World's Most Popular Knife Isn't Good?! | ESEE - 5

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 927

  • @RandallsAdventureESEE
    @RandallsAdventureESEE 6 років тому +1603

    Thanks for the Review....I will say Ive never understood how this knife garnered a bushcraft following. Indestructible, yes....bushcrafty? No. Our knives are heat treated to 55-57HRC and as a few have pointed out, this knife was developed to allow pilots to cut themselves out of a downed aircraft. It is a tank with steep grinds and essentially a sharpened pry bar, which is what we were asked to develop by some SERE folks. I personally don't own this knife as I prefer the thinner options in our line for more bushcrafty and normal use. Hopefully our fan boys will take it easy on you guys and an ESEE does NOT end up embedded in anyones plural cavity! LoL....We appreciate what you do and do NOT shy away from negative feedback....we are working and moving forward as a company....I can say that with absolute confidence and I am looking forward to what 2019 and beyond has in store for ESEE. Keep up the good work guys!

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому +300

      This is what I love about you guys. Honesty, not afraid of feedback and keeping it nice! As we said in the video you guys are awesome people! Your explanation here makes total sense! The esee is indeed a crowbar with an edge and that's where it shines. It takes a crazy amount of beating. There is no perfect tool, only the right tool for the job. The esee 5 is not for bushcraft but did get a large following there. We hope to talk to you guys in the future on the podcast about your thoughts and what it was designed for.
      Again! We really appreciate you guys reacting to this in such a positive manner. Huge respect from us to you all. Looking forward to see what 2019 has to offer!

    • @RandallsAdventureESEE
      @RandallsAdventureESEE 6 років тому +191

      @@DutchBushcraftKnives no worries man....we appreciate the coverage and conversation.....all the best.

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому +60

      @Nicholas Ovel haha thanks a lot

    • @wmcwane01
      @wmcwane01 6 років тому +106

      @@DutchBushcraftKnives I'll be danged. They commented. And with true class. See that's why I like your company. Good people.

    • @devonsanterre8449
      @devonsanterre8449 6 років тому +13

      Cant wait to get myself the 6 this christmas lol... Or the junglas 2... Or both. Should have looked into it more before I bought the 5, love it but it just doesnt camp as well as my 4 and I want the 6 now..

  • @NathanHorton-wg7yb
    @NathanHorton-wg7yb Рік тому +6

    Beat the crap out of an Esee and if it breaks they send you a new one. No questions asked. Love them

  • @aaronshirk746
    @aaronshirk746 6 місяців тому +5

    I had no idea Beavis and Butthead were doing knife reviews these days. This is awesome 😂😂

  • @philipsplettstoer3623
    @philipsplettstoer3623 6 років тому +40

    Don't be worried guys you are still the best

  • @hillbillyfromtheswamp6223
    @hillbillyfromtheswamp6223 Рік тому +5

    Out of all my fixed blades which is around 30-40. I love my Esee 5 more than all the rest.

  • @tontonkarim2260
    @tontonkarim2260 6 років тому +13

    I just came by to say : I don't know anything about knives or bushcraft, but I watch every single videos you make. You guys are great, very funny and yet we can feel you're passionate and take it seriously. Best regards from your french neighbours.

  • @wartstein8814
    @wartstein8814 6 років тому +17

    The three fixed blades I use outdoors are in D2, N690 and 1095 (1095 being my Esee Laser Strike); and, yes, the 1095 is dulling fastest out of the three, no question.
    But: The edge retention improved a lot after sharpening the knife a few times. So I guess the factory edge is especially bad concerning edge holding? Maybe due to the heat of the grinders used for the initial sharpening? Just a guess, I am not an expert by any means

  • @michaelmorgan9973
    @michaelmorgan9973 6 років тому +143

    America's first line of defense... From the Netherlands...

  • @guus6541
    @guus6541 6 років тому +66

    My true heroes are always making my Thursday the best day of the week with the nice video's :D

  • @SuperRooster89
    @SuperRooster89 6 років тому +7

    Been watching you guys for a few years now and you never seem to disappoint. Love the content keep up the good work.

  • @Ryanv7x
    @Ryanv7x 6 років тому +58

    Great video as always. Stay true to yourselves. Some knives you won't like. It's all good.

  • @connorshoemaker2466
    @connorshoemaker2466 6 років тому +2

    Can you guys do a comparison of the Ontario tak-1 to this knife? Anyone have any input on the tak-1?

  • @DutchBushcraftKnives
    @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому +15

    Yes People! Our Black Friday Deals! Friday 23th of November 00:00 PDT to 12:00 PDT
    You get 10% off everything with the code: mikkiebigdick
    We also have new sharpening stones! Fallkniven DC-4's with our logo on it! In our opinion the best field sharpening stone out there!
    Get your fine smellin asses to WWW.DBKSHOP.COM. Ok now we'll pop back into the shower with our dirty money asking Esee bashing asses. Cheers!

    • @nataliewitkowski913
      @nataliewitkowski913 6 років тому +2

      Heh.... mikkiebigdick...

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому +2

      @@nataliewitkowski913 Mikkie doesn't have one. he just is a big dick. It's what i've heard at least....

    • @dirtydan179
      @dirtydan179 6 років тому

      I'm saving up for a bravo 1, that'll take a long time tho.
      ay just asking, what do you guys think is the best stainless steel and also best handle design?
      I'm trying to design a knife to make myself but can't decide on what to settle on.

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому +1

      Mate thats a great choice!
      For the steel: we really love Cos steel but since that's hard to obtain: go for elmax! Great great steel. And then for the handle comfort the bark river bravo one, gunny handles are the most comfortable! Good luck mate! Cheers

    • @dirtydan179
      @dirtydan179 6 років тому

      @@DutchBushcraftKnives Thanks man! Keep up the great work!

  • @Jake-bt3fc
    @Jake-bt3fc 2 місяці тому +1

    52100 steals 1095's lunch at recess. 1095 is obsolete. There are cheap alternatives that are better in every way.

  • @dahotrod1533
    @dahotrod1533 6 років тому +10

    I was tempted to buy an esee 6 however I read the reviews on the website and saw so many regarding a weak edge that I decided not to get one

    • @umbalaba
      @umbalaba 6 років тому +1

      +Owen Wellspring Just buy a Mora knife while you save up for a custom knife.

    • @dahotrod1533
      @dahotrod1533 6 років тому

      @@umbalaba got a mora, i have a vast collection of good knives. Overall my favourite is the British army survival knife. It is a beast, the blade is 7 inches long and 6mm thick. It is the easiest knife to sharpen in my collection yet it holds the edge for a long time of usage. The phosphate coating lasts a long time but it was a pain when mirror polishing the cheek of the blade. Overall it is the best knife for the money, may come a tad blunt from factory, but if you can't sharpen it you don't deserve it. Plus it must be the coolest knife around. I have more expensive knives, but this one could challenge its son the bk2, or an a1 pro.

    • @umbalaba
      @umbalaba 6 років тому

      @@dahotrod1533 Sorry man. I thought you were just starting out a collection. That British army survival knife sounds really awesome!

    • @dahotrod1533
      @dahotrod1533 6 років тому +1

      @@umbalaba they are not the most well-finnished knives but that was the sacrifice to keep the cost down for the British army, they did not skimp on the materials or forging though so it is a really solid knife.

  • @SubUrbanNinja-EDC
    @SubUrbanNinja-EDC 4 роки тому +1

    Awesome video...funny too. But can you help me and let me know if you recommend any of the EESE line? I was thinking of getting either the EESE 5 or EESE 6 and now I have second thoughts. What do you recommend that is best for the same price that has the best steel for bushcrafting, food processing, etc?

    • @grom-XR650R
      @grom-XR650R 2 роки тому

      Beaver knive - super knive.

  • @k8a7j7
    @k8a7j7 6 років тому +15

    finally an objective review

  • @jls2975
    @jls2975 6 років тому

    hi guys what a sincere test, we dont want to hear marketing shit if knife isnt as good as it should be for the price. i have one but it starts to rust because it no more goes into the bush, for the same weight a small axe is much better. you should do a comparison (chopping and batonning - for the rest with such big knife or axe we always take a small knife !)

  • @MSLBushcraftSurvival
    @MSLBushcraftSurvival 6 років тому +5

    I totally agree.
    I had similar bad experiences with the ESEE Junglas. Its badly designed and soft and...

  • @lukaspfeiffer4751
    @lukaspfeiffer4751 6 років тому +2

    I dont get why they temper the blade to so low hrc 1095 should be able to handle 59-60 hrc just fine. still i think they should Use better steel. The knive is supppsed to be a Military survival knive and it isnt even rust resistant and the protective coating is bad .if you want a good stainless steel that also ist pretty tough i would take rwl34/cpm154 or cpm s35vn at 59-60 hrc. I think that would work just fine or am I completely wrong?let me know.

  • @tinysupreme6417
    @tinysupreme6417 6 років тому +3

    Could you test the Gerber Strongarm? It's similar to this knife but I think it would do better.

  • @thomassmith8314
    @thomassmith8314 5 років тому +4

    The only ESEE I could ever get on board with is the Junglas. Good ergos, nice sheath, great chopper. Everything else is over priced and hyped up. I agree with DBK for a good bushcraft knife get a Bark River in CPM 3V in any model you like. Excellent ergos, heirloom quality.

  • @Liv1ngTheDream
    @Liv1ngTheDream 6 років тому +8

    Honest reviews are best reviews!

  • @markstanton63
    @markstanton63 5 років тому +1

    Yea ... But it gives its wearer a sense of daring do and tactical prowess as they check themselves in the mirror prior to getting into their vehicle and driving off to the woods for an hour of white-knuckle survival training.
    (It performs much better when you take advantage of the MOLLE-back-sheath/pouch/tin 'system upgrade' options .... Available in bad-ass Black for urban preppers, or OD-Green for wilderness survival enthusiasts).

  • @RealFigureEight
    @RealFigureEight 6 років тому +9

    I was about to purchase a ESEE but thanks to DBK I rethought my in investment. I will now be either getting a Mora Garberg or other silimar knife. Thanks guys!

    • @johnnyeas1431
      @johnnyeas1431 2 роки тому

      There are dozens of videos showing how excellent & versatile the esee 5 is. The "will taylor" video makes bushcraft look easy with the esee 5. If you take what the "Dutch Bushcraft" blessed boys say seriously then you need help.

    • @RealFigureEight
      @RealFigureEight 2 роки тому

      @@johnnyeas1431 Bruh this was 3 years ago, plus I bought a Garbeg and it's amazing.

    • @johnnyeas1431
      @johnnyeas1431 2 роки тому +1

      @@RealFigureEight so did your words expire because they are 3 years old?

    • @RealFigureEight
      @RealFigureEight 2 роки тому

      @@johnnyeas1431 Look upon my feild of fucks... and see that it is barren, for I have none to give.

  • @TheSimba86
    @TheSimba86 5 років тому +2

    I have had three esee knives and I have sold all of them, I hate the coating, edge retention is terrible

  • @ItachiUchiha-yz5nn
    @ItachiUchiha-yz5nn 6 років тому +5

    Awesome video. I agree with you. When it comes to knives, especially a survival/Bush craft knife, is always better to save your money and go with a knife you can trust with your life on the line. I have fallkniven and bark river knives and they are both amazing companies so I agree with your recommendations guys.

  • @TheBeta140
    @TheBeta140 6 років тому +1

    I don't know if you have done it already, but could you make a video about de mora classic n°2? I'd really love to see that video. You guys are just amazing!

  • @FearNoSteel
    @FearNoSteel 6 років тому +8

    Great Review, yeah too soft and too thick, too blocky.

  • @davidkelly414
    @davidkelly414 10 місяців тому

    My knife came blunt out of the box . I convexed the edge , now it's good for splitting. It cannot carve or fetter stick . I advise one to bye a small hatchet instead . Cheers

  • @tugawolfoutdoor
    @tugawolfoutdoor 6 років тому +6

    Great vid as always guys, I was thinking in bying the ESEE 5, now I dont think so, I have the BK2 and it still rock as hell, your the best, keep on going mattes 👍😉💪👊😎🇵🇹

    • @joeantonicci8920
      @joeantonicci8920 4 роки тому +1

      Don't let that stop you i have two and i love them FOR REAL.......................

  • @Ghost32567
    @Ghost32567 6 років тому +1

    Could you try schrade schf37 or 52 as a comparison to esee? I have schrade schf37 and after some batonning i didn't have such problems with blade, also 1095 steel but much cheaper

  • @glenniboi4520
    @glenniboi4520 6 років тому +3

    Im so glad i did not buy that knife. It had so many good reviews, so i seriously considered it. Bought i Fallkniven A1 instead. Do you have any plans to review the Norwegian Sami knife: Samekniven, by Strømeng?

  • @c.h.u.d
    @c.h.u.d Рік тому +1

    The knife across the throat comment you got was completely fkn rude and unnecessary.ignore that pile of crap

  • @michalklopotowski9782
    @michalklopotowski9782 6 років тому +11

    Can't wait for that Esee 5 vs. BK2/BK22 shoot out. I've been looking for a comparison quite a while now so... Thanks guys. And keep it up!

    • @Slitthroat1776
      @Slitthroat1776 6 років тому +1

      I carry the BK 2 on my side everyday at work.

  • @ToughJourneyman
    @ToughJourneyman 6 років тому +1

    Have you tried or tested the Ontario Blackbird SK5?

  • @12314jhghhdfbztjbxfjfsxvjlvfb
    @12314jhghhdfbztjbxfjfsxvjlvfb 6 років тому +17

    Good review. I have a bk2 and tested it against a friend's ESEE 5....BK2 all day long. I also have an ESEE 6, it dulls faster than any knife I have (vg1, vg10, s30v, 154cm...etc,etc). BUT, I have done things to the ESEE 6 that are down right cruel and ridiculous. The ESEE 6 has never snapped, chipped or broken in anyway. I'm certain every other knife I have would be toast. It's redeeming quality is indestructability.

    • @Jake-bt3fc
      @Jake-bt3fc 2 місяці тому

      1095 is objectively just not that good, lol. It's not even very tough. It's soft, it loses it's edge super fast, yet somehow it's still relatively brittle for what it is.
      3v or even just 5160 or 52100 is such an obvious upgrade that a knife this expensive really needs to get.

  • @mr.e9017
    @mr.e9017 4 роки тому +1

    These guys are about high end fixed blades. I'm not surprised on their opinion on esse

  • @sloanIrrigation
    @sloanIrrigation 6 років тому +10

    In my humble opinion, the best bark river knife made that will handle everything but real chopping( carry a small camp axe) is the Aurora LT in A2. Thick enough for bushcraft, thin enough for food prep, skinning, and fish cleaning. Easy field sharpening when it needs some touch up. NOT a fan of Esee. Love the BK 5, 7, and 9. (Bk5 no longer produced) They hold an edge really well and are also easily sharpened.

    • @trenth4514
      @trenth4514 6 років тому

      Sloanirrigation very informative thank you

    • @benwarman5202
      @benwarman5202 6 років тому

      I almost got the aurora but went with the bravo lt instead. Lovely knife couldn’t be happier

  • @jhcollins31
    @jhcollins31 6 років тому

    I currently own a Falkniven DC4 and a CC4 as well as your field strop. Would you guys recommend getting water stones as well? And if so, what kind do you use?

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому

      It depends. If you regrind your knives a lot or if you take high value about the esthetics of your edge water stones would be a big plus. We can recommend the naniwa professional series 400, 1000 and 3000 grit

  • @SwampValley
    @SwampValley 6 років тому +48

    It's not a bushcraft knife... But it gets my nuggets tingling 😂

    • @devonsanterre8449
      @devonsanterre8449 6 років тому +5

      Its definately not, I bought one for camp and it splits wood like an animal but its not designed for camp at all... Unless you have to cut your way in and out of your camper lol

    • @devonsanterre8449
      @devonsanterre8449 6 років тому +3

      Oh and it does get the nuggets tingling 😆

  • @shramj
    @shramj 9 місяців тому

    The ESEE 5 is a beast, it isn't meant for camping/bushcrafting, it is meant to help you get out of a very bad situation that I hope nobody finds themselves in. This knife is designed to get you out of a downed aircraft (if you even survive that) and then give you some options for surviving after that. I have used mine for splitting wood and get a fire started but I have no experience using it to cut through the aluminum fuselage of an aircraft and hope I never do :)

  • @bryanmarsh9886
    @bryanmarsh9886 6 років тому +3

    I agree. I have found ESEE knives to be uncomfortable, soft, and all around disappointing. They cost a lot for really basic steel and slab scales. Like the boys say: save up a little more and get a Bark River.

    • @Wolf_K
      @Wolf_K 6 років тому

      Bryan Marsh
      While BRKT can produce a decent knife they also produce a lot of defective product but sell it anyway so be aware of this well documented fact.
      Also, be prepared to sharpen it at least 4 times to remove the damaged apex steel from dry grinding during stock removal...this goes for almost all knife companies. If dry grinding is used then edges are most definitely burnt and damaged. This is scientifically proven.
      I own a few of their knives but I will no longer support the company, buy their product, or recommend them due to the amount of highly defective knives that get out in the public and are sold as “premium quality”, and the outright lies the owner tells (sells) to people.
      Any knife maker can make you a similar/same custom knife for much less.

  • @AedansOutdoors
    @AedansOutdoors 6 років тому

    Hey what do you guys think of the bark river Kephart in cpm3v? I am considering purchasing it. Are you guys a fan of that model?

  • @MrChamberlaindavidd
    @MrChamberlaindavidd 6 років тому +3

    You two convinced me to trade my Esee4 for a Bark River years ago. Best knife decision I ever made. Can't thank you enough!

    • @nicoleonard2420
      @nicoleonard2420 5 років тому

      yeah i bought my first mora because of them, now i have to many. but that is not a problem

  • @joshuagonzales1563
    @joshuagonzales1563 2 роки тому

    Good video, but can you make a video for ESEE CANDIRU between fake ones and the real ones? Thanks.

  • @masgrey9608
    @masgrey9608 6 років тому +15

    I really wanted to like RAT/ESEE back in the day owning the Izula, 3, 4, & 6 and now they are all sold off. I did not like the knives finding them very overpriced for the 1095 & horrible ergonomics. Good honest assessment on your part. Thank you.

    • @donjuanmckenzie4897
      @donjuanmckenzie4897 3 роки тому +3

      Horrible ergonomics? Are you high?

    • @Ve-suvius
      @Ve-suvius 3 роки тому +1

      The old style handles were horrible to the hands. For sure. I sold them all also.
      But the new ones with the 3D handles look very comfortable.
      But the prices ... not too wallet friendly.
      Bark River I do not trust.
      Had bad experiences with them. Bravo 1 and 2 severe edge rolling from just a bit of chopping of pine wood.
      The heat treat was worse than sh.t.
      Also overpriced. A knife is just a tool. Not someting i get a hardon from.

    • @masgrey9608
      @masgrey9608 3 роки тому

      @@donjuanmckenzie4897 Not at all. I just did not care for the 3 or 4, too thin and I despise choils. The 6 was like a squared off block to me in the hand. Just my opinion. I bought them and then sold them all. Not my "type" of knife and I just did not buy into all of the hype. For me the Fallkniven F1 has been perfect for my needs and never looked back again. To each their own. Good luck with your choices.

    • @donjuanmckenzie4897
      @donjuanmckenzie4897 3 роки тому

      @@Ve-suvius It's not a heat treatment issue per se, Bark River has been known in the past to violently power grind and then cold quench their knives which produces steel that tends the fail in the manner in which you experienced. Bark River was also told about this and their answer was basically that they knew what they were doing and stfu.

    • @donjuanmckenzie4897
      @donjuanmckenzie4897 3 роки тому

      @@masgrey9608 I have the hm 6 which has a very nice handle and the junglas and izula with the square handles and they are fine in hand. The only realy thing I'd change about them is to give them a tapered tang because their handles are really heavy. Higher performance grind would also be nice but that's a problem common to most knife companies.

  • @bbostonnd9372
    @bbostonnd9372 6 років тому +1

    I literally just found your channel and I love it I can't stop watching it. You guys are awesome please keep making great content. I'm signing up for your patreon after Christmas!!! Happy holidays and happy new year !!!

  • @ramonanzures9780
    @ramonanzures9780 5 років тому +7

    Esse knives are overrated as hell I owned a 6 known as "the best knife ever made" and got the same chip playing around with some wood sticks in my back yard before I got it I read about how people accidently hit rocks etc and the edge was still good which I know now is bullshit

    • @RadDadisRad
      @RadDadisRad 4 роки тому

      I’ve had good luck with mine. I’ve even stripped the coating off my Junglas 6 and 4. Acid etched it then carburized it. Works amazing.

    • @bena3341
      @bena3341 4 роки тому +1

      Yep. My Gerber Ultimate Pro is way better and cheaper.

    • @Jake-bt3fc
      @Jake-bt3fc 2 місяці тому

      Yeah, it's literally soft _and_ brittle. It's like a knife made of dry play dough.

  • @hillbillyfromtheswamp6223
    @hillbillyfromtheswamp6223 2 роки тому +2

    Regardless. I still love my Esee 5.

  • @03Grunt-arrino
    @03Grunt-arrino 6 років тому +92

    I’ve had a few Esee’s and sadly, it’s true. They lose there edge faster than any other knives I’ve owned. Great, honest video gents.

    • @devonsanterre8449
      @devonsanterre8449 6 років тому +28

      They also only take 2 minutes to sharpen to shaving sharp

    • @stalwart263
      @stalwart263 6 років тому +15

      Similar to any 1095 knife, they hold and edge for a while but are easy to sharpen back up. If you are buying a 1095 knife this is what you get.@@devonsanterre8449

    • @tylerwalsh9020
      @tylerwalsh9020 6 років тому +1

      I made a baton out of a wet piece of birch, I would have been hard pressed to cut myself much less paper afterwards.

    • @PerceptionVsReality333
      @PerceptionVsReality333 6 років тому +6

      Ontario's 1095 seems to be stronger, I've noticed that theirs retains an edge longer than most 1095 from other more expensive knife manufacturers. Just my experience with 1095 HC steel knives from different brands.

    • @nitrorc4life1
      @nitrorc4life1 6 років тому +1

      @@PerceptionVsReality333I prefer Tops knives if I am grabbing a 1095 blade myself, then a Becker.

  • @grandriver3152
    @grandriver3152 6 років тому +2

    Nicely done boys. Funny, honest and comprehensive. A+

  • @m.d.chaika
    @m.d.chaika 6 років тому +9

    👍can you make review about Tbs knives?Tbs"boar" or "grizzly" ? Thanks!

    • @Wolf_K
      @Wolf_K 6 років тому +1

      MD Chaika
      I have the grizzly and aside from the absurd bevel geometry it seems to be a good knife, although far too thick. I’ve since reprofiled it to about 12° per side with a tiny micro bevel at about 17° per side giving a total of about a 34° apex. I’m thinking of thinning the whole blade to around 3mm.

  • @lonniecox7875
    @lonniecox7875 6 років тому +2

    You guys should do a comparison between the esee 4 and tops bob

  • @jaydougie
    @jaydougie 6 років тому +4

    The esee-5 is the first knife I held that I had an emotional connection with. That being said, after holding a fallkniven A1, I sold my esee-5 shortly after. The handle sucks a fat one.

  • @kazuyasurioka5104
    @kazuyasurioka5104 6 років тому +2

    Oh, my God. I was glad to buy K Bar instead of Esee. I know some people like it. Is it made in China or something? What's happened of this product?

  • @RevolutionIsTheOnlySolution
    @RevolutionIsTheOnlySolution 6 років тому +27

    Wow just looked at the price of the ESEE 5.. nearly 200 british pounds on knives and tools if you want it with a sheath.. would rather take a shit in my hands and clap..

  • @joschaklesse2102
    @joschaklesse2102 6 років тому +2

    Pls check out the "mora garberg-killer", the Terävä Jäkääripuuko. This is like the "little brother" of the Skrama and I would be very happy to see what you are thinking about it.

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому

      We own one and actually used it in an older video called 5 ways to make fire

  • @tucoespinoza1704
    @tucoespinoza1704 6 років тому +5

    Try out the schrade schf42d

  • @AdventureTimeOutdoors
    @AdventureTimeOutdoors 6 років тому +1

    Wow there is the proof! And it confirmed many of my thoughts.
    So many people swear by this knife. I looked at them and found they were a little expensive for a 1095 production knife and I didnt like the handles. Flat handles always give me a hotspot in my hand so I passed. I still would like to try one though but not for that price.

  • @ThePentium41
    @ThePentium41 6 років тому +3

    Hello guys, you should try Beaver Knife. It's an Russian Bushcraft knife very beautiful one.

    • @buckfynn
      @buckfynn 6 років тому

      I agree! Excellent fit and finish, great price, and very nice people to do business with.

  • @christopher_martin
    @christopher_martin 6 років тому

    hey guys could you solve an arguement for me....if you could only have one knife in a survival situation would you rather have a bark river in cpm 3v or cru wear... or a fallkniven a1 pro??

    • @DutchBushcraftKnives
      @DutchBushcraftKnives  6 років тому +1

      In a real survival situation maybe we'd choose the A1 pro! Just because its really capable of handling the elements really well. Being stainless, easy to sharpen is also very nice. Never the less if you ask us which knife we'd choose if we could only have 1 knife in general, we'd go for the bark river in CPM3V. (Havn't had enough chance to test it against cru wear).

    • @christopher_martin
      @christopher_martin 6 років тому

      @@DutchBushcraftKnives Thanks guys i appreciate it alot!!

  • @CaptainAiryca
    @CaptainAiryca 6 років тому +4

    Use that broken tip to strike your firesteel 😜. The editing on these videos must take forever!! Thank you for all of your hard work. Esse scales turn me off from them, but they sure have a cult following!

  • @jasonclark8921
    @jasonclark8921 6 років тому +1

    Thanks for the upload and keep the great videos coming. Best knife UA-cam channel ever. I love every video y'all make.

  • @douglasreed9237
    @douglasreed9237 2 роки тому +3

    It's a heavy duty survival knife that you can sharpen on a river rock if needed and not break. Check out JoeX's destruction testing videos he hates Fallkniven because they break so easily. The Esse 5 has many handle options as well. Remember the harder the steel and higher the Rockwell the more easily it will snap in half. The harder steel may hold an edge longer though. I'll take a soft steel that bends before a hard steel that shatters in a survival situation and that is what the Esse5 was designed for. Thanks 👍

    • @willl7780
      @willl7780 2 роки тому

      Ya they should hit there falknivens with hammers lol

  • @mjo4981
    @mjo4981 3 роки тому

    Just bought an Esee 4 and it has a bevel like a cold chisel. Will take some work to get an edge on it, then I can test the edge. A good looking knife none the less and have some hopes for it once I get a new bevel on it.

  • @j.r.peters7234
    @j.r.peters7234 6 років тому +5

    I own a esee junglas and have put it through more abuse than you could imagine. I can tell you guys right now that you got a bad blade. Handle shape and fire steel aside, there is no way it should chip, dull and have its coating come off like that. Esee is known for how good their 1095 is, it's almost bizarre how good they can get it. I know you can only judge a knife by what you have in front of you, as such I really respect your honesty and integrity in giving us this review. Keep up the good work, I'll be watching.

  • @JordanMac79
    @JordanMac79 6 років тому

    Can you check out a white river knife fc4/5 firecrafter in s35vn?????

  • @GladiusArgento
    @GladiusArgento 6 років тому +8

    Good Job guys!!
    My experience is the same as yours. I "jumped in the ESSEE 5 Band Wagon" a few years ago and i was very disappointed with the knife, I found the coating was a deterrent in feather sticking
    and carving, the coating chipped in multiple places after just one outing to test the knife , the edge go dull very quickly , the edge angle is so steep is odd to sharpen.
    Given I was told by "somebody whom apparently knows better then me" that this knife was designed for military purposes as "SERE" Purposes ( Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape ) and it was meant to be like a "72 hr use" and then discard....
    The BK2...much better knife all departments, just my personal experience.
    And I agree with you guys, i cannot recommend it, I don't even know why it is so popular.
    Cheers.

  • @jackanders9545
    @jackanders9545 6 років тому +1

    I would guess that tops USA probably makes the best 1095 knives but when they're super steel out there why wouldn't you use it?

    • @foreverjim5240
      @foreverjim5240 6 років тому

      Bc super steel is brittle. It can break. 1095 will bend a little first. That's why it's great for a survival knife. Not quite as sharp, but won't let u down. The super steel stuff is better for car camping. The 1095, 1070, 440c, and D2 is better for hiking. Both have their place. Just depends on what u want to do

    • @jackanders9545
      @jackanders9545 6 років тому +1

      @@foreverjim5240 all metals can bend or brake. Aluminum can be work hard to break even. The heat treat is what gives The metals these attributes. Tops knives uses 1095 and differential heat treat so the edges harder than the spine.. The whole point of powder metallurgy it's to make the steel tougher.

  • @BraxxJuventa
    @BraxxJuventa 6 років тому +4

    Honesty always prevails! Well done guys! 👍😁

  • @camara12
    @camara12 2 роки тому

    What was the name of the knife he recommended at the end?

  • @joshuagenovese36
    @joshuagenovese36 6 років тому +6

    Great video and review. I own 2 ESEE blades , both the 4-5 and though they dull fast, and don't slice well- I can honestly say that they will get the job done. Maybe not fine feather sticking but enough to get a fire going, will cut , prepare meat, will dig and pry and if you put a 90' degree spine on them they will throw spark. Not a knife that I would call a Bushcraft but a survival knife- Yes. Easy to sharpen, easy to fix if chipped. Just my 2 cents....lol. Anyways, Bark River if you want slicy , own 2 of them as well.

  • @artiruswandi4739
    @artiruswandi4739 6 років тому

    Since you guys don't use folder so much, what about neck knifes? Please give us some opinion about it

  • @RichardCroft
    @RichardCroft 6 років тому +17

    Spot on review. Buy Bark River , same lifetime , no questions asked warranty and a lot better steel choices

    • @nickmegadeth6633
      @nickmegadeth6633 4 роки тому +2

      Much more expensive and brittle edges. You didn't mention that 🤣🤣
      Great knives for bushcraft though..

    • @MovieGuy666
      @MovieGuy666 4 роки тому

      I have had nothing but hassles with Bark Rivers customer service and their edges chip like a motherfucker.

  • @chrissexton6634
    @chrissexton6634 4 роки тому +1

    Good combat knife.. not made for Bushcraft as much. (Mora garberg is better for cheaper. Or condor terosaur with the skindi grinds)

  • @keghinian
    @keghinian 6 років тому +3

    Hands down Bark River bravo is one of the best o es out there.

    • @foreverjim5240
      @foreverjim5240 6 років тому

      Good mail opener. But that slick handle has no place in the woods. Only to be used with clean dry hands

    • @keghinian
      @keghinian 6 років тому

      @@foreverjim5240 good point but the handle can always be roughened.

    • @stalwart263
      @stalwart263 6 років тому

      There are hundreds of handle options on Bark River! I had black Canvas Micarta which did need a roughing up.@@keghinian

  •  5 років тому +1

    Another epic vid from my favorite channel. Love your work boys and you have helped me alot in my knife buying hobby. Thanks for this epic channel.

  • @QuickStrikes84
    @QuickStrikes84 5 років тому +47

    Damn those esee fanboys are toxic. lol
    It's just a freakin knife!

    • @RandallsAdventureESEE
      @RandallsAdventureESEE 4 роки тому +8

      QuickStrikes84 we can’t take them anywhere. We try to house break them and teach them manners but the lessons don’t take.

    • @jmh1189
      @jmh1189 4 роки тому +4

      @@RandallsAdventureESEE WHY DON"T YOU LOVE ME!!!! just ordered a replacement esee 5 as i lost mine in a move from va back to ca.

    • @RandallsAdventureESEE
      @RandallsAdventureESEE 4 роки тому +5

      Sergeant Shultz we love all those in the #eseearmy. We just got to keep some of them at arms length! LoL.

    • @dandetande288
      @dandetande288 4 роки тому +1

      Oh yeahhh!! Hahaha

  • @rafalotreba6824
    @rafalotreba6824 4 роки тому +1

    That is a reason to buy Ontario RAT-5. I have saved few quid.

  • @MrJesulius
    @MrJesulius 6 років тому +6

    So a mora companion is a better knife... Who would have quessed.

  • @patrikblonnigen1761
    @patrikblonnigen1761 6 років тому +2

    Love the videos as always, thank you for all your efforts!
    Could you by any chance in the future do a rigorous test of the Gerber Strongarm? I own one and its the only Gerber knife i like, it's about on par, durability wise, with the Mora Garberg in my opinion, its a beast!
    Much love from Sweden

  • @BeSatori
    @BeSatori 6 років тому +4

    Great video. ESEE has a it's place among survival knifes, but they look like they're made by and for robots to me and don't have a place in my collection. Thanks for being willing to slam a popular knife. I've always appreciated your guys knife sense.

  • @raftika1
    @raftika1 4 роки тому

    Is the 4 preferred more for bush craft?

  • @tphvictims5101
    @tphvictims5101 6 років тому +8

    Is Lilly’s product better?
    And if it is, and by only one digit, she has to get a thumbs up.
    I trust you guys to be fair.
    I think the aus8 is a better choice because of corrosion resistance.
    And how many female tool designers do you see out there?
    She deserves a chance.

    • @aaroncarapace8054
      @aaroncarapace8054 6 років тому

      TPHVICTIMS
      Lilly’s knife is based off of Cold Steel’s SRK (which she’s stated is her favorite knife in previous videos). I like AUS8 as a pocket knife steel (I EDC an Ontario Rat 1 folder and use it heavily in the woods) but for a fixed blade knife, I find it to be on the soft side for doing heavy tasks.

  • @kglandak
    @kglandak 6 років тому +2

    I really would like to see you do a review on TRC K1 or TRC Apocalypse..their knives seem to be good quality.

  • @bornepic1626
    @bornepic1626 6 років тому +15

    Make a video on bk7!!!!!!!!

    • @buddhamack1491
      @buddhamack1491 6 років тому

      They already did the BK2, it's basically the same just bigger.

    • @johnnyra2437
      @johnnyra2437 6 років тому +4

      @@buddhamack1491 not really... the Bk2 is a thick .25" and 5.25" long while the BK7 is .188" thick and 7" long. They perform very VERY differently. And the same goes for the BK9

    • @grandriver3152
      @grandriver3152 6 років тому +2

      Couldn't agree more. I customized my BK7 with a file, sandpaper and a needle and thread for the sheeth. Took me hours to carefully remove the third notch on the thumb ramp and custom fit the handle. Now I have a killer tool/weapon in a compact package that completely solves my big knife need without extra expense. Great bonding experience.

    • @buddhamack1491
      @buddhamack1491 6 років тому +2

      @@johnnyra2437 Fair enough, I've never used the BK7 myself but I have a chopper similar in size and have compared it against my brother's BK2. I just know that the boys aren't much into larger knives so they don't buy a lot to test so it's unlikely we'll see it.

    • @stalwart263
      @stalwart263 6 років тому +2

      Buddha Mack I sold my BK7 to finance a Bark River Bravo Vortex. I don’t regret it at all. Bark Rivers are far superior and only a little more expensive.

  • @gigabangdragon1186
    @gigabangdragon1186 6 років тому

    Awesome video can you please do a reviewand destruction test on the schrade schf36..... And ....... i wanna know does it match mora or even batter

  • @ctford27
    @ctford27 6 років тому +4

    I prefer schrade if I'm buying 1095 steel. It's good enough and I can buy 3 schrades per one esee.

  • @mayo470
    @mayo470 5 років тому

    Hi guys, great video as always, what is the background synthesizer music in the video-- assume it is royalty free? used at 2:20 (batoning) and 5:05 (hardcore testing)... Thanks Gents.

  • @frustratedmajority851
    @frustratedmajority851 4 роки тому +6

    Fair review.
    I love this knife. But it's a survival knife, not a bushcraft knife. It's designed to be used in the event of a helicopter crash... aka LAST resort, worst possible case scenario.
    This knife really shines when you try to break it without using tools (or rocks). You ain't.
    It holds an edge well enough but takes an edge even better.
    That weak coating you experienced was a fluke. That almost never happens. ESEE is known for having the toughest coating around.
    If your thinking about buying this knife to widdle wooden spoons or make the perfect feather stick then save your money. Armored tanks were not designed so you can drive it to the office. If you want a survival knife that will get you home alive and NEVER break, then buy this knife. No other knife is stronger or more reliable.

    • @mikejeffsteel
      @mikejeffsteel 4 роки тому +1

      WTF are you talking about? Your armored tank got dull after a log split :'D

    • @frustratedmajority851
      @frustratedmajority851 4 роки тому

      @@mikejeffsteel
      Not mine

    • @scaryeyeball
      @scaryeyeball 4 роки тому

      Good points, but saying there is no other knife stronger than an esee 5 is not exactly true. For example, the DBK boys have proven that with their over-the-top torture tests of the Ka-Bar Becker BK2, and I have also seen great things from the Gerber Strongarm. Both cost less as well.
      I own an Esee 5 and I still realize this. Just sayin'.

  • @stalwart263
    @stalwart263 6 років тому

    You guys are absolute right. It’s not a bad knife per se, and in a survival situation I would be glad to have it but it is vastly surpassed by any Bark River Bravo. I have a Bravo Vortex and have not used my ESEE 6 since I bought it.

  • @buddhamack1491
    @buddhamack1491 6 років тому +19

    Hahaha I love how people get personally invested in things as though it were a part of them. They feel personally attacked when something they like is criticized like it actually makes them less of a person.
    Personal opinion doesn't matter, if they like it and it works for them then goon on 'em but they don't need to convince the world they're right to justify their opinion.

    • @gwailotus9154
      @gwailotus9154 6 років тому +4

      Its called INSECURITY, INFERIORITY COMPLEX, FRAGILE EGO.... weakness of the heart and mind. interesting how many macho tough guys have these traits. for narcissists, "things" associated with their personal lives (hobbies, work, friends, family, interests, geographic residence, values, beliefs etc) become "extensions" of their ego. don't tell them there is anything wrong with themselves or anything or anyone they like love or believe in or now u r their enemy. REAL MEN CAN BE SHOWN THEY ARE WRONG AND DON'T THREATEN INTIMIDATE OR ASSAULT THOSE WHO SHOW IT TO THEM!!!!

  • @PvTLink234
    @PvTLink234 6 років тому

    Guys, serious talk : I don't know why your channel is not rising like it should.... Maybe, try to advertise your videos somewhere. Like on knife and tools, I thought that was a great idea. Idk... You should really think about it, because you deserve more!!!! Love u guys, from France.

  • @edyvanea
    @edyvanea 6 років тому +7

    The real question is, how did Mikki survive the black hole ?!

  • @ragnarborgh3989
    @ragnarborgh3989 Рік тому +1

    A very true video...Had you also had the knife for more than a few days you would have noticed how very easily it RUSTS only great thing about this knife is its sheet but you can't use sheet to survive

  • @stefanosemisa9288
    @stefanosemisa9288 4 роки тому +3

    Esee 5 was my first “bushcraft knife” and now hilariously I discover that it isn’t 😂😂😂 my second one was a Becker BK-2 and my third one the Morakniv Garberg full Tang Carbon steel. And now I’m waiting for a fallkniven S1X and Benchmade Puukko... so basically the BK-2 was my first bushcraft knife... lol

    • @RandallsAdventureESEE
      @RandallsAdventureESEE 4 роки тому +8

      One thing I’ve observed in our classes is that people normally show up with BIG KNIVES. As their skills increase the size of the knife gets smaller and smaller.

    • @Ve-suvius
      @Ve-suvius 3 роки тому +2

      @@RandallsAdventureESEE
      Cody Lundin all the way.
      Mors Kochanski also..
      Axe machete and short knife (saw).
      That's it.
      For most of these guys, those in the video as well, knives are a near fetish.
      Have nothing to do with using it in real life.
      It's just the cool factor.

    • @Ve-suvius
      @Ve-suvius 3 роки тому

      Mora's are perfect for bushcraft.
      No need for 200 euro knives.
      Need, I say.
      If it is want, for the kicks, cool or whatever.
      Yes.

  • @zafkhan4796
    @zafkhan4796 6 років тому

    Best knive channel ever! Greetings from Durban South Africa

  • @alaskaraftconnection-alask3397
    @alaskaraftconnection-alask3397 6 років тому +4

    Interesting stuff guys... We know Esee and Kabar are reputable companies, that make good knives, and furthermore they stand behind products. However, the E-5 and the BK2 are more ingress/egress tools for rescue and survival. They have no bushcraft panache whatsoever, and of course this is not their wrecking crew virtue. You guys are spot on --- this is an urban or man-made construct demolition/survival genre. The E3 E4 E6 have better geometry for woods or wilderness tasks. In companion mode: the E3 piggybacked to a Junglass is one heck of a pair. The BK9 all-arounder I find much more wilderness useful than the BK-2. PS - sure would like to get my hands on that Benchmade PUUKKO.

  • @gunbunny2003
    @gunbunny2003 6 років тому +1

    good video guys! I was never able to take a liking to esee. Their knives are very overpriced for as little design and material that goes into them. I will give them credit on their sheathes though. I am and always have been a Buck brand man. lol I have had my buck nighthawks for 21 years. My favorite ,the 650c, is made like a tank and has served me well both in the U.S. Army and in civilian life. Of course, there are a few things I do not do with my knives; batonning being one of them, chopping another and prying another. I believe carrying a camp axe or a tomahawk is more practical than taking a risk of breaking your most valuable survival/bushcraft tool. Always use the right tool for the job. Your tests are excellent as are your reviews. Even though I wouldn't do most of the things with my knives you guys do with your test subjects, I appreciate the fact you guys do put the knives through hell. It's too bad you guys don't get all the money you have saved your viewers. lol Please keep up the great work and keep having fun.