A Wedding Filmmaker's Review Of The Zhiyun Crane 2S (vs DJI RS2)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 лип 2024
- 🎵 Signup for Artlist (& get 2 months extra FREE): whoismatt.com/artlistmusic
The Zhiyun Crane 2S is the successor to the very popular Crane 2! But how does it compare to the competition, especially the DJI RS2? Here is my review of the Zhiyun Crane 2S for wedding filmmakers!
Buy the Zhiyun Crane 2S at Amazon: amzn.to/3oEw0td
Buy the Zhiyun Crane 2S at B&H: bhpho.to/3n6lhHK
Buy the DJI RS2 at Amazon: amzn.to/2VXU4et
Buy the DJI RS2 at B&H: bhpho.to/33YAALt
Buy the DJI RS2 at DJI: geni.us/djirs2gimbal
Dan Watson's Crane 2S Review: • Zhiyun Crane 2S Gimbal...
Momentum Production's Crane 2S Roll Motor Mod: • Crane 2S Gimbal Rear R...
►► Get my FREE guide to book more wedding film clients: get.whoismatt.com/bookmorewed...
Color Graded with WhoisMatt LUTs: whoismatt.com/luts
👰 Learn #weddingfilmmaking: courses.whoismatt.com/
✌ Join the discussion in my Facebook Group: learnweddingfilmmaking.co/
❗ Favorite Wedding Filmmaking Gear: kit.com/whoismatt
INSANE lowlight main camera on Amazon: amzn.to/35v99IJ
My favorite wide-angle lens with AF on Amazon: amzn.to/3kGHfA1
Ultra-versatile medium lens with AF on Amazon: amzn.to/3dWHJ2n
GORGEOUS tight lens with AF on Amazon: amzn.to/3kt22H9
Best drone ever on Amazon: amzn.to/2V2XSch
Filters for the best drone ever on Amazon: amzn.to/2YB44uf
BEEFY electronic gimbal on Amazon: amzn.to/3mrzHBD
Fantastic video monopod on Amazon: amzn.to/2TKTdKu
Ridiculously tiny audio recorder and mic on Amazon: amzn.to/2I0gQMM
Prism for fancy in-camera effects on Amazon: amzn.to/2HMI5v0
FAST & Affordable video editing laptop on Amazon: amzn.to/2HpnZIU
Light & sturdy travel tripod on Amazon: amzn.to/2HNDw3L
Portable LED Lighting Kit on Amazon: amzn.to/3opa6e5
⏱ EDIT FASTER! I use Archaius Creative to help edit my videos & they want to help you too!: www.archaiuscreative.com/whoi... (Get 10% off your first editing project when you use this link)
😉My Instagram: / whoismatt
0:00 Intro
0:41 Who is the Crane 2S for?
2:00 Why I Prefer This Form Factor
3:08 Crane 2S Improvements Over The Crane 2
8:43 Where Zhiyun Missed The Mark With This Gimbal
14:55 Is the DJI RS2 Worth It Over The Crane 2S?
16:40 Who Should Buy The Crane 2S?
17:31 Why Artlist is AWESOME
I’m required to state that I'm a part of affiliate programs for Amazon, B&H, ArtList, Google, & Adobe & that some of the links above are affiliate links. - Наука та технологія
Just wanted to say how much your videos have helped me! Thank you for making these. You make every this so clear!
Merry (almost) Christmas y'all!
Watching from philippines🇵🇭
Been waiting for your video about it, thanks Matt!
Would you please make review video for DJI RSC 2 which is for mirrorless cameras
I wish this gimbal was around when I was purchasing my weebil S. Love the form factor of these gimbals!
Thanks for all the content you create! Decided to make a youtube channel this year because of inspiration from creators like you! Appreciate it! 🙏🏽
This is the best review of this gimbal on youtube. No BS, real-world experience, and honesty. I was stuck between this and the RS2 and I know which one I am going with now.
which one are you going with?
@@davidvalens3337 Crane 2S. Can't justify the extra spend when I use it on 1/5 shoots for my business and can honestly get the same results.
I was thinking about upgrading from crane 2, thanks Matt 👍🏻
Rocking it man! I promise you will do that back arm mod and be like...oh, that was crazy easy lol. You put computers together from scratch...I have faith in you! Or maybe I'll come over and you can build my custom pc and I'll mod your crane hahaha
Matt I have the Weebil-S but it always seems like it's underpowered for my BMPCC 6K and because of the form factor and distribution of weight I have to use a counterweight 🙄. Your review was really helpful for considering upgrading to this gimbal and the price seems right.
Same issue with my A7siii. WeebilS was perfect for my GH5s, but the lenses for the sony are so much heavier. This seems like the best choice though!
😱
very good as always!
Helpful video as always👍🏻👍🏻
Thanks Abdul!
Thanks for the information 👍
I did the modification and it was a game changer. Super easy to do. Highly recommended.
Nice review Matt
Where is your Glidecam Matt ? 😄 Great video and advices as usual 👍🧔🏻
Hey, just some food for thought. One reason you would want a heavier gimbal is that heavier equipment bounces around less. You'll get smoother footage in more extreme situations than with a lighter set up! It takes more force to move something heavy. It helps balance the fact you're holding on average, a lighter DSLR.
Plus, you get a better workout 😜
Great review Matt 👍🏻 I am searching for a gimbal for my new fx6 and do not know whether the crane 2s or 3s is the perfect gimbal 🤔 best cinematic greetings from germany
What gimbal do you recommend for a sony a7III to make weddings and documentaries? Thaks
Good review, this thing is definitely too heavy for me to carry all day at a wedding. Really, my aircross 2 has every feature I want so I'm not shopping for a new gimbal, but it's a bummer to see the companies go away from the features we want.
What do you think the best gimbal setup for black magic pocket. I have a ronin s right now and it’s super difficult to balance. I have a side plate and weights but it is seriously tough to get balanced. What are your thought for a easier gimbal for the bmpcc
Thank you for the honest review Matt! In all honesty, the Zhiyun crowd will still buy the Crane 2S, so I know that even a critical review won't hurt their sales:) BTW, I think my youth pastor gets his beard jokes from the same place you do.
Thanks for the great in-depth review. I mostly use a 6400 for UA-cam videos and vlogs, and I'll look for another gimbal, that's less bulky and is easier to transport.
My Zhiyun Crane 2s is for sale!. I live in Belgium. Great review!
Still for sale?
Nice review 👍👍👍 love from Bangladesh ❤️❤️❤️
I can't believe how heavy this thing is. IMO, that's the #1 dealbreaker over the Ronin.
Fantastic review! I’ll be loving my original ronin s. I haven’t seen a big advancement in gimbals just yet
That's what I thought until I bought the RS2. It's so much better I wouldn't think twice about doing it again. Still have the original ronin a laying around but it just collects dust
@@stevenuseda6317 I agree with what Steven said Cory. I also had the original Ronin S until recently picking up the RS2. So many improvements over the S that after using for the 2nd shoot, I knew I wouldn’t be going back to the S and sold it. It’s worth trying for sure.
The follow focus is so nice to have though. I have a moza air 2 and that's one of my favorite things about it. This gimbal seems really similar to the air 2, looks good though, except the weight thing is definitely weird.
You mention that the Crane uses the Manfrotto quick release plate and that it's great for switching to your tripods. I really want to be able to switch between Crane and tripod fast and easy, but havent purchased any new tripod yet, because I fear it's not gonna match with the Crane 2 plate. Any suggestions for tripods? Does 'all' Manfrottos match the Crane 2 plate? Btw huge fan, you've helped me so much especially with export and Premiere in general. Cheers.
Hi matt this nice video comparison
Im using weebil s now
But its not stable like what i expected
I want to buy a old crane 2 again
What do you think?
Are crane 2 is much stable than than weebils?
Thanks =)
Just dropped on here to say I bought the Ronin SC2 - expecting it to arrive next week. I think that thing does all I need. However I think you should lower the arm and try this gimbal with the extra double arm grip - I think using two arms will distribute the weight very well. I saw a wedding guy who already had a crane 2S but then went and bought a Ronin SC2 with his own money and was like - wow - that makes no sense. So I think you are correct - i.e. the weight is a big issue. Also a lot of people are freaking out about the conversion - so I think they should have shipped it at the low angle and advertised that it could be extended...
Thanks anyway - Great video.
Worse thing for me about this gimbal is how the removable plate always covered my battery door... which makes taking your camera on and off the gimbal quickly without having to rebalance pretty useless if you had to simply change a battery...I now have the dji rs2
Hey Matt quick question. On some cameras the mini hdmi is located on the right side of the camera. Is there enough room on the right side of the crane for clearance of a mini hdmi, in case you had a little monitor you wanted to attach to it?
Content creators should consider this one too for vertical gimbal!
Have you tried using an a7 camera with the vertical (battery) grip on this gimbal and how did it work?
Do you know if the stabilization provided by the Sony A&sii including the IBIS and Active Stabilization is additive to the stabilization provided by gimbals like the DJI RSC2 or RS2 ? Thank you.
Hi,Matt
how do you mix dialogue, wedding sound effects.
Love this guy's reviews. However, I think this one is a bit unfair as I don't think this gimbal is meant for weddings at all. Not if you're planning to gimbal most of the day. Wedding shooters travel pretty light usually (I did) and therefore the less powerful gimbals are fine. Would have loved to know Matt's thoughts on using this for a commercial shoot where you only need to use it a few times....
I have watched it to the end and I feel - Blaaahhhh.... That is a perfect expression of how I feel at the end of this video....I think I am just going to buy the Ronin-S as all the things I thought about do not seem to matter. Especially that thing that allows you to put the gimbal on the floor and it just locks on and follows you...
You forgot the RSC2! Just bought the RS2, it's coming in tomorrow!
What do you suggest as a bag for a wedding shoot?
The weight on top of the handle size is a deal killer for me.
Hi Matt, I am about to purchase your luts, do you have discount coupon code? I love your content, they are very helpful. I am a newbie for premier pro, film editing and social media posting. When I have come acrossed with some problems, guess who I turn to? YOUR CHANNEL! Keep great works coming.
Hi matt , please im coming from the DJI rs2 and im a cinematographer and a music video director but my dji rs2 stopped working and its now quiet expensive to buy again for me presently , do you think the zhiyun crane 2s is a good option for me to usenfor music videos
Realize this is a year later but right now B&H has it for $349. That makes it worth it in my book. Bought one.
I heard something interesting you said...tightening the tripod legs? curious how you did that since the screw is so lodged and blocked? I need to tighten one of the legs, it is lose. what tool did you use? thank you
Allen wrench
I use ronin sc + sony a6500 slightly rigged with follow focus(that I use to zoom), zhiyun dual grip handle, and external np-f battery adater (blind spot power junkie).
The only thing I hate is the grip with the battery. It does not last a whole wedding day, so I have unmount the dual hangle and all, just to change the battery.
After a whole wedding season, I'm not sure If I'll stick with it or try to find a better solution.
Thanks 🙏
Спасибо за обзор!))
Its heavy, but some kettle bells 3x a week will help. LOL. Great Video.
Hey Mat, what's up with that led plant??! Did you make it? or is it bought? i like it :D
It’s from ikea. Search Medusa lamp :)
@@whoismatt wow, thanks a lot! 👍👍👍
I have bought this and returned 2nd day
I have zhiyun crane 2 and I was happy to upgrade as it was advertised on social media. But my feedback is, this gamble is not for wedding videographer because it’s so heavy and you can’t hold it for whole event. Twisting camera down and handed up is mission in this as you can only flip from right side and left side is lock.
When camera is down and handle is up moving camera face up is limited to 50% you can’t turn full lens face up to get low angle shoot.
If you have zhiyun crane 2 I would say stuck to that you will regret buying this. This might be good for small project like songs video but for wedding no way
Bought the RSC2, hated it, bought the RS2, love it.
Why you hate?
I love RSC2, maybe you can't use it haha
@@ValenTino-bv6nr not the case, RS2 all the way
Nice video
Thanks Akshar!
If you modify the arm to 45 degrees does that shave off some extra weight?
Let’s say I’m a gimbal looking for hot single gimbals in my area. Is the Crane 2S for me?
Before I start watching - Matt I respect your views. Please I hope you do this justice as I have found a Ronin S already for £300 and if I have to buy this Crane 2S - will cost me £600... So please please make me understand why... :-)))))
Zhiyun Caran 2s it's able wireless mobile jaayro control or not? like DJI Ronin gimbal like !
fully compatible with d750?
Still RSC2gang. Flies the FX3, a Røde SVMX, and the GM 24/35/14 with ease. Absolutely does need a back handle though.
I got a 2S for my pocket 6k and it really struggled with the weight. Could hear the motors and it would start shaking. Sent it back and got the RS2 and it’s been awesome. I think maybe the 2S is better for smaller mirrorless?
even on high motor settings?
@@W93h3753mwesley I’ll be honest, I didn’t try that. But the RS2 has been incredible from jump.
@@pennyzee1176 I hear yeah. the r2. you use the auto tune?
yeah I had to change my crane 2 to high motor. same issues.
I had the eos r with battery grip. and the 24-70mm zoomed at 50mm. Heavy set upppppp. but it handles pretty well on high.
I would imagine the crane 2s is the same.
I might have to skip the crane 2s. for the more weight issue. I'm already pushing 10-13lbs for a daily setup haha and the fact they don't have a wireless remote.
I really like using the dual handle grip and wireless remote I have on a custom fit handle. don't think this is an option yet on the crane 2s.
Was wondering, can this gimbal support a smartphone + case/cage + lenses.??
Yes
@@whoismatt thanks man
I still say the crane plus is best gimbal. Small, skinny handle and super lightweight!
This just dropped on B&H today for less than $250
Hello friends, the Crane 2s in Cambodia sells for 450usd, FYI.
2KG :) this is why I went Weebill-S. But I don't use grips.
Nice!
@@whoismatt and by the way nobody from the other reviewers pointed that out in a way that I will notice so your review was much more helpful :).
On my crane 2 one of the plate mini hex screws hex head got shredded, i emailed zhiyun to as how much for a couple of new spare screws, they wanted $90AUD for two tiny screws shipped form China to Australia. I was like Lol wtf 😂😂 however; i still love using my crane 2 with my Canon C100M2 🙌
RSC2 for lightness 😃👍
Thanks for the video Matt. I really appreciate you posting this even though the wave of Crane 2S's reviews is passed. I feel that you bring up the real, day-to-day gripes and perks of owning the gear. Rather different than most reviews that come out right when the embargo is lifted, those tend to stick with the talking points provided by the manufacturer. Amazing stuff!
Pity it weights more than the previous. I don't see myself upgrading again with zhiyun.
I shoot real estate. My biggest complaint with this gimble is that you cannot move the motor by hand. If this is part of your workflow coming from the Crane2 this creates a huge problem because it takes soooooo much longer to adjust the camera position with a joystick. And it’s crazy heavy.
So I’m “between” gimbles right now. My Crane2 just won’t hold verticals anymore and the 2S is slowing me down.
Also, the NEW Crane2 gimbles have a new MODE cycle that requires you go through F to get back to PF from F. Again, this is infuriating as it’s means I lose my vertical lines after every shot whereas going directly from PF to L and back to PF (the way the original Crane2 did) saved huge amounts of time shooting real estate.
If anyone knows a gimble that will solve these issues please let me know! :)
I thought its weight is the same, I guess I'm going with the RS2
I think if you review your videos you’ll notice that, despite a beard so awful that not even a horny Sasquatch would want you, the scene where you say “Wait a moment, Matt: why did you say ‘probably’?’ Is so good I actually subscribed. Good stuff; I look forward to more well-informed opinions; and with any luck a brushed beard, too.
Why wouldn't this compete with the RSC2? It kind of falls in between the RS2 and the RSC2 as far as price and function anyway.
I bought it based on their list of compatible setups but the list can’t be trusted. It’s impossible to balance my ZCAM with 24-105 zoom. Zhiyun support confirmed that it can’t. Just to keep in mind if you buy it for a heavy setup. You can be sure that it will work even if they states it 🙁
Oh no! How are you liking the ZCAM overall? I've heard great things
@@whoismatt Its great and the image and color is what I like most about it. Coming from GH5 and GH5s its a bit different to handle and you need to add grip, monitor etc. Funny thing is that many clients believe that it automatically will be a higher quality on the delivered project just because you shot with something that doesn't look like normal DSLR or mirrorless camera :)
Don't fall! Looked like you almost fell there in Colorado.
Love from INDIA
Thank you!
DJI also has RSC-2 for $500
Yup! Not a bad price
Yes it handles 3 kg
It is directly on the product-page how much the Crane 2S payload is... 🤷🏻♂️🤔
Min. ca. 0.6 kg and Max. ca. 6.49 kg 😜
Which product page? I swear I checked all over hahaha
@@whoismatt haha okay no Problem 😜🙈 I am from Germany and I checked a few pages too after I watched your video and at our German ZHIYUN page it says what the payload is 🙂👍🏻 www.zhiyun-tech.de/produkte/crane-2s/986/zhiyun-crane-2s?c=263
@@whoismatt it says ->
Traglast: Min. ca. 0.6 kg bis Max. ca. 6.49 kg
Traglast = Payload
Haha ohhh! Glad they are at least telling people in Germany 😂👍
@@whoismatt haha 😂 yeah at least some country! Or maybe there’s a law that they have to tell this here 🤷🏻♂️😁😂🙈
Can it hold the BMPCC4K ... Yes ... Sold. That's how easy it is.
no listed maximum payload made me buy elsewhere.
You're not talking about the stabilization in itself. And after having possessed and used Ronin, Ronin M and Ronin S, the Crane 2S is by far the better gimbal I've ever had. Responsive, ultra smooth, no micro shakes, it's doing the job perfectly. DJI gimbals have a better finition, have a more user friendly software and feels sturdier, but I have never been convinced by the results of their gimbals. And the footage is most important thing.
I got mines for $350...
i literally stoped watching at the point where you displayed the wieght difference between crane 2s and crane 2
ive had the crane 2
now i have the crane m
which is beauuuuutiful
but i was wishing for something in between the two
which this is definitely not
Amazing tutorial! Really appreciate it! I make filmmaking related tutorials as well. Any support would be awesome! Thanks again
superglue the joystick button on...problem solved
😂 modern problems require modern solutions
😎
You win!
👍😆👍
Really nice 👌 😍💋 💝💖❤️
Hi Boys 😍💋 💝💖♥️❤️