Logitech Saitek VS Thrustmaster Rudder Pedals Review

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 125

  • @jjraga
    @jjraga 2 роки тому +45

    thanks for the comprehensive review! no other review on UA-cam was as good

  • @Bunnxies
    @Bunnxies Рік тому +6

    Thank you for taking the time to make this video to help others.

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  Рік тому

      Thank you very much. Im glad if I helepd to someone. Cheers!

  • @1hermannk
    @1hermannk 2 роки тому +28

    Agree with your review on the Thrustmaster TFRP Pedals: In neutral there is a sort of "stickiness" where you have to use force to get the pedals to move forward. Makes for a very uneven pedal movement and difficult to get aircraft on the centre line for takeoff or taxiing.

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  2 роки тому

      Exacly )))

    • @Nublet1871
      @Nublet1871 2 роки тому +7

      If you don't try it until now, put some vaseline or other grease on each metal pipe. I had the same problem and with grease it feels much more better.

    • @Mario-xg1eh
      @Mario-xg1eh Рік тому +2

      Also,I have the thrustmaster it is so buggy on left rudder, only half travel detected. Consider to buy the logitech rudder now.

    • @SkySamurai95
      @SkySamurai95 Рік тому +1

      ​@@Nublet1871 what grease you use?

    • @Nublet1871
      @Nublet1871 Рік тому +1

      @Sky Samurai You can use any grease that will not damage the plastic. I use normal vaseline. Grease for suspension forks should also work well, anyway it should stick well.

  • @DallasJW1
    @DallasJW1 Рік тому +8

    Thank you. Exactly what I was looking for.

  • @joergbock1976
    @joergbock1976 Рік тому +6

    Thanks for the direct comparison. Recently, I got the BF 109 and taxiing that thing with but a controller or a twist rudder joystick is next to impossible since you have to rely on differential brakes to turn. Going for the Saitek pedals. I think the wider spacing is more comfortable in the end and the option to set the rudder tension is a big plus too.

  • @Ava-uq5dh
    @Ava-uq5dh 11 місяців тому +1

    I have never bought sim equipment before, beyond a heavily specialised tank gunner control handle from a private company that doesn't distribute online, this video was SO HELPFUL! Thank you, you are very well spoken and a helpful man. I appreciate your work and will be choosing the Saitek design!

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  11 місяців тому +1

      Thank you very much. You are welcome. )))

  • @edd1682
    @edd1682 5 місяців тому

    The best review I could have asked for no one seems to show the way they function like this! Helps me decide where to start on pedals as I have been trying without pedals which has proven rough.

  • @JB-qg2uc
    @JB-qg2uc 2 роки тому +6

    Great video! Very good in depth analysis from the user experience!

  • @rbsims6376
    @rbsims6376 11 місяців тому +2

    Thanks. I'm glad now that I decided to purchase Saitek. Thank you for the review.

  • @Denis.flores
    @Denis.flores Рік тому

    Thank you for taking the time and for posting your comparison video. Thank you!

  • @THEFALLENF0E
    @THEFALLENF0E 2 роки тому +3

    really good review ! great to see all the features from a real customer thanks !

  • @tobytoxd
    @tobytoxd Рік тому +1

    Great demonstration! Thank you much! You could also use Self-Adhesive Hook and Loop fastener, which i use to fix the left pedal of my kickdrum double pedal on carpet. Could work on non carpet floors, too, if you find one that comes with both sides of the hook and loop AND is self-adhesive. The one that i use on carpet is really strong and sticks to the metal plate forever.

  • @JabariHunt
    @JabariHunt Рік тому +3

    Thank you for this review, I was debating between the two. I think I'm going to go with the Logitech

  • @seralyncampbell4731
    @seralyncampbell4731 5 місяців тому

    This helped me make my decision! Thanks a lot for making this.

  • @edgarw.espinosa7470
    @edgarw.espinosa7470 4 місяці тому

    Thanks for the review, didn't want to go over 200+ dollars on rudder pedals. This helped my decision.

  • @cromthebeast
    @cromthebeast 10 місяців тому

    Thanks for the review. I appreciate the honest comparison.

  • @NobbsAndVagene
    @NobbsAndVagene Рік тому +2

    I initially fixed the awful stickyness of the TM TFRP pedals with some silicone spray. This however made them too slippery.
    Then I bit the bullet and ordered some Nyogel 767A from German Amazon and applied it. At first, it felt weird. Too much resistance at times, too little at others, but I just needed to wear it in. They're perfect now, except for the horrible creaking noises when in use. I know they're some of the cheapest rudder pedals you can buy, but they're still way too expensive for something that feels so cheap and plastic-y.

  • @JohnnyLawBMC
    @JohnnyLawBMC 2 місяці тому

    Thank you so much. I'm with you, I find the Logitech Saitek Pro Flight Rudders and buy them. Hopefully a Christmas sale.

  • @Lautajaska
    @Lautajaska Рік тому

    good video and great notes on both of the pedals!

  • @thierrybo6304
    @thierrybo6304 Рік тому +3

    07:50 €65 for the thrustmaster ? You mean ’used", not new,itissold 100€ now

  • @fredjones554
    @fredjones554 3 місяці тому

    Thank you for your review, very complete and detailed

  • @guoanwen1981
    @guoanwen1981 Рік тому

    Well done! I wasn’t sure which one I should get. Now I know. Thanks! 🕹️ 👍🏻

  • @AircraftBR
    @AircraftBR Рік тому

    Thank you!! Great video bro! 👏🏻

  • @pens6564
    @pens6564 Рік тому

    What a great review, congrats!

  • @adambrett920
    @adambrett920 Рік тому

    Great video. Thanks! Subscribed 👍🏻👍🏻

  • @42LGK
    @42LGK 3 місяці тому

    youtube sometimes is just fantastic. thats excatly what Ive been looking for. thanks!

  • @NC_Number_1
    @NC_Number_1 2 роки тому +1

    thx for the review ;-) keep on going

  • @typingsquirrel2128
    @typingsquirrel2128 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks very good review and helpful on deciding which to purchase.

  • @g_pazzini
    @g_pazzini 10 місяців тому

    I also like saitek one. I’s so durable. I have it since 2012 and still working perfectly

  • @rccosplay3249
    @rccosplay3249 2 роки тому +7

    Logitech Saitek for me as it has the foot pedals wider apart.

  • @infinitewisdom9619
    @infinitewisdom9619 7 місяців тому

    great video, thanks!

  • @FroggyFrog9000
    @FroggyFrog9000 Рік тому

    great review man

  • @merkabah2
    @merkabah2 Рік тому

    I thought you could change the spacing with the Thrusmasters?>?

  • @katnapgamingproductions
    @katnapgamingproductions Рік тому

    thank you for the review

  • @jasonsmall3809
    @jasonsmall3809 Рік тому

    Why not just stick a piece of a non-slip rug underneath the Logitech pedals instead of cutting out a piece of wood?

  • @technofaisal
    @technofaisal Рік тому +1

    Thank you for good review

  • @althafraja544
    @althafraja544 Рік тому

    can i use those items on macbook pro m1 ?

  • @bestskateboreder
    @bestskateboreder 2 роки тому +2

    Thx bro u right i will wait to logiteck to come to inventory agreed but what is the cost

  • @antoncv1050
    @antoncv1050 2 роки тому +1

    Will thrustmaster pedals work with saitek pro flight yoke?

  • @pepeiglesias9603
    @pepeiglesias9603 Рік тому

    Hello. Great review. The Logitech G are compatible with the Hub of Honeycomb for Xbox Series S? I hope you can help me with my question.

  • @massimoilfrassino-yr2bf
    @massimoilfrassino-yr2bf Рік тому +1

    Are they usable also for ps4 or for only pc?

  • @Hdhdhdhxhxhev
    @Hdhdhdhxhxhev Рік тому

    Does a Logitech pedals work with Xbox series X

  • @alexeykolesnik6443
    @alexeykolesnik6443 9 місяців тому

    Thank you, kind man! You just saved me from buying Thrustmaster pedals

  • @swollen2dabone
    @swollen2dabone 2 роки тому +1

    Saitek has had an issue with the toe plastic rocker plate breaking, by the spring hook. Dp newer Saitek rudders have a stronger rocker bracket?

  • @NicReid4
    @NicReid4 2 роки тому

    I have a thrustmaster hotas one joystick would the saitek work for that?

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  2 роки тому +1

      Yes for sure, it has a separate usb connection.

    • @NicReid4
      @NicReid4 2 роки тому

      @@almedinfilms8390 how would you connect it to your pc?

    • @RaynePL
      @RaynePL 2 роки тому

      @@NicReid4 via USB provided you've got version with USB cable (standalone). If you buy it with the full 16000m set, I think it comes with RJ45. Keep it mind if you plan on buying used one.

  • @josemajano6821
    @josemajano6821 2 роки тому

    Question will the logitech pedals work with Xbox series x? I am looking to but the turtle beach yoke and I already have the logitech pedals.

    • @jonny4881
      @jonny4881 2 роки тому

      Turtlebeach has its own specific pedals Logitech pedals are compatible with alpha xpc and xbox hubs

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  2 роки тому

      I think not for now, but I think they will add support for xbox also becouse of MSFS for xbox. )))

  • @halcyonzenith4411
    @halcyonzenith4411 11 місяців тому

    Those thrustmaster pedals gave me pain and neuropathy in my legs. Unless you are very short or a kid they are worse than nothing.
    If you want a decent rudder set you won't find it for cheap. Be prepared to spend if you plan to put serious time into using them. Ultimately I bit the bullet and got the thrustmaster pendular rudders. Expensive but I wish I had done it years ago.

  • @Siberian.
    @Siberian. Рік тому

    Looks like Logitech removed the wall spaces for the Saitek Pedals.

  • @RobBob555
    @RobBob555 Рік тому

    Yep, good review, I assume your Polish, living in the UK ?

  • @rickl6697
    @rickl6697 5 місяців тому

    Why are they so noisy? Do you know if they will work on Xbox 😊

  • @OwnedByMoomin
    @OwnedByMoomin Місяць тому

    So I cut this wood :):):) I love all these crazy setups and DIY stuff going on in everyones gaming rooms

  • @houting931
    @houting931 2 роки тому

    Recently I want to buy Thrustermaster T16000M FCS Hotas and is wondering about if I should buy pedals too (due to nice discount for Flight Pack containing the pedals).
    It seems I should save money since my already owned Saitek one works better. 😆

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  2 роки тому

      Go with them. no mistake. )))

    • @danam0228
      @danam0228 Рік тому

      ​@@almedinfilms8390can you use Saitek with thrustmaster throttle and joystick, hotas or 1600?

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  Рік тому

      @@danam0228 yes you can

    • @danam0228
      @danam0228 Рік тому

      ​@@almedinfilms8390thank you

  • @ONI-ou3bw
    @ONI-ou3bw 2 роки тому

    guess you could put 2 side tape on thrustmaster pedals and avoid sliding

  • @botchi1
    @botchi1 Рік тому

    Thank you

  • @TPHI17
    @TPHI17 2 роки тому

    I’m waiting for the Turtle Beach ones coming very soon.

    • @chris12321222
      @chris12321222 2 роки тому +1

      Not for $300!!! Almost cost as much as their yoke

    • @TPHI17
      @TPHI17 2 роки тому

      @@chris12321222 yep as soon as I saw that price I backed right off I’m up in Canada with taxes and everything $440 Canadian.

  • @алексейподкопаев-я1и
    @алексейподкопаев-я1и 9 місяців тому

    Спасибо за обзор.

  • @Acid_Burn9
    @Acid_Burn9 Рік тому

    Thrustmaster do their job until the cheap plastic at the base of the pedal snaps after 4 months of use because of the design of the pedal that applies pretty much all force coming from your foot to a very small area under the pedal where the pedal pillar connects to the sliding base. Definitely cannot recommend.

  • @manuelkimpel3788
    @manuelkimpel3788 Рік тому +1

    thank you for the video! unfortunately logitech saitek is not to easy to buy right now inside europe. there are no new devices. :(
    Update: Now I ordered the Turtle Beach Velocity Rudder Pedals. Do you have any experience with them?

    • @dukeofdream
      @dukeofdream Рік тому

      Almost impossible to find either of them in Greece at the moment... Even the Thrustmaster pedals are not in stock... I have a friend who works for the Greek importer of thrustmaster and they don’t even have an estimate on when they will get them 😰 After weeks of searching I finally found a used set of thrustmaster rudder for 80€ and I’m debating on whether I should get it 😰 I know I want the Logitech’s but I can’t find them 😰 I’m so confused...

  • @hondarider100r
    @hondarider100r 7 місяців тому

    As soon as the video started I could tell the Logitech were the way to go. Just by the way they moved

  • @j_london9791
    @j_london9791 2 роки тому

    good job

  • @gilflight6485
    @gilflight6485 2 роки тому +1

    ok with you, but if you look in an airplane cockpit you will see the pedals are like trhusmaster, very close together

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  2 роки тому +2

      I dont know but I think for sure no in airbus and boeing. )))

    • @nielsmallant2710
      @nielsmallant2710 2 роки тому +3

      As someone who works in cockpits all the time, Logitech spacing is more realistic

  • @Bolha24X
    @Bolha24X 11 місяців тому

    You sound a bit like Alex Terrible 😅
    Are you also russian?

  • @lennypilot3460
    @lennypilot3460 8 місяців тому

    That is absolute Plastique toys...

  • @videosallnight
    @videosallnight Рік тому +1

    The wall issue on the Thrustmaster is entirely dependent on your set-up. If you have a problem, you really don't have to be Einstein
    to make a spacer block.

  • @HazlittGabrielle-n7x
    @HazlittGabrielle-n7x 4 місяці тому

    Ferry Circle

  • @darsonx6330
    @darsonx6330 2 роки тому

    thx

  • @go737
    @go737 2 роки тому +9

    You too much think wall, think desk please,wall and desk

    • @danam0228
      @danam0228 Рік тому +1

      I think it is good point he made about having the pedals up against the wall, especially if pedals are on slick surface

  • @isaacmack1316
    @isaacmack1316 2 роки тому

    Just make ur own spacers for cheep lol

  • @NoreneMccleary-c8m
    @NoreneMccleary-c8m 4 місяці тому

    Billie Stream

  • @LaLaObeRoT
    @LaLaObeRoT 2 місяці тому

    Thrustmasters suck. Complete ly hated them.

  • @clxudzYT
    @clxudzYT Рік тому

    feet 👍

  • @Sirmellowman
    @Sirmellowman 2 роки тому +1

    do yourself a giant favor and dont buy either of these and just spend 100 bucks more and get the MFG Crosswind pedals. I promise you you will be so much happier.

    • @almedinfilms8390
      @almedinfilms8390  2 роки тому +2

      Thank you for your suggestion, but Im fine for now with these one. )))

    • @herrboeing
      @herrboeing Рік тому

      where did you find it for that price? on their website the cheapest version costs almost $280

    • @knowethjc29
      @knowethjc29 Рік тому +1

      In my country they’re 500+ dollars…. These rudder pedals the man has are around the 150-300 range so no

  • @alexf1525
    @alexf1525 4 місяці тому

    great review