Doctor Kills Dangerous Dictator to Prevent a Genocide | House M.D. | MD TV
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 бер 2024
- A doctor gets too involved in the case of a dangerous dictator and takes extreme actions to prevent a genocide.
From House M.D., Season 6 Episode 4 "The Tyrant": The team treats a controversial African politician named Dibala (James Earl Jones, 'Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb') who has fallen ill while coming to America to give a speech at the United Nations. Meanwhile, Wilson tries to make amends with a feuding neighbour. Fearing a planned genocide, Chase purposely mixes up the blood tests with that of a body in the morgue, causing Dibala to be treated for the wrong illness. The dictator is killed, leaving Chase and Foreman guilty.
House (2004) Dr House, an ingenious and unsociable physician who flouts hospital rules, clashes with fellow doctors and his assistants as he comes up with controversial hypotheses about his patients' illnesses.
Stream full seasons of House M.D. on Peacock: pck.tv/39BlAG0
Watch all seasons of House M.D. here: www.justwatch.com/uk/tv-serie...
Welcome to MD TV! A channel dedicated to your favourite medical dramas! Featuring iconic moments from House M.D., Chicago Med and more. Follow the professional and personal lives of the hospital staff, as you go on a journey right from the very first doctor's call to the E.R and beyond. MD TV is packed full of drama, intrigue, and plenty of medical emergencies!
#MDTV #HughLaurie #HouseMD #MedicalDrama #MedicalTVShow - Розваги
Calling Darth Vader a "Dangerous Dictator" is an understatement.
He said to Luke that he would rule the galaxy as father and son 😊❤❤
🫡ALL HAIL EMPEROR VADER!!
That part gets me every time like why did they have to hire James Earl 🤭
@@MsTinkerbelle87Why not?
Would've also been wrong, since Vader was the right hand man of a dictator.
calling Mufasa a dictator wouldn't have been as far off as we think, either.
it's the trolley dilemma. Chase pulled the lever
WRONG LEVER!!!!
@@winterserpent6966😂😂😂
@@winterserpent6966 Why do we even have that lever?
@@jandreid2023 when I installed the lever I didn't expect crazy assholes to start tying people to the tracks!
@@winterserpent6966kronk! Lol
From the moment his life was their responsibility, they were gonna have blood on their hands either way.
Does a combat medic need a weapon or a bandaid?
@@charleslennonbaker on rare occasions, they can be effectively the same thing.
@@Fireculunfortunately, it's less rare than most people will admit.
"Doc B"
1stID HHC 1-16 Infantry Med Plt Evac Section
Amen.@@Firecul
But yet you're forgetting about the hypocritic oath that all doctors take. Part of which says do no harm.
Chase is out here preventing Order 66
OMG YESSSSS
By killing Vader and not Palpatine?
Then Chase got tortured and murdered by the dictator’s minions
@@FumetsuGolf This guy is Darth Vader if he overthrew the emperor like he wanted, minus Padme anyway.
Whatever you think of the story, James Earl Jones absolutely nailed it with his acting
The man is a legend
He nails every role he takes.
of course he did. Everyone knows how good he is at anything he does.
He’s always been amazing
Yeah. Although, his African accent was bad.
I can't help but think that Chase learned a lot about himself by Dibala's conflict with Cameron. Dibala dared her to pull the trigger and stand by her morals in the most extreme way she can. Cameron realized she doesn't have it in her, Chase realized he does.
Doctors of NathanYahoo should have watched this episode. He shouldn't have returned from surgery last month
@@iwatchwithnoads7480 agreed
@iwatchwithnoads7480 do I want to learn who that is, or is ignorance bliss?
Nathan yahoo?
@@jagoz7465 The Israeli Prime Minister
...and thus for Chase, the question "What would you do if you met Hitler?" is answered...
Hitler was tried to kill 10 times but people failed.
you'd delete him, like any normal person would
@@maskedredstonerprozNah I’d let him live, stalin on the other hand….
@@eiavops4576I’d prevent both. Especially Stalin. Why would you let Hitler live?
@@gmansgnarlyscienceshow2820 Cause he’s probably a Na zi sympathiser, explains why he hates Stalin but is ok with mr Schmitler
The best part is that Dibala probably would have approved of chase’s decision to kill him because of what he told him and Cameron.
People like him dare others to kill them to be able to see it as a sign that they are doing the right things noone else dares to do. They know it's wrong on some level, but justify themselves as giving the sacrifice noone else is willing to do.
Nope. That's where dictators differ from the gallant knights full of principles and honour.
Dictators are Fkin cowards. He would have flipped like a coin if he knew. He challenged Cameron because he knew she couldn't. 😂 Psychopaths are good at manipulation and survival tactics.
In Chase’s defense, the dictator had low key threatened his wife.
Still no because everyone in amrica do that everyday and u have no right against another country get ready to take hate and then wonder why world hate USA
He dared her, not a threat just a dare. She backed down, Chase did not.
I forgot they were married.
“And sometimes, the only way to save a life, is to take one” - Doc, Rainbow Six Siege
Too true, as a siege player we forget about the stories that make the characters
A lot of times actually
That moment changed his whole life. I felt so bad for him. He made that decision, and saved all those ppl, knowing he could lose everything he cared about and loved in return. Not many ppl would do that. But it also broke everything it meant to be a doctor for him as well.
That's horseshit. I understand the "do no harm" but this is a HUGE exception that needs to be taken into consideration.
@@TheUnseenPath Not everyone will see things the same way as you. It all comes down to if you think its worth it or not, and not everyone will think it is, or just don't have the heart to kill someone. BUT, there are some crazy ass ppl out there, so it's hard to tell really.
How I see it is Chase was a ridiculous foreigner who decided to kill the leader of another nation because he was tired of his people being slaughtered by another form of people he was going to steamroll them to help protect his people. Anyone who doesn’t have the guts or the courage to do that is a coward who doesn’t deserve to be in a leadership position. And if anyone complains about what I said, they’re also a coward.
@@TheUnseenPathit was a job for an assassin, not a doctor. He broke his oath.
That being said, I think he was morally correct. But I'm not a doctor or philosopher
he replaced House M.D. and continued lmao
This is how talented James Earl Jones is; You know he's just playing a character but he's so believable you hate him as if he's really that horrible person on the screen. Then when the movie or TV show is over, you realize you love him and greatly admire is extraordinary virtuosity. Truly a living legend.
or he always wanted to be a dictator and it really fit in
Usually the kindest people enjoy playing the villains because it’s so different from their true character.
Have u not seen him in Fences
Jones is a master of the form.
Reminds me of John Bernthal as Shane in the Walking Dead lol. Giant asshole and I was glad Rick killed him. Then next season I was like “Damn, I miss Shane” lol
"This is a signed consent form."
I noticed that they didn't specify who signed it...
Good catch
Chase did what Cameron wanted to do but was too scared to do it and when Chase does kill Dibala she has the nerve to call him a murderer and then end their marriage. This episode made me hate her character so much
I didn't like her from the very beginning. Such a westerner
Bizzare take. Morality in medicine is pretty clear. Doctors don't politicize, their responsibility is to the patient.
@@m.bird.Any treatment for a dictator is political. Also, there are limits Doctors are expected to tolerated. If their patient wants to live, maybe they shouldn't be raising genocidal, drugged child soliders so he can command them to commit warcrimes. Skill issue
Also, earlier in the episode they violated code of ethics by letting them coerce someone into signing over their blood so as to save her family. I don't hear anyone complaining about breaking the rules then
@@m.bird. why should we tolerate the intolerable
@@m.bird. Alright then, let's do an outrageous hypothetical situation. Adolf Hitler shows up in the U.S. with a mysterious illness that German doctors can't figure out, but for western medicine it's a walk in the park. Do you treat and cure one of the worst human beings of the modern age? Doctor/Patient confidentiality are you even allowed to tell officials that he's even there? If you treat him and cure him of what would kill him if left untreated, is the blood then on your hands as well?
This episode made me hate Cameron, she wanted him dead so Chase killed him and she had the ga to be mad at him for doing it
And left him because of it. She wanted to leave, he didn't.
Yeah
It’s like Lori in The Walking Dead, tells her husband to do something about Shane (very clearly implied to kill him) then gets mad and horrified that it happens
Shocker...woman says one thing but means another ..smh
Yeah, in that sense, I can respect Cuddy when she makes the choice that she thinks will save a family (and, unfortunately, she's right). Chase also made a choice that saved lives.
Cameron just acts like inaction somehow absolves her when she would have been party to an entire family dying to keep HER OWN conscience "pure"
Damned if you do
Damned if you don't
Yes, but Chase still ended up saving lives, which is still his job. I can't say it was easy. But he prevented a genocide.
@@tierefuerimmer9635negative. That is not the oath they took, of course this a TV show 👍🏼
@@thefifthbelfry92Same vibes as "I was just following orders"
@@thefifthbelfry92 negative. he saved lives. get a set of morals kid
You my heart seized when Rwanda was mentioned. That movie still makes me shed so many tears. But oh goodness…I didn’t know James Earl Jones could be a bone chilling villain
You never heard of "Darth Vader"?
Are you referring to Hotel Rwanda? Do you know where I can stream that movie? I’ve been looking to watch it for a while, but I haven’t been able to find it anywhere.
@@mask938 I don’t. I first saw it as a kid. Last I saw it, it was on tv but I don’t recall what channel. But that was a while ago
@@sayadiva123 Oh, ok. Thanks anyway. I'll let you know when I find a place to stream it.
@@mask938 try checking, Amazon. That or UA-cam. My history class is currently going over world problems. We just got done watching that movie, presentations, and essays about it.
Chase responds , "and you , do you really think you can save somebody's life and not face the consequences ? Call it triage ."
The interesting thing is that the dictator was vocally tired of people not acting on their convictions and making the hard choices.
I think Chase took that lesson to heart. I don't think the dictator expected his vibe to turn on him so quickly though
It haunts chase until the end of all the seasons 😢
Good! He broke his duty and responsibilities as a doctor!! He should've been fired or imprisoned!
@@Aemilius46well he would have been if it had been know. It's not like in the show, the law didn't decide to prosecute him. You can't be convicted of a crime no one knows took place in the first place.
@@Aemilius46nah he was based
@@Aemilius46 do you know how many doctors break duty and responsibilities ...just for a sake of money and fame. Their greed has destroyed our medical system and insurance companies will just throw back into our system causing havoc. At least chase was doing us a favor ? look at haiti right now how much chaos its done to their society
it's a tv show folks(no it doesn't represent real life lol)
Foreshadowing chase being the next house
It’s great writing
I always felt this was one of the most compelling episodes of "House, MD." Dr. Chases struggle with the implications of his actions intersects the conundrum between medicine and morality.
Apparently someone didn't do this to neytanyaho and let him go on with his G
"I dont care what he was gonna do" you would if you were a Satibi
Yeah that's a privileged statement
Or if you are tutsi in rwanda
But he isn't and he took an oath. I also did, as a medic. It's on others to judge and punish, it's my responsibility to save patients.
@@ckreuzbichlerSo you think this oath matters more than international law?
another awesome performance by james earl jones. man he is an awesome actor
Totes McGoats
He truly is an amazing actor
i thought the "negotiations" sounded familiar
Right he has me believing him
"You think you can kill another human being without any consequences to yourself?"
It sounds like he thought a lot about the consequences to himself.
This was the moment when Chase embraced becoming the "next House".
This was when Chase became Housenberg
Bravo, Vince!
@@defonoteleazar4998Vravo Bince
It's good to see an Australian actor play an Australian character on American TV.
Hahahahaha exactly
There's the inner Sith of James Earl Jones peeking through...
The "what is an enemy to you" line was gold. Cant believe it was in an episode of house of all things
so many different ways to kill an sick, elderly man with no trace and he chose the dumbest one
hands up who would have murdered Hitler before the gassings before the wars if you say no your lying to yourself if you say yes congrats
@@Delta_Aves oh snap
That's why the best thing is to stay out of it. Haha, you try to take out someone who clearly needs to be stopped, and you become just as bad. And people complain, and you get in trouble, and everyone else gets to live happily, from the sacrifice someone else made. Not worth it to get involved haha
@@Delta_Aves You can apply the utilitarianism in any perspective and make it look good or bad.
@@Delta_AvesYes. Because the means are significantly less bloody, and the end much more peaceful.
@@Zevox144 WWII would still happen though. Hitler wasn’t the sole cause it.
In this case, yes, yes you can get away with killing another person. Good luck finding a jury that would prosecute him after learning what the guy was planning to do.
Problem is what the dictador's followers will react. They might become emboldened.
Unfortunately any jury would have no problem to prosecute him in court, even if the genocide was already committed. Also you go to court for a verdict and not for justice. That's the world we live in.
For those who want a more practical understanding of right and wrong:
Hospitals and doctors have an ethical obligation of neutrality. The phrase 'do no harm' is the standard. Even doctor assisted suicide when in great suffering could be considered illegal.
However, it is a political standpoint. Much like soldiers or politicians who can do the wrong thing only because it is their job and they can ignore most liability.
Neutrality can be a good thing, as showing mercy to your enemies is. However, neutrality is also a man-made construct. Implying we should act without responsibility or guilt for our actions ignores the human ability of free choice and praises actions that are autonomous and without bias.
He knew that his actions were unethical by the standards of a doctor, but he acted to save the lives of others. Doctors commonly assist in curing diseases or other issues. The dictator was one such disease. By removing the disease, he's saved many others.
I also saw it as that and boiled it down to just good people doing the right thing to prevent a disaster. Sure it is Chase's job as a doctor to treat patients and make sure they are back into a healthy state, but he's treating someone who can be very vile and cruel and massacre a lot of people once he's up and going.
Is it illegal to do what Chase did, oh most definitely so, and a scenario like that I doubt would really happen, but it was for the sake of saving a lot of lives.
Chase did not take an oath to defend the people of a foreign country he did take an oath to treat patient with the knowledge and care of a physician, even medics in war treat enemy soldiers because that is their duty. This is exactly why the common people have no faith in modern medicine.
And who tells us what right and wrong is? Who enforcers it the people or the government? Never the people
Well. There was a thing in Mass Effect 2. Mordin (a doctor/spy) tells that there is 2 ways to heal people. First by being a doctor and curing them. Second was removing those threaten lives of many.
@@onatyungul872 report to the ship soon as possible we’ll bang okay
One minute, he regrets what happened to an innocent woman, and then the next he says that it was "necessary"?
He’s full of it
You can regret doing something but still think it was necessary. Exactly like the doctor did. Obviously he thought it was necessary, but regrets it.
Psychopaths are incapable of regret. It’s a fundamental part of their pathology.
Cuz he’s a evil liar
Think about Thanos' situation with Gamora, he clearly regrets killing Gamora, but for the soul stone, its "necessary" for him
I'm just wondering what a defibrillator was supposed to do about internal hemorrhaging.
They turned heart into a roast chicken
I guess force it to keep pumping, idk
@@strider7198force to pump on a total stop? oh i forgot, its a show
they probably just wanted it to look like they were doing something
@@KyubiHitashi yeah I guess lol
I’m a doctor!, “ You are part of the rebel alliance and a traitor! “
Take him away!
Who better to play a dictator than Darth Vader himself? (Well, the voice of Darth Vader, that is)
When asked that question if I would be able to live with myself, no but at least hundreds of other individuals will. So I guess I won't need to live with myself, if that is the price I need to pay
I cannot live with myself. But at least two died rather than hundreds.
It also can be asked "if I would be able to live with myself if I let him live"
James Earl Jones is such a phenomenal actor he ate this role up!
But what happens after he is dead, won't his vice president or his successor simply follow up with the massacre?
As he said, his advisors and colonel preferred negotiations and treaties, hinting that he is pretty much the one gunning for the massacre and pushing for it to happen. With him gone, the others around him will continue negotiations and treaties.
@@openthinker6562 commented before I finished, thanks 😅
See, rebellion is only as strong as the rebels doing it.
K
"So they can sit and watch, like they did in Rwanda?" Just like they have sat and watched Myanmar, Armenia, Palestine and many more; these so called elected representatives of their respective peoples
New plan: Have them meet JFK
Wow… I honestly don’t know what I would do in their position with a man like that. I do know that creating Peace is ten times better than creating more enemies with more bloodshed, death with people struggling to make a living and supporting themselves or their families who are also defending their loved ones and their beliefs. Most if not all people in power are not the best to give orders. Thanks for uploading.
"I don't care what he would have done" does he not realize how MESSED UP that is? To only care about the person who put himself in your care, when his victims fundamentally COULD NOT do the same? To just ignore the consequences of your actions the moment they leave the operating room? Does he really expect that Chase could have let the man go, without spending the REST OF HIS LIFE feeling the weight, not of one life, but of hundreds of thousands on his shoulders?
the death of "hundreds of thousands" was not chase's choice or responsibility. his duty was to his patient, and not only did he failed it but he betrayed it.
@@kingrichardiii6280 How was it not? Seriously, explain this to me. He had the chance to prevent a _literal genocide,_ how was it not his choice or responsibility to do so? What makes his "duty" to a genocidal maniac, who was only his patient because he was rich enough to seek foreign medical aid, take precident over basic human decency?
@@johnathanmonsen6567 it is not about saving the most life or taking justice for yourself, but doing your duty. any time you work for the public in a professional setting your chief duty is for your patient. let me ask it like this. if a priest listens to the confession of a murderer who was never caught the priest has no right to report to the authorities, he has to honor his responsibility no matter what harm is caused by keeping the secret. same here chase's responsibility as a doctor is to treat the patient. the only instance i can think of that could happen is if a psychologist hears a threat against another during treating his patient, which case the therapist may have grounds to report to the proper authorities, not take matters in his own hands (chase reporting to the UN or the like as opposed to killing a patient under his care).
@@kingrichardiii6280 Actually, the priest thing doesn't really work. A priest can refuse absolution if he feels the confession is not actually in good faith. Alternatively, he can choose excommunication and tell anyone he wants about the murderer. Forgiveness for sin is not a get out of jail free card that most people think it is to the Catholics.
The thing is, your conflating the letter of the law with the spirit. Yeah, if a doctor did this in real life and got caught he'd no doubt lose his license and never practice again. You know what else would happen? Flood of support from people who are sick of people in power who can stamp all over other human life with no consequence. People would be setting up campaigns and money donations by the end of the day.
@@kingrichardiii6280i feel as if theres a seperation between doing what is right morally, versus doing what is right for your job/position. here, it’d be morally right for chass to have stopped that planned genocide. however. it’d have been right for his job to just help the patient, no question. in the end, i think the lives of other people are more important than a job or rules to uphold
You know, with a little bit of editing. This could be a super dark sequel to coming to America.
Hahaha
Elaborate, please.
@@HelghastStalker did you ever see that movie?
@@garganrose what are you talking about?
@@HelghastStalker the 1988 classic Eddie Murphy film coming to America
Stunning episode, really stayed with me.
Man James earl can play characters of many extremes.
The king of zamunda went bad
A shame that Akeem wasn’t there to take power.
Facts
It would have been kinda cool if Eddie Murphy walked into the room and said "Father, how do you feel?" and we find out that the dictator is actually the warm king from Coming to America, except now he's a tyrant.
I love cross overs
Or he was also a bloodthirsty dictator. Remember, in Coming to America, we only see inside the palace from their perspective.
Always, not also
Great thing you don’t write for television 💩
@@Kaede-Sasaki he was shocked to hear his son was working and even told his son to use the harem at his leisure and that he does all the time despite making it seem like he was faithful to his queen. Honestly you brought up a interesting idea
Chase was there to stop Vader from getting the youngling slayer 9000.
I have a huge respect for James Earl Jones, truly one of the all time legendary greats in the acting world...saw him most recently in Coming to America 2
He doesn't have to wear body armour or breathe heavily to scare the crap out of you . . ..
James Earl Jones one of my favorite actors.
james earl jones is always such a powerful presence in anything he's in. there's always this gravitas that not a lot of actors have.
Yoooo! They got James Earl Jones in this episode. He's a legend!
"I find your lack of determination disturbing.... Remember Chase, you are the Lion King... by CNN"
Best quote ever
James Earl is so great
chase eventually tells cameron and she leaves him because he just wants to pretend it never happened like house and foreman were so she says he is just as bad as house
Well she's a bit ch for that
@@BrennanCh06 Especially after basically telling him to do it.
@@sillydave5544I would respect her if she wasn't wanting to kill the guy.
Wow just stumbled on this clip this is a very interesting debate especially for a doctor. Great acting by James Earl Jones and everyone else
My father was a doctor and early in his training he had a John Doe patient who was in very bad shape. He treated the man for something like a month, bringing him back to health. When the man was released he took two steps out of the hospital and was arrested. One of the cops came up to my father and said "good job, doc. Now he's going to prison for the rest of his life." Turned out the guy was a murderer. My father said he'd wondered in he would have done the same thing if he'd known beforehand. He said he probably would. The doctor's Hippocratic oath is that important.
This episode is a good example of how good the show was. It deals often with moral dilemmas, it makes people human. I don’t believe for one second, that people who are evil killers, completely immoral. The scene where he points out that the practical versus the moral, and how it is difficult when it is you that must do it, when there is a gun involved. I applaud the show writers for including this, because it is never easy. I have never had to kill a person, but I don’t imagine it is for any sane human being Even the evil ones. 4:04
You guys forget James Earl Jones was also Thusla Doom, in Conan the Barbarian
And Vader :)
@@michaziomek and Mufasa
Man his performance was legendary in that film.
J E J knocking it out the park. Great voice work
Yeah, but bad African accent.
I absolutely loved this scene. The whole episode was amazing.
This is an awesome episode
Looks like he was not too afraid to act in his convictions.
This was a damn good House episode 👍
You save his life, wouldn’t you also be an accomplice? Decisions decisions.
flawless logic
When he said “rebels” I smiled
this is the moment where chase becomes heisenberg
And when evil is not stopped,you get the consequences.
The actor that portrayed the dictator is very great. I am pretty sure he can portray more dictators like Darth Vader
The dictator is a very good actor.
He’s Darth Vader
He’s Mufasa.
Following heroic path isn’t always heroic … this sentence has very deep meaning
Choose our dead door hits ideally
This was one of the best episodes of the series.
James Earl Jones was an amazing actor! What an incredible performance!
James earl jones. If it’s not Darth Vader he’s playing, it’s an African king
At least we know what happened to King Jaffe Joffer, Akeem's father and King of Zamunda at the end.
Fun fact, the aid of the Dictator is the voice of Achilles Davenport from AC 3
Only on a television drama do people pretend to care about killing a dictator or a mad man. These doctors in real life deal with death daily and would just do the deed and go on to the next patient without a qualm of remorse. One life in exchange for a hundred thousand; shrug, cop this you baskit.
Alt. Title: Darth Vader and Achilles Davenport run Rwanda.
I’m glad someone else recognised Achilles.
This one was one of the BEST episodes imo.. Even at the conclusion, I was partially like Yes! Chase did ti! Ad the other was like, its not supposed to be up to us..
The "batman paradox"
Why no unalive the joker if the joker has done so to thousands of people and will do it to thousands more...
You can’t shock asystole!
They needed to play The Empire March lol
I love that you csn still hear that Vader in his voice. Iconic
I wasn’t prepared to hear him say “rebels” and get hit with a wave of Star Wars nostalgia
I swear this scene wasn’t in “coming to America”
Chase is an idiot most times. But this time he's 100% in the right. Foreman's a coward
Damn...If I was Doctor's boss I would give him a raise instead!
"Instead" of what, House actually helped him get away with it lol
@@ghostwalk2446 I knew House would make the smart decision.
You are so moral. The world is blessed to have people like you
@@thejohnbeckcan't say the same for you.
The way he talks reminds me of James Earl Jones in coming to America
Perhaps he was always a bloodthirsty dictator. Remember, in Coming to America, we only see inside the palace from their perspective.
The dark sequel to a great Eddie Murphy comedy.
James Earl Jones masterclass of acting right there.
People like him dare others to kill them to be able to see it as a sign that they are doing the right things none else dares to do. They know it's wrong on some level, but justify themselves as giving the sacrifice none else is willing to do.
James Earl is king
The lion king Mufasa
6:46 Bro is literally Agent 47 💀 💀 💀
This is a case where they are both right and both wrong at the same time. However, one is more right than wrong.
The right thing and the correct thing are not always the same.
But that’s the king of zamunda
Is he talking about Netanyahu