Does Benjamin Netanyahu actually have a plan? | James O'Brien on LBC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 тра 2024
- As the US warns of a potential power vacuum in Gaza, James O'Brien questions Benjamin Netanyahu's strategy amid escalating conflict between Hamas and the IDF.
Israeli troops have advanced for the first time towards the centre of Rafah and launched operations in several areas where there has previously been fighting.
Thousands of Israelis joined protests over the weekend calling for a deal to bring home hostages still held in Gaza by Hamas and the resignation of Netanyahu.
However, James argues that Netanyahu is 'not committed' to these demands and has a different motive entirely.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#Jamesobrien #Benjaminnetanyahu #LBC #Israel #Gaza
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
Sangita is greatly missed. Bring Sangita back you leading british cowards!
Bring back Sangita?
What makes you think she'll want to come back to this dump that removed her for being a journalist..
It's a shame Sangita isn't here to question Israeli officials.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023
@@stevestokes-li8xrYou poor soul.
@@stevestokes-li8xr I'd laugh if your comment was actually funny.
@@stevestokes-li8xr Will Tiffany be appearing with her?
The owner promotes his own views.
LBC has been compromised by sacking Sangita🤢
She is a honourable woman.
When the presenters don’t talk about Sangita, you can comfortably say they have been compromised.
My thoughts too! They're addicted to the perks of the platform.
Money
How much do you think israel donates to them?
This, 100 per cent. LBC supported Netanyahu, the Zionist far right, and has no spine. Disgusting.
How can James EVER again talk about the editors of the Daily Mail?
NDA.
Leave LBC James o brien
Make your own show with Sangita as genuine journalists you will both clear up the scene without a doubt
The fact he wouldn't ever consider this, or even stand in solidarity with his female colleague in the face of obvious discrimination, shows that James morality is just performative. All he cares about is his ego and his ratings
He used to be brave. After they fired Sangita, he lost it. Listen his current talks and compare with the previous ones - he is securing his job now.
Yeah I would subscribe to their channel for sure!
JoB is compromised !!
He knows that too !!
Says anything controversial and he's OFF like Sangita !!
That much is crystal clear. !!
Maybe on a local hospital radio for charity
Bring Sangita back or explain her exit if you respect journalism and free speech.
He doesn't respect journalism. If he did he would have spoken out in support of Assange many, many moons ago. This fella is feckless.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023
Bot
They have explained her exit. She was sacked because she was warned twice about her racism and Anglophobia, and she refused to tone it down..
LBC is like ever Broadcaster in Britain they are part of the establishment. Free speech don’t make me laugh , only if it’s right wing views is allowed
Jeremy Corbyn has bucketfuls of empathy but you used that against him. 😢
On this issue Jeremy Corbyn would have been a fantastic pm. Unfortunately I don't know if he would be able to handle domestic politics quite as well.
@@marcusmiz Yeh. He did have his faults. But I think the world or UK's place in it right now would be safer.
@@webleydevelopmentidk he came out when Russia invaded Ukraine on US national tv and said he thought Ukraine should surrender all its eastern territory. Just because he is right on one issue doesn’t all of a sudden make all his foreign policy correct
He has buckets full of something else
Corbyn was removed and Starmer put in his place on purpose so Israel would continue to have an ally in the UK.
Bring Sangita back!
Shame on you for sacking sa.gita.. I've already unsubscribed for lbc supportvof a genocidal state who is committing hillocost in.palestine..shame
Greater Israel for only Jews from the river Jordan to the sea isn’t genocidal but calling for freedom to Palestinians from the river to the sea is. We live in a world that has turned upside down
Only because we not support the atrocities that Israel 🇮🇱 is committing 🤔???
Well said
depends who say it
For Zionists from other countries.
DO I CONDEMN HAMAS ? Only in the same way I would condemn the French Resistance for the way they opposed their brutal occupiers! History has judged the French people as Heroes.
👏👏👏
Well framed!
The Maquis sometimes "went too far". Sometimes they were excessively brutal when they arrested and executed German soldiers and officials. And some of the people punished for collaborating with the enemy weren't collaborators at all but were the victims of false accusations by their enemies. But only a fool or a monster would say that the resistance as a whole was wrong. Just as some individual German soldiers might have been relatively innocent but the German occupation as a whole was brutal and illegitimate and entirely deserving of resistance and overthrow.
True.
Well said..double standards in this world.
James you of all people must se ethe problem with Sangita, we all know your one of the more ethical members of LBC, come on mate Sangita is your Friend and Colleague no? Prove it to us.
Spoilers: He won't
I suspect he enjoys his paycheck more than Sangita's company.
James needs to stay quiet and keep his job
He's a Israeli lover, he thinks this all began on October 7th.
@edwardbrady5843 ...an Israel lover? When is the last time you listened to the show?
LBC is no different from BBC since Sangita left.
Fun fact: the Government appointed impartiality tsar at the BBC is Sir Robbie Gibb, the owner of the (pro-Israel) Jewish Chronicle
Where's Sangita? Sacked for speaking out against Israel?
She’s hanging from upside down, tied to a branch in Ashley Tabor King’s tree house
Bring back Sangita
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023
Where is Sangita?
Sangita Myska ❤ Please bring her back
Bring back Sangita!
WHERE IS SANGITA?????
Netanyahu's goons got her
Probably sacked because of her antisemitic rants?
@@Fedrod105 BOT 😂😂😂
Bing back Sangita
James is on a sticky wicket trying to maintain his usual moral high ground yet working for the station that sacked Sangita for asking the wrong questions.
And as we know they were the right questions from a competent journalist which were at odds with the fundamental principles of LBC. We want Sangita, wherever she goes I will follow.
Probably in his next-to-next book.He might dedicate it to ...his Public School.
JOB has repeatedly says he has an emotional attachment to Israel and believes in its unique necessity, FFS. He’d feel different if the settled Kidderminster
Do you take the side of the people that "feel" threatened, steal land and pay for their propoganda or the side that is literally being murdered and their homes destroyed... it's a toughy
In 2018 Israeli soldiers shot over 6,000 Palestinians. In many cases they were shot with illegal expanding ammunition. So, did the present iteration of this problem begin on 7th October 2023 (1,200 casualties) or March/Dec 2018 (6,000 casualties) Discus ??
@@brianferguson7840 Tell it to Pierce Morgan and ask him if he condemns it
Corbyn had understanding and empathy and you smeared him as anti-Semitic.....
Yes we haven't forgotten. He's still living rent free in obrians head 😊
Everybody knows what Netanyahu wants: keep in power and lay waste to Gaza 😢!!!
and western media complicity (oops, he already has that)
What do you mean 🤔??? Are you saying that the media in Russia 🇷🇺 or China 🇨🇳 are better 😂????
I guess do not read the legal opinions of Israeli Lawyers concerning the corrupt politician NETANIAHU!! You do not want to read them!!
@@LukVik At least the mentioned countries are not claiming to be the gaurdians of DEMOCRACY !?
@@wallendegen1 Low bar 🥹😅😂🤣🥲!!!
Sangita
SANGITA, James...same energy when Kate Middleton disappeared ‼️‼️‼️
Madam Sangita, the real journalist, is missing.
There has never been such a evil government since 1934
Really have you been in a coma 😂
@@DelUK72 counterexample?
@@crazymonkeyVIIRussia just invaded a whole country I’d say they win
@@DelUK72
Leave Boris Johnson out of it, poppet. 🙄
@gibgibbo5738 they haven't killed as many civilians, children, journalists and humanitarian workers as Israhell though, nor have they destroyed well over 70% of all homes in Ukraine, or cut off all life essentials to Ukraine (although I have no doubt that they would if they could). And that's in over 2 years of war, compared to Israhell's 7 months... I strongly oppose the invasion of Ukraine as well, but the level of evil demonstrated by Bibi and his government (with astonishing support of his population and western allies) is staggering! Bibi and the people supporting/enabling him are morally not a hair better than that German painter from the later first half of the last century.
James needs to see Netanyahu holding up the map at the UN with Israeli borders including the land "from the river to the sea" 🙄
Yes, that's the goal. How would Israel feel if attacked and forced out completely? With the help of USA, Israel has become so arrogant that they believe their way is the only way and it is not only Netanyahu, it is all the top people. They have a rogue government.
Netanyahu said on tv that he would invade Rafa despite hostage deals.
Already there
I was going to comment on the video but then I remembered.... Bring back Sangita Myska.
Sangita Myska just entered the chat..
Since LBC took the ridiculous decision to sack Sangita ( probably with Israeli pressure) , there’s only James left to hold Israel up to public scrutiny. LBC needs as many people with this independent platform such as this. BRING BACK SANGITA NOW !!!!!!!
We are Sangita ❤
Yes, he actually has two plans. Short term, save his skin. Long term, lay Biblical claim to the Promised Land.
👏
Religion is a blight on humanity.
Religious morality is a lie.
In 2018 Israeli soldiers shot over 6,000 Palestinians. In many cases they were shot with illegal expanding ammunition. So, did the present iteration of this problem begin on 7th October 2023 (1,200 casualties) or March/Dec 2018 (6,000 casualties) Discus ??
He want the war to continue. It keeps him in power.
Religion is a blight on humanity.
Religious morality is a lie.
James can you call in Jeremy Corbyn for an interview about this conflict
Yeah. We need hate speech
Why would Jeremy corbyn want an interview with a z list journalist who knows naff all about Palestine. Obrian thinks apartheid Israels attacks on Palestinians started on October 7th. Even I know it started with THE BALFOUR DECLARATION 1917.
Be really nice if you could spare a moment to show some support for your colleague and fellow presenter Sangita , I thought out of all of her colleagues you would have the courage to do this .... we want truthful answers as this is what Sangita stood for ... courage and not letting the the spokespersons off the hook
Sangita!!!! Bring her back!!!
James. How do u sleep. Representing this likud mouthpiece. The ghost of sangita needs to b exorcised bro
Do you have a plan O'Brien to ever comment on Sangita Myska's silencing? Get in the bin LBC 🤮
Bring back Sangita!...
Sacrifice of Sangeeta for speaking the truth?
Poor Sangrita....
10:20 He always starts with Oct 7 casualties. Just goes to show his true narrative.
In 2018 Israeli soldiers shot over 6,000 Palestinians. In many cases they were shot with illegal expanding ammunition. So, did the present iteration of this problem begin on 7th October 2023 (1,200 casualties) or March/Dec 2018 (6,000 casualties) Discus ??
nail on head, he needs to grow a pair 🤬
Where is sangita????
They have a waiting list with people who are ready to move there. 500 so far!
They interviewed a woman in Long Island! Her and her
husband are on the list!
Where’s Sangita?!?!?!
Wow...the ignorance is staggering. I'm sorry James, I really do like you, your sense of fairness is endearing..your pendantry annoying...but what I've just heard you say about Bibi "passionately committed to a two state solution". I just can't. I'm out.
Bibi is totally against a 2 state solution. The only way this will happen is with international insistence.
He didn't say that though.
@Extra_050 maybe not word for word what I wrote, but yeah, he did.
@@Elizadoolittle1948 No, he really did not. And I say that as someone that doesn't even like him.
Have you spoken about sangita myska's ouster james?! I'll come back after I hear you cover that with an ounce of honesty
He did speak on it on a show a week or two ago. He basically said if something had been improper she would/could speak up and people could support her, but until she actually said something saying her firing was improper all of the people making up conspiracy theories were just that.
Ashley Tabor?
@@jiiaga5017 so the ounce I was looking for was missing
Probably not allowed for threat of sacking too
@@jiiaga5017Great suggestion... bit like in the US... when we believe IHL is trampled by our allies... we ask them to investigate themselves
If it takes 100 kids to bring back 1 hostage is it worth it? Would you want to be rescued if it took a sacrifice of 100 kids?
Nope
Events of past few months have left little doubt that there are two different factions of Zayo NOT-Z:
Those who are denying the Palestinian Hollowcost and those who are insisting to carry on with a Palestinian Hollowcost
*Rest* *in* *Power* *Aaron* *Bushnell* I will never forget you and your last words of " *Free* *Palestine* "
@5:46 -> "Netanyahu has never been a subscriber to that school of thought"
Netanyahu recently made headlines for using maps of "Greater Israel" at the UN - maps that show Israel as controlling territory from multiple other countries. I'm not sure how you could say he doesn't subscribe to the concept of Greater Israel when you can literally just google "Bibi Greater Israel" and see him making headlines by using maps of a hypothetical Greater Israel in places where maps of real-life Israel should be.
James was talking utter nonsense there.
That is most western journalist do when talking about Palestine and it's problems. Ignore the history, pin point that particular incident and blame Palestinians.
Yea, that was such a brain dead thing for him to say. You don’t even need to have read all that much about what’s going on over there to see it’s plain as day they are in the process of expanding their territorial borders. He’s the longest serving Prime Minister in the history of the country, is it supposed to be some kind of accident that they’ve been rapidly expanding settlements his entire premiership?
Gary Lineker spoke for me on Gaza. That’s how much this has changed people.
6:00 Netanyahu put up a map last year sometime showing no Palestine
He's right there is no Palestine.
But there is a country called Israel with two other areas called the west Bank located in Israel and an area given to Palestinians called Gaza.
Again he's right.
@@DelUK72 Except what's outside its '67 borders, all the land is Israel. Everywhere else, Israel doesn't hold any legal authority.
@DelUK72 and who is this delusion aimed at, exactly?
Bring Sangita back !!! Hypocrites ..
Novara media and owen jones have been covering these issues in detail.
Yeah stopped following them. Hear the first sentence, very predictable.
Real journalists ❤
Need Sangita back.
Sangita was unfairly sacked...she was just genuinly doing her job. With my network, we are not interested in biased journalism. We should undubscribe really!
9:45 and taking their land and giving it to Europeans.
Agree with everyone, bring back Sangita! She was amazing at her reporting of Gaza!
He does not need a plan when organisations like LBC will do his bidding.
Hamas never left. Israeli military does not have the know-how to deal with counter-insurgency.
If they gave equal rights to Palistinians and stop stealing their land and go back to living in peace, they wouldn't need to worry about insurgents. But they would have to worry about a growing population of Palistinians at the voting booths (something they want to avoid completely). So a 2 state solution is the only one possible (which Israel also will be against).
Where would they go? It's their home. Whatever you think of them and their actions, where realistically would they go?
Palestinians should move to Qatar or Iran because they do not have their own country!
@@user-wq6sz7vt3w Well that's just factually untrue. The official position of pretty much every government and international organisation is that of a two state solution. Anything beyond that is illegal under international law.
Former British Diplomat Alistair Crooke suggests that eventually Israel may be need to speak to Iran about living on the land 'from the river to the sea' as Iranian Jews did happily for 300 years with equal rights for everyone.
What is the name for anti Palestinians extremism?
Thers no palestinians xtremists
A realist.
Zionism
Devil
@@DelUK72 explain
Thank you for your Humanity James. I've unsubcribed in soldiraty of Sangita
Bring Sangita back!!
Netanyahu's policies have over 90% support in Israel
Then they have been brainwashed.
No, they don't. I'm a typical Israeli and I want him in jail.
@YosiFrancos Glad to hear that buddy. I know some fantastic Israelis who are outraged by what's happening. Best wishes from Ireland. Hopefully peace will come to the region sooner rather than later.
@YosiFrancos thanks for your honest input.
Can I ask what your stance is on all this? Genuinely curious.
Hope you're safe
Apartheid Israel
More resistance... thousands of Palestinians joining Hamas. I have heard a Gazan child who was detained by IDF, he lost members of his family say that he wants to take revenge for them.
james , under international law and also according to historical facts by israeli historians the kibbutz are palestinian land militarily occupied by israel , so no invasion happened
100% true
The Likud Party, and in fact Zionism in general has always been wanting "the Greater Israel" from the get-go! It's what the 2 blue bars signify on their flag.
The reason you don't have an answer is because you haven't been given one by your paymasters Jim.
James do not forget to keep mentioning October 7th 😂😂😂😂, and do you condem Hamas James?
In 2018 Israeli soldiers shot over 6,000 Palestinians. In many cases they were shot with illegal expanding ammunition. So, did the present iteration of this problem begin on 7th October 2023 (1,200 casualties) or March/Dec 2018 (6,000 casualties) Discus ??
DO I CONDEMN HAMAS ? Only in the same way I would condemn the French Resistance for the way they opposed their brutal occupiers! History has judged the French people as Heroes.
Netanyahu probably envisions this as the opportunity to rid Israel of the Palestinians. He told the world this when he held up a map of Israel and Palestine on which everything had become Israel. He probably thiinks that if he can achieve that then he would be a national hero and probably not held accountable for the corruption he is charged with.
Where is award winning journalist sangita ❤
9:00 the penny drops. James finally realizes that the consequences of being a forelock tugging royalist/imperialist is approving of other people dying for your benefit.
JoB is not the same JoB BEFORE Sangita was kicked out !!
James you are too of clever man to hold these views after 8 months. There’s more into this than Netanyahu not wanting to leave because he is scared he’ll be jailed. Netanyahu has made a promise to some Rabbis and he is fulfilling this. He won’t go nowhere until then
The Rabbis are speaking up for the Palistinians.
@@margaretwince2748 I am not talking about those rabbis! The Rabbis of Knesset supporters
LBC where is Sangita.
Isreal has already lost. Majority of the world is totally against thier actions
Why has no UK media reported on the killing of another UN worker, in a UN livery car, by the IDF in Rafah. Plenty about it online, and from UN HQ, but no UK coverage
UA-cam censorship 🤔????
Israel controls LBC😂. Shame. Bring Sangita back. Anything they say on Gaza we take it with a pinch of salt.
"Sangita, you've got a censor" 🎶
Does Benjamin Netanyahu have a plan? Why doesn't he ask Sunak for one, he as plenty, or so he keeps telling everyone.
what will it look like when its over ? "They make a wasteland..and they call it peace" - tacticus , would be my guess :(
FREE SANGITA
He thinks this is an opportunity to do in gaza what they are doing in the west bank at a wholesale rate
People are beeing slaughtered and you are wandering what's the plan of theese psychopath
Hi James, from the southern tip of a certain continent. Long time listener first time caller...
I have a thought I'd like to leave you with on the topic of the current and arguably many previous Isreali leadership. That is to paraphrase Benjamin N. on video > Americans are easy to pieces to move around...we just need to play with the wording and the specifics...<
Curious if you'd play that video side by side with your thoughts here, I honestly hope it doesn't infuriate you but it should.
All the best to everyone, in choosing our leaders in the coming months, may your humanity speak to you.
You raised a great point of empathy and how teaching has a role in this collective empathy. Could apply that in isreal/gaza situation too. Lots to think about there James.
Eradication? What's the difference between that euphemism and the "final solution"? Know what I'm sayin?
I thought the Naz!s no longer existed until I realized that they are rebranding themselves as the NAtional Zlonism of Israel.
Bring back Sangita Myska
Really miss Sangita, I wonder if she will turn up at a better place that deserves her
James is my second favorite after Sangita... lets hope they don't get rid of him too
Current death toll ratio since Oct 7th: 1 to 27 - That's 27 people in Gaza have died for every victim of the Oct 7th attack.
How high does this need to get before people admit that this isn't about Israel "defending itself"?
Bruing our Sangita back 😊
What happened to Sangita???
Did she lose her job for doing her job???
LBC you have shown yourself.
Yea that kind of mentality either I stay in power or go down and bring everyone down with me.
US population - cries for Palestinian children
US media - DO YOU CONDEMN HHHHHAAAAMMMMAAAAASSSS
O brien talks about israelis and Netanyahu. Talk about the war crimes of idf.
About war crimes we are hearing every day. But the question, what will be the Day after is a valid question
Where is Sangita? James Tell us what really happened...even if you risk it with LBC. You and Sangita have what it takes to start your own show! At the very least, tell us if LBC employees have a "Daily-Wire" esque gag order on this very topic.
It will never be over until Palestine is free