How To Replan Indian Cities || Solution ||
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- #mumbai #cityplanning #skyscraper
Replanning Indian cities involves a comprehensive and multi-faceted approach that addresses various aspects of urban development, infrastructure, environment, and social well-being. Given the diverse and rapidly growing urban landscape in India, effective replanning is crucial for sustainable and inclusive development. Here are some key considerations and steps for replanning Indian cities
🔔 Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @powertrain
OUR OTHER CHANNELS
⚪VLOG CHANNEL - / @aakashbhavsar2342
⚪FOOTAGE DEMOCRACY - / @footagedemocracy3663
⚪SHORTS CHANNEL - / @powershorts1068
FOLLOW US ON
⚪INSTAGRAM 1 - / aakash_rb
⚪INSTAGRAM 2- / powertrain_yt
⚪FACEBOOK - / powertrainofficial
⚪TWITTER - / powertrain_yt
⚪DISCORD - / discord
_____________________________________________________________________
INTRO MUSIC IF PRESENT - LEMMiNO - A THOUSAND YEARS
• LEMMiNO - A Thousand W...
CC BY-SA 4.0
Even if indian cites just focus on efficient solid waste management and clearing haphazard wires they will exponentially look nicer.
totally agree.
Just that and rebuilding old depleted buildings ..
Yahh I totally agree with you
@Akarsh2008no advertising market growing faster and give huge money to building or owner specially banner
@Akarsh2008no you can't widen all streets to 40ft land mass nhi hai utha 20ft sufficient hai streets k liye 😊
What we need is
1) waste management
2) pollution management
3) population management
4) Good Govt
5) Serious compulsory Planning Law so every Engineer and develop follow this rule
He lack all of them 😢
We need good citizens too
we just need good govt, they will eventually fix everything else
@@DebranjanMajumderthat's the main point.
@@358csreedharsononey7and what about people?? Will they support the government??
Indian population needs 100 smart cities as like dolera
One smart city population maximum 10 lakh
100 smart city 10cr population only
So only 6% of Indian population will live in smart cities 😢
Bro Dholera doesn't even exist 😂. What's wrong with you. Why can't you be realistic for a second. You could have said cities like GIfT city, but on the scale of Delhi or Mumbai. Basically like top class a list Chinese cities.
@@_snehaa_._2Rip city expansion.
Bro cities do expand
Dholera is a failed project ?? No smart city in this world ever be a failed project @Akarsh2008
@Akarsh2008 No, it's not. It just takes time. Like Chandigarh. Remember, China being autocratic can do it 2-3x faster than us. That's why Chandigarh took a long time to become succesful,
Replanning city is very tough as i live in banglore here only tunnel road is costing around rs 75000cr so replanning city may cost billions of dollars,,, but the best solution is developing of tier 2 and tier 3 cities with good grid patters and shifting industries and population to tier 2 and tier 3 city
Indian tier 3 cities may don't have that much issues while developing it.
Just select a city where there is nice rainfall and water resources and your selection will win.
Patna is tier 1 city bro
@Akarsh2008 it's oldest city and size is big
money was never the problem for a country
Look shanghai a d shenzhen of China they we're 90% completed by the 2010 when China china economy was just 5 trillion
Actually india missed the era of robust INFRASTRUCTURE of 1980-90 where every country was rapidly building new cities like China, korea, Japan, singapore and UAE, and there's very little chance that we can make a perfect fully planned city of about 500km sq in any future
@@user-go7re4vz3e China is a communist country , they spawned hard military To it's people. Where as comparison with cities like in Seoul, Tokyo , Bali , Singapore their size and population is pale incomparison to big Indian cities. (Barring Tokyo interms of population)
India can learn from Singapore in urban City planning.
India must take inspiration from East Asia, Singapore and Europe.
India doesn’t need to “learn”. It needs to “start” doing city planning. Any noob city planning will also be better than our current unplanned city.
@@SiddharthRaiyani Indian civil engineers when designing city streets don't give a damn about implementing some of the most basic concept of dedicated left / right turn lanes and associated traffic lights which have been a concept since the 1920s-1930s. I think these ppl need to stop getting ahead of themselves.
@@SiddharthRaiyani True, even some basic planning would help let alone highly detailed EU capitals
I live on Greater noida (adjacent to delhi which is very well planned, it always feels so much nicer when i come back to greater noida from delhi, away for all dirt and congestion
Slumoida 😅
@@TheKing-bb2wuabe suar zayada mat bol
@@TheKing-bb2wu Ghanta tu kabhi Noida aya bhi hai
@@Abhi-nb1xo abhe me gurugram se hu 😅
@@TheKing-bb2wuWo to concrete jungle hai jo 2 minute ke barish me Pani me dub jata hai.😂
It won't be possible for India if don't build cities from scratch, like we are doing with Gift city. Though Hyderabad Hitech can be a model of how we can turn old cities to new, but upgrading old to new is more expensive in most cases than brand new.
That's what I was thinking..!!!! Making Greenfield cities is the only and comparatively cheap option.....
I fully support the building ofnnew cities. Every developed country became developed on the backs of good cities.
Old City can easily be converted into Modern just need to better waste management and better infrastructure upgrades, example is varansi though some parts of City is bad due to waste
Hyderabad's old city still remains old. Hitech city is a new city completely built from scratch and not related to old city by any means. Although it is a great start by the government but somebody must do something to improve the old city. I'm giving Hyderabad as an example and all major metro cities comes under this category as well especially Mumbai and Bengaluru.
No no no
Most population in the cities should be shifted to high-rise buildings then the empty lands we should build parks, plant trees. I think this way our cities would look more beautiful and air will be fresh
😂😂 everyone knows the solution but who is going to solve it u and I knows the solution but what can we do as citizens
that's what china did but its too expensive for the normal people to afford
High rise buildings my ass these "high" rise apartments look ugly not so well planned and like matchboxes and they give the feel like they have been dropped in some barre land and they are the only piece of civilization, we should use land wisely and beautifully
Medium sized building with clever and beautiful different architectures in mass but who would do that lmao
Make money make it look dirty
@@kashyap_0-0_ depends on which type building you make not saying build 50 storeyed building build 10 storeyed building, gardens in balcony, roof it looks nice i saw that type of building...Indian cities are overpopulated we need to build high-rise otherwise there will be no place for trees, gardens, parks
@@mukeshKumar-pw2oc govt will take over the land and build buildings then will give flat in free of cost to those people
Hawkers are not fined, but Vehicle in the same area are fined for No-Parking
Hafta
They are giving weekly, monthly to police 2000-4000
Main issue is lack of education which must be fundamental to everyone practically, we need to have change from bottom (root should be very strong)
This is the only channel I have seen to upload such a video to make India and its city developed
The government needs to build new smart cities adjacent to our tier 1 cities, so that the people who already live in those can move to the newly built efficient city after seeing the benefits it provides
Ranchi has got a 3 Storey Hawker Market in one of the busiest markets. The market has got many hollow bandstands, allotted to each hawker, over which he/she displays their shop during daytime and then lock it up inside the bandstand while closing the shop. Vishwanath Corridor in Varanasi is also a better example of old City redevelopment.
Bro just finished watching 4 of your videos today and they all are extremely good suggestion.
Removing Municipal Corporation from Road planning will bring down corruption drastically......slums are a political game, very true........keep up the good work. Make Indians more informed.
No construction should be allowed without design and engineering done by professional engineers. This will improve appearance of cities, quality of buildings, sustainability, and reduce unemployment
In Udaipur's old city part municipal tried the same but this time the residents created opposition cuz they don't like to travel this much on daily on foot despite providing e-riksha services
❤
We as Indians have to change first, otherwise no change will take place. First fix government schools
I think Hyderabad has seen exceptional development especially Hitech city.Very well planed and efficient however there is also problem of Drainage but overall it is better
And the rest of old Hyderabad lives in mud
Hats off to the narrator, for speaking out the raw truths.
Replan mean destroy and build 😂😂😂
The cost of to rebuild will skyrocket 😢😢😢
I recommend your thoughts
I appreciate your stupidity.
It's better to do that, all over the world ppl call our country as dirty looking cities (especially our cities architectures)
Paisa kaun dega? Tera baap?
Indian Government should Introduce some strict laws for Cars Holder... For ex-Nowadays every person who is earning good goes to office by Car even when he/she is single.... So government should make rules to prevent traffic and introduce many good public transport like Buses...... And other step to develop Our country on wider level is to make Smart and Greenfield Cities and many as possible cause those cities will automatically remove burden from cities like Mumbai, Banglore, Delhi and Gurugram cause people will approach cities which are nearer from their Home town.... So making new planned Cities on some Rapid Speed is the only Option... India should make minimum 20 Smart, world class and fully working cities in upcoming next 20-25 years....
First improve public transport, they are in deteriorating stage
Jab tak tier 2 & 3 cities ko develop nahi kiya jayega aur illegal immigrants ko nahi bahar kiya jayega tab tak purane cities ko replan karna bahut mushkil hai...
Every Indian cities should need and require to replan like foreign countries.
Not even possible in 1000 years.
@@ayushgaurincredible how?
@@piyushtekade3915 Indian civil engineers when designing city streets don't give a damn about implementing some of the most basic concept of dedicated left / right turn lanes and associated lane-specific traffic lights which have been a concept in the civil engineering space since the 1920s-1930s and yet India has still not yet realized this simple innovation.
I mention this exact point to most Indians and they look at me like I am some alien who landed on this earth. How can you expect anything to change in the next 1000 years?
@@purveshsane1435 they do this for replan the city below 1000 years.
@@purveshsane1435 well let's be patient, because no one expected India to reach where it is... could you have expected metros, shopping malls, ac office 50 years ago ? So don't be pessimistic ❤😊
Tier 2 cities like Nashik SambhajiNagar In MH has good potential. And even its good time to plan this cities before it overcrowded (which already started). So Govt can easily shift the load over mumbai and pune to another adjacent cities.
Maharashtra is already too developed government need to focus on other states like up Bihar northeast Odisha j and k which are underdeveloped
@@thegggamer2626 odhisha state govt is effective
Old cities must have their property prices fall by depopulation. Move industries out of the cities and drive down the traffic. Have government and corporations sweep in and buy the properties for junk prices. Only then can renewal happen.
Cruel thinking.
This is not how development is done.
Old areas/slums have higher fsi than posh area which has potential to promote the area by attracting developers.
@@saurabhj4950 Only comparative is Shanghai and they flat out removed the people. At least India would be giving option to sell in a market economy. There is no other way around these filthy, grimy, and bursting cities.
@@AO-xd2ml No.Such things backfire in democratic world.
Negative press will kill city forever.
India also had something called Urban & rural ceiling act that prevented corporation from buying large areas of lands
@@saurabhj4950
Cruelty is that majority of middle class people cannot even afford an apartment in Mumbai. Even white collar workers live in slums and ghettos.
This issue of unplanned urban development was neglected by the previous ruling governments. Kudos to the BJP for giving more focus towards this issue. Keep the urban planning related content coming.
True, as long as no new better party is formed, I am not voting for any other party
Very well researched video. You said things which many do not dare to speak on social platforms. What we need is a strong political will power, without which progress seems difficult.
Urban city planning or re-planning requires a different skillset that none of our govt agencies have. This is a critical area that both central & state govt should take up soon in a systematic way.
2:52 this is very true..i experienced it a lot in thane city..perfect observation 👍 kharaab town planning india ke liye bohot bada sir dard banne wala hai aur aap ke channel ko follow karke itna pata chalta hai ki koi toh hai jo is emerging "danger" ke baare mein baat toh kar raha hai,awaj utha raha hai..keep going 👏 "tum bohot accha kaam kar raha hai maqsood bhai" 😅
❤
Cleaniness hygiene local level infrastructure better crowd management traffic management street vendor k liye proper rules in sb p dyan dena padega tb jak hamri cities jaisi hai waise rhte hue bhi acchi lagegi
Kuch nhi hoga. Just keep looking at south east Asian cities and cry.
India is still unbelievably poor and in dark ages.
#AskPT is it possible to make greenfield planned cities and towns parallel to old ones, gradually shift the people from older to new cities, and then re-develop older cities.
Paisa bahut lagega Bhai humara Desh abhi itna bhi Ameer nhi hai😢
Parallel planned development will lead to major disputes. The people in other areas will complain that only areas surrounding urban areas are being developed.
@@maxxplanck2876money was never the problem for a country
Look shanghai a d shenzhen of China they we're 90% completed by the 2010 when China china economy was just 5 trillion
Actually india missed the era of robust INFRASTRUCTURE of 1980-90 where every country was rapidly building new cities like China, korea, Japan, singapore and UAE, and there's very little chance that we can make a perfect fully planned city of about 500km sq in any future
@@user-go7re4vz3e so true brother bura lagta hai bura lagta hai😭😭😭
@@hrushikeshavachat900 but won't we end up with a larger urban space in the long run? benefitting the people, more space for people to migrate from rural to urban. We desperately need to end disguised unemployment in the agri sector.
#AskPT Why Indian apps like Moj, MX Taka Tak couldn't compete with Instagram reels after TikTok was banned and Koo App is not equivalent to Twitter (or X)?
Because they are ripoffs of Instagram, not original in any way... (I think even more inferior quality than Instagram) So Noone's using them
#AskPT Is there no firm in India that works to put overhead wires underground? And if there is such a firm, then why don't the authorities of many of our cities hire such firms to put the overhead wires underground? these overhead wires appear like spider webs in our cities and spoil the aesthetics of the city.
He has covered this topic multiple times in his videos,it's because it's very costly also the houses will have to be redesigned for underground wiring to go into houses,moreover the roads are broken and build multiple times so it will effect the wiring,in conclusion India is not ready for this,but even then the govt is doing it in newly planned areas like gift city.
Ive always wondered about this too, turns out its very hard to convert overhead wires underground for massive residential places. Its better to do underground wires for new cities.
Sir ek video.. india main road ke upar wire khiche jate he ..is pe banaiye
For your kind information London isn’t old as delhi it was rebuilt from start after the world war 2
In our area theres was plan to run govt buses but due to disagreement of pvt bus conductors, govt didn't implement this as they don't wanna lose vote bank. Normal people are facing crowded limited pvt buses now
i never understood why govt didnt just ban traffic from entering market areas, i mean just one look at sarojini nagar market in delhi, where's something like rajouri garden or tilak nagar market in comparison? both unpleasant, unnecessarily and irritably noisier, more pollutive unlike the calm, collected and peaceful area that is sarojini nagar market. these "mafias" if any, are truly the detriment of cities because they only hurt themselves by not letting govt implement better policies.
There's something called local govt full of illiterate & uneducated goons..which only collect water & land tax.
High rise building/skyscraper bhi bnane nhi dete vrna vertical Cities bnaye to jyda fyda rhega
Spne china vle kam Africa vla isse thode kam chlega population bhut jyda hai
At least we need one new smart City in every state . For manufacturing and financial operations and to make India developed by 2047
What place(s) do you suggest for West Bengal, Bihar, Jharkhand and North Eastern states, for building green field smart cities?
@its_K213 Actually there is one planned town at right that distance with regular and developed connectivities, but that town didn't flourish much! It's Kalyani, 40kms North of Kolkata city, developed long ago during independence
@@newchannelverygood162 north east ka centre guwahati ko bana dena chahiye
🐄🐄🐄🐄💩💩💩💩
@@rdsfahim2883tor mayer gud mete sutiye dabo khankichele
without economic growth these are not possible.... most people don't demand these . We are very small population of India. When most people have a good life like most of us they will also demand it... mafias are there in every country especially it used to be a big problem in London but they are also humans just as we are...
Corruption is the problem, Conclusion.
I don't think ki existing city ka kuch ho sakta hai, jayda chua toh ye protest, politicians, human rights wale aa jayenge. Puri new planned city from scratch se hi banani padegi proper strict laws ke saath taki encroachment na ho sake
Every thing will improve as india progress for sure
Not possible unless Indian government becomes like chinese , problems of having a democracy
bruh Singapore is also democratic, how did they managed to design good cities
Playing city skylines really help to understand about city planning
Step 1 : start from ground
1: remove beggars and slums
2: cleanliness is the major important thing (penalty for those who trash roads) - dustbins should be there in every 1000 m
3: the public washrooms should be available in every 7 km
4: replace auto and rikshawalas to taxis and e rickshaws
5: 2 child policy should be strict
6: govt should create jobs in cleanliness committee (beggars can be taught to clean )
7: planned transportation should be done step by step, replace Indian railways to intercity fast metros- like Switzerland)
8: trams and new busses
9: artificial rains can reduce pollution- solar panel is good environmental solution
10: work life balance and health insurance should be mandate
At least make wires underground, remove encroachment, remove hawkers,stop parking in unauthorised place, clean footpaths will be a lot
And make bypass for trucks and vehicles who don't need to enter the city can use the bypass and remove unnecessary vehicles from city roads
hawkers matlab?
Sabse pahle electric pole aur wires ko under ground karo. Saare naale ke upar road construction karo. Multilevel parking banao aur roads ko wide karo
For devellopment of cities they need good public transport so that people to start using them rather than using private vehicles and then comes the waste management and i thing this is pro as well as con factor for the india but only they need how to manage it.
Mumbai and 😂😂😂 Shanghai not even in dreams.
Replanning is impossible, better to build new smart cities
Yes
mostly this is what i think when i think about my country
The main problem is politics, the authority of development of cities should be given to experts
Smart city is biggest jhunjhuna.
Mic change hua han kya sir
keeping other things aside great video❤
Bahut hi kadva sach hai. Sab bahut achche aur hard hitting video. This should be shown to as many w as possible
गांव उजाड़ कर केवल शहर बसाना मूर्खता है ; गांव में पूँजी निर्माण होते है और शहर में केवल पूँजी खपत ।
Best solution for good cities like foreign develop new and move population slowly slowly by creating work facility and then free a space in cities like delhi and make it greener by park and devloping good infrastructures bu it will take time now to be there
Underground wires, strict Traffic rules, make small streets pedestrian, one way roads, discourage new development in already congested area, clean streets and make hawking illegal, nice waste management
by solving these small things our city problem will be 90% solved
Aap ne jo Hawkers / Thela ka baat kiya, mai usse fully agree nahi karta.
Aap sabko nahi hata pao ge.
Insted, Thela/Food Truck ke liye spaces phele se plan karna chahiye, har 100- 200m distance par,
taa ki Foot Path / Road par kisi ko Thela lagane ka zarurat naa pare.
Food Trucks bahut convenient hota hai, both buyer ke liye aur seller ke liye bhi, kyu ki agar uska buisness ek purticular area me nahi chal raha because of low demand to he/she can move to another place instantly.
We should not try to ban economic activity, we just need to Plan it properly, taa congestion na ho.
Chandigarh ek planed city h pr uske nearby area mein bhot encroachment hua h jiske wajah se main city mein problem hote h.
Indian Cities should made CBDs out of Cities and 50km away from Airport so we can make Skyscrapers
First ban "two wheelers" bcoz streets are congested, compair europes streets or dubai
Impossible, many middle class people in india commute by 2 wheelers
Only option,move to a green field planned cities, old cities are good for vibes not for living
Jab tak democracy hai.. tab tak encroachment rahenge. Very tough to remove them.
Only when parents stop allowing their kids and themselves to litter on ground/rail tracks/roads..
Har ek state ke rural area mai ek new mega city plan karni chahiye government ko
I was hoping to see some optimistic solution but at the end you showed totally negative. We all know the current fact and we want to see again and again small but real solution.
main problem is over population according to gdp its so high in comparison to China
Why don't we build artificial island and make a city and settle half of our population over their, in this way our agricultural land will be intact create more job opportunity... Or create a new city in barren land.. where we can settle millions, water can be easily provided by long canals...
I have a flat in society on 3 building, in mumbai such big building and with so much land is very less to see. But our building needs redevelopment any builder is offering us whatever percentage we want until they get to unauthorised hawker consisting small scale hotel for auto drivers, garage, tea stall has literally broke tye border wall and moved completely inside like we live in locality where their are no slums and no hawkers entirely residential and peaceful and their mandir hospital school. But still they come here slowly and when we file case they expect money or something as they we have been here for years. Builders now say they will offer us what we want if these hawker get out without much hustle and money.
very nice
Instead of replanning old ciites building new cities with proper infrastructure is better
Very good...
Sir Dharawi Redevloped pe kya koi updat he?
Even the newly built residential buildings ,office buildings ,railway stations etc made up of match box design.Day by day our cities becoming more and more ugly.Nobody has any aesthetic sense,now im feeling that india is never going to improve
Pehele population kam karna hoga warna kuch nhi hoga
True
just look at china how they manage it. If we are able to do 30% of that. I will be happy
Rebuilding the cities does not seem feasible now, lots of houses needs to be destroyed, roads are to be dug. We should have planned this after independence, but we did not, so...
Just give us good big footpath to walk upon...
Good waste management...
Good public spaces with no vehicles
And good public transportation..
Also, Please make people follow traffic rules...It is insane..
Why 2100 lol china did it in 30 years
Democracy vs 1 party system samajh bhai 😢 bohot problem hai democracy mai delay se protest se lekar corruption corrupt govt official sab kuch jisme koi vision nhi hai china jesa infrastructure banane ka akale Central govt kuch nhi kar sakti apne yaha. Bullet train ka example he dekh lo kese 1 State ne delayed kiya project ko OR supreme court & NGO KO KESE BHUL sakte ho jo 1 decades tak project ko stop karke rakhte hai fake case laga ke court mai 😂😂 is desh ka kuch nhi ho sakta Bhagwan he maalik hai amravati ka smart city bhi ek vision tha Singapore usko bulid karna chahta tha lekin govt change hui or project ko band kar diya Andra Pradesh mai 😢😢
@@harshitrai5306- We dont need this much democracy, frankly.
you have to consider that china has a massive land unlike india, which is smaller and mostly densed populated than china. Evergoing conflicts between states of india are also a problem. Our majority population depends up on roadside markets or small businesses rather than big and organized supermarkets, and if you remove those small vendors it'll impact our economy that's why its really difficult and time consuming to build rapidly like china.
And major reason.... you know politics and lack of public cooperation.
@@Arthur7788890% of population in china live-in as much land in India
India lacks institutional structure which could facilitate the planning of the cities. There is no political willpower to make such changes. Only gujarat had some form of structure for planning of their cities in form of tp plans. Till the motive of the government either remains limited to freebies or religion such institutional changes will not take place.
good work keep it up
If you are thinking Money is the problem for India, Think again. Look at the cities in Africa, South America, Central Asia. They are doing much better than most India cities. These changes can only happen at Primary School level.
As shown in the cover photo the land must be distributed into green cover for others and tall buildings for human
जय हिंद जय भारत 🇮🇳🚩
Beautiful country India ❤️ ❤️😍😍
Great video 👍
Why not new City with good plan
Worst Indian Mentality :- Chalta hai toh chalne do
Step 1. Educated and disciplined population
But who will focus on religion politics if everyone is busy on making India a better country?
@sheetalsharma3686 well said 👏one should keep their religion to themself no need to tell everyone
Avi 1000 saal lagega yeh sab hone me
Ya its true, not 1000 but atleast 150 years to lgega.. Its long process.. But don't know why indian people think 5-10 saal me city change ho jaayegi.. Todays New York ko 350 saal lage hai build hone me.. Same with Hongkong, Hongkong 40 saal pehle bilkul aaj ke mumbai ki tarah lagta tha, but look today's Hongkong..
Is the old city shown in the video at point 1:37 Bhopal ?
mai apke content ki jitni tareef karu utni kam h
Waste management
Removal of too much wires
Removal of too much ad banners
If govt focus on these things only then india will look much better
Studies has shown that car free streets attract more footfall and therefore more consumers who buy stuff from those shops.
The govt shld start slowly like: car free zones, parking spaces and bike parks near bustops, metro, railway stations; putting up bollards on footpaths and car free streets; preventing illegal parking of bikes and cars; ban of bikes and scooties in market areas; licensed rickshaws only in dedicated heritage streets; remove overhead wires; more funding into waste management and clean water supply.
Hawker problem can only solved by long term sustainable economic growth, where more people transitions into organised sectors, municipalities cannot just prevent poor people from setting up business.
जों भी plan कर रहे हों,तालुका City से शुरू करों भाई अतिक्रमण बहोत बड़ी समस्या है
Always politics politics and politics...
Beleive me if we all stop doing politics politics game then India have enough power to become no.1 country in the world ( in all sectors) 🙏
Mamata said that Kolkata would be like London...but it never happened.
I agree she said it as jumala.. But its actually true..
Wow ❤
Ban cars in busy places. Ban two way traffic. Ban roadside enchroachments
With that many people in India I don't know if that's even possible