Best Joker: Heath Ledger vs. Joaquin Phoenix
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лип 2024
- Playing the Joker can take everything out of you, learn how Joaquin Phoenix transformed himself into the iconic character, right here!: • How Joaquin Phoenix Tr...
The Joker... versus the Joker. Heath Ledger... versus Joaquin Phoenix. Two incredible actors … one role. Join WatchMojo as we pit the late, great Heath Ledger against living legend Joaquin Phoenix to see who gave us the superior big screen incarnation of iconic Batman villain, the Joker, from their portrayals in "The Dark Knight" (2008) and "Joker" (2019), respectively. Come along as we evaluate a wide-range of categories to determine which interpretation of the Clown Prince of Crime reigns supreme. Which Joker performance is your favorite? Let us know why in the comments below!
Check out more awesome Joker content from WatchMojo below:
Top 10 Reasons Joker Will Blow Your Mind: • Top 10 Reasons Joker W...
Top 10 Things You Need to Know About Joker (2019): • Top 10 Things You Need...
Why Joaquin Phoenix Is Meant to Be the Joker: • Why Joaquin Phoenix Is...
Have an idea you want to see made into a WatchMojo video? Check out our suggest page at watchmojo.com/suggest and submit your idea.
Subscribe: goo.gl/Q2kKrD and also Ring the Bell to get notified // Have a Top 10 idea? Submit it to us here! watchmojo.com/suggest
#Joker #JoaquinPhoenix #HeathLedger
Check our our other channels!
/ mojoplays
/ mojotalks
/ msmojo
/ jrmojo
/ watchmojouk
WatchMojo's Social Media Pages
/ watchmojo
/ watchmojo
/ watchmojo
Get WatchMojo merchandise at shop.watchmojo.com
WatchMojo’s ten thousand videos on Top 10 lists, Origins, Biographies, Tips, How To’s, Reviews, Commentary and more on Pop Culture, Celebrity, Movies, Music, TV, Film, Video Games, Politics, News, Comics, Superheroes. Your trusted authority on ranking Pop Culture. - Розваги
Learn how Joaquin Phoenix transformed himself into the Joker, right here!: ua-cam.com/video/CP4LtGXi5oc/v-deo.html
What are you guys talking about Phoenix’s suit isn’t purple!?
Can I suggest? Can you compare the two best Batman? Bale and Keaton?? I love Bale because he is my fav actor and Keaton's performance is great too..
Ledger but phoenix is great
why do yall always make it where it goes to the last question yall do it every. single. time.
Who ever subs to me I'll sub to you
Pheonix played the origins of the Joker to perfection, Ledger played the prime Joker to perfection. It isn't really fair to compare. Can we all just agree both were incredible?
Agreed. Both rolls are different but both so perfect. Shouldn’t be compared.
James Boisits I really don’t get why it has to be a competition they were both amazing and Leto was shit end of story
Clipper fan since 2012 unfortunately that’s the world we live in, just like how it’s ridiculous that the media is saying this movie is condoning violence. It’s been the same shit for 40 years. Video games, movies, etc. Just the world we live in today unfortunately. It’s like people forgot what the joker character was.
Agree dude
Yes! Ledger played a Joker who has already gone over the edge, while Pheonix played the version still trying to hold it all together, but we get to see him go over the edge.
#LetoCanFuckRightOffToFuckOffityLand.
Heath made me love JOKER..JOAQUIN made me understand JOKER..
Stan Maden You’re not really supposed to understand the Joker though.
Dimitry Thomas If we are intelligent, then of course we are!
Well, I agree because even though it might scare us, most of us can follow the way of thinking of Joaquin's Joker. We get a look of his tragical, traumatizing life, his motives and reasons why, and we can see how he slowly slips into the path of destructing. We see how he becomes Joker. And even though I really loved Joker because of Heath, Joaquin gave me that deeply shocking effect what I was looking for in the caracter of the Joker. He gave me the feeling of 'holy shit I understand how all these tragedy, trauma and depression became so much to him that he stopped feeling these kinda things. I understand why all the craziness made him lose his mind. And that, in my personal opinion, makes him the most amazing villain I've ever seen.
Exactly!
@@tzytzy7171 No, he's not dissing Phoenix's Joker or anything (because I think the majority can agree that he was great), but Joker as a character really isn't meant to be understood, which is what has made him so iconic. One of my favorite lines from him is: "If I have to have a past, then I prefer it to be multiple choice." Ledger's Joker was a harbinger of chaos. Phoenix's Joker was a victim of it. And Leto...well we don't talk about that Joker here.
Ledger's Joker wanted to watch the world burn because he saw the world as a joke.
Phoenix's Joker wanted to watch the world burn because the world saw him as a joke.
Exactly
@@seattlebeast6165 well yes but actually no he wanted to show that humanity will turn against eachother to show that eveyone is as crazy as him and while doing that he also put the mobs off business and exposed a bunch of corrupted cops
Ohhhhhh Well Said
copied
@@genghiskhan7691 stfu
Joaquin Phoenix : his dance, laugh, murders makes goosebumps
Heath Ledger : everything he does makes goosebumps
*goosebumps
@@keanuismyfather7477 nah geesebums
Yes. Heath is just good at making you feel whats happening in the movie. And hes just amazing
@@user-ns4sm2kc6w 👍
You include everything for joaquin phoenix
Heath Ledger's joker laughs because he makes people suffer, Joaquin Phoenix's joker laughs because he suffers.
So deep bra
Nah, Heath Ledger laughed at his own pain and suffering too; the dude was a full-blown misanthrope, no exceptions.
Jared Leto laughs because he makes the audience suffer
❤
Samuel Chvojka hence why he suffers....what’s not clicking?
*Joaquin Phoenix:* Psychotic Joker
*Heath Ledger:* Chaotic Joker
*Mark Hamil:* Cartoony Joker
*Jack Nicholson:* Classic Joker
*Jared Leto:* A joke
Can’t say it better myself
You just can't label one joker psychotic all of them are. Every joker movie or cartoon he's psychotic, Joaquin joker was ass/trash garbage plot and to think about it he was to fucking old. To try to have him that old with a job and being depressed, would of been better if he were in his teenage years going through a depressed mode and from there a psycho was born. But heaths joker deserves to be labeled psychotic/mastermind and everything else. We have yet to see a better joker than heaths
@@Eboo85str8OD Yeah well Phoenix's Joker ain't the real Joker anyway. All that was just his psychotic hallucinations firing up. It is made pretty clear in the movie if you watch it like you would watch Inception. The Devil is in the details.
Couldnt Agree More
Eboo85str8OD Your clearly right and millions of people are wrong I guess lmao
Heath - what a man could do to society
Phoenix - what society could do to a man
Simple yet terrifying
Dude, that is... wow, I will frame that quote and hang on my wall
The fact that Michael Caine forgot his text when Ledger came in at the party, because he was so shocked of his appearance and acting says everything about how great Ledgers performance was.
Heath Ledger would’ve been so proud of you, Phoenix.
exactly, it's not fair to compare
@@Mimi-qw7lz Is he comparing tho?
Really? I disagree..... Looking down, this is Heaths LEGACY.... Phoenix was a "friend".... I would never try to TOP my deceased friends legacy.... why doesn't he do Stand By Me remake while he's at it... plays Rivers part.
Batman they were actually good friends, and phoenix never tried to top ledger. he just did his job, and very well.
@@batman4452 Even tho it's his legacy it doesn't mean that his friend can't play the same role. I think Phoenix wanted to do the role and he was really dedicated to the role because he wanted to pay respect for Heath Ledger's legacy. He did his all because he knew how amazingly Ledger played Joker. If he really didn't care he would do as bad of a job as Jared Leto. Jared's Joker was so bad and definitely did not do Heath Ledger's Joker any justice. I think both Phoenix and Ledger did amazing job as Joker and both of their hard work should be noticed.
Well, you know what they say. "In every deck of cards there's always 2 jokers" 🃏🃏
Woow
Your comment is so fucking underrated 🤯🤯🤯
@@xSinfulGodx yours too
You rock. Both complete each others.
Both have nothing to lose.
Heath played the Joker perfectly as a Batman supervillain but Phoenix added more depth to the character's origins. Honestly they both were great,its hard to compare. And I love both the versions.
Actually is better not knowing Joker origins... 😂😂 That's what make him much more terrifying and impredictable...
LEDGER was an agent of chaos and super evil genius
PHOENIX was an angry child that was bullied 😂😂
Not talking about acting skills because as an actor Phoenix and Ledger they were both superb and marvelous but talking about being truth to the essence of character LEDGER STILL RULES
Ikr?the both movies grosses out 1 billion dollars on box office so it means they both slayed it
Phoenix could add sub layers to the character bcz that was there in the script, Bruh!
Heath Ledger's layers to the Joker's characters weren't in the script.
Ledger his own self imagined what Joker's past life has been that had made him stand against The Dark Knight.
I guess, Phoenix's job was much easier than Ledger's.
@@santangelogaia19 ledger was at his prime i.e joker like every comic and cartoon character but phoenix joker was hard not gonna say that ledger was bad he is legend and always will be but phoenix movie was all abt joker there was no Batman if y have watched that movie ull know but saying phoenix was not on par with ledger it's funny
Can we talk about how Heath Ledger learned to put on his own makeup for every shoot as part of him diving deep into method acting? That alone should stand out as truly excellent.
@Christian Stewart well the joker role will be heath but sadly he pass if he had a whole movie God damn think of all he can do the movie batman it self it focus more on joker instead of batman
In the words of J. Cole, “They act like two legends cannot coexist”
CaptainPhantasma facts
They can’t coexist, ledger is dead.
J cole is corny 🌽 now
But I never beef with a nigga for nothing if I clown a rapper it’s gon be legit
But there is still one best
Heath leadger made it look like it was a movie about joker while it was about batman
Because of the "script" maybe?
Yes and No
Heath Ledger*
... okay, sure, I'll take thar
Dude definitely stole the movie. I wanted him to win when I saw it in the theater
Heath as Joker was mysterious . There was no past . No childhood , no mother, no father . Heath was simply The Joker . The grandious Joker .
there was, the thing about the blade in his mouth, the thing about how his drunk dad
Because the dark night wasn’t a joker origin story..
@@702boiand there is like 3 different origin stories
I disagree with this review, You can't just compare two wonderful perfromences, heath ledger is a much more scarier and darker joker, on the other hand, Joaquin reflects more on Arthur himself as the events occur before he actually truly became the Joker. Both are amazing.
That's what makes Heath ledgers joker so amazing... Phoenix Joker was the main character of the film...it was all about him and his origin...Heath ledgers Joker stole the show and outshined Bales Batman in the Dark Knight and created a new perception of the character never seen in cinema...a darker more sadistic Joker
Also worth noting, Heath Ledger‘s Joker is a different one entirely. Heath played White, while Phoenix played Fleck
This wasn't Joker in his prime, This was Joker being born.
Dougie damn..... you must be a joy to be around
@Dougie He's campy, not a little girly or gay
Nerds
@Jacob Molyneux just ignore him i mean we all have opinion but this dude doesnt know what the fuck he is talking about...ok maybe only that he is kinda too old but if you look at comic perspective nobody knows who joker realy is nobody knows his origin only that joker is an idea
Dougie your opinion not mine I lived both films and I truly loved that they went more in to mental health with this film
I feel like you cant compare them, they're a whole different take on the character and they both did a great job
I feel the same. Both versions valid. Both versions great.
Me, too. I am fan of Ledger. When he passed away, there was a deep sorrow in me. His famous movie Brokeback cannot be forgotten. However, Phoenix plays well, too. We don't need to compare them. They are both gorgeous actors
I concur.
Distracted A Agreed 100 percent
Well said
Heath Ledger played Joker
Joaquin Phoenix played Arthur Fleck
No disrespect to Joaquin Phoenix and Jack Nicholson, who are both in my top 10 actors of all time. But what Heath Ledger did in that movie, people wont say it, because it's a Batman movie, it's not a serious drama, but I'll say it, it's the most breathtaking acting in the whole history of cinema... It's up there with Jack Nicholson's flight over the coockoo's nest, and stuff that Meryl Streep seems only able to do... In retrospect, the whole batman world seems too small for the kind of performance Heath gave us in this.
Literally, each and every mannerism is so meticulously created for this character, each and every tone change, his smacking of the lips, licking, his unpredictability, I feel that he was so into it that it must have been scary to be Maggie Gylenhall or any of the other actors which he gave the ''you know how I got this smile?'' talk, it literally seems like he was close to actually physically hurting the actors, let alone play the part well...
And the whole script behind it, made it something special, which I also have no doubt that Heaths improvised stuff, which was A LOT of it, have added so much color that it all made it believable...
I remember, watching the movie for the first time... And nobody needed to tell me that I saw something that I'll maybe never see again in film... Just like it was when you first saw LOTR or something... I just put the movie on, again, and again, I've seen it 4 times in the first 24 hours that I had access to the movie for the first time.
I mean, I know it's all subjective, and people will love someone else, don't get me wrong, Phoenix is an awe inspiring actor, and his movie was more of a character study on a psychotic, schizophrenic guy with really demoralizing circumstances and self-esteem... But to me, the script for that movie seemed like, ''We have to make this a sick movie, so that it's more crazy than the dark knight'', but in the end, the movie ended up being really hard to watch because it's about actual mental illness basically, it's going too deep into hopelessness... So it does leave a strong feeling afterwards, it wont leave you feeling indifferent... But Heaths Joker, freaking keeps you peeled to the screen, I want to relieve that brilliance, every second of it...
It's like watching the best of the best, at their prime, crushing it, doing what they were born to do, at their finest...
What Heath did is, just like the moment Cobain wrote Smells Like Teen Spirit.... it's a freaking masterpiece, and we can all just admire it...
Lol, just HAD to write a long Heath appreciation post, sorry.
And again, I'm really grateful for Nicholson and Phoenix, both are legends, there's no taking away from them what so ever.
This was just Heaths role of the lifetime...
Don't compare a legend with a legend
there can only be one legend
@@noname9041 That's obviously not true.
Heath is still better tho
Heath is a junkie
@@user-ex7yq6xq9s Phoenix can’t stop smoking yo I do k ow that right? Even irl he can’t stop smoking he’s also a addict you just can’t talk about one person🤡
"Ledger's voice was more *Joker*"
That's because he was the Joker for the entire film. For the majority of Joker, Joaquin Phoenix was playing Arthur.
Exactly what I was thinking.
exactly so why should we even bother calling phoenix's role "joker" when like you said, he wasn't even him
Sapph Sliv TRANSCENDENCE DUMMY. FROM ARTHUR TO JOKER HIMSELF. CAN YOU NOT ANALYZE FOR SHIT?
People don't seem to get the evolution and the birth of the Joker at all.
Thats why comparing is not appropriate. Two different plots and characters
its comparing The Joker to A depressed and ill man
Lets all be fair enough to admit that Heath Ledger introduced us all to a totally new version of Joker. The one which made us a fan of the antagonist. Joaquin Phoenix did a splendid job of improvising it, but the canvas was already made by Heath Ledger.
Bruh Joaquin Phoenix played Arthur Fleck while Heath Ledger played Joker
Comparison seems pointless
True
Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix: *laughs like two crazy dudes*
Jared Leto: *laughs like a creaking door*
lol
😂😂😂
Leto’s laugh sounds so fake and low pitched.
RGM don’t be rude
Gooby tf I think not
Joker is just the beginning he still isn’t a crime boss yet
Will they make a sequel?
@@Nicholas_Chen_ Joaquin has said he doesn't wanna make a franchise
There will never be a 2nd movie the joker won’t be a mob boss it doesn’t work with this story and really think about it this is so life like ..Batman doesn’t fit in this universe he doesn’t exist Bruce Wayne does but that’s it
Agree
@@bobxkennedy2008 I agree, making a sequel will ruin this interpretation of the joker.
I love both, but Heath Ledger more Joker than Joker in the Comic😂 his iconic
Heath Ledger is a legend he played the role so well he will forever be my favorite joker , no one comes close. May he Rest In Peace 🕊🕊🕊
Phoenix is better
@@tommy2439 hard cap. see a doctor.
@@tommy2439better at being mad boring
@@TheGuyWith3Legsthey're same in acting
1989: You ever dance with the devil in the pale moon light?
2008: Why So Serious?
2019: Knock knock
Put a happy face
Smile put on a happy face.
You get what you deserve. 💥🔫
There are way better quotes but of course you'd pick that...
I like how u skipped 2016
I like how Jared Leto isn’t even part of the conversation
Oof.
SUICIDE SQUAD IS FILLER
We don’t talk about that
Lol 😂
Who?
I think the full spectrum of Heath Ledger’s joker can be found in the scene he captures a civilian dressed as Batman. When he growls the words “LOOK AT ME” it’s enough to send chills down your spine.
heath is way ahead of joaquin not because he is no more with us but because he played the joker so good they had to make a entire movie about the character thats the biggest compliment to his acting
I don't like this comparison
Phoenix is the build up to Joker while Ledger was already Joker. Two different roles
Totally agree!
@@Lit-UP. smart cookie
True
Yes, but the problem with the Phoenix Joker is that you can't actually envision him ever becoming the Ledger joker. He's weak, and incapable of developing a strategic plan. Joker at his best is a perfect blend of crazy psychopath AND strategic mastermind. The origin story only highlighted Joker as a mentally ill, psychopath. As it stands, I can't see him ever becoming a criminal mastermind. He didn't have the personality for it. None of that was developed at all. In my opinion, a BIG missed opportunity.
@Darren Scott agreed
_”When the chips are down, these... these civilized people, they'll eat each other. See, I'm not a monster. I'm just ahead of the curve.”_ - Joker
BSJ IN YO HOUSE “Where is he”
See you have to play my little game if you want to save one of them.
@@siddharthjha7022 my little what?
Joker predicted SJW, NPC culture.
Siddharth Jha you know for a while there... i thought you really were Dent, the way you threw yourself after her
Heath Ledger will always be reminded as the best Joker.
Heath actually is like as if he was joker. He died because he want to see how insane joker is and he wanted to make the movie so realistic that he even told Bale to actually beat him.
I used to think Leto's Joker was a comedy. Now I realise it's a tragedy.
First rule of Joker Actors
We don't talk about Leto
Second rule of Joker actors
WE. DO. NOT. TALK. ABOUT. LETO
Stolen comment
Well leto joker is have more accurate looks/design than ledger or Joaquin
Leto isnt the real joker... He was robin....
@@calogerogriffin861 sadly the comparison ends there.
"as kids we loved the hero's, as adults we understand the villains"
when we are kids we are naive to reality due to our inexperience as adults we understand the shiettiness of reality due to the experience.
bitch plz u just stole this comment from someone at least credit them for it lmfaoo
Ain’t that the TRUTH 💯💯💯💯
this is something a teenager would say. cringe
that's a bullshit statement.
Each were perfect for their respective roles. They both win, and the fact they both won an oscar for playing a comic book villain proves that point.
Absolute legends!
There's no need to compare
"Deck always has two jokers"
-Weird Badger
“I’m waiting for the punchline”
“There is no punchline”
Right? Lol
@@Electronicmedium1111 Have you seen the movie?
Just watched the movie. Crazy af
"I hope my death makes more sense than my life." -joker 2019🤦🏻♂️💔
@@allaboutanime9426 cents*
Imagine if we had a stand alone film of Heath Ledger’s Joker 👀
best comment yet...Ledger the legend. he owns that role
A standalone Heath Ledger Joker film...God help us all
Nah it wouldn't really work. I would've loved to see that, but it wouldn't have worked.
Idk, I feel like his joker kind of needs Batman to counteract him
But part of what made his version so compelling was that we knew nothing about him. Having a stand alone film would ruin that about the character.
Heath was not "The best Joker"
He was Joker...
I mean we all know no one can compete with Ledger's Joker. But damn did Phoenix come close in my opinion. That whole scene with him on the late show will go down as one of my favorite movie scenes of all time. Twas absolutely perfect.
Heath ledger show how the joker think
Joaquin phoenix show how the joker feel
Jared Leto show how not to be joker
@@muratkayar8921 jajaja agree 10000%
bryan Jaramillo exactly
Murat Kayar looooool
Love the way you put it. Maybe that's why so many people felt catharsis with his story.
Phoenix is young Joker
Heath is Joker when he’s older
Both are perfect
That a 44 years old actor plays the young one and a 29 years old actor plays the old one is in itself a joke.
exactly what i was thinking Antone Wilson
I just can’t see Joaquin’s joker becoming Heath’s joker. Heath is too unpredictable and he doesn’t take revenge. he just kills people because he finds it fun. he’s completely psychotic. While Joaquins joker clearly kills people who he finds awful and uncivil. he has plans and does exhibit remorse. The two are completely different characters with completely different motives even if they both are the joker
Master Robotnik shut up
Ah no, the timeline doesn't make sense.
Joaquin's joker is an alt-Batman universe where he's older than Bruce. Heath's Joker is also an alt-Batman universe joker which both he and the Batman are around the same age.
Both actors did an incredible job. But for me Joaquin Phoenix made me fall in love with his portrayal. I love Heath Ledger's portrayal, but I couldn't watch it over and over. The Joaquin Phoenix portrayal I could spend an entire three day weekend watching on replay. I can't get enough of his descent into becoming Joker. It's both heartbreaking and enthralling. Best ever and should be no Joker ll.
Must watch the dark Knight 💯 real joker u feel 💯
Get some help bro
I think u haven't watched THE DARK KNIGHT yet...😈😈
Bullshit, Joaquin's joker is shit. This is not a joker that is enemy of batman. Heath Ledger is still the best. A rip off of taxi driver and king of comedy.
They both won Oscars...love em, hate em. That's the bottom line. Opinions can sometimes be like assholes. Everyone's got one. They all stink, ijs....
To even be compared with Heath is an Honour in itself.
I love both of them!
Joaquin carried the entire movie, his discomfort during his first show was absolutely gives you the cringes but you felt a sadness as well. He brought depth to the character.
Ralph I think its not fair to compare because they are drastically different characters. Phoenix's joker snaps after abuse, whereas ledgers joker didn't snap because there was he had no concept of morality in this first place. I would say Phoenix's joker is a Sociopath; driven to insanity and crime by external factors. Ledgers joker is a psychopath, born without any true moral compass and unable to feel. Ledgers joker is more of an existential threat to Gotham, as Alfred put it, some men can't be reasoned or negotiated with, some men just want to watch world burn. Phoenix's joker can be. Both wonderfully played. In my opinion I prefer ledgers performance and his take on the joker. More menacing
Ledger carried the movie, and that's saying something considering its one of the greatest comic book movies and also he isn't in many scenes. The anticipation of the next scene of him possibly appearing in was what I remember most about seeing it for the first time in the theatre
Matt Mohr Joaquin did the better Joker character. Just taking the concept of what it means to be a “Joker” from the roots and becoming just THAT.
Heath did the better Joker to combat Batman. The villain archetype.
@@superexclusive452 Ledger changed the way Joker is and has been portrayed ever since. Even the Leto joker was a poor imitation of the Ledger joker. Prior to Heath, Joker was a criminal mastermind in a costume. Period. Now he's a sociopath with a multi-faceted personality. And this is all thanks to how Nolan wrote him and Ledger portrayed him. Ledger IS the Joker just as much as Reeves was Superman. This is not up for debate. Thank you.
Lil Bella #YungestCumeDumperOfTheCentery I'm not a big fan of the joker having a history of abuse and that's why he lost his mind. The better concept of Joker is he never had a moral compass and the ability to show and feel empathy his whole life.That is ledgers version. Think of little Michael Myers from Halloween, who murdered and showed no remorse. He was born without the ability to feel. A disfunction of the brain. That is ledgers version. Not phoenix's. That is why ledgers version is more menacing and a much bigger existential threat to gotham
U compared legend against legend??
That’s illegal
Im calling the police
I’m telling God
Srunheng Meng I’m telling God’s dad.
But... Apex Legends!
911
Heath ledgers joker will forever be unmatched. He’s performance was a our masterpiece it sad that he departed quickly 😔 longlive heath ledger
Let’s be honest. Joaquin made us understand the joker. And heath made us love the joker.
You cant compare them. They're completely different characters in a sense
Exactly. I do really love Heath's portrayal. But Joaquin's felt in my opinion more like an original screenplay rather than a comic book adaptation. That's why I think his portrayal and the movie will become a timeless classic that even non comic book fans will admire for years.
@@remdolf07 Health perfected the classic comic book psychopath. Phoenix is a completely fresh take on the character. The sense of realism he adds is not only an utterly terrifying wake up call to the effects society can have on different people, it's almost beautiful in a sense. They are such different characters and they should be loved in their own respects, but never compared.
@@jakobvaden7106 What do you mean, never compared? They're playing the same character!
Nah, Heath did such an amazing job, you can't follow him.
They could've told the same story but with another character. Call him Laugher instead.
A character like joker isn't supposed to be humanized. You're not supposed to know his name.
'Arthur', hahaha!
@@remdolf07 I'm non comic book fan and I still prefer Heath version
Yes I agree with u
I feel like you can’t really compare the two because in The Dark Knight, the Joker was already very much the Joker and has been insane for years already. But in Joker, it shows him as a somewhat normal person and his decent into madness. So they really are two different types of people...
Exactly, Phoenix's Joker needs time to grow hes onky been Joker for like a day lmao
Odin666 exactly bro
Odin666 I agree. I commented the same thing. This video dumb these two can’t be compared
Yes, for me both actors are equally good.
That actually is perfect. I considered watching Joker that Joaquin was more playing Arthur Fleck having a breakdown than watching THE JOKER being created.
Even comparing them for a second is a sin,they are so good
That pencil trick had me SHOOK when I first saw that movie 🤣🤣
Honestly I just loved Joaquin Phoenix acting in joker movie but there is no one that can replace Heath Ledger!
Heath Ledger was great but idk Joaquin killed that roll and the movie was just a origin, imagine him doing another movie only this time looking more like dc comic joker with a Batman in it
Icy Hot good point bro. Maybe joker part 2 will be a world difference and then we can REALLY compare the two guys
I feel the same.
did finex win a oscer npt close did FedEx win NO
No comparism heath ledger show the joker's real personality where Joaquin pheonix play the origin of joker . Where he shows the pain of a man who converted into joker at the last . So no comparism there roles are just different
I like how Phoenix didnt try to copy Ledger just made his own version of the Joker.
Edit: Thanks guys for the votes I wasn't expecting these many likes 😂👍
Why should Phoenix, the genius, try to copy a weird Joker version by Ledger ?
They did steal one of heath ledger’s line though.
@@jimmybopped1154 which one?
Unlike another dc movie. Even lex luthor tried impersonate joker in the movie.
@@josswandalov3552 weird joker??? U seriously here undermining ledgers joker? Ledger lived the character of joker on the big screen.
Phoenix is really good at joker
But
Ledger is something else I mean you can't imagine someone at his level
Heath - No fancy, Serious violence jokes, He literally treat Batman as a dog lmao.
Phoenix - Depressed, Goodguy, The victim.
they both great, just different script.
"Why did you bring a gun to a hospital?"
"Its part of my act"
amzn.to/30Vxe74
ok but like whats the point of saying movie quotes no one cares
Don't spoil
(I've already watched it but... Just don't)
It means that the character is more significant to our human comprehension and that is what's frightening to people. Violence will never seize if people do not give movies like these the reality check they deserve.
“It’s just a prop”
Joaquin’s joker made me just wanna give him a hug :( people can be so cruel.
Same
He also killed several people and started city wide riots killing even more
Same, it made me want to be more compassionate towards the mentally ill rather than treat them like shit
our world is full of sad people....
@@fishguise6818 wanna think of the reason why he did that, bud?
I love the most iconic Purple and green joker Combo. Miss you Heath Ledger 😭❤️
Ledger was, is and always will be the best Joker. His acting was so incredible , i didn’t notice it was heath playing the role.
Heath Ledger’s Joker was a total badass
Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker was phenomenal
So both versions of the Joker was amazing
But Ledger is just better.... from voice to laugh he IS better !!!
@@MrMrjack18 Ledger is better Joker, Phoenix is better Arthur xD
@@MrMrjack18 one can argue that Phoenix is better, he brought a new whole layer to the character.
Plus ledger was held back because of pg13.
@@drsoe08 Ofc you can have your own opinion.... but WatchMojo judged well in my opinion !
Ledger Is best joker, phoenix is best Arthur fleck
Thank you for stating this. I've read alot of comments. I don't think people understand that arthur fleck is simply a side story of the joker universe, he is not the original character.
My brain cant analyze
Yas🥺
Phoenix is the only Arthur fleck
No, Joaquin's better.
they are both absolute legends, and always will be.
The Joker Is the real winner here, having both of these Legends portray his character as well as Jack Nicholson goes to show what an amazing character he really was
They’re incomparable, they’re both great jokers in their own ways.
They really are uniquely amazing in their own ways!But Heath I think will never be topped , just perfection!
You can't judge them because they are from different time periods.
Exactly. there can be no comparison between them. Phoenix's Joker comes from an origin standpoint, realizing and embracing himself as the Joker and what he's capable of.. while Ledger's is a more evolved character of the Joker, one that has mastered that nature and pushing things to its limits in other to accomplish his purpose. If anything Phoenix's version complements Ledger's Joker. I like how the two of them played a real grounded version of the character.
Even...L-Leto...
One not really truly the Joker we know yet
Ledger's Joker made me enjoy the clown but Phoenix's Joker made me feel the clown's emotion and pain.
Yes, this right here 👆
That's because joker film is all about joker and dark knight wasn't about joker yet he nailed and overshadowed the batman, comparing and having these types of feelings don't make any sense.
eating sugar no papa that’s not at all what he was talking about😂nobody asked
This is the reason why Heath's is better imo. I feel like this new movie makes The Joker just like everyone else. They tell a sad story and make you feel bad for him and in a way "justifies" him. I never felt bad for Heath's Joker even when he told those weird fake stories about his past. I liked that with Heath and other Jokers we never needed to see this long build up of him being mistreated in order for us to understand him, but I still feel for him.
To me the best thing about The Joker was never knowing for sure who he is or where he keeps from and hes crazy just because.
eating sugar no papa Pheonix is my joker from now on.
In the character of the 'Joker'
-Joaquin Phoenix= 10/10
-Heath Leader= Infinity/10
When you thought no one can come to the level of heath ledger as joker then we have joaquin phoenix who is on the same par as ledger. Both incredible.
*Mark Hamill* - Best cartoon joker
*Heath Ledger* - Best Joker in his prime
*Joaquin Phoenix* - Best Joker Origin Story
*Jared Leto* - Best Joker without the *"R"*
Lee D Sin the best joker origin was Cameron monaghey
Lee D Sin you forgot Jack Nicholson- Best comic representation joker
@@Bigpoppapump24 THANK YOU! Ive waited along time for someone to acknowledge Cameron Monaghey's performace as Jeremiah from Gotham. no offense to Joaquin Phoenix but Jereiah's is the true Joker orgin
Can we just say that Jack Nicholson, Heath Ledger, Cameron Monaghan, Joaquin Pheonix - good jokers
+Ondřej Machovský
Cesar Romero was fantastic, too. He played Joker in the "Batman" television series from the 1960s! For real, check him out. The perfect Joker comic book representation from that time period. :)
i was petrified of Joaquin phoenix's joker
and I was in awe of heath ledger's joker.
Period. Both cannot be compared
I actually we can
The joker as a joker in the joaquin phoenix wasnt perfect
We never got to see the prime of joker we just saw the origin so we obviously cant tell what the new joker could do in a stand up story that is not an origin
Also even if the performance i beleive that Joaquin phoenix was the best.if you have seen jack Nicholson act in " the shining" you can understanf what im telling
But heath ledger is better because of the mastermind he was
In the new joker we only got to see his inner self and pathetic side
@@hq3802 Well it wasn't really the origin. It's a stand alone film, not DC
@@silloweet im talking about a movie that joker is arleady a set up
Like dark night
Insted of watching him act like joker from the first 30 minutes
Heath Ledger wasn't the best joker, he was THE JOKER
JOKER : "I'm like a dog chasing cars I wouldn't know what to do with one if I actually caught it (dramatic pause) I just do things."
Perfect description of a dog
Phoenix’s Joker has two laughs. His laugh when he’s stressed out and his laugh when he’s trying to fit in with society. You’ll notice he only does that high pitch laugh in situations where he’s forcing himself to fit in.
Yup, exactly
He has 3 laughs . His laugh when he stresses out (his condition), the fake laugh when hes tryin to fit in with society, and his last laugh at the Arkham asylum, which is his true laugh, as he's played his final joke
The biggest difference is that Ledgers Joker created chaos and Phoenix Joker was created by chaos.
I personally think both did an amazing job! We shouldn't make a competition!
Fuchs I agree there both great in there own way
@Secure the Bag Heath Ledgers Joker is not like the Joker in most comics.
Well said
I think it's good they both have a different spin on the character, if phoenix copied ledger then that's all people would be saying. I think tbge both were excellent. 👍
Score Magnet heaths joker is exactly like the joker go read the first issue of Batman and you’ll see that there the same, I understand what you mean by most comics as in late 70s and early/mid 80s comics but those were during the campy times whilst before that joker was more evil and realistic
Crazy how Joaquin really took on this project and delivered
Both killed it
Ledger's joker is extremely intelligent. He is totally in control of his emotions. Phoenix's joker is emotionally traumatised. He is totally consumed by his trauma. As an adversary, he is just one step away from committing suicide or making a fatal error. Ledger's joker is an invincible enemy. Phoenix's joker is an extremely dangerous one.
Couldn't agree more with this assessment.
@Josef Jackson Right. But if one has to disagree for the sake of disagreement, I can say that Phoenix's Joker is not to be under-estimated. Anybody who does not have to think twice before killing another man is an extremely dangerous enemy. On a scale of difficulty, his Joker is probably 6.5/10 while Ledger's Joker is 9.75/10.
It makes you wonder though how Ledger's Joker got good at planning and scheming, and even though Pheonix's Joker may not be good at it he does have an army, I wonder if there will be a movie about the in-between part.
While Phoenix’s joker has an army, what good is that without the brains to control it? Ledger’s joker would know precisely what to do with that army and how to command them. I mean Ledger’s joker bought out the two most trusted detectives going against him before he even made his first move. I literally rewatched both of them tonight and Ledger’s joker had me on edge still to this day. Not to diminish how good Phoenix was, but the joker isn’t even supposed to understand himself. From the moment he was made as a character he had no back story for a reason. With that being said one of my favorite lines of the joker is “if I have to have a past, I’d prefer it to be multiple choice”. And Ledger hit the nail directly on the head, and that’s more of a critique perspective.
@@senpai_sake3276 Ledger's Joker was a genius at work. Phoenix's Joker is an emotionally distraught man bumping off everyone who is awful with him.
Apples and oranges, they are different Joker storylines.
If i may, Joaquin's is a failed adult with mental issues who just happens to have a laughter tick he cant control..a victim of mommys own mental instability...NOTHING TO DO W THE JOKER
Raul Rodriguez no? Joker was born joker? he doesnt have a story? do you think he had a “normal” life and suddenly he said, “know what, might as well become an insane killer”. You can see the craziness, the insanity building up, with joaquin’s acting, at the end he starts to kill and doesnt even care abou it, everyone thinks he is a symbol, he is the king of gotham, you think a mentally ill, insane, killer, someone who lost everything, and is loved by others doesnt have anything to do with joker? HAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
@@shinsokudev9823 Joaquin's character had nothing...grew up with abuse both physical and physiological as well as his own mental disorders...a "tick" that makeshim laugh is not sufficient...a total failur in kife does not become a mastermind or inspire one!
@Let's put a smile on that face Dont add me to the crowd ..there is no comparison.
JOAQUIN'S IS NOT THE JOKER!! AGAIN THE CHARACTER WAS BRILLIANTLY PLAYED AND WORTHY FOR ANOSCAR NOMINATION..BUT HE IS NOT THE JOKER NOR WILL HE BECOME/INSPIRE ANYONE TO BECOME THE JOKER..
@Let's put a smile on that face No Sir, i actually prefer Jack Nicholson version...
OmG, both did an amazing job but I'm just so mesmerized by Heath Ledger's performance 😍
I seriously can’t decide. Both amazing performances. It really is just a preference in the end. Like which written joker character you like more but the acting were on a same level imo
“When most people imagine Jokers laugh, they think Mark Hamil.”
Proceeds to use the worse example of his laugh
Hamill is a crappy cartoon.
I was going to post this very thing!
Brian Smith hamill is literally the best joker
@@SickVapeTricks Not even close. 😀
@@briansmith7845 He's playing a live action version in the Arrowverse crossover, so he won't be a 'crappy cartoon' for much longer...
"his scheming and voice didn't seem like the joker"
Because he wasn't the joker until the last 10 minutes.
Still didn’t seem like the joker
@@KingSukuna Thats why I havent seen it yet. It doesnt feel like Joker. Heath literally defined how Joker should have been and thats a tough mold to break. Totally unhinged.
@@picallo1 you should see it, it shows his decent into madness. It left me thinking would I have reacted the same way he did? And I answered yes in some ways more then others
Stan and so your opinion is invalid and biased. The movie is how he becomes joker. Simple as that. It is a masterpiece. Both ledger and phoenix played the part perfectly and comparing them is impossible. Which is why this video is complete and utter horseshit.
@hku505 the day will not come anytime
Without heath ledger we wouldn't get a solo joker movie, so...
It’s like Joaquin’s joker is just starting out, just finding out who and what he is. He’s trying to learn how to live with himself and slowly starts to come out of his shell. By the end he’s let it all out for the world to see. Ledger’s joker on the other hand seems like he’s been the joker for a while and he’s comfortable in his own skin. He’s already gone through the “I’m crazy and I’m learning to be ok with it” phase, and is on to the “take over the world” mentality. That’s why the world already knows him and fears him in the dark night. Joaquin’s joker is just the origin story that’s why he had beef with Batman’s dad.🤯🤯🤯
“This is what happens when an unstoppable force, meets an immovable object.”
both were great.
Gilbert Cobos right, I’m glad they didn’t try to go after a previous style of Joker, every time they let an actor have the freedom to show us their version of Joker we get magic
True! No need to compare both since they have different versions. Heath Joker is a criminal mastermind with dark humor while Joaquin's joker is a complete schizophrenic clown killer. But one thing is for sure both actor are great and it would be nice if Joaquin wins an oscar for his joker portrayal. That would be win win for both jokers
The fact that we’re even debating this just shows how amazing J Phoenix’s performance was
Not really. They always compare good or bad.
@@tevo1192 Did anyone even dare to compare Jared leto's Joker to heath's?
@@kouroshrm7 YES!!! Funny that you're on UA-cam to look that up how fortunate.
Hypotheticals Are Pointless still irrelevant as what you have think dummy.
@@davodxsuperstar Triggered are we😂😂😂 (Joker laugh)
Phoenix's Joker - Destroyed by the *society*
Ledger's Joker - Destroys the *society*
Can we pls stop comparing them? They both made their own version of the Joker and they both did a brilliant job.
I can't believe that they made two perfect versions of the same character
Now we need the third and the final version of the Joker
But I think its more like how it begins and how it will become
I am sure if there are 2-3 squeal Pheonix will come closer to Heath
Nope.. this Joker is a moron. How could he possibly cause any problems for Batman?
@@jd0604 lol
They're two different moments in Joker's life. While I don't see Arthur becoming Ledger's Joker in the future, one has to remember he's a sane human being until about half of the movie. Ledger's Joker has probably lived for years in his own maniacal way and is therefore a more complete Joker and less fleshed out Arthur, if that's his real name in the Dark Knight trilogy.
Rest in peace Heath Ledger 🙏😔 I wish you were able to see your iconic performance as the clown prince of crime
Jaoquin’s Joker gave me the creeps. Heath’s Joker gave me the chills.
This many people think Jared letto joker was the worst
👇🏽
If only he got the attention they got
we don't think Leto is the worst joker. we know he is
And u r an asshole
Jared Leto was not terrible. The Joker was just terribly written in Squicide Squad
Terrible indeed... not the actor to blame nevertheless.
*Phoenix Joker:* Is it me or is it getting crazy out there?
*Ledger Joker:* Why so serious?
Leto : Ha..Ha..Ha..
Ledger & Phoenix : Dude...
It triggers me when someone misspells Phoenix with Pheonix :(
Suryansh Sinha
It’s a bad joke.
Mr. Divergent “You wouldn’t get it”
Mr @@g05s26 "and i thought my jokes were bad"
Both Are Legend!!! ♥️
Joker(2019) seemed like a prequel to the The Dark Knight. Put the two movies together and you will get one big story of how a joker transforms into a joker and then runs into Batman.
Absolutely no...
Dark Knight Joker exists because Batman exists... And the past is uncertain and this make Joker much more impredictable and terrifying...
Joker 2019: exists because he was bullied... 🙌🙌😂😂