I don t think this is concludent because of the temperature of the oil. You have to be close to the temperature that the engine will run. At this temperature you ll run only for a few seconds. Thats it. Just an opinion . Please share your toughts
From personal experience, I have felt Motul operate smoother than liqui moly. I did use the 5W-40 variant because the vehicle used is a German automobile, Mercedes Benz CLA 250. Both lubricants work very well and are worth the money. Can't wait to see where this series goes. I personally love Valvoline but the competition is only getting more fierce. Thank you for these oil test.
Hey friend. I have skoda octavia 1.9tdi diesel 2006 clocked 1 lac kms on odo. I recently used mobil1 0w40 fully synthetic has vw 502 and 505 approvals. Its good oil. But 5w40 is recommended .so can you please tell me which 5w40 vw 505 01 is best brand for skoda 1.9tdi diesel? Thank you bro
Stuck in houston traffic. Motul semi synthetic oil cut my engine heat in half on my Yamaha FJ1200 air and oil cooled motorcycle. My engine on Castrol would heat up and shut the engine off. And I was stranded in traffic. Motel it never shut off.
Lasst euch nicht von diesen Ergebnissen täuschen. Die Timkenmaschiene wird für Wälzlagerfette verwendet, dabei wirken andere Kräfte wie im Motor, da noch andere Faktoren im Motor-Öl entscheidend sind, hat dieser Test keine Aussagekraft.
Interesting comparo. Thanks for posting. Suggestion: for the flow test, a better experiment to rule out cap orifice differences (don't assume they are identical) would be to swap containers and run the test again.
Why did you use the VW Specific Motul oil over a xclean or xgen of the same weight? just a bit curious as the LiquidMoly one was a multi vehicle oil from what I can see
You should include cold pour tests (below zero Fahrenheit) & also how much burns off when heated super hot. Living in Chicago we had a -59 day this past winter so cold performance is huge to me.
@@ANDREWSAMY562 My Stock 2011 WRX with 75k miles uses not a drop of oil, Oil doesn't evaporate, it get's burn't. One of the side effects if your piston rings are wornout because the owners didn't do frequent enough oil changes, or the vehicle was modified. The main reason I keep mine stock.
Test oils on high temps... Thats trick, not test. I ve seen oils in room temps to be much worst after been heated due to enginge stress. LM is very good but Motul is much better...
Hi, i have used moly 5w 40 to my accord cl7 06, and i changed it to motul 2100 eco. Does this motul 2100 eco good enoght? Or better change it to moly 5w 40? Another question, does the castrol 5w 40 edge better than moly and motur. Thank you.
Motul eco is their entry stuff/ or cheaper. Better go for motul x-cress since it could handle better in high heat and it’s their fancier stuff. I wanna see a heat stress test on motul and pennzoil platinum 😬
Stay away from anything that has eco in its name if you want good performance. Motul 2100 eco is their entry level oil and maybe its good for its price but definitely not a good oil that would protect your engine
Hi sir I am from India . I have 160 cc 4 stroke bike modified so my company recommended oil grade is 10w30 so wich will be better motul 7100 10w40 or liquimolly ?? Wat is drain interval of motul 7100 ?
Take two same brand cars .. Sponsor ur oil to them .. Let them drive for 10k kms .. Let them share the drive experience. Fuel average, How's the oil condition after removing, lastly cost !! If oil companies print their additive on the oil can surely I can stir and make my own coffee better !! 😎
The Bearing scar test has absolutely NO correlation with internal engine wear and is an invalid test for wear protection in a motor oil. Once the bearing is scarred the oil has failed. So, the load being applied is excessive for the material under test and not relate-able to components in a modern engine. You viscosity test just shows which lubricant has a lower viscosity at the tested temperature. Some engine would respond to less and other to a greater viscosity - so there would be no clear winner here. I see someone trying to model his channel after another successful huckster on the Tube and ring the cash register. I wish you good fortune nonetheless.
@@WISHBONEL7 European oil must meet the Manufacturer's Approval Like: Porsche A40 , VW508 or MB 229.51 or BMW LL01. That means it already meets a high Standard Nothing much YOU can do other than run the oil in your vehicle and monitor Fuel mileage, engine noise and consistent power production from low end pull to high RPM passing power. You can also have a lab run a Used Oil Analysis like CAT or Blackstone but that will cost 30-40 bucks. Cheers! - Sandy
@@sandyshoremann7524 - I have had the oil specimen done on semis before . However , is there a test that will show how an oil does in regards to friction ?.
Fake video 1,35 runs oil together...and 1,36 the oils big difference just 1 second.. 1,35-1,36 look the video stop and start again..Redline and amsoil the best oil ever..I have 20vt engine on my car and 670 ps the mystake is change oil ever 5000-7000km and your car run for much years..
Don't use Imperial measurements! All chemistry tests are done in SI units. For weight use Grams! Oz is cumbersome! Why bother with hundredths of an Oz when you can use whole numbers for grams!
Im sorry the camera doesn't jump its changing angle while the test is going but the camera never stops or there would be a edit. It doesn't matter to me which one wins. I really appreciate you sharing your thoughts, thank you.
You forgot that temperature plays a big role. Also, contact of oil with the fuel and how it behaves under pressure. This test is for elementary school physics class.
Test only on how fast u can drink oil :D. This test says nothing. U should test it in -30C and then on +100C all the frictions, and most important is to test how strong is oil's skin during the friction.
Because all the tests have nothing to do with the actual processes inside a combustion engine. It's nonsense. And people still belive in this, while engineers are laughing...
I Love how he cuts the vid in some significant moments of the comparison 😂 1:33 cuts the vid all of a sudden LM on the lead. 8:26 weighs the LM bearing without showing the abrasion and cuts the vid again before putting in the scale. Label the bearings before the test and dont cut vids for keen doubters like me.
These experiments are completely ridiculous since the conditions in the car engine and what you are doing - have nothing to do with each other. I suggest in the next experiment to fry fish. From an airline pilot.
I saw on other channel amsoil won while motul n liquid moly did not make to the final. There is another channel showed that motul beat liquid moly. Who knows.
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO Hi... yes If you can! I find ur videos very helpful. Trying to decide what is the best 5w-40 for a Volkswagen. Been using valvoline mst 5w-40, and thinking about switching to moly molygen 5w-40
More information liqui moly & motul
Click the link below.
amzn.to/2PobRaE
Please test Mag1 thanks
Toptec 4200 very clean oil
Heat the oil and redo tests. How does it perform after operating temperature is reached
I don t think this is concludent because of the temperature of the oil. You have to be close to the temperature that the engine will run. At this temperature you ll run only for a few seconds. Thats it. Just an opinion . Please share your toughts
I personally love Motul 8100 series. In my Suzuki Van, engine runs absolutely smoother with very less noise.
Motul for BMW feel better , hope we can do more test to find out the reality
From personal experience, I have felt Motul operate smoother than liqui moly. I did use the 5W-40 variant because the vehicle used is a German automobile, Mercedes Benz CLA 250. Both lubricants work very well and are worth the money. Can't wait to see where this series goes. I personally love Valvoline but the competition is only getting more fierce. Thank you for these oil test.
I appreciate your time and information also valvoline has a lab in Kentucky so i have gathered much information and for sure its quality
NATES INTERACTIVE AUTO Valvoline 0w20 synthetic is garbage. I tested it. In Kentucky they make better moonshine. 👍
Hey friend. I have skoda octavia 1.9tdi diesel 2006 clocked 1 lac kms on odo. I recently used mobil1 0w40 fully synthetic has vw 502 and 505 approvals. Its good oil. But 5w40 is recommended .so can you please tell me which 5w40 vw 505 01 is best brand for skoda 1.9tdi diesel?
Thank you bro
Thanks for watching check out our tests
Liqui moly is the best oil I've known since I saw what was the effects to the cars and motorcycles riders.
I use it in my subaru outback 3.6 doesn't burn a drop and oil stays clean during the 5000km intervals I do. I also drive like I stole it
How can oil have any effect on car drivers or motorcycle riders.? 🤔
@@thedonn138 psychological effect
LIQUI MOLLY= Meguin germany😂😂😂...in Germany Best oil ist Meguin
Liqui moly is the best oil among all types...i used for 17 years ago till now no any problems...and i will never try any oil yet
Go to 🖐💣
17 years is too old, i think its time change the oil.
I
Liquid Moly is great oil.. for sure❤❤🎉🎉🎉
Stuck in houston traffic.
Motul semi synthetic oil cut my engine heat in half on my Yamaha FJ1200 air and oil cooled motorcycle.
My engine on Castrol would heat up and shut the engine off. And I was stranded in traffic. Motel it never shut off.
Silly test. You are doing these tests at room temperature. Your oil runs at close to 100 degrees C.
Shear strength test is very important. The heat affects are nil if shear measures up.
Lasst euch nicht von diesen Ergebnissen täuschen. Die Timkenmaschiene wird für Wälzlagerfette verwendet, dabei wirken andere Kräfte wie im Motor, da noch andere Faktoren im Motor-Öl entscheidend sind, hat dieser Test keine Aussagekraft.
I was waiting for this one to be done. Can’t wait for the final results. Great job!
Hey i really appreciate your time i will work towards making the test better.
Is it possible to mix liqui moly 5w30 4600 top tec with Motul 5w30 x clean efe and put it in the vehicle?
NO
Interesting comparo. Thanks for posting. Suggestion: for the flow test, a better experiment to rule out cap orifice differences (don't assume they are identical) would be to swap containers and run the test again.
Why did you use the VW Specific Motul oil over a xclean or xgen of the same weight? just a bit curious as the LiquidMoly one was a multi vehicle oil from what I can see
Correct note.
You should include cold pour tests (below zero Fahrenheit) & also how much burns off when heated super hot. Living in Chicago we had a -59 day this past winter so cold performance is huge to me.
Absolutely we will do just that
-59 ? Isn't It like Alaska temperatures ?
Definitely hardcore
People don’t realize how cold it gets in Chicago. Lake Michigan’s winds drive down temps.
I cant begin to imagine
thx for the test, I will always go with liqui molly
Thank you for your time i will try to improve our test.
U wanna see something impressive? See bestline oil additive. I'very been using it with liquimolly. Super great results on used oil at 30000km.
Sound like another great test
Soon
@@mihaeladumitru9480 You engine cry
I’ve used motul x-cess 5w40 on my wrx heavily modified been running it for about 50k miles now no issues love it
Subaru's are known for using/evaporating oil between changes, can I know how much oil u added between changes?
@@ANDREWSAMY562 My Stock 2011 WRX with 75k miles uses not a drop of oil, Oil doesn't evaporate, it get's burn't. One of the side effects if your piston rings are wornout because the owners didn't do frequent enough oil changes, or the vehicle was modified. The main reason I keep mine stock.
Doesn’t matter what oil you use in that engine. It’s gonna blow. Even a prayer won’t help.
Test russian vodka, please!
taste beluga
Gray goose
Что уж там, давай сразу боярышник
Hahaha.
Yes test Russian vodka..... Lol
Guys it’s so simple.. when liqui moly is not available.. go for motul. Game over 💯🔥😎
Thx for the video.
I'm looking forward to watch the result of Mobil1 vs. Liqui Moly. 😉
Might be interesting to see how these oils compare after a couple thousand miles in the crankcase.
Hey nate, what oil do you use in your vehicles?
Test oils on high temps... Thats trick, not test. I ve seen oils in room temps to be much worst after been heated due to enginge stress. LM is very good but Motul is much better...
How about when the oil get 210 F and up, that cause wears when oil loose the viscosity on hot engine
Have you ever tested Amsoil?
Can you do liquid moly vs amdoil european test?
Castrol can never be better then pensoil! Penzoil ultra platinum and AMS oil are the best in the Business ..
Hi there! in theory the motul specific was made for the vag group fulfills everything ... right?
The Motul in this video meets all VW specs yes
95% of VAG engines.
Test Shell Helix Ultra C2/C3 against some other VW 504/507 oils, please.
Which one is better?
when changing the chamber, in 3 oz the oil levels are different - min 1:34
Hi, i have used moly 5w 40 to my accord cl7 06, and i changed it to motul 2100 eco.
Does this motul 2100 eco good enoght? Or better change it to moly 5w 40? Another question, does the castrol 5w 40 edge better than moly and motur. Thank you.
Motul eco is their entry stuff/ or cheaper. Better go for motul x-cress since it could handle better in high heat and it’s their fancier stuff. I wanna see a heat stress test on motul and pennzoil platinum 😬
Stay away from anything that has eco in its name if you want good performance. Motul 2100 eco is their entry level oil and maybe its good for its price but definitely not a good oil that would protect your engine
Flow test is pretty genius. Should test them under freezing temps using that same method
Yes great idea we will
And dont cut the vid 😂
What the result I don't understand English can you please answer me how is the best
Could. you do a test with Pensoil Ultra platinum too please. This is an oil I've had great results from. Thanks
Yes i have used pennzoil ultra platinum check out the video.
Did you ever do the LiquiMoly Vs Redline test?
Hey Nate.
Which oil is good for skoda octavia 1.9tdi diesel 2006? Please suggest .
bro try amsoil the best one
Thank you brother.
I will try Amsoil Europian car formula 5w40 . How was your experiance? Previously i was using mobil1 0w40
which good of oil for corolla s 2013 i live in lebanon 115000 kn ?
How about Dura Lube ?
NICE TRY, BUT THE WEAR AND TEAR TEST SHOULD BE DONE WHEN THE OIL IS HOT LIKE RUNNING IN THE ENGINE.
Mobil 1 esp 5w30 made in France is my go to for 504.00 507.00 approval
The scew that holds bearing in place ... is that really keeping it accurately in place...
nazi
Raxol 5w30?
how about top 1 oil and lucas oil?
can you make a video ty
Hi sir I am from India . I have 160 cc 4 stroke bike modified so my company recommended oil grade is 10w30 so wich will be better motul 7100 10w40 or liquimolly ?? Wat is drain interval of motul 7100 ?
Follow manufacturer's instructions and check out my video on both oil motul vs liqui moly
liquid moly mologen is a really good oil for 31.88--for 5 liters--easy 5000 mile oil
liar 1:36 no difference from long distance and you cut the video oh after that moly wins
What is ols?
Take two same brand cars .. Sponsor ur oil to them .. Let them drive for 10k kms .. Let them share the drive experience. Fuel average, How's the oil condition after removing, lastly cost !! If oil companies print their additive on the oil can surely I can stir and make my own coffee better !! 😎
I’d say you failed the pour test right out of the gate ;)
So how do we know you are being honest?
look between 1.31 and 1.36 with 0.25 speed,and you'll have your answer! here's a clue....3oz!
Enjoyed the test. I would have chosen wrong. Thought Motul would have done better.
I thought they did well
That's entry lvl motul oil grade vs a top grade liqui moly diesel engine oil. Im surprised it was that close tbh.
Liquimolly is good but MUCH more expansive than Motul
Isn't a valid test because you can change the force applied on bearing with screw between that arms.
Absolutely not true
The Bearing scar test has absolutely NO correlation with internal engine wear and is an invalid test for wear protection in a motor oil. Once the bearing is scarred the oil has failed. So, the load being applied is excessive for the material under test and not relate-able to components in a modern engine. You viscosity test just shows which lubricant has a lower viscosity at the tested temperature. Some engine would respond to less and other to a greater viscosity - so there would be no clear winner here. I see someone trying to model his channel after another successful huckster on the Tube and ring the cash register. I wish you good fortune nonetheless.
What would be some good test to show how good an oil is ?? .
@@WISHBONEL7 European oil must meet the Manufacturer's Approval Like: Porsche A40 , VW508 or MB 229.51 or BMW LL01. That means it already meets a high Standard Nothing much YOU can do other than run the oil in your vehicle and monitor Fuel mileage, engine noise and consistent power production from low end pull to high RPM passing power. You can also have a lab run a Used Oil Analysis like CAT or Blackstone but that will cost 30-40 bucks. Cheers! - Sandy
@@sandyshoremann7524 - I have had the oil specimen done on semis before . However , is there a test that will show how an oil does in regards to friction ?.
@@WISHBONEL7the Astm 4 ball wear test, industry standard!
Who won?
What is the name of this device?
Who won the test?
Joe
I'll say you do a good job of explaining
Fake video 1,35 runs oil together...and 1,36 the oils big difference just 1 second.. 1,35-1,36 look the video stop and start again..Redline and amsoil the best oil ever..I have 20vt engine on my car and 670 ps the mystake is change oil ever 5000-7000km and your car run for much years..
Диктор как будто пятку дунул перед началом видео
Пацан с Техаса, ето нормально)
8100 X-clean+ 5W-30 is better than Specific 504 507 5W-30
Győző Győry why is that? proof source ?
VW Dieselben használod? Aktuális nekem is az olajcsere, ha jobb az X-clean+ neki, akkor azt veszek inkább.
@@peterlevai3449 nem dízelbe, de abba is ugyan úgy jó.
Én csak ezt használom.
Which is best liqui moly or motul . In this video. Tell sir
You decide
penrite
Good suggestion
Don't use Imperial measurements! All chemistry tests are done in SI units. For weight use Grams! Oz is cumbersome! Why bother with hundredths of an Oz when you can use whole numbers for grams!
2016 Suzuki gsxr600 moly w10/40 very very nice 🏍⌚
Yea i used it on my z650 and zx10r and i love it
300v only for my bike
which is better
This is straight up lying.
Look at th3 viscosity test at 1.31 when camera jump
Im sorry the camera doesn't jump its changing angle while the test is going but the camera never stops or there would be a edit. It doesn't matter to me which one wins. I really appreciate you sharing your thoughts, thank you.
Love the vid it help me to pick my Pennzoil
Motul 300 v legendary Oil .Literally nectar for any Bikes .Liqy Moly has to brab Made in Germany sign
You forgot that temperature plays a big role. Also, contact of oil with the fuel and how it behaves under pressure. This test is for elementary school physics class.
moly very nice 👍 🏍⌚
Very interesting competition, when is the next match? Really looking forward to the next one.
In the next couple of days
I will work hard to improve just help me do so.
Liqui Moly Leichtlauf 5W40 please
Thanks for the suggestions vs what oil?
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO vs anyone you would like :)
Test only on how fast u can drink oil :D. This test says nothing. U should test it in -30C and then on +100C all the frictions, and most important is to test how strong is oil's skin during the friction.
Motul, perfect!
Pablo William Rosa not that good !
He said it correctly!
I saw another (italian) youtube video where Motul came as winner in this very same setup
Because all the tests have nothing to do with the actual processes inside a combustion engine. It's nonsense. And people still belive in this, while engineers are laughing...
A pour test shows flow ability also the wear test machine is legitimate.
Yes unfortunately some people can turn machines on and off by hand plus more
@@Tomelino What are good test to show how good an oil is ??.
@@WISHBONEL7 Put it inside your engine, drive it, do an oil analysis!? Avoiding hydrocrack oils in the first place ...
Motul 7100
20 w 50
Fully synthetic
Good idea whats another oil to try?
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO i used shell 15 w 50 it's not good
What do you recommend
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO I recommend Motul Fully synthetic 20 w 50
7100
Ok thanks for watching
Motul 300V is the best
I Love how he cuts the vid in some significant moments of the comparison 😂
1:33 cuts the vid all of a sudden LM on the lead.
8:26 weighs the LM bearing without showing the abrasion and cuts the vid again before putting in the scale.
Label the bearings before the test and dont cut vids for keen doubters like me.
Place your bets folks
Hi
Can you test the xado oil?
Yes thanks for the suggestions
Beee
Tear down a engine that both of these oils have been used...period..all these home made diy test ...a joke...
You're a joke
@@billyjunks lol....go get em...lawnmover man.....
These experiments are completely ridiculous since the conditions in the car engine and what you are doing - have nothing to do with each other. I suggest in the next experiment to fry fish. From an airline pilot.
There no brand called liqui Molly in Bangladesh my country .
I have to use motul
Absolutely but still very good quality
Liqui Moly available in Bangladesh, Mirpur 10, Autoplexbd shop e
@@beyondmiles2311 Online address plz....becz i can,t Find out in Comilla city
Malaysia pirgi lah bangla oii banyak minyak mecam2 jinis
Royal purple is best. Do the test send it to lab. Royal purple will come out superior
Pretty amazing you started this competition before some other you tuber and getting vastly different results from day one it seems
Yes i use timers and my machine was made for testing not made by myself.
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO I would recommend a cold test too just because a ton of us are up north
Very true thanks
I saw on other channel amsoil won while motul n liquid moly did not make to the final. There is another channel showed that motul beat liquid moly. Who knows.
Hay Joe your grandmother be much smarter from you
Who told you to do those scam test?
Liqui moly molygen 5w-40?
For a future test?
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO
Hi... yes If you can! I find ur videos very helpful. Trying to decide what is the best 5w-40 for a Volkswagen. Been using valvoline mst 5w-40, and thinking about switching to moly molygen 5w-40
Good luck and thanks i will provide any helpful information possible.
NATES INTERACTIVE AUTO please test LiquiMoly 0w40 Synthetic vs Motul 0w40 Max 8100 synthetic. I’m also interested in Amsoil 0w30 premium synthetic
Absolutely but who will win this tournament
your pour test is no good. Those end caps are restrictive to flow
Test mannol oils :)
You should have tested Motul 300V estercore...not the cheap motul
Нихуя не понял, но интересно !
Ааааа!!! Я орнул!!! С Вашего коммента!
такая же зуйня
На каком масле сколько миллиграмм металла ушло, то есть стерлось... ЛМ оказалось лучше, если я правильно понял.
ibrahim Ghudi не понятно. Может бочонки разной массы первоначально были? Надо взвешивать ДО и ПОСЛЕ и смотреть сколько грамм потерялось.
@@цукенголд-ц4и все верно
Hot oil test abrasion test ( like 90°C ) and cold oil abrasion test :)
Awesome
@@NATESINTERACTIVEAUTO I would try to have oil like to -20°C
amazing bro
Use totachi oil too
LIQUI MOLY THE BEST.. !
Great oil
can you compare mobil 1 5w30 vs mitasu platinum 5w30 please, thanks.
Thanks for the ideas
2 fantastic oils
Yes