Characters React To Aerith's Demise Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лют 2024
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 190

  • @GodOfAI_
    @GodOfAI_ 3 місяці тому +32

    Cloud has not lost his mind, he’s LITERALLY stuck between 2 universes
    that’s why they will probably find a way to bring her back in the third game.

  • @RealKyndleNance
    @RealKyndleNance 3 місяці тому +89

    Tifa hits me the most. 😢 It’s like she lost her sister.

    • @mistcries
      @mistcries 2 місяці тому +2

      poor girl lost jessie now aerith

  • @kjdee140
    @kjdee140 3 місяці тому +186

    I think Cloud's lost his mind, and Tifa seems to be the only one aware of it right now.

    • @mashimaru161
      @mashimaru161 3 місяці тому +39

      It’s Aerith’s ghost. Red can sense her when she pets him.

    • @KJames2345
      @KJames2345 3 місяці тому

      ​@@russellbrown1814 So wrong dude

    • @darkrevan2635
      @darkrevan2635 3 місяці тому +5

      It might be something between the two she s fighting insisde the life stream and he snaped because of jenova cells (black materia and Sephiroth controling him)

    • @darkrevan2635
      @darkrevan2635 3 місяці тому +2

      He s not really the best example of sanity

    • @elcraneo3d
      @elcraneo3d 3 місяці тому +5

      I think this “ghost Aerith “ it’s Jenova. Because if it’s real Aerith, she is dead now she could be in touch with lifestream and by extension know more and know that cloud is not sane. But it seems she is pushing him to keep mad.

  • @alwaysloctis
    @alwaysloctis 3 місяці тому +92

    There's also a possibility Aerith told Cloud something else while he was falling through the portal so he knows things others don't. And Marlene said to Zack that Cloud can save her, so... Waiting for part 3 hoping for the best.

    • @enriquepowers
      @enriquepowers 3 місяці тому +7

      Hopefully, I mean they already kinda botched her death scene, which was the most impactful part of the original game

    • @loritaylor1602
      @loritaylor1602 3 місяці тому +1

      It confuses me……

    • @lordrald09
      @lordrald09 3 місяці тому +4

      @@enriquepowers I really hope they're saving that scene for when Tifa "saves" Cloud in part 3, resulting in him coming to terms that Zack and Aerith are dead

    • @alwaysloctis
      @alwaysloctis 3 місяці тому +16

      @lordrald09 if nothing changes in the end then the whole point of all this nonsense with whispers is simply useless and dumb... all that with "this time I will never let you go" like wtf. I hope they'll make it right for Aerith this time

    • @xxsilvermoonxx3580
      @xxsilvermoonxx3580 3 місяці тому +3

      ​@@lordrald09There is literally a whole timeline where aerith and zack is alive, i don't understand your point.

  • @Rare-Candy
    @Rare-Candy 3 місяці тому +16

    My theory is that Aerith is not a ghost but JENOVA. "Those you hate, those you love, those you fear - JENOVA would become anyone to fool her pray" Sephiroth has been hinting at it the whole time. He never specifically said that Tifa was the one he was talking about.

  • @dek6413
    @dek6413 3 місяці тому +22

    Why do I feel like Cloud's current state stays between the real world and lifestream and the conversation between Cloud and Aerith "You gonna be okay getting back" can mean that she can somehow possibly return to the real world and "Don't worry. It's like a second home" can actually mean she's in lifestream now so she can stop the meteor there which is the same in OG. But Rebirth actually gives a new potential that Zack and Aerith can return but don't really know how.
    PS. Poor Cloud gonna go psycho in the next chapter where many things going to be resolved. I guess

  • @lulima8755
    @lulima8755 3 місяці тому +28

    They managed to make Cloud crazier than he is.

    • @jofez27
      @jofez27 3 місяці тому +1

      Cloud is likely experiencing Schizophrenia.

  • @freebritney89
    @freebritney89 2 місяці тому +3

    I think her death hit Tifa the most, which is sad to see because the devs showed a sisterly bond between the two.

  • @charliegriffey7773
    @charliegriffey7773 3 місяці тому +39

    I think in Part 3 it will open with the cutscene of what really happened

    • @michaelrobosa146
      @michaelrobosa146 3 місяці тому +3

      yep. that is EXACTLY how i envisioned it

    • @kevinj12345
      @kevinj12345 3 місяці тому

      I hope so, otherwide this will be a miss on the level of CP2077 in terms of sheer let down

    • @ry2950
      @ry2950 3 місяці тому

      Knowing Square they will probably string us along until the Mideel moment.

  • @zamaskowany12
    @zamaskowany12 3 місяці тому +95

    Cloud actually thinks he saved her, he trully still belives Aerith is still alive...

    • @thenoorcrownofficial
      @thenoorcrownofficial 3 місяці тому +14

      Red can feel her presence, too.

    • @zamaskowany12
      @zamaskowany12 3 місяці тому +8

      @@thenoorcrownofficial He could do that in the OG too.

    • @michaelrobosa146
      @michaelrobosa146 3 місяці тому +9

      @@thenoorcrownofficial yeah but only her presence, unlike Cloud who is literally hallucinating that he can see her, that he believes that he saved her, when he didn't

    • @Borink---
      @Borink--- 3 місяці тому +7

      ​@@michaelrobosa146he's not hallucinating.. he actually see her but he does think she's alive.
      I think Aerith is trying to buffer his shock.
      I think Cloud knows Aerith dies since remake.. he alluded about her death so much i lost count.

    • @michaelrobosa146
      @michaelrobosa146 3 місяці тому

      @@Borink--- he is literally hallucinating as he is the only one who can see her. sure, Red XIII felt her presence, but that's just it. Only Cloud can see her, but not the rest of the team.

  • @loganthevillager9176
    @loganthevillager9176 3 місяці тому +19

    Time to recollect this scene after Cloud loses his mind and realizes things in FFVII R (Part 3)

  • @StanDiggs
    @StanDiggs 3 місяці тому +3

    Considering they were saying that theyre making this line up with Advent Children, it would make sense why Cloud talks to her throughout the movie.

  • @andresgarza8511
    @andresgarza8511 3 місяці тому +22

    I think rarity is a force ghost since we see her even touching red in the ending
    And cloud doesn’t blame himself this time

  • @X_Lord_of_the_Night
    @X_Lord_of_the_Night 3 місяці тому +7

    If we took what Sephiroth said seems like the different realities are collapsing, so the Aerith Cloud sees is actually the one he saved from Sephiroth attack holding his sword,while the one who died is the one from 97. The next game probably will dive into the multiverse crossing theme. Because of the collapse, Aerith is dead and alive at the same time as both timelines fused (remake and 97), Cloud is probably the one who can see her because he was present in both the reality she died and the one he was able to prevent Sephiroth attack.

    • @elizadoolittle9657
      @elizadoolittle9657 3 місяці тому +1

      I agree 100% 👍

    • @redhelmet4991
      @redhelmet4991 2 місяці тому

      I have a feeling that this observation is close to the truth, I really hope it is

    • @potatofun3328
      @potatofun3328 Місяць тому

      That's my theory too! Sephy was laughing cuz he knew Cloud saved Aerith but it didn't matter cuz he's merging worlds. She's alive somewhere! And Cloud is living in multiple worlds like Aerith. Adding to your point, only Cloud can see her, it'd be neat if Tifa could too as she was in the lifestream...to hit home Aerith's bestie love for her.

    • @X_Lord_of_the_Night
      @X_Lord_of_the_Night Місяць тому

      Also,the latest FF VII book, Ultimania Rebirth, mentions the different realities as a possible explanation for Cloud seeing Aerith. The book released on April 12, 2024.

  • @aesden
    @aesden 3 місяці тому +17

    I feel like maybe he does know shes dead but at the same time is okay with it and just communicating with her through the lifestream or something which explains why he isn't sad. Or maybe he just lost it completely lol

    • @user-df8lp9zq8s
      @user-df8lp9zq8s 3 місяці тому +2

      He doesnt thinks she is dead lol, he literally tells her to wake up, and he skipped buring part in his head

  • @josecuestas7246
    @josecuestas7246 3 місяці тому +28

    So, Aerith become like a Force ghost.

    • @slyktech1860
      @slyktech1860 3 місяці тому +23

      A lifestream ghost I guess? Cloud could also just be having a mental breakdown too.

    • @josecuestas7246
      @josecuestas7246 3 місяці тому +21

      Two theories:
      - Aerith is actually a hallucination of Cloud, much like the Joker in Arkham Knight that is a hallucination of Batman.
      - Aerith become like a Force ghost, making her capable to reveal herself to who she chooses, like Cloud.

    • @CarlosMartinez-tt4qp
      @CarlosMartinez-tt4qp 3 місяці тому +16

      ​@@slyktech1860I think it's both. Aerith is in the lifestream and at the same time she and Sephiroth are in the same space (which perfectly aligns with the events of FF7 og).

    • @darjeelingdelise
      @darjeelingdelise 3 місяці тому

      Cloud is literally is schizo doesn't accepted the fact that Aerith died and his mind is starting playing tricks with him having hallucination of Aerith around where ever he goes.

    • @Borink---
      @Borink--- 3 місяці тому +6

      Yep she is and Cloud can actually see her but he's deluding to himself that she's alive.
      The jaring fact here onwards is that Cloud can actually see Aerith vs his OG and AC self where he can only "feel" her presence and only been able to see her hand reaching towards him.

  • @dravguitao7265
    @dravguitao7265 3 місяці тому +19

    I like this touch that Aerith is still part of the team, and is guiding them even though she is gone. And the little touch that Red XIII can still sense her presence is a nice touch too.

    • @elizadoolittle9657
      @elizadoolittle9657 3 місяці тому +1

      Yeah, she’s still “there” but I don’t think she’s a force ghost like everyone’s theorising, or else she would follow Cloud and the gang wherever they go. She doesn’t get on the tiny bronco, she’s staying there at the city of the ancients.

  • @ionel2921
    @ionel2921 3 місяці тому +7

    Knowing that he s so traumatized that he can still see her, after all he s been through anyway, is even more dramatic than the original :/

  • @midnightthoughtsss
    @midnightthoughtsss 3 місяці тому +7

    1:59 it turns out Cloud is the one who hurt Aerith. "Do not blame yourself" Aerith said beforehand. Yeah I know, in Advent Children she said the same thing

    • @revostepify
      @revostepify 3 місяці тому +7

      But Cloud’s sword is clean. Sephiroth’s was shown to have her blood.

    • @LittleMissCherryPie
      @LittleMissCherryPie 3 місяці тому +6

      I think she meant it like "don't blame yourself for not being able to save me"

  • @DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv
    @DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv 3 місяці тому +15

    Aerith appearing every 5 minutes kind of defeats the purpose of her death.

    • @michaelrobosa146
      @michaelrobosa146 3 місяці тому +3

      because she is literally now a ghost from the life stream

    • @DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv
      @DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv 3 місяці тому +15

      @@michaelrobosa146 Sure but its a bad narrative choice. The original death was so impactful because she dies, and she stays like that. Its sudden and grounded. No final words or speech, someone dear to you just disappeared.

    • @michaelrobosa146
      @michaelrobosa146 3 місяці тому +4

      @@DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv i believe that the actual scene of the stabbing and her burial will be the opening of Part 3. also, you can literally see Cloud say something to her but inaudible because they are saving it for Part 3 heheh

    • @ugh5281
      @ugh5281 3 місяці тому +3

      @@DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv they've been teasing for a while that her death scene was gonna be different and considering the changes they had made since remake it was to be expected that it would be different. honestly i think even if they remade that scene 1:1 the impact would not be the same bc everyone knows it's gonna happen. the og scene was impactful because it was so shocking and unexpected, even if they were to recreate it everyone was already expecting her to die. they're trying to convey a different feeling on this one bc it's not the same exact game as the OG. i do agree that her death scene here and the emotions felt very inconclusive but i'm pretty sure they'll continue to explore that in part 3 which is why her death scene feels so "open ended". the OG death scene was definitely a lot more impactful and sadder but it was because she died and that was it, in this one they clearly want to explore something different with her death and the timeline stuff (that is still very confusing to me personally).

    • @itisthefear
      @itisthefear 3 місяці тому +1

      @@DiegoRodriguez-dw7pv nah i think it adds more to the story because we can see how deranged Cloud has become, compared to the other characters who are at a loss for words after what happened.

  • @JohnnyinCLE
    @JohnnyinCLE 3 місяці тому +3

    Part 1: Re-MAKE...
    Part 2 (Where we are now): Re-BIRTH...
    Part 3 (Where we are headed): Re-UNION.
    This is NOT the end of Aerith.

  • @synovelle
    @synovelle 3 місяці тому +7

    Am I the only one that thinks Cloud realized Aerith is dead, and this is just Aerith's spirit showing herself to Cloud as a means of helping him and the group face the issues that's in their way? Stranger things have happened, I don't think assuming Cloud is just crazy and hallucinating is the best scenario here. ;D Besides, Nanaki even recognized when Aerith touched him, and that was hundreds of feet away from Cloud's eyeline. So, it's kinda clear that Aerith's soul is still hanging out.

    • @MrArkRaptor
      @MrArkRaptor 3 місяці тому +3

      Aerith is probably like sephiroth now, in the lifestream able to force ghost to cloud which only he can see like in the first game.
      The reason why she can force ghost is cause she has more practice in being using the lifestream like going to other worlds and taking cloud with her.

    • @synovelle
      @synovelle 3 місяці тому +2

      @@MrArkRaptor Yesss, you explain it better than I do, this is what I meant. She's part of the lifestream now, and with all the timeline schenanigans it's no surprise that something like this can occur. Cloud /does/ have issues, but him seeing Aerith isn't him being crazy, he's legit being visited by her soul.

    • @iam4026
      @iam4026 3 місяці тому +3

      Not to mention, Sephiroth says he underestimated Aerith when she shows up to help Cloud against him

    • @elizadoolittle9657
      @elizadoolittle9657 3 місяці тому +2

      She’s either alive in another timeline or in the lifestream because he doesn’t act like she’s there in front of the party members. He’s not telling the others “look it’s Aerith, she’s right here”.
      He doesn’t talk to the air while the others are around to see it, it’s like he knows if they saw him do that they’d think he’s crazy. Cloud knows something we don’t. If he had gone crazy he’d act like she’s physically there for good.

  • @OGBabygurl
    @OGBabygurl 2 місяці тому +2

    Can someone please explain to me why they chose THAT part of the song to play when Aerith appeared 2:13 ? It just feels so sinister...

    • @hi9073
      @hi9073 Місяць тому +1

      Seriously, and the lighting doesn’t help lol also ngl I really love that part of the music though

  • @yourgoblinsecretary3842
    @yourgoblinsecretary3842 3 місяці тому +7

    Cloud’s hallucinating really gets in the way of the emotional impact of this scene. What made the original so emotional is that it was a very straightforward gut punch. I can’t help but feel that the impact gets lost in the convolution of alternate timelines and cloud’s psychosis.

  • @HamzaAli55659
    @HamzaAli55659 3 місяці тому

    The is beyond awesome we'll get the full scene in part 3 i hope i am gonna buy this masterpiece soon the themes of depression and trauma in ff7 are also incredible😢

  • @01Danni10
    @01Danni10 3 місяці тому +1

    12:32 Man! This is insane!
    It's like Aerith is still there with them but as a Spirit that no one can see her! RIP Aerith! 🥺😢

  • @joshuaguste6883
    @joshuaguste6883 3 місяці тому +2

    I think the game is setting up for Cloud's mental breakdown and Aerith's endgame for Sephiroth.

  • @simplycity592
    @simplycity592 3 місяці тому +3

    Just like what happened with zack, cloud lost his memories

  • @samuraiedge2619
    @samuraiedge2619 3 місяці тому

    Cloud telling Barret that "he can handle it", make me think that he actually is aware of Aerith demise, Red's reaction when she is near, tells me she is a ghost or maybe he is just losing his mind.

  • @georgetek
    @georgetek 3 місяці тому +6

    F off with the spoilers.

  • @JustaThinkr
    @JustaThinkr 2 місяці тому

    Man… as if Cloud didn’t look like a complete nutjob… Not only does he have constant headaches, passes out and has visions, but now he has a ghost waifu that’s having him look like he’s talking to the air. The group probably think he’s a total loon 😂

  • @sado429
    @sado429 3 місяці тому +2

    And kids, this is why you don't do drugs, 'K? They make you see things you shouldn't 💀

  • @seiryukanninja
    @seiryukanninja 2 місяці тому

    I have a feeling Tifa will comfort Cloud when she repairs his mind because the feelings Sephiroth suppressed from his mind will catch up to him from what happened to Aerith.

  • @G1Grimlock94
    @G1Grimlock94 3 місяці тому

    Till all are one... 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

  • @mattgee4867
    @mattgee4867 2 місяці тому

    I wasn't sad in this scene because I had no idea wtf was going on. We saw him stopping Sephiroth with his sword, thinking he saved her, but then she's dead after all but still around for Cloud like wtf. And they don't show one of the most iconic scenes in gaming history: Cloud carrying Aerith into the water. Come on

  • @cindyluu8523
    @cindyluu8523 3 місяці тому

    Og made me cry and hurt for cloud, this just made me be like wtf?

  • @sammyay-man2754
    @sammyay-man2754 3 місяці тому

    To be continue to find fantasy 7 vol 3 Re-created

  • @carlu0255
    @carlu0255 3 місяці тому +1

    My heart is not good 😭

  • @richardmcgowan1651
    @richardmcgowan1651 3 місяці тому +2

    Go play through the OG FF7. At this point of the game Cloud is under Sephiroth control and Cloud is at the start of a full mental breakdown. The only difference this time around is Aerith is with him. Speaking to him from the lifestream. Were Remake changed it up. Rebirth seems to be sticking to the OG story.

  • @elizadoolittle9657
    @elizadoolittle9657 3 місяці тому

    Everyone’s forgetting about the “new world”/timeline/realities that get created whenever someone goes against destiny, Sephiroth mentions it before this. Cloud clearly saved Aerith, watch the moment he deflects Sephy’s sword.
    It’s possible she’s alive in a new world, I know that sounds crazy, but it would explain why they didn’t show her death that occurred in the remake/OG world, so that we the audience don’t feel that finality. It’s to show there is hope. Cloud can’t be going crazy, if he is then he’s aware he’s going crazy because he doesn’t act like she’s there in front of the party members, he knows something that we don’t.

  • @user-yq9ko7vu7c
    @user-yq9ko7vu7c 3 місяці тому

    I love this game 😊

  • @alexdanciu5107
    @alexdanciu5107 3 місяці тому

    Îs Like a sad ending of disc one

  • @alejandromolina1563
    @alejandromolina1563 3 місяці тому +1

    Pobre cloud, si siguen así en la parte 3 va a terminar en un manicomio

    • @Eliocall
      @Eliocall 3 місяці тому

      Jaja asi es ya abusan de la reaccion de inyectarle celulas de jenova, aunque en parte lo manejaron bien porque aun no entrega la materia negra en el north crater, la mmente de cloud esta twisted fuk.

  • @aureliacortez3625
    @aureliacortez3625 3 місяці тому

    Did anyone not cry, I didn’t the music wasn’t sad plus confused if she’s actually dead they mourned for only a short time felt underwhelming.

  • @kayin5696
    @kayin5696 3 місяці тому

    The way they protrayed everyone's sadness for Aerith dying is so bizarre to me (besides Cloud's who clearly is having a moment for whatever reason). Think they missed the mark a bit here.

    • @ugh5281
      @ugh5281 3 місяці тому +3

      i think the point is that we're seeing it mostly through cloud's perspective. they barely showed the other's reactions and they mostly showed cloud's pov, him thinking that he saved her and thinking that she's safe and with them. they're definitely gonna explore more of her death scene and explain it in part 3 because her death scene in rebirth feels very inconclusive and there's still a lot of questions that need to be answered especially regarding the whole "timeline" stuff.

    • @kayin5696
      @kayin5696 3 місяці тому

      ​​@@ugh5281 i do agree i just cant help being disappointed because the scene with aerith and her mother got me more than this. If Aerith did indeed die, I wanted it to hurt. I wanted her to live tbf, but if they went the same route, I wanted it to be impactful. Now I have to wait awhile...

  • @smashbrolink
    @smashbrolink 3 місяці тому +1

    So even after all that, we still need to wait for part 3 just to see if we really can save her?
    Ffs man...

    • @Eliocall
      @Eliocall 3 місяці тому

      She’s dead , aerith is alive in the lifestream 😢

    • @smashbrolink
      @smashbrolink Місяць тому

      @@Eliocall There's prevailing theories that the reason Cloud can still see her is because she survived in some sort of alternate timeline.

  • @Dannysasazaki
    @Dannysasazaki 3 місяці тому +3

    For player pov who doesn't play OG, I think this ending was the best they could get before part 3 as conclusion.
    Although imo, I still love the death of aerith in OG. An event that slowly almost drown cloud in insanity 😂
    Now let's hope the final part of FFVII R(whatever) could integrate advent children and dirge of cerberus as part of the final game too, because we still don't see any trace or act from genesis playing part in this game shenanigans.

  • @davesartdesk1778
    @davesartdesk1778 3 місяці тому

    😔There’s only one place left to go now . 😠 to the northern crater . …….. and the reunion that awaits

  • @kevinj12345
    @kevinj12345 3 місяці тому +1

    The way this was done, was awful compared to the OG

  • @garethhayles6885
    @garethhayles6885 3 місяці тому +5

    The one thing I like in these comments is no one’s bring up the shipping war but I will say this he doesn’t love aireth romancatilly but he does care for her just like he cares for the other but he only loves Tifa romacatlilly sorry for kinda being ships Ito this it’s just nice to see people actually understand the reason cloud mind is so fuck even M more after this isn’t because he love aierth romantically but because he feel survivor guilt which is showing in advent children which is canon because the creator have said the the remake trilogy are before advent children any sorry for being ships up it’s just nice to see that a lot people understand the symbolism of aireth death if that makes sense

    • @seven8090
      @seven8090 3 місяці тому +43

      I'm not into shipping either, but saying Cloud had no romantic feelings toward Artith is the biggest load of cap I've ever had to read.💀

    • @garethhayles6885
      @garethhayles6885 3 місяці тому +2

      @@seven8090 no it’s not read the books which are canon also rebirth makes it obvious that he loves tifa romantically

    • @seven8090
      @seven8090 3 місяці тому +6

      I've played Rebirth. Please point to me outside of scenes that are OPTIONAL where it's shown he's shown romantic feelings towards to Tifa.

    • @wingadept8793
      @wingadept8793 3 місяці тому +21

      Dude. How are you going to compliment about people not talking about shipping and you do the just that in regards to who Cloud loves. Come on man...

    • @garethhayles6885
      @garethhayles6885 3 місяці тому +2

      @@seven8090 gongarga sorry if i spelt that wrong they almost kiss or did you miss that

  • @salvatorestabile5547
    @salvatorestabile5547 3 місяці тому +1

    The game is boring. First part takes forever and stopped playing already. Hate the combat. First part was much better in every way except for intergrade. Can't play a boring game.

    • @absolutezero6423
      @absolutezero6423 2 місяці тому +1

      Yawn..... If its so boring why are you watching these videos?

    • @salvatorestabile5547
      @salvatorestabile5547 2 місяці тому

      @@absolutezero6423 maybe because I can? I know... critical thinking comes hard to you but I know you can do it if you try

    • @absolutezero6423
      @absolutezero6423 2 місяці тому

      @@salvatorestabile5547 Predictable. A non answer and a feeble attempt at a insult. Your the one who is boring.

    • @salvatorestabile5547
      @salvatorestabile5547 2 місяці тому

      @absolutezero6423 you do know one word sentences to start your insulting comments doesn't make you sound smart, right? I answered the question. You're just unable to comprehend basic sentences.
      Also, it's "you're".

    • @absolutezero6423
      @absolutezero6423 2 місяці тому

      @@salvatorestabile5547 I use one word sentences to start my insulting comments"maybe because I can"?
      Now do I sound smart? Lol. I'm done. You amused me slightly but I have no more time for your silliness. I'm out.