'Putin Not Evil': Ex-Indian Envoy To Russia Lashes West Narrative; Explains Russia-Ukraine Reality
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 кві 2024
- Amidst rising global tensions, the Ukraine conflict stands as a pivotal battleground, with the West and Russia engaged in a high-stakes standoff. As diplomatic efforts intensify, a proposed peace summit looms on the horizon, aiming to address the crisis. However, with Russia's reluctance to participate, questions arise about the effectiveness of such initiatives. In an exclusive interview with Kanwal Sibal, former Indian Ambassador to Russia, insights into the West's desperation to involve India in the summit are revealed. Stay tuned as the world watches closely for the next move in this geopolitical chess game. Click to uncover the unfolding diplomatic maneuvers.
#russia #russiaukrainewar #india #ukraine #moscow #terrorattack #putin #isis #pmmodi #india #france #italy #israel #netanyahu #china #usa #biden #zelenskyy #ukraine
Subscribe to The Times of India's UA-cam channel: goo.gl/WgIatu
For daily news & updates and exclusive stories, follow the Times of India
Facebook:
/ timesofindia
Instagram:
/ timesofindia
Download the app: toi.in/3SLUCa80
Follow the TOI WhatsApp channel: bit.ly/3RYl0J9
Follow TOI+ for well-researched and in-depth news and analysis
Facebook:
/ timesofindiaplus
Twitter:
/ toiplus
Instagram:
/ toi_plus
Germany not only has no sense of history , it has no sense at all .
Including the common sense...
Including the common sense...
Same for You !
Chamberlain said the same of Hitler. We all know how well that turned out. Those who do not learn from the past are certain to repeat it.
This is a case of the pot calling the kettle black.
🇵🇱 With love from Poland 🇵🇱❤🇷🇺
Piesz nie pisz 😂
Are these the words, written on the bombs on russian troops.
My Germany is not better.
@@grzegorzgorlewski8103I wish my country have Mr.Putin as president instead persons like rudy Tusk or idiot Holownia
American gas sold to Europe is 4 times more costlier than sold to Americans in their domestic market. So ; who blew up the Nordstream pipeline ?
They hawked up and spit violently into Europe's face.
Gazprom! They wanted to avoid being sued in a German court of law for failure to preform their contract. On top of that, Gazprom is trying to collect on the insurance for the pipeline.
So Gazprom destroyed the best economic leverage they had over Europe, losing 10s of millions in gas and the cost of the pipeline, just so they didn’t have to pay a fine? And they could have just turned the gas off instead? Lol, ok. 😂
Pipeline? Please do not ask what you know like teacher.
@@michaelkatz275 you really believe what you wrote? it been debunk long ago? german is the one sanction the pipeline . logic
you cant sanction the pipeline then sue it for not delivery that is the most dumbs thing ever
God bless this ex Indian diplomat for speaking the TRUTH. 😁👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Да, правду в иностранных СМИ, практически, невозможно услышать. Сплошные фейки. Например, было удивительно умлышать, что Россия воюет лопатами.
Every killed person in Ukraine would disagree with you. You can spin it all around but every reasonable human knows who the victim is and what just outcome should be.
@@mbanjur In war there are many victims on both sides. Any reasonable human being knows that a) Putin being painted as straight up evil is nonsense, and that anyone that does so is being malicious in nature, and b) that the EU/NATO/Zelensky are not good guys either, and are also corrupt and puppeteer ''democracies''. So which side as a whole is the victim here? Putin and Russia, that pretty much openly have a dictatorship regime, but who doesnt paint the EU leadership as evil? Or the EU, that also has a dictatorship regime but that claims to ''defend democracy'' and calls truth ''disinformation'', and who does call Russia and Putin evil? For any reasonable human being the answer is very obvious.
@@mbanjur You can try to spin it whichever way you want, but its a reality that Ukrainians are being forced to die for leaders (Zelensky and NATO country leaders) that do not care about them at all, and who just see them as a resource to use to conquer Russia and defeat an opponent that doesnt bow down to their regime.. just like Yugoslavia..
Move to a country with some actual moral authority to stand on, like Israel or India, and only then can you say Russia would clearly be in the wrong if they attacked them.
Whose truth?
West is not the whole world.....
Believe me,many of us are aware of this,but whoever is pulling the strings just doesn't care.
You guys shouldn't tolerate the warmongering in Washington in Europe and you should firmly Ally yourself with Russia and China both and Iran as well if you want to be on the right side of history and have the moral High Ground than I suggest you do this and then you will be smart and good people as well and you already are both those last two things as unlike a lot of westerners I have the highest regard for the Indian people and all of the various ethnicities in people that comprise the Indian people as a whole and its history especially it's early Vedic history when ancestors of both of our people were first expanding into India and Europe from I'd say somewhere around Armenia probably or Persia at the furthest but probably more like Ukraine like they always say or maybe they did come from India like a lot of your nationalists like to say but it doesn't matter the fact is we have common Roots partially in our ancestry in our cultures and that's what got me really interested in your culture in the first place but from then on I just fell in love with the way you guys do things a lot of times there's a lot of shit you guys do I think stupid as fuck but it's far more things you do that I love and respect plus I think you're just a beautiful people the beautiful culture you're one of my favorites in the world. And you are ahead of most European nations as far as my esteem and respect goes there's only a couple that are anywhere near you and they would be besides Russia of course which is my favorite country probably Belarusian turkey and hungry and I can't think of another European country that I have any respect for it all right now
Can you do you get ally yourself with Russia is what you need to do
But just like yourselves there are many people in the world who are waking up to the truth and then of course there are people like me who have known the truth about this all along and actually I suspect you guys have as well meaning the two of you. Putin doesn't want to recreate the Soviet Empire he wants to recreate the romanovs empire
West believes it IS the whole world.
Nowadays Greeks turn to India's Media to learn the truth. Thank you.
Do they? How many?
@@JaneSoole As far as I know , very many. Especially the educated and smart.
The Indian media is extremely biased.
India's media has become as toxic as the Western Mainstream Legacy Media.
They are owned by Western MSM to spread Propaganda more Effectively and undermine BRICS.
Not only the Greeks, I can assure you.
The only sane NATO leader appears to be Victor Orban, Hungarian PM.
Am from Kenya and deep down i know Putin is a great man .The west really fears That man .I wish him to live upto 120 years so that USA can feel it well
Why is this "great man" committing genocide? If Russia hates the west so much, why did they attack little Ukraine and not Germany or the US?
Are they cowards??
To Russia with love.
To Ukrain with love.
Nobody can like the terror government that jail its opponents.
Love to Russia from the USA
@@henrikstephenson2246are You talking about Biden putting attempting to put Trump in jail?
@onieljimenez5357 yep that's what he means😅😂thank you
I love how he said Germany lost sense of guilt the distraction Germany brought on Russia in WW2 .
Indeed. Germany owes centuries of guilt for the crimes of its ancestors. But Germany has dementia. It wants a repeat.
Russia murdered thousands when beating back the Nazi Germany. They are acting like the Nazi themselves now sadly.
I don’t understand why Ukraine cannot attack Russia with whatever they get, Russia is at war with them and HAVE invaded Ukraine. War mongering from the west ???? Russia invaded, have bombed and killed civilians and civilian infrastructure !!! Western hegemony, this is a nonsense idea. Russia started this. The west did not react when they illegally annexed Crimea ???
So Russia is threatening nuclear war because another country is fighting back Russians invasion?
Truth is the way to peace. Well done India for your clear thinking.
APPEASEMENT only encourages the aggressor .
God bless, I love India ❤
Ukraine fighting Russia in name but US-NATO and other allies in reality!🚀🇷🇺
As China and Iran and North Korea are supporting Putin.
Nato not there sorry your wrong and you know it
@@user-pj5tl5gf6l perhaps in physical war but the lethal supports to Ukraine in battle grounds is the testament that US-NATO rallying behind in Ukraine war against Russia!🤦🤭
NATO is there as well as french foreign legends and they are being sacrificed .
Ukraine defending itself from Russian Z Nazi invasion
Correction...the world does not hold a negative view of Russia, it is the US and its so called allies that wish for that and it is not happening!
For real❤
The fall of the Soviet Union was the greatest benefit to mankind during the last century.156 million people got their freedom from Russian colonialism.
That may be true in India, but else where it is an entirely different story. You should have a look at Russian television. It appears that everyone in Moscow is afraid of all the new American military equipment Ukraine is receiving.
@@michaelkatz275 Not just in India. The citizens of quite a few countries view Russia as more sinned against than the West will have us understand. Quit the hole you have ensconced yourself inside.
@@kaushikbasu3778 Never underestimate the Russian intelligence services' ability to manipulate the narrative for their own advantage through the world. It was Vladimir Putin who invaded Ukraine and led Russia into a quagmire, believing he could seize the entire country within a few weeks. Needless to say, things haven't turned out as well as he hoped, and now he faces the prospect of the war continuing into the 2030s as American weapons begin to arrive.
Putin is thee example of a true leader
Thee leader of orcs.
funny
He’s a leader. A terrible murdering one. How many hundreds of Russians have fallen out of 13th story windows or been poisoned for opposing him.
Move to Russia then .
@@user-tw3kr9if1f haven’t you heard Russia opened its border…guess you’re not welcome 😭
The losing party (Ukraine) is setting up conditions on the victor (Russia). This has got to be the funniest joke for 2024 so far.
The United Nations: Russia shall immediately completely and unconditionally withdraw all military forces from the territory of Ukraine.
And that is not it bro, Russia Will take all of Ukraine and Zelensky Will be in florida as a refugee STILL asking Russia to surrender 😂😂
@@onieljimenez5357🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣hey stop it😂😂😂
They’re used to dictating terms when they invade and destabilize other countries that have no military
Annual Report disapproval
Annual Report 👊🏻 ✊🏻 🖕🏻 👎🏻
Joe Biden disapproval
Joe Biden 👊🏻 ✊🏻 🖕🏻 👎🏻
N.A.T.O. army no no ukraine no no no no not
army no no ukraine no no no no not
NATO no no no no not
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------‐--‐-‐------‐--‐----------‐-------‐‐-----------------------------------
International Court of Justice yes
Police Army yes
Russia yes
United Nations Development Programme
Police Army United Nations (Earth) World Maps (Earth Federation)
Russian Federation (RF)
Russian United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland Federation (RUKGBNIF)
Russian French Republic Federation (RFRF)
Russian Federation Federal Republic of Germany (RFFRG)
Russia United States of America (RUSA)
United States of Russian Federation of EurAsian Union (USRFEAU)
United States of Russian Federation of European Union (USRFEU)
United States of Russian Federation of Asian Union (USRFAU)
Alaska Russia
Vladimir Putin is a GREAT LEADER ❤FROM UK
In agreement in Canada
A huge difference how Biden talks about Putin, and Putin about Biden. Biden uses despicable words towards Putin, while Putin says that he prefers Mr. Biden over Trump. I think the west must be happy that Mr. Putin is in charge and very restrained. Otherwise it already would have escalated. I hope for peace soon, but my support goes to Russia.
You obviously have been very partial in your hearing.
Remember Russiagate how Russia interfered in US elections and Trump won so Trump was accused of being a puppet of Putin. Well I think Putin said he preferred Biden so the Democrats won't want to accuse Russia of interfering when Putin is backing Biden. Now will Trump play his ace and accuse Russia of interfering in US elections and supporting Biden?
@@JaneSooleThen YOU haven’t been paying attention. The 1st poster is completely correct - in 3D reality, anyway.
What are you talking about?!!
@@lashakhonelidze1350Biden called Putin an idiot super unprofessional and the worst thing Putin ever said about Biden is that he’s doing a fake cowboy act
Respect to president Putine!!! From the US.
The us is not in Russia 😂😂
Why? If you are in the US why don't you go and live in Russia?
No you are not from the USA. The Russian dictator paid you to write this comment.
@@JaneSoole He doesn’t have to ….
He just said that he likes Putin …
And he is not only one …
Mostly people who really knows what is going on in Europe like him …
I like him more then delusional zombie Biden …
I wish we had a president like Putin in Canada.
Every Canadian politician appears as butt-licking, born-again YanKKKees who salute Nazi war criminals.
Every Canadian politician will salute any lie coming out of Washington no matter how ridiculous.
Why should Russians engage in negotiations when Washington's statements, promises, and treaties are worthless asswipe?
Ukraine False Hope: there will be no negotiations with Kiev and the White West.
Anyone thinking Russia or China will negotiate existential security with lying Western politicians is delusional.
The Minsk Treaties are revealed as asswipe intended to allow Ukrainian Nazis time to rearm and continue the war.
Germans, French, Ukrainians and Washington don't have the brains or character to appear embarrassed or ashamed of their murderous lies.
They gloat over the dead.
Russia responded by announcing their goals now require complete destruction of the Zelenskiy regime.
Anatoly Antonov (Russian Ambassador to the United States): “The emergence of tanks, bearing Nazi insignia, on the former Soviet soil unequivocally makes us aim at toppling the neo-Nazi regime in Ukraine and creating normal conditions so that the neighboring peoples in the region could live peacefully like in the old days.
So it won’t be the vacuous opinions of irrelevant Westerners that define this war’s end.
It will be blunt demands and brutal facts on the ground that define Ukraine’s public defeat.
This war will end with Washington--NAYOYO humiliated,
Russian tanks shaking the ground at western borders,
and the Global South dancing drunkenly in the streets for a week.
George Carlin: “It’s called the American dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.”
Winston Churchill (1944): ”I have left the obvious, essential fact to this point, namely, that it is the Russian Armies who have done the main work in tearing the guts out of the [Nazi] army."
Salah ad-Din Yusuf ibn Ayyub (Saladin): “I warn you against shedding blood, indulging in it and making a habit of it, for blood never sleeps.”
H. L. Mencken (1880 - 1956): “The men the American people admire most extravagantly are the most daring liars; the men they detest most violently are those who try to tell them the truth.”
Poland and the Baltics have Russian bullseyes on their people and governments as long as these neo-Nazi states threaten Russia.
These fools think they can hide under a nuclear umbrella while uttering ridiculous threats.
These fools think lying about the "Russian Bear" will impress the Global South.
Harold Pinter: “The crimes of the United States have been systematic, constant, vicious, remorseless, but very few people have actually talked about them.”
Senior G7 diplomat (Newsweek, Oct 2023): “We have definitely lost the battle in the Global South. All the work we have done with the Global South [over Ukraine] has been lost . . . Forget about rules, forget about world order. They won’t ever listen to us again.”
@@richardgraham7055 Приятно осозновать, что большинство граждан Канады, США имеют адевкватное представление о причинах войны как на Украине, так и на Ближнем Востоке и других странах.
@@richardgraham7055 Russia is not going to attack anyone,” Dmitry Peskov, a spokesman for Russian President Vladimir Putin, told reporters Tuesday morning, according to a translation of his remarks. “It’s not like that.”
There is only one and he is Russian. Make your own.
We respect and admire president putin from the philippines
And after Putin helps China grab the Philipines?
No you don’t
Well get him to defend you against China !
@@neillgowans4350Are you trying to say you can decide for other people whom to respect?😅
Zelenskyy lost his chance in April 22. Now he should go after Boris Johnson. President Putin will decide and dictate the terms of the agreement. President Putin is one of THE BEST PRESIDENT in the world.
❤
You should have a look at Russian television. It appears that everyone in Moscow is afraid of all the new American military equipment Ukraine is receiving.
In whose opinion?
@@JaneSoolein EVERYONE'S opinion! Just look at BIDEN, is he an example of great leader???? 😅😂
@@tmoney007confederation7 Biden may not be, but the White House political bureau is far more effective than Putin, who isolates himself from everyone as he trusts no one. Is it any wonder he managed to embroil himself and Russia in a Ukrainian quagmire by solely trusting his own judgment?
Clever man, good to hear some common sense from India. There is little of that in the West.
Excellent interview! Why can we not get journalism like this in the mainstream media?
Who cares what they do, live your own life 🙏
there was such an interview with an austrian politician, Karin Kneissel (channel? sorry, Nachdenkseiten?), specially as she has been smeared of course...
A threat to national security... as usual !
The reason why the west cant have any good journalist is because thy are corrupt 🦠🦠🦠🦠🦠🇺🇸🇷🇺🇬🇧
The war in Ukraine started in 2014 (ten years ago with Kiev troops killing civilians in Donbas) and backed by the US led coup. It DID NOT START 2 years ago.
But it wasn’t a U.S. coup. That’s a Russian talking point used to justify its unprovoked aggression against a neighboring country.
It started with the Russian invasion of Crimea in February 2014, the first injection of foreign armed forces into Ukraine.
It was preceded by a Russian trade war against Ukraine in the preceding year to prevent a Ukrainian free trade deal with the EU, contrary to treaties made with Ukraine.
The war started in February 2014 with the Russian invasion of Crimea, the first injection of foreign armed military forces into Ukraine. It is nonsense to suggest otherwise. There was no act of international aggression before this.
The war started in February 2014 with the Russian invasion of Crimea, the first injection if foreign armed military forces into Ukraine. It is nonsense to suggest otherwise. There was no act of international aggression before this.
@awalk5177 The war started in February 2014 with the Russian invasion of Crimea, the first injection if foreign armed military forces into Ukraine. There was no act of international aggression before this.
Mr. Putin is the best. Respect from India ❤
Fuck India
Care to tell us why russia forced Iran to capture Indian weapon export to Armenia?
@@bipulchandra424 coz Armenian announced recently that they no longer can depend on Russia and want move towards west. They even allowed EU observatory forces on their ground to check the situation between Azerbaijan and armania which irked putin.
Is it enough??
and respect from Holland❤. I also think the West (where I happen to live) has gone totally mad
@@Ajay-vf6di who gave russia the right to stop export of any country? India was not operating on russian land . Russia wants to play games with Armenia, they can do that but who gave them right to stop India's export?
Putin believes no! Country should tell another country what to do! Go Russia! 👍
So why are they invading Ukraine, threatening the baltics, etc.?
@@physically3027 Тётя Салли такого никогда не делала, даже не слыхала о таком! Она и писать-то не умеет!
Botty alert
@@physically3027why was ukraine killing Russians and breaking the minsk accords?
You have not been paying attention to what’s going on
Putin is not stupid. His soldiers are well trained.
From prison to the front line how can they be well trained ,😗
Really?
CRAP !
@@user-pj5tl5gf6lyou are living in the past my friend, that prison to the battlefield of bakhmut story has long been dead😂
@@anuragtiwari5661 is it true that Wagner boss hade a bad fall wink wink
Putin will go down as one of the greatest leaders of all time!!!
a bot
It's why the US and NATO are like mean girls!
Many Germans felt the same about Hitler, but in the end freedom and justice always prevail.
Put is a very silly little man, obsessed with self, a serial liar about Russia's history, and Russia's destruction of Ukraine and Russia's stealing of Ukraine's children.
Putin is not only loved and respected by his people but by citizens of many countries India and China huge population much of Africa etc.He has earned their respect by his deeds we don't believe western lies propoganda and spin we know the evil ones even their own citizens don't respect them trudeau sunak Biden Scholz etc
Russian Federation 🇷🇺❤️ support 💯 STAY STRONG RUSSIA and brave kind Russian people 🇷🇺❤️ praying for you all the way 🇷🇺❤️ SLAVA ROSJI ‼️‼️❤️🇷🇺polish here
❤❤❤🎉
Слава России!🤍💙❤️
The Russian dictator paid you to write this comment.
Well - Mr. Putin is a Politician. So he need to be aporoached with a certain reservation. But, he is more transparent than all western leaders together.
It hurts me as a Swiss that we have chosen to follow the lead of the US and given up Neutrality.
I was actually surprised to hear that Switzerland would allow itself to be used in such lowly biased drama. Not the stuff I expect from this great, usually soberminded country.
Your politicians are hvg IQ below room temperature,what to do.
Transparent??? He, who on Feb 22 told the world and President Macron, Russia was not going to invade Ukraine, and two days later did so. The fact that it went wrong for Putin, who had assumed he'd have taken Kyiv in 3 days..is neither here nor there. Sadly, the one thing we do know about Putin, is that he is a consistend liar, including about RUssian history.
This was a big mistake, stupid
Vladimir Putin is a autocratic despote first, and a politician who listens to the people last. And just what evidence do you have to show he is more transparent than all Western leader together?
love Putin here in Virginia. Rootin for Putin
The only statesman I can respect is Putin!🇸🇪
The only statesman wanted by the International Criminal Court.
@@henrikstephenson2246 Hello my Dear!
@henrikstephenson2246 on fake charges.some people are really brainless-looking at your name I can see you are american puppet 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
@henrikstephenson2246 you are blinded with hate and dumbed with onesideness. Heal and go away. Nobody is influenced by such nonsense.
@@timgibson3754 Putins travel to BRICS meeting in South Africa was cancelled as he would be arrested.
Russia never tried to take Kiev. It entered Ukraine for the Donbass region. It was in Kiev to get Ukraine to the negotiation table. That occurred in March 2022 which is why Russia left Kiev.
google it: "Battle of Kyiv"
Where ever did you get that? Putin's troops had their number 1 dress kit in the tanks heading for Ukraine - in preparation for Putin's victory in Kyiv.
@@JaneSoole Change your med dosage as i think you are high
@@JaneSoole Because Ukraine went to the peace table in Ankara, Turkey in March 2022 and were ready to sign a treaty with Russia until Boris Johnson flew in to prevent the signing. Two of Ukrainian negotiators were assassinated when they got back to Ukraine. The Corporate media ignores these facts because it doesn’t fit their childish narrative that the war started in 2022 - and not 2014 with the CIA-Azov created Maidan Coup.
@@orriblecol6587 Back at you. Stop following mainstream western media and you'd know the truth.
To President Putin, Russia 🇷🇺 with love ❤❤❤ !!! Thank you, Bharat India 🇮🇳 for your impartial support.
clearly a bot
How very true. Putin is one of the greatest statesmen of our time He will be in the history books when all the US and EU leaders are long forgotten.
Russia made a stand worthy of a great country when there's wolves surrounding you make a stand
India is surrounded by wolves also🤣
The Wolf is Vladimir Putin ! Ask Ukraine, Ask the Balkans, Ask Georgia, Ask Afghanistan, Ask Finland .
Russia INVADED Ukraine for no reason other than he wants Ukraine's mineral wealth and power for himself.. The rest is a smoke screen -he is a violent criminal and runs a mafia style state, where any opposers are clapped in to jail, even for saying no to the war. Why don't you go and live there if you are enamoured?
The Russian dictator paid you to write this comment.
🔺🔳⚫🔳🔺
Switzerland home of the Beast the Pharaohs still rule the world from Switzerland they rule every country it doesn't matter what the culture looks like the bloodline is the Pharaohs they want to get rid of several billion people
Evil to ' US and British Devil ' .
And the same to you!
How naive you are, if you think that every country supported Ukraine and the eu and nato, I’m English and trust me I’ve supported Mr Putin since this started, the idiot we had as a pm was a nightmare, johnson,
I’ve ended up being laughed at because of my beliefs that Mr Putin was the not the problem it was our own idiots who were in power,but I stood my ground you can’t compare who’s in charge in America and the UK, with Mr Putin, I’ve been sent to Coventry, but I can hold my head up and say I was right, you just couldn’t compare them and look how our government has put in two leaders, who wasn’t even voted for, unbelievable,!
@@jacquelineloaring2438 Do you favor autocratic despots in Eastern Europe who retain power through fraudulent elections?
Germany current administration is not political independent and has put Germany to disgraceful level . Hope another European country to rise up to take over the position of leading European Union in to independent political systems .
Yes France will then Put in will really be worried.
Serbia
Im orginal from Finland, i feel so sad that Finland destroy own future, economy.. for be puppy of US. 😢
Welcome to Russia.Russia will never be a doormat for the USA.
@@user-ow7xc7fx9j never have been, but in my former Life in Finland, Russian customer's we're best customer. Also now I live Asia and have Russian's friends and customers I'm want go next summer to Moscow.
Feel sorry to u , but u now in gang of America who is the threat to the world peace
Same here. 😢
@@user-ow7xc7fx9j Thank you 😊.
Mr. Sibal is very rational and objective. Good message.
He is telling the Russian narrativ.
He is telling the Russian narrativ.
@henrikstephenson2246 you like the western narrative 😅😂
@@henrikstephenson2246 learn what is cuban crisis and what happened in 2014 in ukraine, now recently US supplied MRC to Phillipines
@@henrikstephenson2246Huh! Russian narrative, give the time stamp and tell where he is wrong!!
I would salute you if you really able to do that? 😉
Putin is the only real statesman in these times. Great respect for this leader who build,up his country after Jeltsin.
He is wanted by the International Criminal Court
@@henrikstephenson2246 why Netaniau or George Bush that started the criminal actions in Iraq are not wanted ? Let me tell you the US is manipulating gang style with allies the world justice including the UN , do you still beleive in santa claus??
for building up his country and protecting it from greedy western investors?
@@rayofsun64 Whataboutism. Your comment do not help Ukraine.
No doubt that Putin is a dirty, genocidal dictator.
Peace talk without Russia is just stupid!
Zelensky 10 points is ludicrous!
Russia would talk surrender terms not peace terms!
This war is going to end just like most people familiar with conflicts knew it would 2 years ago. Ukraine never had any chance of victory, especially not on its own. The massive disaster which was their summer (PR) offensive which resulted in catastrophic losses to the AFU with basically zero gains was the final chance to turn things around, and they failed that. Now the east are liberated back to Russia and Khavkiv and Odessa will return with them. It will be interesting to see if Poland retakes Lviv, as most people expect them too.
What's left will be a failed state for decades to come, with an enormous bill to pay to the US. 😊
@@Vlad88822 😊Isn't America going to adopt Zelenski?
The handiwork of stupid leader ...sold his countrymen n country to US n the west.
Russia has several times forwarded peace treaties to Biden, who ripped them up. The only thing Biden wants is war. He is manipulated by AIPAC
You mean America dog ?
"There can be no European peace unless there's friendship between Germany and Russia
Peace means that Russia leave Ukraine.
We don't want friendship with any of these monsters Putler, Xi, Kim, Raisi, Modi. We already had Hitler ourselves.
@@henrikstephenson2246Peace can only come about when the Collective West, grow up and realize the day's of interfering, and destroying other Countries, using their colonialistic attitudes, changes,------
@henriks tephenson2246 Peace means when warmonger US Nato get dismantled.
@@EagleWolf2 FYI: It is Russia, not US that have invaded Ukraine. 141 countries have ordered Russia to withdraw.
Russia was forced to war by the West. NATO constantly expanding eastwards after promisses made they wouldn't do that and now also wanting to include Ukraine in NATO. That was a very understandable red line for Russia because that would mean losing their important naval base they have on Crimea (which historically also was part of Russia) and NATO missiles stationed relatively close to Moskou. The US wouldn't accept Russia stationing their army and missiles on their Mexican border also (like they also didn't during the CUBA-crisis). All that combined with the discrimination and poor treatment of the ethnic Russian population in eastern Ukraine caused this war. The West is mostly to blame for the current situation. Russia (and the citizens of Ukraine) are the victims...
With the devil n willing zelenski....
This is a fantasy created by a string of academics in America, to name but a few.
The majority of the world supports Russia.
Not the intelligent world, just the usful idiots
Not true Boris
@@narendra62 Actually it's quite true...
@@narendra62 It is true
@@narendra62 dude every non western country supports Russian and the west makes up 13% of the planet. Maybe they don't teach you math at the cia bot?
Crimea was never LEGALLY part of Ukraine.
THAT IS NOT A PART OF ANY NEGOTIATION
ZELENSKY & U.S
KNOW THIS.
Putin fanboys will go to any lengths to deny that the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet transferred Crimea to Ukraine in 1954 lmao
Russia signed multiple treaties recognising Ukraine in its internationaly recognised borders, including Crimea. Some of these treaties had been signed by Putin's Russia, and Putin publicly declared havong no border delimitation conflict with Ukraine. Putin and Russia = The Empire of Lie.
@@FabGreg When those treaties were signed Ukranians were not slaughtering ethnic russians in Donbas nor threathening Russia access to Crimea.
@@ZoticusZ this is pure bullshit and it has been recognized by Prigojine ('we were in the Donbass from the very beginning") and Girkin / Strelkov. Same as for Crimea, first denying Russian forces intervention (cf. the little green men), then proudly claiming it some years after. Same for Wagner in Africa, firstly Putin denying Wagner existence, then explaining after Wagner march to Moscow "we paid everything for Wagner". All this has been publicly declared on TV. Lies, lies, lies, as Soljenitsyne denounced during his time.
@@ZoticusZ Regarding the "slaughter of ethnic russians in Donbass", there had been heavy fights in 2014 and 2015, with victims on booth sides (including Wagner forces, now recognised by the Russian Duma as military veterans). Then, situation had been calm under scrutiny of the OSCE. In 2020-2021, most of the very few victims were caused by mines, not any slaughter. In 2022, nothing could justify Russia invading other parts of Ukraine after Crimea and Donbass, except lies. Point.
Now that we know it is a very cunning plan on the part of NATO and Switzerland, India must not join this peace summit. India should support the Russia-China Peace plan, we are BRICS and must stay united, bit join a western alliance and act as a fence-sitter. If India joins this summit, Ukraine will present a plan to Russia and say this has the support of India. it will be an insult to our russia-india friendship.
No, we will never support any Chinese geo-political drama. Also, BRICS is just an Economic Forum not any sort of a geo-political alliance. We will only look after our own interests.
German politicians should heed Mr. Sibal's reasonable words!
You can not give a man a haircut in his absent.. That is what having a peace conference without Russia.
😂 well said 👍
😂😂😂😂
So Ukraine is Russia's hair? Interesting. :)
It's disingenuous to call it a peace conference, because the so called Zelensky's "peace plan" is nothing but a demand of total and absolute capitulation by Russia.
The west is so insane and unhinged that they're trying to arrange Russian capitulation in absentia, all that while losing the actual war in the field 😅🤡🌍
I always thought was a good man. Just for a short time I began to question but now I am fully in support of Russia.
Oh absolutely! If anyone else had invaded another country for the purpose of conquest and aggrandizement, you would have criticized them severely.
@@michaelkatz275 SO only USA can invade?
@@michaelkatz275you mean every other Tuesday in the US?😊
@@D64nz No I do not. Are you one who always likes to twist events out context, or change the mean of someone's sentence?
@@michaelkatz275 Putin DID NOT INVADE , he was INVITED, REQUESTED by the Donbass peoples to help them against the Ukronazi, in FACT, the SMO got started to preempt around 60 000 Azov (Kiev's n*z*) that were at Donbass border getting ready for an Ethnic Cleansing!
It's refreshing to listen to the thoughtful, intelligent perspectives of these Indian thinkers on Russia. In the West we hear nothing but "badmouthing" in the media of both Russia and Putin.
We in Russia listen to both Russian news and Ukrainian news, as well as news from Western news agencies. I can tell you that in Ukraine and in the West, the news is fake, a complete lie. I am not talking about the shovels that Russians are supposedly fighting with.
I didn't know this man before. But i can tell you that he is a one of a rare persons who has been speaking a real truth. Thank you mister Kanwal Sinbal. God bless you 🙏🕊️🍀🌿
Hindu support Russia!! We love and respect Russians!!!
INDIANS** support Russia
Your Flying monkey won't help Russia. Indian science can..
Indians***
You're a circus animal.
Russia is kidnappning Indian men and send them to their army.
❤❤❤
India Is Taking An Honorable Stand With Truth , Neutrality N Decency.
I'm watching this from England, late at night. Thank you for informed intelligent discussion which we are currently denied by 'Great British' MSM
Solidarité avec la Russie
Switzerland no longer has an important role to play, as it did as a neutral country.
In the event of a new major war, Switzerland will no longer be considered to be neutral with the consequences this entails.
Switzerland was never neutral lol.
@@thewolfofgod3908 I do not disagree with you there, but it was considered to be neutral by others with the possibilities and benefits such a status give.
Putin is great man human being God bless him and Russian peopleforward ever backward never
SLAVA ROSJI 🇷🇺❤️ and brave kind Russian people 🇷🇺❤️ polish lady friend
I am ashamed of polish government and many people in Poland divided Poland insane REALLY isane ‼️‼️‼️‼️
He poisons people, its that a great human being?
But still no fresh eggs 😂
No leader has done so much to turn his country around. The real concern is when he retires, who can take his place. Let's hope the Russians are preparing the next generation of great leaders too. 😊
@@D64nz Yes so true! his SMO has turned Russia around in a way we could not imagine. He has had a lot of people killed so he can grab more land its not right and the world knows it, even you know it but cannot admit it.
A consistent interview facing the reality. In Germany we can't nearly hear such differentiated point of view.
Big newspapers and Radio and Television are permanently discussing only the USA nato arguments.
I would appreciate that we could see your discussion.
Greatings from Germany!!!
This is a great interview. Thanks to the Times of India! Your former ambassador is a very capable man. Best regards from Germany.
This Gentleman makes perfect sense. 👏👏👏
The world has an obligation to say: STOP! Stop these escalations & provocations. We don't want our world to end because of warmongering irresponsible nations.
You stop now and all seat at the table and negotiate peace or.... 😡
Go tell that to Vladimir the Great and see what type of response you get.
@@michaelkatz275: which Vladimir? Ex comedian zelensky? 😅
@@msdolly6101981In all of Eastern Europe, there's only one Vladimir who likes to compare himself to Peter the Great, a former Tsar of Russia-the one who resides in the Kremlin in Moscow.
@@michaelkatz275 fool, EU+RU was too powerful to control EU's industrial growth, now see the LPG benefitting USA not RU, that is what US wants
@@msdolly6101981 The fool that inhabits the Kremlin!
We have had more than enough of US/Nato influence and their "poisoning" effect on our politicians (especially those inside the EU) here in Europe.
The reason to dehumanize Russians by Ukrainians was a big mistake. In Africa we call it xenophobia. The hate speech was unbelievable.
You haven't been paying attention to Russian hate speech against Ukraine over the last decade. Look up 'eliminatorist rhetoric against Ukraine'.
Thank you for your excellent program and wise guest👍
100 percent CORRECT!!!!!
Disagree Appeasement encourages more aggression which one of PUTINS neighbors will be next.
Excellent: I am happy that 80% of the world that really counts and has actual resources are thinking and can see straight.
Congratulations for being honest and outspoken!
I admire and love Indians with independent views and thoughts.
Every one I have ever listened to or known from India are really smart and have wisdom. Thank you Kanwal Sibal.
Bravo…non-since it is. Putin is a good man, smart and sensible!
Kudo to this indian diplomat, excellent comments and very enlighting. The 1st knowledgable man to speak the whole truth concerning the West but especially Zelenskyy and Biden.
The issues is that. American and Britain don't want to see any country economy growths up out of Britain and American decided . They're trying to put every countries on limit which they decide . They can support a country for economy growths with everything else but that country must not have to growths it economy beyond Britain and American decisions . Don't dream to grow beyond ..
You will never be demonise by people better than you, only those who are below you.
❤🎉
Love u russia
Listening in from Italy. Thanks for the very refreshing analysis.
Aditi Prasad let her guest speak and didn't try and shape the narrative ...and Kanwal Sibal has an excellent grasp of what is actually happening , What a brilliant interview Well Done
Its good to see people standing up and speaking the obvious truth.
Praying 🙏 for Russia Russia needs to win or the world will go to to further hell.
Richtig 🙏 wir beten auch in Thailand 🇹🇭 für den russischen Sieg.
The World has never been perfect but if Putin wins it will only encourage more Chaos.
Agree
Amen
Let’s not forget the peace talks in Istanbul in 2022, which Ukraine withdrew from at UK’s recommendation.
Mr. Sibal is a great diplomat, we wish we have this kind of smart analyst in Europe.
Thank you for a rational and informative interview.
They're hard to find in the west.
In the EAST as well !
Great guy. Great OBJECTIVE SPEECH
I am sure India is aware of the real reason for the summit and will stay away.
1 million rupees to Modi and he will go to summit for sure
It’s time the west. Be held account for the words. And actions
The Old man is a leader and he has been telling the truth which politicians will never tell. Thank you
Putin is a very good speaker and projects actions that the public finds attractive. He is shown as an outdoorsman, loves dogs, likes kids, and very patriotic. The video him singing the Russian national anthem in a stadium full of other people was very impressive.
Anyone who underestimates him is making a big mistake. Western "Bad Mouthing" him
could well be counter productive. It may be increasing his popularity.
He is wanted by the International Criminal Court.
@@henrikstephenson2246so what. That court is not recognized by Russia or even those who you blindly follows their narrative.😂 Stop the bs.
@@Gerdeo64 It limit Putins possibility to travel round the world as more than a hundred countries will arrest him.
It's all Russian propaganda from their department of pysop's.
@henrikstephenson2246 Blair and Bush will follow suit for what they did in Libia, lying about nuclear weapons and killing Gaddafi,, Netanyahu to follow🎉😅
President Putin is a great man and he leads a great country. May God Bless him and his prosperous and amazing country.
The Swiss peace conference is almost childish😂
Children are not nearly this foolish. Zelinsky is a known clown, who never grew up.
Please let the gentleman finish his answers before interrupting 🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
Kanwal Sibal is a wise man with a lot of knowledge. Impressing.
Great analysis fair and incisive
Not Fair and Obviously Biased .
A 'genuine dialogue', like 'the west' did with the Minsk 1 and 2?
Or something more genuine?
Wish we in the UK could have talks like this thank you
Sir your views and comments are logical.l endorse your views.Thanks
BBC wont repeat this
It is NATO terrorists who are holding on in Ukraine. But that is fast changing now looking at Russia's remarkable gains at the battlefront.
Keep rising 🇷🇺 ❤
GLORY TO RUSSIA! I LOVE PRES. PUTIN!🇷🇺💪🤝👊🇵🇭
Yes 100% agree !! President Putin is protecting his countries interests .
At the expense of his neighbors. China might choose to do the same to its neighbors.
@@user-tw3kr9if1f yes absolutely, but , China needs to know its neighbours better, like President Putin new what he is getting into and is standing till date and going forward as well. …… in short real powers don’t intimidate. They just do it…….Which China tried to do in Galwan, but failed miserably.
Brandon is EVIL!
Putin is even worse.
Pure evil and he must go. Vote him out
@@Seyiwale6127 What about Putin? He is in fact the one who started the war, and has caused the deaths of 400.000 Russian men.