How the Revolutionary Movement and British Responses Still Define India | Arth - A Culture Fest 2022
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 сер 2024
- Sanjeev Sanyal tells us how Lal-Bal-Pal, the trio who stood for Swaraj, were the first thinkers or leaders of India’s Revolutionary Movement, the Anushilan Samiti provided the spark for this movement, the link between people instrumental in seeing this to fruition and how the British responded to this resistance.
Arth - A Culture Fest Co-powered by Greenply - India’s First Zero Emission Plywood, Macho Hint and Parachute Advansed Gold, Special Partner Protinex.
Disclaimer:
All the opinions expressed by the Panelists are their individual opinions. Arth - A Culture Fest, as the organiser, holds no responsibility for the views expressed at the event, live coverage and social media.
Subscribe to our channel: / arthaculturefest
Follow us on our social handles:
Twitter: / arth_live
Facebook: / arthlive
Instagram: / arth_live
Hearing all these, no way one cannot remain w/o crying several times - worst part is we as a generation were told lies after lies. So many have put their lives for us to live now.
Don't cry. Take pride, hold your head high and think how can we repay the debt to our ancestors for we owe our lives to them
This was hands down my favorite session on Arth 2022. Veer Savarkar and Sachindra Nath Sanyal's stories are painful, thrilling and just so unknown..
This man is a gem. He should be protected at all costs ❗️
You should not miss last 15 min.....
I would request this channel to put all your videos in more videos of less than 10 minute videos....it would increase view counts exponentially (may be)
Thanks to your team for bringing this....More power to you ❤️
They put it eventually
Totally
Finally the true history had the fortune of visiting Singapore for work and went to the Town Hall at the place of the memorium , true goosebumps. Freedom didn’t come marching with a stick and spinning charkha like NCERT books
This video should be played at all schools in this country
The only history book and frankly my gateway drug to Hindutva is Land of seven rivers which I made atleast 4 other people read. 🙏🏼
That's the way to knock on the doors of the otherwise dormant indian Nationalists completely unaware of the Neo-colonialism silently trying to stretch its dreaded tentacles in the country.
Need to make aware as many concerned Indians as we can.
Works and thoughts of the people like Sanjeev Sanyal, J Sai Deepak, Rajeev Malhotra ,Meenakshi Jain and many more are to be spread like wild fire as fast as possible to counter the Neo-colonial and anti national elements, and to protect our Bharat, preserve our civilization and uphold the Dharma.
Army fighting on the border at two fronts. We,the civilian nationals, have to fight at the 3rd front- the Propaganda war against India. (Late Gen Bipin Rawat's fighting at 2.5 fronts theory)
Good to know your work. This is the least we can do.
Jai Hind, Vande Mataram 🙏
Truly so informative 🙏so much of unknown happenings … an eye opener indeed .. and sanjeev you are such a good story teller .. so many events and people .. I am ashamed to say I did not even know about …
God bless you and your research and work ..
give us more of this
ARTH … 🙏🙏👏👏👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏
We are now blessed indeed to have such a personality to open our eyes to the suppressed history by the anti national congress party, the actual successor to the imperialist country. 👍👍🙏🙏
🙏🙏👍
Thank you Mr. Sanyal. Have great respect for him, and last year I found out while researching about Paramhansa Yogananda ji that he is a relative to parampujya Shri Lahiri Mahashay 🌼🌺🌻
Immense respect to Mr. Sanyal 🙏🏽 Imagine the significant investment this individual has made to bring these heroes to the fore. Imagine what could be accomplished if our so-called National historical institutions can achieve only if they have their hearts in the right place! Jai Bharat!
Being a UPSC Aspirant, it's a blessing in disguise.
Dhanyawad 🙏
Just listen and forget. If you mention any of events mentioned by Mr Sanyal , you will be disqualified in UPSC exam.
@@vedalasrinivasan1490yes , unfortunately yes listen but present them what they want to see
Extremely good presentation Sanjeev sanyal ji. You actually explained a lot of things. You took out the myth I had that India had to beg it's freedom ( thanks to gandhi) I can proudly say we took it.
আমি বাঙালি, আমি গর্বিত আমি বাঙালি 🙏
History speaks......💯💯
thank you Mr. Sanyal - would be great if could cover the revolutionaries from the south as well. Tiruppur kumaran's hijack of train with armaments to equip revolutionaries, Kattabomman's armed struggle with Brit to name a few. Unfortunately, many in north are given to believe that freedom was won by the north and south got it for free. Our history books are to be blamed for it (and ofcourse their ignorance)
An excellent exposition. I do wish you had included the names of unsung heroes including women freedom fighters. One name I suggest is Urmila Shastri who was imprisoned in Meerut jail and has written an account of her prison days. Titled “Karaagaar”, it has been published with a foreword by Kasturba Gandhi. She died soon after. More details on her can be provided.
What a civilised lot the Brits were!
Great session, clearly explained the parts of suppressed history. Hope NCERT books start including the full history. As after school only some people read history.
Brilliant presentation.
Always great to listen about the revolutionary activities during freedom struggle but the way Sanjeev Sanyal Sir concisely descripted some of the cascaded stories is just awesome.. He has always been a great heard for me.
Finally.... Have been waiting for this for over 4 years now!!
It's always great experience to listen him... Congratulations to his promotion to EAC PM after Bibek debroy...Artha tq very much for this wonderful session
As kids growing up our elders referred to our motherland as Bharatvarsh and not even Bharat but in school it confused us as our class mates referred as Hindustan and India. We didnt know which one should we follow however so nice to see NOW our elders in the family were right
The renaissance is happening again 🧡
Astonishing, meaningful facts from history all our kids must know and reflect. They must redefine sense of character from these real hero’s. Thanks!!
I am happy that there are some people who is openly speaking the truth. Congress was never a freedom loving people and a true loyalists of British India that is why they had given power to loyalists Nehru and not Sardaar Patel. Britishers took revenge by their own way to this real freedom fighter.
Abey chomu…
Do you know that BJP has an age limit of 75?
Sardar Patel was 72 in 1947. He was 75 when First election was held and he died at that age before the first election was completed. Nehru was only 58 when India got freedom.
On 20 April 1946, Gandhi made his choice for Congress party President known in the favour of Nehru. Despite Gandhi’s open support for Jawaharlal Nehru, the Congress party overwhelmingly wanted Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel as the president and consequently the first Prime Minister of India, because Patel was considered “a great executive, organizer and leader”. At that time only the Pradesh Congress Committees could nominate and elect the Congress president. By 29 April 1946 which was the last date for the nominations for the post of the Congress president, and thereby the first Prime Minister of India, 12 out of 15 Pradesh Congress Committees nominated Sardar Patel. The remaining three abstained from nomination process. Once Gandhi was informed that “Jawaharlal will not take second place”, he asked Patel to withdraw. Rajendra Prasad lamented that Gandhi “had once again sacrificed his trusted lieutenant for the sake of the “glamorous Nehru” and further feared that “Nehru would follow the British ways”.
When Rajendra Prasad was using the phrase “once again”, he indeed was referring to the denial of Congress president-ship to Patel in 1929, 1937 and 1946 in preference to Nehru; and always at the last moment. Nehru was made prime minister of the Interim Government of India in the British Raj from 2 September 1946 until 14 August 1947.
@@chandlerminh6230 Abey chamche just check below comments by someone
@@chandlerminh6230 Shameless imbeciles like you are a burden on this planet let alone in India.
BJP was not even formed then and there was no such age limit which you're highlighting here nonetheless.
Taras ata hain tum jaise gaddaron ko dekh kr, it's about time that people like you should be thrown out of this country or put in cellular type of jails , so you understand what it takes to get the freedom!!
How much clarity he has about the modern day history of India that's amazing and and at the end what you have explained about state like punjab, Maharashtra and bengal you answered thousands of my questions thanks 🙏
Some of the instances gave goose bumps. And feeling ashamed to have not known our own history and that too a recent one! 😞
I am really thankful for such an eye opener , i am always looking for any video of Sanjeev Shanyal
This unforgettable remarkable vendeta i have heard from my late Grandfather and it was remaining a favourite when i wax class 10 ,even still i am not able to control my tears when i listen it .Mr Sanjeev Sanyal 's Father and Grandfather both are revolutionary
We were never heard of these true heroes in our school history books
That was the intention. It’s called propaganda. A form of brainwashing.
Awesome as always
Salute to all revolutionary heros for bharat
My favourite speech of 2022
That was so well knitted, Mr. Sanyal.
A sincere, thank you. 🙏🙏
and the truth prevails...
What a gem of last 10 mins of fresh information or rather PoV💐
The session was an eye opener.
Thanks Sanjeev Sanyal Babu.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🙏🏼
This is really an eye opener for me. I am surprised to see how the ruling clan practiced divide and rule even after independence by suppressing the leaders of other form of freedom movement. AICC came to power by playing palace politics and continued for more than six decades. Hats off to Sanjeev bhai for his thorough research and a neat presentation
Each of these great leaders who sacrificed should be chapters in high school! Thanks for opening a door towards truth, which is just a start to reach there.
The freedom movement of India from British colonialism has multiple facets. The major facets were those led by Gandhi as opposed led by the revolutionaries. The British were comfortable with the Gandhi faction.
Absolutely brilliant ❤️
Fantastic and must listening talk!
East bengali hindus are now being targeted again in north east and west bengal also. Last 10 minute was pure gem.
Excellent piece of information on Indian freedom movement breaking the sinister left propaganda. Thanks Mr Sanyal and thanks Arth.
Really well researched and eye opening
Thought provoking sessions.. Sanjeev Sanyal to the point as always..
The aftermath of the revolutionary movement mentioned in the last minutes of the video are sad.
History is always written by the victors
Misnomer. It’s usually written by predators. Victory implies a fair fight/match. Sometimes it’s an ambush, a predatory tactic.
Result is the same but intentions mean a completely different situation.
Brilliant
Excellent and motivational
Needed more such sessions.
I am the inhabitant of Chandannagar, where many revolutionaries silent foot steps existed.
Sanjay at his best. Tk u sir.
What a Beautiful Stage Design… KUDOS TO ORGANIZERS…
Very informative presentation, thanks Sanjeev Sanyal.
Insightful. It is noteworthy to mention few names from Southern part of India viz., Rani Kittur Chenamma who fought against British like Jhansi Rani. Also Krantiveera Sangoli Rayanna who was hanged by British on whose name the central railway station of Bangalore is named after.
Anyone who enjoyed this amazing lecture should read Arun Shourie's "Eminent Historians: Their Technology, Their Line, Their Fraud"
Thank you❤
Well narrated
Must share & subscribe to this channel videos.
This channel is real gem,full of quality content on imporatant issues.
It appears to me that the UA-cam Algorithm is somehow not fully understood by Arth Organizers…. Because this video is being brought up here in my feed after more than an year…
Context at 43 mnts . Yashpal in his सिंहावलोकन never mentioned himself as the informer .
Sachchidanand Vatsyayan Agnya was involved with revolutionary activists Chandra Sekhar Azad and others ; he mentioned Sachin dada in his works .
Did you seriously expect him to declare himself as an British informer and a traitor ???
Why no series ( better yet multiple limited series) on any of our OTTs on all these incidents!!? A gutsy director can make and show so much about the Indian history as we have so much .. so much of material!!! It's indeed heroic!!! Inspiration, Inspiration, Inspiration... it's all one can feel but our movie makers who are busy taking Inspiration from western series and imaging sex scenes to mimic west !!
Please make a conference on Bagha Jatin
🙏🙏🙏
Thank you. Last 10 mins were very informative. Now I understand politics of Maharashtra better. How the likes of Sharad Pawar are elected again and again!
Looking at the memorial stone of the Cellular Jail, the number of Revolutionaries from Bengal is staggering. Now compare that to the Bengal of today - The repeated "Bhadralok" narrative ingrained over generations after indeoendence that has reduced the once revolutionaries to an entire generation of woke pseudo liberals. Sigh...
Don't worry, we are reviving it back. It has always been there. Rest of India always worked on not empowering bengalis, because the same traitors came to power in delhi. Their hindi language imperialism continued , and every linguistic group, bengali/Tamil/Punjabi/ were treated as second-class citizens.
One of best session I hard
हम आपके बहुत आभारी है ईसलीये की आपने सच्चे स्वातंत्र्यसैनिको को वह सन्मानित किया जिन्हे तथाकथित गांधी और नेहरू के और देशद्रोही साम्यवादी ईतिहासकारोने इतिहास के पृष्ठोसे जानबुझकर गायब कर दिया. वो भी ईस लिए कि आने वाली पिढीयो को सिर्फ गांधी नेहरू ही याद रहे.
Bagha jyotin plot leaked out exchange of French who got from polish secret Service and had to share with allies british, 1915
🙏
Still not brought back from the miserable state - Bengal and Punjab.
Still not recognized - Maharashtrian brahmins.
When will this english revenge end? It's going on for generations.
😮❤
Fabian communists came to power in W Bengal not Communists. Jyoti Basu had his training in Communist party of Great Britain which is a failed as a communist party. Ref: MN Roy, Gegen den Strom
👍🙏😊
All this would have been so good to listen to if the speaker were not nervous or maybe had prepared better. So many ah ... Àh s pauses was extremely distracting !!
Sri Barindra Gosh took the refuge of Sree Sree Thakur Anukulchandra
अगर आप को इतना कुछ पता है फिर भी आप ने भारत की शिक्षा नीति और स्कूलों के सिलेबस को बदलने के लिये कोई फंड क्यों नहीं दिया
Congress, Communists, Jihadi - Sabse zyada khatra inho se hi hai.
It's the journalist who betrayed his country then too!!🙄
Indian tricolor is similar to IRA
20:50 It's Forest Research Institute, not Forestry Research Institute
so as a start, oct 2 shouldnt be declared a holiday anymore, 25 May - Rash behari bose or 23 Jan - Subhash chandra bose - birthdays should be declared a national holiday to honor our armed forces. jan 30 should still be remembered for the murder of a great man that mobilized the crores of ordinary ignorant people all over the country, not withstanding his numerous other blunders and poor judgement/stubbornness for which we're still paying the price, no??
where did Gandhi fit into this??? seems he was cannonised by Brits to dilute the movement.
YOU DID HEAR THE TERM "LOYALIST" . HE WAS THE GEM OF THEM .
If you want to know gandhi read the book written ,letter written by gandhi itself.
The list shows only only Bengali Hindu and Punjabi Hindu and Sikh names. Why not any Muslim names.
Dari hui minority using assssssmani kitab logic 😂
Aahfaqullah
You name one¡
Muslims were working for Britishers
Why does the host sound like a eunuch?
Why do we have a cartoon as a host
Because you weren't available 😂
@@mihirshah7695 lol damn that was a good one dude
@@architjain30 also momo the pedo was busy chasing 6 year old girls, boys , goats , sheeps , monkeys , cats , donkeys , camels , dogs basically anything with a hole so between the 3 of you they chose a more intelctual person 😂
Maybe stop referring to these great men as "characters"? How about how show them some respect? You make your living off talking about them after all.
Yeah one who is researching their hidden Stories need to learn respect from someone whose only contribution is getting offended
He is principal secretary in finance ministry and he is related to Sachindranath sanyal ... 🤦
I think it just used the word not with any intention of disrespect. After all he is close relative of sachindarnath sanyal himself. Sachin sanyal is his grand uncle
@@shreevatsarao3260 what does him being a finance secretary have to do with respect??
@@musicworship4520 you said he is living out of these talks .... So mentioned his job .... Now stop being dumb and respect hard working people contribution for India
Was this revolt useful ? Sardar Patel also refused to include INA soldiers into “Independent” Indian Army. Aurobindo realised that the extensive amount of life loss was futile affair against Raj that’s why he exiled himself from those activities. If you say independence (which is not bcz ultimately you are going to be ruled by anybody) then the power transfer from Britain to INC (WW2 which damaged entire Europe) then that’s the biggest blunder what happened in India from Economical standpoint. Whatever freedom enjoyed by Indian bourgeoisie prior to 1947 totally destroyed by Nehruvian protectionism. Tremendous life loss of Bengal only brought Bengal’s doom intellectually and economically
If these events didn't happen then India would remain a colony in perpetuity due to the loyalists.
🙏