@@alysiusgabrielmosquito6779 It's true sadly, there are very few moments all nine voices are used in a choral sense. It is admittedly difficult to control the tone of nine unique singers, hence why they usually only stick to the Mains and Leads. I had hope for Promise, but even then it's just well-layered on that last line.
Yes first time I listened to Taeyeon's high notes after the bridge, I also heard Seohyun's voice there Likewise, when Jessica's high note at the end of the song, there is Sunny's voice too
@@ryanalirzyad4421 I'm glad Seohyun and Taeyeon singing together this song (high note part) in American show but that moment that is their last chance to singing in high note and the rest like music show and concerts, Taeyeon do it that alone.
omg I never noticed Sunny backing up Jess, that's so cool!! also it was really nice to hear them all do "girls bring the boys out". thank you for another great analysis!
It was a wasted opportunity to let Seohyun and Sunny do their back up for Taeyeon and Jessica in the bridge live. But at least Seohyun got to do it in their overseas performances.
Sm struck gold with this group their voices fit so perfectly together and blend so beautifully together I haven't seen a kpop group since that has such perfect vocals maybe because nowadays only certain members get lines it's hard to see who sings well with what member and all the lip syncing on stage nowadays it's hard to tell which member sang which part
Not my favorite song, but this certainly is a fascinating analysis, and also breaks down the harmonics on Tae and Sica's high notes. My ear for Sunny strikes again, legit didn't realize it was her supporting Jessica and why that high note fascinated me so much. XD
7:14 never noticed Tiffany here There's a yt channel called BlowBlast music, they uploaded a video showing that Sooyoung sings the intro too... so it's not her?
@@punpun1818Then YoonA would probably sing Tiffany's lines in the 2nd chorus and that would actually make sense, hence the choruses would be YulSoo/YoonHyo/SunTiff all the members called either rappers or sub rappers
It will be really a tight battle for the top 4. TaeJesSeo with their double layers on the intro and post bridge. Seohyun with double layers on all “B-bring the boys out” lines. And Tiffany’s whisper ad libs and lead on chorus. But I think the eventual ranking will be Jes, Seo, Tae, Tiff in that order.
@@RescueDogFamyeah Seo’s chance of being #1 here is also really high which is quite a surprise but well deserved given she barely ranked first on a title track if all vocals are counted for their title tracks up to this point.
@@punpun1818there was one channel who only did lead vocals line distribution for this song and she was #2 behind Jess as that channel included her harmony with Taeyeon and her “Bring the Boys out” lead before first chorus. So I kinda expect it would be most likely the same. Unless Tiffany’s ad libs or whispers in the verses are counted as lead vocals.
@@addicted2ys If we took out her harmony with Taeyeon she'd be behind Taeyeon. Overall, JeTi would be 1st and 2nd still in the lead vocal. I really thought my mind was messing with me when I heard Tiffany's whisper in Taeyeon's "bring the boys out" in the pre-chorus until one channel did the boys line distribution and perfectly captured all Tiffany's adlibs in the verses. This video confirmed my speculation that Tiffany did indeed was whispering with Taeyeon's bring the boys out.
@7:14 I've always heard Tiffany here layering with Taeyeon, but no line distribution I've seen counts it, even though they count all her other ad libs. But of course you found it too :')
@@Dolphinboi because the official lyrics labeled it “All”, so the lead vocals on the left will be normal Line Distribution, just like other channels. And on the right of the video is background vocals and choruses.
@@Dolphinboi basically, the lead vocals on my videos will count based on the official lyrics, and the others (harmonies, chorus, background vocals) will count separate.
He is former SM legendary producer/songwriter/musicArranger/singer/singingteacher his name is Yoo Young Jin he worked with SM since 1996 but sadly he left SM in March 2023. He is and legendary vocalist check out his song that he made specially for Girls Generation (Yoo Young Jin Beautiful Girls)
I still don't know who is responsible for the lasting high note 'my heart ', after Tae and Seo's joint high notes. It sounds like Tae and it's literally my favourite part.
![[4K] Catch Devil who stole $100! The game to find hidden thieves! (Turn On CC)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dqgCqfxSFRA/mqdefault.jpg)
"GIRLS BRING THE BOYS OUT" the only moment in their discography were all members actually sing together
what? most of their songs they actually sang together esp the chorus part
@@alysiusgabrielmosquito6779 It's true sadly, there are very few moments all nine voices are used in a choral sense. It is admittedly difficult to control the tone of nine unique singers, hence why they usually only stick to the Mains and Leads. I had hope for Promise, but even then it's just well-layered on that last line.
Jessica's low harmony starting at 10:19 is so good and sounding solid for a soprano. Her chest voice is probably one of best in korean industry!
Seohyun in "my heart ~~~" OMG 9:54
Yes first time I listened to Taeyeon's high notes after the bridge, I also heard Seohyun's voice there
Likewise, when Jessica's high note at the end of the song, there is Sunny's voice too
@@ryanalirzyad4421 I'm glad Seohyun and Taeyeon singing together this song (high note part) in American show but that moment that is their last chance to singing in high note and the rest like music show and concerts, Taeyeon do it that alone.
omg I never noticed Sunny backing up Jess, that's so cool!! also it was really nice to hear them all do "girls bring the boys out". thank you for another great analysis!
It was a wasted opportunity to let Seohyun and Sunny do their back up for Taeyeon and Jessica in the bridge live. But at least Seohyun got to do it in their overseas performances.
It's cool to see all the girls shouting "Girls bring the boys out"
Sm struck gold with this group their voices fit so perfectly together and blend so beautifully together I haven't seen a kpop group since that has such perfect vocals maybe because nowadays only certain members get lines it's hard to see who sings well with what member and all the lip syncing on stage nowadays it's hard to tell which member sang which part
I just know there's so much vocal layers in The Boys. Hats off to you for disecting every voice present. o7
Not my favorite song, but this certainly is a fascinating analysis, and also breaks down the harmonics on Tae and Sica's high notes. My ear for Sunny strikes again, legit didn't realize it was her supporting Jessica and why that high note fascinated me so much. XD
@10:35 COME ON SUNNY
The ot9 vocals are gorjerous
9:54 😮😮😮 I can't heard Seohyun's voice clearly before. Thanks for this ❤
taeyeon: singing
tiffany: yeah ah ah hahahahahaha hahaaha
7:14 never noticed Tiffany here
There's a yt channel called BlowBlast music, they uploaded a video showing that Sooyoung sings the intro too... so it's not her?
The way Tiffany got like 2-3 lines here, and ended up being 2nd because of her adlibs in the 1st and 2nd pre-chorus sends me 💀💀💀
Yoona first line actually Tiffany's line
@@wahyu6981 Yeah, but poor Yoona would only have 1 line
@@punpun1818Then YoonA would probably sing Tiffany's lines in the 2nd chorus and that would actually make sense, hence the choruses would be YulSoo/YoonHyo/SunTiff all the members called either rappers or sub rappers
These videos keep me so entertained, thank you so much for keeping the SNSD fandom alive and giving us such interesting and well formatted videos!!
It will be really a tight battle for the top 4. TaeJesSeo with their double layers on the intro and post bridge. Seohyun with double layers on all “B-bring the boys out” lines. And Tiffany’s whisper ad libs and lead on chorus. But I think the eventual ranking will be Jes, Seo, Tae, Tiff in that order.
I think Seo might be no 1 here, with Sica/Tae very close 2 & 3 and Tiff not far behind.
@@RescueDogFamyeah Seo’s chance of being #1 here is also really high which is quite a surprise but well deserved given she barely ranked first on a title track if all vocals are counted for their title tracks up to this point.
@@addicted2ys I think she'd be first in all vocals but 3rd in lead vocals only.
@@punpun1818there was one channel who only did lead vocals line distribution for this song and she was #2 behind Jess as that channel included her harmony with Taeyeon and her “Bring the Boys out” lead before first chorus. So I kinda expect it would be most likely the same. Unless Tiffany’s ad libs or whispers in the verses are counted as lead vocals.
@@addicted2ys If we took out her harmony with Taeyeon she'd be behind Taeyeon. Overall, JeTi would be 1st and 2nd still in the lead vocal. I really thought my mind was messing with me when I heard Tiffany's whisper in Taeyeon's "bring the boys out" in the pre-chorus until one channel did the boys line distribution and perfectly captured all Tiffany's adlibs in the verses. This video confirmed my speculation that Tiffany did indeed was whispering with Taeyeon's bring the boys out.
7:34 hahahahahaha 😂
10:25 YAAAAAAS SUNNY
Please analysis Galaxy Supernova and Paparazzi
it's amazing how you can trace each layer 🔥
@7:14 I've always heard Tiffany here layering with Taeyeon, but no line distribution I've seen counts it, even though they count all her other ad libs. But of course you found it too :')
their most sophisticated song in terms of layering and harmonisation
Omg where have you been, I'm always waiting for you and waiting for VITAMIN LINE DISTRIBUTION ALL VOCAL😢😢😢😭😭😭
So sorry 😢 I’m fixing the Vitamin LD video now and I’ll release it soon.
@@thedoradora today release vitamin line distribution all vocal , i’m still waiting until this tonight 🥺🥺🙏🏻😅
THANK YOU SO MUCH DORA! you slayed again ❤
Will you upload the album distribution of ITNW 1st single?
The distribution video for the first single ITNW, will be included with the first album Girls’ Generation.
I always thought that hyoyeon was in the chorus haha but thanks for the video, i was waiting for this analysis!!
my favorite song ❤👑
Maybe mr mr next? 🫣🫣
Good analysis, as always, but one question: Will you also include "The boys: English Version" for the Album Distribution?
Yes, I will
@@thedoradora Cool, thank you for answering me 😊
There are some vocals that I’ve never heard before. Thank you for filtering them. 🥰
At 10:19 I can hear the lower harmony is continuous and not just the girls part and it sounds more like a talking/rap part
There’s an extra lower harmony under “Girls”. Not just the continuous one
That's part still have harmonie by produce this song "Young Yoo Jin" (sorry if I'm write wrong name) 😅
@@Taeyeon89 I know and that extra lower harmony is what i meant to still be continuous as well
Hyoyeon doesn't sing "bring the boys out" 😢
❤8:40 that's Hyoyeon
4:52 Seohyun doesn't sing with Yoona?
No, Seohyun only sang it when they live on David Letterman Show. The reason is maybe SM wanted the performance sounds better I think
what a complex song OMG.
This comeback was the definition of hype.
Is Tiffany not leading her chorus??
The Boys allowed Dancers & Lead Vocalists to take over the chorus!!🎉
So unique!✨️
i can’t really hear tiffany but i hear taeyeon, jessica & seohyun
Ok but that’s such an unflattering pic of Hyo
Amazing!! Will you do a line distribution of this song?
Yoona sound so hot tho
Omg what in the world did you use to isolate those vocals?
So for the chorus of every girls generation song all members sing but a couple of members lead the chorus?
Yeah, I think they chose a few members to record the chorus "All", but on stage it’s all members singing.
@@thedoradora so why in ur vids do u count the chorus as separate from the lead vocals?
@@Dolphinboi because the official lyrics labeled it “All”, so the lead vocals on the left will be normal Line Distribution, just like other channels. And on the right of the video is background vocals and choruses.
@@Dolphinboi basically, the lead vocals on my videos will count based on the official lyrics, and the others (harmonies, chorus, background vocals) will count separate.
Fun Fact: The extended taeyeon high note is changmin from TVXQ
wow
Also do y’all know who did that high “aaaaaaah” after Taeyeon’s my heaaaaaarrrttttt in the bridge?
it's a male singer but i don't know who
It’s Yoo Young Jin, his name is in the credit background vocals of this song.
He is former SM legendary producer/songwriter/musicArranger/singer/singingteacher his name is Yoo Young Jin he worked with SM since 1996 but sadly he left SM in March 2023.
He is and legendary vocalist check out his song that he made specially for Girls Generation (Yoo Young Jin Beautiful Girls)
I love intro this is song ❤
Sunny voice always there…
I still don't know who is responsible for the lasting high note 'my heart ', after Tae and Seo's joint high notes. It sounds like Tae and it's literally my favourite part.
it's probably Yoo Young Jin you're talking about
Wow! It sounds so much like Tae, but he is an amazing singer that it's totally plausible. It would have never occurred to me. Thanks 😁
this was really interesting! thank you for the analysis 💞
maybe Tiffany is 3rd...
No, top 3 in the boys SEOJESSTAE
@@ryanalirzyad4421 on the song? yes. on the album? probably not
@@abc_jv_xyz no , if total album the boys all vocal , still TAEJESSSEO 1-3
@@abc_jv_xyz just see 😊😊
i love this channel sm