I-Land 2 Ep. 5 - Review and Ranking

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 60

  • @helenzhang8039
    @helenzhang8039 6 місяців тому +270

    the way the mentors were acting like sujung is a choreographer they hired for the show and not a normal contestant like everyone else

    • @SoraiaLMotta
      @SoraiaLMotta 6 місяців тому +34

      feels like they are trying to make her crumble for the drama. you cant just be the better dancer, what else you can offer? as they did with the "visuals" but maybe this pushed her to choose a strange position in the 1 to 1 battle, to prove herself in the next episode.
      She is very mature / pro that I forgot that she is still fragile. maybe they are trying to build up a story line of superation, as she hardly had any challenge beyond lack of vocal training.

  • @hao7250
    @hao7250 6 місяців тому +114

    The way everyone agrees that ground creative should have won instead of iland Tells a lot they were so harsh on sujung when she was upping the standards alot

    • @mariasol1545
      @mariasol1545 6 місяців тому +12

      I am not sure if sujung will debut or not at this point... it definitely is starting to worry me how against her the judges are

    • @emzellaaaa
      @emzellaaaa 6 місяців тому

      @@mariasol1545pls vote for her when the time comes!

  • @Isabella_5488
    @Isabella_5488 6 місяців тому +118

    I love Mai, but I totally agree with you on this one. If Jeemin or Sujung get eliminated next episode i will cry.

    • @kimkardashi-un2.051
      @kimkardashi-un2.051 6 місяців тому +8

      I don't think Jeemin will be eliminated this early, I think she'll at least get in the final, Sujung idk tbh, the judges hate her lmao

    • @mariasol1545
      @mariasol1545 6 місяців тому +1

      yes I also really like chaeeun and how much growth she has shown in dance, I know that's an unpopular opinion amongst western fans, but she really would be a great addition to the group

    • @K_LEE100
      @K_LEE100 6 місяців тому

      I believe sujung will make it to part 2 because many DarLings votes for her too.

    • @juuviolets2643
      @juuviolets2643 6 місяців тому

      Jeemin will definitely debut, she’s the most popular trainee both in Korea and internationally, but if she doesn’t then the show is rigged.

  • @blueveluv4748
    @blueveluv4748 6 місяців тому +36

    I feel like the stage outfits played a role on ground's defeat in the creative battle. I mean just look at these outfits compared to iland's outfits bro... Iland gets all these sparkly shimmery eye-catching outfits meanwhile all ground gets are white tops with black shorts like? The stage outfits also play an important part in a performance and I feel like it's just so much harder to connect with ground's performance when they look like they're just doing a dance practice and not an actual performance.

  • @kczyue
    @kczyue 6 місяців тому +32

    in short, judges r biased. i can tell they hate sujung

  • @alexisseaborn8463
    @alexisseaborn8463 6 місяців тому +28

    the whole jiyoon and jungeun "feud" is really annoying to me. as someone who's new to mnet survival shows i was made aware of the evil editing and it seems like jiyoon is the victim this year. jiyoon and jungeun might be friends, they might not be friends, but who the hell cares? it doesn't make either girl a villain because of it. sometimes you don't get along with everyone and that's okay, but again they might be friends or trying to be friends. i'm sure the contestants could barely hear anything with yui crying her heart out, the other girls pointed it out, but instead of showing how happy everyone was they decided to show an awkward looking jiyoon and jungeun. i know they need drama, but pitting a 16 year old against a 18 year old is weird

  • @Thing1G
    @Thing1G 6 місяців тому +63

    I think 6 was the right amount of people to leave iland, but ground DEFINITELY deserved to win the creative battle. I've gone back and rewatched their performance several times, and I NEVER rewatch survival show performcanes just for fun. And the lack of Sujung appreciation just suckssssssss. I'm also glad someone agrees that Mai's expressions are just a bit too much in that performance. Scared for thursday cuz I feel like Soul and Gyuri are getting eliminated.
    Also, I know most Mnet shows have 12 episodes, but sine episode 7 is a filler does that mean part 2 is gonna be shorter than part 1? Especially when you consider that most of episode 8 is probably going to be centered around the elimination, and episode 12 is just going to be a dramatic reveal of the final lineup, so we basically only have 9, 10, and 11 for team missions. Probably only 9 and 10 since 11 will probably mostly be prep for a finale mission. When you compare that to the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 that part 1 got it really makes you doubt if they're going to be leveling it up in part 2 like Mnet keeps telling us they are.
    Anyways, sorry for ranting, have a nice day!

    • @kimkardashi-un2.051
      @kimkardashi-un2.051 6 місяців тому

      Soul is definitely getting eliminated, she isn't that popular, idk about Gyuri tho. I think Jeemin, Sujung, Yuju, Lingling will stay because they are really popular, maybe Yeeun and Koko as well

  • @R.o.S.E_BLUE_
    @R.o.S.E_BLUE_ 6 місяців тому +19

    I watched this entire video and literally agreed with every single part of it. That's pretty rare for me when watching these types of videos lol. I love your survival show comments they are always so interesting.

  • @minwonruuu2283
    @minwonruuu2283 6 місяців тому +13

    I may never get over how frustrating the judges were with the Rain On Me performances... maybe it's my inexperience or maybe it's my bias, but I still don't get what was so good about iland's performance that pushed them to win over ground's. Like, the gap between their scores should NOT be that close. Also, it's your ONE job as a judge to judge based on ONE criteria. It's okay to expect more from Sujung, but judge her as an idol trainee, not as a dancer, because ILAND 2 is an IDOL survival program.

  • @miskatulmumu5785
    @miskatulmumu5785 6 місяців тому +80

    Leejung's hypocrisy is on another level. She can do a f****** shoelace tie choreo that's also too nonsense for me but can't give a honest feedback to a trainee who is literally just a trainee of the show choreographing a whole performance alone. Leejung just lost all my respect with her comment "it was just stable". I don't know what "stable" means to her. In every episode she never fails to fangirl over mai blindly or with her open eyes I don't know. But it's really annoying to see whatever her biased trainees give she will eat all. Performer like Yui, gyuri just can't get a chance to listen some appreciation from them cause they are not "mothers" or "leaders" to their same age or 1 year old fellow trainee. Sujung's this epi is just a example of how mentally strong she is as a trainee. I hope they don't rig the voting also but can't believe them anyways.
    Just agreed with all your opinion.

    • @kimkardashi-un2.051
      @kimkardashi-un2.051 6 місяців тому +14

      Mai gets all the attention because of her visual, I don't find anything interesting about her tbh

    • @lovetahsin
      @lovetahsin 6 місяців тому +2

      @@kimkardashi-un2.051same! The only appealing thing she has is stage presence, while that’s a good thing, it’s the only thing she has 😅 I wish yuju won.

    • @miskatulmumu5785
      @miskatulmumu5785 6 місяців тому +4

      @@lovetahsin Yuju is much more consistent than Mai. But they wanted to show us Mai's mothering or leadership "quality" and that's the place they got content about her. I was so confused about her that if I'm not so fond of her or something then they released the "day off episode". I really wanted to see Mai's personality. But what I found is she has no personality it's all mn*t's edit credit whatever you say. Just because someone has good expression that can't really beat someone who is more good in another units as well as "stage presence/ facial expressions" Yuju is more deserving for me.

    • @lovetahsin
      @lovetahsin 6 місяців тому

      @@miskatulmumu5785 exactly!!!

    • @taeynv_
      @taeynv_ 6 місяців тому

      ​@@lovetahsin tbh mai's stage presence in Rain on me came off very unnatural and made her look like she was doing too much

  • @AriLostinSpace
    @AriLostinSpace 6 місяців тому +16

    I 100% agree with your top 7! I definitely think Mai needs more training before she can debut. Don’t get me wrong I love her, but her voice is nasally and she needs to practice her breath control. Having watched episode 6 I feel like Gyuri continues to get shunned by both the audience and the producers which is frustrating because she has so much cute charisma and charm alongside her skills. Yui definitely shined in episode 6 as the center of one of the Iland groups. One person I think may definitely be a top contender especially considering her popularity is Lingling. She has many international fans that love her and she might fight her way to the top through votes alone. I can’t deny she has a strong stage presence in the most recent episodes as well. Another top contender is Bang Jeemin who will definitely debut on votes alone. So if I were to be realistic about my ideal lineup Jeemin would definitely take the spot of either Sarang or Yui. (Maybe Gyuri but my heart won’t be able to take it if she doesn’t debut) Anyways I feel like I-Land 2 is definitely pushing its stronger contestants which is a relief. I get flashbacks to Wonhee from R U Next? And I honestly think that though the spotlight is definitely unfairly distributed, the spotlight is given to the people who shine. People like Sujung, Fuko, Jungeun, and Jiyoon deserve to shine.

    • @miskatulmumu5785
      @miskatulmumu5785 6 місяців тому +5

      But mai is definitely debuting. She is mn*t's favorite yk. Not hating but Yui, gyuri are kinda more deserving to me

    • @azkayla504
      @azkayla504 6 місяців тому

      @@miskatulmumu5785agreed

    • @kimkardashi-un2.051
      @kimkardashi-un2.051 6 місяців тому +2

      ​@@miskatulmumu5785Gyuri doesn't really bring anything to the group aside from her cuteness tho, at least Yui is a good rapper and a decent dancer/vocalist

    • @miskatulmumu5785
      @miskatulmumu5785 6 місяців тому

      @@kimkardashi-un2.051 but I like gyuri's vocal. Just my personal opinion

    • @_c.a.t__
      @_c.a.t__ 6 місяців тому

      ​@@kimkardashi-un2.051if we compare Gyuri to Mai (love both) gyuris vocal is a lot better than mais. they both have great stage presence, both decent dancers and both have leadership qualities. personally I feel like Gyuri is a vocally better version of mai. I love Mai tho, I love her attitude and her stage presence. she's getting a bunch of hate and she deffo doesn't deserve it cause she's super talented too

  • @elly1433
    @elly1433 6 місяців тому +10

    i personally preferred the i-landers' performance for rain on me better but maybe i'm just easily emotionally affected

    • @__renn
      @__renn 6 місяців тому +2

      yep me too 😭 but it really couldve been either way ground was so good

  • @blinkoverhere4649
    @blinkoverhere4649 6 місяців тому +14

    pretty shocked to see that the iland creative unit won. imo, ground deserved it, but at least they moved some of them to iland from ground.

    • @missaminah
      @missaminah 6 місяців тому +2

      The iland won but after that most of them go to ground and both from iland are eliminated.

  • @mxiulivs
    @mxiulivs 6 місяців тому +19

    This show is so confusing. I wanna cry.

  • @ladydiamond6611
    @ladydiamond6611 6 місяців тому +3

    *THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU* The mentors must have been smoking weed the way they were so off this episode?!?! Had me feeling like I was going *CRAZZY!!!!*

  • @korphish
    @korphish 6 місяців тому +4

    edit: SUJUNG MADE IT TO PART 2 PLS VOTE FOR HER IM BEGGING
    no bc i was watching this episode live and i felt so gaslit with how they justified creative iland’s victory like,,, did we watch the same thing ? and as a sujung supporter since previews i am so tired of how they treat her pls like it’s completely understandable to have a higher standard for those with more refined skills compared to other contestants but i feel like they’re taking it too far ??? the “too stable” comment was so annoying because yeah,,, she’s stable,, consistently good,,, and her choreo was good !!! or at least better than the iland choreo u know ?? icb this was graded by the mentors like ??? i was rooting for you we were all rooting for you !! overall i guess it felt unfair bc they focused so much on the bad factors when objectively there was more good factors lol

    • @miskatulmumu5785
      @miskatulmumu5785 6 місяців тому +2

      I believe if they got to perform first they would definitely win. The difference was one point, they definitely exaggerated the points to balance. Three of the ground unit just did so well that they deserved all the victory but I kinda knew they wouldn't do that. 9 i landers going to ground is too much for them, all is about TRP yk.

    • @korphish
      @korphish 6 місяців тому +1

      @miskatulmumu5785 oh yeah for sure mnet didn't plan on 9 girls leaving iland, it just sucks that the girls would have possibly felt like they didn't do well enough when, in reality, they truly did do a good job :< I hope they didn't lose confidence because of that but oh well all I can do right now is vote as much as i can for my pick😭

    • @miskatulmumu5785
      @miskatulmumu5785 6 місяців тому +1

      @@korphish same here. I voted for them and really wished for them. This is all we can do

    • @lxve_585
      @lxve_585 6 місяців тому +2

      RIGHT I AGREE WITH YOU SO MUCH You can tell the Iland team was never meant to win anyways most of the team went to ground and 2 people from their squad got eliminated Not to mention why was the camera work carrying their preformance 😭 And lastly the day they can treat Sujung like a normal contestant and not some person choreographer is the day I’ll rest in peace

  • @dzrmgkva
    @dzrmgkva 6 місяців тому +10

    Thanks for informing, I'm curious about new group but watching whole show is too much for me, also I'm still traumatized after runext

  • @blackman3957
    @blackman3957 6 місяців тому +1

    *Sarang definitely desrve the center position. Among all the trainees her presence is more refined.*

  • @elfieedae
    @elfieedae 6 місяців тому +1

    Choi Jeungeun’s voice reminds me of Kim Sujin from Universe ticket

  • @jaimeyss895
    @jaimeyss895 6 місяців тому +8

    Well at least im not the only one that thinks that Juwon and yui are so underrated and Mai and sarang are extremely overrated and biased 😂😊

  • @josealexanderocampo3805
    @josealexanderocampo3805 6 місяців тому +1

    I miss your videos where are you😢 if you are busy I hope you can do it after ☺️

  • @lama7763
    @lama7763 4 місяці тому

    I agree with many of your creative unit points and you honestly changed my mind on who should’ve won but I want to point out some things.
    I would like to point out more is how I feel like iland seemed more like a team effort (not that that’s a bad thing on ground) but ground seemed like it was only one persons idea comparatively (even with the whole umbrella being a comment) non of this is for or against any team but honestly I feel like if it’s based on “creativity” it makes no sense because you would have to incorporate how much someone suggested creative ideas into the points which you couldn’t see on the performance. Anyway, if it was based off of creativity of individuals, I would, based on what they shown, give island a higher average then ground because only one person would have the creativity points (maybe two).
    Second thing I want to bring up: although I feel like ground should’ve won (shouldn’t be based off of “creativity” as in like each of the members creativeness individually like I feel it implies) iland should definitely have been given a ton of props still because they were literally doomed to fail, but didn’t give up and came up with creative ideas individually (the challenge was obviously harder for the team and they had way less experience)
    Sorry if some of this doesn’t make sense 😂 thanks for reading if you did

  • @silkentertainment6749
    @silkentertainment6749 6 місяців тому +1

    Ground ate up iland I fear…
    In every single performance

  • @Karen-ex5tg
    @Karen-ex5tg 6 місяців тому

    Can't believe the person who created the stupid shoe lace choreo criticised Sujungs fun and creative choreo

  • @wonderingchuu
    @wonderingchuu 6 місяців тому

    Am I the only one who liked better Iland's Creative Unit ? Both were very creative but Iland's one felt better, idk it's just a feeling...

  • @joyurizzzz
    @joyurizzzz 6 місяців тому

    mai is sweet, but that’s all there is to her. she doesn’t particularly excel in anything, and saebi overpowers her in terms of being a stan attractor. imo, mnet pushing her so much is doing the exact opposite of what they want bc there’s not much to back up the high scores/feedback she’s been getting

  • @leti5247
    @leti5247 6 місяців тому +1

    Yesss new video

  • @loveurselfuwu
    @loveurselfuwu 6 місяців тому

    No no, now ep 7 is gonna come on this thursday

  • @teapage101-x3v
    @teapage101-x3v 6 місяців тому +6

    i swear if jeemin does not dabut ima boycott mnet

  • @Lucaate
    @Lucaate 6 місяців тому +1

    I dont know if im the only one , but i think nana did really good , something that her points dont show im so confused?
    i think she shouldnt have be eliminated this episode but maybe loose the vote (shes clearly not a fan favourite) her solo part is also something i reallyyyyy and i mean REALLLY enjoyed , kang jiwons elimination for example was more fair , her solo part was short , she looked a lil whacky but even all that put into her performance , i think she still stood out. What do u thinkk??

  • @wiinnnn___
    @wiinnnn___ 6 місяців тому +2

    ୧⍤⃝🍿

  • @buniisuz
    @buniisuz 6 місяців тому +1

    We know you don’t like jeemin but not having her in the lineup while having gyuri and some others is too much

    • @cayley.
      @cayley. 6 місяців тому +4

      gyuri is talented but not sure about chaeeun

    • @chuu_guevara
      @chuu_guevara 6 місяців тому +1

      gyuri is so talented tfym

    • @buniisuz
      @buniisuz 6 місяців тому +1

      @@chuu_guevara She is but honestly very few of them can compare to jeemin 🤷‍♀️