@@Taeyeon89 Her voice sounds fuller as well. Idk if the producers implemented her voice to be like that, same with Sunny doing the cutesy voice. Such a shame
@@alexblack4048Not gonna lie. Seo does a good job but i feel like it should be. Seo does the harmonies for Dance line while Yuri does it for Vocal line. Dance line Vocals are good but not compared to vocal line. Yuri is a weaker vocalist but with Stronger Vocalists she still can be heard. Meanwhile there are times when i cant hear Seohyun.( Like ITNW except for Flower Power. She overpower Yuri voice) Seohyun does a good job though. Seo voice is quite obvious when pair with Dance line.
That background harmony at the bridge 11:07 is absolutely gorgeous! I knew Taengsic were in charge of that harmony, very similar to the background in Run Devil Run choruses
I don't think people realize how truly innovative this song is in just the production alone. The vocal mixing, layering, harmonies, everything was so well thought out and done with a purpose. Even though it was a big risk musically for GG, 11 years later and IGAB still stands the test of time, and you can see it's impact in sooo many hit kpop songs. This is the definition of iconic
I said what i said..many people said i got a boy album and mr mr album was the downfall of jessica position as main vocalist..she might be not the top 3 in line distribution, but her voice can be found everywhere in the songs..she basically in charge in background vocal, harmony and chorus
yess! i been waiting your analysis from this song, i was a little suspicious that Jessica is in chorus, but with this i confirmed that, good job like always! ^^
This is why sm still the best when it comes to production.. they first don’t depend on 1 member doing all the bg vocals, second not use doubling as much as harmony and layering.. on top of that, SNSD vocals never disappoint
@@thedoradorafinally someone said this! Lots of sones are calling Seohyun as the queen of harmonies when Taeyeon and Jessica mostly do the works behind the scenes. Like i know seo is really good but both tae and jessica had to sing the melody and had to sing the loudest (mentioned by jessica in strong heart) because they are the main vocalists
@@babae6598Seohyun is queen of harmonies because she easily has the best sense of pitch in the group and rarely goes off key, whenever they do live performances with harmonizing you can tell she’s by far the most talented in harmonizing
@@TwBelgi78Seo is the best harmonizer. She cab harmonize easily due to her neutral tone. I think Seo only sang it live due to Tae singing the line after the Chorus or Tae singing the melody. But Seo does have some bad moments. Seo has some bad moments like when She cover Jess HN in mr mr. (She did great but her tone though...)
@@nighthunter3372 Jessica would go flat during that same note which is fine. It’s normal for your notes outside of your supported range to not be consistent. (Also a irrelevant comparison because we were talking about harmonization and that’s not an example) Seohyun learned how to harmonize well before becoming a member of SNSD so to say she’s good at harmonies just because she has a neutral tone in the group doesn’t make sense. Seohyun’s voice is still pretty light and feminine and especially during their debut her voice changed somewhat because of her age. Her ear for harmonies didn’t change even after puberty though which tells you her skill.
@@Oliver-uz1fstrue even Soo and Maybe Yuri and Yoona were in the chorus. (Yuri has a chance in Tinkerbell and Yoona in Girls Generation) but that’s very likely it’s them
@@beebeehruaii9590 Don't worry, I'm just referring to myself. I entered the comments section and became quite late with the fun and excitement. It has relatively more user engagements than the other videos.
I always thought that the chorus was TaeSeoYul not TaeJessTiffYul. Anyway I think chorus is counted as Tae x 2 Jess x 2 Tiff x 1 Yuri x 2 then move to Tae x3 Jess x 2 Tiff X Yuri x 2. Then those ooh are Tae x1 Tae x2 Jess x 1 Jess x2 Tiff x 1 Seo x 1 Ranking Tae Jess Tiff Seo Yul Soo Yoon Hyo Sun Yuri might over take Seo who knows.
@Oliver-uz1fs ummmm.... wasn't it first Japanese 2010/2011, the boys 2011, 2nd Japanese in 2012, and then igab 2013? Third Japanese mid-2013, and then mrmr early 2014? I think
You sure misses me a lot! Right? To the point of never forgetting it. What a joke! 😂😂😂 Well, you stans are the ones who really complained about her lack of leading lines 🙄🙄🙄 I can see Taeyeon still tops that song. Oh! By the way. Wasn't she kicked out the of he group not too long after this album was recorded? Lol It's been like ten years now and you stans are still so delusional😂😂😂 It's still very entertaining even after all this time... kicked out 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@MichelRodrigues-xb8kesnsd fans are hypocrites and fake like their favs trying to erase jessica from the group's history as if she hadn't been part of the debut group until 2014 (7 years in the group) lol 😂
It’s always been Taeyeon. Seohyun only sang it live but let’s be real. That’s Taeyeon through and though. Seohyun (or anyone in the group ) has never sounded that strong
In the live stage, Taeyeon needs to sing the melody chorus, so Seohyun sings the harmony instead of Taeyeon. Or you want Taeyeon uses “Bunshin no Jutsu” so she can sing melody and harmonies at the same time 🙂 plus, this is not a job cuz I didn’t earn any money from these video 🙃 thank you for your toxic cmt
![[Knowing Bros] Thai Female K-pop Idols' Wittiest Moments Compilation🤣](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A7VGRr96RDE/mqdefault.jpg)
Don’t forget to join my discord group: discord.gg/6AWfqtGAbG
The Yuri in the thumbnail is proof that yuri gonna be slay here
11:07 I was NOT expecting that beautiful Taengsic part
11:07 taengsic harmonization is eargasm main vocal thing
“Babe wake up Dora Dora just posted another analysis” ahhh it’s IGAB too!!!
yuri's voice is perfect for choruses she blends perfectly she should have sung in more choruses
They really should've groomed her to be part of the vocal line. Too bad they ruined her voice after they released 4 albums.
@@lalalalalalalalalariHonestly. The light , nasal &whiney singing she does 95% of the time now is much less pleasant than her pre 2011 approach
@@Taeyeon89 Her voice sounds fuller as well. Idk if the producers implemented her voice to be like that, same with Sunny doing the cutesy voice. Such a shame
In all fairness seohyun already had the chameleon job
@@alexblack4048Not gonna lie. Seo does a good job but i feel like it should be.
Seo does the harmonies for Dance line while Yuri does it for Vocal line.
Dance line Vocals are good but not compared to vocal line.
Yuri is a weaker vocalist but with Stronger Vocalists she still can be heard. Meanwhile there are times when i cant hear Seohyun.( Like ITNW except for Flower Power. She overpower Yuri voice) Seohyun does a good job though.
Seo voice is quite obvious when pair with Dance line.
That background harmony at the bridge 11:07 is absolutely gorgeous! I knew Taengsic were in charge of that harmony, very similar to the background in Run Devil Run choruses
YURI ATE THAT CHORUS UP I CAN ONLY HEAR HER VOICE
Vocal line being credited as background vocals is everything 👏🫶
Just realized doing a line distribution for the last chorus is gonna be hell 😭😭
I'm crying 😭
I want to know why wasn't Yuri credited she did so many Bg vocals.
omg that pentatonic-esque scale harmony by taengsic at 11:07 is ethereal sounding! what a lost duo 😔😔
was not expecting jessica in the “i got a boy” chorus part omg?
I don't think people realize how truly innovative this song is in just the production alone. The vocal mixing, layering, harmonies, everything was so well thought out and done with a purpose. Even though it was a big risk musically for GG, 11 years later and IGAB still stands the test of time, and you can see it's impact in sooo many hit kpop songs. This is the definition of iconic
The TaeSicaTifYur chorus is everything and the TaeSicaSun refrain/bridge part is heavenly. Truly an iconic song.
I said what i said..many people said i got a boy album and mr mr album was the downfall of jessica position as main vocalist..she might be not the top 3 in line distribution, but her voice can be found everywhere in the songs..she basically in charge in background vocal, harmony and chorus
10:53 so beautiful and strong 😍❤
SLAY YURI
Wow, now I can hear Jessica's voice in the chorus. But Tiffany low melody is really hard to filter 😱
yess! i been waiting your analysis from this song, i was a little suspicious that Jessica is in chorus, but with this i confirmed that, good job like always! ^^
Predictions for all vocals :
1.Taeyeon
2.Jessica
3.Yuri
4.Tiffany
5.Seohyun
6.Yoona
7.Hyoyeon
8.Sooyoung
9.Sunny
This is why sm still the best when it comes to production.. they first don’t depend on 1 member doing all the bg vocals, second not use doubling as much as harmony and layering.. on top of that, SNSD vocals never disappoint
not the entire dance line out-background vocalling sunny.
Sunny is taking revenge in look at me lol
i think she'll be 7th in the overall distribution
Recording IGAB must've taken a lot of time. Missing SNSD even more now
The way I always KNEW Hyoyeon and Yoona sang that 3:07 part with Jessica and literally no one believed me lmao
I dunno why but they always tried to blend hyo vocals with softer tones like her vocals was a problem when there was nothing wrong with her voice
So the first verse is JeHyoYoon 😮
11:07 this was always my favorite part of the song, taengsic’s harmonies are too good
Girl i can't wait for a line distribution video of yours of this song like..
I couldn’t believe Seohyun is not in the chorus as she always did the higher harmony live.
I knew Yuri sang the "I got a boy..." part cause I could hear her voice so much in that part
Can't wait for the LD
wonderful!
oh, I thought Seohyun was in the chorus and harmonizing like when she was live on stage. Still hear her voice
In the live stage, Taeyeon needs to sing the melody chorus, so Seohyun sings the harmony instead of Taeyeon
@@thedoradorafinally someone said this! Lots of sones are calling Seohyun as the queen of harmonies when Taeyeon and Jessica mostly do the works behind the scenes.
Like i know seo is really good but both tae and jessica had to sing the melody and had to sing the loudest (mentioned by jessica in strong heart) because they are the main vocalists
@@babae6598Seohyun is queen of harmonies because she easily has the best sense of pitch in the group and rarely goes off key, whenever they do live performances with harmonizing you can tell she’s by far the most talented in harmonizing
@@TwBelgi78Seo is the best harmonizer. She cab harmonize easily due to her neutral tone. I think Seo only sang it live due to Tae singing the line after the Chorus or Tae singing the melody.
But Seo does have some bad moments. Seo has some bad moments like when She cover Jess HN in mr mr. (She did great but her tone though...)
@@nighthunter3372 Jessica would go flat during that same note which is fine. It’s normal for your notes outside of your supported range to not be consistent. (Also a irrelevant comparison because we were talking about harmonization and that’s not an example) Seohyun learned how to harmonize well before becoming a member of SNSD so to say she’s good at harmonies just because she has a neutral tone in the group doesn’t make sense. Seohyun’s voice is still pretty light and feminine and especially during their debut her voice changed somewhat because of her age. Her ear for harmonies didn’t change even after puberty though which tells you her skill.
You're the best! Please never get tired of these vocal analysis videos. 😭❤️ We are grateful for your work!
11:10 Jessica+ Sunny sounded like Yuri
I’ve been waiting for Igab version 😙
yuriiiiiiiiiiiiii
FINALLY❤❤❤❤
ISTG the YulSoo sound like Hyo is in there as well. 3:55
Vocal line group:
Let's all do the bg!
*Sunny has left the group
*Yuri has enter the group
It’s kinda true if you look at the 1st album, Yuri has more lines than Sunny
@@nighthunter3372 gets worst when you think that Sunny isn't apparently in any chorus of the first album
@@Oliver-uz1fstrue even Soo and Maybe Yuri and Yoona were in the chorus. (Yuri has a chance in Tinkerbell and Yoona in Girls Generation) but that’s very likely it’s them
🤩🤩
quá tuyệt vời shop oi, ra ngay cả album cho mình nha 🥰🥰
Bà chờ thêm mấy năm nữa nhé =)))
@@thedoradora trơi ơi gục ngã
Whens the distribution. I can't wait
When I finish the new layout for LD video :< it’s gonna be a long timeee
omg what do you use to separate and get in between the vocal layers?? i’d love to do some for the pussycat dolls
Someone is missing in the comments section...
Do you mean the Sooyoung stan who dislikes Yuri lol
@@beebeehruaii9590 haven't been to DoraDora's channel lately so what's the tea? 😂😂
@@beebeehruaii9590 Don't worry, I'm just referring to myself. I entered the comments section and became quite late with the fun and excitement. It has relatively more user engagements than the other videos.
I always thought that the chorus was TaeSeoYul not TaeJessTiffYul. Anyway I think chorus is counted as Tae x 2 Jess x 2 Tiff x 1 Yuri x 2 then move to Tae x3 Jess x 2 Tiff X Yuri x 2.
Then those ooh are Tae x1 Tae x2 Jess x 1 Jess x2 Tiff x 1 Seo x 1
Ranking
Tae
Jess
Tiff
Seo
Yul
Soo
Yoon
Hyo
Sun
Yuri might over take Seo who knows.
FINALLY!
3:13 isn't that's Jessica & Hyoyeon??
Jessica always sang in live version
She’s literally credited a few seconds after for the same part
Jessica is in lead layer, HyoYoon is in bg layer and that line is trio
okay 😂 thank you 😊😊🙌💞💕@@thedoradora
@@snsdgivemetwice also in some stage, 3 of them lipsync that line so it makes more sense why they have different choreography
@@thedoradoraMake sense 😅 but sometimes HyoYoon forget about sing/lipsync it. Yoona who often forget to sing it. Lol
4:56 Seohyun isn't on the chorus but Jessica is?
At first I though there is TaeYuTi only, then Jess dropped her voice there and I was like: 😲 okay girl
@@thedoradora i'm really surprised but i'm happy yuri has a chance to be in the top 4
Yuri is the first dancer to record an all chorus then
Half the dance line did the TOP all choruses
@@RescueDogFamtop was after or before this?
@@Oliver-uz1fs before IGAB....or maybe after? i mean girls and peace album defo was released before IGAB album
@Oliver-uz1fs ummmm.... wasn't it first Japanese 2010/2011, the boys 2011, 2nd Japanese in 2012, and then igab 2013? Third Japanese mid-2013, and then mrmr early 2014? I think
@@RescueDogFam exactly
To the one calling this album "Jessica's downfall"
You sure misses me a lot! Right? To the point of never forgetting it. What a joke! 😂😂😂
Well, you stans are the ones who really complained about her lack of leading lines 🙄🙄🙄 I can see Taeyeon still tops that song. Oh! By the way. Wasn't she kicked out the of he group not too long after this album was recorded? Lol
It's been like ten years now and you stans are still so delusional😂😂😂
It's still very entertaining even after all this time... kicked out 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@MichelRodrigues-xb8ke and who are even you? I wasn't talking about you lol
@@MichelRodrigues-xb8keliterally no one gives a fuck
@@Oliver-uz1fs You don't even believe that yourself.
@@MichelRodrigues-xb8kesnsd fans are hypocrites and fake like their favs trying to erase jessica from the group's history as if she hadn't been part of the debut group until 2014 (7 years in the group) lol 😂
Isnt seohyun the higher harmony in chorus. 💀 Do yout job well
It’s always been Taeyeon. Seohyun only sang it live but let’s be real. That’s Taeyeon through and though. Seohyun (or anyone in the group ) has never sounded that strong
and why are you being so entitled? doradora doesn't owe you anything
In the live stage, Taeyeon needs to sing the melody chorus, so Seohyun sings the harmony instead of Taeyeon. Or you want Taeyeon uses “Bunshin no Jutsu” so she can sing melody and harmonies at the same time 🙂 plus, this is not a job cuz I didn’t earn any money from these video 🙃 thank you for your toxic cmt
@@thedoradora dude you killed me with the "bunshin no jutsu" 🤣🤣🤣
Shut your little mouth if you don't have anything nice to say. You don't know better than anybody here