This is a true picture by this gentlemen. For the first time in the last 500 years a "PAGAN", a "KAFFIR" can proudly stand up and shout out to the world, without any sense of apologia, "I am Hindu, my forefathers were Hindu, a 1000 generations back, and I'll continue to adhere to my mother faith for eons to come"
@adityakumar, That’s unfortunate for you. You want to keep worshiping the stone idols made by your own pandits for their own good. Pagans like you are misguided brother, Ram is non existent, he was no where before 12-23 century. No mandir was destroyed to make Babri Masjid. Ram is a fictions character, or if he was there, he was just a normal local king. City of Ayodhya was non existent before 13 century. Get a grip brother. These false gods can not benefit you hereafter.
Yes most welcome but everyone must bring a percentage of land with them. If not, there's no need for them to come. They chose to live in India during partition time.
@@hritikraghuwanshi2049if they were smart they would atleast have sc or Yadav wing as they say Jai Bheem Jai Mim But their anti Hindu hate has made them morons
The names say it all...RSS is for the nation and not religion and JI is for religion not nation. It's unfortunate reflections on Indian muslims that to.attract them RSS needs to name separate muslim manch
@metaxerart Islam, Christianity, Marxism & Fiat Currency like $ driven hedonistic consumerism are foreign gangs/legions created specifically to enslave, rob, deracinate and grab REgal political political power. So Jamaat by design is anti national and hates everything native. It can't create a nation or Rashtra. Present condition of Pakistan is because of rootless parasitic population.
This is the first time I’ve seen a rational analysis of Hindutva by a Pakistani. I would like to add that Pakistan’s hostility towards India since the day of its creation has also played a major role in the rise of Hindutva movement in India.
I am from state of westbengal, here govt give subsidy for haj,free muslims girls education,monthly pension for maulana,why special treatment for others?why not equal treatment..Muslims are the richest community in our state..even our temple development comes under a muslim minister
Jaisa vote vaisa mantri 😊. But most bengalis keep telling us that they are the intellectuals of our society and start listing out all the Nobel prizes they have. Now since we r all not intelligent enough for them they have started this great experiment in their state a f trust me the freebies and violence will keep increasing till it becomes unsustainable 😊
Indian muslims : we want to be communal(islamic) but India and other communities need to be pro islamic secular..this is totally unfair and you miss this important mindset of muslims of India. And you can't blame hindus for this. Only muslims and their islamic ideologies are responsible for their dire state not just in India but around the globe...
Sex slave, jihad, loot & rape, namaz, jumma, more sex with wife, sex with sister, sex with goat, gay sex with mulla, pedophilia, sex with hoor, jihad, alla Akbar boom !! There you go 90% of Islam summarised.😂
One of my friend worked in US for 10 years in CISCO and one day left everything, came back to India to become RSS Pracharak. Now he is in North East India, working among Tribals. Life dedicated to nation. Rashtraya Swaha, Idam na mama.
😂😅 by muslims we want islamic country, we want freedom of religion, we want every fundamental rights in other islamic land but you have to be a liberal😅 otherwise you are communal.
Westerners are C H R I S T I A N by background but liberal secular in governance like the way our India USED TO BE.............until goondutva showed up on our doorstep in 2014
Ram Leela ki murti? Yeh kaun si language is. This is again political criticism in the garb of in intellectualism. You still don't understand Hinduism 😅
It’s not a revenge if a victim goes to oppressor to hold him accountable. Hindus reclaiming their identity and holding invaders accountable is called as assertiveness and getting closure from past colonial times. Don’t call it revenge. If it was revenge, situation with be totally different.
Very mature and nuanced analysis, honestly this is the first Pakistani analyst who hit the nail on the spot, even acclaimed Pakistani journalist were also superficial.
I am impressed with the Professor Sahab’s understanding of Indian politics and his balanced articulation. I don’t think I have seen such balance from any Pak expert
I have heard 100s of Pakistani Intellectuals and believe me I have heard each of them in details. I must congrats the professor for such a deep understand of Hindutva Philosophy and Indian politics. This is the first time, I have heard a Pakistani Intellectual to be honest and in-depth anayslis of Hindutva & Indian Politics. You both deserve a big round of applause for being so unbiased and truthful
Also this professor did not blame Hindus and BJP but did very fair Anyalsis not only that Pakistani Muslims are in fashion to bring bhrhamis to blame, but he equally expose Ashrafasim and Syedisim of Islam too, wish indians had this kind of honest Muslims, but he is in Pakistan where he will be not valued.
India, Pakistan and Bangladesh must exchange population on religious basis. Pakistan and Bangladesh must accommodate Indian Muslims, and India will accommodate Pakistani and Bangladeshi Hindus and Sikhs.
In India second largest majority that's Muslims are not discriminated as Ahmediyas and Shias are being discriminated, what to talk of Minorities, like Hindus and Christians in Pakistan.
Logic of a Peaceful : I will practice Jihad against Kaffir. But all Kaffirs should keep practicing SECULARISM against us and focus more on giving more rights to Peacefuls. The moment Hindus doubt the concept of secularism, they become FACISTS & Communal. The entire world knows about this “logic” of Peacefuls
Pakistan hardly matters as far as Indian elections are concerned... Albeit, Mody is well placed to win 2024 general elections...the reasons being.. Good performance on economic front especially on inflation which has been consistently low for a long period of time.. Secondly, opposition is divided and don't have charismatic leader like Mody... Thirdly, INDIA alliance is a non starter...they are divided
Allah could not save his 360 relatives and siblings who were there in Kaba at Macca. We hear his loud wailing and moaning in pain because of MohMadMasti of MohMaddens five times a day. Natives of the subcontinent have decided to save poor Allah and heal his bleeding MohMad. They will give him Ayurvedic treatment which does not have side effects. Would you help natives in this noble endeavor? Hindus can't be booked. Their scriptures and history is in their DNA Look around - a typical EU city might have 4% MohMaddens in the total population, but 40% of criminals booked and convicted are MohMaddens. The crimes they did are rape, drugs peddling, running prostitution, grooming of underage white girls for sexual slavery (laundi bazi) and MohMadMasti with little boys (bacchabazi as done by brute Babar with 13 year old love boy Babri Niyazi in Urdu/Turki Army rent). Tree stable hoti hai jab uske roots deep aur strong hote hai. AbraHarami legions/gangs (Christianity, Islam, Marxism & Fiat Currency $ driven hedonistic consumerism) survive and spread by cutting roots of converts. Roots are native spirituality, native culture, native languages & pride in achievements of native ancestors. Why do you have to tag currency of Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent (ISIS) to super Kaffir State's currency $. ISIS also need to stop calling its currency Roopaya, since next door existential enemy Kaffir has been calling its currency Roopaya for last ten thousand years. Most of ISIS's problems get resolved when it starts calling its currency Dinar. Desi Anar khatte hote hai par phorren Arabi Dinar meethe hote hai - Hai ki nahi?
THERE WERE 22% HINDUS IN PAKISTAN IN 1947 AND NOW IT IS 1.5%.PLEASE EXPLAIN TO US HOW IT AS HAPPENED.IN INDIA IN 1947 MUSLIMS WERE 9% NOW IT IS 16%.PLEASE EXPLAIN IT TO US.
Who are you... A Hindu whose ancestors converted. How are you different than me or any Hindu. Look at you... You look like me your DNA is mine. Just because some Invaders came and brutalized your ancestors now Mohan became Mohammad. Ravi became Rizwan. Can you deny this ultimate truth? By you I mean the common Pakistani. You deny your reality and roots if you say you are an Arab or Persian ancestry. People of the land of the Sindhu river where Hinduism actually began. Infact you are more Hindu than anyone of us.
Bahaut tareef kar di Dr sahab ne 😂 Though, I can tell Dr Sahab has read a lot about Hinduism, the evolution of Hindu Reform Movements, pre Partition Congress Politics and growth of Hindutva Political Structure and Ideology.
Sensible and knowledgeable professor. Good points. Does not do any dog whistling or hateful prejudice. Need more people like this in both india and pakistan to present views.
Indian Muslim never declined , we saw muslim president , muslim union ministers and many celebrities, cricketers and government officers in India. But, will we ever getto see Hindus on such position in Pakistan. 😂
Ram is not same as we saw. We came as Refugees from Lahore. Please learn history. Word HINDU + BAROOD CAME WITH BABAR- from AFGANISTAN- DNA AURANGZEB BIRTH 3RD NOV I618 DAHOD GUJARAT LAKSHAHGRAH IN UTTAR PRADESH MAHABHARAT IN 1947- PLEASE GO TO KATASRAJ SHIV TEMPLE IN ZILA CHAKWAL- YOU DO NOT KNOW HISTORY AT ALL- READ ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF KALHAN'S RAJ TARANGNI+ BABARNAMA- PLEASE LEARN ABC 🙉🙊🙈
Faisal Gurmani I doubt you deserve brickbats for this show because you and your guest were by and large pretty fair and balanced…..not the usual rhetorical stuff that we come across from Pakistani UA-camrs….infact I would actually commend the professor for dissecting politics and the socioeconomic factors so succinctly
'Decline of muslims in India's...r u joking?? Badti hui population kya asman se aa rahi hai?? Whoever left post partition in India are nationalists not of religion identity...agar hai to fir Pakistan bana hua aiso ke liye.... Talk on decline of non muslims in Pakistan.
If there is a decline of Muslims in India then how come Muslim population in India grown from 9% (3.6 crore) in 1951 to 15% (24 crore) 2021? However in West Pakistan Hindu+Sikh population went down from 7% in 1951 to less than 1.5% in 2021??
Ayodhya toh Bas jhaki hy Abhi Mathura kashi Or 40 Hazar Baki hy.।। 🕉🚩 Picture Hum Banayenge Dekhega Pura Islamic World.।। Allah ny in jahilo k Dimag me tala laga Diya He allah tala🔒😆 teri Chabi kho Gyi.।। 🔑🤣
This is for the 3rd time I am hearing Pak professor doing discussion on Hindutva and let me tell you, the whole discussion and arguments provided by Honbl Prof. Are filled with inaccuracies, lack of historical context, Lack of scholarship on Hindutva ideology starting from Savarkar, Tilak, Vivekananda etc. then rise of BJP and it's separation from Congress. You need to do more research, Prof. Had a lot of contradictions. Kindly invite Kushal Mehra from Carvaka Podcast Dr. Rangnathan or Abhijit Iyer Mitra as a serious scholar and let me tell you all of them are well read, Experts in thier fileds and consider themselves as Hindu Atheists who accept Hinduism and hindutva with all Major Flaws while advocating Massive reformation. Do consider my comment and I assure you that you gonna shoot up your viewership specially Abhijit and Dr. Anand.
Please do more podcasts with him... He is the only one who I found sensible among so called Pakistani intellectuals.... All the best bro.... Keep it up.... One advice... Please don't bring scrap into your podcast. Bring people like this man
Next BJP steps are---- Muslims Waqf bord Uniform civil code Education of science and math in Madarsa Muslims mordenity Removal of Bangladeshi and rohingya Removal of illegall possession from government land
Greetings from New Delhi...Just two limited points..1) 500 years ago Ayodhya was just land dotted with a few temples. The Babri Masjid could have been constructed anywhere..The very fact that it was constructed on a spot after demolishing an important temple ( authenticated by chief Archeologist KK Muhammad who was a Muslim) shows the intent was to subjugate and humiliate the Hindus. 2) In Saudi Arabia Mosques, Mazars and Cemeteries are all shifted to make way for development. Why cant the Indian Muslims show some generosity to 85% of the population and agree to shifting Kashi and Mathura Mosques to other sites where land and even construction cost can be born by the Govt to make brand new modern mosques. It will be a gesture which will win over Hindu hearts. The fear that this will continue with other mosques is unfounded. These temples are of great significance to the Hindus and beyond this there is no interest.
After listening to the podcast for a few minutes, I am fully into it. I was a teenager when Modi came into power in 2014, and I have personally witnessed the shift in mindset of the Indian middle class. I can see a parallel between this podcast and the societal transformation taking place. keep doing good work👍👍
Etna sare Pakistani podcast dekhne ke bad ajj ek sehi or right Pakistani intellectual Mila actually me educated Me wait karta ta Raha the full podcast kahnape galti karenge lekin sir pura perfect the good analysis by professor Dear host please bring these type of intellectual in your show 👍👍👍
I agree to some of the observation by the Prof. But from Hindu point of view the 3 most holy places of Mathura , Kashi and Ayodhya temple had to be recovered from muslim occupation which were demolished temples .
almost exactly explained the political situation of India. Loved it... He is saying points from both left and right wing. Most accurately explained. 1st ever Pakistani professor explaining things so factually and accurately
This professor is a rare man. The accurate insight he has gained on India is amazing. I would love to listen to him again on the subject what he thinks is the way to improve the education status of Muslims in India. Honestly I have tried and occasionally run foul of relegious teachers - volunteering in poor Muslim neighbourhoods is a nervewracking experience
Actually first Pakistani, I have found who is rational and intellectual. There are certain glaring errors or misconception professor did had such, Temple Puja recently started in basement. No it was just state government stopped for many years, without any permission from a court yo apease muslim. Also all the archaeological evidence and historical evidence by historian including Auranzen historians write that they have destroyed temples and build mosques on top of it. So if we want to solve the problem, we need to accept what the problem is professorsaab. The last thing I would say, you are very clear in your identity and you do not have identity crisis because you accept yourself as a Indian and a proud Muslim. Most of the Pakistani do not have this most of the Pakistani thinks they are either Turkish or Arab or Afghani or Persian hence the problem. Now going back to one thing which you Really identified was Pakistani looks Indian Muslim has one bunch but that’s not the case just to give you example shia has were not allowed to have their possession in Kashmir by Sunnis until Modi came and allowed that so there you go.
Also, you have many misconceptions about cast system. Cast system is just the work classification at least in original sense, and you were allowed to move freely between cast that one was broken by Brahmin in a old time, but now Brahmins do not have a power and they are not rich also and every one is now just Hindu cast barrier will eventually go away with time.
Whenever I tried to find any Pakistanis having any in depth knowledge of socio politics of India, most of the time, I saw uncles exhibiting racial/Islamic supremacy or suffering from "hamne hazar saal hinduo par hukumat ki hai" fallacy. Furthermore, most of them are unaware about the India beyond the Punjabi or Urdu-speaking aspect. On the other hand, there are a lot of Pakistan watchers in India who have immense knowledge of Pakistani politics, society, to its internal faultlines. I am glad to see that finally, we encountered academicians like Prof Mujeeb Afzal, who has sufficient knowledge about India's diversity and regional politics. Hope to see him again in the future.
I stumbled onto this video by chance and thoroughly enjoyed it. Your guest has been a joy to listen to. His analysis is by far the most fair and just one I've heard about India, RSS or hindutva. That other prof hoodboy should learn a lot from this gentleman or jump into that black hole where he talks from. Thank you for making this nice video and bringing such a properly educated gentleman.
Narendra modi is leader of india and he pumps a hope in every hindu family that he will reclaim our history of ancient India . We want our cholas pandyas rashtrakuta raghuwansh suryawanshi culture and prosperity back which was deprived by mughal and muslim rulers they demolished our many temples and made masjid and we are reclaiming our temple
Suffering of the Indian Muslims is due to partition of British India, Britishers locked Muslims into three part...... Worst part East and West Part (Bangladesh), while rest left into the hands of Higher Castes Respected Hindus.... 😢😢😢
Kitna tarakki kar raha ha pak ke muslim bharat se alag reh kar ?? Bhai ab bhi pakistan Jane ka rasta open he bharat bahut bura he hindu bahut bure he nare lagao aur chhod do bharat ko immediately
@@mayankindian3750 inhe Inka kuch mat kaho Inka kehna he ke ko bura ho Gaya ise thik karna julm he matlab koi Inka ghar todkar mandir bana le to ye sari zindagi nahi bhulenge lekin Ghar todkar masjid bana li to use waisa he rehne do aur masjid todna inke liye julm he lekin mandir todna julm nahi he,,,pak me sare hindu khatam karna Inka right he lekin bharat me muslim ke population 1947 se ab Tak 9 times jyada ho gaye ye julm he,,,,bharat ke tukde kar ke islamic desh pak banana Inka haq he lekin bharat me hindu rashtra ke baat karna camunal he ye halat he inki
Dr. Mujib watch, read and observe India and it's current affairs from right sources. He also unapologetically accepted that His origin is Indian and his ancestors were Hindu.
Logic of a Peaceful : I will practice Jihad against Kaffir. But all Kaffirs should keep practicing SECULARISM against us and focus more on giving more rights to Peacefuls. The moment Hindus doubt the concept of secularism, they become FACISTS & Communal. The entire world knows about this “logic” of Peacefuls
Islam itself is very serious impediment in modernizing muslims. For ex madras is more important than a good English or hindi medium schools, scul cap, 5 times Nawaz is more important than productivity, half pygama with long kurta became more important...... However your speaker is sensible analyzer unlike most other Pakistani speaker.
Hinduism is so diverse and deep that followers of Abrahamic can never understand its philosophy.
Thats why they have simplified it only one god believe or die 😂
@@Shashi3577😂👍
BC ye log imagine hi krte rhnge
that why onli in india
So then explain us
This is a true picture by this gentlemen. For the first time in the last 500 years a "PAGAN", a "KAFFIR" can proudly stand up and shout out to the world, without any sense of apologia, "I am Hindu, my forefathers were Hindu, a 1000 generations back, and I'll continue to adhere to my mother faith for eons to come"
why is he gentlemen ? this pod is impossible without Pak army's approval.
BS "true picture"
@adityakumar, That’s unfortunate for you. You want to keep worshiping the stone idols made by your own pandits for their own good. Pagans like you are misguided brother, Ram is non existent, he was no where before 12-23 century. No mandir was destroyed to make Babri Masjid. Ram is a fictions character, or if he was there, he was just a normal local king. City of Ayodhya was non existent before 13 century. Get a grip brother. These false gods can not benefit you hereafter.
@@nerf2752 Modi is a terrorist
Hindus are not pagans neither Kafirs. This worldview we reject
Pakistan should open its doors for muslims who want to live in a Muslim country, Palestinians, Yemenis, disgruntled Indian Muslims.
Pakistan is LAND OF HOLY SOULS and Indian Muslims want to become a part of it.
Ek nhi jayga.. likhwa lo
Yes most welcome but everyone must bring a percentage of land with them. If not, there's no need for them to come. They chose to live in India during partition time.
@@saleemkhan12 89.2 percent of Muslims in India voted for Muslim league and creation of Pakistan in 1946… just Google it.
@@saleemkhan12then don't cry when they suffer bhikmange..
RSS has a Muslim wing called Muslim Rashtriya Manch since 2002. The Jamaat on the contrary has no Hindu wing.
Lol they don't have Hindus in Pakistan left and you are talking about Hindus in jamat 😂
@@hritikraghuwanshi2049if they were smart they would atleast have sc or Yadav wing as they say Jai Bheem Jai Mim
But their anti Hindu hate has made them morons
The names say it all...RSS is for the nation and not religion and JI is for religion not nation. It's unfortunate reflections on Indian muslims that to.attract them RSS needs to name separate muslim manch
@metaxerart
Islam, Christianity, Marxism & Fiat Currency like $ driven hedonistic consumerism are foreign gangs/legions created specifically to enslave, rob, deracinate and grab REgal political political power.
So Jamaat by design is anti national and hates everything native. It can't create a nation or Rashtra. Present condition of Pakistan is because of rootless parasitic population.
bhai is se bada reply koi ho hi nhi skta@@hritikraghuwanshi2049
This is the first time I’ve seen a rational analysis of Hindutva by a Pakistani. I would like to add that Pakistan’s hostility towards India since the day of its creation has also played a major role in the rise of Hindutva movement in India.
I am from state of westbengal, here govt give subsidy for haj,free muslims girls education,monthly pension for maulana,why special treatment for others?why not equal treatment..Muslims are the richest community in our state..even our temple development comes under a muslim minister
mamta ko vote dete raho or kuch din baad bangladeshi ban jaao
Jaisa vote vaisa mantri 😊. But most bengalis keep telling us that they are the intellectuals of our society and start listing out all the Nobel prizes they have. Now since we r all not intelligent enough for them they have started this great experiment in their state a f trust me the freebies and violence will keep increasing till it becomes unsustainable 😊
Soon you will wear a burqa 😂
Even your Chief Minister is a Muslim. She will never acknowledge it publicly but that's the reality. She is called Mamta Bano now.
Aur rape bhi karte hai.. congratulations your State achivement..
Indian muslims : we want to be communal(islamic) but India and other communities need to be pro islamic secular..this is totally unfair and you miss this important mindset of muslims of India. And you can't blame hindus for this. Only muslims and their islamic ideologies are responsible for their dire state not just in India but around the globe...
Truly said 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Abhi revenge nahi h. Ager revenge hota to hindu court case nahi karta.
Me chahta hu ki revenge ho.
Choro Bhai revenge ko. Wse v ye log apni maut mrr rhe h😂
Let's focus on our civilizational progress.😎
@@Leonardo_dada_vinchi123 bhai inko kuch history nahi pta
Revange to ham le rahe hai west, middle East me job karke English ke loot ke badle me.......😂😂🤣😂😂
Now let's decode Islamization 😂😂😂🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Iska Srrrr tn se juda.😂😂😂
If he will decode Islam then Pakistani extremist radical will send him to Jannat.
Blasphemy law in pakistan. They can't talk talk against Islam
Sex slave, jihad, loot & rape, namaz, jumma, more sex with wife, sex with sister, sex with goat, gay sex with mulla, pedophilia, sex with hoor, jihad, alla Akbar boom !!
There you go 90% of Islam summarised.😂
One of my friend worked in US for 10 years in CISCO and one day left everything, came back to India to become RSS Pracharak.
Now he is in North East India, working among Tribals.
Life dedicated to nation.
Rashtraya Swaha, Idam na mama.
This is an exception, people leaving India has only increased in last 10 or so years.
So people coming back.
What is he going there?
M coming back from London
😂😅 by muslims we want islamic country, we want freedom of religion, we want every fundamental rights in other islamic land but you have to be a liberal😅 otherwise you are communal.
Westerners are C H R I S T I A N by background but liberal secular in governance like the way our India USED TO BE.............until goondutva showed up on our doorstep in 2014
When Pakistan can be Islamic State then why India cannot be Hindu State?
Pakistanis: we will keep our nation as radical islamic but would crave for india to remain a ‘secular’ republic. 😊😊
Ram Leela ki murti? Yeh kaun si language is. This is again political criticism in the garb of in intellectualism. You still don't understand Hinduism 😅
He meant RamLalla
It was Mrs Indira Gandhi who issued postal stamp in to honour Savarkar..
She also was supported by RSS during her prime minister ship..
Because she wanted Hindu votes.
Only Pakistani seeing who is decoding Hindutva, Muslim and India both ways. Unlike so called Pakistani secular and liberals.
Pakistan m secular or liberal v hota h kya😂
@@rohitgope4006 I said so called 😅
Dr Mujeeb is absolutely wrong to interpret Hindutva. He is interpreting hindutva with islamic state of mind. Bogus understanding.
Very matured podcast... balanced views given by Professor unlike lies and fearmongering by most Pakistani podcast guests about India
Thank you
Pooja which was started in basement by court order was actually going since independence till 1993 when the govt had stopped it.
Exctly and he said - the basement of masjid.
pata nahin hota he fir bhee gyan dete hain.
It’s not a revenge if a victim goes to oppressor to hold him accountable. Hindus reclaiming their identity and holding invaders accountable is called as assertiveness and getting closure from past colonial times. Don’t call it revenge. If it was revenge, situation with be totally different.
I love Rss
The day pakistan was created on eslm, u have given rise of hindu rastra - ExMuslimSahil
Great podcast. As an Indian i can say he is 95% accurate. 🎉
Very mature and nuanced analysis, honestly this is the first Pakistani analyst who hit the nail on the spot, even acclaimed Pakistani journalist were also superficial.
I am impressed with the Professor Sahab’s understanding of Indian politics and his balanced articulation. I don’t think I have seen such balance from any Pak expert
Aaj Kinte hindu bache hai Pakistan me?
Beautiful,rational & well explained talk.All hindu & muslim need to listen to this to improve the relations with eachothers.
I have heard 100s of Pakistani Intellectuals and believe me I have heard each of them in details. I must congrats the professor for such a deep understand of Hindutva Philosophy and Indian politics. This is the first time, I have heard a Pakistani Intellectual to be honest and in-depth anayslis of Hindutva & Indian Politics. You both deserve a big round of applause for being so unbiased and truthful
he is exception
there is nothing in depth here. He didn't even acknowledge existence of temples under the mosques.
Also this professor did not blame Hindus and BJP but did very fair Anyalsis not only that Pakistani Muslims are in fashion to bring bhrhamis to blame, but he equally expose Ashrafasim and Syedisim of Islam too, wish indians had this kind of honest Muslims, but he is in Pakistan where he will be not valued.
SHUT UP BOT! 😑😒
Garv se kaho hum hindu hai❤
Meaningful discussions .Both the guest and host are empathetic and understanding persons❤🙏💐 .
❤❤
Very sensible discussion! I wish more Muslims listen to this podcast.
India, Pakistan and Bangladesh must exchange population on religious basis. Pakistan and Bangladesh must accommodate Indian Muslims, and India will accommodate Pakistani and Bangladeshi Hindus and Sikhs.
In India second largest majority that's Muslims are not discriminated as Ahmediyas and Shias are being discriminated, what to talk of Minorities, like Hindus and Christians in Pakistan.
Logic of a Peaceful :
I will practice Jihad against Kaffir.
But all Kaffirs should keep practicing SECULARISM against us and focus more on giving more rights to Peacefuls.
The moment Hindus doubt the concept of secularism, they become FACISTS & Communal.
The entire world knows about this “logic” of Peacefuls
Problem is eslm- ExMuslim sahil
Even Many indian sociologist doesn't have this fine understanding of Indian society like Professor.
Definitely an good Indian observer
Its just Xerox copy of Situation of Muslim in Pakistan 👍👍A muslim elite class dominant both side 👍👍👍but they always be in victim hood mode in india 👍👍
Pakistan hardly matters as far as Indian elections are concerned...
Albeit, Mody is well placed to win 2024 general elections...the reasons being..
Good performance on economic front especially on inflation which has been consistently low for a long period of time..
Secondly, opposition is divided and don't have charismatic leader like Mody...
Thirdly, INDIA alliance is a non starter...they are divided
Allah could not save his 360 relatives and siblings who were there in Kaba at Macca. We hear his loud wailing and moaning in pain because of MohMadMasti of MohMaddens five times a day. Natives of the subcontinent have decided to save poor Allah and heal his bleeding MohMad. They will give him Ayurvedic treatment which does not have side effects. Would you help natives in this noble endeavor?
Hindus can't be booked. Their scriptures and history is in their DNA Look around - a typical EU city might have 4% MohMaddens in the total population, but 40% of criminals booked and convicted are MohMaddens. The crimes they did are rape, drugs peddling, running prostitution, grooming of underage white girls for sexual slavery (laundi bazi) and MohMadMasti with little boys (bacchabazi as done by brute Babar with 13 year old love boy Babri Niyazi in Urdu/Turki Army rent).
Tree stable hoti hai jab uske roots deep aur strong hote hai. AbraHarami legions/gangs (Christianity, Islam, Marxism & Fiat Currency $ driven hedonistic consumerism) survive and spread by cutting roots of converts. Roots are native spirituality, native culture, native languages & pride in achievements of native ancestors.
Why do you have to tag currency of Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent (ISIS) to super Kaffir State's currency $. ISIS also need to stop calling its currency Roopaya, since next door existential enemy Kaffir has been calling its currency Roopaya for last ten thousand years. Most of ISIS's problems get resolved when it starts calling its currency Dinar.
Desi Anar khatte hote hai par phorren Arabi Dinar meethe hote hai - Hai ki nahi?
Mic quality👎👎👎
Does Pakistanis know Indians don't care what Pakistanis thinks feels or believe about india
THERE WERE 22% HINDUS IN PAKISTAN IN 1947 AND NOW IT IS 1.5%.PLEASE EXPLAIN TO US HOW IT AS HAPPENED.IN INDIA IN 1947 MUSLIMS WERE 9% NOW IT IS 16%.PLEASE EXPLAIN IT TO US.
😆😂😂🤣🤣😂😂😂😆
The guy in the video do not have answer for your question.
Who are you... A Hindu whose ancestors converted. How are you different than me or any Hindu. Look at you... You look like me your DNA is mine.
Just because some Invaders came and brutalized your ancestors now Mohan became Mohammad. Ravi became Rizwan.
Can you deny this ultimate truth?
By you I mean the common Pakistani.
You deny your reality and roots if you say you are an Arab or Persian ancestry. People of the land of the Sindhu river where Hinduism actually began. Infact you are more Hindu than anyone of us.
First ever honest analysis of "Hindutva" from Pakistan. This is a really really really good podcast. Kudos to you sir!💕
Cope harder
We reached to moon but Pakistan still trying to reach Kashmir 🤔
you haven't reached@@ifyouknow-sl6zv
What about Pakistani Hindu
First, they don't recognise who are their ancestors ? Then how will u expect them to care about THEIR OWN MINORITY PEOPLE.
@@AdityaKumar-tuvrsv they think they are arabs and turks 😂😂🤣🤣
Out of syllabus
The analysis is best I have ever heard from any Pakistani Intellectual and nearest to truth. Salute you professor.
Bahaut tareef kar di Dr sahab ne 😂
Though, I can tell Dr Sahab has read a lot about Hinduism, the evolution of Hindu Reform Movements, pre Partition Congress Politics and growth of Hindutva Political Structure and Ideology.
Well said Professor Mujeeb.
Sensible and knowledgeable professor. Good points. Does not do any dog whistling or hateful prejudice. Need more people like this in both india and pakistan to present views.
Indian Muslim never declined , we saw muslim president , muslim union ministers and many celebrities, cricketers and government officers in India.
But, will we ever getto see Hindus on such position in Pakistan. 😂
Hindus kings are rulling on this bharat (subcontinent) since more than 3000 years ago, muslim & cristian came later ...., read some history
Ram is not same as we saw. We came as Refugees from Lahore. Please learn history. Word HINDU + BAROOD CAME WITH BABAR- from AFGANISTAN- DNA AURANGZEB BIRTH 3RD NOV I618 DAHOD GUJARAT LAKSHAHGRAH IN UTTAR PRADESH MAHABHARAT IN 1947- PLEASE GO TO KATASRAJ SHIV TEMPLE IN ZILA CHAKWAL- YOU DO NOT KNOW HISTORY AT ALL- READ ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF KALHAN'S RAJ TARANGNI+ BABARNAMA- PLEASE LEARN ABC 🙉🙊🙈
Plz take your muslim brother... We want peace...
Faisal Gurmani I doubt you deserve brickbats for this show because you and your guest were by and large pretty fair and balanced…..not the usual rhetorical stuff that we come across from Pakistani UA-camrs….infact I would actually commend the professor for dissecting politics and the socioeconomic factors so succinctly
watching pakistani intellectual from last 10 years. you are the most honest person. love from india. ❤
PAKISTAN KA BASE HINDU HATRATED HAI.
Sahi kha bhai 😊
If Pakistan is islamic republic then India is Hindu country.
Whats the problem in this statement.
'Decline of muslims in India's...r u joking??
Badti hui population kya asman se aa rahi hai??
Whoever left post partition in India are nationalists not of religion identity...agar hai to fir Pakistan bana hua aiso ke liye....
Talk on decline of non muslims in Pakistan.
Upor se Bangladesh se India main muslim ata kyu ki India main muslim safe nhi hai 😂
By decline he aimed to indicate political decline not the population.
If there is a decline of Muslims in India then how come Muslim population in India grown from 9% (3.6 crore) in 1951 to 15% (24 crore) 2021? However in West Pakistan Hindu+Sikh population went down from 7% in 1951 to less than 1.5% in 2021??
Ayodhya toh Bas jhaki hy Abhi Mathura kashi Or 40 Hazar Baki hy.।। 🕉🚩
Picture Hum Banayenge Dekhega Pura Islamic World.।। Allah ny in jahilo k Dimag me tala laga Diya He allah tala🔒😆 teri Chabi kho Gyi.।। 🔑🤣
This is for the 3rd time I am hearing Pak professor doing discussion on Hindutva and let me tell you, the whole discussion and arguments provided by Honbl Prof. Are filled with inaccuracies, lack of historical context, Lack of scholarship on Hindutva ideology starting from Savarkar, Tilak, Vivekananda etc. then rise of BJP and it's separation from Congress. You need to do more research, Prof. Had a lot of contradictions. Kindly invite Kushal Mehra from Carvaka Podcast Dr. Rangnathan or Abhijit Iyer Mitra as a serious scholar and let me tell you all of them are well read, Experts in thier fileds and consider themselves as Hindu Atheists who accept Hinduism and hindutva with all Major Flaws while advocating Massive reformation. Do consider my comment and I assure you that you gonna shoot up your viewership specially Abhijit and Dr. Anand.
Rare brilliant academic discussion! Eminently listenable! Thanks!
Please do more podcasts with him... He is the only one who I found sensible among so called Pakistani intellectuals.... All the best bro.... Keep it up....
One advice...
Please don't bring scrap into your podcast.
Bring people like this man
Aare yaar Kahan se utha laye....... standard of education of Pakistan!!!!
First see your pakitan history against minorities
Read research data than open your mouth 😅
Congratulations to both Prof and Anchor for presenting wonderful analysis. Your understanding about the subject matter is far better than many Indians
Next BJP steps are----
Muslims Waqf bord
Uniform civil code
Education of science and math in Madarsa
Muslims mordenity
Removal of Bangladeshi and rohingya
Removal of illegall possession from government land
Greetings from New Delhi...Just two limited points..1) 500 years ago Ayodhya was just land dotted with a few temples. The Babri Masjid could have been constructed anywhere..The very fact that it was constructed on a spot after demolishing an important temple ( authenticated by chief Archeologist KK Muhammad who was a Muslim) shows the intent was to subjugate and humiliate the Hindus. 2) In Saudi Arabia Mosques, Mazars and Cemeteries are all shifted to make way for development. Why cant the Indian Muslims show some generosity to 85% of the population and agree to shifting Kashi and Mathura Mosques to other sites where land and even construction cost can be born by the Govt to make brand new modern mosques. It will be a gesture which will win over Hindu hearts. The fear that this will continue with other mosques is unfounded. These temples are of great significance to the Hindus and beyond this there is no interest.
U R right 💯👍
Abrahamics can never fathom the deep layers of sanatana dharma and hinduism.
Castes are not the part of Hinduism for your information. You can check it in our vedas and puranas.
After listening to the podcast for a few minutes, I am fully into it. I was a teenager when Modi came into power in 2014, and I have personally witnessed the shift in mindset of the Indian middle class. I can see a parallel between this podcast and the societal transformation taking place.
keep doing good work👍👍
Like what shift in mindset?
like we are hindu we are indians first hindu second and thats the end no more divison@@stefano1405
Bahut dino ke baad koi sensible person tha discussion mein. He didn't exaggerate too much nor did he underestimate. Good 👍
Etna sare Pakistani podcast dekhne ke bad ajj ek sehi or right Pakistani intellectual Mila actually me educated
Me wait karta ta Raha the full podcast kahnape galti karenge lekin sir pura perfect the good analysis by professor
Dear host please bring these type of intellectual in your show 👍👍👍
Couldn't agree more.
Fake account hai pakistan agent ka..😂
I am indian hindustani .this prof. Is right truth person.
I agree to some of the observation by the Prof. But from Hindu point of view the 3 most holy places of Mathura , Kashi and Ayodhya temple had to be recovered from muslim occupation which were demolished temples .
Can you have a discussion on Pakistani Hindu on your program.
What has Pakistan achieved making a separate country? Pakistan is not a country. It’s the idea of Modern days Madina.
almost exactly explained the political situation of India. Loved it...
He is saying points from both left and right wing.
Most accurately explained.
1st ever Pakistani professor explaining things so factually and accurately
But Dr Mujeeb Afzal is a genuinely learned person who deserves respect
Ohh bhai the first Pakistani who is talking sense
This professor is a rare man. The accurate insight he has gained on India is amazing. I would love to listen to him again on the subject what he thinks is the way to improve the education status of Muslims in India. Honestly I have tried and occasionally run foul of relegious teachers - volunteering in poor Muslim neighbourhoods is a nervewracking experience
Muslims only love madarsa education
Modi Saab achievement itself will bring BJP back to power
Because they have worked hard and u can see how India is progressing
It is OK for Pakistan to have "devout" Muslim like Imran Khan , holding the beads 24x7 but Pakistanis start having diarrhea seeing Modi in India.
Mullo me makkari kutkut ke bhari padi h.
Actually first Pakistani, I have found who is rational and intellectual. There are certain glaring errors or misconception professor did had such, Temple Puja recently started in basement. No it was just state government stopped for many years, without any permission from a court yo apease muslim.
Also all the archaeological evidence and historical evidence by historian including Auranzen historians write that they have destroyed temples and build mosques on top of it.
So if we want to solve the problem, we need to accept what the problem is professorsaab.
The last thing I would say, you are very clear in your identity and you do not have identity crisis because you accept yourself as a Indian and a proud Muslim. Most of the Pakistani do not have this most of the Pakistani thinks they are either Turkish or Arab or Afghani or Persian hence the problem.
Now going back to one thing which you Really identified was Pakistani looks Indian Muslim has one bunch but that’s not the case just to give you example shia has were not allowed to have their possession in Kashmir by Sunnis until Modi came and allowed that so there you go.
Also, you have many misconceptions about cast system. Cast system is just the work classification at least in original sense, and you were allowed to move freely between cast that one was broken by Brahmin in a old time, but now Brahmins do not have a power and they are not rich also and every one is now just Hindu cast barrier will eventually go away with time.
Whenever I tried to find any Pakistanis having any in depth knowledge of socio politics of India, most of the time, I saw uncles exhibiting racial/Islamic supremacy or suffering from "hamne hazar saal hinduo par hukumat ki hai" fallacy. Furthermore, most of them are unaware about the India beyond the Punjabi or Urdu-speaking aspect. On the other hand, there are a lot of Pakistan watchers in India who have immense knowledge of Pakistani politics, society, to its internal faultlines.
I am glad to see that finally, we encountered academicians like Prof Mujeeb Afzal, who has sufficient knowledge about India's diversity and regional politics.
Hope to see him again in the future.
This anchor has no knowledge and neither he was ready to patiently listen to guest. Anchor is somehow trying to divert guest to take hard line.
Muslim identity is deeply superior and exclusive.
I stumbled onto this video by chance and thoroughly enjoyed it. Your guest has been a joy to listen to. His analysis is by far the most fair and just one I've heard about India, RSS or hindutva. That other prof hoodboy should learn a lot from this gentleman or jump into that black hole where he talks from. Thank you for making this nice video and bringing such a properly educated gentleman.
Narendra modi is leader of india and he pumps a hope in every hindu family that he will reclaim our history of ancient India . We want our cholas pandyas rashtrakuta raghuwansh suryawanshi culture and prosperity back which was deprived by mughal and muslim rulers they demolished our many temples and made masjid and we are reclaiming our temple
What is wrong with ur Audio ??
yes 💯
I am an Indian, and i can confirm, this was a balanced and respectful discussion.
Appreciate Dr sahab and Faisal bhai.
This professor Sahab knows too much about Indian politics.
Much more than many of our experts. 😊
Suffering of the Indian Muslims is due to partition of British India, Britishers locked Muslims into three part...... Worst part East and West Part (Bangladesh), while rest left into the hands of Higher Castes Respected Hindus.... 😢😢😢
Mfs got whole new country still they are the one suffering 😂
Pakistan bna to liya kitni tarkki ki bna ke
Kitna tarakki kar raha ha pak ke muslim bharat se alag reh kar ?? Bhai ab bhi pakistan Jane ka rasta open he bharat bahut bura he hindu bahut bure he nare lagao aur chhod do bharat ko immediately
@@NEWSMANORANJAN true bhai yha kya kar rahe ho agar bharat bura hai or hindu bure hai to
@@mayankindian3750 inhe Inka kuch mat kaho Inka kehna he ke ko bura ho Gaya ise thik karna julm he matlab koi Inka ghar todkar mandir bana le to ye sari zindagi nahi bhulenge lekin Ghar todkar masjid bana li to use waisa he rehne do aur masjid todna inke liye julm he lekin mandir todna julm nahi he,,,pak me sare hindu khatam karna Inka right he lekin bharat me muslim ke population 1947 se ab Tak 9 times jyada ho gaye ye julm he,,,,bharat ke tukde kar ke islamic desh pak banana Inka haq he lekin bharat me hindu rashtra ke baat karna camunal he ye halat he inki
34:19
What is this "Malabar incident Mukherjee report" ????
India is Hindu country ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Dr. Mujib watch, read and observe India and it's current affairs from right sources. He also unapologetically accepted that His origin is Indian and his ancestors were Hindu.
interesting this gentlemen has not spoken about the corruption of cong-i and not modi or bjp
Make Pakistan a secular
If u all believe in it so much
Logic of a Peaceful :
I will practice Jihad against Kaffir.
But all Kaffirs should keep practicing SECULARISM against us and focus more on giving more rights to Peacefuls.
The moment Hindus doubt the concept of secularism, they become FACISTS & Communal.
The entire world knows about this “logic” of Peacefuls
Islam itself is very serious impediment in modernizing muslims. For ex madras is more important than a good English or hindi medium schools, scul cap, 5 times Nawaz is more important than productivity, half pygama with long kurta became more important......
However your speaker is sensible analyzer unlike most other Pakistani speaker.
Muslman ko Hindu secular chahiye khud islamist jihadi rehna hai.
Dr Mujeeb Afzal knows alot about india
70% Indians don’t consider Pak a threat!
Bhai aap achee log hai pulwama attack bhee mention kar do
Kehdoo india nahee kar vayaa pulwama??