Iqbal's Philosophy to Jinnah's Politics|How Partition Changed Everything|FT Hoodbhoy|115|TG Podcast
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 тра 2024
- Iqbal's Philosophy to Jinnah's Politics|How Partition Changed Everything|FT Hoodbhoy|115|TG Podcast
In this enlightening podcast, join us as we sit down with renowned scholar Pervaiz Hoodbhoy to delve into a multitude of thought-provoking topics. From exploring the reasons behind Hoodbhoy's fame to dissecting activism, scrutinizing distorted historical narratives, and examining the repercussions of Partition on the Muslim community, this conversation traverses through pivotal moments in history and sheds light on the complex issues surrounding them. Tune in for insightful discussions on the role of Congress, critiques of Jinnah, the perception of Iqbal, the strategic utilization of Islam, reflections on the 1857 war, educational disparities between Hindus and Muslims, the decline of Muslim influence, and the dynamics of leadership and discourse. Don't miss out on this engaging dialogue that navigates through the intricate tapestry of South Asian history and politics
Pervez Amirali Hoodbhoy is a Pakistani nuclear physicist, author, media commentator, and social activist
0:00 Highlights
1:33 Introduction
2:35 Why is Hoodbhoy famous
4:29 Being an Activist
8:04 The distorted History
13:17 Is Congress to Blame?
17:30 Was Partition bad for Muslims
22:33 The faults of Jinnah
24:30 Iqbal was not a philosopher
31:54 How Jinnah used Islam
34:26 1857 war
38:20 Why did Hindus learn and Muslims didn't
45:05 Decline of Muslims
51:12 Discourses and Leadership
Stay Connected:
x.com/TimesGlo?s=20
/ timesglo1
timesglo?h...
Our Website
timesglo.com
Modi proved that Jinah was right,,, 🧐
Jinnah was right and partition was the best idea
Can't tolerate 60 crore jihadists in unified india we are fine in our country u should be in yours and yup if you are indian and there is the problem in the country u can leave the country for 😃
10:25 Muslim mandir nehi toda ? Kuchhu to saram karo jhutt bol ne se pehele😂😂 🖕🖕🖕
isko iislamb main ttakkiya ( for sshia) kehtey hai and kkitman ( for ssunni) kehtey hai ..
Irfan Habib Like Marxist Islamist Historian Spread This Narrative.
@@AryaArsh arsh is a persian word .
@@urrasscal8380 So?🙄I Like Arabic Names Also. I Love Them.❤️
@@AryaArsh arya can't be aarrab . so remove the aarya word from ur name.
The professor is so fascinated with the golden period of Islam, but he hates Indic philosophers. Different kind of Islamist.
Even that golden period if analysed properly will come out to be fake... it was nothing but small period , even then they copied knowledge from all over world and specially india
He is not even muslim, he is atheist , so stop this propaganda.
Till we don't learn , why and how this strip called Pakistan was created
We will remain lost
Jinnah Poonja Chap, whom the unwashed call Quaid e Azam, was a Hindu from village Panali in Gujrat
His house is still seen in Panali
His grandfather was Premji Lal, father. Poonja Lal
Poonja was a very clever chap, initially English tried to pass him as Ismaili Muslim and said he was born in Wazir Mansion near Ismaili Jamat Khana in Kharadar
But Ismaili Imam, refused to give a fake certificate that he was Ismaili
So in, 1900 it was decided to call him a Sunni Muslim and name was changed to Mohammad Ali
Rest history we know how with help of English and Hindus who were also in game,
Poonja created two nation theory
He got 1.5 million Muslims Slaughtered
Handed India to Hindus
Hindus, never had any say in ruling India
Till 1947, Muslims ruled over most of India. Whole of Punjab, Bengal, Assam, Kashmir, 35 Muslim States, in Central India, Hyderabad with half India wealth, Bijapur etc, were all under Muslim rule
Muslim culture centres like, Delhi, Lucknow, Agra, Kanpur, Hyderabad etc
Were also handed to Hindus,
Muslims were confined to a small strip they call Pakistan
This strip was to be a buffer, between Russia and India,
Unwashed mob called Pakistanis will not comprehend till they read history of Great Game, which started in 1840s
*BRAIN WASHED GODI MEDIA IT CELL POINTED*
Dr sb ethiest
اپ دونوں حضرات کا بہت بہت شکریہ امید ہے کہ اپ حضرات ائندہ بھی ہمیں ایسی باتوں سے نوازتے رہیں گے یہی ساری باتیں ہمارے دل میں بھی موجود تھیں اب ائندہ کیا کرنا ہے جو کچھ ہونا تھا سو ہو گیا !گھر کو اگ لگ گئی گھر کے چراغ سے !ہمیں بے وقوف بنایا گیا !؟!
Dr. Israr gave an accurate reply to secularists scholars about Quaid E Azam and Pakistan establishment reasons.
Partition was best thing ever happened to hindus in past 1000 year
There was no Hindus for 1000 years. So relax. Your Hinduism is a British creation.
Don't worry sweetheart, with Modi's hate speeches against Muslim, stage is all set for another "best thing" for India Hindus!
@@Aaadil8..d next best thing for india..n indeed for d entire wrld..is already happening..n dat is rising hindutva n growing x mslm movement..
..so frget modi n brace for yogi!!..akhand HINDU bharat is in d making!!..
..so congrats!!..soon u will b free of d mzhabi n zeheni ghulami of d invaders..n to follow ur real religion..d religion of ur hindu ancestors!!..👍👍👍👍..
@@YoYo-dy6rt I'd be stupid to argue with people like you but thanks anyway for showing real filthy side of India Hindus! No wonder the real Indians are mourning at the demise of tolerant India envisaged by Gandhi!
*BRAIN WASHED GODI MEDIA IT CELL POINTED*
Going by your conversation, I feel that Pakistani Muslims are the most peaceful and secular society in the world... Pakistani Muslims are very fair towards their minorities including Hindus, Sikhs and Ahemedias..
Pakistanis definitely deserve Nobel Peace Prize...
@@mauroofsultan6887That's called sarcasm
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@utkarshdixit6280 🤣
Nobel peace prize is currently the property of RSS that's why Pakistanis can't get it.
Are you joking
یہ بھی ایک اچھا مذاق ہے کہ فزکس کا پروفیسر تاریخ کے بارے میں اپنی "ماہرانہ" رائے پیش کرے 😂
Jesai qaisar ahmed raja evolution par aur sahil adeem physics par bongian marte hain😂😂😂😂
تاریخ پر بات کرنے کیلئے ڈگری کی نہیں بس مطالعہ پاکستان کے جھوٹ کے علاوہ کچھ پڑھنے کی ضرورت ہوتی ہے۔
@@FRdocumentary925😂😂
Everyone has the right to express hi opinion on almost everything he has any knowledge,but should not make it as his expert advice.
hudson ھر فن مولا
Scientists are expected to examine everything objectively and draw conclusions. This basic trait has deserted Hoodbhoy because he has made so many false conclusions about RSS, Hindutva Modi etc.
Having disagreement with RSS or BJP is one thing but generalization of entire Hindu community is shameful.
He is a jihadi professor, moved away from science
What false conclusions? Hendoo mentality is evident all across UA-cam comments. Dude, who are you fooling? 😂😂😂
@@hawkingdawking4572 k2a mentality?
I can show u from koran and tafseer
@@only-is-pure
So you can show about RSS and Hindutva in Quran and Tafsir? Too much smoke paj.
These are the kind of hosts who sit down to program after watching the history of Pakistan from Google an hour before a program. Neither they know anything about the history of Pakistan nor about the circumstances of that time.
O yes absolutely right…….mun uthaya or Chal pry discuss krny..
قائداعظم پر تنقید کرنے سے پہلے ھود بھائی تم یہ جان لو کہ پاکستان تمہارے لئے نہیں مسلمانوں کیلئے اللہ تعالی نے ایک علہدہ ملک کے طور تخلیق کروایا ۔ اپنی گندی زبان بند ھی رکھو تو اچھا ھے ۔ اپنے سبجکٹ تک ھی رھو ۔
Ye Shakal se Ghaddar or uthigeer lag Raha he or anchor bhi asa he he
Tum bata do apni kitabon wali history..
@@hindioldhitsongs6816 lo aik aur aa gia mun……..
Hoodbhoy is atheist but still his heart bleeds for Muslims who are divided in three countries. As an atheist he should be concerned about all humans equally🤔
He is showing Liberal face with lot of hatred for hindus in his heart. Some of his biases are deep rooted indoctrination.
He can't say he is aethist even if he is. Apostasy is like blasphemy. Logic not allowed to be used when it come to religious beliefs
Jinnah was too not a practicing muslims
Nothing more than a Western coolie.
@@parjanyashukla176
Nope ! It's not his fault. Actually he follow Shashi Tharoor and Nehruvian historians like Irfan Habeeb, Romila , DN Jha , BN panday , Tarachand etc.
Hudboy is like any other ordinary Pakistani,there is little difference in his thoughts with other typical radical Pakistani.Pakistan will never change as Islamic thoght is induced in their mindset since childhood by moulavis and political leaders.
My friend you are genuinely unaware or mistaken as nothing could be further from truth.
Hoodhbhoy is a noted MIT trained physicist and Kalinga Awardee (2003) who is one of few people in Pakistan who have been consistently (since seventies) a pro-Secularism, anti-Mullah, anti fundamentalist, anti Bomb and anti Miliitary Dictatorship activist. He is the inspiration of a large number of Pakistani liberals.The minimum respect you can show him (or for that matter any person) is by spelling his name correctly. He has in recent past founded The Black Hole; a forum for promoting activists of all shades from Science, Arts and Humanities to deliver talks and interact. He is often accused of being an Atheist (or atleast sympathiser thereof).
Maybe you would like to have a look at his recent book "Pakistan: Origins, Identity and Future" (or older one titled "Islam & Science: Religious Orthodoxy and the Battle for Rationality") or else listen to his online interactions. Regards.
*BRAIN WASHED GODI MEDIA IT CELL POINTED*
After watching this video partition was blessed for Hindus and bharat
These people must be cursing Jinnah so much...
Such people still reside in India. They must have been kicked out with Jinnah
@@vinod1147 ghandi was great jinnah was puppet of british
Incomplete partition. People who voted to create Pakistan and Bangladesh, stayed back inside India. Their population has grown to 21%. India will also become Pakistan part 2 soon if youth of Kafirs don't wake up.
no we are forced to live with bhhaiyaas
Wipro founder who is a Muslim was asked why did not have more Muslims in his IT company . He said that did not find qualified and educated Muslims 😊
Really , Azim Premji said that?
IT is hhaarram in iislamb.
@@shatnermohanty6678 yes I heard it my self. on a informational program. . Cannot remember the program. Could be a segment of 60 minutes as I am USA based
@@sakootdacca6706
Firstly , there is no recorded evidence He said that , we only have your word for it .
Secondly , Indian Muslims are relatively lagging behind because those Muslims who are success stories Actors , Sportspersons , Bureaucrats, Judges as well as Industrialists and Tycoons , don't take initiatives to uplift their fellow Muslims .
They could open vocational centres for the Muslim youth .
Retired Bureaucrats could offer free tuition to children of poor Muslim families .
I found this on India TV website:
Hurun India and EdelGive on Thursday released the EdelGive Hurun India Philanthropy List 2021. Indian business tycoon Azim Premji has retained the top spot among philanthropist billionaires of India for a second time. The founder of software major Wipro made donations worth ₹9,713 crore during fiscal 2020-21, which comes up to 27 crore per day.
So this gentlemen is saying ( as an expert 😂) that No Temples were destroyed by the invaders ?
Also the Minority Appeasement policy at the cost of larger interest was okay ?
Be Happy & Stay Where you are dear Professor 😂😂
No muslim is ready to accept this reality. Because their initial study has been in Madarsa and By Maulvi
Absolute bigot. And we thought education opens minds. In fact education make people like him more lethal. Extreme cocktail...
In 1875 India had Muslims all over the country but there were only 17 Muslims who had a BA degree and only 3 Muslims had MA degree. If there was no Pakistan then chances were high that this guy Hoodbhoy would never be a Physicist??
عجب منطق ۔۔۔ ڈگریاں انگریز لایا جو مسلمان کو قابل قبول نہیں تھا ۔۔ یہ راز سر سید احمد خان کو معلوم ہوا اور علی گڑھ کالج کی بنیاد ڈالی اس میں قصور ہندوستان اور ہندو کا نہیں
ہم استعمال ہونے کے لیے بنے ۔۔ایک وزیر احسن اقبال نے کہا کہ اگر فی کس آمدنی مسلم کی بھارت میں زیادہ ہوئی تو پھر یہاں کیا جواب دیں گے
Are there not well educated Muslims in India
مسلمانوں کو پڑھنے شوق نہیں
مسلمانوں کو عورتوں کا شوق ہیں.
Abdul kalam became a physicist while being indian citizen and gave them atomic bomb.......and they honoured him also
Pakistan is on a verge of economic default and these fellows still talking about partition, Jinnah, Congress 😂😂😂
Modi's doing hate speeches as a PM of India? Go sweet before you own door!
Root cause to jinnah hee hai 😂
پروفیسر ہود بھائی بالکل ٹھیک کہتے ہیں کہ تقسیم ہند دراصل تقسیم مسلمانان تھی۔ مسلمانوں کو تین حصوں میں بلکہ کشمیر کے ساتھ چار حصوں میں بانٹنے کی انگریزی سازش جناح کے ہاتھوں
انجام دلوائی گئی
Now people knows what is written in quran and Hadith , so reaction will come and coming from around the world - ExMuslimSahil
If you are not a Muslim then why you have to write Ex Muslim
Truth has its own power so many western people who hated Muslims still end up embracing Islam after studying Islam! So keep doing propaganda but in the end the truth will always prevail...
@@AbdulKhaliq-wt8ig my gf is exmuslima
@@TheSinner749if she was ur gf then she was nvr a Muslim
@@rahehidayat2755 u mean angoor khatte hain?🤔
Pervez never disappoints. It is hard to be a physicist and this dumb all at the same time. 0 research. Time for retirement if you don't keep up with studying.
He doesn't read correct history. He knows nothing about Vedas, Purans, Ramayana, Mahabharat. He has not seen Sanatan temples and their carbon dating. He should actually be ashamed of himself talking nonsense about greatness of barbaric Muslim invaders. He should check with Archeological department about HARAM Mosques built by barbarians on top of temples they destroyed. Shame.
I agree he might not have good knowledge about pre Muslim India as his research is based on left writers........... But what he says is true......... Those andhbhkts from cow belt jahil Hindi States with their communal mentality of one nation theory can't digest criticism.....because they live in dream of ancient sone ki chidiya and muslim invaders...(Not greeks no other , mostly muslim...because UP politics wants that)and lack of knowledge about rest other dynasties that ruled india.
Harsh....huns....guptas...mauryans....satavahan......cholan .etc.
This is a problem when one views the world with Abhramic lens.
@@everydevoteehasastory. No the lense is very pitted when it is Pakistani and Muslim
he is long retired. satiya gaya hai yeh.
अजीम मुसलमान को कांग्रेस बहुत अच्छी लग रही है 2014 से पहले कांग्रेस का ही राज था और इसी पाकिस्तान में हिंदुस्तान के ऊपर कांग्रेस के राज में ही चार बार युद्ध की शुरुआत की
میں یہ کہتا ہوں کہ جو جنا کے مخالف لیڈر تھے کانگرس کی یہ ان کی کتابیں کیوں نہیں پڑھتے جو جنا کو بھگوان مانتے ہیں
Kya nonsense baat kr raha hai ye bnda hindus or indian history ke baare main... bilkul clueless hai ye or ye scientist kehlate hai pakistan main iss trh ke log to or bhi jyada dangerous hai kisi hardcore islamist se...pakiyo tumhara kuch nahi ho skta
What Hindu history? You didn't know about your British made religion until Gora gave you books and schools.
Munnay ja kar Modi Terrorist ko vote kar jo Anti Muslim sentiments pay thrive karta hai!
he is talking about the facts... but i know u r pak study educated.. don't even know.. just wake up eat and sleep😂
@@amazingfacts79617 Well, I am not biased so I can't take criticism of my own people & system but same will not be true with you prejudiced Indians! Will you Mr Well Informed, condemn the fascism of Modi where he's making hate speeches against Indian Muslims? Do you have the EDUCATION or Moral Courage to oppose Modi? Let us see! So???
ھندو تو ویسے ھی شروع سے بےایمان لوگ ھیں اور بزدل بھی ساری دنیا جانتی ھے ان کو تو اپنے دھرم کے بارے کچھ
پتہ نہیں گندے لوگ ھیں
Even a person like Hoodbhoy also started talking like this ? 🤦♂
They paint a picture as if all muslims are just running away from India to live in some other countries to save their lives.
*BRAIN WASHED GODI MEDIA IT CELL POINTED*
Thank God Partitioned happend. We got a buffer between Taliban.
Thanks to Jinnah. He seperated most of green snakes from India 😂
Modi will create more Talibans than even Taliban in Afghanistan as he is making hate speeches against Muslims of India!
..👍👍👍..a buffer n also a duffer!!.. 😂😂..
*BRAIN WASHED GODI MEDIA IT CELL POINTED*
سنو اس اویسی ٹائپ گدھے جناح کی مسلم لیگ بنانے کی تباہی۔ زرا غور سے میری بات سنو۔ تقسیم ہند سے پہلے ہندوستانی مسلمان بے انتہا دولت مند اور پاور فل تھے ہندوستان میں ۵۰۰ پانچ سو ریاستیں تھیں اور سب کی سب مسلم ریاستں تھیں۔ نا عاقبت اندیش جناح صاحب نے کانگریس چھوڑ کر اویسی کی طرح۔ مسلم لیگ بنائی اور بر بادی کی داستان شروع ہو گئی۔ بعد میں جناح نے کہا بھی تھا کہ مجھے ایسا کٹا پھٹا پاکستان نہیں چاہئے۔ مگر اس وقت تک بہت دیر ہو چکی تھی مسلم لیک اے ائی ایم اویسی کی طرح بھڑک کر بر باد ہوئی۔ حالانکہ آزادی سے پہلے فارسی زبان سرکاری زبان تھی اردو بھی سرکاری زبان تھی۔ ہندی انگریزی کا کہیں پتہ نا تھا۔ مسلمز کے پاس دولت کی فراوانی تھی ہندوستان زراعتی ملک تھا۔ امریکہ نے برٹش راج کو برباد کرنے ہندوستان میں آزادی کی تحریک چلائی۔ جناح مہرہ بن گیا جیسے غدار نواز شریف ہے ایسے۔ ممبئ سارا جناح صاحب کا تھا۔ امریکہ اور برٹش راج نے اچھے پیارے ہندوز کو کہا کہ مسلمز بھی باہر کے تھے اور ہندو کو شوشہ چھوڑ کر بھڑکا دیا۔ جب جناح صاحب جب دیکھے کہ تقسیم میں کچھ ہاتھ نہیں لگیگا تو تقسیم کے لئے نہیں مانے مگر دیر ہو چکی تھی۔ اب تو ماونٹ بیٹن نے ولبھ بھائی پٹیل کو کہا اور بھڑ کا دیا کہ اگر تم تقسیم نہیں کرو گے تو چھ مہینے میں ہی دلی پر واپس مغل کا راج ہوگا پچاسی فیصد دلی کی آبادی مسلم تھی۔ بہرحال برٹش راج کے ماتحت ہندوستان پر مسلمز ہی حکومت کر رہے تھے۔ امریکہ کو یہ بات پسند نہیں تھی کہ ہندوستان ایک رہے۔ وہ خود قبضہ چاہتا تھا قبضہ نہیں ملا تو پاکستان بنا کر اس پہ قبضہ رکھا۔ پاکستان ابھی بھی غلام ہے۔ تقسیم ہوگئی جناح نے مسلمز کو برباد کر دیا مسلمز کے چار حصہ ہوئے۔ ایک امیر نوابوں کا حصہ مار کر لوٹ لیا گیا ایک پاکستان بنا ایک بنگلہ دیش بنا ایک بھارتی مسلم بنے۔ سب تتر بتر ہوگئے الدیکھو بھارتی مسلم پچیس کروڑ۔ پاکستانی بیس بنگلہ دیشی پندراا تو ساٹھ کروڑ مسلم ساتھ ہوتے تو بتاو کتنا اچھا ہوتا۔ ؟؟ ازل سے ہم مغرب کی سازش کا شکار ہوئے ہیں اگر تقسیم نا ہوتی تو آج ہندوستان ساری دنیا پر بھاری رہتا۔ ہندو مسلم میں بہت پیار تھا۔ ایک دوسرے کے لئے جان دیتے تھے۔ 1947 ہندوستانی پارلیمنٹ میں پچاس فیصد مسلمز نواب تھے۔ اویسی بد معاش کی طرح کوئی بھی بل پاس نہیں ہونے دے رہے تھے۔ آٹھ مہینے بھی حکومت چلنے نہیں دئے تنگ آکر ہندو راضی ہوا کہ تھوڑا سا تکڑا پاکستان دے دیو اور باقی سب پر قبضہ کر لو۔ اویسی کی طرح گدھا لیڈر تھا جناح جس نے خود کی قوم کے چار تکڑے کئے۔ یہ تو ہندو بھی کہتے ہیں۔
اویسی کا منھ بند کرو اور کانگریس کو مضبوط کر کے اپنی مانگ کرو۔
Hypocrisy of Hudhbhoy.
He ridicule great hindu sages wisdom in fields of spirituality, science, philosophy, mathematics, astrology, Astronomy, aryurveda, meditations but in same breath he promote few scattered muslim scientists and philosophers. Wht a bigotry?
yes sir. he is biased.
however educated a momin is always a momin and he will always hate hindus. pig with lipstick is still a pig!
He is more dangerous than a radicalised moulvi of Pakistan. Such educated people for own livelihood/survival in society have ruined pakistan by way of radicalising common people.
All Muslims are.
Pakistani Mullah 😂
Pakistani brothers & sisters, Aap mano ya na mano. Pakistan ki es halat ka jimmedar aapke diplomates, senior officers, bureacrats, professors, political leaders and Padhe-Likhe old people hai. Ye aaj bhi pak army ke agenda ko support karte hai.
Pak army ka agenda hai ki apne country ki awam ko majhabi churan dete rahna hai, school syllabus, media and moulvio ko sath leker (hindu, yahudi, America, kafir hate).
Pak army ka yahi tarika hai country mai apne hisab se rule kerne ka jisme wo fake news, videos and dahshatgard tanjim ko promote kerte hai and political interference kerte hai. Sarkar se fund lete hai and Logo mai dar ka mahol paida kerte hai.
Prof Hudbhoy, like any other Pakistani has the same view of Hindu and India... Pakistanis are in denial of destruction of hundreds of Hindu temples...I ask Prof Hudbhoy to visit Mathura and Varanasi and then make such nonsensical comments..
Hidhbhoy is desperately making wrong statement against hindus to impress radical pakistan audience
Pakistani ex-Muslims also have massive hatred towards Hindus.
No He will not change his views He is a Jihadi
Pakistan was Invented by two Ismailis (Minority) Jinnah and Aga Khan III.
One thing which is often overlooked about the partition : Muhammad Ali Jinnah alone was not responsible for the partition of India. The British wanted India divided into parts. Leaving India as a single unit made the British uncomfortable. They were afraid it will emerge as powerful country of the region. They wanted to weaken India while quitting it. This required dividing it in to parts. Present day India , Pakistan and Bangladesh. Had the British wanted to leave India intact , Muhammad Ali Jinnah could have done nothing about it. Because British were the real decision makers.
yupe all Muslim league were feudals trader and so on they want that after creating knew muslim country we will govt and our future son's and grand sons will enjoy the rule... thats what happening in todays Pakistan really make sense of that... on the other hand british also want the same what muslim league want... they fully supported muslim leuge and jinnah...
No matter what analysis is given , the fact remains that a new state for the converts would always have identity problem
How many Muslim have come to Pakistan since partition. You are such disappointment.
If India had no wealth and riches then why did your muslim ancestors come to India...to do donations?same applies to the british. You remaining in denial of the rich hindu heritage is not going to cause any dent to it. We keep pursuing and seeking knowledge.
They are not logical people, don't waste time with them on this.
Britishers were paid to come to India by traders of India to fight against Islamic Rulers and establish secularism.
Why not to come. India was a barbaric backward region with no country or any kind of unity. Anyone could have just walked in.
Hindustan was ayyash only the British developed it and India is still living with mythical stories 100’s of years ago.
What rich Hindu heritage? Your HINDUISM was made by the British.
It’s ironic that people those who look the same
Eat the same
Dance on same music
Dress up the same
Listen to same music
Celebrates the same
Lived on same land for thousands and thousands of years
Are been forced to separate due to some foreign invaders ideology forced on local people 😕
British played a master stroke by dividing India depriving Muslims from being part of a future superpower.
I think he should just do a little research before opening his gutter mouth, it is recorded history that Sushruta who lived in 1000-800 BC invented plastic surgery
That is their biggest problem! They can neither accept their inferiority nor can they appreciate the good in native Indians
😂😂😂
@@saiyidshahabrizvi5464
No point laughing, it's actually true.
He will never do that as his reference point starts from Islamic invasions, everything else before that was farce...Bigot in cloths of Scients
@@saiyidshahabrizvi5464 Bhai sach mein tum logo ka kuch nahi ho sakta
You Pakistanis don't be apologetic to jinha. Pakistan should make law like CAA for indan muslims and Bangladeshi muslims. Instead of abusing jinha.
Sirs,the great fallacy of muslims in the Indian subcontinent has been that they had ruled india for 1000 years before British finished off the mughal dynasty.
Muslims did not rule india.
It was the Islamic invaders dynasties who ruled parts of india with continuous battles among them.Sindhis never ruled Sindh or any other part of india. Neither did Punjabi muslims or bengali muslims.
Delhi Sultanate had 6 or 7 dynasties all of whom came from persia/afghanistan/central Asia. Mughals were turko-mongol muslim warlords.
Conversion of hindus was a great phenomenon during this long period.And muslims of indian subcontinent have been extremely shy to recognize this major phenomenon.
Contd: Mr Jinnah's father was a hindu,"jinna thakkar" and Mr jinnah was a 2nd generation convert.
😂😂 u r badly exposing pak lies. Confidenceless forced converts can't be good leaders in anyway.
He has not read any books written by invaders.
@@AshokGupta-oq6hs that's prove that iislamb is danger to iindia ..
@@AshokGupta-oq6hs
His father left the British made HINDUISM as they ostracised his family for selling leather. No sane person would stay in such a stupid slave made up religion with a fake history.
Yes.. There was no bakhtiyaar khilji.. No nalanda University.. No library burnt... Hatred for hindus is real..
Both of them are twisting history. Moulana abdul kalam azad was a clear supporter of congress, ghandhi and to a large extent oppossed to jinnah's thinking. Since the guest extols the education system established by nehru, let me tell you azad was the first education minister of independent india. Clearly the man knew where to invest his energy! I doubt if azad would have pleaded to jinnah on their plight for many like azad felt sevured being in india. On the other hand frontier gandhi pleaded with the congress and is quoted saying "you have thrown us to the wolves"and the great man was thrown to jail for most part of his life to jail by the pakistani state
Yes you are right
The one person who got the worst deal out of partition was Khan Abdul Ghaffar who was abandoned by Congress and Persecuted by both British and Jinnah.
@@deepsareen1 exactly
Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan was awarded the Bharat Ratna
Don't know if pakistan remembers Him
Doctor is doctoring the history. JAALI nuclear daktor.
*BRAIN WASHED GODI MEDIA IT CELL POINTED*
Prof is a fan if Sir Syed and Aligarh Muslim Univ, from where the separatists took root.
The day , pak created in the name of eslm, u have already given rise to hindu rastra and that is justified - ExMuslimSahil
Muslims kabhi koi scientists nahi bane. Non Muslims jo convert hone ko majboor huye unhone science research continue kiya kyunki unka profession hi science tha. Inki Makkari ki koi inteha nahi.
Jokers wasted Jazia money collected from Hindus on making grand mausoleums for dead tyrants.
Is your father one of them
Care to elaborate on the “majbooris”?
A British made country, religion and language???!!!!
1. Hindi was made as a new language by the missionaries in the oriental college of Calcutta by combining various northern dilects and heavy infusion of Sanskrit.
2. Hinduism was made up around 1812 as a 'religion'. The followers were a minority until the 1871 census and after that casteless, AthiShudras, Chandalas etc were declared overnight as Hindus without the converts themselves knowing that they were Hindus by then. Thus Hindus becomes majority.
3. Santhana Dharma was cooked up in the early 1900s by the foreigner Annie Besant by copying the word from the Budhist scripture 'Dhammapada'.
4. New country called 'Bharat' is invented for the newly evolving British empire of the Indies or the Indian region.
So basically actual Hindus were a minority and majority of the current so-called Hindus are paper-converted for getting electoral majority.
no wonder why pak education system is like this ...everytime i listen to him ..i laugh 😂 😂
He is too much biased against Hinduism. Very opinionated and very ignorant.
Hey andhbhakt from whatsapp University
Kindly give your counter argument , i challenge you.
Nikhil Deshmukh pune Deccan college
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 he says surgery didnot take place in iindia which is wrong plastic surgery was indeed practice in iindia by susruth... except that viman thing (no physical evidence present how ever concept was present of flying object ) every thing else the so called rright wings says is true.
@nikhildeshmukh6221
Hoodbhoy is a media person who works for the Deep State who accumulated $555Trillion by colonization using Christianity and using Islam as Weapon of Mass Destruction. He is not much different from James Roy, Burkha Dutt and Ravish Kumar of NDTV.
What's nationalism? Is it nurturing of nativity, celebrating achievements of native ancestors, Nurturing of native culture, languages and caring for everything native which includes native rivers, lakes, mountains and flora-fauna by treating them divine? Vande Mataram, Vanderbilt Bharat!
Can a religion which is nothing but a gang/legion created to enslave, rob, rape natives by grabbing REgal political power create a nation especially a civilizational nation?
First such gang, Christianity destroyed almost all natives of Africa, Americas, Australia and a copy of it the second such gang Islam destroyed natives of West Asia, North Africa and half of South East Asia.
Physics journalist Hoodbhoy wants to demoralize natives of Bharat so that Dharmic natives become rootless like him and accept Islamic misrule like Mughlai. Anglos created first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent) by breeding and using Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah. Chiknah Jinah used his Anglo life style as a Weapon to destroy greater India, Hoodbhoy is using his Physics Journalism to destroy rising Bharat.
Lagta hai bhai ki fatt gayi challenge deke @@urrasscal8380
سائنس دان کو سائنس دان ہی رہنا چاہیے
سائنس دان کوئی تاریخ دان نہیں ہوتا
Absolutely right. He shouldn't be allowed out of his lab.
کیا آپ خود کو تاریخ دان سمجھتے ہیں ؟
یہ کس کتاب میں پڑھ لیا اپنے؟ یہ اتھارٹی کس نے آپکو دی کہ آپ اس قسم کا فتویٰ دیں؟
NOT JINNAH ITS ISLAM WHICH BETRAYED MUSLIMS.
I do not understand why the Pakistanis go back to the partition of British India again and again. There a constant search into the past, why? Perhaps, the present is a great disappointment. On the other hand, Bharat is looking forward confidently. It has left the partition behind and not burdened by it. Comments please!
A man of science should be objective and should evaluate the evidence before him. Should not be selective with truth or just be untruthfull.
*"Islam is devisive*
*Islam devides humans in two groups viz. Muslims and non-Muslims*
*Islam is not universal brotherhood of Man.*
*Islam is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only with hatred against non-Muslims"*
*Dr.B.R.Ambedkar*
*(Read Book-'Pakistan Or The Partition Of India‘, first published in 1940)*
The same Ambedkar used to servie Bromen masters by justifying brutal 19th century British made Hinduism and its nonexistent reforms. He eventually adopted Budhism.
@@hawkingdawking4572 *But not like Mohd(PUBG) Ali Jinha 's family got converted to Islam from Hinduism to avoid paying Jaziya to Terrorist Mughal Empire*
*Talwaar ne tum sab ku salwaar utaar lee*
😁😂🤔
@@sunala1265
Jinnah's village story - m.ua-cam.com/video/PaDdNF0u7XQ/v-deo.html
@@sunala1265
Jinnah's family was converted to the newly made HINDUISM In their tribal name. But they had to leave that brutal and barbaric pseudo-religion due to the oppression of the Jhenna community. They boycotted his family and rest because of their trade in leather goods. Only a fool would remain as a Shudra to act as a slave for Bromen with no reward. (May be born as Bromen as next life as a luck) .
@@hawkingdawking4572 *Now Don't say that PISSLAM is a religion of Peace but it's Piece*
*Don't shoot and Run*
Tell me the genuine reason for below persanalities Who Converted To Islam by force/wrong teachings.
1 AR Rahman:
2. Kusum Sheriff
3.Kamala Surayya
4.Yuvan Shankar Raja:
5.Sharmila Tagore
6.Amrith Singh :
7.Monica Rehman
8. Mohammad Ali
9.Shaquille O’Neal
10.Cat Stevens
11.Mike Tyson
12.Malcolm X
And so on .....
Quran is full of hate verses asking muslims explicitly to kill,murder,harm the non believers(2:191 2:193 3:118 4:75-76 4:84 4:104 5:33 5:51 5:57 5:80-81 8:12 8:13 8:14 8:50 8:065 9:23 9:38-39 9:42.).
I think i have made my point,
جسونت سنگھ سابقہ اڈیفنس منسٹر آف بھارتیہ جنتا پارٹی اپنی کتاب اور اپنے ایک انٹر ویو میں کہہ چکے ہیں کہ انڈیا کے بٹوارے کا قصوروار جواہر لال نہرو تھا جبکہ جناح متحدہ ہندوستان کا حامی تھا لیکن نہرو کی دوغلی روش نے جناح کو دیوار سے لگایا اور پھر جناح کے پاس بٹوارے کے سوا کوئی چارہ نہی چھوڑا ۔ جسونت سنگھ نے جناح کو کامیاب لیڈر اور نہرو اور گاندھی کو ناکام لیڈر بھی کہا
My Indian friends want him to say, what they like to hear, 😊 But he is not a politician. Let him speak his mind,, ,He is a very independent and Talented person.
Absolutely on the dot!
He gets to say things without being countered. Thats the point. He won't stand a chance in 1 on 1 debate. That's why Indians mock him. For all his physics proff and Mit accolades he is very mediocre in intellectual and factual arguments.
independent and talented person lol. say that again please.
..pdhaaii likhaaii kisi momin ka kuch bigaad nhi paati..
..saari pdhaaii likhaaii ek taraf..mominaaii ek taraf.. 😂😂😂😂..
Yes .. we want him to keep talking . So that we will realize , what Pakistani mindset is .. and why we cannot be friends .
پرویز حود بھائی صاحب اپ کو اس نکمے ہوسٹ کے ساتھ پروگرام بالکل نہیں کرنا چاہیے تھا
واقعی یہ ھوسٹ شکل سے ھی مخنچو لگ رھا ھے اور اسکے سوالات بھی چغدوں والے ھیں۔
Whether he had deceived Muslims of Sub-Continent or not but his decision and struggles for partition was absolutely wrong!
Dr. Iqbal’s lineage did not originally follow Islam. His work, “Shikwa,” could be interpreted as the passionate outcry of a convert who appears to be more devout in his adopted faith than those born into it.
Huge respect for Dr.Hudboy.. but the problem is that we have all studied neo liberal & colonial history.. I agree with a lot of his view points, but temples were destroyed can never be denied.. especially by someone as learned as him
What's nationalism? Is it nurturing of nativity, celebrating achievements of native ancestors, Nurturing of native culture, languages and caring for everything native which includes native rivers, lakes, mountains and flora-fauna by treating them divine? Vande Mataram, Vanderbilt Bharat!
Can a religion which is nothing but a gang/legion created to enslave, rob, rape natives by grabbing REgal political power create a nation especially a civilizational nation?
First such gang, Christianity destroyed almost all natives of Africa, Americas, Australia and a copy of it the second such gang Islam destroyed natives of West Asia, North Africa and half of South East Asia.
Physics journalist Hoodbhoy wants to demoralize natives of Bharat so that Dharmic natives become rootless like him and accept Islamic misrule like Mughlai. Anglos created first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent) by breeding and using Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah. Chiknah Jinah used his Anglo life style as a Weapon to destroy greater India, Hoodbhoy is using his Physics Journalism to destroy rising Bharat.
I think he does that to save his life .
He constantly criticizes Allama Iqbal , Jinnah as well as pakistani hypocrisy .
So if he didn't criticize India as well , he could get into trouble .
Your own religion, country, history, scriptures, culture were all shaped by the very same colonials. Your 19th century concept of a 'Bharat' is a British orientalist concept.
@@hawkingdawking4572 what about pakistanis ?
Are you Arab , Mongol , Turk , Persian or converted?
@@shatnermohanty6678
They are Indians UNLIKE you who has no identity unless given by the British. You are converted to a fake identity.
2.Savarkar nd golwalkar are neo favourite characters of Hudhbhoy but unfortunately he hasn't studied them properly and going by Congress perception of them.
Ofcourse he can't be very accurate about savarkar,when even in india people are not .... But andhbhkts are perfect example of what ideology of savarkar and jinnah does.... religious nationalism sucks
jinnah and savarkar are complex conjugate. same number with different taste
@@trishulart-nr3ev read the book by Vikram, he literally put every detail including primary sources. You not knowing something does not mean nobody does. Read then speak. That's my service to hoodbhoy as well. Don't claim to be a scholar when you don't read about the things you speak about.
@@srijandatta287 lol, I've read ssampats book and it's worst of many.......I'm marathi from kokan... we have more honest writers to read about savarkar's life..... We are not recently savarkarvadi like Many indians........
I think you don't know the difference between Islamic nationalism and Hindu nationalism and how it changes your perspective........
Parvez hoodboy hates Islamic nationalism but sees history through that lens only due to Pakistan and his dependency on Indian leftists...............
Same way you Savarkar vadi people are looking at history from one particular lens only..... Where already biased writers like Vikram samvat Sai Deepak are writing history for you guys...... There is difference between ...historian....researcher and biographer and novel writer............ You guys are doing exactly what Congress did using left Marxist lobby.....to create propoganda.
Savarkar'opinion on true Hindus, sikh , Buddhist, Jain , Hindus are Hindus
Muslims and Christians are outsiders
Go and spend a day in todays India. You will realize how correct was the action of Qaid
Musalmaano k beech m hinduon k haalat bhi to bata
Chhodiye na inke hath me na inko Islam ijjat deta h Islam ko dusman chahiye land of low to h nhi katalo garat or sex this is Islam
Indian brothers only want to hear praises, hence "Partitino is the best thing that has ever happend"
Prof. Hoodbhai, Indian civilization is about 10,000 years old. Some scientific claims of ancient may not be true but largely they are true. ISI in collaboration with its local agents were bleeding India during corrupt Congress rule. Now hindus chosed Modi led BJP beacuse Modi is doing fadt economic development of India including giving welfare schemes mostly benefiting muslims. Corruption and riots are down. But a section of BJP and hindus are now assertive and reacting to Islamic fundamentalism and not keen in relation with Pakistan due to its cross border terrorism and radicalisation of muslims especially in Kashmir. Over all conditions of muslims are better than hindus of Pakistan.
Dear Modi Bhakt reality is not all Blackand white. Who dismembereed Pakistan? Who exchanged a bunch of deadly Terrorists in wake of a plane Hijack ? You are right though that it is Islamic Radicalisation that fed into other kinds of Radicalisation and Rightists extremism all over the globe.
BTW If you really want to know true status of Minorities in India go read Sachhar Committee report by Ex chief Justice Rajinder Sachhar of Delhi high-court who was a pro civil-liberties anti-establishment (anti-Emergency) judge who helped prosecute Partap Singh Kairon the congress CM of Punjab as well as ordered FIRs against congress leaders in Sikh-Riots of 1984. Regards.
Your first statement shows how brain dead an average Paajeeeet Hendoo is. 😂😂😂😂
Indonesia mein bhot mosque hai pr sub se jayda tourist area bali Island hai Yhan 80% hindu population aur hindu temple hai
Cambodia mein angkor wat temple duniya ka sub se big religious structure aaj bi hindu temple ke naam se jana jata hai jo Cambodia ke flag mein bi hai jish se Cambodia aaj duniya mein tourism ke liye jana jata hai
India Pakistan Bangladesh Yhan hindu religion start huwa waha ke hindu jahil al biruni ne likha tha
Pakistan Bangladesh mein Hindu temple ke khandhar mein toh muslim ne mitti dal di pr martand temple somnath temple Kashinath mein nahi dali hai
Qutub minar mein aaj bi hindu temple ke symbol saaf dikhte hai jisko duniya dekhne aati hai
Islamic terrorism aaj bi global problem hai duniya mein
Hoodboy shahab you can say that Jinnah puts Pakistan under West as colony again after 1947 making efforts to dismember India spreading communalism among Muslims reaction to Hindus .but couldn't happen in India.
As it is in Quran and hadees, always divide Muslims and unity of Islam, so Quaid e Azam did act according to Islam and divided Muslims in three different parts as India, Pakistan, Bangal
So rewriting history. Depth of ignorance , he thinks Chinggis Khan destroyed Baghdad. With virtually nill original contributions to his own subject of physics spanning 50 years he is now teaching Pakistanis about their own history
Hoodboy jitna bolta hai utna iska mukhota hat raha hai. Yeh bhi ek Islami hai.
He has strong hatred for hindus deep inside his heart. He try to wear mask of intellectual to express his hindu hatred
Or kya krega Islam khud ki criticism nhi jhel skta murtad ki sja kya h to hoodboy konse alian h
अरे राजा राममोहन राय को छोड़ो वह तो थे ही समाज सुधारक लेकिन हिंदू तो हमेशा तुम्हारे हिसाब से 1000 साल मुसलमान को गुलाम रहा उसने उर्दू अरबी फारसी सखी तो उसने अंग्रेजी भी सीख ली
Behooda bhai is a physics teacher but not a singal achievement in physics . . he is self proclaimed historian. . irony
Mr Jinnah did not ask the Muslims, who now live in Indi a , not to come to Pakistan. Urdu was a language, that was supposed to link people, he did not prohibit to stop using regional languages. Iqbal was a poet, and his poetry was not meaningful, it involved philosophy, that was based in indepth thinking.. The analysis here, is out of context. University of Tehran, is poo performing excellently on Iqbaliat
No comments from any Pakistani or Muslim why I wonder ?
Be he doing job for Endian Hindus Antankwadi, Pakistani know him, So keep happy 😊 he Some kind like Tariq fatah
Because they don't care about your fake history and attention seeking for validation in Pakistani channels to cover for the deep inferiority complex if being a foreign made 'Hindu'.
They are told in Friday prayers not to engage and they are not free like us they get bossed around from birth by mullah and molvis
Dr Hoodbhoy ji is a great pleasure to listen to.We bow down to him.He has a huge following in the Subcontinent.
I am from India.
He is blatantly lying and modifying history to support his leftist narrative. He is too much biased here.
What's nationalism? Is it nurturing of nativity, celebrating achievements of native ancestors, Nurturing of native culture, languages and caring for everything native which includes native rivers, lakes, mountains and flora-fauna by treating them divine? Vande Mataram, Vanderbilt Bharat!
Can a religion which is nothing but a gang/legion created to enslave, rob, rape natives by grabbing REgal political power create a nation especially a civilizational nation?
First such gang, Christianity destroyed almost all natives of Africa, Americas, Australia and a copy of it the second such gang Islam destroyed natives of West Asia, North Africa and half of South East Asia.
Physics journalist Hoodbhoy wants to demoralize natives of Bharat so that Dharmic natives become rootless like him and accept Islamic misrule like Mughlai. Anglos created first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent) by breeding and using Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah. Chiknah Jinah used his Anglo life style as a Weapon to destroy greater India, Hoodbhoy is using his Physics Journalism to destroy rising Bharat.
"Muslims never did to Hindus of Indian subcontinent what Chenghiz Khan did to Muslims in Baghdad". These likes of so called moderate Muslims Hoodhbhoy and Ishtiaq Ahmed whom secular Hindus make friendship with, are real enemy of Hindus.
Professor needs to learn a little history. Complete waste of time.
ملک کی تقسیم➗ کا سب زیادہ نقصان مسلمانوں کو ہوا اور اس زیادہ نقصان اردو تہذیب کا ہوا ہے۔
Perveez hoodbhiy breaks the boat which is sailing her on the sea. Always complaining about Pakistan. Very biased against Pakistan.
Islam is not against Nation States but against Islamic States because Islam is not a religion but a way of life 👍
Lies of hudhbhoy..
1. Who destroyed Takshshila University?
Who destroyed Nalanda University?
How many educational institutions mughals made?
What was taught in nalanda and takshashila when whole Europe was fighting and killing each other like animals. Indian civilisation is older then 4000 yrs and was center of international trades before.
You are typical andhbhkt with muslim invaders as villain.....i also think same... but at the same time I am aware of all pre invader kings are their contribution to society....from huns kushans mauryas to samudra gupt, harsh...etc.........most of them were destroying each other's sites.....just because muslim has that kafir-budhparasti angle you want to focus more on that.
He is biased.
They know all that! They just cannot accept their criminality! The cause of Pakistan's destruction is their own thinking!
Nalanda University was destroyed by Bakhtiar Khilji .
But who destroyed Takshashila University?
@shatnemohanty6678
Hoodbhoy is a media person who works for the Deep State who accumulated $555Trillion by colonization using Christianity and using Islam as Weapon of Mass Destruction. He is not much different from James Roy, Burkha Dutt and Ravish Kumar of NDTV.
What's nationalism? Is it nurturing of nativity, celebrating achievements of native ancestors, Nurturing of native culture, languages and caring for everything native which includes native rivers, lakes, mountains and flora-fauna by treating them divine? Vande Mataram, Vanderbilt Bharat!
Can a religion which is nothing but a gang/legion created to enslave, rob, rape natives by grabbing REgal political power create a nation especially a civilizational nation?
First such gang, Christianity destroyed almost all natives of Africa, Americas, Australia and a copy of it the second such gang Islam destroyed natives of West Asia, North Africa and half of South East Asia.
Physics journalist Hoodbhoy wants to demoralize natives of Bharat so that Dharmic natives become rootless like him and accept Islamic misrule like Mughlai. Anglos created first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent) by breeding and using Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah. Chiknah Jinah used his Anglo life style as a Weapon to destroy greater India, Hoodbhoy is using his Physics Journalism to destroy rising Bharat.
Jinnah was unfair, Iqbal wasn't a philosopher because he didn't write a thesis! Man, this guy is clueless! Did Shakespeare ever work in a university? But now his books are taught to English literature students?? These so called limitless thinkers are limited themselves as they say that a man with a belief system can't be a philosopher! This clueless person is unable to highlight that Mr Jinnah did agree with the idea of United India but after Nehru's continuous refusal to address issues of Indian Muslims, Mr Jinnah had to change his course! Today, the killer of. Indian Muslims of Gujrat, Modi, is the PM of India, hell Modi even imposed a ban on BBC Documentary that seriously questioned Modi's role in the killings of Muslims of Gujrat! What does that say about India and Modi?? Today, Modi as a PM of India is making hate speeches against Muslims of India! Mr Jinnah was a Genius who knew always knew Hindus would behave like Modi so no wonder we Pakistanis call him, Quaid e Azam! Pakistan Zindabad!
Jinnah did not frauded muslims, the fudals frauded jinnah and the muslims because they knew what will happen with them if we dont separate and we saw all rajay maharajays, nawabs, jageerdars were gone after india came into being!
But Jinnah failed to see those selfish and corrupt feudals around him, hijacking Muslim League to rule, rather loot the separated "land of the pure" where common man would only suffer. Great leader must be with wisdom and VISION.
His name is Hood bhai shalwani❤
14:39 Yes , British were to blame for Hindu Muslim divide as was Jinnah and the Muslim league .
17:47 yes , Muslims are the biggest sufferers of Partition
18:06 yes , there are more Muslims in India than in pakistan
So , it turns out Partition was a Blunder for which generations suffered and coming generations will suffer as well
Britishers have nothing to do with Kafir Muslim divide.
Muslims are not the biggest sufferers, their wealth increased 3 times due to partition. They have Pakistan, Bangladesh and India also.
Great, then there should be another partition of India.
No buddy, muslims wanted to do scientific experiement. so they created these 3 partitions to see how the humans act up in their boxes. Don't you see the love for science and experiments? 😀 Now there's a need to open up some connections between these boxes for more interesting experiments but no one is ready for that yet....
Hoodbhoy is fortunate enough to be sitting on this side of the divide I would like to see him in Modi’s India today in which the gloves are off and the true face of the Hindu bias has shown it’s true colours ! Jinnah was right in his assessment of a separate homeland for the Muslims. Pakistan can well do without such pseudo intellectuals !
In the hindsight, everyone seems to become an expert on partition and its aftermath.
بہت ہی مفید اور معلوماتی بحث۔۔
شکریہ ڈاکٹر صآحب
Tamam Unpar jahilo ko is bewakof ki bakwas pasand ati hy
We are the only unfortunate nation that we can not pay respect and tribute to our father of Nation . Shame on these kind of stupid intellectuals . Allah bless our beloved country ❤Pakistan❤. Mumtaz Ali
Hoodbhoy aur hasn nisar ye hare hue log h jo rudali aur matam ke siwa kuch nahi kerte h.
This guy is nothing but a Western coolie. And his words are basically Urdu translation of pre-written European transcript.
Jinnah was a lawyer, a hired gun. His personal beliefs were irrelevant to the job he was retained for by the Muslim League. He knew the partition of India was wrong, yet he pursued it like fighting any other legal case, irrespective of his inner beliefs. He once speaking to Alighar University students when asked the rationale for partition of India, asked for a glass of water and showed a Muslim student would drink his T.B. contaminated water but not a Hindu.
I personally feel that Partition was Congress agenda fulfilled by Jinnah. If few states were carved out of India, it was very clear that they cant flourish as states in Indian subcontinent are deeply dependent on each other. After $$$ aid is exhausted, see the economy of Pakistan. BTW Hindu converts like Jinnah (Lohana Rajput) and Iqbal (Kashmiri Sapru Pandit) were carrying the most hatred against their own ancestral religion.
British after 1857 taught communalism to Hindus and Muslim but in England they remain firm on secularism, Hindus communalism rose under leaders like Bhai permanad , B. D. Savarkar etc without gaining popularity because of visionary Congress . Moreover under jinnah Muslim communalism reached on hight dividing mother India on support of looter British. Jinnah land failed to understand even today the west game.
جناح صاحب پنجاب اور بنگال کی تقسیم کے خلاف تھے۔ پنجاب میں ھندو %24 , UP میں مسلمان %27 تھے۔ ایک صوبہ تقسیم ھوا دوسرا تقسیم نہ ھوا۔ ھند UP سے 1948 کے بعد پاکستان انے والے کہتے ہیں کہ پاکستان انہون نے بنا یا ہے۔ پنجاب کے مسلم اقلیتی اضلاع ھم سے ھندو لے سکتے ہیں لیکن مکمل پاکستان بنانے والے اپنے صوبے UP کے مسلم اکثریتی اضلاع کو ھندو سے نہیں حاصل کر سکے۔ جناح صاحب کی ڈائریکٹ ایکشن کی کال پر بنگال اور پنجاب میں بہت سخت رد عمل ایا ، لیکن پاکستان بنانے والوں نے اپنے صوبے UP کے مغربی مسلم اکثریتی علاقے میں کسی ایک کی انگلی بھی زخمی نہیں کی تھی۔ صوبے سے حصہ کیسے حاصل ھوتا۔
پنجاب کی تقسیم بہت غلط ھوئی دھلی کے ساتھ فریداباد ڈویزن اور میوات ڈسٹرکٹ مسلم اکثریتی تھے ، امرتسر اور دیگر اضلاع کی ابادی %50/%50 تھی وہ بھی لاہور ھمارے پنجاب کو نہیں دیے گئی تھے۔ کانگریس نہرو کی سوچ میں پنجاب کے صرف دو ڈویژن راولپنڈی اور ملتان ڈویژن ھمارا حق نہیں بلکہ جناح صاحب پر احسان کر کے دینے کیلئے تیار تھے .
اگر اس وقت کانگریس سے قاعداعظم پاکستان حاصل نہ کرتا تو جس طرح اج ھند میں صوبوں کو تقسیم کرتے ہیں پنجاب کو تقسیم کرتے ھندو مفادات کو پیش نظر رکھتے , ھماچل ،ھریانہ اور لاھور ریجن پر ھندو اکثریتی آبادی کا پنجاب ھوتا، بھاولپور ، پنڈی اور ملتان ریجن پر مسلم اکثریتی آبادی کا NWFP کی طرح کسی نام سے صوبہ بنا دیتے کیونکہ ھندو ، مسلمان پنجابی کو پنجابی قوم کا قبول نہیں کرتے تھے۔ معاشی ترقی صرف ھندو اکثریتی لاھور کے پنجاب میں ھوتی۔
سندھ کو بھی تقسیم کرتے ، دریائے سندھ تک ھندو اکثریتی آبادی کے صوبے ھوتے ، صرف دریائے سندھ کا مغربی حصہ لاڑکانہ دادو اور کراچی سندھی مسلم کے حصے میں أتا، بقیہ اضلاع گجرات اور راجستھان میں شامل کردیتے ۔ گھوٹکی سکر خیرپور ایک ایک ضلع کی حدود راجستھان سے دریائے سندھ تک ایک پٹی کی طرح ہے۔ میرپورخاص ڈویژن ھندو اکثریت ابادی تھی ۔ ھوسکتا تو کراچی بھی نہیں دیتے کیونک کراچی میں ھندو کی بڑی ابادی تھی اس کو بھی میرپورخاص حیدراباد کے ساتھ گجرات صوبے میں شامل کرتے اس میں مسلم اکلیت ابادی ھوتے۔
اس لئے جناح صاحب نے اپنے 14 نکات میں صوبائی خوداختیاری ، صوبوں کے حدود کو اس صوبے کی 2/3 اکثریتی آبادی کی حمایت سے تقسیم اور کسی صوبے کی ابادی میں فرق پیدا کرنے کیلئے کسی خاص ابادی والے علائقہ کو صوبے میں شامل کرنے ، نکال دینے یا ابادکاری نہ کرنے کی ائین و قانون میں ضمانت چاہتے تھے ۔جس پر کانگریس راضی نہ ھوئی۔ بلکہ تقسیم ھند پر راضی ھوئی کیونکہ اس سے ھندو سیاسی لیڈروں کو ھند دیش پر اپنا کنٹرول ختم ھوتا نظر ا رھا تھا۔
تقسیم سے پہلے والی کانگریس اج کی BJP اور RSS سے زیادہ ھندو شدت پسند تھی ، موجودہ BJP , RSS کی قیادت مودی اور یوگی جیسے جاھلوں سے زیادہ کانگریس والے علمی اور سیاسی حوالے سے باشعور تھے۔
ھم سب شکر کریں کہ جناح صاحب کی کوششوں سے جو حاصل ھوا بہت بہترین تھا ، دنیا کا تیسرا بڑا وطن اسلامی دنیا کا سب سے بڑا وطن ھمارا پاکستان تھا ، ھم نے اپنے وطن کو ذاتی مفادات یا اداروں کی مفادات کیلئے توڑا اور کمزور کیا اور کرتے جا رہے ہیں ۔
اگر ھماری سیاسی قیادت باشعور ھوتی تو 1963 کی چین ھند جنگ میں اپنا حصہ لیتے حیدراباد اور جھوناگڑھ کے بدلے میں ھندو اقلیتی صوبہ اسام , مشرقی پاکستان کے مشرق اور شمال میں ھندستان کے علاقے و صوبوں میں ھندو مذہب اج بھی اقلیت میں ہے، منی پور ، میگھالیہ ،میزورم، اروناچل , ناگالینڈ اور سکم سب حاصل کرتے، سکم ریاست کے حکمران مسلم تھے ، ھند کو چکن نیک علاقے سے کاٹ لیتے ، وھاں سے نیپال کی سرحد بہت قریب تھی ، مکمل کشمیر کو اپنی طاقت سے حاصل کرتے ۔ لیکن اس وقت ھماری سیاسی رہنما فاطمہ جناح اور دیگر سیاسی قیادت پابند سلاسل تھی۔ اج کی طرح ملک میں سیاسی یکجہتی نہیں تھی ۔
جناح صاحب کلات ریاست کی طرح کشمیر سے پہلے افغانستان کو بھی پاکستان میں شامل کرنے کیلئے فوج کو احکامات جاری کئے تھے لیکن اس وقت بھی ھماری فوج کے انگریز چیف نے ان احکامات کو قبول نہ کیا۔
کاش ایسے ھوتا ، اج پاکستان میں اراکان برما کا مسلم اکثریتی ابادی کا علاقہ بھی ھمارا ھوتا، ھند کے مشرق و مغرب میں پاکستان کی کروڑوں کی ابادی والے ھمارے علاقے سے گذر کر دیگر دنیا سے واپاری اور تعلقات قائم کرتا جنوب میں مالدیپ ھند کے زیر اٹر ہے وھاں پر ھند کی فوجی کیمپ ہیں وہ بھی ھمارا ھوتا ، ملائیشیا بنگال برما کے سامنے سمندر کےجزائر انڈیمان پر اج ھند کا کنٹرول ہے ان جزائر پر بھی حدود کے اعتبار سے ھمارے وطن کا حق ھوتا ، ھند چاروں طرف سے ھمارے وسط میں ھوتا۔
اج پاکستان کی ابادی 70 کروڑ سے زائد ھوتی ، پاکستان ، چین کو ویٹو پاور دلانے کیلئے نہیں بلکہ اپنے لیئے حاصل کرنے کی کوشش کرتا ۔ افریقا ایشیا اور اسلامی ممالک کی قیادت پاکستان کرتا۔
سیاسی غلط فیصلوں کے نقصانات نسلوں کو دیکھنے پڑتے ہیں ۔ کشمیر فلسطین روھنگیا اراکانی اور ھندی مسمانوں پر مظالم نہ ھوتے ۔ ایک طاقتور وطن پاکستان کی اواز ان کے تحفظ اور حقوق کیلے ضمانت ھوتی۔ کاش کاش 😭
ھند کے مسلمانوں میں اور مسلم لیگ میں جناح صاحب جیسی دوراندیش سیاسی قیادت نہیں تھی ، سارے لیڈر اور سیاسی جماعتیں صرف اپنا مفاد دیکھ رہے تھے ۔
کانگریس کے پاس گاندھی ، نہرو ، پٹیل کی طرح شاطر , دوکھےباز، چالاک و مکار درجنوں سیاسی لیڈر تھے جو صرف ھندو مفادات کا تحفظ چاہتے تھے، مسلم اور دیگر اقلیتوں کا کوئی بھی حق ھند کی زمین پر تسلیم کرنے کیلئے تیار نہیں تھے۔ مولانا ازاد جیسے سیاسی لیڈروں کو معلوم نہیں تھا کہ ھندو کی کتنے خطرناک منصوبے ہیں ۔
اللہ تعالیٰ کا ھم سب شکر کریں کہ ھم ھند میں نہیں پاکستان میں ہیں ۔
Yes I am happy that partition happened. Good riddance of junk.
Pervez has max Indian followers/commentators & max of them negate his ideas. Muslims rarely believe him but somehow he continues to deliver his thoughts which are out of his qualifications/subject. He is urged to reconsider and recourse it
The framework is something like this: 1. VERY extreme Hindophobia is built into turkic/Islamic colonization of India. Which sholud not be surprising to anyone who has read history. 2. Local peasant converts were not fully integrated into elite indo-Islamic culture. They lived in dozens of older subcultures w own characteristics and evolved own "syncretic" elements too. But with our leaders are our leaders. When push comes to shove, people line up w their own (which is why civilization discourages shoving matches) 3. Pakistan reflects the triumph of the most bigoted and separatist version of Indo-Islamic political culture. It was NOT the only version, even among the elite, but thanks to short-sighted and generally ignorant pukka sahib Jinnahbhoy, Hindo "betrayal" of the empire in WW2 (and Jinn's smart adoption of "we are loyal supporters of the British Empire and deserve special consideration") and anglo-American strategic fever dreams, it is what triumphed in the 1940s. 4. East Pakistan has escaped this trap and become a slightly more normal country. West Pakistan has concentrated the founding ideology even more in a smaller and more manageable area. Pak is holding 77% of that poison in a poorly armored throat right now and it is not pleasant. 5. Peasants, even today, can be moved in a different direction. Esp if elite loots the place and leaves. The more likely evolution is towards "lets try Islam seriously" though. 6. The future is unwritten Strive on with diligence Hoodbhoy represent the sorry figure/situation of Pakistan.
Hinduphobia of Turks? 😂😂😂Paajeeeet, you dididnt have Hinduism before 19th century British rules. Your yourself is a convert to the pseudo-religion called Hinduism. 1871 first census had 30%~ of the 'Hindus' in British named 'Bharat'.
Only Pakistani I found rational and unbiased till now is Shakil Chaudhary.
Even Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed also a hidden Islamist..
Jinnah betrayed muslim 1947.
No i feel he did favour to hindus, we are grateful to him
He is ok with Muslim league but not with Hindu Mahasabha, RSS and BJP.
Off course M.A Jinnah was well aware what gonna happen in future and he was 100% right look at now India or Indian Muslim M.A Jinnah predict the same scenario 76 years ago Salute to Quaid E Azzam Muhammad Ali Jinnah
True and Excellent Statement 👍
This man is against Pakistan and against Islam 😡
i am a lawyer in uk and i 110% agree with him. i hire indians in usa and uk business. i know what he is saying.
Fake Jihadi account with Christian name
Modi jaisa means he is pm and leader.pl note dr. Saheb.
You are gem of our Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️