the power of a system that must compel by law, what it dare not ask in the name of civic patriotism".
A federalist EU is anti-Europe. The deliberate, manipulative attempts by many politicians to conflate the EU and Europe in the public mind should be called out on every occasion. If the EU is to exist, it should be minimalist, and be contained in that state by strong constitutional laws.
Hieronymus Larsson You are so right Herr Larsson
frank brown - I'm surprised that after 3 months I am the first person to give your reply a "like".
Thanks man
""Wonderful , well done Mr. Hannan .""👍
Makes the point perfectly and undeniably.
I love this man, I really do.
An outspoken, eloquent British version of Peter Schiff.
These are the voices we need to be hearing from, not the likes of Obama or labour.
A truly exceptional speech. Even the great Farage would love to make one such as that!
You're mixing cheap wine with great whisky mate
Such a good speech. A very clever man who argues from logic and fact.
So true are his words.
577666 Hes exceptional isnt he. I particularly enjoyed his presentation on why socialism does not work at the Oxford Union. Hes almost irrefutable!
Hannan has more charisma than the entire Labour party combined! He should run for leadership, I would rather him than Boris.
This man is amazing, far ahead of most other politicians. I wonder why he isn't leading the Brexit campaign? So eloquent, yes!
Absolutely! This man speaks out of genuine conviction and principles, and I can only respect that. How many other politicians really mean what they say? How many really think deep at all? The majority only lie and squirm to build themselves a well-paid career. Dan is for the people.
He sure is eloquent, but so was Goebbels. It only becomes a good trait if you use it to convince people of your cause, not manipulate them into believing it. Also you should not think he is different from any other politician. They all say exactly what their voters want to hear and not even the most compelling facts can push them out of their comfort zone. He lies as much as left wing politicians, bending the facts to match his agenda and all only to build themselves a well-paid career
Paul Ralph, because he is not a proponent of a "One World Order", or as they used to say, hes not a "One Worlder"
FarmerSchinken have you ever pondered that it might be possible that Geobbels and Hitler actually spoke the Truth? Truthful propaganda? Or would you say that the Jews who were in Germany at the time spoke the truth in thier newspapers before they were forced out?
@@FarmerSchinken illuminate his lies Farmer, we deserve the truth, nothing less.
It is a brilliant speech. Down with the EU commission please! We need a Council of Europe not a communist state.
this aged well
@TheMadScotsman mckay Well said Mad Mac ! We have been sold the lie of "shared sovereignty, sometimes they call it " pooled sovereignty" again, a lie. Sovereignty cannot by the definition of sovereignty be shared. To lose, or give away sovereignty is to abolish ones nation. To accept laws imposed by a foreign power is to accept the abolition of ones nation. To remove borders, eventually also removing them from maps as national demarcation lines, replaced by outlines of administrative areas, is to accept the abolition of ones country. We want it back, so that we can cooperate in areas of mutual benefit, but be free to make our own treaties, our own trading arrangements, our own laws instead of ,as currently approximately 2/3 of our laws emanating from Russell's with EU law taking supremacy over the laws we have made ourselves. Tied as we are to the EU, we are not free to adopt good ideas from other countries, unless 27 other EU members agree. That is not progress, except towards the dreary harmful one size fits all of the Orwellian super state. To hell with it. No one needs it. Europe will be better when we are all free nations once again rather than the soon to be monolith Europa. Nations that make their own laws, trade where and when they will in friendly cooperation.
@@barryfullick7981 Yeah lets get back to the first half of the 20th century when Europe consisted of separate states it was all love, peace and prosperity. Or perhaps you would like to go back to the 19th century or the 18th, take you pick.
Try looking up at the sky it appears every day our sovereignty is being infringed with aeroplanes flying over, landing etc from scores of different countries. Why the hell don't we stop them infringing our sovereignty? Or how about the American Forces that are stationed in the UK or even our immigrations officers station in Calais Just some examples of your so called sovereignty in the real world.
@@Tridhos in one word, nonsense!
He and the UK have to face the consequences of that claims already now.
A truly remarkable orator, such speech making can only come from true conviction and belief. Agree with him or not you have to admire his ability to truly captive an audience.
He should be leading the leave campaign...great speaker!
I will agree with you if you can allow Scottish independent, United Ireland and Wales independent. You people always double standard.
Samuel Olaogun stupid idiot! who are you to want to split UK!?? GO TO AFRICA and do the politics there!
@@samuelolaogun9044 let them good riddance!!
@@samuelolaogun9044 To be quite honest.... you can do your own votums. Sadly enough the scottish independence vote is for EU or for britain which is bad vote as scotland could just choose not to be part of either.
@conspiracytheory1066 I think we can still agree on one thing, though- We need more people like this, everywhere.
IMPRESSIVE SPEAKER.
You said it Ralf. There is only one way to wealth.....work, save, and invest. I don't care what hole you find yourself in but you can dig out. It may not even be you who sees the fruits of those labors. It may be your grandchildren. The Irish and Italians came to America and worked 7 days a week and smiled, glad to be in a free market country where they would someday see the fruits of their labor, and they did.
Ireland and Italy were and are free marker countries.
@@euan7166 buzzzzz.....wrong....they had a semblance of a free market controlled by powerful land holders and rulers who hob nobbed with the rich and powerful and did their bidding. This left the lower people impoverished. Go read some history.
@@j50wells You're right, I'm sorry. That sounds so different to the USA.
@@euan7166 Huge, huge difference. Anyone in America can buy land easily. You can also start a business. Are you willing to work hard to get there?
Very well said Mr Hannan..
I feel my IQ is being squared!
Well said Daniel Hannah wonderful to hear sanity spoken, bless you 🌞
THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOU
My grandpa was full blooded German. He worked 70 hours a week all of his life. His fruits included a big house and a red barn on ten acres. You know what he did for a living? He drove a belly dump truck, but he kept working and pinching pennies. Anyone today can do what my grandpa did, if they want to work to get it. There's no free lunch. A lot of people are caught up into this dream world of working 40 hours a week and becoming rich. Nonsense. That might work for a small select category of very talented people, but even they had to knuckle down and work their butts off at some point.
Bollocks mate. For a start there are more people than jobs. Then there is the fact that govts make working so many hours illegal. And then theres the fact that the the price of houses and land relative to wages has doubled or tripled or quadrupled.
David Sharp we are free to work as much or as little as we wish in the USA....We like to work....Money is !!
(Freedom to do what you want ,when you want) Europe has lost its way,it does not even value children....That's why the birthrates,have been sub replacement for decades....
Try again in the English language.
Sounds like you have comprehension problems,I would recommend a good Neurologist...:)
"We like to work... Money is!!!" Lol. No.
This aged like milk for the UK
This man is a great speaker. Does he write his own material?
+wingingninja Yes.
+stefanos2691 - And just who do you think writes it?
He used to write for William Hague when he was leader of the opposition, so I imagine he writes for himself now.
Probably explains why Hague never won the general election. I recall him banging on about saving the pound and nobody at the time was suggesting otherwise certainly not Brown the then Chancellor.
What a speech!!! So well put together. I had to clap my phone.
He speaks really well, listening to him, I thought he was a UKIP MEP
I don't think it is directly pro German propaganda. What is wrong with a German exit from the EU or a British exit from the EU for that matter. Why should young Germans feel guilty about WWII? He is saying what many have already seen. I took part in the Schalke International Military Tattoo earlier this year. We (a British band) were conversing with a German band, and they were looking at the medals on our uniforms. One asked a question: "Which war is that medal from?" Another German said (in comically forgetful tone): "Vat War, vat war? Then all together with the John Cleese classic. "Don't mention ze var!" Laughing, smiling and in good humour. They have put the past behind them and want to move forward in peace.
falcons1988 He should be really, his views probably align more with UKIP than the conservatives of today. UKIP represent a lot of the traditional conservative attitudes that modern conservatives abandoned to win power.
I think hes smart enough to see though that its better to stick with the oldest political party in the world than jump ship to the very recent and not that well established phenomenon that is UKIP.
It is a little frustrating that some of these comments on political matters are disabled. The opportunity for astute comments to be heard are being missed.
Excellent speaker and speech 👏👏👏👏👏
And on top of all that....there's the Kalergi Plan.
i wish that we have brilliant brain as daniel hannan in our countries
Great speech!
Somehow I knew all that but did not know to put words in right order. Bravo mr. Hannan, you have got my voice from Serbia.
We do not have the population groth that the usa has. Germany had 1974 78Million, in 2011 it had 80 Million; The UK grow in the same period from 56 to 63 Million of Population. The USA grew from 213M to 310M; Thats 45% vs. 12% or 3% (!); But pop grow indicated GDP grow is not wealth grow. The GDP per pop matters!
Absolutely brilliant, as usual!!!!!
If he had said 600 years - he'd be right, but 500 years ago one could forsee, that Europe was on the rise.
Honestly, me, as an Austrian, must admit: An eloquent & profound gentleman. It truly makes sense, indeed. If we could only come to understand his statements.As we like to say in German: "Er hat den Nagel auf den Kopf getroffen!" We truly appreciate this 😊
Bravo !
Daniel Hannan is ALWAYS worth listening to. If only the British governments listened as well.
Bravo and Bravo again Daniel Hannan! You hit the nail on the head again
The idea of a European trading community was a good one. The forced march towards a European political union dominated by Germany is an abomination.
Yes and I voted for it, but it was never the intention for it to only be trading. Besides, who needs a trading community - Britain traded with the whole world for hundreds of years before this little plan.
even though britain and france have been growing stronger by the fact to be in the eu
@@michaelsmitten9240 you "traded with the world" you invaded nearly everyone and forced them to let your stuff in.
Brilliant guy .... pity he forgot to mention that its is financial institutions that are being bailed out and not southern european states .... I wonder how a bright guy like him managed not to mention that?
Made me teary eyed talking bout Germany
Brillant nice to hear common sense for a change
keep it up we need to hear another reality apart from the pro eu media hegemony
Why isn't this man in the British Parliament? Beautifully spoken sensible speaking. Well done I am proud of you.
Always love listening to Daniel Hannan, common sence and intellectual talk. Brilliant.
NEVER EVER HAS THERE BEEN A SPEECH OF 9 minute 4 seconds MAKING SO MUCH POINTS THAT ALL MADE SENSE.
YOU ARE A HERO “SIR”. IAN FROM 💕SCOTLAND💕
Hannan, is the most eloquent speaker in parliament, imagine him together with farage in one party, together they can create the downfall of european dictatorship, showing to their voters that the EU is just a money consumming monster with no feelings at all about europe
Yea, if only speaking could change anything...
It does Kevin. It changes hearts and minds. That the source of all action
wingingninja Nope, nowadays the source of all mass action is propaganda. If his statements have been being duplicated and publicised in mainstream media few times a day it would take effect. But while his oppinion is sinking in only some more aware minds...Well, an individual can't change the direction of policy, unless he is very rich or influential.
@@Kevi_N. No, but his teachings can if widespread.
Compare the money of your countrys budget for the Eu and for your own country and you will see which one is the consuming monster.
How could he overlook millions of death from wars in Europe in every century?
dude than ask yourself what your country did in the past!
Wow! That was a great speech
Pumkin Eater 77( n7h
Hooray !!!! English gentleman !!!!!! Very proud of you
hes not English
Centralization is anathema to freedom and justice! Power that isn't local is despotic! We MUST specify the limitations of cooperation and leave as much freedom to the individual as is possible!
It's amusing to consider that the Brits fought French unification of Europe twice under Napoleon, and fought German unification of Europe twice. Now they are fighting the unification of Europe under both France and Germany.
How true, a clarity of eloquence dispels the dyspepsia of myopsis
And none of it written so eloquent.
Just "Whoa". Great Speech. I cant remember listening to a "british" Speaker to which i could agree more. Splendid speech, thank you, Mr. Daniel Hannan!
Très intéressant ! Merci !
You just cannot deny David Hannan's intellect on these issues. It's pretty obvious that anyone debating against David here would fall flat when it comes to the people and how disenfranchised they are right now. David really strikes a chord that is ringing so true to the common man and no pro EU bureaucrat can put forward a better argument for European centralisation. You can have great trade deals without centralisation of power.
I wish the UK Parliament agreed with this man. The people know what is right, that is why the majority vote was to the the EU.
"the the" or "leave the".. huge difference
xyork correction....leave the EU.
NAAAAGH THEY HAVE OTHER INTERESTS---THEIR OWN
Majority vote to the EU .... Have you been living on another planet ? ... The majority vote was to ' LEAVE ' ..... Yes Leave , You really need to take your head out of the sand and join us all in the real world !
Absolutely brilliant!
Gladly. Good luck with all that greek debt. And italy, and spain, and ireland...
Listening to this speech in 2020 it is clear that it was not about Germany and Europe, it was about Britain and Europe.
Why should Germany not need Europe anymore?
The EU is not about Germany writing the cheques, it is about nations pooling tasks and sovereignty to achieve more together than they can alone.
Does Germany need Europe? Of course it does.
4 contributors and 23 receivers of cash - what could go wrong?
@@SNORKYMEDIA A matter of perpective. If you see which parts of your country contribute and which receive, you would not even start to think about exiting the UK as - let´s say - London.
Why? Because in a greater entity there will always be receiving and contributing regions.
Daniel is a fine speaker with every point making very good sense
And now Europe no longer needs the UK. Well done, my Lord Danny-Boy of Not-Very-Clear. Your apotheosis into the H of L is admirable!
"Living together as friendly neighbours" - GCHQ is showing currently how friendly they are with their neighbours.
Be glad they are. With such hostility directed against us it would be a dereliction of duty not to do so. Do you imagine that so called friendly powers do not spy on us? Anyone who does, lives in an imaginary world that has never existed. Ignorance of the intentions of those around us can only lead to trust misplaced and catastrophic mistakes. Btw that also applies to your everyday life, though of course not with the ruthless inquisitiveness of the security services, but an awareness of the realities around you will not do you any harm. A wisely applied, scepticism can be a faithful protector. Knowledge is power, the power to survive, to prosper, and to thrive.
The Brits one has to admit have a natural innate gift for eloquence..
This so true and neither does the UK
Why not have Germany return to the dozens of principalities?
We are still, actually now we are 16 principalities.
The Bundesrat can block any legislation and the Ministerpräsidenten der Länder are absolutly capable of standing up to Berlin and getting their will.
@Y T And Scotland.
Nobody cares about Wails...poor Wails
stunning statement backed up with a plethora of facts, evidence and reason!
or not, your pick.
Love this man. From America.
Run for leadership of the Tories Mr.Hannan, for Christ's sake
Germany today is so strong and rich like no other nation in the world. The future of the world goes germany! Even the germans did not know what should they do with so much money! So the germans do what they always do: working! Becasue this is the real sense of life! Today you have the best cars in germany, the best autobahns, you have the best culture and technology in germany, the best football teams, a agreat history and a glorious past and a great nation of all time. No other nation can claim this! If you are born in germany today you are a winner and never a loser. All - what you want is all what you find here in germany - today you live your dreams only in germany - the most beautifull country of all countries. Germany needs no europe - germany is europe! germany is the world today! A land of hope and glory! And God is here!
***** But Narania - tell me a great country that had no crimes in history???? So - now your position is very very weak!
Germany is today a great country with a glorious past in spite of all evil that germany had brought in the world - germany today is a land of hope and glory!
***** Hello narania - germany is so small you cant find on globe! How can so a small country opressive, 90% right-wing, xenophobic, nationalistic Authoritarianism who is still trying to take over Europe???????????????
Impossible!
But germany is unblieveable rich country - why we can not make today europe and the world more german??? The Theory germany would taje over europe is only a myth! Better for europe if germany could take over!
No other country and nation is better than germany today - even you cant compare your country with germany!
Ehrlich, jetz beruhigense sich mal, Herr Rath. Sie reden wie ein 14-Jähriger. Nee, ich bin kein roter/grüner "Gutmensch" und wir müssen uns nicht alle Respektlosigkeiten gefallen lassen. Aber Ihre nicht enden wollenden völlig naiven "Deutschland-über-alles"-Aufsätze unter allen möglichen UA-cam-Videos sind echt peinlich.
***** ISt das so schlimm, wenn Deutschland über alles ist?
***** goebels was a nazi! Are you a nazi?
If Europe and continents in general fare better diverse, decentralised, and as a multitude of nationalites then why doesn't Germany deunite into the multitude of German states that made up Germany before 1871? By that logic it will do much better than it does now.
A decentralized germany is harder to control. Don't forget, that European Nations used, and to some extent still see germany as a huge threat. Lagarde herself called the savings of the German people the biggest threat to the European economy. German ppl are very resourceful, other nations aren't as competitive. Too bad the Germans are always doomed with bad governments.
k4yser, Good points. Germans are a resourceful and intelligent people......except when it comes to picking their leaders. Then they have the brains of a sack of rocks. That's why they chose maniac Idiot leaders like Bismarck, Hitler and Merkel. SMH
@@richardharris3423 The same ur country ! The difference is our Leaders succeed when it comes to wealth while ur country is full of Homeless people and will collapse soon
These identities dont exist anymore.
@@richardharris3423 Bismarck and Merkel are /were alot smarter than whatever leader you had during those times. agree on Hitler but that guy was austrian.
Great orator!
...EUROPE No Longer needs U.S.A...
Carlos Krueger Thank you.
...No Problema...
Dodge Mustang The problem lies with our politicians spending the money, not with other countries. What started 70 years ago as loans to help rebuild, turned into a carrot and stick of control. This country is ignorant of European & Asian cultures, and we have plenty of concerns in this hemisphere to focus on.
The second you guys leave your global presence in EU, the russians will dominate the EU oil market. Chinese will get all good trade deals in EU. The great united states will look at it's former glory. The US depend on europe. Slava Rossya!
LaSiMuSi You are probably right based on the mindset of US policy makers over the past 50 years. I'm simply saying let the market decide who sells where.
I'm glad to see the old communist economies of China and the former Soviet Union modify to market driven economies and for nearly 2 billion new customers to open up to the EU and the rest of the world. I simply want the US to get out of the way and let the best man win. We need to stop spending money to defend a part of the world that doesn't want us there to begin with.
"... you would assume that the Chinese would be the ones who sail around Africa and discover Portugal, rather than the other way around..." Mai nada Caralho!!! Proud Portuguese over here!
@AurynThePaladin hee hee! Damn he's articulate and eloquent. Brilliant comment!
And this was five years before the Brexit referendum.......... I thought he sounded just a tad like Sir Humphry at the end....but excellent !!!!
Les Griffiths Australia
Patriotism has to do with,
keeping the country in good heart,
the community Governed with justice and mercy,
These will enlist loyalty and courage often.
And sacrifice sometimes even martyrdom,
Bear these eventualities in mind also,
they will concern you for ever,
But at this moment bear in mind these dead.
Bear in mind these dead,
I can find no plainer words,
I dare not risk using that loaded word,
Remember........
Always liked this man, talks sense and we should listen to him.
Perhaps we should join forces with Germany and be proud of our own country.
@conspiracytheory1066 Bah, helping is far from the thoughts of nearly every politician, not just the euro ones. I'm american, and we damn well need this guy over here.
I could listen to him all night he is amazing wish he was prime minister.
Wow and bravo!!!!!!!
Why does Germany not want Europe anymore now the uk is leaving it seems a little strange don't you think.
In Britain, too many people talk themselves drunk with their thoughts.
😁 Yes
Such CLARITY of speech. Such clarity of view.
I don't suppose its occurred to Hannan that in the first half of the 20th century that Europe spent most of the time tearing each other to bits which is why Germany and France got together after the 2nd such bout and decided to stop that happening ever again thus the European Union was born.
As for Asia, I guess Hannan has never heard of ASEAN founded in 1967 which brings together now 10 countries of SE East Asia.
Also perhaps he would like to explain China which is a Communist country, they seem to be doing rather well trade wise apparently according to Hannan that isn't supposed to happen.
Tridhos China started doing much better after they took over Hong Kong from the British. Maybe they picked up a few good ideas.
William Boyd China started doing much better long before they took back Hong Kong when they got rid of the lunatic Mao and his disastrous policies.
how dare you muddle his eloquence with rational argument?!
Tridhos ASEAN is not a Superstate. It is a Association for cooperation. The tragedy of EU is the USE german project.
@@wlboyd I think you will find that China started doing better as you put it when the lunatic Mao died and the pragmatist Deng Xiaoping took over.
What a speech, congratulations for such mind.
Cringe inducing
Problem being that this interaction which he wants for europe has caused a whole lot of wars prior before the EU