I like the redesign, it's very interesting and 100% demonstrates the new concept you can up with. However, I feel like it's just too complex for a main character for SMG4, as the only original characters with designs similar to this are the villians, like Zero in his final form. Though of course in the case of a complete reboot, it wouldn't matter.
@@redmagnezone5295 that’s fair! Even I thought it was a little too much It’s just presenting an idea if Like and Kevin decide to go full reboot, as they have for some characters with retcons
No offense but personally I feel it would better if Luke and Kevin just simply let SMG4 go rather than to undergo a reboot, the design is good but it doesn't scream SMG4 to me.
I know a lot of people are coming in, so I would like to take this time and say thank you for the continued support and criticism, having these discussions on how to further improve my designs, content, and outreach with you all has been a pleasure that I cannot say enough. please watch my other videos if your anticipation for more is not sufficed, thank you.
This is a good idea and I like the design, but I feel like this kinda goes against what SMG4 is about. The simplicity. Well current SMG4 also kinda goes against that but you know what I mean.
@@Oceane1803 yeah I see what you mean, but unfortunately I just don’t think that’s a possible way as Glitch productions have already set their sights on ambitious projects, which allows merchandising, jobs, marketing Just how business goes, doesn’t mean it wouldn’t be bad though I get you
I do believe that sometime they will have to abandon all the nintendo characters, mario included. Or possibly give them all redesigns and change their personalities in some points. For some reason I see Luigi would don a business suit wearing shades, being the more financially focused brother, of course he would still have his fears. While I could see characters like bowser being transformed into a more human/reptile hybrid capable of taking different hybrid forms with special skills attached. Human/Turtle for Strength, Human/Chameleon for stealth, etc.
@scifiguy9000 I want to intend on making the cast fully original as SMG4 has themselves considering the over arching themes have gone from the mushroom kingdom to smg4’s kingdom So names such as Luigi or Mario will be characters gone from the cast or reshaped
It's still the same character, and the old videos with the Mario recolors are still canon, but SMG4 and SMG3 were given in-universe redesigns because Luke feared that Nintendo would go after him. But flashbacks to old episodes still use the Mario recolor designs because he still canonically looked like that up until the events of the Lawsuit Arc.
Very nice, though a common flaw that is shared here is that it doesn't fit SMG4 and the machinma series as a whole. It's obviously not a bad design, I'd say it's a great design. However, it fits more of something like TADC or something more original. SMG4, definitively, has never been an original show with complex themes or a hip with the trends show. It has been a recolored Mario and an out-of-character one going on silly adventures and doing stupid things. I feel SMG4 doesn't need a redesign and should have just been put on a hiatus or even fully dropped when they truly ran out of fresh ideas. I'm glad they are planning this for their shows. Great video, by the way.
@@Starpunz1 i know,its hard to maintain the public entertained,i had 4 channels,and today i have this channel(www.youtube.com/@HackyNoxusYT )that only have 10 subs
I'm sorry, but I'm not much of a fan of your redesign. The official redesign while moving away from looking like Mario, at least stayed simplistic. That's just my opinion.
that's fine, I'm just trying to make a more narrative approach with the smg4 universe by erasing all potential nintendo related IPs or choices that might hinge on their series.
That’s a fair question, I don’t argue the idea that the fanbase is a lot older than I was noting them to be, but it isn’t an understatement to say a third or more of viewers are at least a younger demographic
Just the looks of it It looks so modern and scifi-ish the face and all that weurd clothing style the pink hair is the cherry on top But i appricate your kindess
PART 2 : ua-cam.com/video/QKz1xO3TVlY/v-deo.htmlsi=QftsHI5MqRGxhDbO
All it needs to be is funny to me.
Which is kinda ironic considering how they gave me my sense of humor growing up.
@@TheIzzlzzy honestly if they just replaced the designs and kept the gmod humor the same I’d be fine with it
I like the redesign, it's very interesting and 100% demonstrates the new concept you can up with. However, I feel like it's just too complex for a main character for SMG4, as the only original characters with designs similar to this are the villians, like Zero in his final form. Though of course in the case of a complete reboot, it wouldn't matter.
@@redmagnezone5295 that’s fair! Even I thought it was a little too much
It’s just presenting an idea if Like and Kevin decide to go full reboot, as they have for some characters with retcons
Yeah.
Why does he look like a sonic character 💀
Imagine him being a Nicole variant of Super Mario.
It's the gloves, isn't it?
5:35
"what is smg4?"
his channel name stands for super mario glitchy four, and in his videos, it stands for super meme guardian four
@@rjseditsandcleanytps yes! But I was elaborating on WHAT he is, not who
@Starpunz1 oh oops
@@rjseditsandcleanytps it’s alright!
I love this redesign so much!
I can't wait to see the other characters! Especially SMG3, Mr. Puzzles and more!
@@loonysanity9638 I was close to putting in SMG3 but wanted to save that for later!
Thank you!
This redesign is a straight bonfire
@@Korophite Yeah it’s pretty drastic from the Mario design, can I ask what doesn’t appeal to you?
@@Starpunz1 Nothing does, I meant to say it's S Teir
@@Korophite oh, thank you!
Tari Should be a little Astro Bot esque character that uses Aqua, Yellow, Black and White.
i like you smg4 reboot i ideas of him be virus but not a harmful once like smg3 he just want to make friends and have fun
I love the design, but it just SCREAMS “Jester Villian”
he does live in a circus castle
No offense but personally I feel it would better if Luke and Kevin just simply let SMG4 go rather than to undergo a reboot, the design is good but it doesn't scream SMG4 to me.
He is wearing shoes, you fool
@@kenzonPower I meant to say boosters honest brain fart
The editing software has been kind of buggy so if you see issues like OBS or off sync talking, that’s why, sorry!
PERSONA 4 MUSIC!
It looks so cool! This smg4 would look SO cool in a anime
This is a super cool concept! Thumbs up for me!
I know a lot of people are coming in, so I would like to take this time and say thank you for the continued support and criticism, having these discussions on how to further improve my designs, content, and outreach with you all has been a pleasure that I cannot say enough.
please watch my other videos if your anticipation for more is not sufficed, thank you.
This is a good idea and I like the design, but I feel like this kinda goes against what SMG4 is about. The simplicity. Well current SMG4 also kinda goes against that but you know what I mean.
@@Oceane1803 yeah I see what you mean, but unfortunately I just don’t think that’s a possible way as Glitch productions have already set their sights on ambitious projects, which allows merchandising, jobs, marketing
Just how business goes, doesn’t mean it wouldn’t be bad though I get you
I do believe that sometime they will have to abandon all the nintendo characters, mario included.
Or possibly give them all redesigns and change their personalities in some points.
For some reason I see Luigi would don a business suit wearing shades, being the more financially focused brother, of course he would still have his fears.
While I could see characters like bowser being transformed into a more human/reptile hybrid capable of taking different hybrid forms with special skills attached.
Human/Turtle for Strength, Human/Chameleon for stealth, etc.
What about names, since even they would be copyrighted too to some extent.
@scifiguy9000 I want to intend on making the cast fully original as SMG4 has themselves considering the over arching themes have gone from the mushroom kingdom to smg4’s kingdom
So names such as Luigi or Mario will be characters gone from the cast or reshaped
Looks great bro
@@FangAlt thank you springtrap
@ your welcome bro
Likes Mario and nights
i am turning old who the fuck is this guy isn't he the mario with blue color codes i used to love
It's still the same character, and the old videos with the Mario recolors are still canon, but SMG4 and SMG3 were given in-universe redesigns because Luke feared that Nintendo would go after him. But flashbacks to old episodes still use the Mario recolor designs because he still canonically looked like that up until the events of the Lawsuit Arc.
❤tari! 8:22❤
Can you redesign the smg4 crew?
@@delvymarina2667 on it!
Very nice, though a common flaw that is shared here is that it doesn't fit SMG4 and the machinma series as a whole.
It's obviously not a bad design, I'd say it's a great design. However, it fits more of something like TADC or something more original.
SMG4, definitively, has never been an original show with complex themes or a hip with the trends show. It has been a recolored Mario and an out-of-character one going on silly adventures and doing stupid things.
I feel SMG4 doesn't need a redesign and should have just been put on a hiatus or even fully dropped when they truly ran out of fresh ideas. I'm glad they are planning this for their shows. Great video, by the way.
Thank you!
gzus for god sake stop him
oh no.
woah
What’s the name of the music track that starts playing here? 5:32
@@SR.PlayAlot64 persona 4 - pursuing my true self
What the hell is that redesign.
No seriously, what the hell is that redesign.
my ranking is:
og design:actually good
1st redesign:should not exist
2nd redesign:WOW,WOW,WOW,that was accually MID
Lmao, I know it’s very drastic but can you explain why you don’t like it? I’m planning on changing it for the next video!
@@Starpunz1 im not saying abou your redesign,i was talking about the og smg4 redisigns
@HackyNoxusYT ohhhh ok!
Yeah it’s really hard to not alienate your audience so the designs do the best they can I believe
@@Starpunz1 i know,its hard to maintain the public entertained,i had 4 channels,and today i have this channel(www.youtube.com/@HackyNoxusYT )that only have 10 subs
I'm sorry, but I'm not much of a fan of your redesign. The official redesign while moving away from looking like Mario, at least stayed simplistic. That's just my opinion.
that's fine, I'm just trying to make a more narrative approach with the smg4 universe by erasing all potential nintendo related IPs or choices that might hinge on their series.
Can you please explain to me why you think the modern SMG4 fanbase is comprised of toddlers
That’s a fair question, I don’t argue the idea that the fanbase is a lot older than I was noting them to be, but it isn’t an understatement to say a third or more of viewers are at least a younger demographic
@ yeah i guess you’re right about that but for me SMG4 has never really felt like it was made for young kids
I dont want to lie but it looks kinda bad
that's fine! Can I ask what exactly about it you don't enjoy?
Just the looks of it
It looks so modern and scifi-ish the face and all that weurd clothing style the pink hair is the cherry on top
But i appricate your kindess
that's good to know, I'll use that for the next episode to keep it grounded
also no problem!