When astro girl first released it seemed like such a uplifting message but after sana left it feels much more bitter sweet either way it's a lovely song and I'll happily listen to it whenever I have the chance.
They took it as reassurance that she'd be staying on, but...sometimes life does not give us everything that we want. If Sana's original is the song played over the happy ending of the movie, then Gura's version is the quiet melody sung on a balcony at night.
Before Sana's graduation I would say Deadbeats from Cali or Gura's Reflect. But now I am in total agreement with your opinion especially after her farewell concert during her graduation stream when it was live.
I didn't know Sana, I got in a little after she left...but the community constantly shows how much she mattered to them and this heartfelt rendition of her song through Gura's sweet voice still makes me emotional. I feel like I miss someone I never knew.
Sana was special, for sure. She was the embodiment of "The flame that burns twice as bright burns half as long." Astrogirl is the eternal gift of Beeg Sana.
I know the general sentiment is to wish Sana well, but to my fellow Breaddog brothers and sisters, know that you are also loved, and that you are not alone, either.
Would it be wonderful if all the girls could use Sana's emotes?...I know it's alot to ask but it's, in my opinion, to always have her with us... I know she's always with us but just seeing her emotes...
Having just watched Sana's last stream this still makes me tear up, I didn't watch Sana before but I wish I did. Amazing job Gura, Sana will always be remembered
Oh, damn… her singing… and this song. Oh, the tears… Sana might not be here in body but she surely is still here in spirit. I miss her so much but it warms my heart to see all the love and support she still gets from the community months after her graduation. Sana is truly eternal. 😢❤
It's 2023 July but I still have that gaping hole in my heart. Ah who cut some onions! The message of the song resonates so much it hurts and how Gura usually sing with a slow tune makes it even sadder. Sana is eternal.
man. i just listened to altare’s unarchived cover, then the original, and those brought me to tears, but listening to this actually broke me. i know i’m not alone, but… it still feels lonely, y’know?
A lovely rendition of one of my favourite Hololive songs. I was there for the start of the stream but had to go due to the time, then I later found out it wasn't archived, so i'm thankful for the songs being clipped.
Starlight, you shine, illuminate the sky The endless void reminds me of aeons gone by An astrogirl watching galaxies rise and fall Wondering the meaning of it all Till like a comet, you came into my orbit, I know I'm not alone I'm not alone When our hearts grow bigger than the sun There's no challenge we can't overcome So send them over and watch our supernova explode I'm not alone, now you are here The constellations are so clear Your gravity is pulling me Oh until our hearts collide My satellite, through the darkest nights Got the cosmos at our feet Oh, but you are all I need Though we've just begun I know we'll make it 'Cause somehow the universe is fun now I'm not alone Sunrise and night can be so intertwined The event horizon line between darkness and light An astrogirl watching history come and go Pondering the punchline of the joke Till like a comet, you came into my orbit, I know I'm not alone I'm not alone When our hearts grow bigger than the sun There's no challenge we can't overcome So send them over and watch our supernova explode I'm not alone, now you are here The constellations are so clear Infinity sounds good to me As long as you are by my side The Milky Way is not far away When love travels faster than the speed of light Let's go, I know we'll make it 'Cause somehow the universe is fun now I'm not alone
she is not begone she just went home and don't worry we will always be with you sana also gura thanks for your beautiful voice go sharky spread you voice to all human
Sec 0:35 man, heard the song and didn't even say "oh no it's this one" . He just started singing it on his/her own. That "I'm not alone it's so ominous amongst all the emotive comments. Love this song. Love Sanana. Love Goomba.
Wherever Sana is I hope she is spreading the love and compassion she gave all of us. She may have been here only a short time and it's sad to see her go but the memories we made our precious. Enjoy those special moments cause you'll miss them once they are gone. Sana is beeg & eternal 💛
A lot of comments on how bittersweet the song itself hits or the fact she left so soon.(especially this version) And you are entirely right. It's a stretch, but there is still a hopeful vibe if you read it as her feeling connected enough it's okay to move on.
I swear I could fall asleep to Gura singing on songs like this, even tho music usually keeps my brain going. Not this one specifically tho, I'd just cry to it lol I still feel so emotional about Sana's graduation, one year from it.
Holy. Fucking. Shit. This was the most beautiful thing I’ve ever heard. I started saying “holy shit” under my breath during this, and I ended up saying it 214 times in a 4 minute video. 209 times during, 5 times after it ended 🥹🥲😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Is a rainy night with no star or moon.. and no light in my area.... what going.. i can feel sad in inside gura voice... Is make me feel i have one hole inside my heart.. is cold and dark.. help
When astro girl first released it seemed like such a uplifting message but after sana left it feels much more bitter sweet either way it's a lovely song and I'll happily listen to it whenever I have the chance.
for me, it seemed like a mellow sad song even since the early of it. but then after the retirement.. it's sadder than before
They took it as reassurance that she'd be staying on, but...sometimes life does not give us everything that we want. If Sana's original is the song played over the happy ending of the movie, then Gura's version is the quiet melody sung on a balcony at night.
This gave me tears. I miss Sana, we all do. Everyone loved her so much.
Goodbyes are temporary, but Sana is eternal.
One of the best EN originals
fr
Agreed. Personally my favorite.
Before Sana's graduation I would say Deadbeats from Cali or Gura's Reflect. But now I am in total agreement with your opinion especially after her farewell concert during her graduation stream when it was live.
and the underrated one
An EN original completely in English, somehow making it even more bold.
Sana is eternal o7 💛
o7
o7
o7
o7
o7
I respect Gura for singing this but god this broke my heart and soul
It's a terrible day for rain
Me too kid.
@@MaxPowerzs it's not even rainin stinky. *snort*
@@TheItuber who you callin' stinky, stinky?
Ahhhhhh that hurt soooo much more than I expected. Sana is *eternal* 💛
Aw. Thanks Gura, Sana is Eternal 💙💛
I didn't know Sana, I got in a little after she left...but the community constantly shows how much she mattered to them and this heartfelt rendition of her song through Gura's sweet voice still makes me emotional. I feel like I miss someone I never knew.
I know this comment is almost a year old but I feel like you just put the exact way I feel into words thank you for that-
gura singing soft/slow/sweet/sad type songs is when she really pulls at your heartstrings
Sana was special, for sure. She was the embodiment of "The flame that burns twice as bright burns half as long." Astrogirl is the eternal gift of Beeg Sana.
This whole stream was a roller coaster of emotions but this was very sweet.
This version hurts so much... because of the tempo and Gura's voice. Sana is eternal!!!
I know the general sentiment is to wish Sana well, but to my fellow Breaddog brothers and sisters, know that you are also loved, and that you are not alone, either.
You too man. You too.
I will see you in the stars
*headpats fellow Sanalite.* we’ll meet again.
Been saying that Gura has a Disney Princess voice so for her to sing this emotional song fits very well
1:43 I really love her angelic voice…
Gura has a very endearing voice that is very powerful
Sana is eternal and Sana forever 😭😭💛💛💛
Would it be wonderful if all the girls could use Sana's emotes?...I know it's alot to ask but it's, in my opinion, to always have her with us... I know she's always with us but just seeing her emotes...
@@nyne9611 Ina still has her Sanadachi emote!
Omg 😲 I didn't know that!. I haven't caught her streams cuz of work sadly. 💛💛 makes me happier knowing this thank you
Having just watched Sana's last stream this still makes me tear up, I didn't watch Sana before but I wish I did.
Amazing job Gura, Sana will always be remembered
最初オリジナル聞いた時からいいなと思って、ホロに限らず色んな曲を聞き返すけどAstrogirlのこのピアノバージョンは別格に好き。歌詞もめっちゃ好き
I can feel Gura getting sadder as the song progresses. She also misses her.
Oh, damn… her singing… and this song. Oh, the tears… Sana might not be here in body but she surely is still here in spirit. I miss her so much but it warms my heart to see all the love and support she still gets from the community months after her graduation. Sana is truly eternal. 😢❤
o7
The stream exploded with emotions with her cover. She first tried it with her ukulele but shifted to a piano version. 💛
Wasn’t planning on crying tonight.. but I guess plans change.
It's 2023 July but I still have that gaping hole in my heart. Ah who cut some onions! The message of the song resonates so much it hurts and how Gura usually sing with a slow tune makes it even sadder. Sana is eternal.
Gura is the first person ever to be able to make me cry. Just something about the way she sings. You can just feel her heart.
I still miss Sana…thank you goober!
Still playing this as part of my hololive karaoke playlist. Still makes me emotional. The Goomba goof at the end is always welcome.
man. i just listened to altare’s unarchived cover, then the original, and those brought me to tears, but listening to this actually broke me. i know i’m not alone, but… it still feels lonely, y’know?
bro i REALY need to hear that! missed stream(
Sana is forever!
A lovely rendition of one of my favourite Hololive songs.
I was there for the start of the stream but had to go due to the time, then I later found out it wasn't archived, so i'm thankful for the songs being clipped.
Aw man... This is hurts a lot, but it also makes me happy knowing Sana is still technically with us, watching with us, and still talking to the girls💛
I hope she’s doing okay wherever she is and I hope she heard gura’s beautiful cover of her song o7
as skillful as ever, even with the small spots where you can tell she's holding back some tears.
Starlight, you shine, illuminate the sky
The endless void reminds me of aeons gone by
An astrogirl watching galaxies rise and fall
Wondering the meaning of it all
Till like a comet, you came into my orbit, I know
I'm not alone
I'm not alone
When our hearts grow bigger than the sun
There's no challenge we can't overcome
So send them over and watch our supernova explode
I'm not alone, now you are here
The constellations are so clear
Your gravity is pulling me
Oh until our hearts collide
My satellite, through the darkest nights
Got the cosmos at our feet
Oh, but you are all I need
Though we've just begun
I know we'll make it
'Cause somehow the universe is fun now
I'm not alone
Sunrise and night can be so intertwined
The event horizon line between darkness and light
An astrogirl watching history come and go
Pondering the punchline of the joke
Till like a comet, you came into my orbit, I know
I'm not alone
I'm not alone
When our hearts grow bigger than the sun
There's no challenge we can't overcome
So send them over and watch our supernova explode
I'm not alone, now you are here
The constellations are so clear
Infinity sounds good to me
As long as you are by my side
The Milky Way is not far away
When love travels faster than the speed of light
Let's go, I know we'll make it
'Cause somehow the universe is fun now
I'm not alone
I keep finding myself coming back to this, it’s so beautiful
Anyone just keep coming back here to feel that bittersweet taste of a moment just outside of your fingertips?
Yeah, this song gives me Disney vibes for some reason.
Man, it's been so long since I've seen Gura do Karaoke. I miss those days.
she is not begone
she just went home
and don't worry we will always be with you sana
also gura thanks for your beautiful voice go sharky spread you voice to all human
Miss you Sana, you are eternal and I'll always wish you the best
This song in Gura's gentle voice hits so right.
Sec 0:35 man, heard the song and didn't even say "oh no it's this one" . He just started singing it on his/her own. That "I'm not alone it's so ominous amongst all the emotive comments.
Love this song. Love Sanana. Love Goomba.
Man! I hate tears! 🥺
the thing i love about goomba is when she sing its like she is telling the whole story of the song and she letting all emotion that she can muster.
I love her intonation in 1:45
Ah this piano version is awesome.. it made me cry during graduation stream
Sana...
The universe is indeed fun now and so you are not alone
God speed Astrogirl, wherever you are right now
Wishing more will sing Sana's Astro Girl
This song gets me everytime and Gura singing this version really brings the showers
Sana is eternal 🩷
The perfect companion while watching the pretty night sky 🥺
I still miss her
A person who we didn't even know personally can did to our heart to this day is terrifying.😢😭
Me too
I actually teared up.
Beautiful, the track and gura....
i ain't gon' lie, but everytime hearing this song always give me shiver and it feels nostalgic already, damn it..
3:55 i cry everytime
Gura my heart broke LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Thanks sharky. Somehow in the future or even somewhere in the multiverse. Sana and you will do a live duet of this 💙💛
I still haven't been able to listen to this cover without shedding a tear or two
been over several months since Sana left, but this emotion... It won't going anywhere
Wherever Sana is I hope she is spreading the love and compassion she gave all of us. She may have been here only a short time and it's sad to see her go but the memories we made our precious. Enjoy those special moments cause you'll miss them once they are gone. Sana is beeg & eternal 💛
A lot of comments on how bittersweet the song itself hits or the fact she left so soon.(especially this version) And you are entirely right.
It's a stretch, but there is still a hopeful vibe if you read it as her feeling connected enough it's okay to move on.
This is beautiful. Sana is eternal 💛
That was traumatic. Absolutely nailed it
She was really getting into it around 2:34, listen close.
That piano music paired with this slowed-down version of Astrogirl was beautiful. Bravo to whoever played that.
Just imagine listening to this as Hololive as a whole was coming to a close.
Gura is great for doing this
Apart from the emotion if we know Sana, this version is very good, and plus Gura comfy voice make this version more perfect..
I swear I could fall asleep to Gura singing on songs like this, even tho music usually keeps my brain going.
Not this one specifically tho, I'd just cry to it lol I still feel so emotional about Sana's graduation, one year from it.
man the feels hit again
probably the best hololive song ngl
I'm not crying.
Gone, but never forgotten
virtual hugs Sana. ***hug*** miss you!
You mean head pats. All the head pats.
Yes, it was a good karaoke for sure
so much emotional song. Piano version make it more Emotion.
I missed this live, but I feel like my heart broke a little. Beautiful cover.
SANA IS BEEG.
Holy. Fucking. Shit. This was the most beautiful thing I’ve ever heard. I started saying “holy shit” under my breath during this, and I ended up saying it 214 times in a 4 minute video. 209 times during, 5 times after it ended 🥹🥲😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
To see and go an adventure full of gold and all I can say as you go is thankyou.
She's not alone, and she never alone
goosebumps for this is real
I told myself I wasn't gonna cry! "runs and cries"
this is a good song, it's written well
Aww...Sana is eternal o7
this song hit different in piano ver
Gura's feel for timing is insanely good.
that + me being a Sanallite and Chumbud
this Gura cover of Astrogirl is super precious to me
I was managing it at first but then she switched to the piano version.
I can never deal with this... 🥲
💙💛
You can see her blood pressure getting lower and lower for each minute it passes with this song playing...
The ukulele version she was trying to play was soooooooo good... Too bad she couldn't figure out the chords :/
You're not alone😭💛
I'm not crying you are crying!
Missed this. Time for a feel trip :(
o7 Miss you Sana
im not crying, youre crying
This song is a reminder the onion head girl's leaving too...
we miss her 😢
Sana is eternal!
Beautiful!
YT recommendation do be hitting my kokoro
im not crying im just sweating from my eyes T.T
Good tension break at the end there!
Right in the kokoro
I'm not crying. I just have something in my eye.
Is a rainy night with no star or moon.. and no light in my area.... what going.. i can feel sad in inside gura voice... Is make me feel i have one hole inside my heart.. is cold and dark.. help
So awesome!