True story. In 1977 I worked for the BBC as a sound engineer on this very recording. For production reasons, Paul sang this song three times at this session Each performance was as good as this one. Truly, an amazing artist.
That is amazing. Is there a cleaner copy of the audio to be found? I can listen to this over and over. Thank you for you work to capture this beautiful moment.
@@northwards2218 This programme was hosted by Andy Irvine and Paul Brady and was recorded in mono. They went on to record the song in stereo on an album entitled Andy Irvine/Paul Brady on Mulligan Music .Well worth a listen.
Many thanks for the prompt reply and direction. I will seek that out. And again, many thanks for being part of this lovely moment in many lives. God bless.
Hi Bob! I'm really obsessed with this live version. however, this youtube upload has a lot of very bad sounding digital artifacts. Do you know where I can find a cleaner version of this mono live version? you got any tapes laying around? I have a studio and can do the transfer. i've been searching high and low for it...but can't find. the studio stereo version is wonderful...but not the same ;)
@@philipweinrobe I agree, this version is really special. I know that we didn't record a "snoop" tape. As it was recorded 45 years ago the original material will be hard to locate. The original uploader says that his/her file was reduced to fit, contacting him/her might be an option. There are other versions on You Tube.
I'm not exactly sure where Paul Brady got this tune, but the only historical recording I could find that uses the same tune was a Scottish one from the 1930s. I cleaned up the audio as much as I could and featured it in this video: ua-cam.com/video/293fUgqyHAw/v-deo.html
In the worst of my daddy's dementia this song would stop him in his tracks and he was transfixed. Paul Brady is and will always be an absolute legend. This song is his masterpiece. No one else will ever come close ❤❤❤
What a lovely, touching post , thank you so much. My dear brother now has Alzheimers and loves Paul Brady also ...our parents were from Ireland....bless you for your words 💚💚☘
@@Martin-tn5lm I’m visiting Galway for the first time in a couple of months from now, and I am AMPED. There was a travel show on American TV that did an episode on Galway and in the segment on nightlife (craic), the host warned, “Do not try to keep up with the locals”. I’m going to try to keep up with the locals, at least once 😅
My oldest boy watched and listened to this video as a baby. Today he plays acoustic guitar, slide dobro, electric guitar, mandolin, ukulele, and drums. He often goes back to his irish songs he perfered over those typical nursery songs. What 10 years can do.
I'm 31, my father sang this to me as a baby. When my 2 girls were born, 11 and 7, I made sure this was the first song I ever sang to them. This is the first song they ever heard, straight from Paul Brady. I love this song deeply.
Many yrars later, many's a tune, many's a singer who had made their effort, there is no-one nowhere, who can better this. Streaming, vocals the whole she-bang... this is life... ladies and gents,. Mr Paul Brady, legend.....
Do you think he knew he nailed every last second of this rendition with both vocals and guitar at the time? How he holds onto "charming" at the end of the first verse and how he sings "same" in the second verse is just talent beyond belief. I have proudly watched this video dozens of times.
I reckon he nailed it everytime he played it. That's just the nature of a genius. This one happened to be captured, but I bet the rest of the performances went equally as "charming".
The song is probably English and Scottish, not Irish (as you can see here www.vwml.org/search?q=rn2355&is=1). I'm not exactly sure where Paul Brady got this tune, but the only historical recording I could find that uses the same tune was a Scottish one from the 1930s. I cleaned up the audio as much as I could and featured it in this video: ua-cam.com/video/293fUgqyHAw/v-deo.html
@@TheFolkRevivalProject In this video, ua-cam.com/video/cpgU6ly5GlY/v-deo.html Paul explains finding the song in a Library of Congress book called "The Songs of Carrie Grover." Here is a recording of her from 1941: carriegroverproject.com/title/arthur-mcbride/
Totally with you on your "same" comment. What is best is not so much that he masters these ornamentations, but that he uses them to express the feelings he finds in the song. It is all about the music in the heart.
As the economy is being trampled into the ground and the country is being flooded with foreigners. Enjoy the song because this type of Irish culture won’t be around for much longer if things don’t change.
My grandad passed away today I can remember he told me he always listened to his cds on the bus rides wherever he went and this was his favourite song, hopefully it’s his favourite song of all time because this song is how I’m going to remember him. Fuck cancer
Having watched many a singer songwriter perform live on this forum from Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, John Martyn etc, I can honestly say that this is the best example of a true artist who has mastered his craft. The guitar playing is sublime and the singing is beyond that. A beautiful rendition of a fantastic song from a genius of a musician.
Anything wrong in just loving this outstanding piece of music? I´ve been listening to this song for more than 40 years now and I never got tired of it. I never will. Greetings from Hamburg, Germany and wishing for peace all over the world.
This is astonishing. I saw him perform it in October 1975 when he replaced Christy Moore in Planxty. FOURTY FOUR YEARS later I remember that thrill. It might be the single best song I have ever heard.
There are things that this man is doing with his voice in this video that haven't been done before it, and haven't been done since. This is an absolutely mastery of melisma, pitching, phrasing, the lot. I have absolutely no earthly idea how a person can sing that way.
My best guess is that Paul was surrounded by a lot of Sean Nós singers growing up. When he sings "same" it's almost like he's cradling it with his voice. A lot of the phrasing and pitch he uses is very similar to sean nós singing, a very old Irish style of singing and all in Irish, absolutely spellbinding when sung right. There's a 17 minute video from St Patricks Festival that you might find worth a wee listen.
@@bluecurlygirl It's called a trill, very common in folk music from all over these islands but the gaels have certainly mastered it. It's ornamentation that is found in lots of Sean Nós as you say
@@artseosamhogriobhta Not exactly. A "trill" is simply the alteration of two notes repeatedly and quickly. A melisma is technically any one syllable that's sung with several notes, so it's a catch-all term for many different ornaments. While a vocal trill would be a type of melisma, trills (extended ones, at least) are far more common on instruments because it's much easier to do than with the voice. What he's doing here is a melisma, but it's not just a trill, because it involves more than just two pitches. It's closer to another type of ornament called a "turn," which involves three notes: the principal note, a note above, and a note below. What he sings exactly on "same" (I slowed it down to half speed) is E - F - E - F - E - D, where the first E - F - E happens together, and then the F - E - D happens together. Of course, these groupings are much harder to hear at full speed, but at half speed, they're quite clear. Anyway, so, while it is a melisma, it's not just a trill; it's closer to a turn. On a side note, it's absolutely ASTONISHING how spot on his pitch is throughout (including this melisma) even at half speed. What an incredible talent.
Thank you for explaining. I didn't know it was that complicated. It's very common ornamentation in Irish music. So now I know it isn't a trill but a turn. We'd grown up learning it was called a trill, more of a watch and repeat kind of deal without understanding any of the fundamentals. As others have mentioned, it's very common here in folk music styles like Sean Nós. @@chadjohnson-authormusician8072
I love this song so much. It really illustrates in stark relief the absurdity of peaceable, free men being recruited to die in someone else's stupid war.
Mind boggling how he can play such a complicated piece and sing so passionately and freely at the same time. I'd say he'd be some man doing the household chores.
Multitasking abilities, drinking a pint of Guinness and a whiskey chaser after it, along with the quick wit of a good storey or a song, years of practice
don’t mean to be a stuck up ass but it’s really not a complicated piece at all. It’s in open G that gives it that magical presence. The intro is a handful but overall the song is rather easy going on... the hands anyway. The vocals are what really takes the show in my opinion.
Wow. Never heard this guy before. At the beginning I was just thinking "this is some pretty nice guitar playing," then he opens his mouth and - what a voice! Great song, too.
I'm not exactly sure where Paul Brady got this tune, but the only historical recording I could find that uses the same tune was a Scottish one from the 1930s. I cleaned up the audio as much as I could and featured it in this video: ua-cam.com/video/293fUgqyHAw/v-deo.html
In 1975 I had the great experience of being Planxty's UK tour driver. Their support was the wonderful Steve Ashley. I had not been exposed to Irish folk music before. I became a fan immediately. Andy Irvine, Paul Brady, Liam O'Flyn and Jonny Moynahan. I didn't realise at the beginning of the tour how popular they were already in the UK. They were also really good company. Watched Paul play this every night. Always got a huge response from the audiences. Paul played a Yamaha acoustic and changed strings before every performance. I think his guitar tuning on this was DADGAD.
I've watched and enjoyed this video so many times but have never noticed how superb Paul's breathing is! He can singing two or three phrases without an intake of breath! A real singer/ musician in every sense and still as good today as he was in '77.
Once again it happens..!? After so many listenings to this song, as I'm marveling at the gorgeous guitar work in that open G, he comes in singing and the hair on my neck stands up straight, I'm usually driven to tears, not by the words, but by the emotion in his voice. As great as the guitar work is, and it's as good as I've ever heard in this genre, his singing here is magnificent , as great an instrument as I've ever heard regardless of genre. For many years my favorite singer was Kenneth McKellar, and I add Brady to the short two person list
As I was listening to this for probably the 100th time right now, I was thinking the exact same thing: the voice of his singing here is absolutely marvellous, easy though it may be to sort of miss that because of how beautiful the guitar playing is at the same time.
Ind4ed, if this were all he ever had done he would be up there with the finest acoustic musicians. But he did seminal work with the Johnstons and wrote The Island and on and on. A true Irish icon.
Guys, please listen to me: This is absolute master class of musicianship. Listen carefully: The fabulous guitar playing, the singing, both together, the lyrics, everything. I don't know how to express this, since it's indescribable. Just listen and you'll see what real music is like.
This is why life is worth living. What a talent. History and music intertwined. 'Sir' Paul Brady you are truly a legend. I cannot figure out how I grew up in Ireland for over 40 years without hearing this. Just baffles me.. Its farking beautiful
download77 for this kind of song that’s what good but I do see why most pop singers have stupid gimmicks in concerts Need to keep the crowds attention somehow
I love this song, I love the island of Ireland and I love being Scottish because we are the same, they will never take that away from us, I am a Gàidhlig speaker, us Celts. I play this on Christmas morning. We'll all get there ; Scotland and Ireland forever!
Oh, me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride As we went a-walking down by the seaside Now, mark what followed and what did betide For it being on Christmas morning... Out for recreation, we went on a tramp And we met Sergeant Napper and Corporal Vamp And a little wee drummer, intending to camp For the day being pleasant and charming. "Good morning! Good morning!" the sergeant did cry "And the same to you gentlemen!" we did reply, Intending no harm but meant to pass by For it being on Christmas morning. But says he, "My fine fellows if you will enlist, It's ten guineas in gold I will slip in your fist And a crown in the bargain for to kick up the dust And drink the King's health in the morning. For a soldier he leads a very fine life And he always is blessed with a charming young wife And he pays all his debts without sorrow or strife And always lives pleasant and charming... And a soldier he always is decent and clean In the finest of clothing he's constantly seen While other poor fellows go dirty and mean And sup on thin gruel in the morning." "But", says Arthur, "I wouldn't be proud of your clothes For you've only the lend of them as I suppose And you dare not change them one night, for you know If you do you'll be flogged in the morning. And although that we are single and free We take great delight in our own company And we have no desire strange faces to see Although that your offers are charming And we have no desire to take your advance All hazards and dangers we barter on chance For you would have no scruples for to send us to France Where we would get shot without warning" "Oh now!", says the sergeant "I'll have no such chat And I neither will take it from spalpeen or brat For if you insult me with one other word I'll cut off your heads in the morning" And then Arthur and I we soon drew our hods And we scarce gave them time for to draw their own blades When a trusty shillelagh came over their heads And bade them take that as fair warning And their old rusty rapiers that hung by their side We flung them as far as we could in the tide "Now take them out, Divils!", cried Arthur McBride "And temper their edge in the morning". And the little wee drummer we flattened his pow And we made a football of his rowdeydowdow Threw it in the tide for to rock and to row And bade it a tedious returning And we having no money, paid them off in cracks And we paid no respect to their two bloody backs For we lathered them there like a pair of wet sacks And left them for dead in the morning. And so to conclude and to finish disputes We obligingly asked if they wanted recruits For we were the lads who would give them hard clouts And bid them look sharp in the morning. Oh me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride As we went a walkin' down by the seaside, Now mark what followed and what did betide For it being on Christmas morning
I am 61 and first heard this in '76 and am back… Hard to believe I heard this on the same FM station as Led Zepplin-back in the dasy when DJ's played what they wanted! Cheers, from Toronto
I couldn't agree more, I find this in turn calming, thought provoking and clever. I particularly love hearing him virtually spit 'spalpeen or brat'. SO good.
He's so magical ..I knew him in the Johnston's Trad days....I was so lucky to have brushed elbows with them..Loved them all.Still do...Rip Adrienne . x
one of my favourite vocalists of all time. theres something about the great folk singers thats so pure, so captivating and...real that very few others can compete with. no gimmicks, just timeless perfect music
The seminal version - without a shadow- the hairs on the back of my neck have no control every time I hear this - wistful, meaningful and most of all, from the heart!
I have sensory processing issues. This performance is SO good that the physical pain I feel in my head from that high pitched noise is still worth bearing to listen to this over and over again. It's literally so good I go through pain to listen to it. Holy crap.
My sweetheart share his favorite Irish album with me when we were separated by miles and no cellphones...I fell in love with this piece and after sweet 16 years of marriage, just Googled it and found it...had been looking for years!
I love at 3:21 the combination of what he does on the guitar (the two repeated chords) and how he sings the lyric ‘for you’ve only the lend of them as I suppose.’ The two rhythms are so independent.
I actually believe that's a mistake in an otherwise flawless performance. If you're playing this yourself you should just play the verse as it's played before and after that verse.
When I first heard the great Paul Brady perform this it was approx 1997 on my local NPR radio station, WGBH (BTW much thanks to the one and only Brian O'Donovan, for all the amazing celtic music over the years!). When I first heard this tune I thought it was "nice" and very listenable. But over the years (decades) I have grown to appreciate this as a true masterpiece. PB's phrasing, his accent, his high voice, his accent, his unparalleled subtle and sublime guitar playing - all of these grew on me year after year. There are countless moments in this performance that are brilliant, subtle or sublime.
The reality of press gangs in times past is something a lot of us might fully appreciate. You could be beaten, abducted and forced into service into one of Britain's many wars, never to be seen again by your loved ones. It's sobering to think of the families of men who died in foreign lands after being pressed into service, never knowing what happened to their sons, brothers or husbands. I've always loved the contempt of this song for the warmongering recruiters, for each man shouldn't have to fight and die for any King's cause or any foreign lands other than his own.
Oh, me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride As we went a-walking down by the seaside Now, mark what followed and what did betide For it being on Christmas morning... Out for recreation, we went on a tramp And we met Sergeant Napper and Corporal Vamp And a little wee drummer, intending to camp For the day being pleasant and charming "Good morning ! Good morning!" the sergeant did cry "And the same to you gentlemen!" we did reply Intending no harm but meant to pass by For it being on Christmas morning But says he, "My fine fellows if you will enlist It's ten guineas in gold I will slip in your fist And a crown in the bargain for to kick up the dust And drink the King's health in the morning For a soldier he leads a very fine life And he always is blessed with a charming young wife And he pays all his debts without sorrow or strife And always lives pleasant and charming... And a soldier he always is decent and clean In the finest of clothing he's constantly seen While other poor fellows go dirty and mean And sup on thin gruel in the morning." "But", says Arthur, "I wouldn't be proud of your clothes For you've only the lend of them as I suppose And you dare not change them one night, for you know If you do you'll be flogged in the morning And although that we are single and free We take great delight in our own company And we have no desire strange faces to see Although that your offers are charming And we have no desire to take your advance All hazards and dangers we barter on chance For you would have no scruples for to send us to France Where we would get shot without warning" "Oh now!", says the sergeant "I'll have no such chat And I neither will take it from spalpeen or brat For if you insult me with one other word I'll cut off your heads in the morning" And then Arthur and I we soon drew our hods And we scarce gave them time for to draw their own blades When a trusty shillelagh came over their heads And bade them take that as fair warning And their old rusty rapiers that hung by their side We flung them as far as we could in the tide "Now take them out, Divils!", cried Arthur McBride "And temper their edge in the morning" And the little wee drummer we flattened his pow And we made a football of his rowdeydowdow Threw it in the tide for to rock and to row And bade it a tedious returning And we having no money, paid them off in cracks And we paid no respect to their two bloody backs For we lathered them there like a pair of wet sacks And left them for dead in the morning And so to conclude and to finish disputes We obligingly asked if they wanted recruits For we were the lads who would give them hard clouts And bid them look sharp in the morning Oh me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride As we went a walkin' down by the seaside Now mark what followed and what did betide For it being on Christmas morning
When we hear this masterfully performed, and frankly masterfully written song...we are seeing back in time. To how most people were entertained before electricity. The thing is, its still more capturing than anything in the electrical medium. Its had thousands of years of a headstart over the electrical medium.
One of the most perfect performances - in terms of execution and conviction - ever committed to tape. A genius and to be compared with the very greatest of his time.
A once very dear friend introduced me to this song about 10 years ago. We had a falling out over where we were going to drink a beer (of all things) I often come here to listen to this song and think of him. I usually shed a tear like I am now. He moved backed to Ireland and has blocked me on social media, so I know I'm dead to him. I miss you Dave, & I still love ya. I hope all in life is going well.
I'm paraphrasing my Dad here but he's talked a lot about the influence and impact this guitar arrangement had when Paul first started playing it in the Dublin folk clubs, it just stood out and set a new standard among all the guitarists in the scene, my Dad included. 'Tour de Force' is the perfect phrase for how he's described it, with all the guitarsts watching every note and complete silence, pin-drop silence from the audience.
The little vibrato accents he puts on some of those notes are so subtle and easily overlooked in efforts to replicate Brady's music. That kind of thing only comes when everything else you are doing is automatic. The finishing details on a masterpiece arrangement.
Holy shit! 100MB or not... this is spectacular. A voice and an acoustic guitar and it is 100 times more powerful than almost anything on the radio these days.
Ahhhh Arthur rebel of all the rebels. Fearless. Such sweet, melodic sounding madness. Brady & Irvine album from 1976. The best of Ireland. Just joyous with history, heart, and intellect in music.
I was born in 1977, so this performance is as old as me!! LOL I grew up to this song and other Irish fabulous tunes throughout the whole 80's and I believe it gave me a certain sensitivity, notably to folk music in general... My dad would play the tape in the car on each of our long trips through France up to Brittany and back, and it's only last year I discovered the name of the artist, his face, the date. Thanks to UA-cam! I'm moved to see how much people seem to love this song like I do :-)
Just bought this CD (Andy Irvine and Paul Brady) --long ago had the vinyl but no longer have a working turntable. So grateful it just fell into my hands again in this format. Many fine serendipities. This is so compelling a song and singer. I searched two years to find out who recorded this back in the early 80's. Had heard a cassette of a Thistle and Shamrock show that included this song but the attribution was missing. I wore out the record, frequently come to UA-cam to watch the video. It just doesn't ever get old. Hits me the same way every time I hear it.
First heard this song 10 years ago on a tour bus in Ireland the wife and kids were asleep. I was awake looking at the beauty of the country song has stuck with me ever since
frigging brilliant. Double stops , incredible playing., perfect diction and timing. This is probably my favourite folk-y song. It never gets stale, I listen to it over and over. The movie is fun also.
I just discovered Paul Brady today on St Patricks Day....I am blown away...your singing brings tears to my eyes.between your playing and your glorious voice there is nothing better...
I bought the album in '76 and there was just the photo of him and Andy Irvine. I feel blessed that the same FM station that was playing Led Zepplin played this album-back when DJ's played what they wanted-and blessed to have UA-cam and this concert footage (for free!) when I am 61. Cheers, from Toronto
I Hadn’t Heard This Before Today. But It’s Absolutely Marvellous !. All Comes Together Here. Splendid Guitar, Forceful, But Wistful Vocal. A Wonderful Performance. And a timeless masterpiece. It will never, ever, be bettered.
Just listened to this song for the first time. Bloody brilliant. The only other time I'd heard of this genius was his song "nobody knows" Just as good guitar player as Richard Thompson I'd say. (& I'm not even Irish) !
Lightning struck twice for me in 2019. I got to see Paul perform this at two separate concerts, both of them very special, the first was with Andy Irvine at Bord Gais (although he performed it alone, exactly as here) and the second was as a duet with Rufus Wainwright at NCH, taking a verse each throughout the song. Both performances were just outstanding, and also very special to me as I was them with my Dad, who introduced me to the song when I was a child and always preferred when Paul would perform it this way, no accompaniment except that incredibly intricate acoustic guitar arrangement.
Been listening to this for 30 years and never get tired of it, got the album in vinyl and listened constantly until turntable gave up. Fortunately got the Liberty Tapes on CD excellent live performances. The man is a genius and doesn't get the credit he deserves, Strabanes best export!!!
It's amazing. It's not just celtic, it's also reminiscent of the way that middle eastern singers can do those crazy trills between multiple notes over and over. Elite level stuff.
it is Sean Nos but more specific the Ulster strain of Sean Nos, it's less 'celtic', the melisma used at 1:24 is much more common, it's earthier almost like gospel or soul singing. Sean Nos purists would be disgusted at this, but it's not too far away from Mariah Carey's melismatic style.
He is a musical wizard. He actually started performing songs while accompanying himself on piano. In addition to his performances, such as this wonderful video, I was seated a couple of feet from him in the mid 80’s in Sligo as he sang beautifully while playing piano. He’s also a great story teller.
I love the fact that, only 2 years after this platform got started, when there was relatively so little that could be found here, good Mick Connell took the time to upload (and apologize for now-nonexistent upload limits!) these priceless, precious bits of folk culture. Thank you, sir.
I can't believe that 38 years have flown past since I first heard Paul Brady perform this amazing version of Arthur McBride. A brilliant performance Mr. Brady!
I had a girlfriend in Seattle who was aware of the whole UK/ Irish scene. I play, and thought that the blues were the end-all for music, but when she turned me on to Irish stuff particularyly, I was blown away by the open tunings and stories. Great, Paul Brady!!
True story. In 1977 I worked for the BBC as a sound engineer on this very recording. For production reasons, Paul sang this song three times at this session Each performance was as good as this one. Truly, an amazing artist.
That is amazing. Is there a cleaner copy of the audio to be found? I can listen to this over and over. Thank you for you work to capture this beautiful moment.
@@northwards2218 This programme was hosted by Andy Irvine and Paul Brady and was recorded in mono. They went on to record the song in stereo on an album entitled Andy Irvine/Paul Brady on Mulligan Music .Well worth a listen.
Many thanks for the prompt reply and direction. I will seek that out. And again, many thanks for being part of this lovely moment in many lives. God bless.
Hi Bob! I'm really obsessed with this live version. however, this youtube upload has a lot of very bad sounding digital artifacts. Do you know where I can find a cleaner version of this mono live version? you got any tapes laying around? I have a studio and can do the transfer. i've been searching high and low for it...but can't find. the studio stereo version is wonderful...but not the same ;)
@@philipweinrobe I agree, this version is really special. I know that we didn't record a "snoop" tape. As it was recorded 45 years ago the original material will be hard to locate. The original uploader says that his/her file was reduced to fit, contacting him/her might be an option. There are other versions on You Tube.
Let not the enchanting vocals and charming storytelling blind you, this is a masterclass in acoustic guitar playing....
Ireland is the home of music
A true master of his craft
I'm not exactly sure where Paul Brady got this tune, but the only historical recording I could find that uses the same tune was a Scottish one from the 1930s. I cleaned up the audio as much as I could and featured it in this video:
ua-cam.com/video/293fUgqyHAw/v-deo.html
no it isn't
@@TheFolkRevivalProject cmon now you've already been told off
@@TheFolkRevivalProject will I go copy and paste what I said the the last one?
In the worst of my daddy's dementia this song would stop him in his tracks and he was transfixed. Paul Brady is and will always be an absolute legend. This song is his masterpiece. No one else will ever come close ❤❤❤
What a lovely, touching post , thank you so much. My dear brother now has Alzheimers and loves Paul Brady also ...our parents were from Ireland....bless you for your words 💚💚☘
A legend!!! From west Ireland.
@@theresacarr1758 Your reply is equally as touching.
@@Martin-tn5lm I’m visiting Galway for the first time in a couple of months from now, and I am AMPED.
There was a travel show on American TV that did an episode on Galway and in the segment on nightlife (craic), the host warned, “Do not try to keep up with the locals”.
I’m going to try to keep up with the locals, at least once 😅
Your words hit me hard! Such a beautiful picture ❤
My oldest boy watched and listened to this video as a baby. Today he plays acoustic guitar, slide dobro, electric guitar, mandolin, ukulele, and drums. He often goes back to his irish songs he perfered over those typical nursery songs. What 10 years can do.
I'm 31, my father sang this to me as a baby. When my 2 girls were born, 11 and 7, I made sure this was the first song I ever sang to them. This is the first song they ever heard, straight from Paul Brady. I love this song deeply.
Many yrars later, many's a tune, many's a singer who had made their effort, there is no-one nowhere, who can better this. Streaming, vocals the whole she-bang... this is life... ladies and gents,. Mr Paul Brady, legend.....
Do you think he knew he nailed every last second of this rendition with both vocals and guitar at the time? How he holds onto "charming" at the end of the first verse and how he sings "same" in the second verse is just talent beyond belief. I have proudly watched this video dozens of times.
Genius
I reckon he nailed it everytime he played it. That's just the nature of a genius. This one happened to be captured, but I bet the rest of the performances went equally as "charming".
Simply a genius. Brilliant. Gerry Farry 🇮🇪🎸🎶🎤💚🇮🇪
"I have proudly watched this video dozens of times"
ME TOOO!!!
He is using his voice as another instrument in those places - I imagine it just comes naturally each time (as Neil says below).
Good Lord , it's just ..... well if your here and listening you already know ...
The song is probably English and Scottish, not Irish (as you can see here www.vwml.org/search?q=rn2355&is=1). I'm not exactly sure where Paul Brady got this tune, but the only historical recording I could find that uses the same tune was a Scottish one from the 1930s. I cleaned up the audio as much as I could and featured it in this video:
ua-cam.com/video/293fUgqyHAw/v-deo.html
@@TheFolkRevivalProject In this video, ua-cam.com/video/cpgU6ly5GlY/v-deo.html Paul explains finding the song in a Library of Congress book called "The Songs of Carrie Grover."
Here is a recording of her from 1941: carriegroverproject.com/title/arthur-mcbride/
@@danieltompkins3072 Thanks so much! I was trying to research it properly but reached a dead end.
@@TheFolkRevivalProject Glad I could help!
Indeed. Know exactly what you mean.
The way he sings 'same' at 1:24 is absolute magic.
In my opinion it's not the pinnacle in an otherwise fantastic song!
Totally with you on your "same" comment. What is best is not so much that he masters these ornamentations, but that he uses them to express the feelings he finds in the song. It is all about the music in the heart.
nice to see another who finds happiness in some small, seemingly insignificant portion of a tune..
I played the “same” part for my wife 4 times and...well I’m glad to find others that care about such things.
I can only describe that it sounds like water flowing over stones in a river
One of the silver linings of lockdown is to be able to take the time to remind yourself of masterpieces like this.
lol
As the economy is being trampled into the ground and the country is being flooded with foreigners. Enjoy the song because this type of Irish culture won’t be around for much longer if things don’t change.
@@eoink8387 well said mo chara
You got it right, just catching up and remembering too. Good health, Slainte
@@1dulchie113 tha neil
I never get tired of this. Six minutes and fifty two seconds of human civilisation at its finest.
I did not believe it was half that long, and had to check the timestamp, it seemed to go by like that. A privelege to see such a level of artistry
"Civilization at its finest." Indeed sir. I feel the same about your comment. Pithy perfection.
Found this last night. I've listened no less than 40 times in the last 24 hours.
+American Deluxe Fair play, this some song....Greetings from Ireland
good on ya
welcome to paradise my friend
American Deluxe is that all.
I too have found myself in this majestic infinite loop! Having just discovered Paul Brady I am in awe.
My grandad passed away today I can remember he told me he always listened to his cds on the bus rides wherever he went and this was his favourite song, hopefully it’s his favourite song of all time because this song is how I’m going to remember him. Fuck cancer
Your grandad was clearly a very discerning gentleman of exquisite taste in music . May he rest in peace 🙏
I agree FUCK CANCER!!! I lost my mother and brother to it..
Having watched many a singer songwriter perform live on this forum from Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, John Martyn etc, I can honestly say that this is the best example of a true artist who has mastered his craft. The guitar playing is sublime and the singing is beyond that. A beautiful rendition of a fantastic song from a genius of a musician.
Paul Brady, a great one of Ireland who represents each one of us beautifully and graciously with such music and song.
☘️☘️☘️
Anything wrong in just loving this outstanding piece of music? I´ve been listening to this song for more than 40 years now and I never got tired of it. I never will. Greetings from Hamburg, Germany and wishing for peace all over the world.
Every single year on this holy day of St. Patrick, I listen with eyes closed and dram in hand 🥰 🇮🇪☘️💚
One of the greatest performances you will ever see, Brady is a legend. This is superb.
This is astonishing. I saw him perform it in October 1975 when he replaced Christy Moore in Planxty. FOURTY FOUR YEARS later I remember that thrill. It might be the single best song I have ever heard.
There are things that this man is doing with his voice in this video that haven't been done before it, and haven't been done since. This is an absolutely mastery of melisma, pitching, phrasing, the lot. I have absolutely no earthly idea how a person can sing that way.
My best guess is that Paul was surrounded by a lot of Sean Nós singers growing up. When he sings "same" it's almost like he's cradling it with his voice. A lot of the phrasing and pitch he uses is very similar to sean nós singing, a very old Irish style of singing and all in Irish, absolutely spellbinding when sung right. There's a 17 minute video from St Patricks Festival that you might find worth a wee listen.
@@bluecurlygirl It's called a trill, very common in folk music from all over these islands but the gaels have certainly mastered it. It's ornamentation that is found in lots of Sean Nós as you say
@@artseosamhogriobhta This style of singing is distinctively Irish ,as described.
@@artseosamhogriobhta Not exactly. A "trill" is simply the alteration of two notes repeatedly and quickly. A melisma is technically any one syllable that's sung with several notes, so it's a catch-all term for many different ornaments. While a vocal trill would be a type of melisma, trills (extended ones, at least) are far more common on instruments because it's much easier to do than with the voice.
What he's doing here is a melisma, but it's not just a trill, because it involves more than just two pitches. It's closer to another type of ornament called a "turn," which involves three notes: the principal note, a note above, and a note below.
What he sings exactly on "same" (I slowed it down to half speed) is E - F - E - F - E - D, where the first E - F - E happens together, and then the F - E - D happens together. Of course, these groupings are much harder to hear at full speed, but at half speed, they're quite clear. Anyway, so, while it is a melisma, it's not just a trill; it's closer to a turn.
On a side note, it's absolutely ASTONISHING how spot on his pitch is throughout (including this melisma) even at half speed. What an incredible talent.
Thank you for explaining. I didn't know it was that complicated. It's very common ornamentation in Irish music. So now I know it isn't a trill but a turn. We'd grown up learning it was called a trill, more of a watch and repeat kind of deal without understanding any of the fundamentals. As others have mentioned, it's very common here in folk music styles like Sean Nós. @@chadjohnson-authormusician8072
I love this song so much. It really illustrates in stark relief the absurdity of peaceable, free men being recruited to die in someone else's stupid war.
David Matthew Shere exactly...
@@TheFolkRevivalProject "someone elses war" still applies even if it is scottish or english in origin...
Mind boggling how he can play such a complicated piece and sing so passionately and freely at the same time. I'd say he'd be some man doing the household chores.
And remember all those lyrics
He’d be some man emptying a dishwasher!
Multitasking abilities, drinking a pint of Guinness and a whiskey chaser after it, along with the quick wit of a good storey or a song, years of practice
don’t mean to be a stuck up ass but it’s really not a complicated piece at all. It’s in open G that gives it that magical presence. The intro is a handful but overall the song is rather easy going on... the hands anyway. The vocals are what really takes the show in my opinion.
Ha ) ...I don't do servants! ..
It wouldn't be Christmas morning without a quick blast of Arthur McBride from the peerless Paul Brady. Merry Christmas everybody.
by bob dylan, what a christmas to be be told!?
Merry christmas friend
Happy Christmas to you too.
And Merry Christmas to all of you!
Always have to give it a listen on Christmas day
Wow. Never heard this guy before. At the beginning I was just thinking "this is some pretty nice guitar playing," then he opens his mouth and - what a voice! Great song, too.
I'm not exactly sure where Paul Brady got this tune, but the only historical recording I could find that uses the same tune was a Scottish one from the 1930s. I cleaned up the audio as much as I could and featured it in this video:
ua-cam.com/video/293fUgqyHAw/v-deo.html
Bruce Bodden legend.
@@TheFolkRevivalProject no
Would you ever fuck off no one asked you
There is actually something magical with this song and Paul’s voice , of all the songs I love there’s just something else in this one
I agree
Yes, he nails it with this. I love this song.
Spellbinding, simply pure magic.
If this were any more beautiful, I don’t think I could bear it.
428 thumbs down!! Have you no musical bones in your body to thumbs down this absolute masterpiece of talent!!
Those 428 are everything that’s wrong with this world
@@patdainel9037 ulster loyalists.
Obviously had their phone upside down when giving a like..
In 1975 I had the great experience of being Planxty's UK tour driver. Their support was the wonderful Steve Ashley. I had not been exposed to Irish folk music before. I became a fan immediately. Andy Irvine, Paul Brady, Liam O'Flyn and Jonny Moynahan. I didn't realise at the beginning of the tour how popular they were already in the UK. They were also really good company. Watched Paul play this every night. Always got a huge response from the audiences. Paul played a Yamaha acoustic and changed strings before every performance. I think his guitar tuning on this was DADGAD.
Open g
@@jamesmulhern1355 yes, my bad knowledge of open tunings.
That must be why start sounds like Led Zeppelin
Amazing. I love this song and Paul Brady is just the best.
I've watched and enjoyed this video so many times but have never noticed how superb Paul's breathing is! He can singing two or three phrases without an intake of breath! A real singer/ musician in every sense and still as good today as he was in '77.
stunningly good..probably the best solo guitar and voice performance i have ever heard
Watched him live at Grand Opera House Belfast in the 70s. The man can make the guitar sing. What a player.
I've listened to this over two dozen times in the last 24 hours. Magic.
as have I mate
,pure magic Paul Brady
Same Ruaidhrí a chara.
I’ve been listening for 49 years!
@@TheFolkRevivalProject no
Once again it happens..!? After so many listenings to this song, as I'm marveling at the gorgeous guitar work in that open G, he comes in singing and the hair on my neck stands up straight, I'm usually driven to tears, not by the words, but by the emotion in his voice. As great as the guitar work is, and it's as good as I've ever heard in this genre, his singing here is magnificent , as great an instrument as I've ever heard regardless of genre. For many years my favorite singer was Kenneth McKellar, and I add Brady to the short two person list
As I was listening to this for probably the 100th time right now, I was thinking the exact same thing: the voice of his singing here is absolutely marvellous, easy though it may be to sort of miss that because of how beautiful the guitar playing is at the same time.
Dolores Keane is on my list as well! Check out Craigie Hills, she's like the Paul Brady of Irish singers
The pace of playing such an intricate rhythm whilst singing is insane to me. Always come back to this even years later, amazing
It is almost incomprehensible how good this is... absolutely jaw dropping
Astounding
Ind4ed, if this were all he ever had done he would be up there with the finest acoustic musicians. But he did seminal work with the Johnstons and wrote The Island and on and on. A true Irish icon.
Guys, please listen to me: This is absolute master class of musicianship.
Listen carefully: The fabulous guitar playing, the singing, both together, the lyrics, everything. I don't know how to express this, since it's indescribable. Just listen and you'll see what real music is like.
I am completely obsessed with this song. His voice 😍😍😍 and guitar arrangements melt me!
This is why life is worth living. What a talent. History and music intertwined.
'Sir' Paul Brady you are truly a legend.
I cannot figure out how I grew up in Ireland for over 40 years without hearing this. Just baffles me..
Its farking beautiful
This is the 'Die Hard' of christmas tunes
full lol
I know this is from a year ago but you are entirely right
You're not wrong!
@@schmoyoho what the fuck
Me da shared this with me many moons ago , its a gem !!
Fine, particularly fine. No pyrotechnics, no gimmicks, no gyrations, just talent honed by practice and joy.
download77 for this kind of song that’s what good but I do see why most pop singers have stupid gimmicks in concerts
Need to keep the crowds attention somehow
I felt the one thing missing from this performance was a gyration or two
B hi
So natural, perfectly understated performance!
I love this song, I love the island of Ireland and I love being Scottish because we are the same, they will never take that away from us, I am a Gàidhlig speaker, us Celts. I play this on Christmas morning. We'll all get there ; Scotland and Ireland forever!
A lán grá, sláinte agus sáistainach air tú féin agus do clann buíochas le Día Caoimhínn a mac.
🏴🇮🇪🏴🇮🇪
i do the same every christmas morn
Thig ar latha, gu dearbh!
youre a sound man Kevin
Oh, me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride
As we went a-walking down by the seaside
Now, mark what followed and what did betide
For it being on Christmas morning...
Out for recreation, we went on a tramp
And we met Sergeant Napper and Corporal Vamp
And a little wee drummer, intending to camp
For the day being pleasant and charming.
"Good morning! Good morning!" the sergeant did cry
"And the same to you gentlemen!" we did reply,
Intending no harm but meant to pass by
For it being on Christmas morning.
But says he, "My fine fellows if you will enlist,
It's ten guineas in gold I will slip in your fist
And a crown in the bargain for to kick up the dust
And drink the King's health in the morning.
For a soldier he leads a very fine life
And he always is blessed with a charming young wife
And he pays all his debts without sorrow or strife
And always lives pleasant and charming...
And a soldier he always is decent and clean
In the finest of clothing he's constantly seen
While other poor fellows go dirty and mean
And sup on thin gruel in the morning."
"But", says Arthur, "I wouldn't be proud of your clothes
For you've only the lend of them as I suppose
And you dare not change them one night, for you know
If you do you'll be flogged in the morning.
And although that we are single and free
We take great delight in our own company
And we have no desire strange faces to see
Although that your offers are charming
And we have no desire to take your advance
All hazards and dangers we barter on chance
For you would have no scruples for to send us to France
Where we would get shot without warning"
"Oh now!", says the sergeant "I'll have no such chat
And I neither will take it from spalpeen or brat
For if you insult me with one other word
I'll cut off your heads in the morning"
And then Arthur and I we soon drew our hods
And we scarce gave them time for to draw their own blades
When a trusty shillelagh came over their heads
And bade them take that as fair warning
And their old rusty rapiers that hung by their side
We flung them as far as we could in the tide
"Now take them out, Divils!", cried Arthur McBride
"And temper their edge in the morning".
And the little wee drummer we flattened his pow
And we made a football of his rowdeydowdow
Threw it in the tide for to rock and to row
And bade it a tedious returning
And we having no money, paid them off in cracks
And we paid no respect to their two bloody backs
For we lathered them there like a pair of wet sacks
And left them for dead in the morning.
And so to conclude and to finish disputes
We obligingly asked if they wanted recruits
For we were the lads who would give them hard clouts
And bid them look sharp in the morning.
Oh me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride
As we went a walkin' down by the seaside,
Now mark what followed and what did betide
For it being on Christmas morning
This song is just impossible to get out of your head,you know you just got to get your fix on a regular basis.
I am 61 and first heard this in '76 and am back…
Hard to believe I heard this on the same FM station as Led Zepplin-back in the dasy when DJ's played what they wanted! Cheers, from Toronto
I couldn't agree more, I find this in turn calming, thought provoking and clever. I particularly love hearing him virtually spit 'spalpeen or brat'. SO good.
I only discovered it a few weeks ago and I am making up for lost time!
@First name Last name There's few if any better songs to listen to again and again!
@@TheFolkRevivalProject no
Borderline perfection. That standard of guitar playing and singing is just not impossible for a normal human being to do simultaneously.
Everything here is brilliant! His guitarplaying, his voice, the melody and the lyrics. And a fun story it is if you listen...
not so fun from an irish point of view
Exactly, Jan.
@@ArchStantonify the story is about to irish lads beating the crap outta recruiters 🤨
In hispital ill this keeps me going ,mam and i loved this
Ireland, the musical nation, owes a huge debt and and an as yet unacknowledged tribute to Paul Brady.
He's so magical ..I knew him in the Johnston's Trad days....I was so lucky to have brushed elbows with them..Loved them all.Still do...Rip Adrienne . x
one of my favourite vocalists of all time. theres something about the great folk singers thats so pure, so captivating and...real that very few others can compete with. no gimmicks, just timeless perfect music
One of the finest folk guitar and singing presentations ever. So authentic. Heartfelt. Gimmick-free. Brilliant! Thanks, Paul!
My favorite Christmas song about hanging out with my cousin and bludgeoning English recruiters to death.
Todd Dwyer Yay! LOL
😂😂😂
You mean “almost to death.”
Rather them than me
You bounder. But I love it.
The seminal version - without a shadow- the hairs on the back of my neck have no control every time I hear this - wistful, meaningful and most of all, from the heart!
That's a heck of a bit of guitar playing, everything else beside.
You can say that again.
Check out his re-recording on Spotify. To see how even more intricate it is after another 30 years
As simple as that !
@@TheFolkRevivalProject this is just beautiful. Thank you so much for that
i dont play guitar but that looks so detailed and awesome
I have sensory processing issues. This performance is SO good that the physical pain I feel in my head from that high pitched noise is still worth bearing to listen to this over and over again.
It's literally so good I go through pain to listen to it. Holy crap.
Try downloading it and using Audacity or something to remove that sound.
@@themanhimself1229 my best attempt to remove it: ua-cam.com/video/LM8RwzvcgE8/v-deo.htmlsi=-AB5q8l-e2ea6bXV
My sweetheart share his favorite Irish album with me when we were separated by miles and no cellphones...I fell in love with this piece and after sweet 16 years of marriage, just Googled it and found it...had been looking for years!
I love at 3:21 the combination of what he does on the guitar (the two repeated chords) and how he sings the lyric ‘for you’ve only the lend of them as I suppose.’ The two rhythms are so independent.
I actually believe that's a mistake in an otherwise flawless performance. If you're playing this yourself you should just play the verse as it's played before and after that verse.
@@artseosamhogriobhta In a different version (Lost Liberty Tapes), he does the same thing, so probably not a mistake.
March 17th 2020....who's still listening to this? Happy St.Patrick's day!
When I first heard the great Paul Brady perform this it was approx 1997 on my local NPR radio station, WGBH (BTW much thanks to the one and only Brian O'Donovan, for all the amazing celtic music over the years!). When I first heard this tune I thought it was "nice" and very listenable. But over the years (decades) I have grown to appreciate this as a true masterpiece. PB's phrasing, his accent, his high voice, his accent, his unparalleled subtle and sublime guitar playing - all of these grew on me year after year. There are countless moments in this performance that are brilliant, subtle or sublime.
What a voice, man. This dude can belt it out with the best of them.
The reality of press gangs in times past is something a lot of us might fully appreciate. You could be beaten, abducted and forced into service into one of Britain's many wars, never to be seen again by your loved ones. It's sobering to think of the families of men who died in foreign lands after being pressed into service, never knowing what happened to their sons, brothers or husbands. I've always loved the contempt of this song for the warmongering recruiters, for each man shouldn't have to fight and die for any King's cause or any foreign lands other than his own.
Lol boo hoo. Our great and Glorious Empire. Oh to be part of it again!
@@killercd7682 No
@@killercd7682 it's dead and gone...never to return..
Oh, me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride
As we went a-walking down by the seaside
Now, mark what followed and what did betide
For it being on Christmas morning...
Out for recreation, we went on a tramp
And we met Sergeant Napper and Corporal Vamp
And a little wee drummer, intending to camp
For the day being pleasant and charming
"Good morning ! Good morning!" the sergeant did cry
"And the same to you gentlemen!" we did reply
Intending no harm but meant to pass by
For it being on Christmas morning
But says he, "My fine fellows if you will enlist
It's ten guineas in gold I will slip in your fist
And a crown in the bargain for to kick up the dust
And drink the King's health in the morning
For a soldier he leads a very fine life
And he always is blessed with a charming young wife
And he pays all his debts without sorrow or strife
And always lives pleasant and charming...
And a soldier he always is decent and clean
In the finest of clothing he's constantly seen
While other poor fellows go dirty and mean
And sup on thin gruel in the morning."
"But", says Arthur, "I wouldn't be proud of your clothes
For you've only the lend of them as I suppose
And you dare not change them one night, for you know
If you do you'll be flogged in the morning
And although that we are single and free
We take great delight in our own company
And we have no desire strange faces to see
Although that your offers are charming
And we have no desire to take your advance
All hazards and dangers we barter on chance
For you would have no scruples for to send us to France
Where we would get shot without warning"
"Oh now!", says the sergeant "I'll have no such chat
And I neither will take it from spalpeen or brat
For if you insult me with one other word
I'll cut off your heads in the morning"
And then Arthur and I we soon drew our hods
And we scarce gave them time for to draw their own blades
When a trusty shillelagh came over their heads
And bade them take that as fair warning
And their old rusty rapiers that hung by their side
We flung them as far as we could in the tide
"Now take them out, Divils!", cried Arthur McBride
"And temper their edge in the morning"
And the little wee drummer we flattened his pow
And we made a football of his rowdeydowdow
Threw it in the tide for to rock and to row
And bade it a tedious returning
And we having no money, paid them off in cracks
And we paid no respect to their two bloody backs
For we lathered them there like a pair of wet sacks
And left them for dead in the morning
And so to conclude and to finish disputes
We obligingly asked if they wanted recruits
For we were the lads who would give them hard clouts
And bid them look sharp in the morning
Oh me and my cousin, one Arthur McBride
As we went a walkin' down by the seaside
Now mark what followed and what did betide
For it being on Christmas morning
well done!
Love it when people post the full lyrics!! Cheers man!
Thank you for posting the lyrics to this superb song. Something to give true pause.
Love when people do this. Many thanks!
Excellent work! Thank you. x
When we hear this masterfully performed, and frankly masterfully written song...we are seeing back in time.
To how most people were entertained before electricity. The thing is, its still more capturing than anything in the electrical medium.
Its had thousands of years of a headstart over the electrical medium.
one of the best live performances i have ever heard
One of the most perfect performances - in terms of execution and conviction - ever committed to tape. A genius and to be compared with the very greatest of his time.
Love this song, and the legend that is Paul Brady!
Hello Deejay, how are you doing my dear
Some of the cleanest, most beautiful Irish vocals I've ever heard.
A once very dear friend introduced me to this song about 10 years ago.
We had a falling out over where we were going to drink a beer (of all things) I often come here to listen to this song and think of him. I usually shed a tear like I am now.
He moved backed to Ireland and has blocked me on social media, so I know I'm dead to him.
I miss you Dave, & I still love ya.
I hope all in life is going well.
Birmingham?
What a masterpiece, he just makes its look so easy and natural. Every word clear and note just perfect.
as a performance...this is peerless...the work of a master.
His rendition of this, complex, open G song is amazing. Vocals and guitar both are a tour-de-force performance.
I'm paraphrasing my Dad here but he's talked a lot about the influence and impact this guitar arrangement had when Paul first started playing it in the Dublin folk clubs, it just stood out and set a new standard among all the guitarists in the scene, my Dad included. 'Tour de Force' is the perfect phrase for how he's described it, with all the guitarsts watching every note and complete silence, pin-drop silence from the audience.
The little vibrato accents he puts on some of those notes are so subtle and easily overlooked in efforts to replicate Brady's music. That kind of thing only comes when everything else you are doing is automatic. The finishing details on a masterpiece arrangement.
Exactly! Those little vocal runs give me life. The absolute best.
Oh my. Where have I been all these years? Excited to have discovered him. Better late than never.
Hi dear friend how are you doing over there hows things working out for you how’s the weather conditions over there hope you keep safe?
The dynamics in his playing and vocals are effortlessly fluent, natural, and hugs perfection.
The way he’s playing that guitar is on some fuckin legendary shit. Dudes gettin it🤙🏻
Holy shit!
100MB or not... this is spectacular. A voice and an acoustic guitar and it is 100 times more powerful than almost anything on the radio these days.
Ahhhh Arthur rebel of all the rebels. Fearless. Such sweet, melodic sounding madness. Brady & Irvine album from 1976. The best of Ireland. Just joyous with history, heart, and intellect in music.
I was born in 1977, so this performance is as old as me!! LOL
I grew up to this song and other Irish fabulous tunes throughout the whole 80's and I believe it gave me a certain sensitivity, notably to folk music in general... My dad would play the tape in the car on each of our long trips through France up to Brittany and back, and it's only last year I discovered the name of the artist, his face, the date. Thanks to UA-cam! I'm moved to see how much people seem to love this song like I do :-)
I first heard Paul Brady in the 1960s at the Number 5 folk club on Harcourt Street, Dublin. Those were the days!
Just bought this CD (Andy Irvine and Paul Brady) --long ago had the vinyl but no longer have a working turntable. So grateful it just fell into my hands again in this format. Many fine serendipities. This is so compelling a song and singer. I searched two years to find out who recorded this back in the early 80's. Had heard a cassette of a Thistle and Shamrock show that included this song but the attribution was missing. I wore out the record, frequently come to UA-cam to watch the video. It just doesn't ever get old. Hits me the same way every time I hear it.
First heard this song 10 years ago on a tour bus in Ireland the wife and kids were asleep. I was awake looking at the beauty of the country song has stuck with me ever since
Same exact experience. It's forever imprinted on my brain as a result.
frigging brilliant. Double stops , incredible playing., perfect diction and timing. This is probably my favourite folk-y song. It never gets stale, I listen to it over and over. The movie is fun also.
Absolutely phenomenal guitar playing and singing. Bravo.
Paul Brady has the heart of Ireland in his soul
came across an irish radio station on the internet - just love all the music.
I just discovered Paul Brady today on St Patricks Day....I am blown away...your singing brings tears to my eyes.between your playing and your glorious voice there is nothing better...
I bought the album in '76 and there was just the photo of him and Andy Irvine.
I feel blessed that the same FM station that was playing Led Zepplin played this album-back when DJ's played what they wanted-and blessed to have UA-cam and this concert footage (for free!) when I am 61. Cheers, from Toronto
what a lovely high lilting tenor voice, and a great melodic variant of this classic song. from 1977.
One of the best performances i've ever heard, unbelievable great guitar playing and wonderful voice
I Hadn’t Heard This Before Today. But It’s Absolutely Marvellous !. All Comes Together Here.
Splendid Guitar, Forceful, But Wistful Vocal. A Wonderful Performance. And a timeless masterpiece. It will never, ever, be bettered.
Just listened to this song for the first time. Bloody brilliant. The only other time I'd heard of this genius was his song "nobody knows"
Just as good guitar player as Richard Thompson I'd say. (& I'm not even Irish) !
Who could Possibly dislike this- the most golden male voice from Ireland ever?
You’ve obviously never heard of Luke Kelly.
Either of you heard of Van Morrison? Paul has sang (very much backup) with Van and was completely outshined.
This never gets old.
this just brings me back to childhood, neautiful at a session
beautiful*
+Emma Fitz Some do say that it's the quintessential Irish song recording ever.
simply stunning
Must agree!
Lightning struck twice for me in 2019. I got to see Paul perform this at two separate concerts, both of them very special, the first was with Andy Irvine at Bord Gais (although he performed it alone, exactly as here) and the second was as a duet with Rufus Wainwright at NCH, taking a verse each throughout the song. Both performances were just outstanding, and also very special to me as I was them with my Dad, who introduced me to the song when I was a child and always preferred when Paul would perform it this way, no accompaniment except that incredibly intricate acoustic guitar arrangement.
Also got to see him at NCH. Unbelievable performance, especially considering his age. Goosebumps
@@eoinegan1021 great wasn't it? He's kept his voice in immaculate condition.
Lockdown delirium when I posted. The Bord Gais concert was 2017 not 2019
Been listening to this for 30 years and never get tired of it, got the album in vinyl and listened constantly until turntable gave up. Fortunately got the Liberty Tapes on CD excellent live performances. The man is a genius and doesn't get the credit he deserves, Strabanes best export!!!
Amen! Ireland's finest export, in fact. Genius.
1:24 the ornamentation on the "same" of "same to you" - outrageous, lol.
That’s insane.
Its sean nós
It's amazing. It's not just celtic, it's also reminiscent of the way that middle eastern singers can do those crazy trills between multiple notes over and over. Elite level stuff.
This is an ancient, distinctive style of singing In Irish traditional music, known as “sean nos”,which literally means “old style “.
it is Sean Nos but more specific the Ulster strain of Sean Nos, it's less 'celtic', the melisma used at 1:24 is much more common, it's earthier almost like gospel or soul singing. Sean Nos purists would be disgusted at this, but it's not too far away from Mariah Carey's melismatic style.
He is a musical wizard. He actually started performing songs while accompanying himself on piano. In addition to his performances, such as this wonderful video, I was seated a couple of feet from him in the mid 80’s in Sligo as he sang beautifully while playing piano. He’s also a great story teller.
The forgotten Christmas song. Pure brilliance
I love the fact that, only 2 years after this platform got started, when there was relatively so little that could be found here, good Mick Connell took the time to upload (and apologize for now-nonexistent upload limits!) these priceless, precious bits of folk culture. Thank you, sir.
I can't believe that 38 years have flown past since I first heard Paul Brady perform this amazing version of Arthur McBride. A brilliant performance Mr. Brady!
Pro se dobhearhabhaile
Check out the performance he did of this song a couple years back. Dude sang it in the same key and it's just as enchanting! He is a national treasure
My favorite Irish folk song by a mile
I had a girlfriend in Seattle who was aware of the whole UK/ Irish scene. I play, and thought that the blues were the end-all for music, but when she turned me on to Irish stuff particularyly, I was blown away by the open tunings and stories. Great, Paul Brady!!
Reading his book at the moment and he certainly thought the blues was the end all for music too!