Will Brighter Shores Change Runescape FOREVER?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 тра 2024
  • Brighter Shores is the next big MMO coming out this year with it's similar style to Runescape and other tabletop RPGs, I decided to go over all the similarities it has with other games and how good this game actually is.
    ➡️Join my Discord - / discord
    ➡️TWITCH - / kriibus
    ➡️Follow me on twitter - / kriibusrs
    ➡️For business inquiries: Kriibusbusiness@gmail.com
    ➡️In-Game Clan Chat: KriibusFC
    Runescape and Old School Runescape are MMORPG by Jagex LTD. Runescape & Old School Runescape both have an active playerbase of thousands of players online every single day. Both games consist of multiple skills, bosses, quests, minigames and adventures to explore. If you are looking for any skilling guides, money making guides or pking for both runescape and old school runescape, make sure to subscribe.
    Created using intellectual property belonging to Jagex Limited under the terms of Jagex's Fan Content Policy. This content is not endorsed by or affiliated with Jagex.
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 149

  • @KriibusRS
    @KriibusRS  20 днів тому +89

    Andrew Gower has made me addicted to one of his other games for almost 20 years now so I'm giving him the minimum respect and atleast giving this game a try and I think you should too.

    • @Osrsezgame
      @Osrsezgame 20 днів тому +5

      100% agree

    • @larsmars2497
      @larsmars2497 19 днів тому +1

      Ye for real not trying it is not an option to me.

    • @sir_1nfamous
      @sir_1nfamous 17 днів тому +2

      Out of respect for him, i will try it out. Out of spite to myself, i will play it daily.

    • @user-kl1nd2ic1c
      @user-kl1nd2ic1c 16 днів тому

      That i would like most done right is that my american visa card is acceptable cause for rune scape couldn't pay through website or the ingame store cause the company that owns the game has a bank in Britain and that bank handles all of the transaction pretty much, since its a British bank its a separate entity from the american visa card thus no compatibility of course theres the steamstore page but your wasting alot of your money rebuying the same starters packs or delux packs over and over again, no option to just directly buy membership

    • @nathanloosemore4141
      @nathanloosemore4141 15 днів тому

      There are banks in the US that will offer global services and a card that will work in the way you you mention. There are options

  • @frankoarseeknee4793
    @frankoarseeknee4793 20 днів тому +30

    Me watching other content on youtube: runescape ambience
    Me watching Runescape content: Hearthstone ambience

  • @healthyminds9279
    @healthyminds9279 17 днів тому +9

    Brighter Shores definitely looks like it's designed to be more psychologically engaging than RS and OSRS from a gameplay perspective. Not too grindy and being strategically challenging, while still feeling like a classic MMORPG. It's probably very fun to play without guides, unlike OSRS where you gotta look everything up to keep up with other players.
    A lot of people won't try this game because they don't like certain "control freak" stuff that Andrew Gower did with Runescape like 20 years ago. But I personally want Brighter Shores to succeed, because it's being made with all the right gameplay psychology in mind, and it's being made for all the right reasons.

  • @DevelKutta
    @DevelKutta 20 днів тому +8

    This strange board-game aesthetic doesn't do a thing for me, and the idea of being room-to-room cuts off my favorite part of MMOs: the open world. Sounds a bit naive to think that a homebrew engine will stand up against the kinds of reverse-engineering and memory skimming that specialized macros are made of, and generic solutions are getting more sophisticated all the time. Premium-only trading also doesn't filter out the big botters that do it for a living (and on a large scale), just the curious players that don't want to risk much.

  • @llToastyratll
    @llToastyratll 20 днів тому +30

    Its hard to get past the artstyle of it. Reminda of rs3 alittle bit.

    • @Solo-Born
      @Solo-Born 19 днів тому +6

      Don’t forget art style is what turns most it players away from oldschool RuneScape, just because it looks similar to rs3 don’t let that turn you away. It could be just as good as OSRS but only time will tell 😊

    • @MattHarner
      @MattHarner 18 днів тому

      Osrs is rs3 just with older graphics, well not so much anymore i guess since theyre releasing hd... osrs is rs3 now

    • @TheCooderix
      @TheCooderix 17 днів тому

      Not a negative like at all.

  • @mufin6930
    @mufin6930 57 хвилин тому

    gower bros are absolute legends

  • @AluviumOSRS
    @AluviumOSRS 15 днів тому +1

    I will support anything that Andrew Gower makes. As an avid OSRS player I'm looking forward to this one.

  • @Noman1000
    @Noman1000 20 днів тому +15

    a homebrew engine just means security through obscurity which is not a good best practice. I'm sure there are anti-botting measures implemented but if there is a will there will be a way.

    • @2147B
      @2147B 20 днів тому

      Its raining and pouring i cant stand it! But i'm not wet have a wonderful day!!@@

    • @moeday99
      @moeday99 18 днів тому

      This.

    • @freshairkaboom8171
      @freshairkaboom8171 17 днів тому

      If it's click to move, there will ALWAYS be ways to easily bot unfortunately. Simulating clicks on certain parts of the screen based on image recognition is so easy, you can set one up in like 30 minutes with ChatGPT's help. Not that it's not detectable, but if you spend even more time making it, it will be. I just hope that those who bot won't impact our experience as much as in RS.

    • @moeday99
      @moeday99 17 днів тому

      @@freshairkaboom8171 If a human created it, computer can do it better. It may not be easy, but it’s doable.

  • @ScopetacticsTheWelsh
    @ScopetacticsTheWelsh 20 днів тому +14

    I'm very much looking forward to Brighter Shores and have it wishlisted, here's hoping it lives up to the hype

  • @carpa6691
    @carpa6691 19 днів тому +21

    Hey Kribus, something you forgot (or maybe didn't know) is that Andrew Gower gave an interview to PC Gamer explaining what he meant by eliminating bots:
    '"Obviously, you're never going to completely eliminate bots," Andrew Gower told PCG in a recent interview, "so our approach has been more to make it so that they don't negatively impact the game." That means all sorts of things, of course: Gower says the studio has "designed the economy of the game so it's not gonna be broken if lots of people bot," and that "the whole way that instancing works [means] you're not gonna be standing in a chunk and there's tonnes and tonnes of bots all around you."
    But it also means something a bit more unorthodox: a "legitimate way" of botting the game.
    Gower says one of the ways Brighter Shores is trying to minimise "grindy gameplay" is with a feature that lets you "set your character to carry on doing [activities] even whilst you're logged out." That means you shouldn't have to spend "hours and hours and hours to get your level up." Instead, you can set your character to get on with the grind while you're away. "You might be doing combat while every night [your character] is doing fishing," or vice versa.'
    So Brighter shores will provide a way to "skip" grinds by AFKing them for less XP. And since botting does risk a big chunk of time investment going into limbo compared to a legitimate, more slower way to level up skills, most people will feel discouraged to bot.

    • @ageofampire2
      @ageofampire2 19 днів тому +2

      Classes afiliations and auto gameplay , welcome to any other generic game from 2007 , but hey here you will train exactly the skills(professions) from other 2007 games , runescape 4 or metin 3? your choice

  • @peterrestine8237
    @peterrestine8237 20 днів тому +4

    😮😮😮 dang this could be wild!

  • @Patwick
    @Patwick 11 днів тому +2

    You deserve way more subs than you have tbh.

  • @cookiemuncher807
    @cookiemuncher807 19 днів тому +3

    It's not going to affect Old School RuneScape at all, because OSRS players aren't attracted to it - it will, however, affect RuneScape 3 a lot. If Brighter Shores could live up to what Gower had promised, lots of RS3 players would probably end up leaving RS3 in drove for Brighter Shores. So we would have thriving and active OSRS and Brighter Shores, with a near dead RS3.

    • @rslerch1113
      @rslerch1113 17 днів тому +1

      I play osrs and I'm attracted to brighter shores

    • @ImBuanana
      @ImBuanana 16 днів тому

      Not everyone plays one game and one game only.

    • @ChunkSchuldinga
      @ChunkSchuldinga 13 днів тому

      ​@@ImBuanana Not everyone has the money for more than one mmo.

    • @ImBuanana
      @ImBuanana 12 днів тому

      @@ChunkSchuldinga I don't really see what your point is but you don't need money to play either rs3 or osrs

  • @evilbee94
    @evilbee94 15 днів тому +1

    It would be nice to try for the fresh start aspect, seeing yourself at the top of the high scores possibly. So far the only announced release is in Q3 of this year, so July at the earliest?

    • @KriibusRS
      @KriibusRS  15 днів тому

      Probably september if I had to guess and we'll get beta testing next month

  • @OLegndz
    @OLegndz 20 днів тому +1

    Excited to see what will come 😄

  • @GuthixLives
    @GuthixLives 16 днів тому +1

    Runescape 4 looks pretty good. I'll definitely try it

  • @Tale_swapper
    @Tale_swapper 15 днів тому

    You know these small instances maps reminds me of the game jagex made on funorb back in the day. It was a runescape styled turn based strategy. I kinda dig it.

  • @HollowNightingale
    @HollowNightingale 20 днів тому

    Thumbnail image looks nothing like Brighter Shores - I doubt I'll give it a shot since im not maxed on OSRS yet lol

  • @aqdrm1291
    @aqdrm1291 16 днів тому

    I fucking love the intro with the slightly increasing bombed out bassboosted weird english/aussie rap. Its such a great vibe.

  • @CaydGaming
    @CaydGaming 12 днів тому

    Things I want to see in an MMO in 2024:
    - Teamwork / Co-Op play
    - Support roles, Tank roles, Ranged DPS, etc.
    - Trading not locked behind a paywall
    Playing an MMORPG is inherently a social thing, so I hope that Andrew Gower can find a way to make this feel more like a party game and less like a solo experience.

  • @CherryQueenFennecFox
    @CherryQueenFennecFox 17 днів тому

    Please tell me that ill be able to play it on my phone

  • @Ructions
    @Ructions 19 днів тому +6

    Jagex are already excited to sue them.

  • @Its_philodox
    @Its_philodox 16 днів тому

    I’m going to need the president of mmorpgs idyl to review this first, but I’d be willing to give it a try

  • @jjw6961
    @jjw6961 20 днів тому +4

    I've had the game wishlisted for a few months and I'm looking forward to it, but I just wish it looked more like osrs than rs3.

  • @Mrmghz1
    @Mrmghz1 12 днів тому

    I may do the start an account and let it bot itself, but i don't see myself playing this game seriously. At least not at the start unless it's more RuneScapey

  • @BrighterShoresCentral
    @BrighterShoresCentral 20 днів тому +3

    Can't wait to play the game. Like that the content will be released in episodes.

  • @shore73
    @shore73 20 днів тому

    Is brighter shores out already?

    • @Osrsezgame
      @Osrsezgame 20 днів тому

      Not yet it’ll be out Q3

  • @Reviveftp
    @Reviveftp 18 днів тому

    love the agro thing like classic

  • @davidbowen9899
    @davidbowen9899 20 днів тому +3

    I'm very excited for brighter shore but I'm a little sad that there wasn't really anything mentioned in this video about runescape 4. I understand that brighter shore could push jagex to building out rs4 but that wasn't mentioned much either. Great video overall. Just a poor title choice. But it did get me to click on the notification so that worked exactly for what it was supposed to I guess.

    • @flansable
      @flansable 20 днів тому

      nice comment, saved me watching the vid

  • @Lampaluile
    @Lampaluile 13 днів тому

    osrs is already mostly by and for gamers so it won't change anything for Rs players. Some will try , fewer will stay

  • @danielrolf3768
    @danielrolf3768 13 днів тому

    I just hope the quest aren't as mind-numbing as they were with rs 3 with NO MORE SLIDERS

  • @Spookspek
    @Spookspek 15 днів тому +1

    I just wish there were no classes... It's what I like about Runescape and Skyrim.

    • @aguitarrist1096
      @aguitarrist1096 10 днів тому

      So you don't like rpgs. Skyrim is the dawnfall of the TES franchise

  • @BallyBoy95
    @BallyBoy95 6 днів тому

    Holy! That's a cool accent.

  • @ChaChaChief
    @ChaChaChief 20 днів тому

    If it wasn't for the highly hypnotising, nerve stimulating shop.
    I'd still play the game.

  • @kenko7735
    @kenko7735 20 днів тому +5

    I can’t wait for RuneScape 6

    • @Alphatangg
      @Alphatangg 20 днів тому

      we'll prolly see it before gta 6

  • @PROJ3CTDARK
    @PROJ3CTDARK 17 днів тому

    J1mmy is shaking in his boots rn

  • @maniacmatt7340
    @maniacmatt7340 19 днів тому

    Competition is a great thing indeed.

  • @FoxyNWolfy
    @FoxyNWolfy 20 днів тому +2

    Cant wait to try out brighter shores

  • @McDelagold
    @McDelagold 20 днів тому

    wrinkle wrinkle little star made me laugh harder than it should have.

  • @omniscientindisplay7217
    @omniscientindisplay7217 16 днів тому

    no bots or rmt?
    how can anyone believe such a claim?

  • @TwinGrimm
    @TwinGrimm 18 днів тому

    Andrew Gower made both games

  • @DrKorvett
    @DrKorvett 20 днів тому +9

    If you can automate keyboard and actions with a script, you can create a bot. Brighter Shores will have bots guaranteed. Arrogant to claim it wont.

    • @stevenalcorn4955
      @stevenalcorn4955 19 днів тому +1

      Well they can’t be ftp bots at least

    • @MooseyMax
      @MooseyMax 19 днів тому

      @@stevenalcorn4955they literally can and probably will be. Why would a botter pay for members before they’re accumulated the items they want to sell.
      It’ll likely have lots of ftp bots, some of them converting into p2p accounts, that gold / item stack being transferred to a main.

    • @divinrth5187
      @divinrth5187 18 днів тому +1

      he didn’t say it won’t, he said there will be few because there is little to gain from it.

  • @user-wz1fy7tl5j
    @user-wz1fy7tl5j 19 днів тому

    When I am hearing you talk about botting all I am thinking is .. "Oh you sweet summer child"

  • @ChunkSchuldinga
    @ChunkSchuldinga 13 днів тому

    At least Brighter Shores is transparent on being pro-bot, giving the player AFK/offline leveling tools. OSRS is just straight up hypocritical being "against the rules" and doing nothing about it. Other than that, I doubt anyone will move.

  • @The90sSkyDweller
    @The90sSkyDweller 18 днів тому

    When yah get all the METAs down etc with 100s of boss camping videos etc I’m in so maybe 5 years after launch

  • @alexgarland2747
    @alexgarland2747 18 днів тому +1

    RIP Osrs 😂

    • @Liam-ci8bx
      @Liam-ci8bx 18 днів тому

      Nah this aint gonna kill osrs, i thought that too initially, but its not actually like osrs.. i mean its not even openworld 🤷‍♂️
      All small things add up, and there seems to be huge amounts of small things that makes it nothing like osrs

  • @walou3917
    @walou3917 20 днів тому +2

    as an average osrs casual player, i would check out brighter shores but wouldnt play on grinding it out like i have runescape all my years playing.

    • @tiestofalljays
      @tiestofalljays 19 днів тому

      It’d be sick if they could offer an account importer - based on your total xp/total lvl/quest points, you get a unique cape or something lol. That’d 100% boost the initial player count for like…no investment. I’d consider it if I were making a new game.

    • @tiestofalljays
      @tiestofalljays 19 днів тому

      This is the first time I’m hearing of Brighter Shores though. If it’s free, yeah I’ll check it out obviously, but I can’t say I’m excited for it or anything. I am interested though.

  • @Xeorty
    @Xeorty 17 днів тому

    Wish they have mobile

  • @Kindofsavvy
    @Kindofsavvy 20 днів тому +7

    I just dont like the look of it myself. Looks like its being released dated. I'm not sure if its done on purpose; however it doesnt have a charm to it.

    • @KriibusRS
      @KriibusRS  20 днів тому +7

      Understandable. I've never cared about graphics personally, that's why OSRS is my favorite game among few other older games, I'm more interested in the stories and since Paul Gower who made most of the quests in OSRS is also making the content in this game, I'm happy to atleast give this game a try.

    • @Kindofsavvy
      @Kindofsavvy 20 днів тому +3

      @@KriibusRS I'll definitely be giving it a try out of respect. But it's not the graphics as much as it is the style. It reminds me of the clayish look of RS3 and that doesn't sit well with me 🤣

    • @AbdullahSediqi23
      @AbdullahSediqi23 20 днів тому

      Osrs has much worse graphics

    • @Pheonixess
      @Pheonixess 20 днів тому +2

      @@Kindofsavvy I agree with you, I much prefer Osrs graphics over RS3 graphics because it's a style. Simple stylized looks over semi-realistic, weird looking models is always way better imo. Kind of the reason I like 2D animation almost every time over 3D cgi looking shows/movies.
      If they really wanted realistic looks, there's the tech for it. Otherwise go for something way more stylized, so it's not semi-realistic characters moving stiff af.

    • @Kindofsavvy
      @Kindofsavvy 17 днів тому

      @@Pheonixess yeah, it just seems soulless and not thoughtful. There's too many games with the same generic graphics.

  • @KillingDemons
    @KillingDemons 16 днів тому

    If you think Andrew Gower wouldn't sell this game for a lot of money you're crazy. Did he need the money when he sold out the first time? No, but he did it anyways.

  • @djh780
    @djh780 16 днів тому

    We're going from RS to BS lol

  • @TehDMBfan
    @TehDMBfan 16 днів тому +1

    You can't run an MMO without revenue. £75m will only get you so far. You've got developers wages to pay

    • @jordanjanice1
      @jordanjanice1 16 днів тому

      It isn’t a free MMO so the revenue will come from membership just like rs pre 2011/2012

    • @oatmeal3795
      @oatmeal3795 15 днів тому

      ????????? It's a subscription service what the fuck are you talking about LMFAO

  • @zmuflahi
    @zmuflahi 18 днів тому

    Mhhwahh 😘

  • @zackeryolsen5502
    @zackeryolsen5502 13 днів тому +2

    it’s gonna be micro transaction heavy 100%

    • @carlshatred931
      @carlshatred931 4 дні тому

      Where the fuck is there any proof of that? Up your ass?

  • @xarbinchaoticneutral1785
    @xarbinchaoticneutral1785 15 днів тому

    Ummmm... wow is sub only and its covered in bots. Membership just means the company will profit off of bots.
    Also L for the click to move gameplay. Ppl play osrs for nostalgia any successor to RS needs to abandon the MUD style or youre going to alienate an entire generation of upcoming gamers. Hell i hate click to move but enjoy osrs for the memories.

  • @Liam-ci8bx
    @Liam-ci8bx 18 днів тому

    As an ironman man, sorry i dont want to trade players. Imo this looks shit, and i think itll either take rs3 players or just die or get an overhaul and be back at the drawing board.

  • @samdense6459
    @samdense6459 18 днів тому

    I wonder if selling RuneScape was Andrews biggest regret. He made bank out of it but his baby got torn to shreds :(

    • @KriibusRS
      @KriibusRS  18 днів тому +2

      He has stated that he regrets selling Runescape in hindsight but I think it was the right thing to do. Securing your financial future for the rest of your life is never a bad option.

  • @trapaspas7923
    @trapaspas7923 13 днів тому

    Bots will take care of this game in month time :)

  • @zoidsfan12
    @zoidsfan12 18 днів тому +1

    I think this game has potential. But I kinda don't like the graphics at all, it smacks too much of rs3 and doesn't feel like it has too much character.
    None of the environments shown in the teasers really speak to me. It all just kinda feels like "yep thats a kitchen".
    Kudos to the dude for trying something so risky. But right now it's not something up my alley.

  • @Priest_Of_Zebak
    @Priest_Of_Zebak 19 днів тому +1

    You can't really compare the 2 games.
    Brighter shores is just temple trecking.
    Osrs is open world.

  • @stanime3065
    @stanime3065 19 днів тому

    If Brighter Shores is succesful it will likely game its playerbase from..Runescape. So the game is actually just bad for RS.
    But if the games good enough i'd quit RS for it, wait and see I guess

  • @mastaches
    @mastaches 13 днів тому

    Seems boring game but looks better than trash eoc mtx RS3 game. OSRS is still far superior when it comes to contents like raids, inferno and colosseum. I hope Brighter Shores can compete with OSRS in terms of high level pvm content.

  • @Osrsezgame
    @Osrsezgame 20 днів тому +1

    I can’t wait to quit osrs. Jagex running it into the ground. High hopes for the new RuneScape

  • @Skeletoxica
    @Skeletoxica 17 днів тому

    No

  • @PSunnyFx
    @PSunnyFx 17 днів тому

    idk the integrity of runescape has been good even with all the owner changes. Jagex makes stupid decisions at times but you can tell with all thier newsletters they really do care about the player base and listen to us. At least comparing to the real greedy shit bags like epic games

    • @MahalGC
      @MahalGC 16 днів тому

      RS3 crawled so that OSRS could walk, and without OSRS Jagex would have gone under a long time ago. I'm sure most game devs have good intentions, but a lot of uncaring business suits and interference from investors is likely the reason why RS3 has gone the way it has when it comes to all the shitty skill-boosting MTX.

  • @jackwolstenholme8213
    @jackwolstenholme8213 13 днів тому

    Ngl it looks like rs3 and it’s off putting.

  • @Jorvalt
    @Jorvalt 16 днів тому

    I'm probably not gonna give it a try because it has that ugly-ass RS3 artstyle. That was one of the big changes to Runescape's direction that I hated.

  • @AlmalekeLoL
    @AlmalekeLoL 18 днів тому

    Didn't watch the video yet. Answer, no it won't. (But it'll be cool)

  • @TheRealCHIMShady
    @TheRealCHIMShady 20 днів тому +1

    zogbot artstyle, horrific stuff

    • @rolingpingu
      @rolingpingu 15 днів тому

      What's zogbot?

    • @TheRealCHIMShady
      @TheRealCHIMShady 15 днів тому

      @@rolingpingu Google

    • @rolingpingu
      @rolingpingu 15 днів тому

      @@TheRealCHIMShady it doesn't show much, besides something that seems to come from the conspiracy theory about ZOG. How is that related to the artstyle?

    • @TheRealCHIMShady
      @TheRealCHIMShady 15 днів тому

      @@rolingpingu you wouldn't get it

    • @rolingpingu
      @rolingpingu 15 днів тому

      @@TheRealCHIMShady just admit it's rambling nonsense

  • @sheengreen864
    @sheengreen864 18 днів тому

    Awww yes RuneScape copy pasta

  • @JJ-en7dv
    @JJ-en7dv 20 днів тому +1

    We are not playing thisb

  • @StzaJack
    @StzaJack 20 днів тому +1

    5th view lessgo

  • @markpicarello7133
    @markpicarello7133 20 днів тому +3

    No way this isn’t an Ad lmao. You speak as if there’s no negatives to the game

    • @KriibusRS
      @KriibusRS  20 днів тому +5

      I'm legally obliged to say if this was an AD, otherwise I would risk losing my partnership on youtube. No, this is not an ad, I just really like the look of this game.

  • @maryjanemj9187
    @maryjanemj9187 20 днів тому

    The only thing gayer than rs3 is rs4

  • @toomuchortoolittle
    @toomuchortoolittle 20 днів тому +4

    unsubbed, was this an ad?

    • @StoveandGarden
      @StoveandGarden 20 днів тому +1

      😂😂😂

    • @metlingaming9162
      @metlingaming9162 17 днів тому +2

      Why would u think this is an add? Its a game made by the rs creator something 99% of rs players would be imterested in

    • @oatmeal3795
      @oatmeal3795 15 днів тому

      Cry more queerbait

  • @Reporting_U
    @Reporting_U 20 днів тому +71

    nah, ill stick to osrs.

    • @christopheduron6181
      @christopheduron6181 18 днів тому +1

      I quit rs ages ago. Mostly because it became p2w, but also because knowing that the game is infested with cheaters and rwters just ruins the experience.
      That's why osrs and especially rs3 are just no options anymore. Those games are corrupted beyond repair.
      I hope this one will fix that. I doubt it, but the least i can do is give it a chance.

    • @mortuumhagl8012
      @mortuumhagl8012 18 днів тому

      ​@@christopheduron6181how is osrs p2w?

    • @divinrth5187
      @divinrth5187 18 днів тому

      @@christopheduron6181how is osrs p2w? and how do cheaters and rwters affect your experience in any way? aside from wildy pking

    • @Liam-ci8bx
      @Liam-ci8bx 18 днів тому +5

      ​@@christopheduron6181 make an ironman in osrs and your sorted

    • @phxntomplanet
      @phxntomplanet 17 днів тому +1

      @@Liam-ci8bx making an Ironman doesn’t solve those problems lol you can literally play a normal account and ignore them.

  • @skellingtongaming9934
    @skellingtongaming9934 20 днів тому +2

    nah game looks trash