Your City Placement Sucks! | Civ 3 Tutorial

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @crashcoursefilms
    @crashcoursefilms Місяць тому +106

    Instructions unclear - I planted all my cities on whales.

    • @baawbaaw9931
      @baawbaaw9931 Місяць тому

      Must be harvesting land whale plenty of them in America

    • @iiiiiifggffggffgfgfg
      @iiiiiifggffggffgfgfg Місяць тому +3

      I always plant my cities on volanoes.

    • @RDH376
      @RDH376 Місяць тому +6

      The advantage of that is you have geysers that you can build geothermal generators on late game 🐳 Hang on, which game are we playing again....

    • @TheTrolliosis
      @TheTrolliosis Місяць тому +1

      Well now you can rush longbow

  • @Serena_Lunar
    @Serena_Lunar Місяць тому +44

    I’m already subscribed but more tutorials are always appreciated

  • @user-m8k9d
    @user-m8k9d Місяць тому +25

    I'll add a tip:
    if you are unsure whether a tile is adjacent to a river, right click that tile and compare the gold with an identical tile that definitely is next to a river. Especially at the river's spring I find it hard to identify the fresh water spots

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +6

      Very good tip! Sometimes it can be really deceptive.

  • @ImEddy92
    @ImEddy92 Місяць тому +24

    yo Suede! so glad you are still making Civ3 content. i took a long break but just started getting back into it and will eventually achieve my goal of beating the game on all levels lol

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +4

      How far are you now?

    • @ImEddy92
      @ImEddy92 Місяць тому +6

      @suedeciviii7142 emperor I believe. I have a bad habit of starting new games when I start one and go a while without playing it. With 4 kids and other stuff I start new games constantly haha

  • @dallenhaven3329
    @dallenhaven3329 Місяць тому +13

    Thanks for the clarification on how you lose or don’t lose bonuses. I’ve always avoided planting cities on BG, especially my capital, I didn’t know about that so now I won’t worry so much 🎉

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +10

      Same! Being able to plant on BGs opens up a lot of nicer placements (especially on fresh water, where you'll get the shield back sooner)

  • @StanLazaridis
    @StanLazaridis Місяць тому +2

    This is so great. I'm playing Civ3 for 20 years, but I wasn't aware of amny issues mentioned here. Thank you so much!

  • @InfernalLegion84
    @InfernalLegion84 Місяць тому +3

    I love coming back to civ3 from time to time. I stumbled upon this channel like a few months ago and incorporated a lot of tips to my gameplay, especially regarding trading with other civs, how starting civ traits really work and such.
    The way I used to play was like: monarch difficulty, large map, 5 AI opponents, as India for commercial and fast temples = fast area expansion and quick change to democracy and later communism, almost no city overlap, I liked to save on turn one, scout my surroundings to figure out what's going on around and then start playing (I know it's kinda like cheating, I'm not proud of it). Out-research opponents, out-produce them, go to tank -> start amassing -> go to modern armor -> wipe out everyone. Watching yar vids made me realize it was kinda one-dimensional thinking on my part. I still like to play like that tho :p

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +2

      Don't worry about cheating, play how you want to play. And India is a great Civ.
      I'm not sure if you've stumbled across my opinions on oversized maps, but if you haven't, be careful with them. They make the late game slow and grindy, as well as mess up resource distribution. Another viewer sent in a save file where he was the Iroquois, on a massive massive continent with 0 horses. How is he even supposed to get a Golden Age?
      Anyway, if it's working for you, no need to change that! But if you want to mix it up, consider playing the same map against the regular number of opponents. But retire the game until you spawn sufficiently alone.

  • @LemonCake101
    @LemonCake101 Місяць тому +3

    But I don’t like it when the tiles overlap :(

  • @Antmaniacable
    @Antmaniacable Місяць тому +2

    Amazing as always. Please keep these refresh tutorial vids coming, it's good to keep ourselves on our toes thanks to your guidance

  • @Niko_R
    @Niko_R Місяць тому +1

    In my early civ days i extensively used 5-tiles-apart pattern to avoid overlapping and established settler/worker factories in 4 unused tiles between "proper" cities. Struggled a lot early game but at least i had big population due to settlers joining and huge armies of workers, lol.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +1

      Worker/settler factories are hard when dealing with big distance corruption

  • @walruseggtv
    @walruseggtv Місяць тому +4

    the info on getting bonuses once your city is size 7 is really helpful, i didn't know that! i recently one my first serious game on deity by masterminding some island's on an archipelago and now i need to catch up my continents and pangea skills past emperor

  • @kyufuyuvbvbllymjnncuhuhbuh7538
    @kyufuyuvbvbllymjnncuhuhbuh7538 Місяць тому +16

    Suede you made a mistake at 0:38, you forgot to mention that you shouldn't build cities on Fish or Whale either. Do better.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +2

      tenor.com/view/anguish-coolness-kingdom-gif-2596694747614120487

    • @youmukonpaku3168
      @youmukonpaku3168 Місяць тому +2

      if you're able to build a city on fish or whale, you should! The AI is broken and doesn't know how to get a land unit into that city to capture it, so it doesn't need defenders.

  • @MorganJ
    @MorganJ Місяць тому +2

    The land at 4:48 is better in fut, because if I remember right that mod gives more food on irrigated desert, so it makes working the desert tiles by the floodplains viable.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +3

      Drafting would make this better in future, but it's still weak! It can only ever get 11 or so base shields. Planting 1 tile west or NW would be better

  • @Winspur1982
    @Winspur1982 Місяць тому +1

    Oh the cruelty of Civ 3! I love planting cities on bonus food tiles (wheat/corn, oasis, cow) in Civ 2. I get that this is an unearned and very random advantage for some over others, but this is one more example of how Civ 3 is misanthropic, or maybe dystopian (because new cities immediately f*ck up the soil under them, even with zero pollution?)
    Great Venn diagram by the way.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +1

      Yeah, monsoon jungle in Alpha centauri is a favorite of mine for that reason.

  • @histhoryk2648
    @histhoryk2648 23 дні тому +1

    Planting a city on Whales (adn fish to some degree) makes your city impossible to conquer for the long time as ships can't capture cities and only few units can attack from sea tiles

  • @scobeyrowley5115
    @scobeyrowley5115 Місяць тому +1

    Brilliant video. Very clear with good pacing

  • @estrategiaenespanol1329
    @estrategiaenespanol1329 Місяць тому +3

    I need this type of videos for civilization 4 realism mod
    very good video!

    • @russianbear0027
      @russianbear0027 Місяць тому +4

      City placement in RI is very similar to the base game. I think the civilopedia and the RI thread on civfanatics has ri specific stuff. But most base beyond the sword tutorials should be enough to get you started. Food is the most important resource in the early game. So prioritize spots with good food in the first ring

  • @MorganJ
    @MorganJ Місяць тому +2

    Good video, it contained helpful info communicated clearly and concisely.

  • @setokaiba1539
    @setokaiba1539 8 днів тому

    Thanks for helping keep this game alive. I really enjoy it.

  • @michaelbird9148
    @michaelbird9148 Місяць тому +1

    Oh man, I really appreciate your tutorial format. Would love you to crash through some core basics in a modern way for SMAC, given that Vel's guide tends to ramble, reddit comments vary heavily in quality, etc.
    I've never played Civ3, but your channel is peaking my interest in it.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +1

      Even the in-game info for SMAC is lacking! The game will just straight up not tell you important info about, for example, what factions do (Yang's efficiency interaction, the data angels starting with a probe).
      So yes. Right now I'm limited to what I know. But I have an "8 Essential Tips" Style video planned, talking about mistakes players might make.

    • @michaelbird9148
      @michaelbird9148 Місяць тому

      @@suedeciviii7142 Yeah, the game's approach to usability was, "we'll just give them the equation so they can calculate it themselves!"

    • @nathangamble125
      @nathangamble125 Місяць тому

      Piquing, not peaking, I hope.
      If your interest is piqued, it is increasing. If your interest is peaked, it has already reached its maximum and is now decreasing.
      Yes, English is dumb for having homophones with almost exact opposite meaning.

    • @michaelbird9148
      @michaelbird9148 Місяць тому

      @@nathangamble125 Yep - good catch.

  • @wadehilts1215
    @wadehilts1215 Місяць тому +1

    Ven diagram at the beginning was great info!! Thanks suede you're the best

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому

      That would be a great quiz question: "What resource gives at least one bonus food, commerce, and shield?"

  • @Planetdune
    @Planetdune Місяць тому

    I know what you said, I will still NEVER overlap. I want to give my precious cities all the chances in life. :)

    • @Winspur1982
      @Winspur1982 Місяць тому

      When you start on an island that isn't very big but has pretty good resources, as I did in my current civ 2 game, it's almost mandatory to overlap. Once you build harbors you can collect plenty of food from the sea tiles. I get that this hurts folks' OCD; maybe the overlapping just looks more benevolent in civ 2.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +1

      Map size affects it a lot. If you want to plant further apart, play 60% water. On 80% water you'd be crazy not to overlap.

  • @HansLemurson
    @HansLemurson Місяць тому

    I usually like to settle cities at a 3 tile distance from their nearest neighbor so they are all "a day's march" from each other. Makes it very easy to shuffle defenders and military police around as needed. Not all cities are that close to all neighbors, but I like to have a continuous branch of cities all a day's march apart. There generally aren't any problems with tile competition until you build hospitals, but I only build those in a few places where I let a few good cities grow big while their neighbors give up land for their glory.

  • @leobezard5998
    @leobezard5998 Місяць тому

    love this content, it got me back into the game after a long hiatus!

  • @rezaanataj6978
    @rezaanataj6978 Місяць тому

    Awesome video, short and informative
    I didn't even skipped a second
    But we need even more tutorials...
    For one, Can you do a video on each civs traits strategy
    Thanks ❤

  • @Luna-jk5mu
    @Luna-jk5mu Місяць тому +5

    Hey, Suede! Thanks to your guides, I was finally able to win on demigod! I won a game as the Celts (domination) and a game as the Dutch (diplomacy). I'm still struggling to win without good civs and favorable maps, though. I narrowly lost a game as China, and I've gotten destroyed in a couple of games as Babylon. Keeping up in techs is the hardest part for me, especially in the early stages of the game.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +6

      Congrats! Hey, if it's any consolation, based on yesterday's stream, I am also struggling on demigod with weak civ/map

  • @Spoonwood
    @Spoonwood Місяць тому

    Planting on bonus food does have a use, as I learned from EMan. If playing for histographic, sea squares do NOT count towards the domination limit. So, planting on a cow so that you maximize sea squares after cultural expansion can make sense to maximize score.

  • @guest273
    @guest273 Місяць тому +1

    Oh no. I remember a game of CIv 3 I had as kid, where I walked my starting settler over by 1 tile to plant on a hill gold tile... bruh moment right there.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому

      gold = +4 gold on the tile. So depending on how much other commerce you had on that tile, you may very very have got a substantial payoff from the city center.

    • @guest273
      @guest273 Місяць тому

      @@suedeciviii7142 I think it had no river, so probably none. :D

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому

      @@guest273 You still get commerce for hitting 7, 13, for being commercial, for being coastal with seafaring trait, etc

    • @guest273
      @guest273 Місяць тому

      @@suedeciviii7142 What about the capital city commerce bonus? Or did I misunderstand it. I though the Capital city tile gets +4 commerce and overrides all lower yields.
      By the way does anything change if you build a Palace elsewhere and relocate your Capital? Like is the bonus actually tied to your first city or your capital city?

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +1

      @@guest273 tied to your capital

  • @victorianomas89
    @victorianomas89 Місяць тому

    Yes, please make newer tutorials! I want to get back in the game, but there are so many details I miss

  • @jamesgreen5298
    @jamesgreen5298 Місяць тому

    Already subscribed, but I would love to see updated tutorials.

  • @garrettcarver8346
    @garrettcarver8346 Місяць тому

    Unit blocking might be worth a mention, i like to send a few warriors to my nearest ai neighbor to try to prevent their settlers moving toward me. Scouts are even better if you are expansionist

  • @GROller86
    @GROller86 Місяць тому +3

    Love the reference to the Punic wars 😂
    Finally you explained well the agri bonus. You always get 3 food in the city center no matter where you plant. It’s just that the despotism penalty invalidates it until lifted 👍🏻

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +4

      Yes! So note that this effects anarchy too, since in anarchy, you get the despotism penalty. I'm sure I've explained it at some point, but putting it in a short punchy video makes sure everyone sees it.

  • @robertmiller4139
    @robertmiller4139 Місяць тому

    Keep up the great content!

  • @Cygnus__X1
    @Cygnus__X1 Місяць тому +1

    Do you ever build cities further away than adjacent to your furthest city ring in order to secure something strategic, then "fill in" the gap(s) later? i do this sometimes if the land inbetween is really bad and theres an important set of resources to get.

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +5

      Good question! I've seen some saves from newer players where they walk their first settler 9 tiles away! No, don't do that (except maybe on very big maps). You lose a ton of tempo and the new city will be useless due to corruption. Resources are good to get, but if you have a good expansion phase, you can secure the resources militarily later on.

  • @Ducal_Burgundy
    @Ducal_Burgundy 23 дні тому

    More tutorials please , subbed

  • @hairharbor5080
    @hairharbor5080 Місяць тому +1

    Suede is there still a way to play Civ III vanilla or PTW? I'm a bit tired of having to play Conquests all the time.

  • @bunkerhash4569
    @bunkerhash4569 Місяць тому

    I disagree about Allegeny position. Maybe the coastal factor makes it the best choice, and the +1 bonus with no aqueduct are also huge in early game, but if you plant 2 more tiles away in the same direction it is a sacrifice that will worth much more in the longest portion of the game

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому

      On the plains to the southwest would also be viable. Planting off river is not. A 50% boost to growth early game is insane and is worth any lategame penalty.
      It's also not the longest portion of the game. The portion of the game between Allegheny hitting size 13, and the end (or effective end) of the game probably averages under 80 turns.

  • @TheMtb312000
    @TheMtb312000 Місяць тому

    excellent tutorial

  • @jasa_m7990
    @jasa_m7990 Місяць тому +1

    how do you know if a tile of water is freshwater or sea?

  • @R_5_D
    @R_5_D Місяць тому

    *sigh* I haven't played civ 3 in a couple of years... Looks like I'll be back!

  • @theophileburtz1624
    @theophileburtz1624 Місяць тому

    Based playing as France

  • @josipbebek8135
    @josipbebek8135 Місяць тому

    I am having a rough time on deity because of switching to republic can be so hard at times because of unit support and long anarchy times... Even when i have TGL when i get education from others i find myself unable to tech forward. Maybe its map type and they just tech faster on small land area maps?

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому

      How many cities do you have compared to the top AI?
      Do you have all your tiles worked?
      How bad is unit support by the time you get education?

    • @josipbebek8135
      @josipbebek8135 Місяць тому

      @@suedeciviii7142 i get a good amount of cities and can conquer some aswell i get most of worker moves done but cities outside of my core are not big enough in size to support a republic switch and since i dont have to tech while i have TGL i stack up on cata/trebu and swords/horses/knights so i bleed money over the cap

  • @Hellisfear
    @Hellisfear Місяць тому

    Thisnis super super helpful thanks

  • @down__lo7359
    @down__lo7359 Місяць тому

    👌i like the tutorials too

  • @forcelightningcable9639
    @forcelightningcable9639 Місяць тому

    What if I want more tutes but I’m already subbed?

  • @BrockSamson18
    @BrockSamson18 Місяць тому

    Great video!

  • @engelbrekt000
    @engelbrekt000 Місяць тому

    Good Stuff !😄

  • @yevheniido
    @yevheniido Місяць тому

    Thanks!

  • @pablolongobardi7240
    @pablolongobardi7240 14 днів тому

    Damn... Now I have to download civ 3

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  14 днів тому

      If you get it on steam, check out this video
      ua-cam.com/video/Y6qzO_bh-2U/v-deo.html
      For fixing the issues with the steam version of the game
      If you use GOG or pirate it this is less relevant

  • @matiaswasyluk
    @matiaswasyluk Місяць тому

    Hi suede

  • @thewinner7382
    @thewinner7382 Місяць тому

    Why does anyone need a tutorial for the worst Civ game...

    • @suedeciviii7142
      @suedeciviii7142  Місяць тому +2

      Please tell me what your favorite Civ game is so I can give the appropriate clapback