Broadchurch | Broken

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 30

  • @hurricanedrunk
    @hurricanedrunk 7 років тому +2

    honestly hun, i keep rewatching this and i am in complete awe. you got out of your comfort zone - which takes actual balls, imo, even and especially when it comes to editing - and created /this/ and I feel beyond grateful, as a fan of the show but most of all as a woman. because this video is not only a tribute to an outstanding final season but mostly it's a video about women. there's so much raw emotion pouring out from this. i feel them all and it devastates me. the simple editing and the voiceovers you chose (and used perfectly) just heightened the emotional weight of this even more.
    at the beginning you see the shock, with hardy/miller's questions overlaying themselves + the cut-to-blacks.. it feels like you're actually /her/, like you're in her head trying to process the horror of what happened.
    then it comes the pain, when she gets down to that spot and relives the nightmare then jumps to when she opens her eyes in her own home. and the following section with the fear, and the self-blaming, and the shame, which might feel almost absurd as women are the victims. they didn't cause it, no matter how much you had to drink or how short your skirt was or how pretty you are or how many men did you slept with the previous week.
    finally, the disgust, because "men" like those - who think the same, horrifying, sickening stuff - actually exist in real life. men who show no shame over what they did. men who don't think they're guilty of a crime, a crime which has a name that is rape and should be addressed like it.
    like i already told, you you handled this sensitive topic incredibly and i dare any woman or man who comes across this video - no matter if they're familiar with the show or not - not to be moved by it.
    (this track is aWFUL I HATE YOU)

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      Vale, you absolutely hit every point I was trying to make in this video, your comments always floor me and I do not feel worthy at all. I am but a mere editor trying to show how much this show and its handling of the topic moved me and I'm just happy the points I wanted to highlighted have been picked up. I'm just gonna go cry now over this comment

  • @pradadevil15
    @pradadevil15 7 років тому +1

    wow... just wow. sitting here with tears in my eyes, this was so powerful and moving. have never watched this show but just by watching this (phenomenal) video i feel like i can tell that they handled this so well, rarely any tv shows do. thank you so much for making this video, its so important.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      thank you SO much for your lovely comment, I'm so happy people can see what I tried to show in this video since the show did such an amazing job of showing the topic in the first place, blown away by everyone's comments tbh, thank you so much for the love

  • @xLiesForALiar
    @xLiesForALiar 7 років тому

    this was so powerful, i'm speechless. i don't watch this show but this has such a universal and important message that goes beyond any tv show. wow. i really don't know what else to say. the shots you chose, how you really just used the scenes and voiceovers to propel this without any elaborate editing, i'm just in awe. you handled this topic so incredibly well, this is the type of video that everyone could watch, should watch, because it's just so powerful and important.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      Oh wow, that was my aim for this video, for anyone to appreciate the message that this show so sensitively showed and how it is SO important and relevant, I'm honestly floored by this comment from you, thank you SO much for your ever so kind words and I'm happy that you think I handled this topic appropriately because that was my biggest fear with posting this

  • @Hanneybean7
    @Hanneybean7 7 років тому +1

    that was incredibleI am just sitting here with tears streaming down my faceyou simultaneously make the video feel personal to the characters, highlighting their own experience and emotion, while also invited the viewers to examine how horrific and brutal it is/was. just incredible, literally, I don't know if i'll be able to watch again anytime soon though.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      omg i know you don't even watch this show Hannah so I'm glad you felt what I was trying to show and I don't blame you, it's a very heavy topic.

  • @aainsworld
    @aainsworld 7 років тому

    Oh my god this was truly heartbreaking. I don't even knowwhat to say, but it's like you can feel the angst through your editing while it's truly beautiful portrayed. Incredible tribute to the season and, specially, women.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  6 років тому

      my youtube is being glitchy and i have missed so many comments including this one, thank you for this comment, i was very nervous about this video especially considering the topic at hand and I'm so glad people have responded fine to it

  • @alialthea
    @alialthea 7 років тому +1

    I have not seen this season yet but I had to watch this. This show has always had incredible cinematography but it's so complex and heavy that I never even dared to think about vidding it but YOU FAAYZA!!!! YOU HAVE DONE IT, AND MARVELLOUSLY AT THAT. You've taken advantage of that cinematography to tell such a heartbreaking, heavy but necessary story. I just really loved the fact that you focused on how the victims are perceived in these cases. I am now even more excited to watch the show because of your incredible editing. I just can't take you went for this and did it so gracefully. You never let us down, no matter the fandom/topic you tackle.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому +1

      Hermy483 alicia oh god you're gonna love the final season it was just perfect. Your comments always mean so much to me and I never thought I'd ever be able to tackle a video for this wonderful show and do it justice it deserves but I'm so happy you felt what I was trying to show here. Love you babe ❤❤❤

    • @alialthea
      @alialthea 7 років тому +1

      don't be silly Faayza YOU DESERVE IT!!! Btw I'm watching episode three right now and it's insanely good, I had missed miller and hardy so much!!

  • @Ilovehertjes
    @Ilovehertjes 7 років тому

    I don't even know what to say right now. I have chills. This video is just so phenomenal. This season has been hard to watch because they chose such a difficult topic, but they handled it so well. And you showed that perfectly. The way you used their beautiful cinematography, how well everything was matched to the song, how beautifully and respectfully you showed Trish's story, just everything about this video is perfect. It's a true masterpiece. Saying that you did an amazing job doesn't even fully cover it, so just know that you have created true art with this video.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  6 років тому

      why tf did i not reply to this wonderful comment??? I know it's nine months late but ugh you always leave wonderful comments and you always get the vibe and themes of my videos and this one was particularly delicate in trying to edit, thank you again anouk

  • @witchorking
    @witchorking 7 років тому

    WELL OK FIRST OF ALL I'M HONESTLY CRYING AND IT DOESN'T HAPPEN VERY OFTEN WHEN I WATCH VIDEOS BUT YES I'M A FUCKING MESS. i haven't seen this show yet and i have no idea what it's about BUT you made me feel everything for these characters and god it hurts. the quotes you used, the ending, "it's only sex"... I'M HEARTBROKEN. and let me just say that i really think that this is your best video yet, you're AMAZING at voice overs and using the cinematography correctly and the sONG oh my god and ok i'm just rambling but i can't express enough how much i loved this

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      witchorking EMMMAAAAA IM CRYING!!!! ily so much, I'm so happy that people who haven't watched the show are still able to appreciate what I'm trying to show in this. Also, you should totally watch this show, amazing acting and storylines (especially 1st and 3rd season which is the one I've vidded here) and BEAUTIFUL CINEMATOGRAPHY AKA OUR WEAKNESS!!!!
      Also, as you are the queen of voiceovers, to get this comment from you is honestly the highest honour and praise, love you lots ❤❤❤

  • @brionyx509
    @brionyx509 4 роки тому

    The show handled this whole season with such care and compassion, and your vid embodies this approach through and through.

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  4 роки тому

      BRO!!!! UA-cam didn’t tell me you had commented so RUDE, thank you so much and I’m glad you felt I treated it with care, it was very stressful making sure I didn’t overstep

  • @karokaro34
    @karokaro34 7 років тому

    This season broke me into million pieces, and so did this video, amazing work. And i agree with everything you said, this show dealt with such a hard subject as rape so well, I don't think a show made me sob as loud as Broadchurch did, specially on the first episode and the last. I am gonna miss this brilliant show a lot

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      Thank you for your ever so kind words, I agree, this show did such an outstanding job with dealing with such a sensitive topic and I hope I handled it just as sensitively as well in this! Thank you again

  • @MBelly2703
    @MBelly2703 7 років тому

    OH MY GOD THIS IS AMAZING !!! you really captured the perfect way the show dealt with sexual assault and the various aspect of it. This is so heartbreaking, and genuine I'm in awe

  • @Akatra
    @Akatra 7 років тому +2

    I didn't comment this one, but I saw it and it's so beautiful, and sad. I'm chocked. I wasn't prepared. I feel pain :'(

  • @55i5val
    @55i5val 6 років тому

    Я вырезала аудио дорожку и уже миллион раз переслушиваю её ❤️

  • @boredsleepycranky
    @boredsleepycranky 7 років тому +1

    i' m in so much pain right now.

  • @gaby0189x
    @gaby0189x 7 років тому +1

    I really, really need to catch up. I only ever watched season 1 when it aired and I know each season tackles different topics (correct right?) so its not like its continuous but my god if this show progressed even more than season 1 I can't even imagine its brilliance. So until I do I shall DEF be back faayza!

    • @cynicalromantic261
      @cynicalromantic261  7 років тому

      Yeah the second season was a bit of a continuation of first one but this one was totally different and just so amazing, can't wait for you to catch up!

  • @amyjones6329
    @amyjones6329 6 років тому

    2:45 the episode please x

  • @amyjones6329
    @amyjones6329 6 років тому

    3:21 episode x