@@zacharysuero9012 although I don’t hate legends, I feel like so many legends have been milked like crazy over the years. I’m not sure if we really need to see some people for a 5th or 6th time
Survivor 49: Second Chances 2 (EXCLUSIVE for NEW ERA losers) Survivor 50: LEGENDS season (ANYBODY across the 49 seasons) There. Fixed the "will they / won' they get cast" problem.
I agree, I don’t want either of them back for valid reasons, but I understand I am in the minority on that, so put them together and I could maybe get behind that!
I do think that saving the next returnee season for 50 means that players from Heroes, Healers, and Hustlers-Island of the Idols are probably going to get overlooked in favor of players from 41-48 (assuming they wont have time between production on 49 and filming for 50 to add members of that cast) It really sucks for the late 30s casts that spots for that first returnee season will probably prioritize new era over pre-40, and i kinda wish we got a returnee season in the last production block that could cover the late 30s-42
@@person9305 yeah, but its still less likely that someone from almost a decade ago would get cast over people from just the 40s. I think last production cycle would have been the best time for a first returnee season, rather than waiting for 50
I still think the big names from 35-38 (not sure about 39) are going to get the call, so there’s a good chance to see Chrissy, Dom, Christian, Angelina, and Rick if they choose to return. This May just be copium though
Jake always had such weird energy. He's kind of this sad-sack shlump, but at TC he starts doing 'bits'. That 'WOAH!' was so funny, but also when he repositions himself to carefully watch a crying Kendra get voted out.
@@vaporterraJesse is known for 1 Huge move. He has a bla personality. Cody has an amazing personality. We need them both to come back so they can be the Cochran and Dawn in s50
Honestly, solid choices!! And the quick shots here reminded me that we actually have had a lot of GREAT players and/or characters in the new era (editing and/or other new era issues aside). (There's plenty of pre-40 people i would love to see back too, but for arguments sake, sticking to new era). I would LOOOVE to see a lot of these people in the same arena/season - the dynamics wild be FASCINATING. Like Jesse, Carolyn, Dee, Erika, Shan, Ricard, Omar, Maryanne in particular all together would be so interesting to see how they'd deal with each other (who would bond, who would rub each other the wrong way, who'd be out first and why, etc). Also tempted to just throw some extra chaos in there by bringing back people like Tori, Broccoli Brad, Kendra, and Naseer just because I love Naseer. 😂
Not my favourite cast idea ever but it is one I could see production doing. Teams based on this cast - Red - Shan, Omar, Jesse, Carson, Dee, Venus Yellow - Ricard, MaryAnne, Gabler, YamYam, Emily, Kenzie Blue - Erica, Jonathan, Cassidy, Carolyn, Kaleb, Q
@@Carter-pu3xg I figured Jonathan's already gonna carry whatever tribe he has through the physical part of challenges so I might as well make it as stacked physical as possible and keep the other two even and make them stronger in puzzles and endurance and ended up accidentally going for a Brain (Red) vs Brawn (Blue) vs Beauty/Brain/Gabler (Yellow).
@@jornsyy I was first gonna do the latter but there's a 2-4 gender split. I was then gonna do the former but I couldn't find a way to do it that I liked very much. The other thing is all of these players are late game players - the person with the worst placement is Shan who STILL got 8th and is a strategic threat - potentially more threatening than Erica who won her season from an audience perspective - so after I couldn't get it to work I wasn't super worried. Erica and Dee I placed on tribes full of threats and the other 4 are all on a tribe together so I think I did the best I could
Based on this cast, I’d divide the tribes as so: Tribe 1: Gabler, Erica, Q, Omar, Carolyn, Emily Tribe 2: Yam Yam, Maryanne, Shan, Jesse, Cassidy, Kaleb Tribe 3: Dee, Kenzie, Venus, Jonathan, Carson, Ricard
41: D. Voce, Tiffany S. 42: Jonathan Y, Tori M. 43: Jesse L, Cody A. 44: Carolyn W, Maddy P. 45: Austin L, Katurah T. 46: Charlie D, Venus V. 47: 1 man, 1 woman 48: 1 man, 1 woman 49: 1 man, 1 woman
SURVIVOR 47: LEGENDS AMONG US LOCATION: BORNEO HOST: Rob Mariano 20-person CAST (two tribes of 9, with double elimination first episode "play in"): Economic system from EoE returns Trivia games return from Season 1 CAST: 1. Jeff Probst - it’s time for Jeff to get his torch snuffed 2. Zeke Smith 3. Jeremy Collins - can he be a black player to get two victories? 4. Dreamz - how has he grown or matured? fan favorite for being a "bad guy" (Next finalists are from Seasons 36 and up) 5. Domenick Abbate 6. Mike White 7. Chris Underwood 8. Shan 9. Xander 10. Ricard 11. Zach Wertenberger 12. Johnathan Young 13. Jeanane Zhang 14. Sami Layadi 15. Jesse Lopez 16. Cassidy Clark 17. Carolyn Wiger 18. Emily Flippen 19. Hunter McKnight 20. Q
My Picks 41: Erika, Shan, Deshawn 42: Maryanne, Tori, Jonathan 43: Jesse, Cody, Cassidy 44: Yam Yam, Carolyn, Frannie (sorry Carson) 45: Dee, Kaleb, Kellie 46: Hunter, Charlie, Q Just imagine Hunter vs Jonathan in challenges Also unless I am stupid this cast is a even split on gender I tried going off of if people would want to play again I left out Kenzie because I don't see her returning this soon as she is having a kid I also left out Emily because she said she doesn't really want to play again I doubt Venus would be interested in playing again after some of the tweets she made during the season and I don't think she had the world's best survivor experience Correct me if any of these statements are false
I am really happy you are not ignoring/dismissing Mike Gabler like others have. Winners like him and Erika and several others deserve the chance to show that they won for a reason.
I've always preferred not to bring back winners (except for season #40) to give other contestants a chance and the winners have already tended to get the most screen time on their season. Also winners don't usually do well on returnee seasons. Apart from season #40 only Sandra has won again and she was in a final three with another former winner and someone who thought he was a former winner at the time.
My only disagreements are: - I want Lindsay instead of Maryanne for 42, so we can see Johnathon and Lindsay square off again!! - I want Cody instead of Cassidy for 43, so that we can see Cody & Jesse once more. Loved that duo so much. - I need more Jake from 45. Dee made her case as one of the best, I’d give him one more chance instead. - And from 46, instead of Kenzie and Q , I wanna see Mariah and Charlie back at it again. But absolutely give Venus another chance. We need her chaos. GREAT picks. Honestly SUCH good casting these past seasons, so many contenders.
my picks: 41: shan, ricard, erika 42: maryanne, tori, omar 43: cassidy, jesse, owen 44: lauren, yamyam, frannie 45: austin, kaleb, katurah 46: venus, tiffany, q having 3 winners on the same season is kinda unrealistic to me but whatevs!!
I'm not done with this video yet, but I'm not a super big fan of the list. I just don't really feel like the winners need a second shot no matter how good of characters they are (idk if you did Kenzie since I stopped at Dee, but here's my list 41: I haven't seen this season so I'll just steal yours sub Xander for Erika 42: I dislike just having 3 or the Taku 4, so we're gonna have Omar, Tori, Hai 43: Jesse, Karla, Cassidy 44: Carolyn, Frannie, Danny 45: Drew, Katurah, Kaleb 46: Charlie, Venus, Tiffany One restriction I gave myself was equal men and women, if not, probably I'd put hunter in over Tiff, but whatever. Also I'm casting for good TV and strategy, so the challenge strength is probably a bit lower than normal Now the tribes. This may or not be balanced, but I'm gonna just be going for 3 men 3 women and not completely imbalanced challenge ability. I'm also trying for 1 per season, but we'll see Green Tribe: Ricard, Tori, Karla, Frannie, Drew, Charlie Orange tribe: Xander, Omar, Cassidy, Danny, Katurah, Venus Purple tribe:Shan, Hai, Jesse, Carolyn, Kaleb, Tiffany I think these tribes look mostly fine, though half of the purple tribe were on their season's trainwreck tribe, so if history repeats itself that would be pretty comedic
I’d personally swap out Gabler for Cody, Carson for Frannie, Emily for Austin (assuming she doesn’t want to return), and Kenzie for Tiffany, but you’ve still got a pretty solid lineup!
Shouout to Danny (winner of the Challenge USA. Gotta get SOMEONE who can compete with Jonathan) and Eevie in 41 Owen in 43 Frannie in 44 Kellie in 45 All them would be great to see again.
I hope for the returnee season they do a new era vs old era then we can get a perspective from an old survivor player if the new era is harder. I’d say bring back people from 30-39 for the old era
I want a full cast of all challenge beasts! That way everyone is actually good at challenges and there aren’t any goats to drag along, hell make it individual immunity from episode 1 where the entire cast dukes it out 😂
Just did a branteele simulation of this cast haha. I took a time to meticulously to input their strength/relationship/profiles. I had Omar, Dee and Jesse F3. W/ Erika and Maryanne completing the F5. Insane!
Would love to see Erika back, especially since we were blueballed so hard with her on Traitors Canada. I also think she would have an interesting storyline now that she’s come out of the closet post-winning.
I’m so glad to see you include Erika in this cast. I remember watching her game really closely after she played such a big role in the shan blindside. She played a much better game than anyone wants to give her credit for because “Xander was robbed” lol. I’d love to see her come back and prove all the naysayers wrong, including the editors.
14 newbie seasons (EoE had 14/18 newbies, so I'm counting that) with cast members that haven't gotten an opportunity to return yet. This is why you don't go 5 years without a newbie season after a big returnee season with extremely limited options. They'd better learn for the 50s and 60s.
I’d like to see season 49 to be a battle of the new era where part of the prize is a spot on survivor 50 legends. Maybe the top 3 get a locked position on that season
Idk if I agree with bringing so many winners back. What more can Erika, Maryanne and Gabler and Kenzie do as social players who won? Their games peaked the first time they played, and they aren’t such amazing tv characters. Let’s get some other people a chance.
I want Carson/Yam Yam/Caroline just to have the "Carson votes out his parents" arc, ending with them voting for him to win and smiling like proud parents from the jury.
You really put my top 3 players I DON'T wanna see back 😂 (Q / Gabler / Jonathan) Also I'd like a new era second chance leaving the winners for a more open all-stars season So here's my version : 41 : Shan, Ricard, Tiffany 42 : Omar, Hai, Jenny 43 : Jesse, Karla, Sami 44 : Carson, Frannie, Carolyn 45 : Emily, Kaleb, Kellie 46 : Randen, ??? I was so tired of Q I didn't finish 46 😅 Also I'd really like DeShawn and Voce from 41 to have another shot so maybe keep Shan and/or Ricard for the all-stars season too ?
I personally think this should be season 48. Here me out. We already have survivor 47 confirmed to be new players which means right now this stretch of seasons 41-47 is looking very similar to other parts of survivor history. Where everything is pretty much the same-Same amount of players, same number of tribes, same format. This is really looking like the first ever 7 seasons of survivor where its a long stretch of all newbie seasons that culminate into one giant season. Season 8 of survivor was all stars where players from all across the previous seven seasons were brought back and i think survivor 48 would be a perfect time to do something similar but with the new era. It makes sense too since it was marketed as the new Era. My ideas about this season might be a bit unpopular but imagine trying to cast a season like this, you wouldn't want to cut so many great players and i feel like there is so many players who would be great to see back. So have there be three tribes of eight instead of six meaning the first ever season with 24 players. Its actually not that far fetched since you would want to go big for 48. Also season 50 was confirmed to be a returnee season so this would be a way to get people excited for 48 and not overlook it because 50 is around the corner. This way the new era gets their time to shine while still being able to have old players return for 50. Two big returnee seasons with one newbie season separating it sounds very unlikely but its not the craziest thing ever. season 25, 26, and 27 all had returning players with a total of 23 players being brought back between a three season stretch. Also second chance and gamechangers only had two seasons separating them. This is definitely the BEST way of doing it but i have a bad feeling that 48 and 49 will both do the same thing the past 7 seasons did. Really hoping my dream comes true
I've never been a fan bring back winner so here's a no winner cast; 41: Shan, Ricard, Naseer 42: Omar, Tori, Jonathan 43: Jesse, Cassidy, Karla 44: Carolyn, Frannie, Matthew 45: Kaleb, Emily, Mama Julie 46: Q, Venus, Hunter Blue - Hunter, Ricard, Omar, Cassidy, Mama Julie, Frannie Red - Jonathan, Kaleb, Jesse, Shan, Venus, Carolyn Yellow - Naseer, Q, Matthew, Karla, Emily, Tori
From what I have heard, Carson and Carolyn would likely not be invited, they have been bashing survivor and have a bad relationship with Yam Yam now and it sounds like they may get black balled
I totally understand having all the winners but I’ve gotten the vibe Kenzie isn’t touching survivor with a 1000 foot pole for the rest of her life lmao
Love your videos, P, this one included. Not crazy about Gabler and Q here, though, the former being a doufus who got lucky and the latter being a quitter.
My goodness I love every single one of your videos it's scary. Hey so, just a simple ask about 43, Jesse was a lock for sure, but did you go spontaneouly with Gabler and Cassidy or did bringing back one rivalry cross your mind, such as Gabler-Elie, or Cassidy-Karla? Thanks
Picking Q and Dee was a choice, especially given Dee’s post-game drama. But picking Q over Charlie?? I’m down for venue, but I’d almost rather pick Charlie and Maria over Q and Venus…👁️🫦👁️
I recently saw a post on Twitter saying that Jesse is one of the most overrated players in the new era and I am baffled by that take. Even if I think Jesse could have won without the Cody blindside, I think he would have struggled if Cody was in the final tribal with him. By taking Cody out and in the way that he did, he wound up guaranteeing his win if he made it to the final tribal, and he made it certain that Karla would go next, his biggest threat to win after Cody! Even if you think he was better off not rocking the boat, the position he put himself in was still so strong that I don’t see how people can so confidently say he “shot himself in the foot!”
I’m personally not a fan of all the winners returning but if you put them all on a starting tribe together, then I’m cool with it. Maybe the winner tribe gets a small disadvantage in challenges because they’ve won already?
I feel like those who played from season 35-39 are kind of screwed, and I don’t feel like they’ll ever get considered to play again. I hope I’m wrong
Rerun David Vs. Goliath. Give me the entire cast back again
50 is not just limited to New Era. We’ll see some 35-39 returnees for sure
Season 49 should be New Era All Stars and Season 50 should be legends.
@@zacharysuero9012 although I don’t hate legends, I feel like so many legends have been milked like crazy over the years. I’m not sure if we really need to see some people for a 5th or 6th time
@Godwilla39 my guess is like 5-7 pre new era players
Hunter and Johnathan on one tribe (doesn’t matter who else is on their tribe) vs just Lulu and Yanu players.
Yes Those 2 are the only ones I would cheer for New Era players
I’d toss in Xander into that conversation as well!
@@mynameisdustin Yes! And maybe like an Austin or Maria as well.
Survivor 49: Second Chances 2 (EXCLUSIVE for NEW ERA losers)
Survivor 50: LEGENDS season
(ANYBODY across the 49 seasons)
There. Fixed the "will they / won' they get cast" problem.
So Survivor 50 is just 18 Jelinskis
@@Quetzal00358 nahh, I was thinking more of several Jelinskys
This is exactly what I would want
They have to do 20 players for 50, add 4 more days to accommodate and we have a 30 day season with 2 tribes of 10. Not 39, but closest we will get.
If this was a real season I'd need Q and Gabler on the same tribe constantly fighting so I could even possibly tolerate either one of them back.
Tbh I think they could be a duo, Gabler is pretty loyal and I don’t think Q will have a problem with Gabler in that theoretically situation
I agree, I don’t want either of them back for valid reasons, but I understand I am in the minority on that, so put them together and I could maybe get behind that!
I think putting Q on a tribe with either Shan, Carolyn, or Cassidy would be funny to see
severe lack of Brandon Donlon in this video, but I'll let it slide
I do think that saving the next returnee season for 50 means that players from Heroes, Healers, and Hustlers-Island of the Idols are probably going to get overlooked in favor of players from 41-48 (assuming they wont have time between production on 49 and filming for 50 to add members of that cast)
It really sucks for the late 30s casts that spots for that first returnee season will probably prioritize new era over pre-40, and i kinda wish we got a returnee season in the last production block that could cover the late 30s-42
Well Jeff said season 50 isn’t just limited to new era players. So they’re still open to casting older players
@@person9305 yeah, but its still less likely that someone from almost a decade ago would get cast over people from just the 40s. I think last production cycle would have been the best time for a first returnee season, rather than waiting for 50
I still think the big names from 35-38 (not sure about 39) are going to get the call, so there’s a good chance to see Chrissy, Dom, Christian, Angelina, and Rick if they choose to return. This May just be copium though
No body from IOI would have ever been asked to return I bet. Production wants to bury that season 6 feet deep.
The Jake “WOAH…… sorry woah..” at the end
And “Is it a bird? A plane? A big mistake? Not even close…. it’s Q!” Are both legendary
Jake always had such weird energy. He's kind of this sad-sack shlump, but at TC he starts doing 'bits'. That 'WOAH!' was so funny, but also when he repositions himself to carefully watch a crying Kendra get voted out.
I kinda love the idea of an all winners tribe. Then nobody can complain about the winners being targeted from the beginning.
Not picking Cody for 43 is insane.
If he’s picking just 3 a season (and going with all 6 winners and gender balance) it’s between Jesse and Cody. Jesse is the bigger lock.
Quite true. Remove Gabler for Cody. You don’t need every winner.
@@vaporterraJesse is known for 1
Huge move. He has a bla personality. Cody has an amazing personality. We need them both to come back so they can be the Cochran and Dawn in s50
Does anyone else schedule their lunch breaks on Wednesday to be around the time that Peridiam usually uploads?
No Charlie is criminal
Honestly, solid choices!! And the quick shots here reminded me that we actually have had a lot of GREAT players and/or characters in the new era (editing and/or other new era issues aside).
(There's plenty of pre-40 people i would love to see back too, but for arguments sake, sticking to new era).
I would LOOOVE to see a lot of these people in the same arena/season - the dynamics wild be FASCINATING. Like Jesse, Carolyn, Dee, Erika, Shan, Ricard, Omar, Maryanne in particular all together would be so interesting to see how they'd deal with each other (who would bond, who would rub each other the wrong way, who'd be out first and why, etc). Also tempted to just throw some extra chaos in there by bringing back people like Tori, Broccoli Brad, Kendra, and Naseer just because I love Naseer. 😂
Not my favourite cast idea ever but it is one I could see production doing.
Teams based on this cast -
Red - Shan, Omar, Jesse, Carson, Dee, Venus
Yellow - Ricard, MaryAnne, Gabler, YamYam, Emily, Kenzie
Blue - Erica, Jonathan, Cassidy, Carolyn, Kaleb, Q
Jonathan and Kaleb on the same tribe would be insane
@@Carter-pu3xg I figured Jonathan's already gonna carry whatever tribe he has through the physical part of challenges so I might as well make it as stacked physical as possible and keep the other two even and make them stronger in puzzles and endurance and ended up accidentally going for a Brain (Red) vs Brawn (Blue) vs Beauty/Brain/Gabler (Yellow).
I’d rather the winners be evenly split 2-2-2 or all on one tribe from a fairness standpoint
@@jornsyy I was first gonna do the latter but there's a 2-4 gender split. I was then gonna do the former but I couldn't find a way to do it that I liked very much.
The other thing is all of these players are late game players - the person with the worst placement is Shan who STILL got 8th and is a strategic threat - potentially more threatening than Erica who won her season from an audience perspective - so after I couldn't get it to work I wasn't super worried. Erica and Dee I placed on tribes full of threats and the other 4 are all on a tribe together so I think I did the best I could
Based on this cast, I’d divide the tribes as so:
Tribe 1: Gabler, Erica, Q, Omar, Carolyn, Emily
Tribe 2: Yam Yam, Maryanne, Shan, Jesse, Cassidy, Kaleb
Tribe 3: Dee, Kenzie, Venus, Jonathan, Carson, Ricard
Survivor: Battle Royale / Battle Era Royale
Fun season idea and some good picks! Love the idea of putting the 6 new era winners so far on a tribe together for chaos hahaha. Awesome logo too!
41: D. Voce, Tiffany S.
42: Jonathan Y, Tori M.
43: Jesse L, Cody A.
44: Carolyn W, Maddy P.
45: Austin L, Katurah T.
46: Charlie D, Venus V.
47: 1 man, 1 woman
48: 1 man, 1 woman
49: 1 man, 1 woman
I need charlie and Maria back on the next returnee season, imagine the drama and distrust
No winners they already won I want players that really want to win
Litterally...
You can't have new era all stars without one of the best players ever, Charlie
SURVIVOR 47: LEGENDS AMONG US
LOCATION: BORNEO
HOST: Rob Mariano
20-person CAST (two tribes of 9, with double elimination first episode "play in"):
Economic system from EoE returns
Trivia games return from Season 1
CAST:
1. Jeff Probst - it’s time for Jeff to get his torch snuffed
2. Zeke Smith
3. Jeremy Collins - can he be a black player to get two victories?
4. Dreamz - how has he grown or matured? fan favorite for being a "bad guy"
(Next finalists are from Seasons 36 and up)
5. Domenick Abbate
6. Mike White
7. Chris Underwood
8. Shan
9. Xander
10. Ricard
11. Zach Wertenberger
12. Johnathan Young
13. Jeanane Zhang
14. Sami Layadi
15. Jesse Lopez
16. Cassidy Clark
17. Carolyn Wiger
18. Emily Flippen
19. Hunter McKnight
20. Q
for 45, if emily doesn’t want to play i would personally BEG kellie to come back and be the dark horse of this season
Not picking Cody to return is devastating 😢
My Picks
41: Erika, Shan, Deshawn
42: Maryanne, Tori, Jonathan
43: Jesse, Cody, Cassidy
44: Yam Yam, Carolyn, Frannie (sorry Carson)
45: Dee, Kaleb, Kellie
46: Hunter, Charlie, Q
Just imagine Hunter vs Jonathan in challenges
Also unless I am stupid this cast is a even split on gender
I tried going off of if people would want to play again
I left out Kenzie because I don't see her returning this soon as she is having a kid
I also left out Emily because she said she doesn't really want to play again
I doubt Venus would be interested in playing again after some of the tweets she made during the season and I don't think she had the world's best survivor experience
Correct me if any of these statements are false
I am really happy you are not ignoring/dismissing Mike Gabler like others have. Winners like him and Erika and several others deserve the chance to show that they won for a reason.
I've always preferred not to bring back winners (except for season #40) to give other contestants a chance and the winners have already tended to get the most screen time on their season.
Also winners don't usually do well on returnee seasons. Apart from season #40 only Sandra has won again and she was in a final three with another former winner and someone who thought he was a former winner at the time.
My only disagreements are:
- I want Lindsay instead of Maryanne for 42, so we can see Johnathon and Lindsay square off again!!
- I want Cody instead of Cassidy for 43, so that we can see Cody & Jesse once more. Loved that duo so much.
- I need more Jake from 45. Dee made her case as one of the best, I’d give him one more chance instead.
- And from 46, instead of Kenzie and Q , I wanna see Mariah and Charlie back at it again. But absolutely give Venus another chance. We need her chaos.
GREAT picks. Honestly SUCH good casting these past seasons, so many contenders.
These are the best swaps I’ve seen! Basically a perfect cast
my picks:
41: shan, ricard, erika
42: maryanne, tori, omar
43: cassidy, jesse, owen
44: lauren, yamyam, frannie
45: austin, kaleb, katurah
46: venus, tiffany, q
having 3 winners on the same season is kinda unrealistic to me but whatevs!!
Love this cast
No Carolyn???
I'm not done with this video yet, but I'm not a super big fan of the list. I just don't really feel like the winners need a second shot no matter how good of characters they are (idk if you did Kenzie since I stopped at Dee, but here's my list
41: I haven't seen this season so I'll just steal yours sub Xander for Erika
42: I dislike just having 3 or the Taku 4, so we're gonna have Omar, Tori, Hai
43: Jesse, Karla, Cassidy
44: Carolyn, Frannie, Danny
45: Drew, Katurah, Kaleb
46: Charlie, Venus, Tiffany
One restriction I gave myself was equal men and women, if not, probably I'd put hunter in over Tiff, but whatever. Also I'm casting for good TV and strategy, so the challenge strength is probably a bit lower than normal
Now the tribes. This may or not be balanced, but I'm gonna just be going for 3 men 3 women and not completely imbalanced challenge ability. I'm also trying for 1 per season, but we'll see
Green Tribe: Ricard, Tori, Karla, Frannie, Drew, Charlie
Orange tribe: Xander, Omar, Cassidy, Danny, Katurah, Venus
Purple tribe:Shan, Hai, Jesse, Carolyn, Kaleb, Tiffany
I think these tribes look mostly fine, though half of the purple tribe were on their season's trainwreck tribe, so if history repeats itself that would be pretty comedic
Flawless list, no notes
If no winners, I’d include Deshawn, Tori, Karla, Heidi, Austin and Tiffany
I’d personally swap out Gabler for Cody, Carson for Frannie, Emily for Austin (assuming she doesn’t want to return), and Kenzie for Tiffany, but you’ve still got a pretty solid lineup!
My cast:
**Tribe 1**
- Erika
- Shan
- Jonathan
- Jesse
- Frannie (replaced Carson)
- Kaleb
**Tribe 2**
- Maryanne
- Omar
- Cody
- Yam Yam
- Emily
- Venus
**Tribe 3**
- Naseer (replaced Ricard)
- Karla (replaced Cassidy)
- Carolyn
- Dee
- Charlie (replaced Kenzie)
- Q
You gotta put Carolyn on the tribe with Jonathan bro weakest and the strongest
frannie replacing carson is such a good choice
Shouout to Danny (winner of the Challenge USA. Gotta get SOMEONE who can compete with Jonathan) and Eevie in 41
Owen in 43
Frannie in 44
Kellie in 45
All them would be great to see again.
Love the idea and most of the cast but not having Charlie from 46 try to redeem himself? Wild.
We don't even want at least half of these winners back
Speak for yourself. Aside from Gabler all of the new era winners are popular among the fans.
@vaporterra Erika, Kenzie and yes, Gabler, can stay home. The others are more than welcomed.
I hope for the returnee season they do a new era vs old era then we can get a perspective from an old survivor player if the new era is harder. I’d say bring back people from 30-39 for the old era
All I want for 50 is exclusively first time returnees.
I'd PREFER to have players from HvHvH to IoI considered, but if it's only new era I'd be fine.
I want a full cast of all challenge beasts! That way everyone is actually good at challenges and there aren’t any goats to drag along, hell make it individual immunity from episode 1 where the entire cast dukes it out 😂
That doesn’t work. Look at The Challenge. There will always be someone considered “weaker” among even the athletes
Just did a branteele simulation of this cast haha. I took a time to meticulously to input their strength/relationship/profiles. I had Omar, Dee and Jesse F3. W/ Erika and Maryanne completing the F5. Insane!
Gabler winning twice would be incredible for the sole reason of watching the Survivor Twitter community lose their mind.
Yeah the winner controversy after Erika and Gabler won 1 season apart was wild
Like I can’t understand getting that mad about who wins
@@XanderMatthews-nv9zf he’s a conservative Trump supporter so he’s automatically hated.
Would love to see Erika back, especially since we were blueballed so hard with her on Traitors Canada. I also think she would have an interesting storyline now that she’s come out of the closet post-winning.
So happy you had big John on this list
ooooh an all winner tribe would be SPICY
I’m so glad to see you include Erika in this cast. I remember watching her game really closely after she played such a big role in the shan blindside. She played a much better game than anyone wants to give her credit for because “Xander was robbed” lol. I’d love to see her come back and prove all the naysayers wrong, including the editors.
if Gabler and Erika were to return I think they have a very good shot in being the first two time winners in the new era
41; Ricard, Shan, Evvie
42; Romeo, Zach Wurtenburger, Jonathan - Maryanne Wurtenburger's husband
43; Karla, Owen
44; Carson, Carolyn, Frannie, Matt, Heidi
45; Jake, Julie, Katurah,
46; Tevin, Soda, Venus, Maria
Pretty spot on. Almost half is also my players for season 50
2:09 "rustled" feathers, if I may
What about Charlie??
again, you don't pick Cody to come back 😵💫 wouldn't he be the biggest lock?
14 newbie seasons (EoE had 14/18 newbies, so I'm counting that) with cast members that haven't gotten an opportunity to return yet. This is why you don't go 5 years without a newbie season after a big returnee season with extremely limited options. They'd better learn for the 50s and 60s.
I’d like to see season 49 to be a battle of the new era where part of the prize is a spot on survivor 50 legends. Maybe the top 3 get a locked position on that season
I think you nailed the casting
I completely agree with this 18, this were the best players/characters of 41-46 no ifs no buts
Idk if I agree with bringing so many winners back. What more can Erika, Maryanne and Gabler and Kenzie do as social players who won? Their games peaked the first time they played, and they aren’t such amazing tv characters. Let’s get some other people a chance.
Maybe in like 5 years it’d be nice to see them again, but not so soon
100% agree, other than Maryanne, her spot would definitely be due to her character over her game.
I think Perdi wants a minority to become two timers again but doesnt' want to appear racist maybe I dunno.
I want Carson/Yam Yam/Caroline just to have the "Carson votes out his parents" arc, ending with them voting for him to win and smiling like proud parents from the jury.
You really put my top 3 players I DON'T wanna see back 😂 (Q / Gabler / Jonathan)
Also I'd like a new era second chance leaving the winners for a more open all-stars season
So here's my version :
41 : Shan, Ricard, Tiffany
42 : Omar, Hai, Jenny
43 : Jesse, Karla, Sami
44 : Carson, Frannie, Carolyn
45 : Emily, Kaleb, Kellie
46 : Randen, ???
I was so tired of Q I didn't finish 46 😅
Also I'd really like DeShawn and Voce from 41 to have another shot so maybe keep Shan and/or Ricard for the all-stars season too ?
I really hope they do Old School vs New Era at some point. Also really want Drew from 45 to come back
I feel like this cast would give the entertainment factor from heroes vs villains and the gameplay of second chances a run for its money.
I personally think this should be season 48. Here me out.
We already have survivor 47 confirmed to be new players which means right now this stretch of seasons 41-47 is looking very similar to other parts of survivor history. Where everything is pretty much the same-Same amount of players, same number of tribes, same format. This is really looking like the first ever 7 seasons of survivor where its a long stretch of all newbie seasons that culminate into one giant season.
Season 8 of survivor was all stars where players from all across the previous seven seasons were brought back and i think survivor 48 would be a perfect time to do something similar but with the new era. It makes sense too since it was marketed as the new Era.
My ideas about this season might be a bit unpopular but imagine trying to cast a season like this, you wouldn't want to cut so many great players and i feel like there is so many players who would be great to see back. So have there be three tribes of eight instead of six meaning the first ever season with 24 players. Its actually not that far fetched since you would want to go big for 48. Also season 50 was confirmed to be a returnee season so this would be a way to get people excited for 48 and not overlook it because 50 is around the corner. This way the new era gets their time to shine while still being able to have old players return for 50.
Two big returnee seasons with one newbie season separating it sounds very unlikely but its not the craziest thing ever. season 25, 26, and 27 all had returning players with a total of 23 players being brought back between a three season stretch. Also second chance and gamechangers only had two seasons separating them.
This is definitely the BEST way of doing it but i have a bad feeling that 48 and 49 will both do the same thing the past 7 seasons did. Really hoping my dream comes true
I've never been a fan bring back winner so here's a no winner cast;
41: Shan, Ricard, Naseer
42: Omar, Tori, Jonathan
43: Jesse, Cassidy, Karla
44: Carolyn, Frannie, Matthew
45: Kaleb, Emily, Mama Julie
46: Q, Venus, Hunter
Blue - Hunter, Ricard, Omar, Cassidy, Mama Julie, Frannie
Red - Jonathan, Kaleb, Jesse, Shan, Venus, Carolyn
Yellow - Naseer, Q, Matthew, Karla, Emily, Tori
Not a bad group, but here's my cast:
Tribe 1: Q(46), Emily (45), Danny(44), Noelle(43), Omar(42), Erika(41)
Tribe 2: Maria(46), Drew(45), Carolyn(44), Jesse(43), Maryanne(42), Naseer(41)
Tribe 3: Charlie(46), Dee(45), Matthew(44), Carla(43), Johnathan Young(42), Schan(41)
No winners, please! Either they'll all get picked off or everyone will want to use them as Fonale goats. Bring back 18 HUNGRY players.
“Actually, can I have a redo on that one Jeff..?” When talking about Sp*nc*r and J*e getting on second chance over Culpepper had me DYING 😭😭
Who cares about what they do outside the game? Joe makes sense but people now don’t like Spencer because…he’s not vaccinated?
@@Quetzal00358 i just thought it was a funny part of the video my guy
@@Quetzal00358 Spencer kinda went off the rails. He doesn't even go by Spencer anymore...
Should be some Evvie action in here. You slept on them completely.
I’d worry about bringing Gabler back, he’s very old and likely destined to be an early boot which would be pretty lame
Yah and hes very boring
I have my fingers crossed for 50 players and 50 days. One player returning from each season with an extra from either season 1 or 49
Gabler is a freaking wild choice.
From what I have heard, Carson and Carolyn would likely not be invited, they have been bashing survivor and have a bad relationship with Yam Yam now and it sounds like they may get black balled
Whattt? What happened??
I totally understand having all the winners but I’ve gotten the vibe Kenzie isn’t touching survivor with a 1000 foot pole for the rest of her life lmao
My jaw dropped when you didn’t say Zander😮😮😮
Love your videos, P, this one included. Not crazy about Gabler and Q here, though, the former being a doufus who got lucky and the latter being a quitter.
My goodness I love every single one of your videos it's scary. Hey so, just a simple ask about 43, Jesse was a lock for sure, but did you go spontaneouly with Gabler and Cassidy or did bringing back one rivalry cross your mind, such as Gabler-Elie, or Cassidy-Karla? Thanks
Picking Q and Dee was a choice, especially given Dee’s post-game drama.
But picking Q over Charlie?? I’m down for venue, but I’d almost rather pick Charlie and Maria over Q and Venus…👁️🫦👁️
Cassidy ❌ - Karla ✅
Gabler ❌ - Cody ✅
Carson ❌ - Frannie✅
Kenzie❌ - Charlie✅
Gabler can take a long walk off a short pier
Great cast. I would’ve had Cody and Karla in over Gabler and Cassidy though.
Awesome cast!
I recently saw a post on Twitter saying that Jesse is one of the most overrated players in the new era and I am baffled by that take.
Even if I think Jesse could have won without the Cody blindside, I think he would have struggled if Cody was in the final tribal with him. By taking Cody out and in the way that he did, he wound up guaranteeing his win if he made it to the final tribal, and he made it certain that Karla would go next, his biggest threat to win after Cody! Even if you think he was better off not rocking the boat, the position he put himself in was still so strong that I don’t see how people can so confidently say he “shot himself in the foot!”
It’s a crime not to add Charlie
No?
I’d definitely like to see Charlie but Q is a bigger lock as far as males go
this would be excellent
Picking Gabler over Cody is absolutely wild
YESSSS ERIKA!
I probably would tweak some names, but I could go by with these players
Omar's sister was on Jeopardy! and she's brilliant. Talk about talented family...
So was Drew
@@stettkt1 yes - giant killer!
I think you should watch Australian survivor titans vs rebels … one of the best seasons !!
I want an all star season with just budget era and then another all star with people who are NOT budget era
I actually hope it’s only from
41-49. Let these people have their own All Stars.
My main concern with this list is no one can keep up with Jonathan physically, Hunter is probably the closest we’ve seen.
And yet Jonathan didn’t set an immunity challenge record despite making it to the final 4
New Era All Stars not being season 48 is such a massive mistake
Evie and Karla would be my top picks who weren't mentioned!
Q definitely needs to be back
I’m personally not a fan of all the winners returning but if you put them all on a starting tribe together, then I’m cool with it. Maybe the winner tribe gets a small disadvantage in challenges because they’ve won already?
Drop the winners and replace them with:
Danny
Lindsay
Cody
Frannie
Julie
Charlie
Season 50 better be back at 39 days,
I don't want any of the winners back especially from recent seasons this early. I would rather watch others play one more time
Can we see one without winners? I feel like this list was meh because the winners.
I think we need Matthew instead of Yam Yam for 44. He had SO much potential only to get pulled out for an injury instead.
For 43, if Gabler is there, I'd replace Jesse or Ellie.
You cast is almost perfect to me. To me Noelle or Karla in Cassidy's place and the cast would be perfect