'Judiciary Is At Its Weakest In Modern Indian History' : Dushyant Dave |Interview | Supreme Court
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
- Senior Advocate Dushyant Dave speaks about the contemporary issues of the Indian judiciary in this interview with Manu Sebastian, Managing Editor of LiveLaw.
#supremecourt #supremecourtofindia #republicday #constitutionofindia
LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
This video is an intellectual property belonging to LiveLaw Media Pvt Ltd. Any unauthorised usage of this video/script in any format is prohibited and will be subject to prosecution.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in/
hindi.livelaw.in
Facebook: / livelawindia
/ livelawhindi
Twitter: / livelawindia
/ livelawh
Instagram: / livelaw.in
/ livelawhindi
Linkedin: / livelaw
/ livelaw-hindi
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh
Courage means speaking TRUTH.
Dave is an example of this.
Big joke 😅😅😅
trial courts। give orderd under pressure .
Nobody is honest here, everyone has his own agenda or own greed
Are you serious?
You have blown this sebastian guy@@kamleshlulla5303
A big salute to Dushyant Dave sir ..
One of my all-time favourites, Shri Dushyant Dave has always stood up for the rights of the people and criticized the Hon'ble Supreme Court for passing an order favourable to the Executive. May God give you more power to speak the truth. Simply Incredible speech !!!
Dave is v.courageous, fearless - speaks the truth & his mind without any hypocrisy!!!
Can he be an employee? 😅😅
Mr. Dave’s concern for the well being of the Supreme Court - and by extension the people of India - is really touching. One of the few people who calls a spade a spade 🙏🏻
As a citizen it is extremely sad to see the Indian judiciary in shambles , certainly this is not what our forefathers fought for.
Ancient Aliens ie our forefathers had been right in chartering our path under circumstances in black and white however india is moving to an increasing entropy with time,well meaning gentlemen our judicial faculty have sabotaged civil trust in them India is not a matter of dictates by an individual's prerogative
Sir, When a bulding collapse in an earth quake we cannot expect a particular flat may be intact.
May be Chandrachud, Current CJI expecting to become Rajya Sabha member after retirement.
Rubbish, 23 hindus were killed last month by so called minority in manipur no media outrage. Why so demographic changes has taken place? hindus are declining why? If hindus aren't facing persecution? *South and North east minority majority states almost* they get lots of money to hide atrocities against hindus
@@sreekumarvelupillai6266well said. All the pillars are crumbling
Very correct observations, if justice not delivered from the judiciary, from where we can expect it.
Was thinking of writing the same !!
Exactly... The pity is your highnesses...
do bother little. Have they booked/bothered when most of the COMMISSIONS findings are ignored by the EXECUTIVES elected. Minimum level RELIEF worked out or TRIBUNALS set for actions for the suffered. That means JUSTICE denied
Very Bold with Courage to speak on reality of the Judiciary. It is the fact of the day.
Thank you Sr. Adv. D. Dave for speaking out in the Interest of India in the 21st Century. I have no doubt that you will be remembered as an outspoken just Indian in the years to come.
Words fall short if one attempts to describe Mr.Dave. A man honest in his concepts, clear in his heart, disciplined in his pursuit and committed to his professional avocation. A man like Dave is extinct to be discovered in this mundane world. No words in my thesaurus to describe Dave Sahab. Love You Sir.
People in the legal fraternity would never forget this star.
Rubbish, 23 hindus were killed last month by so called minority in manipur no media outrage. Why so demographic changes has taken place? hindus are declining why? If hindus aren't facing persecution? *South and North east minority majority states almost* they get lots of money to hide atrocities against hindus
and one day tehseen poonawalla congi guy was found on timesnow in a debate alleging that dave threatened him and alleged that former CJI Deepak Mishra was a bjp guy, congi stooge calling CJI bjp stooge, poor creature propagandist, the shops of these dimwits getting shut every day
Is Dushyant Dave Honest?
Utmost
I praise mr dave that is really a great star who is cinscientious in his profession
What a fantastic person Mr Dave is ? Fantastic
Worth listening to the pain of advocates like Dushyant Dave when judgement like article 370 and Ramlala do not go their way
The issues raised by lawyer Dave in this interview were there even when Chandrachud was not cji but these issues not raised earlier
ये हंगामा क्यों है जो मैंने थोड़ा सा राम राम किया और थोड़ी सी क़ुरान पढ़ी है
In fact judiciary today is strongest and gave judgement on Ramlala, article 370 without any fear and issue settled which earlier judges did not deal
According to Dave judiciary was best when Supreme Court rejected petition of Kashmiri Hindus to open cases of crimes done to Hindu pandits on grounds of delay
Today the bulldozers pain advocate Dave but the Kashmiri Hindu pandit did not pain Dave when Supreme Court rejected petition of Kashmiri pandit on grounds of overdue. What a biased Supreme Court when even the petition of Kashmiri Hindu was not heard
@@Earthtghjjffgh jai Shri Ram, in constitution where written media is fourth pillar. Get your facts right, tell where written media is fourth pillar. This medal of g go further pillar given by self obsessed as this interview is compromised to attack judiciary with out any content. If Dave feels wrong than why he not filed a case against cji instead of giving interview
@@Earthtghjjffghtum rote raho 😅😅😅
An interview which goes a long way in the independent India. I don't have words to appreciate the wisdom, the courage, the articulation shown by one of the finest Legal Luminary of our times the learned Dushyant Dave
Mr Dave is speaking from his heart.
Hats off to the great advocate, who is fearless in speaking out the real problems faced by the litigants.
Mr. Dawe is breaking his head against wall. Unfortunately, judiciary is dead in our country.
RIP
Dead, or at least the process is on, with the present dispensation forget about mountains moving, an anthill will not stir, reminds me of a cow chewing cud.
Thanks..Mr Dave 🙏🙏 for your brave stance. We appreciate it !
True
Hats off to your honesty and fearlessness sir
The likes of Senior Supreme Court Lawyer Dushyant Dube shld be CJI of India. I admire the guts n conviction of Dushyant Sir's open criticism of the CJI n Collegium n it's failure to take on the Executive n making it more accountable to the people of the country. Dushyant Sir, I salute you for your brave comments n solutions to make our democracy strong, vibrant n functional in the right spirit 😢
So well spoken Mr Dave. There is so much truth in what you say. In the 90s India was a country to be proud of. Looking at it from Abroad, people were amazed by the way people in India got on. The rich, the poor, the famous, the not so famous, the educated the uneducated, the people speaking different languages, the many, many different religious beliefs. There was a kind of harmony which many people from various countries couldn't understand, yet admired. Sadly today the "trust" that people in India shared has been destroyed and we have begun to live as individuals, with the "I am alright Jack" attitude and "tough" if you are not. The "oneness" has all but gone.
Why do they hold big position when you can't carry your duty morally and integrity
Very true,if they can't deliver they better go home 🏡😔
Now a days it seems that India is working without any Constitution.
There's Manusamriti.
To be precise against constitution.
Mr Dave is excellent and very very mature person
He is highly professional.
Appreciate for speaking the whole truth, legal luminary Dushyant Dave. God bless you.
Very well explained Mr. Dave❤❤❤❤❤
"Justice Chandrachud is a complete failure". A bold statement. A lay person that I'm, I was looking forward to Justice Chandrachud's tenure with a lot of expectations. But it has so far been a total disappointment 🙁
Totally agree with you 💯
Everyone was looking at him with a great hope...
Honestly J M Ramana was best and had some spine in the last 8 years...
Rubbish, 23 hindus were killed last month by so called minority in manipur no media outrage. Why so demographic changes has taken place? hindus are declining why? If hindus aren't facing persecution? *South and North east minority majority states almost* they get lots of money to hide atrocities against hindus
Agree totally
he didn't fall prey to this guy's trap, let this poor chap cry to his max
Honorable CJI is spineless.
Honorable Supreme Court is Toothless.
It’s other way round, Dave is spineless, he cannot digest judgement on article 370
Rubbish, 23 hindus were killed last month by so called minority in manipur no media outrage. Why so demographic changes has taken place? hindus are declining why? If hindus aren't facing persecution? *South and North east minority majority states almost* they get lots of money to hide atrocities against hindus
He is furious as the old hegemony of the very few senior counsels of Supreme Court in choice of forum (read selection of suitable Benches) is broken by our Hon'ble CJI. It is only his frustration speaking.
Hon'ble Judges can't defend in media and so he is so vociferous.
Honourable????
Heart touching words by Arvind Dave ji. You command respect sir.
My foot. Tukde tukde gang lawyer
@@SrinivasRao-vd4kiAndhbhakt
Yep no doubt about it, finally someone spoke the truth
No use of mere speaking. The days have gone. We must raise concrete demands against the judiciary. No trust in any of the judges. The majority of them are corrupt. Each and every judgement should be openly debated. Every appointment should be scrutinized and openly debated. "My lord" should be laughed at.
I am an Advocate by profession and I am grateful to a lone crusader like Dushyant Dave for expressing his views in such an honest and fearless manner. We have very few Advocates of the likes of Dushyant Dave like Prashant Bhushan, Kapil Sibal but its very frustrating to see that entire lawyers fraternity are keeping quiet over the destruction of democracy, secularism and Indian Constitution.
Not entire lawyers fraternity. But few bloody brokers. It is unfortunate that you too are in this group.
In my view Judiciary is strongest in the Independent Indian History. And all harramkors who were working for Anti India are definitely finding it difficult to get favourable orders from SC.
It is highly unfortunate that you are part of bloody pigs.
😂
Secular is not in our legal constitution.
@@thenakeddrummer1413 The word Secular is very much there in the preamble of the Constitution inserted in 1976 by 42nd Amendment.
God save our beloved Nation from anarchy!!!
A brave slap on the CJI and collegium to mend their ways, honestly we require a revolutionary movement to change with people like Mr.Dave to safeguard the Constitution of India
Bravo sir Dushyant Dave. Your interview today was a pleasure hearing. It is a feast to the ears.
You have expressed what many a common man feels....... HELPLESS.
I have always enjoyed hearing you.
❤
You mean LIP SERVICE
When judiciary is weak or fails next is Anarchy
judiciary you cannot call it that if it take 20+ 50+ yr for judgment , but can be summon for terrorist at 2am it is redundant anyway
Rubbish, 23 hindus were killed last month by so called minority in manipur no media outrage. Why so demographic changes has taken place? hindus are declining why? If hindus aren't facing persecution? *South and North east minority majority states almost* they get lots of money to hide atrocities against hindus
Weimar Republic
Sad but true, we need to be proactive.
@@atntaltd Indian judiciary like any other justice system is indispensable to any democratic society. Our justice system is definitely far from being redundant but is becoming corrupt day by day; it is on its way to being a whore for the government.
Mr. Dave Sir you are pelting stones on the face of corrupt judiciary which is completely failed to take decision for citizens. Dave Sir thanks for it.
CJI DY Chandrachud was so good when he initially become Cheif Justice, till May 2023…. he was back to back giving really good judgements…. But after the summer vacation, Since July He is gradually toeing on the lines of Central Government …The Govt. has bowed him down someway
Justice Chandrachud, is a total failure, as CJI,,??
Good Commenter.
Bad decision giver.
Observations and Comments dont make a judgement.
No point giving great observations and a bogus judgement.
I have heard of Dushyant Dave sir never hesrd him talk or argue inthe Hon Courts. Yes this fearless attitude to stand up for truth and justice for the common man irrespective of caste creed position money.yes thats what our Constitution is all about. Today the last hope is the judiciary. Where will thecommon man go. He is,crushed betweenselling his integrity,ethics principles or face the onslaught bravely but safeguard the lriciples of fairplay truth and justice.. Sometimes i used to think why am i different whats wrong. Today after hearing sirs interview i realised there is nothing wrong with me or my thoughts. The wrong is with the system. Vasantasena Srinivasan . Artiste social worker.
As long as you abuse Hindus the judes are ok? What an irony?
Mr.Dave is a renowned name in the legal fraternity. Every word we listen to from him gives strength to fight the Automatic Ruler. Similarly positioned people should come out to resist complete destruction of the social fabrics of nation, to save the constitution of India.
Let judiciary be bold, fearless, and impartial insted of being a follower of POWER.
May their consciousness awake from hybernation.
"We have become a majoritarian nation"
This rings alarm bells louder if u have courage to listen
Let your forefathers ask you why you still in criminals religion that killed him😂😂😂😂
Those who wear salwar in fear of thalwar 😂😂😂 talking nonsense
Can you explain why Mohammad killed pregnant women asma bint merwan?😂😂😂 Don't run away 😂😂😂
Well Said Mr.Dave
Great and real thoughts presented by the senior Advocate. We need many more daring voices like Mr D. Dave to show mirror to the central government
Mr. Dushyant Dave a very fine human, brave & bold Indian Advocate. Whatever little trust in judiciary is because of a few advocates like him.
Being a lay person I see even CJI is scared of ED
so he must have many skeletons in his closet
That means he must have earned black money from other source..
His file is ready on PM table. 😢
True... He sworn in with a great hope... Unfortunately he is not acting it unable to act
May be they scared of Modi
I have heard Mr Dave speak on Judiciary in another video too. I salute you Mr Dave for speaking frankly and honestly the truth about Indian Justice system. I expected a lot from Justice Ramana and even more from Justice Chandrachud but realised that it was a mirage.
In a Govt office a Section Officer is expected to decide whether certain provision in the service rules is applicable to an individual or not. Section officer is a step above clerk. But it is astonishing that supreme court after hearing the arguments from top most Lawyers of the Country for five days had reserved the pronouncement of the judgement for more than a month on the applicability of section 17A of Prevention of corruption of corruption act to a certain individual.
Mr Dave I wish your tribe will increase and bring about a chang for the good of people (citizens).
Hats 🎩 off to Mr Dushyant Dave
Salute to the conscience keeper of the Nation, Shri.Dave.
Good wishes.
Thanks for this very important interview.
Mr. Dave you are the hope of the Judiciary of this great country which is going through a bad, bad time.what is shocking is that in this massive population there is no one else able/willing to stand up..Let's hope the Elections will be the answer .
Not with EVM.
@livelaw : This is an incredible initiative besides the day to day reporting which your team carries. Please do more such interviews with advocates, retired judges etc and other key people who could impact the legal fraternity.
Dushyant Dave is a straight speaker who has not minced his words. Hat's off to him.
Thanking for spoking truth courageously.Thanking daring lawyer
Mr. Dave, Hats off to you. 🙏 My admiration for your forthrightnessn and courage knows no bounds.🎉🎉🎉🙏
We require more Mr Dushyant Daves who are brave to fight for the survival of our democracy.
My sincere thanks to him for being so honest and out spoken to make the citizens aware of the real situation being faced by the country.
Awesome sir..i salute you again and again.🙏🙏🙏🙏
No words! Salute to Dusyant Dave Sir for speaking the truth!
I have known him since his role in Judge Loya case!
Dusyant ji very daring....hats off to u....
Wow what a frank and bold lawyer he is assert to the society and nation as a whole I salute him I am a rtd professor I havent seen such a great lawater in whole of my life
Kitne Logon Ki Aankhen kholega yah aapka interview Naman hai aapko
Brave indeed! Dr Dave you are an asset to us. May God guide the Judiciary in the right manner. Wake up CJI to the need of the hour. CJI is our hope. Do not fear.
Very few BRAVE Man as Senior Advocate Dushyant Dave 🙏
Fearless Mr Dave has hit the nail on the head!❤
Thanks to great minds like Adv. Dave.
Thank you Sebastian for doing this interview and thank you Adv. Davey for your courage in being so brutally honest and you are known for it. High respect for you sir. CJI is a total disappointment. He lacks moral courage. The very fact that he wrote the Babri masjid but left it unsigned! The many critical judgments he withholds, the loopholes he leaves in his judgments and announces it... He loves giving high sounding speeches. That's all.
But who misdirect the judges BAR members
They have vaytha advocates in millions as members of bar - hightime legal education should be instutionalise like CA, ICWA
Incredible Mr. Dave, it’s always wonderful to hear his views. Manu, questions could’ve been better.
True assessment. Hats off to him.
It takes incredible courage for Mr. Dave to make these statements. Whether his views may be right or wrong, his ability to state it in the open is phenomenal.
Hi Mr Dave
Today we have an efficient & fearless CJI & a good panel of Supreme Court judge's.
Hats off to Mr Dave for coming out so bravely and saying things that are expected from the highest office .... CJI Chandrachur has been a huge huge disappointment.
Mr Dave's attitude towards secularism is also absolutely correct!. I wish him all the best.
Worth listening to the pain of advocates like Dushyant Dave when judgement like article 370 and Ramlala do not go their way
The issues raised by lawyer Dave in this interview were there even when Chandrachud was not cji but these issues not raised earlier
ये हंगामा क्यों है जो मैंने थोड़ा सा राम राम किया और थोड़ी सी क़ुरान पढ़ी है
In fact judiciary today is strongest and gave judgement on Ramlala, article 370 without any fear and issue settled which earlier judges did not deal
According to Dave judiciary was best when Supreme Court rejected petition of Kashmiri Hindus to open cases of crimes done to Hindu pandits on grounds of delay
Today the bulldozers pain advocate Dave but the Kashmiri Hindu pandit did not pain Dave when Supreme Court rejected petition of Kashmiri pandit on grounds of overdue. What a biased Supreme Court when even the petition of Kashmiri Hindu was not heard
@@rpsh1 Yes, all those. Being a "real lawyer" in their eyes means being a Congressi. All are Nehruvian fools here.
@@rpsh1 that's why you don't come by your real identity on this comment😂
@@thenakeddrummer1413 atleast he has a rational mind not an andhbhakt mental retards like you 😂. That's why he has been a practicing advocate for 46 years and you are just a frustrated unemployed andhbhakt troll with a fake name 😂😂😂😂
What is going on in Judiciary is so pathetic, we must listen to Sir, Honorable Dushyant Dave, India may shine because such people who upheld Truth above everything... God Bless India
Thank you very much to this Great Son of India
In last few years the judgements of SC has been disappointing. As a citizen my faith in last ray of hope is eroding at an increasing rate.
RIP Indian judiciary.
BJP has destroyed every pillar of our Democracy and it's sad.
It's Damn True
They pressurize, offer carrots or blackmail.
Every institution!!! 😢😢😢
Actually democracy is dead in our country under
Modis rule
Leftists have a saying " either our way or Highway".
With due respect Mr. Dave can u write a letter again to the CJI about the concerns in the interest of the nation.
Apart from Mr Dave & Mr P Bhushan , there is no other lawyer so brave & so correct.
Mr sibbal , Mr singhvi
@@vasuarora9588😂
@@vasuarora9588Rubbish, 23 hindus were killed last month by so called minority in manipur no media outrage. Why so demographic changes has taken place? hindus are declining why? If hindus aren't facing persecution? *South and North east minority majority states almost* they get lots of money to hide atrocities against hindus
@@vasuarora9588all congi lobbyists
😂😂 All anti BJP 😂😂
We need more people like him in the judiciary. His brutal honest opinion of the CJI is commendable. The judgements of the CJI on important matters was not what was expected of him.
Absolutely fantastic.
Judgements are based on laws. Personal feelings or your opinions don't factor in those. Why do you expect the judiciary to be constantly fighting the executive? This is not a TV drama. If you are getting unfavorable judgements, it's because your cases hold no water.
Brilliant...wish we have our entire legal profession could unite to restore our judiciary .....sad that our SC and other courts have let us down. History will never forgive them....
Excellent interview. I hope Adv. Dave's voice echoes where it is directed.
Dushyant. Is great lawyer, most out spoken.
Judiciary is on ventilation. May collapse at any moment. All lawyers should think about. All Democratic people should re inforce judiciary.
Thabks live law for this interview
Respect Respect Respect for sr. Advocate, fearless propagator of democracy.Lot of things I had in mind about the executive thumbing down on judiciary, he said boldy and with authority as a learned counsel for 46 years. Atleast few learned advocates like him, Ranjeev C.Dubey and many brave people to stand up for the weakest citizen of our great Civilization. Salute him from bottom of my heart and thank you for bringing this great interview which mainstream media will hide under their chair.
Mr. Dave is one of the outspoken lawyers and a very bright person. Whatever he has been saying is true. Even he didn't hesitate to point fingers at the present dispensation whenever it committed blunders. We need more such bright and fearless lawyers. Hats off to him.
Fearless 🔥
😂😂😂😂
Loads of respect and regards to you ,Sir Dave . It's the little drops of wisdom which makes it revolutionary. Thank you so much for being truthful, blunt and bold. This is the great legacy you will leave for the future generation of lawyers od India. Thank you for giving hope for Indians that we can love India inspite of some major flaws . May God guide mankind to the straight & righteous path.
Such gentlemen are the pillars of indian true judiciary.
Hat's off to you
Wow! Each line of thought to dwell upon by right-minded citizens
Judiciary should show some courage.
Very True ! Recent court judgements on religious issues & saving adani proves it.
Excellent .
Congratulations advocate Dushyant Dave .
👍👍CANDID AND BOLD INTERVIEW 👍
JUDICIARY SYSTEM IN TOTAL CHAOS😢😢😢
Kudos to Dave for calling a spade a spade. Justice - how do you spell it in India? How can one honestly say Mera Bharat Mahaan when you have such a justice system. Tareek pe tareek 30 years back... continuing. Ask litigants
Thanks for giving ur opinion
We admire and really appreciate Mr Dushyant Dave’s thought provoking views about present justice delivery system in our country. We have a lot of respect for him specifically about his secular credentials.
May Almighty God shower his countless blessings on him. 🤲
People are filing cases and dying before hearng the decision, before getting any relief from justice..Mr.Dave is 100% correct his voice speaks the voice of common people of our country who are being made voiceless by the moneyed and powerful of the society...
Now it is very sad time for people and democracy in our country...
Thank you a lot sir for delivering with direct words.
All are threatened with ED,CBI, IT DEPT
Why worry ED, CBI when u are clean and nothing to hide😅😅😅
Salutation Dave sirjee presenting the reality frankly. A step towards Truth.
All those citizens suffering due to the apparent terminal decline of our once mighty judiciary will no doubt be grateful to Dushyant Dave for his outspokeness.
Thank you sir for enlightening us
I very strongly recomend Ad.D.Dave should to be a Supreme court Judge.
I appreciate the principled stand of Adv.D.Dave. God bless him.
Dr.K.T. Thomas.
Thanks for this kind of interview the grate mr. DAVE. KAUHAL
Lawyers defending justice should be courageous like Mr Dave.