2019 Acura MDX vs Lexus RX Comparison: Which Luxury Crossover Does a Better Job?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- The Acura MDX and Lexus RX are two of the OG luxury crossovers. The MDX debuted in 2001 and the RX just a few years earlier in 1999. They're mainstays in the hotly contested segment and have been kicking it before crossovers were cool. Both crossovers have become well known for offering stellar reliability and the soft, cushy comfort that luxury shoppers are looking for. Both CUVs are available as regular gas-powered models and hybrid versions, and although the MDX comes standard with a third row, the RX is now available in a long-wheelbase version that also offers an additional row of seats, so the two are even closer than ever.
Last year, the MDX sold 54,886 units in North America but the RX sold almost 118,000, which is a huge difference. Does the Lexus deserve to outsell the Acura by that much? We brought both CUVs together to find out.
Get a free price quote: quotes.autogui...
Please show your support and subscribe!
www.youtube.com...
AutoGuide reviews the latest new cars with test drives, car comparisons and shootouts plus coverage of breaking auto industry news, auto shows, rumors, top 10 lists, and spy photos. Help shop for your new car with informative car buying tips and car recall news, and be entertained with feature stories, Top 10s and car review videos.
This review has the worst conclusion as in the whole review they're complaining on Lexus RX but at the end crowns it the winner, WTF.
That said the engine runs better and rides better but picks the lexus because it special lol
I like the dashboard of the Lexus better, but I prefer the MDX in most other aspects, especially in A-Spec trim. The Lexus looks nice from most angles, except the front, which looks like Darth Vader. So I would pick the MDX in A-Spec trim.
Yeah but the front makes it look fierce and it makes it look more stronger
@@gayanekarapetyan8581 then look at the Toyota Avalon
I think most would be happy with either vehicles. Quality stuff from both brands. I recently compared the MDX and RX350 for purchase(amongst others). The RX rides better because of its more upscale interior, but the MDX drives so much better and has more interior space. I ultimately went with the Acura, but I would have been happy with the Lexus as well. Good luck to all those making the same comparison and buying decision.
Lol she said the Lexus RX will look old in few years! Really AutoGuide, you hired these two for reviews?
😂😂all I see is her nostril 🤦♀️🤦♀️😂😂
it true, this car will not age well
cheesun124 But even if its old, it will outlast your life, it doesn’t give up
This what you get when the US education system turns out more snowflakes who like to hear themselves talk (because they're all winners) than common sense young people. Flush out the socialist garbage who call themselves teachers and professors who are focused on indoctrinating innocent children and replace them with normal hard working adults who truly care about kids well being and preparing to be productive citizens in the real world.
@@sideskraft Um they sound Canadian.
It's definitely a good idea to consider either and it's a tough choice really. Both the Acura MDX and the Lexus RX are great luxury crossovers that are very comfortable and great to drive. If you want more confort and quietness, the Lexus RX is the one for you, since that's the goal for Lexus products, isolating you from the real world. You'll still get that in the Acura MDX, but you can also drive it more aggressively and it's a lot more fun to drive. Plus, I think the tech is much more easy to use in the MDX, and it's very simplistic for anyone to get in and learn within minutes, whereas with the Lexus infortainment..... yeah, it's easy to see why you wanna just break the screen off of the car xD Either vehicle is a win for me though, but for me, I'd choose the MDX for more practicality and I just love Acura vehicles in general (even though some of their interiors may not be the best), and Acura and parent company Honda are pretty conservative with a lot of things, but I don't mind it.
First off, you guys wrongly evaluated the MDX and Acura as a whole. You guys kept comparing it to a Honda Pilot, which I'm sure it's based on in some capacity, however you stated that the outside gave you pilot vibes, which it DEFINITELY does not. I don't know if you've seen a Pilot, but it definitely isn't similar to the MDX. The inside of the MDX is much nicer than a pilot, and yes the MDX is due for a full refresh, the interior is still very nice and nothing like the Pilot's. They're not even the same size or platform! I feel like you both played into the stereotype or persona of a Lexus. A Lexus is a very nice car, but I feel that your verdict was solely because it was a Lexus. You didn't even talk about SH-AWD, the hybrid system on the MDX, A-Spec or really anything. For goodness sakes, your title is "Which luxury crossover does a better job?" Which you both agreed it was Acura. The Acura drove better, sounded better, had more space, and better useable features. If you weren't going to have the 3 row RX, you should have brought the RDX, which would have definitely handled this RX. Overall I feel the comparison was unfair and slated. Reviews and comparisons are subjective, but to just say the Lexus won, because when you pull up in a Lexus people notice? People notice Acuras too, more and more since their refreshed styling and new designs. As car reviewers, you all have the power to give Acura and other brands like it, the recognition it needs, and the people honest, unbiased opinions. Very disappointed in this review.
Brandon Banner I totally agree with you!
So true
Totally agree
The Acura’s interior is as kind of outdated compared to the Lexus tho
Lexus is the Japanese king of luxury. Acura is more of the fun/sporty car. I think Lexus definitely competes better with the German rivals. I hate how the Acura interiors aren’t more luxurious. They used to be nice but now are super out dated.
Lexus will cost less in the long term because of resale value and reliability. Scotty kilmer approved!
The title should be "the worst auto reviewers on UA-cam". OMG, who hired these two?
BTW, both are very good SUVs. It just come down to your personal preference.
I love Lexus I do, I do. Owed a Lexus Rx400h loved it. but, my Acura MDX is much better all around over the RX!
The MDX is my choice for zippy and fun sport feel but the automatic transmission won’t hold up like the Lexus will. The Lexus IS a much more reliable and comfortable ride!
I got use to the radio if u dont touch it every 2 min ok .. steering wheel controls do the job also
This is a terribly done review. Totally painful to watch.
I found them so bratty. What the hell DO they like? Other cars might get their whistles blowing but they’re going to break down and cost a fortune to fix. What makes them the experts. She probably drives a yugo.
@@jamespikarski5610 no she probably drives a trabant
Still the MDX the #1 selling 3 row SUV. Can't wait to see what the redesign will look like.
Brandan honda Facts
Brandan honda The new MDX will come out in 2020 and will be sold as a 2021 model.
@@michaelfoulkes9502 yes I read
Lexus any day of the week not only when compared to Acura but also when compared to the German Premium brands.
Lexus IS the Elite luxury brand.
Uhh no, not even close. German brands are better built cars, better interiors, worlds better infotainment, look better etc...We own an RX, my wife likes it, I miss her BMW X3. If I were choosing between these two I'd go MDX over RX.
Seiko Watch iiuiiibb
My Mazda CX5 drives better than the RX. The Mazda has a much sportier ride whereas the RX is soft and is boring. However, the Audi Q5 was better looking, the interior was nicer and it was very fun to drive.
This reveiw sucks. Don't hate on the Acura
The RX IS GARBAGE
Youngmoon Plays ok peasant. I own a 2018 Lexus RX and a 2019 Land Rover Range Rover and both are great cars. The Lexus IS far superior in quality when compared to the Acura which one of my friends own. Acura is shit because of there mediocre attempts at luxury and there shitty transmitions.
❤️
Really, really good job -- assuming automotive journalists still work for the consumer. I've driven both of those recently, and your observations, albeit slightly overdone here and there, are spot-on valid, the questions real buyers have. Your personalities play off each other well.
Seems like Acura made a good decision by not sending the top of the line hybrid vehicle. I wonder how a regular RX350 (no F-sport) with the 18" rims would compare vs the MDX that was received. Most of the criticism in the driving dynamics of the RX is due to its F-sport package which comes with the 20" rims. a slightly stiffer suspension and add the Hybrid on top of that. Sometimes simple is best and Acura played their cards right to please Autoguide. The RX isl the better luxury SUV.
sub310 Great point. My sister was a Lexus general manager, and she told me do not buy the 20” wheels, it just looks nice, but not comfortable to drive
I have owned both RX and MDX. RX definitely better materials. Both infotainment systems stink, but RX really stinks. Where MDX leave the RX in the dust is on the road. MDX is stable and really holds the road; RX eh. Fun factor in driving MDX wins hands down. I really can’t stand Lexus’ grills. They do look like something from DarthbVader.
The thing is the Lexus will last forever
Edmonton, Alberta is full of 2003-2016 MDXes! Those things are tanks.
The Acura will last just as long as the Lexus.
@@MidnightAspec No. I suggest you check out carcomplaints.com and compare the # of complaints vs. the # units sold. Despite selling only a fraction of the RX, the MDX has many times more complaints.
Nothing is forever DICKHEAD
No. Lexus used cheap parts. I had and still have an RX 350 AND I FIXED MY OWN CARS. Lexus used REALLY CHEAP PARTS compare to Acura. I fixed and replaced some OEM PARTS TWICE. Why? Bc they are cheaply made.And driving? Lexus IS not even close. And If they have the MDX HYBRID? The interior materials are upgraded from the regular MDX.
At 1:38 she says the RX “long wheelbase version” 3 row......The RX 3 row has the exact same wheelbase as the 2 row. The body is extended not the wheelbase. Someone needs to check your facts before you post video. Maybe I am nitpicking. Otherwise good review.
Steve Printy you are not
The RX’s interior is so much better and when it comes to reliability these things live for ever. Lack of Apple and Android connectivity and horrible entertainment system really need to be addressed.
I love my Lexus . Everyone in my family is driving lexus and Toyota which last forever. But i love how the MDX looks so nice and more space.b
How many time did this dude say "Whatever"? Such poor quality of a review
I drove the RX last year. What I took away from it was it was like driving an EV.
It was that smooth. A frictionless driving experience.
No one buys the F-Sport, so testing this one and using it to represent the RX is a big problem.
The regular one, once you drive it, you buy it for a reason. It is that good. The F-Sport, not so much.....
The MDX would be the one I'd choose but it's still not a compelling package considering the dated console. But the upcoming precision cockpit though ... MDX 2020
I’ve always find her annoying and not a good reviewer just my opinion 🤷🏾♂️
annoying is an understatement
I agree! Like I could barely get through the video.
@@2001COUPE You got thru the whole video? at 4 minutes, I went to the comments to see if it was just me that felt this way. Confirmed.
I totally agree when she goes bing bing bing bing....
She is annoying so bratty like probably was when she was a kid.
I agree with the Acura/Honda statement. There is no reason to pay a premium for an Acura when a Honda is just as good with similar interior materials.
The MDX has proven very reliable for us
Let’s start here. Personally I like Subarus, but if i weren’t to have a Subaru, I’d most likely have a 09 MDX. My mom has one and i’ve driven it about 3 times, and it’s awesome. I have a Subaru Outback and I would definitely say whenever my outback goes, i’m definitely going for a MDX. It’s reliable, safe, and it’s really good in the snow. I feel like the older ones like the 2010 ones have the same entertainment system as the pilot, which it does. I’m just so in love with the MDX and I would for sure buy it in the future.
MDX all the way, no questions asked
I like the dual screen, the gear shift mechanism and the awd system in the Acura. Regarding Toyota v Lexus comparison. There are similarities with the Highlander and RX including the engine and transmission. Most of the criticisms are really subjective in this review. These reviewers need a lot of work to improve.
Lexus All the way
That Acura interior is brutal.
Surprise K “Brutal”
I literally love the infotainment system on the Lexus. I find that fingerprints get stuck on touchscreen infotainments and dislike that. It's an easy to use system, and all around convenient, other than the navigation on the system.
Thank god they gave it a touchscreen for 2020
One phrase SH-AWD !! Reason why i would get the MDX
Aaronix4 i have lexus RX 350 with AWD
Me too.. Handle like a champ.. Actually I bought an rdx.. Fun cuv
@@TrapBoutBizness Which is not anywhere near the SH-AWD
Give me that Lexus
"Changing the radio station makes me want to murder someone" that cracked me up!
Y’all really don’t like Acura, y’all did I the same thing with the RDX y’all were like the only reviews to bad mouth that suv. Jodi needs to be fire and Greg needs a raise
Jodi is the boss of Autoguide.
I own a 2018 Lexus RX with same infotainment system and for most of its use, it’s not bad once you get used to it. But I will agree with the reviewers that having to type in addresses for navigation is pretty awful. But the voice recognition for adding full addresses works well, and that’s m only method of entering an address. Lexus is using a larger track pad on their 2019 ES, LS, NX, models which is infinitely better than the RX current mouse. Still not as good as others, but better than their current mouse.
Wait I’m confused. You don’t like the RX because it drives car like ? Wtf let me see you complain about that in a BMW. LOVE the looks of the Lexus in its F Sport trim. Looks edgy and cool.
The Acura to me just comes off like a minivan. Pass. Just get a Honda van.
Toyota4Life The Lexus Enform system is so bad that’s enough not to even consider it
....to me as a person that uses plenty of electronic devices, I have never found any of the Lexus systems to be difficult to use...there are steering wheel buttons to control everything so it always makes me cringe when they complain about the joystick. Not to mention they always make it seem like the UI and its controls are like such a major component on a vehicle when virtually everyone only uses it for music, text message readouts & navigation...and unless you're a pizza delivery driver or have a horrendous memory, how often are you really using the navigation..? They always love to trash on the Lexus UI and call BMW and Mercedes input methods amazing but I always fail to see what one needs to be controlling with these "amazing UIs" while you're supposed to be driving...cars, especially luxury ones, have become so inundated with stupid shit that have nothing to do with driving on top of people expecting to be spoonfed everything. I hate hearing about headunit systems on cars, they take up so much in car reviews when in reality they ALL suck anyways compared to my smart phone and computer...
Some fact checks:
1. The Lexus RX-L in most markets will sticker for less than the RX F-Sport Hyrbid you are testing. So, stating that the RX-L would be "much more expensive" than an MDX is simply false.
2. You can change a radio with the simple switch of a button on the steering wheel. You can also customize the remote touch control to be less "jumpy" and you can silence the "ding" sound if you find it annoying all in the setup portion of the vehicle.
3. For SAFETY reasons, you cannot enter an address manually while the car is moving. You can only use voice commands while the car is in motion.
I could only watch 4 minutes of this before jumping down here in the comments because so much was wrong. If you're going to "review" a car, do your research first, friends!
Thanks for watching and for your feedback!
10:52 all I see is complaining. The mdx is a great car!
Grades of gas would kill the debate. RX uses regular gas octane 87. I wish these companies would part with the 3rd row already. Not required tbh unless you want a MiniVan.
A third row is only good for emergencies, so true. Thanks for watching!
I don't understand. You spent the entire video criticizing the Lexus, but it wins because your neighbors will turn their heads when you drive home in it? Based on your review I was sure you were going to pick the MDX. That's my pick.
Because Toyota quality control is better than Honda quality control
I’m not a fan of Honda after having two of them and having the new Accord as a loaner car. I’d go with Lexus personally. I don’t think these two vehicles are in the same category.
Who ever really says ' hey, you're the most least liked person so go to the 3rd row seat please'
The RX just looks so sharp love the sculpted body. Definitely the looker. Love the interior too.
I don’t like either of them . Love my 07 mdx
The review guys just cant hold back their emotions for the Acura :-D, but here is some key facts that makes the MDX not just Better than the RX but even X5, ML350 or CX-90
MDX is the 1st Mid-Size luxury SUV to offer 3rd Row seat before all 4 above, (Pilot had 8)
MDX was pushing 265 HP at 5500 in 2005 more than all except the XC90, had 3 more HP.
MDX Had Sun Visor that extended out, I dont know any others that have that, its very handy.
2007 MDX had the biggest VTECH ever 3.7L pushing 300HP
1st GEN MDX has the VTM-4 To Lock the rear Differential, all others are AWD not a true 4WD.
I belive 30% performance of the car depends on the acutal driver so.. if driven right, the Acura MDX will beat most SUV & Trucks on the Road in all direction (Stock), but will cave in Off Roading to trucks because of the height adjustment trucks have.
Only thing I see all the others have is higher Towing capacity (beats RX-300 tho 3,300 VS 5,000) which I dont really see relevent because I wouldnt buy any of them to tow anything either than maybe a camper trailer. This SUV sholdn't be compared with the RX-300, its not in the same class. I think the price is where ACURA is scrwing up, making it cheaper that all 4 yet giving so much more, the customer these days want to be able to say my Acura costs more than your Lexsus :-D
Thanks
The Lexus is so much better, and she's so wrong about the Acura aging better, the Lexus is still gonna look new in 5 years, the Acura is gonna look very old.
Mutaal My son’s friend told him “your mom’s Lexus looks New after ten years”😊
who da heck uses navi in any vehicle anymore?? it wayyyy more convenient and simple to use your phones GPS ie WAZE duhh? or is this just me??
Just you
Only old people use car GPS.
RX OR COURSE! Why would someone get the Acura?
Lexus as a brand has younger buyers ....
There's a thing called voice command... learn it and it will make your life easier.
Voice command on MDX stinks. The infotainment system in Honda/MDX is their weakest point.
Acura the best!
the Acura will out perform the Lexus SHAWD wow!
Except the rx L isn't a long wheelbase version. It's the same wheelbase across the board.
It’s really the dashboard in the Mdx that’s the issue
If I want a trendy SUV which has an outstanding reliability, safe and fuel efficient. RX seems like a perfect SUV. I heard lots of horrible story about MDX's automatic transmission. For that reason, I picked RX over MDX. I love the new RDX btw.
The lexus is miles ahead of the Honda MDX, oh sorry Acura MDX, and not a fair comparison for hybrid with non-hybrid. Yeah but i totally agree about the adaptive cruise control on the RX the distance gap it maintains is way too wide!!
I'm sure one can equip them both to line up in price, but the top line Lexus is generally much more expensive than the top line MDX. The Lexus is a 5 seater, the MDX is a 7 seater with a 3rd row. To be honest, I'm sure they compete as you suggest. I doubt an RX buyer who only needs 5 seats is cross shopping an MDX and vice versa because if you need the space of the MDX, you need the space and the RX is out. The RX-L 3rd row is literally only for 5 year olds (like the back seat of a 911) while the MDX 3rd row, while not roomy, can actually accommodate an adult.
I guess if your only consideration I'd the seating just get a Highlander. Experts say the Toyota is more reliable long term. Doesn't have the same issues as Honda atomic transmissions
The infotainment on the Lexus keeps me from buying one - maybe they will change it in 2020 model year?
bartwaggoner2000 I agree, I think the whole vehicle needs a redesign. I just do not care for the RX. wifey test drove one and wasn’t sold.
You did not input your destination with the user friendly voice command...whats up with that or did you forget? You also failed to mention that the Lexus RX still is the number one selling vehicle in its class and all others are "copy cats" end of story. AP
Y’all just f****ng wait for the new mdx
Jodi Lai and Mr. Agreeing on everything needs to both get fired. Looks like 2 10yr kids were reviewing the car. Worst car review PERIOD. Jodi needs to review only Honda civics!
She doesn't even deserve to talk about Honda/Acura products. They both might as well be Lexus sales reps
Must be the Lincoln driver. Still use the flip phone, right?
Why am I watching this with the quality content available?
TacticalM - Fire both of them, they sux.
I think you didn't succeed in convincing the viewer to what you're saying or trying to say.
Honestly i don’t think this car is that close to the pilot (mdx), honestly the mdx gets a lot more than the pilot compare interiors once the redesign comes out later this year the new interior will further separate this from the pilot, if you look at the interior of the new Rex you can see it’s much nicer than just a normal Honda but in a pilot you don’t get as high quality materials you don’t get as much stuff standard i think the mdx looks better than the pilot but honestly the mdx will be much bette r
Your comparing mid entry MDX to top of the line RDx not right
if u want for look go rx, if u want a better car go with mdx it has super handling all wheel drive of the best awd system there, most people go with look! thats why they sell more
I think the mouse is simple and intuitive after using it for a while.
I'm gonna end up probably with the MDX because the 3rd row is at least usable for short rides. Also; having had half a dozen subarus; I am use to having really good AWD and SH-AWD is great; the Lexus one is a joke. But I like the Lexus longevity and reputation better..
Lexus for sure
LEXUS > acura
The 18 RX 350 is gorgeous
We have both, and we both prefer the Acura. The driver assist systems are way better, the infotainment are both garbage, but Acura is better. The ride is smoother on the RX. The transmission of the Acura is garbage (I don’t mean the buttons vs lever), it’s super rough, and does weird gear shifts. The Acura is better, the Lexus dashboard looks better, but in terms of ergonomics the Acura did a better job of placing things, e.g. the cruise control on the Lexus is placed on the worst place. The steering wheels controls are not great either.
They did a great job reviewing. What are their names. Guy is goodloking.
When a Lady likes a thing she wants you to agree with her...
For me I will have the Rx Lexus tires over 4 free Mdx.
LMFAO 17:00... there is actually a kid in the back,,,,,
They fkt up in 2019. Both Acura and Lexus.
The RX350 is a much better vehicle, hands down. MDX's transmission is straight poop.
I just luv the Lexus..I super luv the grill n it..I hear a lot of ppl.don't,but by gosh I do..Luv Toyota period..I chose Lexus 4 the looks also..Great cars..
At 9:22 ... She said refering the the lexus rxl 3rd row seat " or a child you don't particularly like"
Really unprofessional... She needs lessons on how to talk ! Never going to visit this channel.
she's a woman, you cannot wish she has the intelligence to do certain things
Acura’s because Toyota’s have a loose, and weak suspension 😩😩😩. But Toyota’s have a better longer lasting transmission
Nothing mentioned about the SH-AWD. The girl just complains here and there and the guy just approves everything she said! Lol!!!!
He's nothing more than a freaking simp. It's very obvious.
That Acura MDX is so much better than that Lexus - this review is all wrong.
Thanks for the 2014 review
Hum I drove a RX and MDX. I disagree The MDX is like a car that is a suv. It drives way better to me than a Lexus. And space forget about it. The MDX has 3 time more cargo room. Any way I also compared the RDX which is what I bought to the NX. and The RDX blows it away. I love Lexus don't get me wrong. but there is no cargo space in a NX. Also you are stating these are 2019 where is the MDX SH?
That comment about people being impressed by a Lexus but not an Acura is really dumb. Anyone who knows anything knows they're both in the same price range. It's the BMW and Mercedes that are a little more expensive. Then you have the Range Rover which is the most "impressive."
Am I the only one who doesn't think of Lexus as "impressive"? Lexus is in the same tier as Acura and Infiniti.
Cover Ontario plate driving on public road not being caught, good luck.
However, all prices are shown for US market.
Acura MDX is the best
No it's not
When Redditors get into car reviews.
Lexus.
@17:19 that’s the problem with people these days. Guy has some serious issues
MDX IS BETTER
Lexus rules.
MDX interiors are crap full of pleather and hard plastics.
Try to find a used MDX that's in good shape.
Good Luck.
Brutal reviews....just brutal
Good job.. was useful.. thanks!
Sidechick : Acura
Wifey : Lexus
lol Thanks for watching!
I didn’t know AutoGuide was still a thing. Most whining Hosts who whine at Millennials. No one of Coin is watching these hosts. Serious
🙄complaining about the pushbutton transmission which has PRNDL layout, falls to hand and can be used by feel without looking at it unlike 1. BMW 2. Mercedes 3. FCA