Be realistic. We can't talk about 'Bangsa Malaysia' while racial pay gap, racial selective in employment and race based school still exist. This institutional racism is the most dangerous.
This is why Indonesia will always have problem of malaysia claiming culture. Malaysian politics cannot comprehend cultural differences of a javanese, bugis, minang, or other groups. They claimed all of them (including their different cultural heritage) as ‘malay’. Stop propagating outdated racial classification of ‘Malay race’ and start thinking past ‘racial politics.’ Recognize differences in ‘malay’, Indonesia do not have racial base party, it is possible.
@Mamat Well simple what groups are they according to malaysian government? Im pretty sure there was a malaysian model usinf the kuda kepang ispired costume so somebody wants to wear that and represent malaysia internationally. Why miss grand malaysia do not use chinese or indian costumes too because they represent malaysian no?
@Mamat Im illustrating a point that ‘racial identity’ is formed and defined by the government. ‘malay race’ was created by malaysian government. Its a legacy of british colonialism, and its so pervasive and deeply rooted that even you have this worldview. The nationality is a ‘supra-ethnic’ one based on this ‘malay’ identity. This is of course in opposition to the ‘other’ identity in the form of ‘chinese’ and ‘indian’. Of course it would clash with Indonesian conception of identity, race was almost never used or defined. The ‘ethnic’ identity is more clearly marked. A minang cultural tradition is different than a malay cultural tradition and different than javanese traditions. Etc. USA is also a former colonial society and have a legacy of british racism too though a bit earlier. In particular the creation of ‘white’ identity in opposition to a ‘black’ identity. This is because of slavery history.
@Mamat 1st to be perfectly clear tionghoa is not strictly ‘chinese’, it is a combination of peranakan and totoks. They have their own culture separate from chinese china. Peranakan and totok have different cultures too. 2. Both dayak and tionghoa are self designated identity. Its a formed identity defined by themselves, not by government. They want to be known as such which is not so different with many groups from the 1928 youth pledge meeting. For dayak you should read the history of Oevang Oeray and his efforts. His and I argue Tjilik Riwut too to create a unified dayak identity. For chinese its the effort of Liem Koan Hien and people from the newspaper sin po (here you would also meet abdurrahman Baswedan who create a similar movement in arab-indonesian society). Of course then ethnic parties are banned and they strictly become social associations. Even then they do separate each groups, singkawang is more likely to be hakka(khek is their word). Medanese are more likely to be hokkien. While javanese groups would be very different as most identify as peranakan. Pekanbaru chinese would identify as hainan. Pontianak chinese would identify more as teochew. Even tangerang have separate identity called ‘cina benteng’. Each of them also have their own traditions and wont claim each others as its different. For completenese sake in sub-ethnic level even javanese in Banyuwangi would not claim tradition of reog (barongan in malaysia) as its Ponorogo tradition will always be referred as such. Btw indonesian census do separate each dayak toward their specific tribes too. (If a group of people want to create a separate identity they actually can, This btw happens manytime, betawi, banjar, cirebonese,bantenis) The most recent census includes cirebon as a separate identity which used to be under javanese etc. Earlier, Bantenis also separate frm sundanese. Kutai and Banjar separates themselves from Dayak.
I remembered when i was 11, a 10 year old girl just attacked me because i was iban (note that the iban race is from Kuching, Sarawak and it was in malaysia) when i told her i was not muslim she literally shouted racial slur's like "go eat pig and go to hell!" and then she attempted to assault me and and she missed then, she shouted "go back to your country" when i told her that sarawak is in malaysia and said she's a dumbass for not knowing it she literally screamed to the point where everyone from 6 floor to the floor im in (floor 1) can hear it then, she accused me of sexual harassment with no proof at all. unfortunately because she's a girl everyone believed her thus, making everyone in the neighbourhood hating me and the only person i know that believed me that i was telling the truth was my parent's because they were in the parking lot at the time and could heard her screaming racial slurs from the place im at to the parking lot, and we had to move out from the place i used to live at and forget about it.
The thing with Singapore is everybody use their official language which is English, eventhought majority Singapore is Chinese but they most of the time speak ENGLISHH, Malay Singapore also speak ENGLISH soo everybody basically really live as one country.. same with Chinese that live in Indonesia!! Just use the mother tongue language at home with family, no problem with thatt but sadly in Malaysia, the official language is MALAY, and Chinese doesn't even use the Malay language as often, just use when it needed, if we go dig more and more, it'll be more and more clear of why the racism never ended in Malaysia. It's obvious really. See, most chinese doesn't want to become friend with Malay, and prefer to go to SJK school. Live in majority Chinese neighborhood, create there own only Chinese community very2 often, and speaking about racism, Chinese also very racist to we Indian. How can chinese said they being discriminated while chinese also discriminate others. Chinese also watching they own Chinese TV channel, they don't even know the famous mainstream Malay artist. And Malay also doesn't even know the famous Chinese Malaysian artist since they always perform in Chinese😧like whatt?? Do you ever see something like this in other country?? Did you see what happen there? Imagine an African-American do all those thing in USA, racism might never ended and just go through the roof. Basically Chinese Malaysian lived in another country but in the same land. I hope Chinese realize that they are the one that set themself apart. How can we love each others without knowing each others???
@@jackjackyphantom8854 if u have live in both country you will realized that the Chinese Malay india in Singapore are more engage with each other compare to Malay Chinese in Malaysia that kind of isolated with each others
People forget that malays Chinese fought together against the Japanese occupation and British colonialism.But nowadays people r too dumb to realise n they get instigated by this old ass corrupt politicians
@@bipolargamer99x why do you say that? Many Malaysian Chinese don’t even speak Chinese anymore and have no connections whatsoever to that country. Race based politics is a cancer. I don’t for one think the NEP was a bad thing, but it is no longer appropriate for today. Your mentality is a stain on not just this country but the entire earth.
Not really impossible. Our issue - starts with education. SK, SJK, SMJK ans SMK are all not good environments. It may come as a surprise but students who go to SK/SJK and SMK/SMJK are still pretty racialistic. I compared this to me and my friends who studied in international schools. We did not see race, religion or language as barriers because we all learnt English, Malay, Mandarin and tiny bits of Tamil. And the writing - Traditional Chinese, Tulisan Jawi as well. Once we got to college we could see the SMK/SMJK graduates only wanting to hang out with their own race or religion. While we... didn’t care because we respect each other’s differences and look at our similarities like hobbies, interests... etc.
The feeling is mutual. We also feel that students who go to SJKC are pretty racialistic, not good environment. We could see in university the SJKC graduates only wanting to hang out with their own race. If only these people knows each other & talk to each other since day 1 of school, then we will not be suspicious of each other. Do you know how we can do that?
Americans be like : "we need to protest , as blm to stop racism" Meanwhile Malaysian: " we need to protest , as anti icerd to encourage and maintain institutionalized racism" See the difference.
@@eddied5366 id rather call ourselves as ‘modernized malays’. not in terms of being okay in the modern world but modern’d in terms of the modern day mentality , not some medieval manipulating mindset from ground zero
Logish baskaran, what other so called Americans need to understand is that ANTIFA AND BLM are on our land. Land that doesn't belong to them. They have disrespected us killed us and they say this land belongs to them. No wrong it doesn't belong to them. They have no right to this land not now not ever. They build on our sacred burial grounds and expect us to say nothing about it. We put up with them for too long now it's time they leave. They are not welcome here. So before you go praising pro communist people keep in mind that this land isn't theirs to take.
Mahathir himself as a political leader is harping on race. As long as politicians do that there is no such thing as Malaysian. I think the young and bright Malay politicians who are breaking away from old Malay politicians are the answers to racial discrimination in Malaysia.
What about Lim Kit Siang??? You Chinese are the real problem in Malaysia...No wonder Islamic right wing party is on the rise.. Please emigrate to other countries
Being an Indian I cannot comment much on Malaysia. The fact being we have similar kind of politics and social issues in India as well. Caste based, region based, religion based politics everywhere. But I pray that Malaysia would sort out all it's issues and work on development path. Or else it would be tough in future when rest if the ASEAN countries and running way ahead of you.
But indian much worse no really similar like indian country selling rice with stone derty water u compare our minister we are so far so good just becous we are not supports hindu and india Despise us
I'm born in 1961 and as I can remember those days when I was a teenager there were "NO" racial gap. Ever since May 13, things began to get worse till today and will surely get worst. It's all in the "mindset" of each race of how they want Malaysia to be in the future. Now Malaysia not only have it's existent race but also race from Indonesia, Myanmmar, Nepal, Bangladesh etc.....etc..... It's a "RojaK" country now!
Looking through the comments below, when talking about the concept of 'One Malaysia', the only provoking issue talked about is the 'vernacular' schools - why? How did it affect the unity of the country? Vernacular schools have the same syllabus as the national schools, same aspiration, similar goals that's to produce good citizen to the country. The only difference is, vernacular schools are doing it either in Chinese or Tamil language, only the language is different, so, what's the problem guys? Moreover, I have been a teacher before in national schools and I know how the Chinese and Indian students are treated when come to selection for scholarships, taking part in sponsored competitions, i.e., school debates, sports, etc., One or next to none will be selected even though the Chinese or Indian students fulfil the requirements - open discrimination which still exist but no one question it or talk about? Why? So, what's wrong with the parents sending their children to schools which will see children as children and not as Chinese or Indian? 'One Malaysia' is easily achievable by simply instilling HUMANITY than race or religion! I'm proud to say I've left the ministry because it was against my principle to watch and see students from the minority suffer due to the discrimination, which was disgusting - I have left the country for good! Good luck, Malaysia!!!
It’s sad that when CNA finally speak up about my country’s issues, but no one watches it. Look at the views compared to other videos they posted... Something tells me that it’s not only Malaysia who has these issues.
@Really Don't Care welp they don't openly made it legal to be racist... unlike us. We're literally the number 1 most racist country in South East Asia with statistics going from 50-55% of our population dislikes people from another race.
Yes, i do not believe that we can be united. I face racism everywhere I go nowadays. As a Chinese in Malaysia, it is worrying me. One time when I go buy stuff I was wearing an old t-shirt and old pants a security guard was call in and look at me and ask me a lot of question. recently, I was in Pantai hospital in Ipoh the lady did not allow me to enter due to the app. My hp is overseas hp and the app is not friendly to playstore. And playstore have different country also. I was also was send death thereat after staying overseas for three years due to education and lifestyle. But I save a lot of cash to go overseas. I believe time will tell and Malaysian will be splitting as soon as possible due to this racism issue. it happens to the younger generation. I am worried that the younger generation will just leave the country due to this racism issue and do not have trust in goverment.
@Rxx x If that school is fair and produce good results why not? But comparing the results between government schools and vernacular schools and you will see its far apart. Why would anyone want to send their offsprings to a government school when vernacular schools gives better results?
@Rxx x Sure by all mean remove the vernacular schools but first make goverment schools at least be in par with vernacular school in terms of quality of education and be fair by removing the quota system for entry into Unis. Can the Matlasian government do that?
@Rxx x Sure remove private Unis too if the government can support the local demands for Unis. As for defending those vernacular schools I don't need to infact their results and enrollment defend for themselves. I am just stating the fact why they still exist. If the local governemnt can be fair and up their standard I too would support the removal of those schools. As for helping the Bumis why not help everyone? Do you think helping one member instead of all promotes a race unity?
It's so sad that races are being generalized as rich or poor Privileged or not. Not everyone is rich or poor just because of their race and doesn't act a certain way because of race. Idk why some people can't get that
For the same reason why they feel comfortable invading other people's lands and taking them by force. Strange that no mention of the Mah Meri or other Orang Asli groups are ever mentioned. I guess people still feel that racist behavior is acceptable. I know that most outsiders still see us as inhuman. I don't expect that to ever change. People love to wallow in ignorance. It feels comfortable to the racist hoard.
Di Indonesia dilarang menyinggung SARA, artinya Suku, Agama, Ras dan Antar golongan. Karena pengalaman sejarah 4 hal ini sangat berbahaya jika dibangkitkan. Mengapa malaysia menyimpannya bahkan nekad ras dijadikan ideologi negara ?...ini sungguh tidak masuk akal
Race mean a group of people who share the same genetic and physical features. Obviously there will be no such thing as malaysia race since we all have different genetic and physical features and that is okay because diversity in physical features and culture is what make us unique. The term "race" that we used to divide malaysian is actually about social construct or class status. Malay class refer to Austronesian speaker who are Muslim, Dayak class refer to Austronesian speaker who are not Muslim in Sarawak, orang asli refer to primitive pagan in peninsular, India class for anyone who have ancestor from south Asia, and so on. If a person who are "Malay race" but convert to other religions, he will lose his Malay status class and become raceless. The government decided what race are u, not yourself. This " race " system was created by the British and continue by our government till this day. Instead of fighting on creating one race like what Nazi German try to do before, we should fighting on one Malaysia nationalism which obviously we lack of that. Nationalism is needed for country creation as it unite people from different race, ethnicity, religion etc. U can't have malaysia nationalism when the government still practicing bumiputra privilege and view Chinese, Indian and peranakan as immigrants eventhough some of them have been here for more then 400 years and we can't have malaysia nationalism when we still have secular school that still glorified their ancestors nationalistic and refused to speak national language. Both side need to trust and work with each other. We are far more behind compare to neighbors country on achieving nationalism.
Exactly what I try to explain to other people but they're too caught up with their privileges. I'm Malay btw. I just don't see us treating each other as equals when we don't have equal rights. To me I don't care if you take away our privileges. I want every Malaysian to be treated like everyone else. Not treated via their race.
I tried to do some analysis on the relationship of people in malaysia with data from twitter. Well, the relationship is getting more and more worse. People from different race keep claiming that it's the fault of the other race that cause them to become racist. They claim that it's not their intention to be a racist and yet they are behaving as a racist. This is really chaotic..
Yeah I have to say that Malaysia lacks the sense of unity in a way a certain group of race is enjoying privileges in the most basic need of the people like education. I also find it strange that some of the Chinese Malaysians cannot speak Malay proficiently- which I assume is the national language. Maybe if vernacular schools are closed and more focus is given to using Malay in every aspects of life from homes to businesses, I think it will help promote the expression of the same, united national identity. In Indonesia, there are still divisions between the Chinese and the native Indonesians in terms of wealth but the enforced assimilation policies have made the Chinese see themselves as Indonesians not as Indonesian-Chinese. There is also freedom of religion in Indonesia that allows the Chinese to convert to Islam, or a Javanese to convert to Christianity and I also found that this is not possible in Malaysia. All across Indonesia, all religious processions, books and the media are available in the national language, unlike in Malaysia where I can't even find church services in Malay??? Logically, people are more connected if they can speak the same language.
That is also the root of the culture claim problem malaysian having with indonesians. They just can’t comprehend the problem Indonesians had with their culture claims. Malaysian state do not differentiate a Javanese from a Minang for example both classified as ‘Malay’. As a result Malaysia must claim both cultural traditions of both these groups as cultural heritage of ‘malay’. In Indonesia a Sundanese will never claim cultural traditions of Javanese from the fact they both originated in Java. They can perform them but never claim it as they know they are different groups even though closely related and even on a same island. This is replicated to lower level as well a Javanese from Yogya will never claim Reog dance as his even though both are Javanese. As he knows he is not from Ponorogo.
@@abcddef2112 i think u should read my comment above, i already explain the racial construct in malaysia. in indonesia they dont used the concept of race or social status but they use an ethnicity while in malaysia we use the social status. malaysia claim javanese and minang culture as part of malaysia culture and not part of malay culture and that simply because there are plenty of minang and javanese in malaysia. even the state of negeri sembilan was establish by minang community and the first yang dipertuan agong of malaysia which kinda like the king of king in malaysia is a minang decent from pagaruyung kingdom. btw whats is wrong with a different ethnic group practice culture from different ethnic group ? even indonesia it self practice culture from different counntry like example nasi goreng which originaly from china or the use of ramayana epic used in many folk theater performance that originally from india or the keroncong music that originally from portugese. there no such thing as pure culture. all culture have influence each other.
I am Malaysian Chinese from national school. I don't think Malaysians regardless race is racist. Those racist is just minority. Although I am Malaysian Chinese gotta to admit Chinese were the most racist compared to other race. It is because Chinese like to label others and condemn other people culture. Like Indian like to feed the pigeon and dirty the environment . To all my Malaysian Chinese friends please respect your Indian and malay friends. Every race have their own rights. Don't talk nonsense about China the second largest economy to other race. We are Malaysian Chinese not mainland Chinese nothing to be proud.
It do be like that, you have malays indians and chinese divided by religions and politics And you have malays indians and chinese that kept their political and stuff to themselves only. And then you have malays chinese and indians that are not really interested in politics at all, more neutral and get along just fine
In malaysia, you hang a cross at a shoplot in kl, would definitely be a problem. Like as if there's Vampires around that area that people wants the cross to be taken down. That one thing is still the same in malaysia. So nothing to be proud of being malaysian at the moment. Till the time comes, and everyone starts to think differently and accept other religion and other races, then only I'll be proud. So till then, El oh el.
This is nothing new in a country where where there is one majority race and the others are discriminated.The colonialists brought the other races and the natuves ofc feel its their right to have privelages.racism will always exist.The only reason singapore is not like that is because if we would we would be in conflict 24/7 or attacked by our neighbours
@Rxx x Different areas are just better with different political stand points and their attitudes towards others For example China was in a civil war and had a mix of political standpoints thus a political stand point like communism and nationalistim are needed to unify the country, however as a country develops these political vies become corrupt in their way thus democracy is better over time Singapore has its bad views like the lack of freedom of speech however it was needed then since more were racist and divided as compared to know
@Rxx x lol freedom of speech? You can't even speak about the constitution being bad or you'll get arrested. And you're trying to tell me you have freedom of speech?🤣
Our school system separated us in three groups since we were child... In a democratic country, what outcome do u expect??? Thats why Malaysia politics is weirder than myth
but dap stand for it..they want uec to be regonize in malaysia..that why i dont like dap they make our people disunity.but our chinese poeple fully support that party.politik in malaysia is very hard.
@@full-timeCyberArmy BN is the one who created and approved the vernacular school system at the first place, not DAP... What happen today is the result of this system... It is the biggest mistake that ever made in Malaysia..
Having said that, we’re also need to take into account of special privileges provided for the bumiputra, such as UiTM, MARA and so on. This special privilege also, in one way or another contributes to the racial segregation as well. Nothing against bumiputra, since I am one myself but I do understand non-bumis frustration of being ‘sidelined Malaysian’. Personally, I have nothing against vernacular schools, I have many good friends who was brought up with the system. Granted they are typical DAP supporters and occasionally questioned bumiputra privilege, right for UEC and Muslim country status, but I take it as it is their freedom of expression and we’re still good buddies. My point is, if they have to deal with bumiputra privilege, then I see no reason for us not to tolerate vernacular schools.
A country simply fails when certain citizens are considered more privileged than others. This leads to the sense on entitlement. Hence Singapore with zero natural resources has become a developed country. Malaysia , in 1990 , aimed to be developed by 2020. i doubt they will be developed even by 2200. If Malaysia has a good government, Singapore is really a gone case. No way to compete.
1) Refusing to abolish british's colonial style of divide and rule's policy such as vernacular school. 2) Refusing to use/prioritize national language to communicate. 3) Questioning the constitution itself in the first place that caused all these racisms (which was agreed upon before independence). 4) Refusing to send kids to national school. 5) A political party that divided the people. I don't know, never experience living in malaysia before the year 2000 but many said the country is very peaceful where people respect each other. I know about that bloody 13 may but it was better after that.
The old senile fox has betrayed the rakyat, the future looks bleak for our nation. I can only dream of the day when Malaysia can become whole again, to fight and strive alongside each other regardless of race... If only.
malaysia should learn from indonesia since 1928 we have sumpah pemuda and we all call ourselves bangsa indonesia regardless we are chinese, arab, javanese, sundanese, malay, balinese, until papuan.. we identify ourselves as indonesian. Just because our races might be different each other doesn't mean we're different.
@@topz8196 tak apa 2 lah saya juga pribumi tapi bisa bahasa kantonis dan mandarin, perlu juga bila kita bertemu dgn orang cina atau orang hongkong, biar tidak di bodoh 2hi
Preferential treatment for a specific ethnic group is racist! To achieve a true level playing field you need to abolish all Bumiputera policies and let people complete based on their own merits.
If you don't like the law in Malaysia, feel free to migrate elsewhere, we don't even want u to begin with. It's was the British idea to put Chinese and Indians in Malaysia at the first place.
What a contradictory views portrayed and actual things happen in Malaysia. Before this so called progressive government “PH” took over, the racial tension was not as high as it is currently. People lived harmoniously. The concept of 1Malaysia has somehow unified Malaysian as one. Malay/Muslims rights are honoured and the other races respect each other. Factors contributing disharmony among races in Malaysia lies in the leadership at the highest level. Rivalry of power between cabinet, between internal parties, Islamophobic statements by ministers, slow economy, unqualified minister(a university dropouts in culinary is our defence minister), false promises and many more. Dr Rais Yatim mentioned in the video, to make Satu Bangsa Malaysia, it need to be constituted. Funny when Malays and Muslims constituted rights are being denied, called backwards and racist. The only thing can help to create a truly Bangsa Malaysia fall hugely on education and school system. Malaysia need to stop to maintaining all race majority funded based school and integrate it as one. This is the only solution.
Not really, Malay Singaporeans don't view going back to Malaysia as an option , whereas Chinese and Indian Malaysians would rather Singapore if they could, a lot of them.
Chinese malaysia background is from china mainland, malay malaysia background is from indonesia, india malaysia is background gtom india. Native malaysia is orang asli, jakun, bidayuh
@@zaimjunaydi3131 does every Nusantaran can't make a coherent and logical explanation on how that's not just selfish and just would end up condemning us to endless race based conflicts due to primitive logics. And also, do all of them speak such bad English because if that's so, no wonder the Malays still need that sweet government money. They can't even speak an international more widely used language than a language that is only used in 1 country that's not even bigger than a state in the US or even China. Want Malaysia to advance? Be more open to change. If you can't learn to change, that we might as well abandon this country because it has no future if we keep the idea that "Malaysia is a Malay land" because that completely doesn't makes sense considering this should've been a Nigerian tribal land.
The only unifying language for Malaysia to be truly Malaysian is English as primary language, after that all different races should have a right to their mother tongues as a second language so they do not lose their cultural identities, which are indeed beautiful.
@@muhammada2445 that’s the problem here because people like you won’t accept the truth and facts, don’t keep telling us to go back to China because Malaysia is my COUNTRY! No matter what I will always be a Malaysian but you guys always blame it on other races without hearing our story. Your negligence has led this country to this point where you guys have all the privileges and other religions and races suffer. If we truly want to unite and be stronger, we should put aside all those and be one. Btw, these privileges are the main reason why we hated each other and if you can’t see through this then I don’t have anything to say because you only care about your race and not others which is sickening
look at singapore alot of younger generation dont know how to speak their native language and their english have heavy accent when they travel out of Singapore they made fun off , malaysia is only country where malay languge is offical languge , if malays loss their languge they will loss their identity and culture
How Indonesian overcome such an issue? We do have some racial crisis but is not like as hardcore as in MY.. Satu nusa satu bangsa satu indonesia... The difference? Bahasa Indonesia... that is one Thing for sure that unites Indonesia from east to west... You can say I am melayu, ambonese, papuans, javanese, dayak, chinese or arabs.. but we have one Motto: bhineka tunggal ika. Which means United in Diversity... we are thought in school to learn bahasa Indonesia regardless of races. Yes all of Indonesian should speak Indonesian as official language.. You have dark colour skin and curly hair? You speak west papuan language as your mother tongue? But you speak Indonesian Fluently? Then you're indonesian Chinese or arab ethnics? Love indonesia and acknowledge indonesia as Motherland "Bumi Pertiwi"? Speak Indonesian? Gz you're indonesian There is no Original Bahasa Indonesia to begin with. It came from low malay language / trading language that used as lingua franca in Nusantaran archipelago. But then we knew that only with this strongest weapon that we have, we can kick the colonization out of our islands. Oh and one last thing. Our 5 foundational principles. Pancasila.. just google it im lazy to write it down
@@AngryLesby Malaysia will always have racial problems. If a video is able an argument between say Chinese and Malay, it's going to spark ethnic tension on the comment section. Racial topic is too sensitive to talk about!
As a Malay in economic view what i can tell this is a product of our history during colonial time where they (the penjajah) separates 3 race in a very efficient way for more then hundred of year. where malay at the sawah padi, indian at the estate and chinese in the city. the Malay after independence, all the animosity with other races on the unfair treatment in their own land during the colonial time makes them distrustful of other races and want to be superior. from there born the current policy Malay first. As for the chinese and indian they were left with their own device with minimal support from the government after couple of generations they also start with the racial games Chinese or indian first. fun notes During P Ramlee and Sudirman time there were less racial animosity as this two big malaysian figure promotes race equality in their arts.
i am srry malaysia i love ur county to retire and live but u have alot of problem. As a canadian we don't discriminate race! U can go to any uni if u work HARD and U can get any job if u work HARD. Malaysian - Bumiputera, Malaysian - Chinese, Malaysian - Indian.... that stupid to have such a divide, and that u have quotas on what race can go to uni.... its discrimination, they are all Malaysian. I have money, i can retire and enjoy Malaysian with my Canadian passport coz its a beautiful cheap and great country in ASIA with multicultural. but u should treat every Malaysian with same opportunity. If i have kids there i would wrry how they will get treated as a minority coz of the disadv of being a different race.
One of my dutch friend told me that he married to an malaysian, they have a child and went to the government center to issue a birth certificate. But little does he know that they are forced to pick a religion for the birth cert on a week old baby? His wife said you have to pick even the government worker were also saying you have to pick something, then my friend was like ok then he is athiest and the worker response that was not the choice. So basically the options he have was christian, muslim, buddist and hindu. In his mind his initial thought was that if he pick christian then his child might get religious discriminate since the majority race who choose muslim distrust the christian as bad alternative religion which probably tie back during the british coloinal era hostility, the effect is still going on today becoming legal form of racism. So he decided to pick buddist in the end because it is the closest to athiest religion, when my friend walk out from the office he said that he was not very happy at all no surprised Putting race and religion as first into any politics was a very bad idea and easy form of manipulation to it one big race and ingrained mentality towards the minorities, possibility afraid of their culture and language being wipe off by certain ethnicity. Perhaps malaysia is a good country to retire, but if you're consider having a child then might as well consider next door singapore or austraila which is more international, equal rights education and stronger passport. Not being label as second class citizen elsewhere and give freedom to let your future generations strive
The thing with Singapore is everybody use their official language which is English, eventhought majority Singapore is Chinese but they most of the time speak ENGLISHH, Malay Singapore also speak ENGLISH soo everybody basically really live as one country.. same with Chinese that live in Indonesia!! Just use the mother tongue language at home with family, no problem with thatt but sadly in Malaysia, the official language is MALAY, and Chinese doesn't even use the Malay language as often, just use when it needed, if we go dig more and more, it'll be more and more clear of why the racism never ended in Malaysia. It's obvious really. See, most chinese doesn't want to become friend with Malay, and prefer to go to SJK school. Live in majority Chinese neighborhood, create there own only Chinese community very2 often, and speaking about racism, Chinese also very racist to we Indian. How can chinese said they being discriminated while chinese also discriminate others. Chinese also watching they own Chinese TV channel, they don't even know the famous mainstream Malay artist. And Malay also doesn't even know the famous Chinese Malaysian artist since they always perform in Chinese😧like whatt?? Do you ever see something like this in other country?? Did you see what happen there? Imagine an African-American do all those thing in USA, racism might never ended and just go through the roof. Basically Chinese Malaysian lived in another country but in the same land. I hope Chinese realize that they are the one that set themself apart. How can we love each others without knowing each others???
You think its 'sad' that the official language of Malaysia is Malay? Bro, the Malay Language is the indigenous and national language of Malaysia historically, demographically and socio-economically. The Chinese people in Malaysia jollywell learn Malay and respect the land that they live in. Think about it, there are no Malay people in China and Malays don't complain about it. You're being delusional Mike Tyron. Bahasa Melayu is, was and shall forever be the official language of *Malay*sia.
@@rynrdntion Bahasa is a pointless language that limits Malaysia's progress and continuing to use it is akin to cutting your nose of to spite your face. You can't even use it when you jibber-jabber among yourselves because it's too simple so ends up as manglish because bahasa lacks so many words. Most Chinese understand Bahasa extremely and eavesdrop on everything you say to fain advantage but you're too damned stupid to realise this. Apart from that why would they use it when you Malays are too damned ignorant to learn simple greetings and pleasantries in Chinese? The Malays are a failure because they would rather be racist than successful. You Malays are your own worst enemies and have destroyed all potential Malaysia had at independence while Singapore surged ahead and now rivals Malaysia's GDP despite its tiny size. You know nothing about the history of your own country, only the lies you were taught at your state funded school. The truth is very different and both Indians and Chinese have been in what is now Malaysia since the earliest times and likely before you Malays arrived. Let's not forget that it was once a Hindu country before forced conversion to Islam just as Indonesia was. You Malays just hate everyone, including yourselves. You've even thrown away your own culture in a desire to be little Saudi clones and are now on the brink of sinking into the abyss of conservative Islam. The damage this will do will last for generations at least and, as always, you Malays are to blame.
problems in malaysia chinese politicians fight for chinese language and chinese schools.that why malay dont vote them..their are minority but so arrogant.
@@kentershackle1329 tapi itu Indonesia dulu ketika politik berkuasa, sekarang ni berbeda rakyatlah yang berkuasa. Cina indon dibolehkan berbahasa cina melestarikan budaya mereka, tak ada hukum yang mendiskriminasi etnik lain dan mengistimewakan yang lain, semua sama dalam satu meja identitas nasional Indonesia.
Some people who come back overseas from training are also worried now. I am not surprise some people also receive blackmail and bad messages from their high school friends due to this.
mewujudkan bangsa malaysia memerlukan pengorbanan setiap kaum untuk berkorban mencairkan identiti bangsa masing2 berdasarkan perlembagaan...setiap warganegara WAJIB FASIH berbahasa kebangsaan, bersatu dalam sistem pendidikan kebangsaan tanpa sistem vernakular, taat setia kepada raja2, serta bersedia kehilangan hak2 keistimewaan tertentu...kalau masing2 ego utk majukan atau utamakan bangsa sendiri sahaja, jgn mimpilah nak membentuk bangsa malaysia
Sepatutnya hak bumiputera tu untuk orang melayu yang miskin bukannya untuk orang melayu yang kaya. Lagi satu kena galakkan kaum lain sertai tentera baru adil. Kalau boleh ikut macam Lebanon, presiden christian, perdana menteri Islam. Kalau Malaysia PM melayu, timbalan cina/india.
@@Koric135 hak keistimewaan utk org melayu, asalkan dia melayu dia layak dapat hak tersebut tidak kira kaya atau miskin....melayu dpt hak keistimewaan sebagai ganti kepada pemberian hak warganegara kepada kaum pendatang...hak sebagai warganegara jauh lebih bernilai drpd hak keistimewaan yg diberikan kpd org melayu/bumi
@@Koric135 bab tentera, kerajaan dah buat byk inisiatif utk galakkan kaum lain sertai tentera, malah semasa interview utk jadi tentera, kebarangkalian utk bukan melayu lulus sgt tinggi berbanding melayu sendiri, dan anggota tentera yg bukan melayu lebih senang dinaikkan pangkat berbanding org melayu...soalnya skrg bukan kerajaan tidak galakkan, ia soal kemahuan bangsa2 tertentu itu sendiri sama ada mahu atau tidak utk turut serta
The hard truth is, human are not classified by races, but by social class( wealth, status). Race or religion is only talk about by low class people, the 80% people in the high places doesn’t even care what races are you, they talk about benefits, only children talks about ideology... grow up people.
bangsa Malaysia probably possible if all citizens received the same education… but now pretty hard Liao, got the ultra-nationalist malay or more to “racialist” that want Malaysia to be a Malay only country, the racist kind chinese that dun wanna mix with others, got the indian that keep claiming irrelevant history to provoke the Malays, the East malaysian that keep blaming west malaysian for any problem in the country… it’s possible but no easy task….
Ketuanan melayu and vernacular school is the problem..im a sarawakian.i know coz i went to sjk, i cant cope up with chinese student not because i am stupid, it is because im not born chinese.i hve to learn from the start like 4 years old tries to speak.then slowly learn till i can speak fluently. Plus the syllabus in chinese school is so fast. U leart A they have reach D. You have to work twice as hard as the chinese kids.it’s because my parents want me to know how to speak chinese, then easier to get jobs.. if parent have a mindset like that you know this country is fucked up..can’t even speak malay fluently until i went to smk..2 different system..fucked up again, coz my malay is not very good.. can’t even differentiate between punca and kesan. People laugh at me coz my bahasa is very bad. Teacher calling me idiot.I hate myself, i hate the separation system but i excel in those..im proud of myself till this day..no matter how people keep calling me idiot i can still manage to rise and give them result.to those who have the same experience as me..i feel you..this must stop..equal is a must regardless of your race.
If malaysia refuted to accept ICERD what is the point of a "One Malaysia" vision? A capable government working to improve lives and economy of the country is what matters, not the race or religion of ministers or majority that make up the political party.
Lol in Singapore, Malay as a native Southeast Asian or Muslim can't wear hijab if wanna work as a nurse, police, teacher. This is the joke created by the settler who come to Southeast Asia as a miner!
For many or majority of Malaysians the ideology of Untuk Agama, Bangsa dan Negara comes to mind (meaning for Our Religion, Race and Country) ... since before independence this country is made up of various races, the citizens are multi-religious and speak various languages ... maybe ppl put priority in their own religion or race before the country because in this ideology the country (negara) comes 3rd place after religion and race.
Singapore kept race and religion out of politics, and everyone was equal under the law and everyone prospered. So why treat non-malays as less? The guy in the video said race base policies are required
To say One Malaysian Race is like saying One American Race. There is just no such race as American race or Malaysian race. As long as people respect each other regardless of religious difference or racial difference, then a country or even the world will be peaceful.
the point is to unite malaysian into one kind of people, just like indonesia, they got more ethnicities than us yet still manage to unite under the term "indonesian" and not javanese, malay, papuan, arab, chinese etc...
Bahasa is a pointless language, one that you should keep at home. Converse in English As for Chinese not understanding Bahasa, most do but stay quiet so they hear every word you say. Quite apart from being able to spy on you why should they speak to you in Bahasa when Malays are too f*cking ignorant to even learn basic greetings in Chinese?
Yang india sama cina dkt malaysia boleh berbahasa sendiri2 yg bnyk skli ngn enggris pon melayu, kita ni ckp melayu atau enggris je. Jangan nk besar hindung sangat eh hina diorg sbb x leh ckp melayu. Kebanyakkan org2 melayu sekarang ni pon aq tngk mcm malu eh nk ckp bhs rojak, bhs2 negara lain, bhs barat, kalo nk ckp bhs sendiri? Haram semua malu, astaghfirullahalazim
00:02:05 "...a common identity, which is what is lacking in Malaysia." I think he is right, Malaysia doesn't have a common identity that can unite people from different races or cultures. The root of Malaysian culture is based on Islam which does not go well with multiculturalism. On the other hand, if you look at Singapore, the root of Singaporean culture is multiculturalism itself, so, people have no problem identifying themself as being Singaporean. Or one more example, if you look at Thailand, the Thai culture is based on Buddhism, it is indeed a religion-based culture as same as in Malaysia, but the difference is that Buddhism is a multiculturalism-friendly religion, buddha's teaching is pretty much about being happy, to be kind or being tolerate.
Nah bruh, Chinese all over the world are the same, they are headstrong to assimilate to the native dominant culture. You seem dun read much bout the the truth event for Chinese in Thailand 🇹🇭. They are the results of force assimilation to Thai-Siamese culture,name,school, identity by then PM Phibul Songram which benefits later generations cuz all can be PM, all considered true Thais but here in Malaysia🇲🇾? We got soft and pro-west leader like Tunku who sacrificed Malay island to immigrants brought by the British while the rest immigrants throughout Malaya was accepted ezily as citizens without any proper assimilation for future equality when during that time , Islam isn't strict like today. Tunku's fault, no wonder Mahathir overthrown him
Racism will never go away , it is something people have to live with . Just consider CHINA yet the people who sow discontent are people who WANT to identify themselves differently & they are from CHINA . All those horror stories spread among people in the West derive from them who want to be called Tibetian , oughurs , mongols , Hongkongers , Taiwanese etc . they are the ones who trigger the anti china sentiment around the globe . As for Malaysia , race has played such important role defined by the way of life of each group , culture , religious belief etc .
Malaysia is truly an Apartheid state in 21st century. All those muslims who are accusing Israel of being an apartheid state, should go live and experience in Malaysia as non muslims.
Gary Dé Rothschild Indonesia constitution and law are protecting all indonesian without differentiating their religions, race and colour. All indonesian have same rights in our constitution and law. Well, Malaysia is not, whether it is from the goverment or the society
There are no racial-based politics in Indonesia. It is a big no-no to form political party based on race and unlikely to suceed nationally. Identity politics do exist though primarily with religions. Though technically you can be a malay and of different religion in Indonesia.
It will happen one day only because Malaysia cannot afford to piss off both India and China in a world increasingly imperialism in some form will be more accepted. My guess is it will happen within 50 years. If you study history across the ages, most prominently involving Russia, but also others in the West you will understand the current policies is giving a casus belli for both countries. They are just not strong enough to enforce it. It is possible in a future that Malaysia becomes partitioned after a crisis like Sudan or Syria with great power backing.
Sebab video ni english semua cakap english. Hahaha Komen aku sebagai “Melayu Tanah Melayu”:- Bangsa lain kalau masuk mestilah nak Jus Soli masing2, kalau tak sedar diri datang dari mana memang aku tak tahulah darah mana. Generasi “Melayu” pon tak kenal tanah sendiri, nak pula jenis ‘serah pada pemerintah’, pemerintah pula jenis lembik tak kenal sejarah/kaki tunduk! Ketahuilah, Perjanjian zaman Tunku Abdul Rahman adalah... (maksud kasar disini) Halau balik pendatang ni kalau tak sedar diri dan buat kacau kat Tanah Melayu! Tapi tulah. Pemerintah pon darah bukan Melayu (carilah ye sapa orang tu), nak pula tak penah sebut pasal Islam dalam talk dia!
Bukan salah Cina India kalau diorang lahir sini salah British yang buat ekonomi jurang .... Tugas sekarang kita kena wujudkan balik jaringan perpaduan antara kaum ... membina satu identiti baru di bawah gagasan Malaysia baik Cina baik India baik Melayu baik dusun baik kaum Dayak baik baik iban baik Kadazan dengan kaum lain lain kita semua rakyat Malaysia .. perlu ada visi untuk bina masa depan negara
Im so impressed by malaysia to have this system. Look at other neighboring countries like Thailand and Cambodia where they didn’t do this. All major businesses are now run there by Chinese immigrants and the locals have become second hand citizens in their own country. Go Malaysia.🇲🇾
There is no assimilation like Indonesia or other countries! Vernacular schools (only in Malaysia but NOT in other countries of the world) , they couldn't even speak Bahasa Kebangsaan fluently. (If in the USA or other countries, you wolud b denied citizenship). In employment, Mandarin speaking only n etc! See the problem???
The problem is because they are excluded from so many things because Malays want to reserve all the goodies for themselves, other races have to create their own thing to survive. What do you want? You want to reserve everything for yourself and them to give you everything they work for?
In south asia only Malaysia and myanmar have same problem! Racis by race! Why u don't look by our neighbor? Like Singapure You guys are very similar to Singapore but why can't you be like them? Or Indonesia?Multi-racial and united by their mother tongue, they are proud to speak their mother tongue! Your government has failed to be firm in using your language, even to the Malays! Im from thailands and love malasian
You think racism in south east asia is only at Malaysia and Myanmar? Indonesia probably has some racial divide between Malays and West Papuans and some people from the Philippines don't like Chinese,Bajaus and Many ethnic groups.
depends. do we need to all talk and dress the same? or have a unique diversity specific to Malaysian? Depends whether we end up communist, conservative or liberal
Malaysia will not and never be able to create Bangsa Malaysia (one national race), unless the following are implemented: 1. Malaysia government and citizen of immigrants defendants agrees to close foreign countries language, e.g., Chinese and Tamil school. The school in Malaysia must only be national language schools, no Chinese language or Indian language school. Many other races in Malaysia, Iban, Kadazan, Bajau, Rungus, Kedayan, Bidayuh, Melanau, Siamese, Portuguese, Muruts, doesn’t have their own languages schools. Malaysia and the country got no problem with them and considered Bangsa Malaysia. 2. Local Billboard, Signboards at business premises and advertisements must only written national language and English language as form of communication. Foreign chinese or Tamil language must not be used officially. 3. All Malaysia citizens of immigrants descendant must able to speak National language, similar to Indonesia, Thailand , Filippine. 4. All Malaysian must adhere to National Constitutions. Currently the Chinese and Indian citizens adamant to separate their children from national schools. These people are not sincere and only lip’s service about bangsa Malaysia.
That's more of a supremacy manifesto than an equality one. That's how you know you're not sincere, you're not willing to accept a national race where everyone is equal, you only accept one where you reign supreme. In that case, better everyone goes their own way.
Ketika Indonesia, Singapura dan Brunei sudah membentuk Identitas mereka sendiri..... .... Orang-orang di Malaysia masih sibuk mempermasalahkan identitas mereka Yang tidak jelas! 😆 Sebenarnya sangat konyol kalau negera ini disebut Negeri terbilang kaum!? Sebab Tidak ada One Nationality!
My favourite subject is BM. *Language proficiency = Daily Practice* Unfortunately, most of the resources we're studying/reading/watching/listening/playing after school are dominated by English language today. And most of them (Esp. Malays) are speaking/texting 'bahasa pasar' to sound funny and adorable - difficult for alot of us to practice standard BM and comprehend. So, we can understand and read BM - just lack of good practice.
Hi guys I'm from Singapore and I'm about to move to Malaysia for university next years, I'm Indo Chinese, and I want to ask does malaysia treat other ppl, are they treat everyone equally, or how's the racisms there like RIGHT NOW like, especially ab religion and skin color, how's the condition there..I have so much friends from Malaysia but they said there are NO ANY racism..but I want to know more before I moved to Malaysia, so PLEASE I'll be so thankful of ur answer and respect it. I love Malaysia! ❤️
Malaysia at top 2 most Racist country in the world.. you guess lah but if you still want to study at Malaysia i recommend you find any university in sarawak hahah
Economic division is no longer racial today. Look around you, poor are from every race. It’s time we focused on helping poor people regardless of race.
mahathir's grandfathers were from India and present day Bangladesh. what pure race? there is no such thing. ethnicity is purely linguistics. get with it malaysia. be one with the human race or just stay petty
I dun think we r petty cuz all around world countries got their own problem, India with ethnic and religious tensions, China with Uyghurs and USA Taiwan, Russia with Ukraine. No one care if even Malay masses were to mass genocide or expell non-natives
Impossible as Malaysia sinks into deeply harmful conservative Islam. The Malays hate everyone including their own culture they've thrown away. Malaysia is heading into generations of dark times.
I think the issue is more than sjkc. I went to normal school but there is still race division. Sure we can abolish sjkc and other non national based school but it would cause more racial tension. Instead, we should teach the younger gen to accept each other as Malaysian. How can we become a Malaysian race if there are people still arguing about simple things like Jawi script, religious differences and status?
By abolishing race based school, student will integrate among themselves at young age. After several years, young people no longer see someone based on race but see them as their friends. As malaysian. Then, you can start to give non malay equal opportunity in university entrance and others.
Guna otak please. Even in Indonesia there is still racism even though they don't have vernacular there. The problem doesn't stem from there. It stems from people like you who want to bring everyone else down to your level. It doesn't matter what we do, it matters what you losers do (Google project converting Sabahans to Islam to suit your needs). Hey idiots, the world doesn't need more racist Islamists like you who cannot adapt to the world and need the world to adapt to them. Singapore Malays put you guys to shame.
@@amatsolehin2526 Agreed just abolish the race based school. Let us understand each other better. You can clearly see from above comments that there are those who don't understand how Melayu's think. Thinking that Melayu only want goverment help. Thinking that Melayu wants to convert them. #facepalm #profiling
Nak jadi 1 bangsa malaysia? Semua identiti bangsa yang bukan Melayu harus dibuang. Tak boleh celebrate Chinese New Year. Tak boleh cakap bahasa selain Malay or English. Tak boleh berpakaian traditional China or India. Tak boleh celebrate Thaipusam. Tak boleh namakan anak nama China/India. Nama keluarga Cina/India kena buang. Selagi tak buat benda tu memang tak akan jadi 1 bangsa. So ask your self. Are u willing to do all that? Nak minta belajar tulisan tradisi Jawi pon sampai nak mengamuk gila. Bahasa melayu pon tidak fasih and refuse to use. How to be one?
Be realistic. We can't talk about 'Bangsa Malaysia' while racial pay gap, racial selective in employment and race based school still exist. This institutional racism is the most dangerous.
@@Secretkill12 gay
This is why Indonesia will always have problem of malaysia claiming culture. Malaysian politics cannot comprehend cultural differences of a javanese, bugis, minang, or other groups. They claimed all of them (including their different cultural heritage) as ‘malay’. Stop propagating outdated racial classification of ‘Malay race’ and start thinking past ‘racial politics.’ Recognize differences in ‘malay’, Indonesia do not have racial base party, it is possible.
@Mamat Well simple what groups are they according to malaysian government? Im pretty sure there was a malaysian model usinf the kuda kepang ispired costume so somebody wants to wear that and represent malaysia internationally.
Why miss grand malaysia do not use chinese or indian costumes too because they represent malaysian no?
@Mamat Im illustrating a point that ‘racial identity’ is formed and defined by the government.
‘malay race’ was created by malaysian government. Its a legacy of british colonialism, and its so pervasive and deeply rooted that even you have this worldview. The nationality is a ‘supra-ethnic’ one based on this ‘malay’ identity. This is of course in opposition to the ‘other’ identity in the form of ‘chinese’ and ‘indian’.
Of course it would clash with Indonesian conception of identity, race was almost never used or defined. The ‘ethnic’ identity is more clearly marked. A minang cultural tradition is different than a malay cultural tradition and different than javanese traditions. Etc.
USA is also a former colonial society and have a legacy of british racism too though a bit earlier. In particular the creation of ‘white’ identity in opposition to a ‘black’ identity. This is because of slavery history.
@Mamat 1st to be perfectly clear tionghoa is not strictly ‘chinese’, it is a combination of peranakan and totoks. They have their own culture separate from chinese china. Peranakan and totok have different cultures too.
2. Both dayak and tionghoa are self designated identity. Its a formed identity defined by themselves, not by government. They want to be known as such which is not so different with many groups from the 1928 youth pledge meeting.
For dayak you should read the history of Oevang Oeray and his efforts. His and I argue Tjilik Riwut too to create a unified dayak identity. For chinese its the effort of Liem Koan Hien and people from the newspaper sin po (here you would also meet abdurrahman Baswedan who create a similar movement in arab-indonesian society). Of course then ethnic parties are banned and they strictly become social associations.
Even then they do separate each groups, singkawang is more likely to be hakka(khek is their word). Medanese are more likely to be hokkien. While javanese groups would be very different as most identify as peranakan. Pekanbaru chinese would identify as hainan. Pontianak chinese would identify more as teochew. Even tangerang have separate identity called ‘cina benteng’. Each of them also have their own traditions and wont claim each others as its different.
For completenese sake in sub-ethnic level even javanese in Banyuwangi would not claim tradition of reog (barongan in malaysia) as its Ponorogo tradition will always be referred as such.
Btw indonesian census do separate each dayak toward their specific tribes too. (If a group of people want to create a separate identity they actually can, This btw happens manytime, betawi, banjar, cirebonese,bantenis)
The most recent census includes cirebon as a separate identity which used to be under javanese etc. Earlier, Bantenis also separate frm sundanese. Kutai and Banjar separates themselves from Dayak.
I remembered when i was 11, a 10 year old girl just attacked me because i was iban (note that the iban race is from Kuching, Sarawak and it was in malaysia) when i told her i was not muslim she literally shouted racial slur's like "go eat pig and go to hell!" and then she attempted to assault me and and she missed then, she shouted "go back to your country" when i told her that sarawak is in malaysia and said she's a dumbass for not knowing it she literally screamed to the point where everyone from 6 floor to the floor im in (floor 1) can hear it then, she accused me of sexual harassment with no proof at all. unfortunately because she's a girl everyone believed her thus, making everyone in the neighbourhood hating me and the only person i know that believed me that i was telling the truth was my parent's because they were in the parking lot at the time and could heard her screaming racial slurs from the place im at to the parking lot, and we had to move out from the place i used to live at and forget about it.
I feel sorry for you my friend. 😢
Malaysia is still stuck on the same issue, their official religion believe in tolerance but the government doesn't
congrats to Singapore
The thing with Singapore is everybody use their official language which is English, eventhought majority Singapore is Chinese but they most of the time speak ENGLISHH, Malay Singapore also speak ENGLISH soo everybody basically really live as one country.. same with Chinese that live in Indonesia!!
Just use the mother tongue language at home with family, no problem with thatt
but sadly in Malaysia, the official language is MALAY, and Chinese doesn't even use the Malay language as often, just use when it needed, if we go dig more and more, it'll be more and more clear of why the racism never ended in Malaysia. It's obvious really. See, most chinese doesn't want to become friend with Malay, and prefer to go to SJK school. Live in majority Chinese neighborhood, create there own only Chinese community very2 often, and speaking about racism, Chinese also very racist to we Indian. How can chinese said they being discriminated while chinese also discriminate others. Chinese also watching they own Chinese TV channel, they don't even know the famous mainstream Malay artist. And Malay also doesn't even know the famous Chinese Malaysian artist since they always perform in Chinese😧like whatt?? Do you ever see something like this in other country?? Did you see what happen there? Imagine an African-American do all those thing in USA, racism might never ended and just go through the roof. Basically Chinese Malaysian lived in another country but in the same land. I hope Chinese realize that they are the one that set themself apart. How can we love each others without knowing each others???
@@miketyron7257 Singapore has racial problems too.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 not as much as Malaysian
@@miketyron7257 There are plenty of recorded cases in the public posted on internet.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 if u have live in both country you will realized that the Chinese Malay india in Singapore are more engage with each other compare to Malay Chinese in Malaysia that kind of isolated with each others
I am a Malaysian born and raised, who feels lost in Malaysia because I don’t know if I am truly wanted in my own country.
Malaysia needs Lee Chong Wei
You ultimately belong to China. That's your real country.
People forget that malays Chinese fought together against the Japanese occupation and British colonialism.But nowadays people r too dumb to realise n they get instigated by this old ass corrupt politicians
@@bipolargamer99x why do you say that? Many Malaysian Chinese don’t even speak Chinese anymore and have no connections whatsoever to that country. Race based politics is a cancer. I don’t for one think the NEP was a bad thing, but it is no longer appropriate for today. Your mentality is a stain on not just this country but the entire earth.
@@bipolargamer99x Aperthied in its core
Not really impossible. Our issue - starts with education. SK, SJK, SMJK ans SMK are all not good environments. It may come as a surprise but students who go to SK/SJK and SMK/SMJK are still pretty racialistic.
I compared this to me and my friends who studied in international schools. We did not see race, religion or language as barriers because we all learnt English, Malay, Mandarin and tiny bits of Tamil. And the writing - Traditional Chinese, Tulisan Jawi as well.
Once we got to college we could see the SMK/SMJK graduates only wanting to hang out with their own race or religion. While we... didn’t care because we respect each other’s differences and look at our similarities like hobbies, interests... etc.
The feeling is mutual. We also feel that students who go to SJKC are pretty racialistic, not good environment. We could see in university the SJKC graduates only wanting to hang out with their own race.
If only these people knows each other & talk to each other since day 1 of school, then we will not be suspicious of each other. Do you know how we can do that?
Omg yes ive seen university clubs are based on races. Like?? What the hell?
Well said
@@whaz4056 Racial harmony is just a fairytale. Racial tension is there, it's just that we don't talk about it much.
saya setuju jugak. dari kecik kene bercampur sesama kita. bila ade mcm tu nnti tak biasa nk hang out bersama . semua ikut race sendiri ja.
Americans be like : "we need to protest , as blm to stop racism"
Meanwhile Malaysian: " we need to protest , as anti icerd to encourage and maintain institutionalized racism"
See the difference.
Some malays don’t see that
@@Mrn0body_ only fews opened minded, most are still living in cage control by politicians…
@@eddied5366 id rather call ourselves as ‘modernized malays’. not in terms of being okay in the modern world but modern’d in terms of the modern day mentality , not some medieval manipulating mindset from ground zero
@@alliswell99199 yes bro if there’s more ppl like you , our nation would be a lot better for sure
Logish baskaran, what other so called Americans need to understand is that ANTIFA AND BLM are on our land. Land that doesn't belong to them. They have disrespected us killed us and they say this land belongs to them. No wrong it doesn't belong to them. They have no right to this land not now not ever. They build on our sacred burial grounds and expect us to say nothing about it. We put up with them for too long now it's time they leave. They are not welcome here. So before you go praising pro communist people keep in mind that this land isn't theirs to take.
Mahathir himself as a political leader is harping on race. As long as politicians do that there is no such thing as Malaysian. I think the young and bright Malay politicians who are breaking away from old Malay politicians are the answers to racial discrimination in Malaysia.
Pls never ever believe islamist I don't surprise if tomarrow they say Islam is more important then Malay 😂😂or Malay ethnic race 😂😂😂😂
What about Lim Kit Siang??? You Chinese are the real problem in Malaysia...No wonder Islamic right wing party is on the rise.. Please emigrate to other countries
Being an Indian I cannot comment much on Malaysia. The fact being we have similar kind of politics and social issues in India as well. Caste based, region based, religion based politics everywhere.
But I pray that Malaysia would sort out all it's issues and work on development path. Or else it would be tough in future when rest if the ASEAN countries and running way ahead of you.
Caste based no more to be honest....
Thx, As a malaysian I also pray for you.
But indian much worse no really similar like indian country selling rice with stone derty water u compare our minister we are so far so good just becous we are not supports hindu and india
Despise us
From what i've understood in malaysia Majority are favoured more than minority and In india minority are more favored than the majority.
I'm born in 1961 and as I can remember those days when I was a teenager there were "NO" racial gap. Ever since May 13, things began to get worse till today and will surely get worst. It's all in the "mindset" of each race of how they want Malaysia to be in the future. Now Malaysia not only have it's existent race but also race from Indonesia, Myanmmar, Nepal, Bangladesh etc.....etc..... It's a "RojaK" country now!
Indonesia and Malaysia are same race same physical
@@williamjohn4229😂😂😂😂
Indonesia is not race lol
Looking through the comments below, when talking about the concept of 'One Malaysia', the only provoking issue talked about is the 'vernacular' schools - why? How did it affect the unity of the country? Vernacular schools have the same syllabus as the national schools, same aspiration, similar goals that's to produce good citizen to the country. The only difference is, vernacular schools are doing it either in Chinese or Tamil language, only the language is different, so, what's the problem guys? Moreover, I have been a teacher before in national schools and I know how the Chinese and Indian students are treated when come to selection for scholarships, taking part in sponsored competitions, i.e., school debates, sports, etc., One or next to none will be selected even though the Chinese or Indian students fulfil the requirements - open discrimination which still exist but no one question it or talk about? Why? So, what's wrong with the parents sending their children to schools which will see children as children and not as Chinese or Indian? 'One Malaysia' is easily achievable by simply instilling HUMANITY than race or religion! I'm proud to say I've left the ministry because it was against my principle to watch and see students from the minority suffer due to the discrimination, which was disgusting - I have left the country for good! Good luck, Malaysia!!!
Let them be, they are so special like OKU need to be spoon fed, if not there are scared to compete plain even field
Vernacular school don’t even want to teach Khat.
@@KK-ro7gx teach what?
@@KK-ro7gx ???
im 100% with u and ill leave ASAP
It’s sad that when CNA finally speak up about my country’s issues, but no one watches it. Look at the views compared to other videos they posted...
Something tells me that it’s not only Malaysia who has these issues.
No other country I can think of is a racist as Malaysia.
@@byteme9718 Others are more subtly racist.
@Really Don't Care welp they don't openly made it legal to be racist... unlike us. We're literally the number 1 most racist country in South East Asia with statistics going from 50-55% of our population dislikes people from another race.
@@byteme9718 Israel is more racist...
Yes, i do not believe that we can be united. I face racism everywhere I go nowadays. As a Chinese in Malaysia, it is worrying me. One time when I go buy stuff I was wearing an old t-shirt and old pants a security guard was call in and look at me and ask me a lot of question. recently, I was in Pantai hospital in Ipoh the lady did not allow me to enter due to the app. My hp is overseas hp and the app is not friendly to playstore. And playstore have different country also. I was also was send death thereat after staying overseas for three years due to education and lifestyle. But I save a lot of cash to go overseas. I believe time will tell and Malaysian will be splitting as soon as possible due to this racism issue. it happens to the younger generation. I am worried that the younger generation will just leave the country due to this racism issue and do not have trust in goverment.
How can there be only 1 race when certain members of that race is given educational and housing privileges compare to other members?
How can there be only 1 race if other races refuse to integrate
@Rxx x If that school is fair and produce good results why not? But comparing the results between government schools and vernacular schools and you will see its far apart. Why would anyone want to send their offsprings to a government school when vernacular schools gives better results?
@Rxx x Sure by all mean remove the vernacular schools but first make goverment schools at least be in par with vernacular school in terms of quality of education and be fair by removing the quota system for entry into Unis. Can the Matlasian government do that?
@@jakerayyan So what if other members don't intergrate do they return to Indonesia and India peacefully also?
@Rxx x Sure remove private Unis too if the government can support the local demands for Unis. As for defending those vernacular schools I don't need to infact their results and enrollment defend for themselves. I am just stating the fact why they still exist. If the local governemnt can be fair and up their standard I too would support the removal of those schools. As for helping the Bumis why not help everyone? Do you think helping one member instead of all promotes a race unity?
It's so sad that races are being generalized as rich or poor
Privileged or not. Not everyone is rich or poor just because of their race and doesn't act a certain way because of race. Idk why some people can't get that
For the same reason why they feel comfortable invading other people's lands and taking them by force. Strange that no mention of the Mah Meri or other Orang Asli groups are ever mentioned. I guess people still feel that racist behavior is acceptable. I know that most outsiders still see us as inhuman. I don't expect that to ever change. People love to wallow in ignorance. It feels comfortable to the racist hoard.
Di Indonesia dilarang menyinggung SARA, artinya Suku, Agama, Ras dan Antar golongan. Karena pengalaman sejarah 4 hal ini sangat berbahaya jika dibangkitkan. Mengapa malaysia menyimpannya bahkan nekad ras dijadikan ideologi negara ?...ini sungguh tidak masuk akal
Race mean a group of people who share the same genetic and physical features. Obviously there will be no such thing as malaysia race since we all have different genetic and physical features and that is okay because diversity in physical features and culture is what make us unique. The term "race" that we used to divide malaysian is actually about social construct or class status. Malay class refer to Austronesian speaker who are Muslim, Dayak class refer to Austronesian speaker who are not Muslim in Sarawak, orang asli refer to primitive pagan in peninsular, India class for anyone who have ancestor from south Asia, and so on. If a person who are "Malay race" but convert to other religions, he will lose his Malay status class and become raceless. The government decided what race are u, not yourself. This " race " system was created by the British and continue by our government till this day. Instead of fighting on creating one race like what Nazi German try to do before, we should fighting on one Malaysia nationalism which obviously we lack of that. Nationalism is needed for country creation as it unite people from different race, ethnicity, religion etc. U can't have malaysia nationalism when the government still practicing bumiputra privilege and view Chinese, Indian and peranakan as immigrants eventhough some of them have been here for more then 400 years and we can't have malaysia nationalism when we still have secular school that still glorified their ancestors nationalistic and refused to speak national language. Both side need to trust and work with each other. We are far more behind compare to neighbors country on achieving nationalism.
Exactly what I try to explain to other people but they're too caught up with their privileges. I'm Malay btw. I just don't see us treating each other as equals when we don't have equal rights. To me I don't care if you take away our privileges. I want every Malaysian to be treated like everyone else. Not treated via their race.
I tried to do some analysis on the relationship of people in malaysia with data from twitter. Well, the relationship is getting more and more worse. People from different race keep claiming that it's the fault of the other race that cause them to become racist. They claim that it's not their intention to be a racist and yet they are behaving as a racist. This is really chaotic..
Yeah I have to say that Malaysia lacks the sense of unity in a way a certain group of race is enjoying privileges in the most basic need of the people like education. I also find it strange that some of the Chinese Malaysians cannot speak Malay proficiently- which I assume is the national language. Maybe if vernacular schools are closed and more focus is given to using Malay in every aspects of life from homes to businesses, I think it will help promote the expression of the same, united national identity. In Indonesia, there are still divisions between the Chinese and the native Indonesians in terms of wealth but the enforced assimilation policies have made the Chinese see themselves as Indonesians not as Indonesian-Chinese. There is also freedom of religion in Indonesia that allows the Chinese to convert to Islam, or a Javanese to convert to Christianity and I also found that this is not possible in Malaysia. All across Indonesia, all religious processions, books and the media are available in the national language, unlike in Malaysia where I can't even find church services in Malay??? Logically, people are more connected if they can speak the same language.
That is also the root of the culture claim problem malaysian having with indonesians. They just can’t comprehend the problem Indonesians had with their culture claims. Malaysian state do not differentiate a Javanese from a Minang for example both classified as ‘Malay’. As a result Malaysia must claim both cultural traditions of both these groups as cultural heritage of ‘malay’. In Indonesia a Sundanese will never claim cultural traditions of Javanese from the fact they both originated in Java. They can perform them but never claim it as they know they are different groups even though closely related and even on a same island. This is replicated to lower level as well a Javanese from Yogya will never claim Reog dance as his even though both are Javanese. As he knows he is not from Ponorogo.
@@abcddef2112 i think u should read my comment above, i already explain the racial construct in malaysia. in indonesia they dont used the concept of race or social status but they use an ethnicity while in malaysia we use the social status. malaysia claim javanese and minang culture as part of malaysia culture and not part of malay culture and that simply because there are plenty of minang and javanese in malaysia. even the state of negeri sembilan was establish by minang community and the first yang dipertuan agong of malaysia which kinda like the king of king in malaysia is a minang decent from pagaruyung kingdom. btw whats is wrong with a different ethnic group practice culture from different ethnic group ? even indonesia it self practice culture from different counntry like example nasi goreng which originaly from china or the use of ramayana epic used in many folk theater performance that originally from india or the keroncong music that originally from portugese. there no such thing as pure culture. all culture have influence each other.
I am Malaysian Chinese from national school. I don't think Malaysians regardless race is racist. Those racist is just minority. Although I am Malaysian Chinese gotta to admit Chinese were the most racist compared to other race. It is because Chinese like to label others and condemn other people culture. Like Indian like to feed the pigeon and dirty the environment . To all my Malaysian Chinese friends please respect your Indian and malay friends. Every race have their own rights. Don't talk nonsense about China the second largest economy to other race. We are Malaysian Chinese not mainland Chinese nothing to be proud.
It do be like that, you have malays indians and chinese divided by religions and politics
And you have malays indians and chinese that kept their political and stuff to themselves only.
And then you have malays chinese and indians that are not really interested in politics at all, more neutral and get along just fine
In malaysia, you hang a cross at a shoplot in kl, would definitely be a problem. Like as if there's Vampires around that area that people wants the cross to be taken down. That one thing is still the same in malaysia. So nothing to be proud of being malaysian at the moment. Till the time comes, and everyone starts to think differently and accept other religion and other races, then only I'll be proud. So till then, El oh el.
AHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
Interesting
This is nothing new in a country where where there is one majority race and the others are discriminated.The colonialists brought the other races and the natuves ofc feel its their right to have privelages.racism will always exist.The only reason singapore is not like that is because if we would we would be in conflict 24/7 or attacked by our neighbours
@Rxx x Different areas are just better with different political stand points and their attitudes towards others
For example China was in a civil war and had a mix of political standpoints thus a political stand point like communism and nationalistim are needed to unify the country, however as a country develops these political vies become corrupt in their way thus democracy is better over time
Singapore has its bad views like the lack of freedom of speech however it was needed then since more were racist and divided as compared to know
@Rxx x lol freedom of speech? You can't even speak about the constitution being bad or you'll get arrested. And you're trying to tell me you have freedom of speech?🤣
3:52 "We're in denial if we say we don't need race-based (policies)."
Why???? After so long, why?
I still don't understand... in denial of what🤔 to me they guy was speaking gibberish.
Our school system separated us in three groups since we were child...
In a democratic country, what outcome do u expect???
Thats why Malaysia politics is weirder than myth
but dap stand for it..they want uec to be regonize in malaysia..that why i dont like dap they make our people disunity.but our chinese poeple fully support that party.politik in malaysia is very hard.
dinrus Rusli
That is the problem
Dap is the main reason racism occur but they still like the innocent one!!
@@full-timeCyberArmy
BN is the one who created and approved the vernacular school system at the first place, not DAP...
What happen today is the result of this system...
It is the biggest mistake that ever made in Malaysia..
Having said that, we’re also need to take into account of special privileges provided for the bumiputra, such as UiTM, MARA and so on. This special privilege also, in one way or another contributes to the racial segregation as well. Nothing against bumiputra, since I am one myself but I do understand non-bumis frustration of being ‘sidelined Malaysian’. Personally, I have nothing against vernacular schools, I have many good friends who was brought up with the system. Granted they are typical DAP supporters and occasionally questioned bumiputra privilege, right for UEC and Muslim country status, but I take it as it is their freedom of expression and we’re still good buddies. My point is, if they have to deal with bumiputra privilege, then I see no reason for us not to tolerate vernacular schools.
A country simply fails when certain citizens are considered more privileged than others. This leads to the sense on entitlement. Hence Singapore with zero natural resources has become a developed country. Malaysia , in 1990 , aimed to be developed by 2020. i doubt they will be developed even by 2200. If Malaysia has a good government, Singapore is really a gone case. No way to compete.
1) Refusing to abolish british's colonial style of divide and rule's policy such as vernacular school.
2) Refusing to use/prioritize national language to communicate.
3) Questioning the constitution itself in the first place that caused all these racisms (which was agreed upon before independence).
4) Refusing to send kids to national school.
5) A political party that divided the people.
I don't know, never experience living in malaysia before the year 2000 but many said the country is very peaceful where people respect each other. I know about that bloody 13 may but it was better after that.
I've identified as Malaysian first, Chinese later for years
This left my father disillusioned
The old senile fox has betrayed the rakyat, the future looks bleak for our nation. I can only dream of the day when Malaysia can become whole again, to fight and strive alongside each other regardless of race... If only.
At least we're finally talking about it
malaysia should learn from indonesia since 1928 we have sumpah pemuda and we all call ourselves bangsa indonesia regardless we are chinese, arab, javanese, sundanese, malay, balinese, until papuan.. we identify ourselves as indonesian. Just because our races might be different each other doesn't mean we're different.
Keep the language tho, chinese malaysian are proud to speak chinese
The Chinese here found that they are less Chinese if they dont speak mandarin
@@brubruh8740 but now chinese in Indonesia start learning mandarin language, i know it because i have chinese friend
@@topz8196 tak apa 2 lah saya juga pribumi tapi bisa bahasa kantonis dan mandarin, perlu juga bila kita bertemu dgn orang cina atau orang hongkong, biar tidak di bodoh 2hi
@@kiti7336 hehehe, justru malahan sangat bagus bisa 2/3 bahasa
Preferential treatment for a specific ethnic group is racist! To achieve a true level playing field you need to abolish all Bumiputera policies and let people complete based on their own merits.
Cemburu much eh
If you don't like the law in Malaysia, feel free to migrate elsewhere, we don't even want u to begin with. It's was the British idea to put Chinese and Indians in Malaysia at the first place.
i have 1 muslim, 1 hindu, 1 buddhist friend and i am christian lol
back in primary school at least😭😭
still friends with them tho
What a contradictory views portrayed and actual things happen in Malaysia. Before this so called progressive government “PH” took over, the racial tension was not as high as it is currently. People lived harmoniously. The concept of 1Malaysia has somehow unified Malaysian as one. Malay/Muslims rights are honoured and the other races respect each other. Factors contributing disharmony among races in Malaysia lies in the leadership at the highest level. Rivalry of power between cabinet, between internal parties, Islamophobic statements by ministers, slow economy, unqualified minister(a university dropouts in culinary is our defence minister), false promises and many more. Dr Rais Yatim mentioned in the video, to make Satu Bangsa Malaysia, it need to be constituted. Funny when Malays and Muslims constituted rights are being denied, called backwards and racist. The only thing can help to create a truly Bangsa Malaysia fall hugely on education and school system. Malaysia need to stop to maintaining all race majority funded based school and integrate it as one. This is the only solution.
Brain drain sounds better
How ironic singaporean media posted about this when this country is more worse
indonesia : ☕
Not really, Malay Singaporeans don't view going back to Malaysia as an option , whereas Chinese and Indian Malaysians would rather Singapore if they could, a lot of them.
Vernacular school.. 2nd class citizenship.. Many cannot speak bahasa kebangsaan.. identified as (race)(Malaysian) .. How can into one malaysian?
ho lee fuk ...my opinion?...the clue is in your last name
Chinese malaysia background is from china mainland, malay malaysia background is from indonesia, india malaysia is background gtom india.
Native malaysia is orang asli, jakun, bidayuh
Ajo Ramen funny .. indonesia born 1925 .. before malaysia born 1957 .. this is malay land .. all nusantara is malay land ..
@@zaimjunaydi3131 does every Nusantaran can't make a coherent and logical explanation on how that's not just selfish and just would end up condemning us to endless race based conflicts due to primitive logics. And also, do all of them speak such bad English because if that's so, no wonder the Malays still need that sweet government money. They can't even speak an international more widely used language than a language that is only used in 1 country that's not even bigger than a state in the US or even China.
Want Malaysia to advance? Be more open to change. If you can't learn to change, that we might as well abandon this country because it has no future if we keep the idea that "Malaysia is a Malay land" because that completely doesn't makes sense considering this should've been a Nigerian tribal land.
@@NomadicCreatorMY balik india,balik cina
If this was a Malaysian production, it could've been banned
Malaysia for MALAYs..tak kan melayu hilang daripada bumi-hang tuah
The only unifying language for Malaysia to be truly Malaysian is English as primary language, after that all different races should have a right to their mother tongues as a second language so they do not lose their cultural identities, which are indeed beautiful.
Interesting
Nope bahasa melayu ☺️ this is malaysia not usa ask your fello Chinese to assimilate bcz this is not china thanks
@@muhammada2445 that’s the problem here because people like you won’t accept the truth and facts, don’t keep telling us to go back to China because Malaysia is my COUNTRY! No matter what I will always be a Malaysian but you guys always blame it on other races without hearing our story. Your negligence has led this country to this point where you guys have all the privileges and other religions and races suffer. If we truly want to unite and be stronger, we should put aside all those and be one. Btw, these privileges are the main reason why we hated each other and if you can’t see through this then I don’t have anything to say because you only care about your race and not others which is sickening
Great idea
look at singapore alot of younger generation dont know how to speak their native language and their english have heavy accent when they travel out of Singapore they made fun off , malaysia is only country where malay languge is offical languge , if malays loss their languge they will loss their identity and culture
How Indonesian overcome such an issue? We do have some racial crisis but is not like as hardcore as in MY..
Satu nusa satu bangsa satu indonesia...
The difference?
Bahasa Indonesia... that is one Thing for sure that unites Indonesia from east to west...
You can say I am melayu, ambonese, papuans, javanese, dayak, chinese or arabs.. but we have one Motto: bhineka tunggal ika. Which means United in Diversity... we are thought in school to learn bahasa Indonesia regardless of races. Yes all of Indonesian should speak Indonesian as official language..
You have dark colour skin and curly hair? You speak west papuan language as your mother tongue? But you speak Indonesian Fluently? Then you're indonesian
Chinese or arab ethnics? Love indonesia and acknowledge indonesia as Motherland "Bumi Pertiwi"? Speak Indonesian? Gz you're indonesian
There is no Original Bahasa Indonesia to begin with. It came from low malay language / trading language that used as lingua franca in Nusantaran archipelago. But then we knew that only with this strongest weapon that we have, we can kick the colonization out of our islands.
Oh and one last thing.
Our 5 foundational principles.
Pancasila..
just google it im lazy to write it down
Love 🇮🇱🇮🇱?
Why would I hate it?
Good good 👍👍
@@AngryLesby Malaysia will always have racial problems. If a video is able an argument between say Chinese and Malay, it's going to spark ethnic tension on the comment section. Racial topic is too sensitive to talk about!
@@user-qs2zs2gf9k As an Indonesian, I respect Israelis.
As a Malay in economic view what i can tell this is a product of our history during colonial time where they (the penjajah) separates 3 race in a very efficient way for more then hundred of year. where malay at the sawah padi, indian at the estate and chinese in the city. the Malay after independence, all the animosity with other races on the unfair treatment in their own land during the colonial time makes them distrustful of other races and want to be superior. from there born the current policy Malay first. As for the chinese and indian they were left with their own device with minimal support from the government after couple of generations they also start with the racial games Chinese or indian first. fun notes During P Ramlee and Sudirman time there were less racial animosity as this two big malaysian figure promotes race equality in their arts.
i am srry malaysia i love ur county to retire and live but u have alot of problem. As a canadian we don't discriminate race! U can go to any uni if u work HARD and U can get any job if u work HARD. Malaysian - Bumiputera, Malaysian - Chinese, Malaysian - Indian.... that stupid to have such a divide, and that u have quotas on what race can go to uni.... its discrimination, they are all Malaysian. I have money, i can retire and enjoy Malaysian with my Canadian passport coz its a beautiful cheap and great country in ASIA with multicultural. but u should treat every Malaysian with same opportunity. If i have kids there i would wrry how they will get treated as a minority coz of the disadv of being a different race.
One of my dutch friend told me that he married to an malaysian, they have a child and went to the government center to issue a birth certificate. But little does he know that they are forced to pick a religion for the birth cert on a week old baby? His wife said you have to pick even the government worker were also saying you have to pick something, then my friend was like ok then he is athiest and the worker response that was not the choice. So basically the options he have was christian, muslim, buddist and hindu. In his mind his initial thought was that if he pick christian then his child might get religious discriminate since the majority race who choose muslim distrust the christian as bad alternative religion which probably tie back during the british coloinal era hostility, the effect is still going on today becoming legal form of racism. So he decided to pick buddist in the end because it is the closest to athiest religion, when my friend walk out from the office he said that he was not very happy at all no surprised
Putting race and religion as first into any politics was a very bad idea and easy form of manipulation to it one big race and ingrained mentality towards the minorities, possibility afraid of their culture and language being wipe off by certain ethnicity. Perhaps malaysia is a good country to retire, but if you're consider having a child then might as well consider next door singapore or austraila which is more international, equal rights education and stronger passport. Not being label as second class citizen elsewhere and give freedom to let your future generations strive
The thing with Singapore is everybody use their official language which is English, eventhought majority Singapore is Chinese but they most of the time speak ENGLISHH, Malay Singapore also speak ENGLISH soo everybody basically really live as one country.. same with Chinese that live in Indonesia!!
Just use the mother tongue language at home with family, no problem with thatt
but sadly in Malaysia, the official language is MALAY, and Chinese doesn't even use the Malay language as often, just use when it needed, if we go dig more and more, it'll be more and more clear of why the racism never ended in Malaysia. It's obvious really. See, most chinese doesn't want to become friend with Malay, and prefer to go to SJK school. Live in majority Chinese neighborhood, create there own only Chinese community very2 often, and speaking about racism, Chinese also very racist to we Indian. How can chinese said they being discriminated while chinese also discriminate others. Chinese also watching they own Chinese TV channel, they don't even know the famous mainstream Malay artist. And Malay also doesn't even know the famous Chinese Malaysian artist since they always perform in Chinese😧like whatt?? Do you ever see something like this in other country?? Did you see what happen there? Imagine an African-American do all those thing in USA, racism might never ended and just go through the roof. Basically Chinese Malaysian lived in another country but in the same land. I hope Chinese realize that they are the one that set themself apart. How can we love each others without knowing each others???
You think its 'sad' that the official language of Malaysia is Malay? Bro, the Malay Language is the indigenous and national language of Malaysia historically, demographically and socio-economically. The Chinese people in Malaysia jollywell learn Malay and respect the land that they live in.
Think about it, there are no Malay people in China and Malays don't complain about it. You're being delusional Mike Tyron. Bahasa Melayu is, was and shall forever be the official language of *Malay*sia.
@@rynrdntion Bahasa is a pointless language that limits Malaysia's progress and continuing to use it is akin to cutting your nose of to spite your face. You can't even use it when you jibber-jabber among yourselves because it's too simple so ends up as manglish because bahasa lacks so many words.
Most Chinese understand Bahasa extremely and eavesdrop on everything you say to fain advantage but you're too damned stupid to realise this. Apart from that why would they use it when you Malays are too damned ignorant to learn simple greetings and pleasantries in Chinese? The Malays are a failure because they would rather be racist than successful.
You Malays are your own worst enemies and have destroyed all potential Malaysia had at independence while Singapore surged ahead and now rivals Malaysia's GDP despite its tiny size.
You know nothing about the history of your own country, only the lies you were taught at your state funded school. The truth is very different and both Indians and Chinese have been in what is now Malaysia since the earliest times and likely before you Malays arrived. Let's not forget that it was once a Hindu country before forced conversion to Islam just as Indonesia was.
You Malays just hate everyone, including yourselves. You've even thrown away your own culture in a desire to be little Saudi clones and are now on the brink of sinking into the abyss of conservative Islam. The damage this will do will last for generations at least and, as always, you Malays are to blame.
Chinese became the majority in singapore also because the gov imports them in. Most from Malaysia followed by PRC
@@tokitoyotokitoyo Well, Malays are of no use. All they want to do is sleep and laze around.
@@byteme9718 oh wait, u not from sinkapore? Come here be a PR and see for yourself wumao !
Is there any Chinese Malaysian guy married with Indian Malaysian girl or Melayu Malaysian girl ?
Yes, but only few. Chinese malaysian are married to chinese malaysians. And so are Indian Malaysians
Indonesia memiliki isu yang sama walau tak sehebat Malaysia, nasib baik kita di satukan identitas nasional yang kuat.
problems in malaysia chinese politicians fight for chinese language and chinese schools.that why malay dont vote them..their are minority but so arrogant.
Indonesia udah bantai habiss mampus.. Cina. Hingga rame yg x tau langsung bahasa cina.. mana sama.
@@amiramarfur4922
🤭🤭🤭 teringin gak kann. Tapi x pa laa, agama kita x benarkan camtu. Cuma terkilan, yg tak sedar diri tuh. Menyalak nk sama rata.
@@kentershackle1329 tapi itu Indonesia dulu ketika politik berkuasa, sekarang ni berbeda rakyatlah yang berkuasa. Cina indon dibolehkan berbahasa cina melestarikan budaya mereka, tak ada hukum yang mendiskriminasi etnik lain dan mengistimewakan yang lain, semua sama dalam satu meja identitas nasional Indonesia.
@@editorizal 👍
Some people who come back overseas from training are also worried now. I am not surprise some people also receive blackmail and bad messages from their high school friends due to this.
Good if you are not ready, lets be divided permanently and not collect any money from us.
Come to Thailand. It will be better
mewujudkan bangsa malaysia memerlukan pengorbanan setiap kaum untuk berkorban mencairkan identiti bangsa masing2 berdasarkan perlembagaan...setiap warganegara WAJIB FASIH berbahasa kebangsaan, bersatu dalam sistem pendidikan kebangsaan tanpa sistem vernakular, taat setia kepada raja2, serta bersedia kehilangan hak2 keistimewaan tertentu...kalau masing2 ego utk majukan atau utamakan bangsa sendiri sahaja, jgn mimpilah nak membentuk bangsa malaysia
Sepatutnya hak bumiputera tu untuk orang melayu yang miskin bukannya untuk orang melayu yang kaya. Lagi satu kena galakkan kaum lain sertai tentera baru adil. Kalau boleh ikut macam Lebanon, presiden christian, perdana menteri Islam. Kalau Malaysia PM melayu, timbalan cina/india.
@@Koric135 hak keistimewaan utk org melayu, asalkan dia melayu dia layak dapat hak tersebut tidak kira kaya atau miskin....melayu dpt hak keistimewaan sebagai ganti kepada pemberian hak warganegara kepada kaum pendatang...hak sebagai warganegara jauh lebih bernilai drpd hak keistimewaan yg diberikan kpd org melayu/bumi
@@Koric135 bab tentera, kerajaan dah buat byk inisiatif utk galakkan kaum lain sertai tentera, malah semasa interview utk jadi tentera, kebarangkalian utk bukan melayu lulus sgt tinggi berbanding melayu sendiri, dan anggota tentera yg bukan melayu lebih senang dinaikkan pangkat berbanding org melayu...soalnya skrg bukan kerajaan tidak galakkan, ia soal kemahuan bangsa2 tertentu itu sendiri sama ada mahu atau tidak utk turut serta
@@amiramarfur4922 Tula, dekat sekolah rmc pon semua melayu je, mana ada budak india cina
The hard truth is, human are not classified by races, but by social class( wealth, status). Race or religion is only talk about by low class people, the 80% people in the high places doesn’t even care what races are you, they talk about benefits, only children talks about ideology... grow up people.
LOL back to this problem haven been solve since 1965. Gratz to sg did a better job :)
bangsa Malaysia probably possible if all citizens received the same education… but now pretty hard Liao, got the ultra-nationalist malay or more to “racialist” that want Malaysia to be a Malay only country, the racist kind chinese that dun wanna mix with others, got the indian that keep claiming irrelevant history to provoke the Malays, the East malaysian that keep blaming west malaysian for any problem in the country… it’s possible but no easy task….
Ketuanan melayu and vernacular school is the problem..im a sarawakian.i know coz i went to sjk, i cant cope up with chinese student not because i am stupid, it is because im not born chinese.i hve to learn from the start like 4 years old tries to speak.then slowly learn till i can speak fluently. Plus the syllabus in chinese school is so fast. U leart A they have reach D. You have to work twice as hard as the chinese kids.it’s because my parents want me to know how to speak chinese, then easier to get jobs.. if parent have a mindset like that you know this country is fucked up..can’t even speak malay fluently until i went to smk..2 different system..fucked up again, coz my malay is not very good.. can’t even differentiate between punca and kesan. People laugh at me coz my bahasa is very bad. Teacher calling me idiot.I hate myself, i hate the separation system but i excel in those..im proud of myself till this day..no matter how people keep calling me idiot i can still manage to rise and give them result.to those who have the same experience as me..i feel you..this must stop..equal is a must regardless of your race.
when foreign country make news about malaysian politics
Malaysia will find it difficult to move away from the bumiputera policy. It 's impossible to remove the crutch from the majority community.
If malaysia refuted to accept ICERD what is the point of a "One Malaysia" vision? A capable government working to improve lives and economy of the country is what matters, not the race or religion of ministers or majority that make up the political party.
Nah bro icerd will not be a thing as long the majority of race is against it
Lol in Singapore, Malay as a native Southeast Asian or Muslim can't wear hijab if wanna work as a nurse, police, teacher. This is the joke created by the settler who come to Southeast Asia as a miner!
stop capping. alot of muslims in sg wear the hijab.
It may surprise you that a lot of them actually don't want to wear it.
@@tartartar23 not in gov servants, Singapore racial discrimination is the worst!
@@etas1c It may surprise me if you can just shut up and stop presenting people who wasn't from your own root!
For many or majority of Malaysians the ideology of Untuk Agama, Bangsa dan Negara comes to mind (meaning for Our Religion, Race and Country) ... since before independence this country is made up of various races, the citizens are multi-religious and speak various languages ... maybe ppl put priority in their own religion or race before the country because in this ideology the country (negara) comes 3rd place after religion and race.
Singapore kept race and religion out of politics, and everyone was equal under the law and everyone prospered. So why treat non-malays as less? The guy in the video said race base policies are required
To say One Malaysian Race is like saying One American Race. There is just no such race as American race or Malaysian race. As long as people respect each other regardless of religious difference or racial difference, then a country or even the world will be peaceful.
the point is to unite malaysian into one kind of people, just like indonesia, they got more ethnicities than us yet still manage to unite under the term "indonesian" and not javanese, malay, papuan, arab, chinese etc...
Bruh...even Arabs and Somalis in Malaysia speak better Malay than Chinese and some Indians who stayed here from Merdeka.
Bahasa is a pointless language, one that you should keep at home. Converse in English As for Chinese not understanding Bahasa, most do but stay quiet so they hear every word you say. Quite apart from being able to spy on you why should they speak to you in Bahasa when Malays are too f*cking ignorant to even learn basic greetings in Chinese?
@@byteme9718 >Bahasa is pointless language
Cara untuk mengajak ribut dengan kami orang Indonesia paling cepat
@@irfannurhadisatria2540 But Indonesians are insignificant.
@@byteme9718 comment from a petty huaren pentan who'll get force assimilated once PN overthrow PH again
Yang india sama cina dkt malaysia boleh berbahasa sendiri2 yg bnyk skli ngn enggris pon melayu, kita ni ckp melayu atau enggris je. Jangan nk besar hindung sangat eh hina diorg sbb x leh ckp melayu. Kebanyakkan org2 melayu sekarang ni pon aq tngk mcm malu eh nk ckp bhs rojak, bhs2 negara lain, bhs barat, kalo nk ckp bhs sendiri? Haram semua malu, astaghfirullahalazim
Nothing is fair someone will always play victim
Malaysia boleh 💯
Hannah GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY...GOOD LUCK WITH SEGAMBUT.
YOU MUST WIN...WE NEED EQUALITY
00:02:05 "...a common identity, which is what is lacking in Malaysia."
I think he is right, Malaysia doesn't have a common identity that can unite people from different races or cultures. The root of Malaysian culture is based on Islam which does not go well with multiculturalism. On the other hand, if you look at Singapore, the root of Singaporean culture is multiculturalism itself, so, people have no problem identifying themself as being Singaporean. Or one more example, if you look at Thailand, the Thai culture is based on Buddhism, it is indeed a religion-based culture as same as in Malaysia, but the difference is that Buddhism is a multiculturalism-friendly religion, buddha's teaching is pretty much about being happy, to be kind or being tolerate.
Nah bruh, Chinese all over the world are the same, they are headstrong to assimilate to the native dominant culture. You seem dun read much bout the the truth event for Chinese in Thailand 🇹🇭. They are the results of force assimilation to Thai-Siamese culture,name,school, identity by then PM Phibul Songram which benefits later generations cuz all can be PM, all considered true Thais but here in Malaysia🇲🇾? We got soft and pro-west leader like Tunku who sacrificed Malay island to immigrants brought by the British while the rest immigrants throughout Malaya was accepted ezily as citizens without any proper assimilation for future equality when during that time , Islam isn't strict like today. Tunku's fault, no wonder Mahathir overthrown him
With politicians like Akmal these days.....don't expect Bangsa Malaysia to ever happen......
With The bumiputra policy malaysia is doomed to oblivion!
It's called Malay-sia for a reason.
@@jakerayyan what is 中国人? I don't speak chinese.
Sia comes from Singapore, Sabah & Sarawak
Malaysia is for all races. You can take ur racist mindset back to Indonesia.
@@IceBloodKing let's goooo
@@IceBloodKingcope harder Bumiputera supremacist😂
Racism will never go away , it is something people have to live with . Just consider CHINA yet the people who sow discontent are people who WANT to identify themselves differently & they are from CHINA . All those horror stories spread among people in the West derive from them who want to be called Tibetian , oughurs , mongols , Hongkongers , Taiwanese etc . they are the ones who trigger the anti china sentiment around the globe . As for Malaysia , race has played such important role defined by the way of life of each group , culture , religious belief etc .
Malaysia is truly an Apartheid state in 21st century. All those muslims who are accusing Israel of being an apartheid state, should go live and experience in Malaysia as non muslims.
try indonesia then, they have same problem, same issue
But it's not their government that is the problem. Their people are.
Gael what makes us any different then lol
Gary Dé Rothschild Indonesia constitution and law are protecting all indonesian without differentiating their religions, race and colour. All indonesian have same rights in our constitution and law. Well, Malaysia is not, whether it is from the goverment or the society
There are no racial-based politics in Indonesia. It is a big no-no to form political party based on race and unlikely to suceed nationally. Identity politics do exist though primarily with religions. Though technically you can be a malay and of different religion in Indonesia.
Malaysia worst
Out of reach? Who care about one Malaysian race , nothing better to do ?
It will happen one day only because Malaysia cannot afford to piss off both India and China in a world increasingly imperialism in some form will be more accepted. My guess is it will happen within 50 years. If you study history across the ages, most prominently involving Russia, but also others in the West you will understand the current policies is giving a casus belli for both countries. They are just not strong enough to enforce it.
It is possible in a future that Malaysia becomes partitioned after a crisis like Sudan or Syria with great power backing.
Sebab video ni english semua cakap english. Hahaha
Komen aku sebagai “Melayu Tanah Melayu”:-
Bangsa lain kalau masuk mestilah nak Jus Soli masing2, kalau tak sedar diri datang dari mana memang aku tak tahulah darah mana.
Generasi “Melayu” pon tak kenal tanah sendiri, nak pula jenis ‘serah pada pemerintah’, pemerintah pula jenis lembik tak kenal sejarah/kaki tunduk!
Ketahuilah, Perjanjian zaman Tunku Abdul Rahman adalah... (maksud kasar disini) Halau balik pendatang ni kalau tak sedar diri dan buat kacau kat Tanah Melayu!
Tapi tulah. Pemerintah pon darah bukan Melayu (carilah ye sapa orang tu), nak pula tak penah sebut pasal Islam dalam talk dia!
Bukan salah Cina India kalau diorang lahir sini salah British yang buat ekonomi jurang .... Tugas sekarang kita kena wujudkan balik jaringan perpaduan antara kaum ... membina satu identiti baru di bawah gagasan Malaysia baik Cina baik India baik Melayu baik dusun baik kaum Dayak baik baik iban baik Kadazan dengan kaum lain lain kita semua rakyat Malaysia .. perlu ada visi untuk bina masa depan negara
Racial slur
Im so impressed by malaysia to have this system. Look at other neighboring countries like Thailand and Cambodia where they didn’t do this. All major businesses are now run there by Chinese immigrants and the locals have become second hand citizens in their own country. Go Malaysia.🇲🇾
There is no assimilation like Indonesia or other countries! Vernacular schools (only in Malaysia but NOT in other countries of the world) , they couldn't even speak Bahasa Kebangsaan fluently. (If in the USA or other countries, you wolud b denied citizenship). In employment, Mandarin speaking only n etc!
See the problem???
The problem is because they are excluded from so many things because Malays want to reserve all the goodies for themselves, other races have to create their own thing to survive. What do you want? You want to reserve everything for yourself and them to give you everything they work for?
Most East Asians, South East Asians, And South Asians are different racially and ethnically at least most pure ones
Indians aren't even Asian
No chance at all. Race is a issue to stay. Only the people must change it.
In south asia only Malaysia and myanmar have same problem! Racis by race! Why u don't look by our neighbor? Like Singapure You guys are very similar to Singapore but why can't you be like them? Or Indonesia?Multi-racial and united by their mother tongue, they are proud to speak their mother tongue! Your government has failed to be firm in using your language, even to the Malays! Im from thailands and love malasian
You think racism in south east asia is only at Malaysia and Myanmar? Indonesia probably has some racial divide between Malays and West Papuans and some people from the Philippines don't like Chinese,Bajaus and Many ethnic groups.
I'l say it short here. 1malaysia?? Lets be real. Superficially yes...truly no. Those who know will agree.
depends. do we need to all talk and dress the same? or have a unique diversity specific to Malaysian? Depends whether we end up communist, conservative or liberal
Malaysia will not and never be able to create Bangsa Malaysia (one national race), unless the following are implemented:
1. Malaysia government and citizen of immigrants defendants agrees to close foreign countries language, e.g., Chinese and Tamil school.
The school in Malaysia must only be national language schools, no Chinese language or Indian language school.
Many other races in Malaysia, Iban, Kadazan, Bajau, Rungus, Kedayan, Bidayuh, Melanau, Siamese, Portuguese, Muruts, doesn’t have their own languages schools. Malaysia and the country got no problem with them and considered Bangsa Malaysia.
2. Local Billboard, Signboards at business premises and advertisements must only written national language and English language as form of communication. Foreign chinese or Tamil language must not be used officially.
3. All Malaysia citizens of immigrants descendant must able to speak National language, similar to Indonesia, Thailand , Filippine.
4. All Malaysian must adhere to National Constitutions.
Currently the Chinese and Indian citizens adamant to separate their children from national schools.
These people are not sincere and only lip’s service about bangsa Malaysia.
That's more of a supremacy manifesto than an equality one. That's how you know you're not sincere, you're not willing to accept a national race where everyone is equal, you only accept one where you reign supreme. In that case, better everyone goes their own way.
The Racist baggage Malaysia is still carrying is the Racist Malaysian constitution where the Malays are given special rights!
Ketika Indonesia, Singapura dan Brunei sudah membentuk Identitas mereka sendiri..... ....
Orang-orang di Malaysia masih sibuk mempermasalahkan identitas mereka Yang tidak jelas! 😆
Sebenarnya sangat konyol kalau negera ini disebut Negeri terbilang kaum!? Sebab Tidak ada One Nationality!
There is only one race, The Human Race, I love Malaysia, 👍🏻❤️🙏🏻🇲🇾
How can we become bangsa malaysia if there are Malaysians who cannot speak Malay the national language
My favourite subject is BM.
*Language proficiency = Daily Practice*
Unfortunately, most of the resources we're studying/reading/watching/listening/playing after school are dominated by English language today.
And most of them (Esp. Malays) are speaking/texting 'bahasa pasar' to sound funny and adorable - difficult for alot of us to practice standard BM and comprehend.
So, we can understand and read BM - just lack of good practice.
Hi guys I'm from Singapore and I'm about to move to Malaysia for university next years, I'm Indo Chinese, and I want to ask does malaysia treat other ppl, are they treat everyone equally, or how's the racisms there like RIGHT NOW like, especially ab religion and skin color, how's the condition there..I have so much friends from Malaysia but they said there are NO ANY racism..but I want to know more before I moved to Malaysia, so PLEASE I'll be so thankful of ur answer and respect it. I love Malaysia! ❤️
Malaysia at top 2 most Racist country in the world.. you guess lah but if you still want to study at Malaysia i recommend you find any university in sarawak hahah
@@vnieraden5772 Yeah, thank you for your answer and suggestions!! it helps me a lot! have a great day!
As long as your Muslim and light skinned, your good to go.
Top resis malasia
Sounds like America.
Econimic division is the cause
Economic division is no longer racial today. Look around you, poor are from every race. It’s time we focused on helping poor people regardless of race.
That is a result of one's own achievement
how to make all as malasian if there is still quota system
mahathir's grandfathers were from India and present day Bangladesh. what pure race? there is no such thing. ethnicity is purely linguistics. get with it malaysia. be one with the human race or just stay petty
I dun think we r petty cuz all around world countries got their own problem, India with ethnic and religious tensions, China with Uyghurs and USA Taiwan, Russia with Ukraine. No one care if even Malay masses were to mass genocide or expell non-natives
Tuhan yang Maha Saksama tidak ada ruang dalam negara ini, how long can it last before Tuhan yang Maha Ehsa dan berkuasa tarik nyawa mereka ke neraka.
Malay ko sa inyo amin yung sabbah
lmao
Go learn your untold history.
@Its Caຖssue nope... 😂 😂 😂
Today malay day
Chinese + Indian = Malay?
This is the big issue.
Malaysia is an Apartheid state, practicing Apartheid law. #BhumiPutra.
Kalau perkara ini masih ada dekat Malaysia, memang patut pun rukun negara tak dapat dicapai.
assimilation is the solution
Impossible.Multicultural country.
Impossible as Malaysia sinks into deeply harmful conservative Islam. The Malays hate everyone including their own culture they've thrown away. Malaysia is heading into generations of dark times.
nice music
Rasict this is true
Abolish sjkc, and then we can start talking
I think the issue is more than sjkc. I went to normal school but there is still race division. Sure we can abolish sjkc and other non national based school but it would cause more racial tension. Instead, we should teach the younger gen to accept each other as Malaysian. How can we become a Malaysian race if there are people still arguing about simple things like Jawi script, religious differences and status?
Jaguh kampung... always looking for handout from government...who can’t survive without government help. Useless...
By abolishing race based school, student will integrate among themselves at young age. After several years, young people no longer see someone based on race but see them as their friends. As malaysian. Then, you can start to give non malay equal opportunity in university entrance and others.
Guna otak please. Even in Indonesia there is still racism even though they don't have vernacular there. The problem doesn't stem from there. It stems from people like you who want to bring everyone else down to your level. It doesn't matter what we do, it matters what you losers do (Google project converting Sabahans to Islam to suit your needs). Hey idiots, the world doesn't need more racist Islamists like you who cannot adapt to the world and need the world to adapt to them. Singapore Malays put you guys to shame.
@@amatsolehin2526 Agreed just abolish the race based school. Let us understand each other better. You can clearly see from above comments that there are those who don't understand how Melayu's think. Thinking that Melayu only want goverment help. Thinking that Melayu wants to convert them. #facepalm #profiling
Nak jadi 1 bangsa malaysia? Semua identiti bangsa yang bukan Melayu harus dibuang. Tak boleh celebrate Chinese New Year. Tak boleh cakap bahasa selain Malay or English. Tak boleh berpakaian traditional China or India. Tak boleh celebrate Thaipusam. Tak boleh namakan anak nama China/India. Nama keluarga Cina/India kena buang. Selagi tak buat benda tu memang tak akan jadi 1 bangsa. So ask your self. Are u willing to do all that? Nak minta belajar tulisan tradisi Jawi pon sampai nak mengamuk gila. Bahasa melayu pon tidak fasih and refuse to use. How to be one?
Pedih2... 😅 Tp tu realiti..
Alam Malaya just a dream lmao
Hehehehehehehe
Madey tak rasis ke?