JoJo Anime & Manga Differences Part 3 - Stardust Crusaders
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 жов 2024
- Patreon: / hamonbeat
Join The Discord: / discord
Follow me on Twitter: / hamonbeat
Songs Used:
Approach
Calm Sightseeing
Purple Thorns
The Return of Travellers
Reasons why anime is better than the manga:
1. Polnareff land
2. Polnareff land
3. Polnareff land
The voice acting,the music and the animation
@@brachialtick6539 **ahem** simpleton its polnareff land
I think you forgot to put in polnareff land
*BURAVO OH BURAVO*
You forgot to put 1 more polnareff land
Props to DP for adding the stardust crusaders picture scene.
And the stand arrow in Dio's wall
I had no idea it was anime only, it's so iconic!
ikr
Goat_ Sama best decision besides holding back Dio’s stand power reveal . That photo is just so iconic and emotional to look at (especially with Last Train Home)
@Chew Diamond Ye but it was never taken in the part 3 manga.
The Anime added Polnareffland. Instant 10/10 Adaptation
Would visit again 10/10
@Jaxen Babia-Ramos the perfect being
Ya know polnareffland was the reason giorno was in Florida
Janrei Africa That was the first thing I saw of Jojo, so I thought Polnareff was the main villain and that Polnareffland was his goofy motivation.
Yes
Extending scene of Jotaro shoting himself.
Extending scene of Joseph being racist.
I see David Production only focuses on important stuff.
I don't know why but the spelling "shoting" makes the coment better, please don't change it
agreed
I wouldn't say racist lol, he was rather being ignorant.
@@elizabethchint6485 _well i mean he did kick a guy in the knee just because he was japanese_
@@keklekekle1114 More likely his temporary hatred toward Japanese because Holy married a Japanese, which somehow upsetting him.
6:08 That was a VERY good decision
For sure, so much shock value
Yeah, shooting the Emerald Splash into a billboard instead was much better. It being shot into a building in the manga pretty much ruined the whole fight tbh.
@@CrunchytheGoblin wrong scene man, wrong scene...
Why? Cause it implies innocent people died because of Kakyoin?
Lol. When i read this comment, I was in that same part you were talking about😂
The anime adds a scene were Joseph complains about his coffee, because why not?
It was funny
Because in part 4, Joseph talks about how good is japanese coffee
@@maciejpolak2458 Character growth
John Blunt Alzheimer’s*
@@mrsplashman8308 "I guess i just get better with age"
Oh, I didn't know that the group photo was only introduced in Part 5 of the manga. Nice of DP connecting dots and fixing smaller continuity errors afterwards.
It's not really a continuity error, the photo would have been taken somewhere in Part 3, DP just gives you the exact moment.
cont-dump yeah, but it’s kinda dumb that it suddenly appears out of nowhere in part 5. This photo is so iconic due to DP showing it in the anime, it’s emotional just to look at it (and that final scene in the plane just makes it 10/10)
@@danielz-v4083 It was iconic before, DP just made it better.
@@danielz-v4083 Dude, it's a picture. Not everything needs to be shown offscreen and there were more important moments in Part 5. Anime only JoJo fans just love to put their priorities upon minor scenes, and then act like "Araki Forgot"
Star Platinum I am not an anime only dickweed. I just love a good story (books or movies) , and when a macguffin(not the case) or an important object from the past just suddenly appears “Because” , it’s bad writing. Cause you’re forcing the idea that something happened even tho you did not show it . Hell, it’s worst than fucking exposition, and everybody knows how great exposition is, right? And no, I am not calling Araki a bad writter, what I am saying is that he tends to introduce or just “forget” pre introduced statements and objects out of nowhere wayyy too much, and that’s probably his biggest flaw as a creator.
3:09 Literally the most important addition
I hope that Jean actually did build Polnareff land after universe reset
@@NiCoNiCoNiCola The universe didn't reset, parts 1-5 still happened.
@@Supertimegamingify so there is a chance build Polnareffland?
@@NiCoNiCoNiCola have you read part 5 yet? I don't want to spoil it for you.
@@Supertimegamingify I know he is a turtle now. Even a female one. But he can change his soul with someonelse's body and make the turtle a mascot for Polnareff land
Heck, he can change bodies with Rohan and become an animator
6:21 I really love David Production decision to have Joseph mentioning Erina in this scene and DIO did remember her because I think it did help to connect Phantom Blood and Battle Tendency to Stardust Crusaders better and somehow serve as a reminder to watch JoJo in the chronological order
Imagine Joseph mention Erina and Dio just say: "I kissed her good back then mmm".
@@rency1803 “mmm yes, good old days mmm”
@@rency1803 mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
hahahaha , good one
@@christmasgrinch4017 "great days"
The photograph bits were super helpful to the contuinity
If only they added a tiny scene of Jotaro picking up a diary or with a diary on the plane, so that part 6 wouldn't be so random.
A LITTLE bit.
@@thatoneotheridiot3361 Jotaro having the diary on the plane would so much more random, because he burned it in Dio's mansion, right after reading it. Also Part 3 and Part 6 are almost 10 years apart and with 2 other parts in between, nobody plans a manga that much ahead. But a scene of the crusaders returning to Dio's mansion after the fight would have been nice
@@Dennis-rv7rd I know right.
@@Dennis-rv7rd Yeah, I just realized I was dumb saying that almost a year ago. I'd ask why you're replying to something a year old, but I do the same thing quite often to see how they respond.
Kakyoin: *I S E E*
Jen
With mummy wrappings around his eyes
Kurapika: Am I a joke to you?
@@GalekC MUMMY
MOMMY
Damn, that group photo scene was added by David Productions? Best decision and change imo, that photo made scenes a lot more emotional, especially during that final act and when we actually saw it in Vento Aureo.
Also, pretty much associates that photo with “Last train home”.... and everyone knows the feelings of jojo fans upon hearing that beauty
Man that song always makes me sad lol
They literally couldn't find a better song for such emotions
I always mention that Dio had a parrot and nobody ever believes me.
Well, who's laughing now, mother!?
Ayyy lmao dis nigga has more friends than me not even my mother watches jojo with me lmaooooooo Depression is just too...xD Xdddddd
@@dr.emmettbrown5345 Well, you'll always have that teenaged boy, doc.
I'd imagine if the parrot could talk, it would be voiced by Gilbert Gottfried
@@ToastyMann It would be amazing if Gottfried had voiced Jotaro. Just imagine him saying "Tare tare daze."
In the anime, DIO's parrot is actually pet shop, that's something hamon beat didn't mention
"When DIO deflects Kakyoin' Emerald Splash"
*BUT NO ONE...*
*CAN JUST...*
*FUCK YOU, KONO DIO DA!*
*DEFLECT THE EMERALD SPLASH*
*DEFLECT THE...?*
𝗘𝗠𝗘𝗥𝗔𝗟𝗗 𝗦𝗣𝗟𝗔𝗔𝗔𝗦𝗦𝗛𝗛𝗛!!!
Part 3 is probably one of the coolest parts in JoJo albeit one of my least favorites. I like how it feels like you are on a genuine adventure with the various characters.
That's why it's my first or my second favorite part
It's just a great adventure through the world, with different people against various stands
I completely agree it may not be my favorite part but its one of the coolest
@@sadcena7204 Part 1 is the best in my opinion,because of jonathan
Part 3 is good, but in retrospective 4-5 and 6 was better.
@@orangeviperau9960 6?
4:10 So, Jotaro had loved dolphins from the start.
Yes.
Good Grief
Yes Yes Yes Oh My God
and apparently he hated Sharks
@@elyisusking3603 i dont blame him
5:54 There's also a Where's Waldo/Wally cameo in the top right corner.
I didn't believe you, but checked just in case
if you want to count that
i would, looks pretty out of nowhere to me
cool
VitalZenny14
OH FUCK DIO KILLED WALDO WTF OMG NO I CAN'T
Za Warudo= The Waldo
So that's where Waldo was...
For all the Jotaro stuff they removed like him being more emotive, they sure added a whole lot that expanded upon the part and did wonders for the continuity. So all is well and I love both versions!
I'm not mad because it fleshes the other Crusaders more, which was something the manga lacked, and they have 4 and 6 to develop Jotaro anyway.
Araki and David productions really dropped the ball on this. Star platinum smiling was always cool to see ,like when jotaro beat kakyoin
@@qtarokujo4144 You are aware Araki has nothing to do with the anime, right? I wonder why JoJo fans automatically asume he's responsible or involved with every single thing that happens in the franchise.
@@DEADPOOL9AND sorry I ment that David productions should have added more scenes of star platinum being emotive, and that araki shouldn't have stopped doing it after the yellow temperance fight.
I personally enjoy star platinum showing more expression's it's what hooked me with jotaro.
Oh boi. The duwang is coming
chew
Random Creative Name even plot points
And its gonna be beautiful
Why are they called the duwang
@@TheM2D Look up part 4 english translation
DP is seriously the GOAT for all those added scenes. Rereading the manga and I swore all those scenes were just there already!
You missed the diference between the "huh you are aproching me" anime and manga, the manga is just jotaro and dio, the anime their stands are clashing punches
Gabriel Eduardo also polnareff going”what? That wasn’t me, that was the car radio!” During the Wheel of Fortune segment
Underrated comment🏆
Actually the anime turned the "approaching" panel into the last frame of the episode (ya know, when the whole screen goes yellow-brown and To Be Continued appears?) and added the stands, while the actual scene where Jotaro is approaching DIO and the latter walks towards him is a lot less epic (it's just a frontal view of Jotaro and DIO's back)
I actually read the manga before Stardust Crusaders was finished and yet i totally forgot that the picture was an anime only thing. That's just how iconic it was.
6:20 man that callback was so sad and yet so important, can you imagine Granny Erina telling young Joseph about Jonathan and how much of a gentleman he was? 😭
I love how even extremely minor details got added in by DP, like the stand arrow getting added in the background. That's some dedication.
0:30 here's normal anime jotaro before becoming a jojos
There he is, an actual 17 year old. It was been there the whole time
@@stevepensando2593 you just personally recked my shit today is my birthday. My seventeenth birthday
I want to see a shoujo anime featuring pre-stand Jotaro.
Queefling, it would be amazing
@@scribbledip53 Late happy birthday by the way. Shame I didn't get the notification earlier
I'm a bit miffed they took out all the expressions Jotaro makes in the manga, as well as all the little introductory panels looking way different. DP added a lot, though, so I'm not complaining.
Also, J.Geil doesn't have some "rain shield" ability. It's just Hanged Man making maximum use of its ability by slashing apart any droplets that would fall on J.Geil. He slashes the reflections of the drops while moving from drop to drop. It should be a cakewalk for Hanged Man, which is incredibly fast.
Manuel Mateo I do like how Jotaro was more expressive in the manga but everything else the anime added was pretty cool
In part 4 they added Jotaro's expressions, so it's cool.
Sounds exhausting, though. Why not just hold the reflection of an umbrella over him?
@@CaptainDoomsday Because that's not how Hanged Man works. It's not like Man in the Mirror where it can interact with the reflections of objects, nor can it create things in those reflections. It just travels between them and pops out to attack.
@@CaptainDoomsday Using Stands normally doesn't exhaust the users at all unless they're doing something that goes against it's natural limits. Going that fast is natural to Hanged Man, and staying so close to J Geil doesn't hurt either.
Still doesn't explain why J couldn't just use an umbrella like a normal person, but maybe he thinks you can't use one unless you hold it in your left hand.
Great vid, but wanted to point out you missed one of the best added scenes: Polnareff destroying the copy of his sister and accepting that she's gone / he needs to move on. In the manga the copy is unceremoniously destroyed by Abdul and there's no revelation for Pol.
NO ONE CAN JUST DEFLECT THE EMERALD SPLASH
This just had to be in the comments didn't it lul
Wryyy
@Milos9 *P L I T*
A woman's ovaries can just not deflect the white splash!
The addition to the Anubis fight is really quite excellent. It's a short moment, but it brings back two otherwise forgotten abilities, heightens the tension in a logical way, and makes sense in the progression of the fight. It's little stuff like that that really shows how much DP cares.
You forgot about the foreshadowing of jotaros timestop. When he punches n'doul with star platnum, there's a small effect with it
Which episode ?
the rainbow? idk. i heard its just effects
Killing lots of people with nasty explicit violence = Okay
Running over some people with a car = unacceptable
they have that scene in the old OVAs
@@ginogatash4030 That's one of the reasons I hate it
Why you hate that? It was in the manga.
@@ginogatash4030 Well I am Egyptian so I hated seeing this happening to people of my country
@@adamdimitri2562 are you trolling? Is them being egiptian the only problem? Would it have been fine if they weren't egyptian? By that logic you could never show people getting hurt/die ever.
DP added a bunch of stuff to get to the 48 episode count.
I personally liked this but it made some people really dislike part 3 and its pacing.
I haven't watched it a second time
But the first time it felt like it dragged on a bit too long
Atleast it makes the anime version the "definitive" one.
@@Robodragon17 That's what i'm saying, the anime version makes it feel like part 3 drags on too much but that doesn't happen in the manga.
Part 3 is the shortest post-part 2 part in the entire series, if they adapted like they did with part 4 it would've been roughly 35 episodes. Since they split the part in 2 seasons i guess they needed to have 24 episodes in each oh them and the pacing really suffered because of that.
Krosez the pacing wasn’t even that bad and it picks up in the second season
@@carlbloke8797 I agree.
As i said, i personally like how DP decided to adapt the part; but a lot of people don't and i can see why.
It's a matter of taste really, anime part 3 was a joy to watch imo, but a chore for others. The pacing isn't bad but it's weaker than the one from the manga imo.
OH MY GOOOOOD!, Joesph was listening to "Get Back"! Which is literally a song about a guy named JoJo! fuuuuuuck
The first line of the song "JoJo was a man who thought he was a loner..." pretty much describes Jotaro in the beginning of SC.
5:53 There is Wally! I didn't notice him at the first time because the last couple of chapters of part 3 I have read weren't in color.
4:30 Oh im sorry, i think you may be mistaken sir. That's actually called the fight with B L A C K P O L N A R E F F
Dark polnareff
they really had to change it to BLACK polnareff in the game lmfao
that one time the photo showed up on part 5. i swear to god, the feelings was in
6:00 : *Exists*
Dub Kakyoin: *WHAT?! THERE'S NO WAY!*
I just realised that The Beatles' "Get Back" at 6:42 has a character in that song named "Jojo"
David Pro really made Jojo great, the manga is really good, but honestly DP brought it to life with all the extra nods and additions to the anime series
In the manga, when Jotaro is sent flying and lands on the bridge, you can see the Pyramids in the background. They're not in the anime, probably because they're not actually that close to the Nile and it's unrealistic to see them from there.
Actually, the anime reversed the direction Jotaro is sent flying. In the manga, he's moving toward the Pyramids, so he's moving west. In the anime, he's moving away from the Novotel, which is on the west, so he's moving east.
In the fight against Avdol on the mangá, he kicks the toilet, on the anime he kicks a little table that breaks the toilet. There's a little addition to the Jotaro VS Kakyoin fight with Jotaro running and using StarPlatinum to kick the trash can on Uncle Kak. Also, on the manga Jotaro is first using another shirt.
They removed the iconic scan of Dios majestic walk
ほぉ？ むかってくるのか？
I’ll never get over when I first saw Jojo it was the part 3 OVA and Avdol came back when they fought Justice. When I finally saw the actual part 3 anime and he didn’t come back I was shook
"Extended scene of Jotaro shooting himself, including him handing back the gun."
people who don't watch jojo: *oh, ok.*
Since you're going to be adding stuff to the Part 3 reference vid, there's a scene where Rubber Soul eats 4 beetles off a tree, which is probably a reference to the Beatles (though I'm sure people have already bugged you about that one).
Also in the end Joseph listens to "get back", which tells the story of Jojo who thought he was a loner and isolated himself far from home, but needs to come back to his friends and family because that's where he belongs.. So yeah get back Jojo
The Stardust Crusaders literally went aboard a yellow submarine during the High Priestess fight.
4:24 perfect sync with avdol's lips
Im fuckin dead especially at the end
You forgot that the anime extends the Kakyoin fight where Jotaro now runs around the room a bit and kicks a stool/table at Kakyoin and the line "Well let me show you; just how evil you are!" is split up so that the second half is after deflecting the Emerald Splash and Kakyoin saying "Impossible, he just shrugged off the Emerald Splash!" and Star Platinum closing his fist and landing a strong punch on Hierophant Green before the barrage
Jotaro reading marine life is like cosmopolitan to him.
4:10 look what he’s reading
*SEA*
@@gigashark068 see
Conclusion, the anime is better than the manga
I think they are both better in their own ways
Diego Liam Santos oh, without a second thought. Not only that, but the way DP innovated with the color schemes, Phenomenal Voice Acting and the great Soundtrack definitely made every jojo part A LOT better, especially part 2, even though it had less than the manga, it made up for it
Never, manga dont have 2 episodes to defeat the SUN in desert and have a better pacing
@@orangeviperau9960 Uh. The Sun fight was only 1 episode?
@@Petronia911 2
They sorta changed the scene where Jotaro is approaching DIO. They still approach each other in a less dramatic way, but iconic panel from the manga appears in a similar matter when the episode ends. The ground has that roundish look with Jotaro and DIO placed in the same spots, but in different poses and their Stands ready to fight.
This time the anime adds a lot of scenes instead of removing them
It should do neither cuz now it drags for far too long
@@IAm-zo1bo I personally think these scenes enhanced the adaption
5:05 Hol horse say "it's high noon"!!
JoJo is the best example of GREAT adaptation of manga, what not only tells us a full manga story, but also give us a LOT of more scenes, details and other things!
4:12 When I finished SC, I was confused of where did Jotaro get his magazine from to save himself from DIO's knife
he landed on a magazine store beforehand
He stuffed his clothes with books since magazines wouldn't do shit
And he lands on a book store after donuting DIO
I've been looking forward to this video!!! thanks for uploading so soon, I really like this manga v anime series ^^
manga: i’m so short that you can read me in only 5 minutes
david productions: chuckles i’m in danger
All of the additions were pretty positive for the overall story IMO
Not sure if this counts, but you forgot that Kakyoin looked different in his first appearance, having a radically different hairstyle (in the manga). Polnareff looked a little different upon his first appearance in the manga too.
For future reference, Part 4 adaptation cut the most important thing in the whole JoJo series - ‘I took a shit and forgot to wash my hands’.
Did it really? I haven't watched the anime adaptation yet. That was a hilarious scene.
Who said that? I only watched part 4 in anime xD
Nahuoxus Josuke, during his game with Rohan.
I love part 3...always nice to see my boys.
Best differences in ascending order:
3: Adding characters like Petshop and Enya to previous scenes to be more impactful to the story
2: The part 3 picture shown in part 3
1: Polnareffland.
I love jojo adapation, cause it complements better the story, it fixs Araki forgot situtations.
ua-cam.com/video/lJ65P8S70WI/v-deo.html
It’s amazing how much DP improved the story with the additions.
Part 5 video is gonna be like 20 minutes
You were right
Can we appreciate the hard work DP has put into Jojo?
you forgot how stand jumps were touched upon in the manga but in the anime it appears like they're flying
Thanks again. These are so great. Good work.
6:02 But... *NOONE CAN JUST DEFLECT THE EMERALD SPLASH*
2:10 Lupin and Jigen.
Wait they are Cannon in Jojo
They added a lot of nice things.
I love all the little additions that hint at the future of the series, like the stardust crusaders picture, or jotaro reading a marine life magazine
In conclusion both are fantastic.
The scene at 5:53 shows Waldo in the air, pretty nice easter egg.
"NO ONE CAN DEFLECT THE EMERALD SPLASH" 6:00
3:39 So...which one of those cloaked figures is Pet Shop?
Or Anubis?
Great video. Concise and straight to the point.
You know i like to imagine dio was reading shakespeare or paradise lost and probably learned every language to be an othentic god
You missed how the ending to the polnareff and vanilla ice was shortened and polnareff bandaging his wounds better climbing Dios stairs being cut
arguably the best scene in sdc is when polnareff bandages his wounds with dio´s curtains and thinks about how nice they are then holds onto them to cough up blood while talking to Dio it showed that yes dio´s curtains are in fact nice having many uses and polnareff being funny both incredibly important
I’d love to see DP do similar changes to Holly running to Jotaro in the beginning of Part 3 to Jotaro meeting Jolyne in Part 6. I’d also like to see them put some later enemy stand users in some Whitesnake/Pucci scenes.
This is American coffee.
Hm?!
I loved the detail that in the anime of Vento aureo the photo remains the same, with the style of ST
5:53 you gotta watch the OVA to get this scene in anime form.
it took me awhile to appreciate part 3, once it was over i was sad, i was all warmed up and ready to see more from jotaro
2:01 She's a little runaway
By the way, I don't know if anybody knows this but in the Beatles song, "Get Back" The lyrics tell the story of a character named "Jojo"
Part 3 was probably my favorite of them all. And it would have been a good ending if that was the end.
Rare to find a person who loves part 3.
It's my Second fav part in the manga
Sadly DP adaptation worsened SC dragging so much the story
I get why Joseph was listening do get back by the Beatles, because they mention a person named jojo a lot
I was hoping to also do the OVA
In another video
@@Hamon_Beat
Just remember: Steamroller>Truck
Spinozilla Saurian oil tanker > steamroller
@@Jana-kc8wi I will get you
I feel like all of these scene changes are very small/negligible or beneficial
Good job DP
4:52 did I miss something I dont remember a trap loli
I wish you hadn't said that.
@@cutecommie I went back and re watched it i think i missed this ep
@@haramberoth117 what do you think of the episode lmao
Okay but at 4:54 it sounds like he said “there’s a new scene of Joseph taking a spirit photo of DIO’s asshole” and I died laughing
Emmett Hanly oh my god
Part 3 is literally the best anime adaptation known to man
Nop, 16 volumes to 50 episodes, rough bad pacing.
That scene with the 9 Gods makes you wonder about Anubis and Pet Shop.
Even if we assume Anubis had possessed somebody earlier, why didn't he keep the host? By the time he gets to Chaka he's just stranded.
Not only is Pet Shop a bird, but as you mentioned, they already showed him with Dio in the scene showcasing Jonathon's Stand (granted it was a parrot in the manga), so there's no reason for him to attend a gathering and leave.
I guess the only logical explanation is the last two were Kenny G. and Vanilla Ice.
Nobody:
Auto-generated Translation names: Jethro, Paul Death, Chucky, Calculon, Paul Arif, Avid, paula rafts, cackling, aghia, kakuhen, deus, díos, kon, tattoing, Ariy, Dia, Pon RF, judge roll
The Jotaro from Holly's flashbacks looks like an entirely different anime
3:55 Where's Wally?
4:30 i think this is the reason about all of those star finger araki forgots
The jotaro theme easily made the anime better than the manga
Jotaro: dude u pissed me off
(Theme song start playing in the background)
Me: _boy he gonna do it_
Jotaro: star platinum!!
Sp: ey boss
Villain: (and it was at this moment he knew,he fucked up)
sp: *ORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORA*
When you're facing jotaro and the theme is on, just run...doesnt guarantee your safety tho
That photo is legendary :'(