I’ve always been 50/50 on Troy. He had so much potential but at the same time he wasn’t supposed to last long anyways. He had more impact “dying” in s3 rather than if it was s4 instead. I wish Travis got a more impactful death like he created the bridge explosion so he actually dies for something meaningful.
I take that back Troy still could have had an impactful “death” in s4. Imagine after the bridge explosion the Proctors go to war with the whole family. Troy is on their side but he became more neutered being around them but after breaking bad for the sake of the war. Madison sees him start to go savage again but this time take it too far. She is forced to kill him because he’s too relentless and he will leave collateral. This betrayal shocks and breaks Troy as well as Madison as he was just trying to help them. This death wasn’t done out of spite but rather out of sparing the universe from Troy’s wrath if that makes sense. Ironically, after they defeat the Proctors she starts to break bad - becoming what she feared of Troy. Eventually going into the direction that Erickson wanted.
Thank you for doing this what if, I was hoping to see a scenario where he survives until the very end but you make some valid points, season 4 would've definitely been way more enjoyable with Troy Would you consider doing a what if where the governor didn't die and met negan
I have done a what if on what if the Governor was not too far gone but in the scenario I had the group stay at the prison. Would be interesting to play out what could happen though if they did meet
If Erickson never left Troy would not of died. The only reason Troy died in season 3 is because Erickson did not want the new show runners to ruin him.
I’ve always been 50/50 on Troy. He had so much potential but at the same time he wasn’t supposed to last long anyways. He had more impact “dying” in s3 rather than if it was s4 instead. I wish Travis got a more impactful death like he created the bridge explosion so he actually dies for something meaningful.
I take that back Troy still could have had an impactful “death” in s4. Imagine after the bridge explosion the Proctors go to war with the whole family. Troy is on their side but he became more neutered being around them but after breaking bad for the sake of the war. Madison sees him start to go savage again but this time take it too far. She is forced to kill him because he’s too
relentless and he will leave collateral. This betrayal shocks and breaks Troy as well as Madison as he was just trying to help them. This death wasn’t done out of spite but rather out of sparing the universe from Troy’s wrath if that makes sense. Ironically, after they defeat the Proctors she starts to break bad - becoming what she feared of Troy. Eventually going into the direction that Erickson wanted.
Finished the entire series yesterday, it wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be
Thank you for doing this what if, I was hoping to see a scenario where he survives until the very end but you make some valid points, season 4 would've definitely been way more enjoyable with Troy
Would you consider doing a what if where the governor didn't die and met negan
I have done a what if on what if the Governor was not too far gone but in the scenario I had the group stay at the prison. Would be interesting to play out what could happen though if they did meet
Do you think victor could manipulate Troy?
No I don’t think he could. The only reason Madison could manipulate Troy is because she was a parental figure and he got big mother issues.
What if the Proctors came back for revenge in season4 and we actually got some continuation from where we left off?
I did do a video about that years ago. Where I talk about what if Fear was not rebooted.
@@HoboDucksyh I just watched the video. The story would have been so much better.
Perhaps Erickson would have actually brought back Troy as well. Only he would have executed it better. By showing and not just telling for starters.
If Erickson never left Troy would not of died. The only reason Troy died in season 3 is because Erickson did not want the new show runners to ruin him.
@@HoboDucks But they did when he returned.
It’s so dumb they brought him back. He was super dead and they did not care
This guy has a real smug look on his face
Does im only one who think Laurent will die in Daryl Dixon saison 2 ?
Why do you think he will die?
@@HoboDucks dont know just a feeling. But hope he not, Daryl too
I think it will be maybe Isabelle that could die