This is my special surprise to celebrate my 1000th subscriber. Thank you for all of your support, and I hope that you guys will enjoy this little present as well as my videos in the future.
@@njotosonny I meant on the studio version. It's a blend of Seo/Tae/Jess singing the middle tone leading part + Taeyeon/Jess harmonizing this blend on a higher part. :) On live she would do it (the higher part) while the others were singing the middle tone leading part.
@@luv_markno Tiffany vocal is weaker than Seo though. Tiff is at best high average (C) while Seo is average to above average (C+). Their vocal ranking now is Taeyeon(above average to proficient) Jessica/Seohyun(average to above average) Tiffany (high average) Sunny (mid average) Yuri(Low Weak to average)(Prime: High weak to average) Soo(Weak) Hyo/Yoon(Undeveloped)
De hecho, hay rumores que la SM tenía pensado hacer la sub unidad entre ellas 3, pero que según Jessica no quiso (ya estaba en planes su empresa) y por eso seleccionaron a Tiffany
@@landyestrada541 nop, Jessica no estuvo en TTS porque estaba ocupada siendo actriz y tenia otras actividades en solo, eligieron a Seohyun porque ella no tenia actividades en solitario planeadas en ese momento. Tiffany y Taeyeon iban a estar juntas por su stage de un concierto creo y de ahi les vino la idea de hacer una subunidad, tenian que elegir una 3ra pero debido a conflictos por el tiempo y Taeyeon no estaba en una guerra fria con Jessica, no se pudo
No, Seohyun was not in the chorus. Her main responsible is for hamornization. Once jessica said apologize to taeyeon because she left taeyeon to lead the chorus alone, I think this can assume that just only two of them who carry/lead the chorus when did the performances.
This chorus is so strong yet only two people sing, while Romantis St's chorus is so soft and has 5 people singing Edit: SEOHYUN IS ON THE CHORUS? WHAT THE FUCK?
It makes sense as if you have power vocals you create echo which can fill the songs like what taengsic did Seohyun sings the melody while taengsic harmonizes with their powerful vocals to create the filling effect in the chorus in ITNW which makes us think all members sings the chorus. Meanwhile if it's soft it is very hard to create the filling effect so you need more members to sing like in romantic st
It's so nice to see more about the songs being discovered even after more than 15 years of their debut. The filter is great quality, and Seohyun's inclusion makes sense in retrospect. Thank you for your work.
Seohyun's voice has been on choruses since INTW, but until Forever1 many are still arguing that shes not 😅🤭 SHE'S THE 3RD LEAD VOCAL INDEED AFTER TAENGSIC
Main*. Lead Vocal is Tiff Sun Seo. She would be the 3rd Main Vocal and Yuri will be the 3rd Lead considering how she has much more lines than Sun in the 1st album
Seohyun proving she is 3rd best voice of the group (maybe 2nd now) and that she should've been a main vocalist since debut! I'm so happy after watching this video! Thank you Dora! And congrats on 1k! This is just the beginning for sure ✨️💗
Honestly, they could have 3 Main Vocalists, 3 Lead Vocalist and 3 Sub-Vocalists. Main Vocalists: Taeyeon, Jessica & Seohyun; Lead Vocalists: Tiffany, Sunny & Yuri; Sub-Vocalists: Sooyoung, Hyoyeon & Yoona. Although Sooyoung received more lines in the japanese albums and seems to be bolder than her, Yuri continues to be the 6th best vocalist of the group and she was treated as a Lead Vocalist when they were rookies.
@@abc_jv_xyz they actually did that in one song 3 main vocals-3 lead vocals- 3 sub vocals. taeyeon-jessica-seohyun got the same line then tiffany-sunny-yuri then yoona-hyo-soo got the same lines. i forgot the title of the song
I have been saying for ages that Seohyun was also in the chorus for this song. I'm glad you could show it to people, Dora. 😊🤓 Seohyun has always been the 3rd Main Vocalist for GG (and since 2015 she's clearly the 2nd, while Sunny took the 3rd role).
Wasn't Tiffany the 3rd vocalist in term of lines :? She got nerfed in the latest album but she still got pretty much in Lion Heart and Holiday Night, and all the adlibs go to TTS in these albums. Meanwhile Sunny probably sneaked the 3rd position in Forever 1.
@@taeyeonkim2112 Hey, T.K. =D It basically depends of which era and time of the group we are pointing. I mean, if we go by the beggining years of the group, Tiffany was actually the one with less lines. Just go by the vocal line only song "Day By Day", Tiffany has just a few short parts where the other 4 actually sing throughout the song. :) On "Kissing You" Seohyun and Sunny have chorus full lines, while Tiffany has a short "dalkoman saranghae..." line. And by the main vocalist role, both Sunny and Seohyun were harmonizing or making unision on the choruses with TaeJess, mainly Seohyun, including the most iconic songs of the group for many fans, like "Genie" (group chorus sang by SeoSunTae), "GEE" (being TaeSeoSunJess) and "The Boys" (group chorus main part sang by TaeSeo). :) Tiffany in fact started appearing more trough "Genie" onwards, but before that, at least on the title songs, she had little lines in comparison to the other 4 vocalists. Then she in fact got more spotlight while Sunny lost it (only recovering it on the japanese songs). And by the "main vocalist role" it is more due to the group "ALL" harmonies on choruses and hooks (which was Jessica's and Taeyeon's main roles), which nowadays are less than before. Tiffany have a few group singing harmonies and unisons, and most of them are not lead songs / single choices ("Europa", "Wait a Minute", "Merry-Go-Round", "Karma Butterfly"), only a few where she appears doing this main vocal part are actually lead / single choices like "Paparazzi", "Indestructible", "Mr. Taxi"... But the majority, in comparison, we have Seohyun even if on half of it like "Into The New World", "Kissing You", "Baby Baby", "Genie", "The Boys", "GEE", "Bad Girl (chorus back vocals)", "Mr.Mr.", "Party", "Lion Heart", "All Night"... And even though, nowadays, if we count OT8 songs only, you can still see it that on the few lead sons or not released Seohyun has this role with Taeyeon, taking the 2nd role while the 3rd, which was hers, went to Sunny, not Tiffany (which has to due with musicality and vocal types). Per example, only the OT8 songs with MVS: - "CMIYC": Solo lines. - "PARTY": Solo lines / group hooks the 'p-a-r-t-y, p-a-r-t-y" part (Taeyeon and Seohyun) - "LION HEART": Solo lines + back up harmonies (Taeyeon and Seohyun) - "YOU THINK": Solo lines, duos and adlibs. - "SAILING": Solo lines, few duos. - "HOLIDAY": 4 and 4. - "ALL NIGHT": Solos on 1st | Duos on 2nd | 3rd chorus (Taeyeon, Seohyun and Sunny). - "FOREVER 1": The 4 vocalists, aparrently, even though Seohyun is the base voice on it. So just by OT8 songs with MV, excluding the solos, duos or half and half ones, we have 4 points for Taeyeon, 4 points for Seohyun, 2 points for Sunny and only 1 for Tiffany. :) If we count on leading lines, which are the verses, then sure, at the time of 2012 - 2014 Tiffany really does have way more overall in comparison to Seohyun. :)
@@taeyeonkim2112 I noticed Tiffany was trying to point her value back then between 2012-2015. Now with 2022 release I felt she was more confident of herself and didn't feel the need to stand out that much. Her years of going solo were very good on her, she not only came back without feeling the need to appear more, but she became a smart vocalist either. By "Magnetic Moon" she was very confident on her sing abilities, and now she just didn't feel the need to prove that prior point, but just to participate and have fun on the group reunion, leaving spot for the dance line, just like she did on the song she herself produced, "Villain". =)
@@taeyeonkim2112 For "Lion Heart" and "Holiday Night" there was a new group formation for the OT8 than from the OT9. - GG OT9: (mainly) Solos on the verses, group choruses / sometimes with solos in between, solos or duos on the bridges, group choruses with adlibs on the ending choruses. - GG OT8: (strongly mainly) Solos on the verses, SOLOS on the choruses, solos or duos on the bridges, SOLOS with adlibs on the endind choruses. So basically, they were trying to find a new vocal color with "Lion Heart", while making the public to be more used to their voices without the color Jessica added to the group harmonies. With "Holiday Night" they felt more comfortable into harmonizing or singing in unison ("Holiday", "All Night", "Fan", "Light Up The Sky", "It's You", "Girls Are Back", "Sweet Talk" - which were mostly Taeyeon & Seohyun + Sunny > a few group parts for the remaining 5). For "Forever 1", I don't know why, they decided to mainly focus on solos again, just leaving a few group harmonies for "Forever 1", "Lucky Like That" (1st intro chorus and back up vocals), "Seventeen" (a few parts only), only the last line of "Freedom" (TaeSeo) and "Paper Plane" (TaeSeo).
@@lordodinaesir7643 I meant the 3rd vocalist role here is just about the amount of lines she got, and also how hard her lines are. Tiffany got a lot of high notes and solo lines during Lion Heart and Holiday era. She got a lot of hard notes and adlibs in Lion Heart, You Think, Show girls, Check, Bump It, Girls Are Back, Holiday, and Sweet Talk, while Sunny was in charge of those parts only in You Think and Bump It. And not even mentioned, Tiffany was always on top 3 in these 2 albums, if Jessica got the second chorus of Goodbye to show her 2nd main vocalist role of the group, Tiffany got One Last Time. But in the latest album Forever 1, Sunny got more adlibs than Tiffany and took pretty much harder lines, for example, Forever, Closer and Seventeen. So I think Tiffany was the 3rd vocalist during 2015-17 era, while Sunny and her shared this role in Forever 1 album.
It was always obvious to me about Seo, there was always something cute/girly-sh compared to TaengSic vocals. Thank you for the video, congrats with 1k!💖 Thank you for your amazing analyzes, it's always detailed with notes (who is who) and amazing audio filters, I wish I could separate the vocals this clear like you😁, sometimes it sounds really fantastic
Congrats on 1k subscribers, well deserved!! Thank you for this analysis! I always felt like someone else was singing with TaengSic, and I'm so surprised that Seohyun was in there all along! Her filter was super clear, it's so cool that we're nearing 16 years since this song was released and we're still discovering new things about it. TaengSic of course worked so hard on this song as well and to now see how much work went into this is fascinating. SNSD really has some of the best harmonies in kpop ever!!
So on their girls&peace world tour they included Tiffany for leading their last chorus, right? It seemed like a seofany leading while taengsic doing adlibs and highnotes
Literally got goosebumps from watching this video, it's so mind-blowing to find out new things about the song more than 15 years later, you're really doing god's work!! Thank you so much and looking forward to more snsd vocal analysis videos
So... it is technically not all members are singing in the chorus part, right? By the way, thank you so much for your attempt to filter Seohyun’s vocal at the chorus part. I can hear her voice super clearly now 🥰.
Congratulations to 1k subscribers! Cheers to more! 🥳🥂 Thank you for this gift and all your hard work! ❤ I always hear Seohyun in the chorus thank you for this proof. ❤❤
Thank you for all hard working and congrats for the first 1k of people that subscribed in this terrific channel, we looking forward to see more videos!🎉💗
Congratulations for your first 1k🎉 I always wanna know the vocal layers of kpop songs and you've made the best vocal analysis videos on UA-cam❤Thank you so much!
Can I request paper plane. I'm pretty sure the chorus was TaeNy(With Yuri/Sunny) with a background harmony whom I can't seem to know whos voice it was.Yuri and Taeyeon and an additional background vocalist are credited as bg vocals. Also in the intro hah hah I could notice Sooyoung+Seohyun+Yuri .
ua-cam.com/video/Spvs2yhcXyM/v-deo.html from 2:58, And in this remix, the bridge's high-pitched part only has Taeyeon's - voice. So, I thought there might be more parts that are different from the existing songs
Can you filter forever 1 ? I am curious about the chorus and I feel like Seohyun , Taeyeon and Tiffany are singing the chorus or is it just me because I'm still new to Snsd .
This is my special surprise to celebrate my 1000th subscriber. Thank you for all of your support, and I hope that you guys will enjoy this little present as well as my videos in the future.
This is a *HUGE* surprise, like, Seo is in thr chorus... Really good job and well done
@@Oliver-uz1fs yeah first, when I hear the song Into the New World, I'm pretty sure the chorus is TAEYEON JESSICA AND SEOHYUN very Clearly
congratulations, and thank you for this! 🎉
Jessica and Taeyeon
Harmonizing by Seohyun
That's Top 3 Vocal SNSD since the beginning.
Seohyun is not harmonizing them, the contrary is actually happening. She's the leading voice. :)
@@lordodinaesir7643 she is, you can see their radio performance when seo ready to harmonize, jess stop her because they do the lead chorus version
@@njotosonny I meant on the studio version. It's a blend of Seo/Tae/Jess singing the middle tone leading part + Taeyeon/Jess harmonizing this blend on a higher part. :)
On live she would do it (the higher part) while the others were singing the middle tone leading part.
I always want Seohyun to be the 3rd Main Vocalist of SNSD. She is so underrated
She is the 3rd best vocalist to me !!
Well it's Tiffany
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@hoangnda it has always been her!
@@luv_markno Tiffany vocal is weaker than Seo though.
Tiff is at best high average (C) while Seo is average to above average (C+).
Their vocal ranking now is
Taeyeon(above average to proficient)
Jessica/Seohyun(average to above average)
Tiffany (high average)
Sunny (mid average)
Yuri(Low Weak to average)(Prime: High weak to average)
Soo(Weak)
Hyo/Yoon(Undeveloped)
Now I understand why Into the new world is so legendary. Taengsic plus Seohyun in choruses is the best combination for a Kpop song.
De hecho, hay rumores que la SM tenía pensado hacer la sub unidad entre ellas 3, pero que según Jessica no quiso (ya estaba en planes su empresa) y por eso seleccionaron a Tiffany
@@landyestrada541 nop, Jessica no estuvo en TTS porque estaba ocupada siendo actriz y tenia otras actividades en solo, eligieron a Seohyun porque ella no tenia actividades en solitario planeadas en ese momento. Tiffany y Taeyeon iban a estar juntas por su stage de un concierto creo y de ahi les vino la idea de hacer una subunidad, tenian que elegir una 3ra pero debido a conflictos por el tiempo y Taeyeon no estaba en una guerra fria con Jessica, no se pudo
I always believed Seohyun was in the chorus. It feels so nice to see there’s proof now.
Since the beginning Seohyun still in chorus. She's Queen of background and harmonie SNSD all of the time.
@@snsdgivemetwice it’s always beeb a debate whether she was in the chorus or not.
@@addicted2ys Yeah because sometimes her voice so similar with Jess, Tae and Tiffany
No, Seohyun was not in the chorus. Her main responsible is for hamornization. Once jessica said apologize to taeyeon because she left taeyeon to lead the chorus alone, I think this can assume that just only two of them who carry/lead the chorus when did the performances.
@@MooKrob9935her voice is literally filtered in the video already.
I always believed Seohyun was leading the last chorus because she was in the middle of the choreography. 😅
to think that seohyun is only 16 yrs old when she did this, she's so talented and deserve her position in the group.
This chorus is so strong yet only two people sing, while Romantis St's chorus is so soft and has 5 people singing
Edit: SEOHYUN IS ON THE CHORUS? WHAT THE FUCK?
Whenever I listen to this song with earphones, Seohyun’s voice is very obvious.
@@KoroSensei_ Honestly, I never noticed her
@@abc_jv_xyz her voice is honestly what makes the chorus sound so youthful.
@@KoroSensei_ makes sense, she was a child when she recorded this song
It makes sense as if you have power vocals you create echo which can fill the songs like what taengsic did
Seohyun sings the melody while taengsic harmonizes with their powerful vocals to create the filling effect in the chorus in ITNW which makes us think all members sings the chorus.
Meanwhile if it's soft it is very hard to create the filling effect so you need more members to sing like in romantic st
Taeyeon’s falsetto is the everything
SEOHYUN IS IN THE CHORUS?!!!!!!??!?!?!?!?
3 best vocalists of snsd lead the chorus, so that's why ITNW is always superior and legendary
I was not expecting Seohyun to show up
There's long been debate about whether or not Seo was in that chorus. 🤔 obviously it was full of taengsic. Good job finding Seo!
It's so nice to see more about the songs being discovered even after more than 15 years of their debut. The filter is great quality, and Seohyun's inclusion makes sense in retrospect. Thank you for your work.
Seohyun's voice has been on choruses since INTW, but until Forever1 many are still arguing that shes not 😅🤭
SHE'S THE 3RD LEAD VOCAL INDEED AFTER TAENGSIC
Main*.
Lead Vocal is Tiff Sun Seo.
She would be the 3rd Main Vocal and Yuri will be the 3rd Lead considering how she has much more lines than Sun in the 1st album
Seohyun proving she is 3rd best voice of the group (maybe 2nd now) and that she should've been a main vocalist since debut! I'm so happy after watching this video! Thank you Dora! And congrats on 1k! This is just the beginning for sure ✨️💗
Honestly, they could have 3 Main Vocalists, 3 Lead Vocalist and 3 Sub-Vocalists.
Main Vocalists: Taeyeon, Jessica & Seohyun;
Lead Vocalists: Tiffany, Sunny & Yuri;
Sub-Vocalists: Sooyoung, Hyoyeon & Yoona.
Although Sooyoung received more lines in the japanese albums and seems to be bolder than her, Yuri continues to be the 6th best vocalist of the group and she was treated as a Lead Vocalist when they were rookies.
And yes, she is second now
@@abc_jv_xyz yuri still get more lines than sooyoung in their ot8 albums.
@@abc_jv_xyz they actually did that in one song 3 main vocals-3 lead vocals- 3 sub vocals.
taeyeon-jessica-seohyun got the same line then tiffany-sunny-yuri then yoona-hyo-soo got the same lines. i forgot the title of the song
@@leeaaron8919 you're talking about Star Star Star?
you mean, this song was like their first day at the job? oh, wow.
The forever and ever talented golden Maknae of SNSD... Seohyun the harmonizing queen ... The definition of perfection 💖🥰💗✨
I knew Jessica was helping Taeyeon with that high note lol finally proof 7:40
I have been saying for ages that Seohyun was also in the chorus for this song.
I'm glad you could show it to people, Dora. 😊🤓
Seohyun has always been the 3rd Main Vocalist for GG (and since 2015 she's clearly the 2nd, while Sunny took the 3rd role).
Wasn't Tiffany the 3rd vocalist in term of lines :? She got nerfed in the latest album but she still got pretty much in Lion Heart and Holiday Night, and all the adlibs go to TTS in these albums. Meanwhile Sunny probably sneaked the 3rd position in Forever 1.
@@taeyeonkim2112 Hey, T.K. =D
It basically depends of which era and time of the group we are pointing.
I mean, if we go by the beggining years of the group, Tiffany was actually the one with less lines. Just go by the vocal line only song "Day By Day", Tiffany has just a few short parts where the other 4 actually sing throughout the song. :)
On "Kissing You" Seohyun and Sunny have chorus full lines, while Tiffany has a short "dalkoman saranghae..." line.
And by the main vocalist role, both Sunny and Seohyun were harmonizing or making unision on the choruses with TaeJess, mainly Seohyun, including the most iconic songs of the group for many fans, like "Genie" (group chorus sang by SeoSunTae), "GEE" (being TaeSeoSunJess) and "The Boys" (group chorus main part sang by TaeSeo). :)
Tiffany in fact started appearing more trough "Genie" onwards, but before that, at least on the title songs, she had little lines in comparison to the other 4 vocalists. Then she in fact got more spotlight while Sunny lost it (only recovering it on the japanese songs).
And by the "main vocalist role" it is more due to the group "ALL" harmonies on choruses and hooks (which was Jessica's and Taeyeon's main roles), which nowadays are less than before. Tiffany have a few group singing harmonies and unisons, and most of them are not lead songs / single choices ("Europa", "Wait a Minute", "Merry-Go-Round", "Karma Butterfly"), only a few where she appears doing this main vocal part are actually lead / single choices like "Paparazzi", "Indestructible", "Mr. Taxi"... But the majority, in comparison, we have Seohyun even if on half of it like "Into The New World", "Kissing You", "Baby Baby", "Genie", "The Boys", "GEE", "Bad Girl (chorus back vocals)", "Mr.Mr.", "Party", "Lion Heart", "All Night"... And even though, nowadays, if we count OT8 songs only, you can still see it that on the few lead sons or not released Seohyun has this role with Taeyeon, taking the 2nd role while the 3rd, which was hers, went to Sunny, not Tiffany (which has to due with musicality and vocal types). Per example, only the OT8 songs with MVS:
- "CMIYC": Solo lines.
- "PARTY": Solo lines / group hooks the 'p-a-r-t-y, p-a-r-t-y" part (Taeyeon and Seohyun)
- "LION HEART": Solo lines + back up harmonies (Taeyeon and Seohyun)
- "YOU THINK": Solo lines, duos and adlibs.
- "SAILING": Solo lines, few duos.
- "HOLIDAY": 4 and 4.
- "ALL NIGHT": Solos on 1st | Duos on 2nd | 3rd chorus (Taeyeon, Seohyun and Sunny).
- "FOREVER 1": The 4 vocalists, aparrently, even though Seohyun is the base voice on it.
So just by OT8 songs with MV, excluding the solos, duos or half and half ones, we have 4 points for Taeyeon, 4 points for Seohyun, 2 points for Sunny and only 1 for Tiffany. :)
If we count on leading lines, which are the verses, then sure, at the time of 2012 - 2014 Tiffany really does have way more overall in comparison to Seohyun. :)
@@taeyeonkim2112 I noticed Tiffany was trying to point her value back then between 2012-2015. Now with 2022 release I felt she was more confident of herself and didn't feel the need to stand out that much. Her years of going solo were very good on her, she not only came back without feeling the need to appear more, but she became a smart vocalist either. By "Magnetic Moon" she was very confident on her sing abilities, and now she just didn't feel the need to prove that prior point, but just to participate and have fun on the group reunion, leaving spot for the dance line, just like she did on the song she herself produced, "Villain". =)
@@taeyeonkim2112 For "Lion Heart" and "Holiday Night" there was a new group formation for the OT8 than from the OT9.
- GG OT9: (mainly) Solos on the verses, group choruses / sometimes with solos in between, solos or duos on the bridges, group choruses with adlibs on the ending choruses.
- GG OT8: (strongly mainly) Solos on the verses, SOLOS on the choruses, solos or duos on the bridges, SOLOS with adlibs on the endind choruses.
So basically, they were trying to find a new vocal color with "Lion Heart", while making the public to be more used to their voices without the color Jessica added to the group harmonies. With "Holiday Night" they felt more comfortable into harmonizing or singing in unison ("Holiday", "All Night", "Fan", "Light Up The Sky", "It's You", "Girls Are Back", "Sweet Talk" - which were mostly Taeyeon & Seohyun + Sunny > a few group parts for the remaining 5).
For "Forever 1", I don't know why, they decided to mainly focus on solos again, just leaving a few group harmonies for "Forever 1", "Lucky Like That" (1st intro chorus and back up vocals), "Seventeen" (a few parts only), only the last line of "Freedom" (TaeSeo) and "Paper Plane" (TaeSeo).
@@lordodinaesir7643 I meant the 3rd vocalist role here is just about the amount of lines she got, and also how hard her lines are. Tiffany got a lot of high notes and solo lines during Lion Heart and Holiday era. She got a lot of hard notes and adlibs in Lion Heart, You Think, Show girls, Check, Bump It, Girls Are Back, Holiday, and Sweet Talk, while Sunny was in charge of those parts only in You Think and Bump It. And not even mentioned, Tiffany was always on top 3 in these 2 albums, if Jessica got the second chorus of Goodbye to show her 2nd main vocalist role of the group, Tiffany got One Last Time.
But in the latest album Forever 1, Sunny got more adlibs than Tiffany and took pretty much harder lines, for example, Forever, Closer and Seventeen. So I think Tiffany was the 3rd vocalist during 2015-17 era, while Sunny and her shared this role in Forever 1 album.
Seohyun!!?! Omg
It was always obvious to me about Seo, there was always something cute/girly-sh compared to TaengSic vocals.
Thank you for the video, congrats with 1k!💖 Thank you for your amazing analyzes, it's always detailed with notes (who is who) and amazing audio filters, I wish I could separate the vocals this clear like you😁, sometimes it sounds really fantastic
On the contrary, your separation vocal technique really impresses me. I'm not on the same level as it lol xD
TJS the real vocal sub-unit 🥰
The trio we never had. I always admire these 3 when it comes to harmony and adlibs.
The best kpop song ❤❤❤
National anthem
thank you for let us hear Seohyun voice in chorus
Taeyeon and Jessica voices blend so well together
Rookie TaengSic and Seohyun were monsters.
Congrats on 1k subscribers, well deserved!! Thank you for this analysis! I always felt like someone else was singing with TaengSic, and I'm so surprised that Seohyun was in there all along! Her filter was super clear, it's so cool that we're nearing 16 years since this song was released and we're still discovering new things about it. TaengSic of course worked so hard on this song as well and to now see how much work went into this is fascinating. SNSD really has some of the best harmonies in kpop ever!!
I listened to this almost like thousand times but i still got goosebumps in the last chorus😭
Taengsic❤💖
So on their girls&peace world tour they included Tiffany for leading their last chorus, right? It seemed like a seofany leading while taengsic doing adlibs and highnotes
Yeah, I think so too, because the ad-libs were sung live, so Tiffany was added to lead the chorus.
Literally got goosebumps from watching this video, it's so mind-blowing to find out new things about the song more than 15 years later, you're really doing god's work!! Thank you so much and looking forward to more snsd vocal analysis videos
Congrats on 1k 🎉 couldn’t wait for this song to be covered
I could always hear Seohyun in the chorus but I guess fans will always be fixated on the “main vocalist” titles handed out over 15 years ago
So... it is technically not all members are singing in the chorus part, right? By the way, thank you so much for your attempt to filter Seohyun’s vocal at the chorus part. I can hear her voice super clearly now 🥰.
Technically all members recorded the chorus. Taeyeon, Jessica, and Seohyun recorded extra lines for better effect.
Yes. The chorus is always counted as "All". But in the studio version, it's mostly the vocal line who handles it (mainly TaengSic and Seohyun).
Thank you very much
My favorite snsd song😢 I miss taessica so much😭😭
heyy could you do line distribution with all vocals of the boys?? congrats on the 1k!!
amazing! i always thought the chorus was TaengSic but calrly this Seo also very good job, congrats for the 1k.
thanks for the analysis!!
So greatttt. Thank you for it.
Congratulations to 1k subscribers! Cheers to more! 🥳🥂
Thank you for this gift and all your hard work! ❤
I always hear Seohyun in the chorus thank you for this proof. ❤❤
Waiting the line distribution all vocal 🎉🎉❤❤
Thank you for all hard working and congrats for the first 1k of people that subscribed in this terrific channel, we looking forward to see more videos!🎉💗
Congratulations for your first 1k🎉 I always wanna know the vocal layers of kpop songs and you've made the best vocal analysis videos on UA-cam❤Thank you so much!
Can you do snsd into the new world line
( distribution (all vocals
I’ve been wondering if yoona had the same case as seohyun in girl’s generation’s chorus
For me yes, however dora has said she/he actually hears Tiffany's voice
I can hear Yoona.
congrats on 1k!!
Found Sooyoung
Can I request paper plane. I'm pretty sure the chorus was TaeNy(With Yuri/Sunny) with a background harmony whom I can't seem to know whos voice it was.Yuri and Taeyeon and an additional background vocalist are credited as bg vocals. Also in the intro hah hah I could notice Sooyoung+Seohyun+Yuri .
Hmmm, the chorus of Paper Plane is complicated since I heard a lot of voices in it :< For the intro, I think I heard Tiff's voice.
@@thedoradora definitely it's Tiff voice in the intro I could hear SooSeoYul top
@@thedoradoraIsn't the Intro SunYul.
❤❤❤❤❤
In 'into the new world' remix version, I can heard that there is a Yuri's voice in the chorus, do you know about this?
ua-cam.com/video/Spvs2yhcXyM/v-deo.html from 2:58, And in this remix, the bridge's high-pitched part only has Taeyeon's - voice. So, I thought there might be more parts that are different from the existing songs
I think in the remix version of all songs, producers can add more vocals or not. It’s not always the same with the original ones.
@@thedoradoraWill you filter the Remix verison of the song.
9:36, the one did that adlib is Seohyun, right?
No, she sang the melody
@@thedoradora it sounds really like her voice
WHAT I THOUGHT IT WAS TAENGSIC CHORUS
is Seohyun alongside Taeyeon on the high note before the 3rd chorus or is it just TaengSic?
Nope, TaengSic only
omg this is fantastic!!! so does that mean that it’s possible that Yoona also sings in the chorus of Girls’ Generation?
I think all of the members sing the chorus but Taeyeon and Jessica are doing the harmonies and TaeSic alongside with Seohyun are leading
is Seohyun only in the second and last chorus?
I'm pretty sure the 1st and 2nd choruses are equal, that's why only one of those was shown and the 3rd is different because of the ad-libs
@@abc_jv_xyz Well not just the adlibs. The key of the song changed too
I have to say this is scary~
how?
how did u do this
Can you filter forever 1 ? I am curious about the chorus and I feel like Seohyun , Taeyeon and Tiffany are singing the chorus or is it just me because I'm still new to Snsd .
Congrats for 1k ❤️