No. I'm a huge Yankee fan and love Judge and Soto back to back. But that's an absurd question. Not even in the top 50 duos. Simply because they've got like 65 games together. Even on the Yankees they aren't the greatest. Ruth and Gehrig is the greatest ever. DiMaggio and Berra, Berra and Mantle, Mantle and Maris, even Jeter and O'Neill would be over them. Not because Judge and Soto aren't individually more talented or anything. It is just come wrong them to guys with several years together. Ask again in 4-5 years if Soto stays with the Yankees.
Are Juan Soto and Aaron Judge the best 1-2 punch in MLB history?
Paul Molitor - Joe Carter of the '93 world champ Blue Jays.
No. I'm a huge Yankee fan and love Judge and Soto back to back. But that's an absurd question. Not even in the top 50 duos. Simply because they've got like 65 games together. Even on the Yankees they aren't the greatest. Ruth and Gehrig is the greatest ever. DiMaggio and Berra, Berra and Mantle, Mantle and Maris, even Jeter and O'Neill would be over them. Not because Judge and Soto aren't individually more talented or anything. It is just come wrong them to guys with several years together.
Ask again in 4-5 years if Soto stays with the Yankees.
I wouldn't put them near the top, but that era of Molly was pretty incredible. Guy was just a professional hitter.
We would need to see a lot more before we make that proclamation. Yankees have had historic tandems of Ruth-Gehrig, Mantle-Maris, DiMaggio-Berra.
you need to hold off on the Soto, Judge combo until October, at the very least.
Every comment here is correct. Way too soon for a question like that. I am a very big yankees fan BTW.