Manoj Jha invoked a CPI MP’s speech from 1958 to make a point about India’s FM. Thoughts?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 217

  • @vihantripathi1847
    @vihantripathi1847 Рік тому +236

    A great man I see here, who speaks facts rather than just shouting, we need more ministers like him in every party. At least he has logic behind his talk.

    • @byron2477
      @byron2477 Рік тому +13

      Only talk though
      No action
      His party is even worst.

    • @shubham5832
      @shubham5832 Рік тому +7

      He is not a minister.

    • @vihantripathi1847
      @vihantripathi1847 Рік тому +4

      @@shubham5832 I know, that is why I am saying we need ministers like him, people like him are outside management but people who only know how to shout are siting on positions, and no party is exefrom this all party have same scenario

    • @himadrib4743
      @himadrib4743 Рік тому +8

      Criticising is much easier than doing something worthy. Ask him what he has done for Bihar. He would go blank.

    • @veernair
      @veernair Рік тому +1

      He is buddhu

  • @kunalbahuguna242
    @kunalbahuguna242 Рік тому +60

    Can't believe this guy is from RJD aka the antithesis to education.

    • @regaliaretailfashionmerch4314
      @regaliaretailfashionmerch4314 Місяць тому +1

      Yes, that could very well be true about RJD, just look at Lalu 's younger son (uneducated, disgusting) ,
      but is Prof. Manoj Jha actually a member or is he just Rajya Sabha candidate from RJD
      These days to enter Parliament you just need to see which party politics can accommodate you even if there are still major ideological differences between you and the party,
      Jaha milta hai le lo warna jagah hee nahi hogi 😂
      What to do
      Even Mahua Moitra doesn't seem fully aligned with TMC but again what to do
      Many examples of this kind
      Hindu candidates from AIMIM are not same as other party members but again contesting on ticket from that party is necessary to be in Parliament
      Have to take most ethical route but at the same time reach Parliament
      😅 Kapil Sibal being SP candidate to Rajya Sabha is another example, he hasn't joined party though
      Young people of India must notice these subtleties when analysing electoral politics and party politics
      It'll make it easier for them to enter parliament in LS or RS
      Jai Hind 🇮🇳🙏

  • @aviatorbold
    @aviatorbold Рік тому +111

    Rjd mein ek to samajhdar neta hai

    • @chanchaldubey7341
      @chanchaldubey7341 Рік тому

      Aur bhi hai

    • @aviatorbold
      @aviatorbold Рік тому +1

      @@chanchaldubey7341 kaun . Yadav brothers? 😃😃😃

    • @chanchaldubey7341
      @chanchaldubey7341 Рік тому +1

      @@aviatorbold tej Pratap to nhi per tejasvi ke bare me soch sakte hai

    • @aviatorbold
      @aviatorbold Рік тому +3

      @@chanchaldubey7341 10th fail . Wah. Jisse apne bache ko tution nai padhao, usko chief minister banao. Kiske papa ne Bihar ko india sabse pichda rajya bana diya. Thanks to yadav family

    • @chanchaldubey7341
      @chanchaldubey7341 Рік тому

      @@aviatorbold to Bhai isse badiya option kaun hai Bihar me . Mai interview dekh rha tha tejasvi ka . English me de rha tha ndtv pe . Health care ke bare me Bata rha tha

  • @yasheebfaridi2888
    @yasheebfaridi2888 4 місяці тому +7

    He speak facts.

  • @foundingtitan7
    @foundingtitan7 Рік тому +16

    "Holding an opinion and being opinionated are two different things."
    Absolutely True

  • @you_cant_see_me123
    @you_cant_see_me123 Рік тому +50

    Look at her amuck face .. it’s like say whatever you want to say , I’ll do what I want she is supposed to be accountable to the parliament but it seems that she is only interested to be accountable to her party.

    • @vbharat4081
      @vbharat4081 Рік тому +2

      Truth

    • @mlg1279
      @mlg1279 Рік тому

      Isn't every politician like that - starting from Nehru to Mamta?

    • @you_cant_see_me123
      @you_cant_see_me123 Рік тому +1

      @@mlg1279 Two wrongs don’t make a right. Also don’t think your point is true about Nehru there are parliamentary debates where he responded to criticisms rather than ignore them with an arrogant smile.

    • @mlg1279
      @mlg1279 Рік тому +3

      @@you_cant_see_me123
      Nehru did what he wanted - gifted away islands to Myanmar, rejected Oman's offer for Gwadar, weakened Indian Army by not investing enough, lost territory to China and pa-kistan, and the list just goes on.... The FM hasn't committed any blunders, so she doesn't have to answer... The country is still suffering because of Nehru's mistakes

    • @you_cant_see_me123
      @you_cant_see_me123 Рік тому +2

      @@mlg1279 ha ha , we'll have to wait at least for 30 years to have the benefit of hindsight to judge her mistakes. However when you say "she doesn't have to answer" that explains the level of your understanding of a parliamentary democracy :). There are other fallacies in your arguments but It seems you are comfortable in your beliefs and I'd let you be there and end this conversation, God bless.

  • @vbharat4081
    @vbharat4081 Рік тому +5

    Just great see his Debates abd speeches , the genuine questions he asks!

  • @-kf6ql
    @-kf6ql Рік тому +86

    RJD single handedly pushed Bihar into dark age in the 90s.
    He should stop fooling the people of this country.

    • @arpitrox476
      @arpitrox476 Рік тому +18

      Then from past 10+years , RJD IS NOT IN POWER THERE .
      NOW IT BECAME MODERN , DEVELOPED PLACE ?
      THING IS U DON'T have anything to do with development, u cannot see state rule and loved by any lower caste .
      And this is main reason behind UP,BIHAR status ..
      Caste system.
      Change mentality, things will change

    • @badpapi5043
      @badpapi5043 Рік тому

      Read books and reports. Bihar is last in every human index measurement.

    • @Critic224
      @Critic224 Рік тому +1

      Bihar was always a backward state , even before they came to power!
      Hence, stop this false blame game

    • @manasdhodi4649
      @manasdhodi4649 Рік тому +1

      @@Critic224 bihar was the best state of india.. UPSC mai b aa chuka hai ye sawal... read before u say

    • @Critic224
      @Critic224 Рік тому +1

      @@manasdhodi4649
      Boss bihar was a developing state a long time back !
      By the time Lalu etc came to power, the goose of Bihar’s economy was already cooked! Bihari laborers were already leaving the state to earn a living in other states in late 70s and early 80s ….

  • @snpssps
    @snpssps Рік тому +42

    Worst FINANCE MINISTER of INDIA ever

    • @utkarshshrivastava8411
      @utkarshshrivastava8411 Рік тому +2

      And how you can say that she’s the worst?

    • @snpssps
      @snpssps Рік тому +7

      @@utkarshshrivastava8411 data nikal ke dekh andh bhakt

    • @8384uru
      @8384uru Рік тому +5

      @@utkarshshrivastava8411Bro are you living in alternative reality?

    • @utkarshshrivastava8411
      @utkarshshrivastava8411 Рік тому

      @snap your language shows you’re not very well educated and you lack manners. What will the data show? India is performing good in terms of GDP growth despite covid, decreasing economic parity despite covid & that European war. Talking about dollar, it’s getting stronger taking advantage of that European war & other European currencies are getting weaker more or less ₹ is stable. What has she done to be called the worst FM? Just because she’s a woman?

    • @snpssps
      @snpssps Рік тому +6

      @@utkarshshrivastava8411 your education shows how blind your thoughts are

  • @aurthrlang7424
    @aurthrlang7424 Рік тому +6

    When parties got no legitimate issue, they start making an issue, go back in history to find some 'quotes', present it in front of people, thus giving senee to people that they are doing something. And they never forget to bring socialism v/s capitalism in discussion. 😏

  • @AbhishekJaiswal-pw8yu
    @AbhishekJaiswal-pw8yu Рік тому +6

    पता नही भविष्य में ऐसे बुद्धिजीवी नेता होंगे या नहीं , लेकिन हम सौभाग्यशाली हैं जो इनको सुन रहे हैं

  • @himadrib4743
    @himadrib4743 Рік тому +60

    Jha knows none of the corporate houses will invest in his parties jungle raj of Bihar. Hence he wants to stop this government from giving incentives to them.

    • @mdfaraz4665
      @mdfaraz4665 Рік тому +12

      So why Bihar could not get investment during Bjp heaven Raj of Bihar for 5 years . Until u leave a party side you are remote controlled

    • @himadrib4743
      @himadrib4743 Рік тому +10

      @@mdfaraz4665 BJP was a coalition partner. It was JDU government.

    • @SSraii
      @SSraii Рік тому +3

      ​@@himadrib4743exactly

    • @mdfaraz4665
      @mdfaraz4665 Рік тому +5

      @@himadrib4743 So partner in Jungle Raj? Bjp had deputy CM and more seats than Jdu Still only Bjp will make heaven Raj in Bihar

    • @himadrib4743
      @himadrib4743 Рік тому +4

      @@mdfaraz4665 Jungle raj was of Lalu and RJD during early 2000s. JDU and BJP were trying to make it better. But unfortunately politics took over. Now Bihar is having another jungle raj.

  • @itsme_sehaj
    @itsme_sehaj Рік тому

    Every indian should understand and know the real House of India yaha se hum hai !

  • @gampamadhav4401
    @gampamadhav4401 Рік тому +23

    Just saying, don’t want any fights with anyone, while the whole world is going through a financial crisis, a recession and many of the international organisations like meta and Google and Microsoft are already in the process of layoffs, India is the only country which is no where near to a recession, this was said by the world bank and even in this condition we r the most economically developing country, isn’t this bcz of the finance ministry.

    • @sanatansatya1105
      @sanatansatya1105 Рік тому +7

      lol, where do you live ? No layoffs in India ? No price hike in India ?
      i won't blame govt entirely for current economic condition but India too is facing a crisis

    • @gampamadhav4401
      @gampamadhav4401 Рік тому +8

      @@sanatansatya1105 those layoffs r related to the international companies I have mentioned above…and price hikes r happening for multitude of reasons, and I request u to check the report from world bank…

    • @b4bthick
      @b4bthick Рік тому +3

      Looks you are living in foreign. Lot of industries are getting closed :(

    • @gampamadhav4401
      @gampamadhav4401 Рік тому +5

      @@b4bthick nope, I live in India...could u give me source of information so that I can check it..i find no problem In learning new things.

    • @b4bthick
      @b4bthick Рік тому +1

      @@gampamadhav4401 looks you are rich. I am already seeing it. Most of my friends in textile industries were laid off. You look to rich IT guy. Enjoy our misery.

  • @AA-zp1eg
    @AA-zp1eg Рік тому +24

    Till 2014, Bharat was not at all opinionated.
    This quality of this govt should be appreciated.

    • @harveyspecter111
      @harveyspecter111 Рік тому +2

      Kuch bhi. Abhi bhi kaha hai

    • @beekeyesdev2617
      @beekeyesdev2617 Рік тому

      What an ignorant senseless and idiotic comment. AA ! Don't be blindly a Modi Bhakth. Go through the post independent history of India. You can see India as one of the strongly opinionated country in World Political Arena! Even the threatening of US Navy by moving their 7th Naval fleet under the leadership of one of their biggest aircraft carriers to the Indian Ocean in support of Pakistan didn’t STOP Prime Minister Smt.Indira Gandhi from taking strong military action against the Pakistani Army which was doing all sorts of atrocities against the people of the region then known as East Pakistan viplating all the basic human rights! Through that strong military action India defeated the 150,000 strong Pakistani Army in East Pakistan and made them to surrender before Indian Army! All these were done when the huge threat of US in the form of the US Navy's 7th fleet stationed in the Indian Ocean! That was the courage and strength of the highly opinionated Smt.Indira Gandhi, which gave her as a widely respected strong leader among the leaders of the World! That military move stopped the cruelty of the PAKISTANI ARMY against its own people ( East Pakistan was an integral part of Pakistan on the Eastern side of India geographically but it was politically an integral part of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan lying on the west of India. The cruelty against the people of East Pakistan ( Now known as Bangladesh) and the huge inflow of millions of refugees from East Pakistan was also stopped! But India was kind enough to show sympathy towards the 20 million refugees who already crossed the border and were staying in refugee camps, were allowed to continue staying in India if they wanted. That is how the present day Bangladesh was born! All these things happened infront of the America who were then a close ally of Pakistan who were strongly in support of the atrocities they were doing in East Pakistan! All these things happened when the powerful US Navy's 7th Fleet was stationed in Indian Ocean close to our Southern Sea Borders! They were helplessly watching all these events, the surrender of Pakistani Army and the separation of East Pakistan from Pakistan and being declared as a new Nation called Bangladesh, from the Indian Ocean! That was the courage and opinion Smt. Indira Gandhi who was the Prime Minister of India from 1966 to 1984 until she was assassinated in 1984 October 31st ! There are many other examples to point out of highly opiniated leaders ruling India other than Indira Gandhi like Shri Atal Behari Vajpayee who took the decision to conduct our 2nd and 3rd atomic explosion for experimental purposes, inspite of the strong opposition from US. PM Rajeev Gandhi too have taken very strong stan, on India signing the Nuclear NON Proliferation TREATY which US wanted India to sign and put a lot of pressure by threatening to impose sanctions! But Ondia bravely denied and still continues as a non signatory of that Nuclear Non Proliferation Treaty till date! All these brave and highly opinionated leaders ruled India prior to P.M Modi coming into power in 2014 ! There are many many incidents that can be pointed out to show the brave and highly opinionated qualities of other PM's like Nehru, Narasimha Rao and Dr Manmohan Singh who ruled India prior to Modi.So don't spread lies and cover up the great decisions taken by other PM's when India was struggling to stand up as a financially strong country after the 200 plus years of exploitation of our Nation! So don't exaggerate the things about PM Modi by covering up the realities and the facts mixing with lies to boost the image of Modi much larger than what he really is! Stop this nasty propaganda to create a larger than life image of PM Modi even by tarnishing our former Prime Ministers who were Great Leaders who had done great things..!! Jai HIND!🙏🇮🇳🙏

  • @armanshah3851
    @armanshah3851 Рік тому +1

    Why is the opposition criticizing the minster. The Economic policy should be criticized or decisions

  • @startrooper690
    @startrooper690 Рік тому

    We have seen how American capitalism defeated a powerfully country like Russia without even directly fighting. This is the true power of corporate houses.

  • @Indian73641
    @Indian73641 2 місяці тому

    She is the best and most qualified FM India ever had

  • @abhishekjha5827
    @abhishekjha5827 2 місяці тому

    The reference to onion was apt.

  • @Bharatraag
    @Bharatraag Рік тому

    Bahut shandar ❤ !

  • @rama_ayurveda
    @rama_ayurveda Рік тому +12

    Akhir white collar criminal na English sikh he le🤣🤣😂🤣

  • @karunanehru620
    @karunanehru620 Рік тому +4

    i m supporter of bjp but seriously i dont like the work of fm....

    • @subhmaypatra5562
      @subhmaypatra5562 Рік тому +2

      She's one of the best BJP ministers

    • @karunanehru620
      @karunanehru620 Рік тому

      @@subhmaypatra5562 may be but still i dont like her work..... she can do much more for general people of this country but they r not even thinking for giving normal rebate...

    • @subhmaypatra5562
      @subhmaypatra5562 Рік тому

      @@karunanehru620 Her works will yield good results after 5-6 years, not now but, the results will be really good.

    • @karunanehru620
      @karunanehru620 Рік тому +1

      @@subhmaypatra5562 chalo hopeful rehte hai

    • @subhmaypatra5562
      @subhmaypatra5562 Рік тому

      @@karunanehru620 Yes, don't worry. Her works are appreciable.

  • @pankajkishorbharty
    @pankajkishorbharty Рік тому

    Problem is that half of the listeners don't get it

  • @Bitupan_saikia
    @Bitupan_saikia Рік тому

    A great member everyone loves

  • @user-oc2nq5cd2z
    @user-oc2nq5cd2z 4 місяці тому +1

    You lose all credibility when you declare you are an RJD employee.

  • @saurabhtiwari7213
    @saurabhtiwari7213 Рік тому

    Its always a moment of great pleasure to listen Dr. Jha. Such an outstanding personality. Love you sir...

  • @ironmikelover
    @ironmikelover 9 місяців тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @01Ashish
    @01Ashish Рік тому

    Interestingly Hiren Mukherjee was the communist leader who put the proposal to pay homage to Savarkar after his death in 1966.

  • @TheSourDivine
    @TheSourDivine Рік тому +1

    Just another day of Nirmala tai getting humiliated
    Inside she’s like “mera toh itna life kharab ho gaya 😢”

  • @pratikkhobragade2870
    @pratikkhobragade2870 Місяць тому

    Worst Finance minister in the history of India, GSTraman 🤡

  • @tarunrajahlawat3347
    @tarunrajahlawat3347 Рік тому +3

    Manoj jha vaampanthi soch wala hai ye RJD mai kaha ghus gya 🤣🤣👈

    • @garnetgun
      @garnetgun Рік тому +1

      Sab dhanda hai dost.

  • @jayashankar7652
    @jayashankar7652 Місяць тому

    Without peoples elections, Financ minister acts arrogant, inhumane

  • @deepthakkar765
    @deepthakkar765 Рік тому

    Conclusion the current finance minister is a tiger 🐯

  • @ananyasain1241
    @ananyasain1241 Рік тому +2

    That CPI Minister Is From Bengal And Shows How The Line Is Still Relevant Today :-
    "What Bengal Thinks Today India Thinks Tomorrow"
    Even BJP Doesn't Win In Bengal In 2019.

  • @babu3009
    @babu3009 Рік тому

    Playing with words.

  • @purnaparakashpain5578
    @purnaparakashpain5578 11 місяців тому +1

    This gentleman man needs to be promoted as a diplomat.

  • @9chetanshetty
    @9chetanshetty Рік тому

    All the gyaan without any application is of no use !! Such people are called bakchod!!!!

  • @gauravnathan5701
    @gauravnathan5701 Рік тому

    But she dont eat onions, i dont think she got your word

  • @samarjeetdwibedy370
    @samarjeetdwibedy370 Рік тому

    You are only saying this because lalu ji or his sons are getting into powers from whom you get the money , for not roji roti , aishon aaram , gaadi mein ghoomnaa phirna , right .

  • @sangeeta963
    @sangeeta963 Рік тому

    Worst finance minister..no raahat ..even congress wasn't this bad

  • @INDIA0101
    @INDIA0101 8 місяців тому

    Mnoj jha sir

  • @sushrutakar1111
    @sushrutakar1111 Рік тому

    I don't why bengal didn't grow during left rule. They are so intellectual and they think about people still the people of Bengal went through hell during their 35 years reign. If any commie want to comment on this they are most welcome .

  • @theultimateshield5133
    @theultimateshield5133 Рік тому +1

    I know he is from rjd but I still don't believe it 😅

  • @vikrantrathaur_
    @vikrantrathaur_ Рік тому

    These old professor always find a sophisticated way to pitch socialism and target big businesses which generate the most jobs and wealth.

  • @sahil53637
    @sahil53637 Рік тому +1

    150 rupiyaa dega 😂😂😂😂

  • @sarlapurohit1216
    @sarlapurohit1216 Рік тому

    काश, जनता भी मनोझ झा की तरह शिक्षित और जागरूक होती 😊

    • @vinaypurohit1751
      @vinaypurohit1751 Рік тому

      Jo itna samjdar ho ke daswi pass ke under kam karte hai😂

    • @sarlapurohit1216
      @sarlapurohit1216 Рік тому

      @@vinaypurohit1751 अच्छा,मोदी के 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @vinaypurohit1751
      @vinaypurohit1751 Рік тому

      @@sarlapurohit1216 Lalu ji ke tejswi balak ke under😁😁

    • @sarlapurohit1216
      @sarlapurohit1216 Рік тому

      @@vinaypurohit1751 वो सत्ता के लिए हिन्दू-मुसलमान के बीच नफ़रत नहीं फैलाते,जबकि बी जे पी की राजनीति केवल सत्ता के लिए मुसलमानों के खिलाफ नफ़रत से शुरु होकर उसी पर खत्म होती है,अति संकीर्ण विचारधारा

  • @niravveg4581
    @niravveg4581 8 місяців тому

    Mooh ful jata he nirmala kA bat bat pe

  • @tikeshwarpatel3824
    @tikeshwarpatel3824 Рік тому

    Capitalism is the harsh truth of the world. If Mr jha really thinks that socialism or communism will make our country prosperous, then maybe he is too opinionated.

  • @parvadhami980
    @parvadhami980 Рік тому

    Bihar needs corporate to provide jobs

  • @manasdhodi4649
    @manasdhodi4649 Рік тому

    Ye saare headphones lagake kaunsa radio suntey hai... ek dusre ki to suntey nai ye mujhe pata hai

  • @letsgain9002
    @letsgain9002 Рік тому

    seetharaman net worth is more than 10k crore

  • @dharmendrayadavdharmendray6804

    I praud off you manojha sir ❤️🙏

  • @photonring
    @photonring Рік тому

    RJD #LOOTED BIHAR
    ONE FAMILY ALONE MADE BIHAR A BEGGAR STATE

  • @basavarajpattanashetty2792
    @basavarajpattanashetty2792 Рік тому +3

    How can this man make personal judgements

    • @8384uru
      @8384uru Рік тому

      Because she shows her class in the parliament instead of doing her job and acting normal she has ego issues and is arrogant since day 1, unlike other MPs she was not elected by public

    • @basavarajpattanashetty2792
      @basavarajpattanashetty2792 Рік тому

      @@8384uru , entire rajya Sabha is selected not elected , no one can make personal comments no matter what

    • @8384uru
      @8384uru Рік тому

      @@basavarajpattanashetty2792 You get my point. Someone who is not elected is not going to be a people’s person. They’re going to look at it as a job. She may be doing her job but in the process triggers people. She is no doubt the most hated minister in Modi’s cabinet. Followed by Smriti. You won’t hear such thinks about Nitin Ji.

  • @jatinderpalsingh1808
    @jatinderpalsingh1808 Місяць тому

    Smil please

  • @mlg1279
    @mlg1279 Рік тому

    Jha is probably the most verbose and usel-ess MP in the loksabha

  • @undergraduate6050
    @undergraduate6050 10 місяців тому

    Hmm, Professor Jha has red Teeth.

  • @rajdeeppatil664
    @rajdeeppatil664 Рік тому

    हि मंद आहे बाई

  • @Successstory.1000
    @Successstory.1000 11 місяців тому

    Main piyaz lehsun nhi khaati ji

  • @kausermehboob3146
    @kausermehboob3146 Рік тому +3

    So much of arrogance in this lady😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨

  • @mohadevbanik7868
    @mohadevbanik7868 Місяць тому

    Sita nirmola
    No
    Loksoba Mp
    Usko
    Bata jut
    Nir.ola
    Moudi ka garami

  • @gypsykalkini
    @gypsykalkini Рік тому

    Mere ko samaj hi nahi aaya

  • @maheshkanade7600
    @maheshkanade7600 8 місяців тому

    Gussaa control nahi ho raha madam ko

  • @HIMANSHUSINGH-xx6nz
    @HIMANSHUSINGH-xx6nz Рік тому

    Professor sala kahi bhi rahe cite jarur karega 😂

  • @shankarcg786
    @shankarcg786 Рік тому

    Laloo party 🥳 talking about capitalism 🤪

  • @rohsindia
    @rohsindia Рік тому +1

    RJD ka leader declare kardo isey.

  • @rameshdesai9205
    @rameshdesai9205 Рік тому

    જય દ્વારકાધીશ અમને અંગ્રેજી નથી આવડતું

  • @KRISHNA_CHANDRAWANSHI
    @KRISHNA_CHANDRAWANSHI Рік тому

    Hindi me समझना hai

  • @veernair
    @veernair Рік тому

    Budhu

  • @dhananjaypandey185
    @dhananjaypandey185 Рік тому

    इंग्लिश बोलो या फ्रेंच मुख्यमंत्री तो नौवीं fail ही बनेगा

  • @evenirevenir989
    @evenirevenir989 Рік тому

    Isko party ka president toh bana lo😂

  • @rajabjp1
    @rajabjp1 Рік тому

    Bhai khena kaya chathe ho 😂😂 seede seede nahi bol sakte

  • @rajabjp1
    @rajabjp1 Рік тому

    Bhai khena kaya chathe ho