RX 580 VS GTX 1060
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лип 2024
- MY FAVORITE BUDGET PARTS ON AMAZON:
Silicon Power Sata SSD: amzn.to/3PyDg8W
Silicon Power NVMe SSD: amzn.to/3ZwEqq7
Teamgroup Sata SSD: amzn.to/48iNgvE
Cooler Master CPU Cooler: amzn.to/3EOzfbR
Deepcool Theta CPU Cooler: amzn.to/3rjBOiN
ID Cooling Tower CPU Cooler: amzn.to/3EOS3HE
Cougar MG130-G mATX Case: amzn.to/3r8onlW
Thermaltake mATX Case: amzn.to/3Ppxuqi
Aresgame 500w Power Supply: amzn.to/3ENyOhU
00:00 Intro
01:54 Parameters
03:08 RX 580 Background
04:20 GTX 1060 Background
05:31 Spec Comparison
06:50 Price Comparison
07:47 Game Tests
13:37 Conclusion
this channel is really underrated, i'm hoping to get back into PC flipping soon so i'll stay tuned for your style of deal hunting!
I personally would give the edge to the 580. As you can see in cyberpunk a lot of new titles will lean more towards the 580. The vram buffer will also come in handy.
The 8gb of vram on the 580 is useless as it cannot utilize all of it. Go check other benchmarks of more recent games and you will see even after the card starts to struggle due to more demanding scenarios on the games it nowhere near reaches 8gb utilization. It is the better shader config and memory bus/transfer rate that pushes it ahead in the newer titles
You, Budget Bin and RandomGamingInHD are my favorite channels rn haha, love seeing more budget-oriented PC part content
The newer the games get the better RX 580 looks. That's just wild
Though the RX 580s were absolute awesome gpu's in their day, these days on the used market a GTX 1660 ti or super goes for about the same price and outperforms the RX 580 as well as the 1060 greatly. Awesome vid you have my sub👍
I'm in the UK and been seeing 1660 supers go for twice what 580's are 🥲
@@GruelingFive8 Yeah it depends on where you are and I see around here the market is changing as well lots of people grabbing 1660ti and supers of the 2nd hand market so people startin to push prices
Excellent video. Keep up the great work. Looking forward to more from tour channel and watching it grow
Man i love you and your vids, here is the sub and like, keep going bro
2016 vibes :) still good budget cards.
Great video. Great voice over. Keep them coming....
I currently have the rx 580 8GB and it does great for the games I play. Also great video, earned a sub from me.
I just posted my RX580 vs GTX1060 comparison last week. Having never used an AMD before I was shocked at how much cheaper it was and in some but not all cases faster than my entire suite of GTX1060s (I have almost every version on hand). In my comparison, I also called it a close tie. The RX580 loses some points for thermal and standalone benchmark performance.
Good to see another perspective! Your video quality is top notch.
Side note: The MSI OCV1 GTX1060 is not a great version. To see the GTX 1060 operate at it's full potential you would want to try the GAMING X variant.
🤔Did you also notice that the "AMD Drivers are garbage" comments are just crap that people say to to scare others or justify their over spending on nVIDIA?
Generally if you question those people you get one of 2 answers, They NEVER Owned an AMD/ATi GPU or if they did when they installed the AMD GPU they had not uninstalled the previous GPU properly.
Be careful of the 2048sp version of 580, has less performance and is hotter, the normal 580 8gb is faster than the 1060 and even a tie
*Cool subbed to the Channel :)*
it's really worth noting that the GTX 1060 3GB has a significantly different performance than the 6GB version, with fewer cores, lower clock speeds, and so on. it's a bit misleading that they're both called the GTX 1060, when really one should be a 1060 and the other a 1060 Ti or something. for forza 5, i've found that going in the open world at high speed can show a GPU's weakness in memory management as it streams in textures (or fails to), and emerging from tunnels into daylight can really hit fps hard on some GPUs.
the 8GB of VRAM on the RX 580 can sometimes be a factor, but at 1080p it's not a big detriment to "only" have 6GB imho.
I have the theory that the GTX 1060 3GB was going to be the actual 1060, however when the RX 480 launched (the 580 was a refresh of RX 400 series) NVIDIA needed an answer to the midrange segment/market, or else AMD was gonna eat their lunch.
In hopes of stopping AMD from getting away with the midrange and entry level, they launched the 1060 6GB (probably meant to be a 1060 Ti) and kept the 1060 3GB as a lesser model of the card with misleading and scummy marketing (classic NVIDIA), explaining why there wasn't a GTX 1060 Ti
@@alexg9601 maybe. the GP106 is the same between the 3GB and 6GB, but with portions fused off the silicon in the 3GB, so its unknown if it would have been possible to reactivate them as fuller featured "1060 ti" parts. i would think due to how close the 6GB and 3GB versions were released, that the GP106-400 could be cut down into the GP106-300 and additional GP104 and GP107 parts were cannibalized to keep NV's market segment from evaporating under AMD's Polaris refresh. Pascal has all kinds of variations of GP cores being used in the mid and low ranges to meet demand since a cheap chip that sells is better than an expensive part that remains unsold.
I love the RX 580 sapphire nitro edition. I think it looks super cool. Thanks for another great video! As a side note I think it'd be cool in future videos to see some of these older GPUs running Starfield, because it's a new game that's popular and very difficult to run. It'd be fun to see how these older GPUs handle it even if it's at 720p low settings. Just an idea. Keep up the good work!!!
I'll definitely test the game out eventually but at it's current price, I could get components to test instead. I definitely want to get more recent titles like BG3 and Starfield and even Hogwarts Legacy for myself to play through but also for testing.
Would the rx 580 pare good with the ryzen 5 4500?
@@UltraBudgetPC One option you could try is Xbox PC game pass. The PC version is only 10 dollars a month and would give you access to Starfield and the new Forza Motorsport when they are released. As well as lots of other titles.
I love your content man.
Great video! In May I picked up a PC for $300 that has an i7 8700k and an ASUS GTX 1060 6GB Turbo. The combination is good enough for the games I play.
That is a really solid rig. With the 8700k you could even upgrade the GPU if you ever needed to.
I had a GTX 1060 and I have to say it held fast for me when I had it at the time. I sold it off when I upgraded, but part of me wished I held on to it
My personal experience with the RX580 came from my cousins PC, and I have to say I did like it a lot. While it is less efficient and hotter, newer games are leaning towards AMD so that might be a factor for some people who want one of these cards to hold out, not to mention VRAM becoming a topic of discussion.
G'day UBPC,
nice comparison on these, as they are so close in performance down here in Australia the RX580 is a no brainer, easily being found for $100-150AUD where as GTX1060 is generally $150-$200AUD when you include shipping. The 1060 doesn't make sense at that price because you can also get the newer & better 1660Ti/Super for $150-$200AUD delivered.
Yeah I suppose it differs based your location. In the US most components are more accessible but it's great that you can get better alternatives in your own market.
@@UltraBudgetPC It doesn't have anything to do with accessibility as there are always more comparable used nVIDIA than AMD for sale, nVIDIA GPUs are just more expensive New & Used plus even nVIDIA rip us off directly.
As an example last year at launch we were at $1USD-$1.48AUD, 4080 ($1100USD MSRP + Tax) but instore + direct from nVIDIA for us it was $2500AUD ($2250 + 10% GSTax), where as RX7900XTX ($1000USD + Tax) was $1789 ($1629 + 10%GSTax), That is a huge difference for what should really be $150AUD. 3000 was worse with mark ups of 2-2.5x USD as we were at $1USD-$1.35/1.37AUD, making AMD a no brainer as they were at about 1.4-1.5x yet nVIDIA still sold out constantly while there was always AMD stock ???
Just to explain the differences in our sales tax to yours, unlike America where States control tax so can vary depending where you live here in Australia it is Federal, we have a Goods & Services Tax (GST) which is 10% on new items & 2nd hand through Registered Businesses, it must be included in the listed price so sometimes depending on the price like the $1789AUD (1629+162.9=1791.9) it can be a little less. For Private 2nd hand sales like Ebay or Facebook MP there is no tax.
Love your benchmarks
Underrated Channel
im on an RX 580 8gb. I bought it just right before pandemic and right before the crazy gpu prices so I was able to get it cheap brand new. Im looking to upgrade to an RX7600 soon though but this card has done wonders and I would give this to my cousin as a gift. Plays most games well especially RE4 Remake and others as long as they're properly optimized of course
Back in the day I would've go for GTX 1060 without a doubt. But GCN's "FineWine" shows its potential once again.
1060 wins for me based on power draw alone. A cheaper PSU and lower electric bill means it's actually more budget friendly considering the meager $10 difference
this guy and iceberg tech needs more subs
I am wondering what additional variables may be effecting your results. In general, when both the cards was launched the nod tended to go to the 1060, now adays the consensus leans toward the 580. Both have been neck and neck for their existence. But I think most people are leaning toward the 580 these days because the drivers have caught up significantly and the extra vram buffer is more meaningful these days.
I can't say the exact reason but the RX 580 may just be more optimized for certain newer titles due to its overall configuration and maybe even drivers. The extra ram in the 8gb version is great but for most 1080p gaming it's not really needed. The 2304 stream processor version is the one to go with that will perform the best.
I had been using a RX 590 for some time and ran games at 1440p and averaged 45 fps (even Cyberpunk 2077) at high or better settings for the most part. I upgraded earlier this year to a RX 6750 XT and was able to go to 4k resolution and increased graphics settings without a fps reduction.
what cpu with that 590?
@@johnster7161 i5 9600k
i5 9600k, still using it.
I have a Prodesk 400 G3 MT, I threw two 8gb ddr4 kingston fury sticks in it (it is an overkill but I was thinking of just upgrading the motherboard and processor in the near feature) and I added a 480 gb kingston ssd to boot faster. I´ve been thinking about getting a certified psu but here´s my question; given the fact that I have an i5 6500, which gpu should I get? Should I get an i7 6700 instead? If so, which gpu should I use in that scenario? btw, I just discovered your channel and I´m definitely subscribing!
With the i5 6500 a good GPU option in my opinion would be something like the 1050 ti or 1650 (RX 460/560 if you want a cheaper but weaker option) if you stick with you're PSU. Keep in mind you may be CPU bound in some titles but if you did end up getting the i7 you'd be set to go. If you got a higher wattage PSU, I'd go for something like the RX 470 or 570.
i have a high end pc, i dont even need to watch this. But I started out with budget stuff, and I still love making a lot out of very little money. I respect the phonk choice as the background, but maybe lower it just a tad cus it's almost the same value as your voice.
New subscriber here
I think the rx580 sapphire nitro would be wayyy cooler this card looks really budget, also really nice that you can replace the fans on the sappphire cards.
Bought two 1060 3GB cards in 2018 because I needed the dual DVI outs for my office machines. My heavy gaming rig ran a GTX 970 4GB up to a few months ago, when I "upgraded" to a GTX 1060 6GB. I was thinking about an RX 580 for the 8GB of VRAM to replace the 1060 6GB, but your video has made me confident that the 1060 6GB is just fine for my modest gaming needs. I like the lower power usage. For Elite Dangerous and Planet Coaster and No Man's Sky, I don't feel the extra 2GB would be worth the $75USD. Maybe I can aim a little higher for used cards, and or take a closer look at going for a new video card, like an RX 6650 XT. Thanks!
I highly recommend the 6600 XT or 6650 XT if you're going new and just need a solid 1080p card. The 6650 XT was my personal card until recently. Pretty much ran anything I could ever want at playable fps at high or ultra in 1080p
Driver version please ?
Your findings run counter to my own, I have numerous 580s, but only 1 6GB 1060, and I’ve found the 580 tends to perform slightly better than the 1060. The 1060 does run cooler but rarely runs better in games. I do also have a pair of 4GB 580s and the 6GB 1060 outperforms those similar to the 580 you are using, but my 8GB 580s consistently outperform the 6GB 1060.
I guess that just goes to show the differences in different cards. I mostly have Red Devil 580s but I also have an ASUS and gigabyte models as well. My 1060 is an msi model.
I have heard people experience both sides but I am sure if I incorporated more newer titles, the 580 would have pulled away as it seems long term optimization for AMD cards is consistently better and the 580 in particular has more overall power in terms of cores.
pls compare dx11 vs dx12 with these cards
I have a 3200g and want a gpu that will not get bottleneck but also uses its all. If say 580 and 1060 are close in price which one will be better? Or anything else you can suggest I'm looking for budget gpus.
If I had to guess, I would assume in some titles, the 3200g would be the limiting factor but maybe only as much as 10%. Either card, the RX 580 or 1060 would perform similarly with the R3 3200g. Something like a GTX 1050ti would probably be a slightly better pairing with this processor but I honestly don't have personal experience with the 3200g so I can't say for sure.
@@UltraBudgetPC oh ok thanks 👍🏻
@@TheVirtualArena24 I am running a 3200g myself with a 1660 ti and I cant say that I have any complaints although the 4c/4t and low L3 cache of the 3200g is starting to struggle to keep up. I would suggest getting some dirt cheap 6c cpu like a r5 4500 first and then start thinking about gpu. As for the 1050 ti I would stay away I had one before I got the 1660 ti and unless you only playing league of legends or cs go that gpu will do nothing for you
@@ANN1H1LATE89 I'm thinking of upgrading to 5600x or 5600 and get like 1660 or 2060 like that. But the problem is don't know what to do with this cpu
@@TheVirtualArena24 There is only a very minor performance gap between the 5600 and 5600x so go for the 5600 it is cheaper. Between those gpu's I would say the 2060 is your best bet with those cpus. There is a huge market for those 3200g cpus as people buy them up for htpc's due to the igpu on them as well as people who build retro emulator pc's and such.
Where are you located man ,card down here in Africa have prices extremely high ,how can I purchase one
I am located in the US so I have access to some of the best market prices. Obviously that differs depending on where you're located. I do not know the market in other places well unfortunately so you'll have to kinda see what's out there.
Okay thank you ,I was thinking probably I could send you money so you can kind of purchase one along with the shipping cost to where I am
I have a powecolor golden sample 580 and while it's a little unstable, it is enough to run most titles. I think it's bottlenecked by my I-3 though
Hi Bro,
I am looking to buy/build a PC
My current budget is 800-900$ (Need only CPU with GPU Setup) don't want RGB can you please suggest a configuration please
So that really depends on the approach you take. You could get all new parts for a newer but lower spec'd build, or all used parts for a more powerful system that comes with any risk associated with buying used. Personally, I would do a mix of both. What I would do with a budget like that is get a modern CPU like the i5 12400f (with stock cooler) for around $130 to $150 and a compatible LGA 1700 motherboard for around $100. Both can be had new for pretty decent prices. Next, I would target 32 GB of DDR4 ram that runs at at least 3200 MHz. Right now both new and used DDR4 is pretty cheap and I still think it will be plenty viable for time to come despite DDR5 being available. 32 GB will usually run you anything from $40-$60 on the lower end from what I have seen. For the GPU, I would look at used options for around $250-$300 like the RX 6650 XT, 6700 XT, 6750 XT, RTX 3060 Ti, or even RTX 3070. These are all last gen cards that are amazing value right now. If you buy new, the 6700 XT would be my pick with it's 12 GB of VRAM and affordable price just over $300. For Power supply, I'd recommend a unit with an 80+ Gold Rating at at least 650 watts but personally I'd go with 750 watts since it's the sweet spot for having an upgrade path. Buying a power supply new is the best bet for a higher end system and usually it'll be around $100 for a good unit. For storage, I'd start with a 1 TB NVMe which will usually be around $40-$50, if you have extra budget you could get one with more storage. Finally, for case, I would just pick the one you think looks best and is compatible with your other components. Generally I don't like spending more than $100 on a case unless you really like how one looks.
Obviously, there are many other ways you could do this. Buying more used parts and even some older components will allow for more savings but less future proofing. For example, one direction I would also recommend is getting a used Ryzen 5 5600X CPU and a solid AM4 B550 ot X570 which would also perform extemely well. This is just the approach I would take right now after thinking about it for a pretty short time. If anyone else has recommendations, definitely comment them.
My brain thought the 580 was like 10/20% faster than the 1060 for some reason
☠️👍 my rx 580 8gb died R.I.P
f
How long did you use it?
😔F
I went from a rx480 8gb nitro+ to a 1060 3gb and tbh it felt like a huge downgrade.
I even ran some games in 4k (only 20-30fps) with the 480 but I had absolutely no chance of running anything playable at 4k with the 1060
I had the Rx 580 in a 2019 iMac I had, used Bootcamp and was gaming on it. Was getting good frames in mw2. Epic
i feel really sorry for anyone that can only afford a budget tier card from ten years ago, at that point just buy a steamdeck lmao
i brought a rx 580 8gb as it came with more vram and was cheaper as i am pretty poor
should of threw the 1650 super in the mix
Still using 1080
Same
the gtx 1060 3gb isnt as powerful as the 6gb , its has less cores and Tmus
*Great video, I need to up my game in the quality of my videos lol but yes these cards are still great for low budget 1080P gaming*
it feels strange to be the 5th comment.
i would get a rtx 2060 or a rtx 3060 insted
For the price, I don't blame you. The RX 5600 XT and GTX 1070 are also solid alternatives
Do RX580 2048SP vs GTX1050 pls