I agree with you. I love to watch these types of video late at night, the over the top music makes it so much harder to relax and just enjoy. So, I appreciate this a lot!
"Well look at all this! Wouldn't you believe all this I'm seeing here? By gabagool this is something I am witnissing here!" -Julius Caesar _De Bello Gallico_
The Swabians were integrated in Northwest Iberia, they made Braga their capital and the social organization of the people of Minho was based in the Swabians and that was one of the main reasons why Portugal became independent of Spain.
@firstjedi2 Mercedes and Porsche are based in Stuttgart, which is in Schwaben, a German region that has its name from the Suebi (people are called the same). Cars, movement, migration, that sorta connection.
@@thekillers1stfan The video already goes into how nobody is really consistent with their use of tribal names. The Duchy of Swabia (lat. Suevia) was one of the stem duchies of the HRE. Initially it also was called Duchy of Alemannia (lat. Allemaniae) - which should explain where it came from; namely the Alemanni. But ultimately Swabia stuck around as a name for part of the region (though both Swabian and Alemannic are used for various purposes; ie Swabian is an Alemannic dialect ...).
Cool video, the town of Swaffam England is conjectured to come from the Swabians, also Tacitus even refers to the Angles as Suebi Angli. Cheers from Mercia
I am Brittas boyfriend, being member of current Schwaben, prefering speaking my dialect over speaking Standard German. In case of of settlements many current towns or villages date back to Alemannic tribal age ( graveyards). A typical settlements name ends with -ingen. Somewhere i read, this - ingen and british -ingham have the same root.
@@antonyreyn : Somewhere i read , that in current english Nottingham would mean Nott's Farm. In my swabian homeregion there is a villlage Notzingen, according to an accademic person , who told me, this - ingen ending means: settlement of ....'s men/followers, and ... is a no more known name of a local leader. So the family/ clan leader , who founded Notzingen could have Had also the name Nott or Notz. A in my Homeregion often told story, that a man from Baltmannsweiler founded Baltimore is of course a joke,
@@brittakriep2938about the „Ingen“ and the „Heim“ I know something, that I found out in a Museum about the Alemanni (Swabians). Apparently, the ending „Ingen“ like in „Bissingen“ was used for settlements on good land, that was fertile. The ending „Heim“ like in „Höpfigheim“ was used for settlements that had been built on less fertile ground, second class settlements so to say. 😂 I dont know if this is 100% true, its what was written in the text of the Museum in „Ellwangen“.
As portuguese, I have to remember the suebs on Iberia were converted by Martinho de Dume, the bishop of would-be named Braga, which was the suebs capital. He also changed the names of weekdays names from latin to new ones, which were retained on modern portiguese (segunda-feira for Monday, terca-feira for Tuesday, etc), which is different from Castilian, which retained the old latin names (Lunes, Miercoles).
Hebrew (and I'm presuming Arabic) just number the days of the week except for their rest day. I didn't know there were European languages that did as well.
@@rohitrai6187 all I can say from observation is that in the countryside outside the city, there is a high proportion of country folk who look blonde / Germanic. Distinct from the typical Portuguese which is the majority in the city. We also have references to the Suebi written in walls of old churches.
@@rohitrai6187 so I would say, very likely yes. I have one friend in particular who I call “the Suebi” because he’s so differently built and blonde. It’s funny because if you get in a car and drive to the countryside, you start seeing mostly blonde, Germanic-looking people.
The slang term for Germans used by the Poles to this day is "Szwaby" (pronunciation is very close to "Suebi"). Not considered a very polite term but then again we've been such great neighbors.
My bulgarian grandfather used to call germans "Шваби" (Shvabi) as well. Usually when he talked about them angrily, if not he called them just "Немци" or, more rarely, "Германци".
This was a great video, from the narration to the writing to the maps showing geographical features often omitted such as the thick forests that served as soft borders between Rome and the Germans. Instant sub and highly encourage you to continue.
As a student of linguistics, I thank you for the linguistic information on the changes of suebi linguistically as it turned me onto a realization and tell of human progress. Languages transform as seen in the francification of english after the norman conquest, the katakanization aka europeanization of Japanese after the Boshin war, and numerous other examples. These changes in the ancient world reflect the clear introduction of the powerhouse Latin into the region. The inference that I make is that there is a very clearly defined window after this linguistic change where the language changes if we look at it also reflects then again into where these people end up roughly 300 years from that linguistic change. Put plainly, linguistic changes are like rings on a tree which reflect the interaction of some major regional connection and then predate the revirbiration of the afterparty. Grewat work tying so much multi science layering into your video.
The fair descriptions of the sources is so great. I also love the maps. I dislike when creators fact dump and focus on "the vibe" without including maps
Never forget about your ancestors.......We are them, they were not savages, they knew how to live off the land, and they were warriors, and werent afraid to fight for it. The system, and the elites would love for you to believe your ancestors were savages, and that nothing they did was of importance. A people is defined by what times they live through. Thise were dangerous times, and our people adapted to that. We are in times now where we will have to adapt again and fight for our own. Our ancestors are right with us. Slainte!
Governments wanting to colonise an area will do that (try to convince you your ancestors were barbarians without any culture worth remembering or keeping alive), not the system. Thus, the French, English etc claimed they were civilising their colonies and refused to consider these colonies too had a proud and very interesting history and culture. There is the other extreme: a government that emphasises the past glory of a culture (like the Uk government at the moment) in order to advocate for that silly act of self-harm called Brexit, or the French far right trying to make the people believe the French are going to be swamped by invaders and must save their civilisation. The best way to save a civilisation is to seduce: the Romans managed it (as we could hear from the way some Suevi joined the Romans) to make people want to become Roman citizens. Seduction :). A lot of what the Romans were about is carried further by western Europe, because of this "seduction". It would be easy to resent it...but at the same time, they did write about the people they subjected, and there was a form of respect in their descriptions.
@@jasrajsandhu1658 What did í just say in my comment? Can you read? I said they were not savages. They adapted, and they were warriors, they fought hard for their people. Where did í say they were tree huggers? They were quick to war. And fighting just like some of us are today. But that doesn't equate to savages. They were also family oriented, and despised degeneracy. Read it again. 1.4.8.8.⚡️⚡️
@@annepoitrineau5650 Agreed. There are alot of parallels between ancient Rome, and what is going today. Except today this is about whether our people die out or not. If we don't wake up, there won't be a European people to speak of. They are using many tools to destroy and erase us.
The Suebi faced frequent attacks from other Germanic tribes, as well as from the Visigoths, who eventually conquered their kingdom in the 6th century. After their defeat, the Suebi gradually assimilated into the larger Visigothic society, and their culture and language disappeared. Despite being a conquered population, the Suevi are generally left in peace in Gallaecia, and they eventually blend into the general population of Iberia. 712 A.D. TO 725 A.D.; The descendants of the Suevi remain relatively free of Islamic influence in north-western Iberia during the early years of occupation. Around 725 they are appended to the recently-formed Christian kingdom of Asturias, which is based a little to the east, on the Bay of Biscay.
I liked your video. One observation: since in Latin writing the letters U and V are written the same, Suebi could just as well be more Svebi. Seeing how the Germans known as Schwaben (pronounced shvaben) have made it through all these centuries into the modern days, I find it more likely that the original pronunciation was closer to Svebi.
Terrific video. Well structured, good pacing, and informative. I feel like this was done well enough both for the amateur and the more learned. Earned a sub! It'd be great if in the video description you listed your notes/sources for those who want to try and dig up more info. Looking forward to more videos like this!
Very good video, smoothly presented & executed, with appropriate attribution to sources and analysis. Top shelf, subscribed & look forward to more like this. So many "barbarian" tribes, voluminous potential.
It is worth noting that a military general's observation of a people he is regularly only in contact with to kill is obviously going to be painted in a certain light. Imagine Caesar coming home and writing a book about how chill all the natives were, about the women/children they massacred, or how uneventful the trip was lol. Wouldn't exactly make for a thrilling narrative that pushes ones career forward.
On the other hand, given his position Caesar was likely to have interacted with these people directly whereas scholars were procuring second hand information mostly. Notwithstanding Caesar's biases his accounts should be taken as more direct knowledge than that of the average scholar.
The Suebi kingdom of the Northwest Iberian Peninsula is the root of the future kingdom of Portugal. Northern Portugal has the highest concentration of Germanic place names. The Portuguese city of Braga was the capital of the Suebi Kingdom.
You are wrong. The root of the Kingdom of Portugal, León and Castile was the Kingdom of Asturias. The Asturians were the first to defeat the Muslims invaders. The Kingdom of Asturias resisted Moors attacks and started the Reconquista. 160 years later the asturian nobleman Vimara Pérez the grandson of the Asturian King Bermudo I, was the first count of Portugal. Vimara was a vassal of the King of Asturias Alfonso III, and was sent to reconquer and secure from the Moors the área from the Minho river to the Douro River including the city of Portus Cale, from where the name of Portugal emerged. Without the Asturians Portugal and Spain did not exist.
Very interesting video thank you. I´m from Coruña Galicia (NW Spain), the village of Suevos is a 10 mnt drive from my place, in fact I have to drive through it more often than not to get to & from work. I grew up in the UK, for the most part of my childhood we lived in a small village on the outskirts of Cambridge, Swavesey! 😅 Belive it or not I hadn´t connected the dots before watching your video, but It suddenly dawned on me how modern Europeans have far more in common than we think, or at least than what I was aware of.
In the West of Romania we have a germanic minority called "Șvabi" (in Banat), related to "Sași" from the center of Transylavia. I think they might be the same or related to "Suebi". Or perhaps a name coincidence.
they are the descendants of settlers colonised at the end of the 18th century by the Habsburgs. In Germany they are known as the "Banatenschwaben" (the Swabians from Banat). And they came not only from Swabia, but also from Alsace, Lotharingia, the (Rhein) Palatinate. So, they are "related" to the Suebi, like all other Germans living in South Germany today, but didn´t came in the region in the antique period. And they have nothing in common with the Transylvanian Saxons, who came (also as colonists) in the 13th century: they speak different dialects, have different religions (most of the Saxons are lutheran, the Schwabs are almost all catholic) etc.
Hi this was an interesting video. I think it would benefit from having more depictions (paintings or otherwise) of the Suevi and their lifestyle. For example, the painting of the settlement in the forest at the beginning was impressive and it helps relate to the content. The first bit about categorisation I thought could have been shorter and instead spend more time describing these people and their lifestyle
Don't forget, the Roman writers often used the 'barbarians' as examples of toughness, in deliberate contrast to Romes soft & effete leaders, the noble Senators etc who had subjected themselves to tyranical Emperors. They were actually 'bigging up' the barbarians, so their descriptions stress the more virtuous, if somewhat chaotic, way of life of such people. The Roman attitude to the 'barbarians' did not have the negative connotation most people think, but they were admired, as examples of people living a more natural life than that of the City dwellers. They were regarded as the 'noble savage', worthy warriors, often better than the degenerate Citizens of Rome.
Just found this and subscribed. Please do the Attacotti of the Great Conspiracy fame. Or the Bacaudae - the armed peasant rebels of the late Roman Period. Thanks :)
The Schwaebisch are not just some lost historical tribes. My paternal grandmother was of Schwaebisch origins; although born in the US, she spoke only German until 1st grade. She and her brother had a distinctive accent (that included a slight lisp). I was able to identify a German immigrant who was married to one of the teachers at my high school, by his accent, as Schwaebisch. I have not heard that accent since 1968 but would identify it instantly. It’s a rather soft-sounding accent. I would like to hear it again.
They didn't want to be conquered, controlled, taxed and confined by the empire, so they were labeled uncivilized Barbarians. How dare they strive for independence and freedom.
I don't think we can label the Germans as good guys and the Romans as the villains. The Germans initiated many of the wars. One of the most devastating was the Cimbrian War of 113 to 101 B.C. (not mentioned in this video).
@@RobertWF42 The Germans were tribal and localized. They were not an ever expanding empire that tried to subjugate all under their authority. They broke up into various tribes illustrating this. They only united to throw off the yoke. The Germanic Franks were infiltrated. They turned on them and made sure the Alemanni all fell under the HRE. This fact, and WWII is why there is animosity between many Germans and French (Germanic) today. The eagle of Rome has landed in many places.
@@RobertWF42 The American Indians (Indigenous peoples-like the Alemanni) initiated many conflicts as their lands were being overrun . The calvary (as Rome) defeated them although they won many battles. Rome used the Franks (an Alemanni tribe) to subdue the Germanic tribes and instituted the HRE. The Indigenous (Old Europeans) were largely replaced by the Indo-Europeans. The eagle of Rome came to the Americas as well. The aim is the same.
I wonder if there is any connection between "suebi" or "suabi" and the term "swoi". The word "swoi" in Polish is quite peculiar. It has translation into English that can be rendered "our own" or in German "unser eigenes". It is known to be used by local persons living in a particular area as the self-description when those persons have not felt particular association with their country/rulers. In some remote locations it was used even as long as in 20th century for locals living in a particular location for many generations to distinguish themselves from the overlords who would come and go. It is common that the tribes names, or even later country names are not the invention of their own members but come from the foreigners who they had contact with. When they would be asked "who you are" they often had different name than those which were passed by historians etc. Possibly some word similar to "swoi" or "suebi" was commonly used back in the day by lots of people who later became classified as Germans, Slavs or other.
In Farsi and English bad has the same meaning and almost pronunciation. But the two "bads" couldn't possible be related because of the consonant switches in old Germanic. So you must always be careful when two words look the same and have similar meanings. It could be coincidence, or it might even be folk etymology, with people changing the meaning of a phrase because it looks like something they know from another language. But the good news is that 90% of all etymologists believe you are right. Suebi and swoyi are related. Swoje and swoyi are also used in Russian by the way, and even so more many years ago, before "nashi" became the normal word for "our own people". Today Russians seem to use nashi more and more to mean Slavic-speaking people who were BORN outside of Russia, BUT in the former Soviet Union. Since Russian-speaking Buryats are not really "nashi" will they again become "swoyi" one day? The other 10% of etymologists believe that Suebi is derived from a Celtic word meaning vagabond or nomad. it could therefore be an insult, like "niemiec".
@@swedhgemoni8092 yes. In order of probability: Bavarians>Saxons>Swabians>Prussians Bavaria and Saxony are still federal states so people will know about them Way more then the other two. Prussia isnt around for a long time so you will be hard pressed to find anyone who knows them except people who are interested in history. For many their history knowledge starts at WW1. For some WW2 even.
I'm half Swiss. I know the Alamanni (my ancestors) where a confederation of mixed Germanic peoples, so I assume a lot of Suebi were in there. I always wondered why the moved to Switzerland because its a much more hostile environment and closer to Rome. Did they just do it as a giant raid on the Roman settlements for loot? It's unfortunate we don't have much information on them.
@@JustAnotherHistoryChannel I would love that. Since we never formed a kingdom or empire, we preserved the democracy from the Alamanni. Our Landsgemeinde (which is where we get our Direct Democracy from) is literally a continuation of the Germanic assembly called Thing.
Dud Suebi are Srbi, because the Latins can't pronaunce 3 consonant one after the other they changed R to UE. And it is common that B changed to V in Greek and Latin.
Fascinating. If you want deep work on an episode in Germanic history you should seek out the chronicles of England where Wotan is mentioned as both ancestor to the Cynneric royal family as well as a witch king, who in the early English reckoning expanded a cult even to the Welsh. The same chronicle mentioned 'Gotha' (words 'great', 'good', & 'God' come from this) along with a few others with virtually no information i was able to find. It was in reaearching Tolkiens nonfiction that I came across these mentioned & I dont now own these chronicles.
I first learned about the Suebi from one of the Anglo-Saxon clans who were Suebi called Angriavarii. The Saxons were multiple tribes and one of them were Suebi.
Markomanni means border-men or forest/wilderness-men. Forests and wilderness areas were often natural borders separating different tribes. Compare «Markland» the name given to Newfoundland by Leiv Eriksson. As well as the modern Norwegian counties Hedmark and Finnmark.
Yeah their main area of influence was northern portugal and galicia wich ended up with a distint culture very simililar to each other(have been sister nations to the modern day even, but it's changing with the depopulation of galicia, and young peple adopting castilian over their motger tongue for more opportunities these days) And some say the suebi kingdom may have been a proto portugal/Galicia of sorts Also an interesting fact is that portuguese can sound slavic to some people and its theorized it may be suevi influence
I think it's possible that "Suebi" could be a term like "Vikingr".I remember reading that they were gifted land bordering Gaul and paid by Caeser to keep the Celts in check.So they were probably raiding in the area before happening upon the Romans.I can imagine Caesar asking who they were and a tribesman replying we are "Suebi" meaning raiders/raiding and the name stuck.Its possible just saying.So many terms have been used to refer to Germanic tribes, yet I think some were lost in translation.
Nothing to do with Viking, at all. Vikings only came about many centuries later. Their history is very well documented, at least here in Portugal. This video is just an overview, touching the most important points. Pretty much, the Kingdom of Portugal emerges from this older Suevi Kingdom.
@@5naf6 Die Siebenbürger Sachsen (Deutsch. Orden 13.Jh.) are not all Saxons. The Donauschwaben (KuK Monarchie 18.Jh.) are from allover Germany / Austria.
Huh, seems the geats/goths (götar) was already at large in continental europe, and the suebe may have been the descendants of swedes (sitones/suiones)? Interesting how there was a shared culture in the suebi which reached up to sweden. It's common historical knowledge in sweden that the swedish peninsula once had 2 dominant peoples - the swedes (svear) and the geats (götar) - and they fought for dominance. The swedes eventually won and the geats mysteriously disappeared from sagas and records. Many speculate the surviving geats fled to continental europe and became the goths. Mayhaps some swedes also fled and became the suebi...
Kingdom of de Suebi in Spain is Galizia, Asturias, Leon, Salamanca, Zamora y North Portugal post with Visi Goths is Kingdom (VisiGoth) of Leon. And post is Kingdom de Leon and Castilla.
I think it’s likely the Chatti of Caesar’s time were in allegiance with the Suebi and therefore he was deferred to them. Caesar had German horsemen in his army, the nuances wouldn’t have been lost on him if they were relevant to the time. The century and half later when Tacitus was writing it was a different political situation among the tribes.
I have a question, is there any way to see a larger version of the tiny image to the right of the screen which appears in the last few seconds of the video and brings up the subscribe box?
So Arius gets slapped by Nicholas, Alexandria gets sidelined, and German converts are deemed heretics for believing that God and Jesus are not co-eternal. And yet they adopt the Nicene creed that states that the father begat the son just before the start of time. Alot of eventual chaos and death for a minor rewording of the same idea.
It's not the same idea, I'm not very well versed in theology but those who are will tell you that the father begetting the son is outside of time. The existence of the son necessitates that there is a father and vice versa, not that the father spawned the son after his own being.
It would have helped if the Romans documenting the geograpghical areas of the Suevi also included physical descriptions for indentification purposes since it appears the tribes cannot be defined beyond the two or so mentioned. Being tall really does not tell you much.
Maroboduus was also a Roman educated German like Armenius. I was surprised how he was able to craft what was basically the first Germanic state with a pseudo capital named after himself.
I've never thought of the Romans since leaving school and the only other time more recently is the British Parliament pushing how great Rome is/was by highlighting Rome on new £50 and £100 Gold & Silver coinage 🤔
I'm Brazilian and I tested positive for Haplogroup I-m253 ( my father too), which is found mainly in Nordic men (35% Sweden, 50% Gotland) even more than in Germany (16%). My grandfather came from the North of Portugal (Suebi territory in the past) to Brazil. Paternal Y DNA is passed from father to son over millennia without significant mutations, so you see exactly who your male ancestors were without error. In my case, my male ancestors are Suebi.
I did wonder about their roots hoever another question I had and went unanswered was their relation to the Allamani, who also lived in Suabia and seem to me indistinct from the Suevi.
As far as I'm aware, the Alemanni could well be considered as part of the wider group we call 'Suebi'. They are first mentioned in sources in the 3rd Century, so a little later than some of the other named suebi tribes like the Hermanduri and Langobardi. But the Alemanni definitely seem to have lived in the regions which could be considered to be suebi territory.
@@JustAnotherHistoryChannel - It was an Alamanni count (Burchard) who first established the Duchy of Swabia. Not sure why he chose that name unless the two nations are connected. The Alamanni are known to have lived in the same region since c. 260 CE and the French name for Germany (Allemagne, also Spanish Alemania, etc.) derives from them. Wikipedia ("Suebi" entry) says: "In 259/60, one or more groups of Suebi appear to have been the main element in the formation of a new tribal alliance known as the Alemanni who came to occupy the Roman frontier region known as the Agri Decumates, east of the Rhine and south of the Main. The Alamanni were sometimes simply referred to as Suebi by contemporaries, and the region came to be known as Swabia - a name which survives to this day".
@@LuisAldamiz With the constant evolution and mixture of the Germanic peoples its hard to exactly pinpoint things like these, but in line with what The Histories said, I would say the Alemanni are a group that evolved from the Suebi incorporating other tribal groups as well. However it does seem some historians and linguists theorise that the Alemannic language was derived or large in part influenced by the Suebi. With all that in mind I think it's fair to picture the Alemanni as descendants of the Suebi. Also as for Allemagne and Alemania that is likely because the Alemanni were one of the largest Germanic people groups with the fall of Rome and the rise of Francia, so its likely that the Gallo-Romance people of France and Spain collectively referred to the German peoples as Alemanni. The Alemanni of Swabia were also one of the tribal groups that gradually mixed together with the Saxons, Bavarians, Thuringii, and Franks to form the modern German identity.
@@Francis-qu2iu - Yes, looks like. My take on the Allemagne denomination is that the French elites thought of themselves as Frankish German, so what was left to the East after the partition would be (especially after the Saxon takeover) "not Francia and only partly Germania", hence Allemania, definitely those Alamani were not part of the Frankish, right? These ancient disputes continue today in Internet forums, with the French typically claiming the share of the lion of Frankish descent, even if they are so obviously wrong that they speak Vulgar Latin (with very strong German accent but Latin anyhow).
@@JustAnotherHistoryChannelthanks for the great content 🤓 @LuisAldamiz interestingly Alman(ya) and Almanca are Germany/German in Turkish..... interesting reading and listening, certainly, it does demonstrate the vastness and long shadow of influence from the Roman Empire 🤔
Theres also a few other tribes who were suebi like the Sciri, Bucinobantes, and Dulgubini. I don't even know who the last group are. Plus Nemetes, Varisci, Triboce. Who i also don't know anything about.
Great video. Two brief comments. 1. What is called 'Catholicism' didn't exist in the 5th century. What modern Roman Catholics believe is medieval. 'catholic' meant the universal church. Often texts get misquoted in this way. 2. Arianism was a spectrum. The Jesus was created is a position that was abandoned very quickly my most Arians. Most arians were Semi-arian, which was itself a spectrum in roughly 4 categories. A. The Father created the Son out of his own essence. The Son is co-equal, but not co-eternal. B. The Father eternally generates the Son (in an unorthodox way). The Son is Co-eternal but not co-equal. C. Binitarianism. The Father & Son are both co-equal & co-eternal. But the Holy Spirit isn't a person, just a force. D. Trinitarians who rejected Nicene language who wanted to use biblical language only. The specific beliefs of individuals are probably impossible to know. But probably The Goths were a mixture of A,B, & C. I doubt there was much of D. Because that party largely caved & eventually excepted Nicene language.
I think he got confused with the area in Denmark with a similar name. As modern Denmark was in what the Romans called Germania, technically, he's right that way, though in a modern sense, yes, he's wrong.
Suebi bloodline can be found in north Spain and north portugal plus in the Hispanic Americas special in Puerto Rico and Cuba in the central mountains with mix ancient Iberians celts bloodlines.The love for freedoms mountains horses and simplicity in the mountains cant be missed.The color of the skin the body structure as well the hot blooded nature in fighting is beyond everything else the pride and honor with in themselves is far genetics from ancient times all this bloodlines can be seen in the Spanish inquisition Christian kingdom brother hood bloodlines the will power to survive conquer and everything else can't be ignored or compare to any other human being in earth.real simple
Thank you for not putting super dramatic obnoxious music in this video.
I agree with you. I love to watch these types of video late at night, the over the top music makes it so much harder to relax and just enjoy. So, I appreciate this a lot!
Ditto!
I think it’s kinda cute that Caesar saw all these clearly mid-migration tribes and was like “yes they eat their pack animals and don’t trade much.”
"Well look at all this! Wouldn't you believe all this I'm seeing here? By gabagool this is something I am witnissing here!"
-Julius Caesar _De Bello Gallico_
Yes, Julius Caesar is often said to have been “cute,” lol.
@@Historian212I love his cute lil totally not balding head 🥰🥰🥰😍😍🤩
@@DISTurbedwaffle918great. Now I'm imagining Caesar talking like the Sopranos. "Hey, Mark 'Tone, you seein' this?"
@@McBrannon1000 "He conquered Gaul is what he did! He was a great Roman general! And in this house Julius Caesar is a hero! End of story!"
Love your style: the thumbnails, assets, maps, etc. come together really well. This channel needs more attention.
The Swabians were integrated in Northwest Iberia, they made Braga their capital and the social organization of the people of Minho was based in the Swabians and that was one of the main reasons why Portugal became independent of Spain.
It’s a great accompaniment to your own channel :)
Agreed aside from the weird AI images spliced in every once in a while
Krauts. Jerries. Goosesteppers
,,goosesteppers,,🤣🤣 never heard that before, great
Their history as a migratory tribe is of course still visible today in the obsession with building Porsches and Mercedeses.
😂
@firstjedi2 Mercedes and Porsche are based in Stuttgart, which is in Schwaben, a German region that has its name from the Suebi (people are called the same).
Cars, movement, migration, that sorta connection.
Mercedeseses
Are you Portuguese? That's where the Suebi ended up
@@thekillers1stfan The video already goes into how nobody is really consistent with their use of tribal names.
The Duchy of Swabia (lat. Suevia) was one of the stem duchies of the HRE. Initially it also was called Duchy of Alemannia (lat. Allemaniae) - which should explain where it came from; namely the Alemanni.
But ultimately Swabia stuck around as a name for part of the region (though both Swabian and Alemannic are used for various purposes; ie Swabian is an Alemannic dialect ...).
Please do more Celti-Germanic tribes.
The specific tribes get overlooked way too often and you did a phenomenal job. 🤩
The Suebi were not Celtic
@ You missed the part where I said Germanic my dude. ;)
Cool video, the town of Swaffam England is conjectured to come from the Swabians, also Tacitus even refers to the Angles as Suebi Angli. Cheers from Mercia
I have been to Swaffham and I had no idea about this! Very interesting
I am Brittas boyfriend, being member of current Schwaben, prefering speaking my dialect over speaking Standard German. In case of of settlements many current towns or villages date back to Alemannic tribal age ( graveyards). A typical settlements name ends with -ingen. Somewhere i read, this - ingen and british -ingham have the same root.
Cool i am in Nottingham, but i also think about the Rune Ing and the language Ingaevonic which Anglo Saxon is part of. Cheers
@@antonyreyn : Somewhere i read , that in current english Nottingham would mean Nott's Farm. In my swabian homeregion there is a villlage Notzingen, according to an accademic person , who told me, this - ingen ending means: settlement of ....'s men/followers, and ... is a no more known name of a local leader. So the family/ clan leader , who founded Notzingen could have Had also the name Nott or Notz.
A in my Homeregion often told story, that a man from Baltmannsweiler founded Baltimore is of course a joke,
@@brittakriep2938about the „Ingen“ and the „Heim“ I know something, that I found out in a Museum about the Alemanni (Swabians).
Apparently, the ending „Ingen“ like in „Bissingen“ was used for settlements on good land, that was fertile.
The ending „Heim“ like in „Höpfigheim“ was used for settlements that had been built on less fertile ground, second class settlements so to say. 😂
I dont know if this is 100% true, its what was written in the text of the Museum in „Ellwangen“.
As portuguese, I have to remember the suebs on Iberia were converted by Martinho de Dume, the bishop of would-be named Braga, which was the suebs capital. He also changed the names of weekdays names from latin to new ones, which were retained on modern portiguese (segunda-feira for Monday, terca-feira for Tuesday, etc), which is different from Castilian, which retained the old latin names (Lunes, Miercoles).
So, what happened to prima-feira?
So, wait, Portuguese weekdays begin with Sunday, like in English (at least, traditionally)?
@@fuferito Domingo Segunda Terça Quarta Quinta Sexta Sábado.
@@crqf2010rulerObrigado por nos educar.
Hebrew (and I'm presuming Arabic) just number the days of the week except for their rest day. I didn't know there were European languages that did as well.
This is the content I crave. Actual information
I am from Braga, the old Suebi capital. We still have much of their legacy around, mixed in with the Roman.
Are there any descendants who can trace themselves to Suebi?
@@rohitrai6187 all I can say from observation is that in the countryside outside the city, there is a high proportion of country folk who look blonde / Germanic. Distinct from the typical Portuguese which is the majority in the city. We also have references to the Suebi written in walls of old churches.
@@rohitrai6187 so I would say, very likely yes. I have one friend in particular who I call “the Suebi” because he’s so differently built and blonde. It’s funny because if you get in a car and drive to the countryside, you start seeing mostly blonde, Germanic-looking people.
Don't you love how the video says they settled in Northwestern Spain instead of northwestern Iberia 🙄
@@rohitrai6187Yes, the whole country
The slang term for Germans used by the Poles to this day is "Szwaby" (pronunciation is very close to "Suebi"). Not considered a very polite term but then again we've been such great neighbors.
😂
Can you translate what insult it's supposed to mean
In Croatia we do the same - Švabe.
@@petergeramin7195 It translates to "Germans".
My bulgarian grandfather used to call germans "Шваби" (Shvabi) as well. Usually when he talked about them angrily, if not he called them just "Немци" or, more rarely, "Германци".
This was a great video, from the narration to the writing to the maps showing geographical features often omitted such as the thick forests that served as soft borders between Rome and the Germans. Instant sub and highly encourage you to continue.
The real Suebi were the friends we made along the way.
Thank you totally not sans, very cool
As a student of linguistics, I thank you for the linguistic information on the changes of suebi linguistically as it turned me onto a realization and tell of human progress. Languages transform as seen in the francification of english after the norman conquest, the katakanization aka europeanization of Japanese after the Boshin war, and numerous other examples. These changes in the ancient world reflect the clear introduction of the powerhouse Latin into the region. The inference that I make is that there is a very clearly defined window after this linguistic change where the language changes if we look at it also reflects then again into where these people end up roughly 300 years from that linguistic change.
Put plainly, linguistic changes are like rings on a tree which reflect the interaction of some major regional connection and then predate the revirbiration of the afterparty.
Grewat work tying so much multi science layering into your video.
Amazing
What? It's easy to spot students.
As a barbarian myself, i feel quite informed.
now please shave your beard and put on a toga
Same here❤
Nah, you aren't one, because 1 you are the same genetically as them 2 you don't have the same facial features as them nor are blond as them
😮🤓
@g.dalfleblanc63 you aren't rest assured lol, there's NO known cherusci samples, read a book
Really interesting video, always excited to see an upload from this channel.
The fair descriptions of the sources is so great. I also love the maps. I dislike when creators fact dump and focus on "the vibe" without including maps
You can never have enough maps!
Great and informative video. I'm really glad UA-cam recommended it to me. That's one well earned subscription for you
Thanks for all that research and compilation. Your delivery is excellent.
This is exactly the video I was looking for. Thank you!!
Never forget about your ancestors.......We are them, they were not savages, they knew how to live off the land, and they were warriors, and werent afraid to fight for it. The system, and the elites would love for you to believe your ancestors were savages, and that nothing they did was of importance.
A people is defined by what times they live through. Thise were dangerous times, and our people adapted to that. We are in times now where we will have to adapt again and fight for our own. Our ancestors are right with us.
Slainte!
Nah our ancestors took over other people's lands, get over it, they weren't tree hugging peace loving people, they enjoyed war
Governments wanting to colonise an area will do that (try to convince you your ancestors were barbarians without any culture worth remembering or keeping alive), not the system. Thus, the French, English etc claimed they were civilising their colonies and refused to consider these colonies too had a proud and very interesting history and culture.
There is the other extreme: a government that emphasises the past glory of a culture (like the Uk government at the moment) in order to advocate for that silly act of self-harm called Brexit, or the French far right trying to make the people believe the French are going to be swamped by invaders and must save their civilisation. The best way to save a civilisation is to seduce: the Romans managed it (as we could hear from the way some Suevi joined the Romans) to make people want to become Roman citizens. Seduction :). A lot of what the Romans were about is carried further by western Europe, because of this "seduction". It would be easy to resent it...but at the same time, they did write about the people they subjected, and there was a form of respect in their descriptions.
@@jasrajsandhu1658 What did í just say in my comment? Can you read? I said they were not savages. They adapted, and they were warriors, they fought hard for their people. Where did í say they were tree huggers? They were quick to war. And fighting just like some of us are today. But that doesn't equate to savages. They were also family oriented, and despised degeneracy. Read it again.
1.4.8.8.⚡️⚡️
@@annepoitrineau5650 Agreed. There are alot of parallels between ancient Rome, and what is going today. Except today this is about whether our people die out or not. If we don't wake up, there won't be a European people to speak of. They are using many tools to destroy and erase us.
@@jasrajsandhu1658 Where did í say they were tree huggers? Can you read?
Great video! Love your stuff man
I love hearing about more obscure history, im super pleased to have found your channel! :D
First time I've been seen this channel. Enjoyed learning about the Suebi history well narrated too I must say. Thanks for sharing 👍😊
That was one of the best historical videos I’ve ever seen on UA-cam. Subscribed.
The Suebi faced frequent attacks from other Germanic tribes, as well as from the Visigoths, who eventually conquered their kingdom in the 6th century. After their defeat, the Suebi gradually assimilated into the larger Visigothic society, and their culture and language disappeared. Despite being a conquered population, the Suevi are generally left in peace in Gallaecia, and they eventually blend into the general population of Iberia.
712 A.D. TO 725 A.D.; The descendants of the Suevi remain relatively free of Islamic influence in north-western Iberia during the early years of occupation. Around 725 they are appended to the recently-formed Christian kingdom of Asturias, which is based a little to the east, on the Bay of Biscay.
Suebi are Swebians, Swedens, Svea.
or better known Gothic swedes
what occupation?
Really love how this combines great history content with a found-footage vibe.
I liked your video. One observation: since in Latin writing the letters U and V are written the same, Suebi could just as well be more Svebi. Seeing how the Germans known as Schwaben (pronounced shvaben) have made it through all these centuries into the modern days, I find it more likely that the original pronunciation was closer to Svebi.
V would have been pronounced as U in Latin though
@@lucadefranco3420 not always, for example the word victory. Sometimes U, sometimes V
Terrific video. Well structured, good pacing, and informative. I feel like this was done well enough both for the amateur and the more learned.
Earned a sub!
It'd be great if in the video description you listed your notes/sources for those who want to try and dig up more info. Looking forward to more videos like this!
Very good video, smoothly presented & executed, with appropriate attribution to sources and analysis. Top shelf, subscribed & look forward to more like this. So many "barbarian" tribes, voluminous potential.
It is worth noting that a military general's observation of a people he is regularly only in contact with to kill is obviously going to be painted in a certain light. Imagine Caesar coming home and writing a book about how chill all the natives were, about the women/children they massacred, or how uneventful the trip was lol. Wouldn't exactly make for a thrilling narrative that pushes ones career forward.
On the other hand, given his position Caesar was likely to have interacted with these people directly whereas scholars were procuring second hand information mostly. Notwithstanding Caesar's biases his accounts should be taken as more direct knowledge than that of the average scholar.
The word barbarians didn’t used to have a negative connotation it just referred to foreigners.
No. The Romans called others Barbar because that was how the foreign language sounded to the Romans. They heard "bah bah bah" hence Barbar
Where’d you come up with that ?
They 100% used barbarians qs a slur for thought barbarian (foreigners) were low iq people unlike them the civilized
Best presentation of the period that I've seen! Well done!
The ominous blood red on the black background in the fraktur script is going to trigger someone lol.
this production quality made me think you had 100s of thousands of subs this is so next level!!
The Suebi kingdom of the Northwest Iberian Peninsula is the root of the future kingdom of Portugal. Northern Portugal has the highest concentration of Germanic place names. The Portuguese city of Braga was the capital of the Suebi Kingdom.
You are wrong. The root of the Kingdom of Portugal, León and Castile was the Kingdom of Asturias. The Asturians were the first to defeat the Muslims invaders. The Kingdom of Asturias resisted Moors attacks and started the Reconquista. 160 years later the asturian nobleman Vimara Pérez the grandson of the Asturian King Bermudo I, was the first count of Portugal. Vimara was a vassal of the King of Asturias Alfonso III, and was sent to reconquer and secure from the Moors the área from the Minho river to the Douro River including the city of Portus Cale, from where the name of Portugal emerged.
Without the Asturians Portugal and Spain did not exist.
Very interesting video thank you. I´m from Coruña Galicia (NW Spain), the village of Suevos is a 10 mnt drive from my place, in fact I have to drive through it more often than not to get to & from work. I grew up in the UK, for the most part of my childhood we lived in a small village on the outskirts of Cambridge, Swavesey! 😅 Belive it or not I hadn´t connected the dots before watching your video, but It suddenly dawned on me how modern Europeans have far more in common than we think, or at least than what I was aware of.
so well produced! the music and the visuals, wow
Great video, my new favorite channel since Cambrian Chronicles
In the West of Romania we have a germanic minority called "Șvabi" (in Banat), related to "Sași" from the center of Transylavia. I think they might be the same or related to "Suebi". Or perhaps a name coincidence.
Likely just a name meaning “Germans”
they are the descendants of settlers colonised at the end of the 18th century by the Habsburgs. In Germany they are known as the "Banatenschwaben" (the Swabians from Banat). And they came not only from Swabia, but also from Alsace, Lotharingia, the (Rhein) Palatinate. So, they are "related" to the Suebi, like all other Germans living in South Germany today, but didn´t came in the region in the antique period. And they have nothing in common with the Transylvanian Saxons, who came (also as colonists) in the 13th century: they speak different dialects, have different religions (most of the Saxons are lutheran, the Schwabs are almost all catholic) etc.
@@stancalung5186 All relevant facts, thank you!
In Bulgaria the word Svabi (Шваби) is used to describe all Germans. This has nothing to do with this tribe
Perfect Podcast Voice….
Hi this was an interesting video. I think it would benefit from having more depictions (paintings or otherwise) of the Suevi and their lifestyle. For example, the painting of the settlement in the forest at the beginning was impressive and it helps relate to the content. The first bit about categorisation I thought could have been shorter and instead spend more time describing these people and their lifestyle
Don't forget, the Roman writers often used the 'barbarians' as examples of toughness, in deliberate contrast to Romes soft & effete leaders, the noble Senators etc who had subjected themselves to tyranical Emperors. They were actually 'bigging up' the barbarians, so their descriptions stress the more virtuous, if somewhat chaotic, way of life of such people.
The Roman attitude to the 'barbarians' did not have the negative connotation most people think, but they were admired, as examples of people living a more natural life than that of the City dwellers. They were regarded as the 'noble savage', worthy warriors, often better than the degenerate Citizens of Rome.
We do the same as the Romans….Conan!
I enjoyed your video. You have a great voice. That voice kept me to stay and watch to the end. I love history.
Thank you
❤️🙏❤️
Just found this and subscribed. Please do the Attacotti of the Great Conspiracy fame. Or the Bacaudae - the armed peasant rebels of the late Roman Period.
Thanks :)
The Schwaebisch are not just some lost historical tribes. My paternal grandmother was of Schwaebisch origins; although born in the US, she spoke only German until 1st grade. She and her brother had a distinctive accent (that included a slight lisp). I was able to identify a German immigrant who was married to one of the teachers at my high school, by his accent, as Schwaebisch. I have not heard that accent since 1968 but would identify it instantly. It’s a rather soft-sounding accent. I would like to hear it again.
They didn't want to be conquered, controlled, taxed and confined by the empire, so they were labeled uncivilized Barbarians. How dare they strive for independence and freedom.
I don't think we can label the Germans as good guys and the Romans as the villains. The Germans initiated many of the wars. One of the most devastating was the Cimbrian War of 113 to 101 B.C. (not mentioned in this video).
@@RobertWF42 The Germans were tribal and localized. They were not an ever expanding empire that tried to subjugate all under their authority. They broke up into various tribes illustrating this. They only united to throw off the yoke. The Germanic Franks were infiltrated. They turned on them and made sure the Alemanni all fell under the HRE. This fact, and WWII is why there is animosity between many Germans and French (Germanic) today. The eagle of Rome has landed in many places.
Which empire was expanding and controlling many people in much of Europe and the Mediterranean for over 500 years???
@@RobertWF42 The American Indians (Indigenous peoples-like the Alemanni) initiated many conflicts as their lands were being overrun . The calvary (as Rome) defeated them although they won many battles. Rome used the Franks (an Alemanni tribe) to subdue the Germanic tribes and instituted the HRE. The Indigenous (Old Europeans) were largely replaced by the Indo-Europeans. The eagle of Rome came to the Americas as well. The aim is the same.
@@RobertWF42 There were no Germans at the time. They were not confederate. They were loose tribes of Germanic peoples called the Alemanni Deutsch.
Fun Fact: some of the suebi have migrated eaven further east and now occupy the territory between bornholmer straße and torstraße
I wonder if there is any connection between "suebi" or "suabi" and the term "swoi". The word "swoi" in Polish is quite peculiar. It has translation into English that can be rendered "our own" or in German "unser eigenes". It is known to be used by local persons living in a particular area as the self-description when those persons have not felt particular association with their country/rulers. In some remote locations it was used even as long as in 20th century for locals living in a particular location for many generations to distinguish themselves from the overlords who would come and go. It is common that the tribes names, or even later country names are not the invention of their own members but come from the foreigners who they had contact with. When they would be asked "who you are" they often had different name than those which were passed by historians etc. Possibly some word similar to "swoi" or "suebi" was commonly used back in the day by lots of people who later became classified as Germans, Slavs or other.
In Farsi and English bad has the same meaning and almost pronunciation. But the two "bads" couldn't possible be related because of the consonant switches in old Germanic. So you must always be careful when two words look the same and have similar meanings. It could be coincidence, or it might even be folk etymology, with people changing the meaning of a phrase because it looks like something they know from another language.
But the good news is that 90% of all etymologists believe you are right. Suebi and swoyi are related. Swoje and swoyi are also used in Russian by the way, and even so more many years ago, before "nashi" became the normal word for "our own people". Today Russians seem to use nashi more and more to mean Slavic-speaking people who were BORN outside of Russia, BUT in the former Soviet Union. Since Russian-speaking Buryats are not really "nashi" will they again become "swoyi" one day?
The other 10% of etymologists believe that Suebi is derived from a Celtic word meaning vagabond or nomad. it could therefore be an insult, like "niemiec".
Really interesting. Good video. Lots of info but not boring.
Outstanding presentation, thanks!
They still exist. Every German knows the Swabians.
They exista even in Romania
Gotta tell you most germans dont. Its also bot really part of the school curriculum
@@busch_ii7450 You're telling me Germans within the country don't know about Saxons, Bavarians, Prussians, Swabians etc.?
@@swedhgemoni8092 yes. In order of probability: Bavarians>Saxons>Swabians>Prussians
Bavaria and Saxony are still federal states so people will know about them Way more then the other two. Prussia isnt around for a long time so you will be hard pressed to find anyone who knows them except people who are interested in history.
For many their history knowledge starts at WW1. For some WW2 even.
@@busch_ii7450 Sigh, this is actually sad. They didn't even properly celebrate the 2000 year anniversary of the Battle of Teutoberg Forest.
I'm half Swiss. I know the Alamanni (my ancestors) where a confederation of mixed Germanic peoples, so I assume a lot of Suebi were in there. I always wondered why the moved to Switzerland because its a much more hostile environment and closer to Rome. Did they just do it as a giant raid on the Roman settlements for loot? It's unfortunate we don't have much information on them.
I'd quite like to do a separate video on the Alemanni specifically - it's a fascinating topic and I know very little about it
@@JustAnotherHistoryChannel I would love that. Since we never formed a kingdom or empire, we preserved the democracy from the Alamanni. Our Landsgemeinde (which is where we get our Direct Democracy from) is literally a continuation of the Germanic assembly called Thing.
Comfy video ❤❤❤ wish there was more of this on UA-cam
Serbians often call germans Schwabi... Шваби in Cyrillic ... Just thought I'd throw that out there since I'm a Serbian/Hungarian person myself ...
Dud Suebi are Srbi, because the Latins can't pronaunce 3 consonant one after the other they changed R to UE. And it is common that B changed to V in Greek and Latin.
Fascinating. If you want deep work on an episode in Germanic history you should seek out the chronicles of England where Wotan is mentioned as both ancestor to the Cynneric royal family as well as a witch king, who in the early English reckoning expanded a cult even to the Welsh. The same chronicle mentioned 'Gotha' (words 'great', 'good', & 'God' come from this) along with a few others with virtually no information i was able to find. It was in reaearching Tolkiens nonfiction that I came across these mentioned & I dont now own these chronicles.
I first learned about the Suebi from one of the Anglo-Saxon clans who were Suebi called Angriavarii. The Saxons were multiple tribes and one of them were Suebi.
Love your aesthetic here
Well done, indeed! Hope this channel grows and more people are exposed to your works.
I was not aware of the Suebi. Thanks for putting them in their context among the Germanic forest tribes
hahaha... I was honestly just wondering this a few days ago.
Thanks
Markomanni means border-men or forest/wilderness-men. Forests and wilderness areas were often natural borders separating different tribes. Compare «Markland» the name given to Newfoundland by Leiv Eriksson. As well as the modern Norwegian counties Hedmark and Finnmark.
The English Kingdom of Mercia, & the Marches of Wales & the Scottish borders are of the same root.
Great story, the time frame was a bit scattered but informative overall. Thx. for the info. 👍
One half of my family is Galacian and Portuguese and the other half is Asturian, love my ancestral homeland
Very well done. Thank you.
0:39 the Danube was THE border. So placing it with a substantial offset to the border of the Roman Empire is just pure sloppiness in video creation.
Danube wasnt border everywhere.
It seems like where they were in Iberia later became Portuguese speaking. Did they have an influence on that in some way?
Yeah their main area of influence was northern portugal and galicia wich ended up with a distint culture very simililar to each other(have been sister nations to the modern day even, but it's changing with the depopulation of galicia, and young peple adopting castilian over their motger tongue for more opportunities these days)
And some say the suebi kingdom may have been a proto portugal/Galicia of sorts
Also an interesting fact is that portuguese can sound slavic to some people and its theorized it may be suevi influence
Great channel TH!!
Subscribed, some of these Germanic tribes don’t get enough coverage.
Great vid. Subbed
I lived in Stuttgart for five years ... the Swabians are a pack of savages ... and I love them!
I think it's possible that "Suebi" could be a term like "Vikingr".I remember reading that they were gifted land bordering Gaul and paid by Caeser to keep the Celts in check.So they were probably raiding in the area before happening upon the Romans.I can imagine Caesar asking who they were and a tribesman replying we are "Suebi" meaning raiders/raiding and the name stuck.Its possible just saying.So many terms have been used to refer to Germanic tribes, yet I think some were lost in translation.
Suebi are Swebians. Sweden Goths. Sveans.
Nothing to do with Viking, at all. Vikings only came about many centuries later.
Their history is very well documented, at least here in Portugal. This video is just an overview, touching the most important points.
Pretty much, the Kingdom of Portugal emerges from this older Suevi Kingdom.
loved it. subd and liked!
We had in region Banat of Romania, Suebi. They were called Shvabs! They were colonized in 17 siecle and all left for Germany after 1990!
Yes, the „Banater Schwaben“ in German.
Die Siebenbürger Sachsen ?
@@antonpressingBanater Schwaben and Siebenbürger Sachsen are not the same!
@@5naf6 Die Siebenbürger Sachsen (Deutsch. Orden 13.Jh.) are not all Saxons. The Donauschwaben (KuK Monarchie 18.Jh.) are from allover Germany / Austria.
Researching about the faceless factions dealt with in Total War is so interesting.
It would have been interesting with some etymological analysis is Suebi, if possible. What did the name mean to them?
Huh, seems the geats/goths (götar) was already at large in continental europe, and the suebe may have been the descendants of swedes (sitones/suiones)? Interesting how there was a shared culture in the suebi which reached up to sweden. It's common historical knowledge in sweden that the swedish peninsula once had 2 dominant peoples - the swedes (svear) and the geats (götar) - and they fought for dominance. The swedes eventually won and the geats mysteriously disappeared from sagas and records. Many speculate the surviving geats fled to continental europe and became the goths.
Mayhaps some swedes also fled and became the suebi...
Thanks! Love ancient history!
Kingdom of de Suebi in Spain is Galizia, Asturias, Leon, Salamanca, Zamora y North Portugal
post with Visi Goths is Kingdom (VisiGoth) of Leon.
And post is Kingdom de Leon and Castilla.
I think it’s likely the Chatti of Caesar’s time were in allegiance with the Suebi and therefore he was deferred to them. Caesar had German horsemen in his army, the nuances wouldn’t have been lost on him if they were relevant to the time. The century and half later when Tacitus was writing it was a different political situation among the tribes.
I have a question, is there any way to see a larger version of the tiny image to the right of the screen which appears in the last few seconds of the video and brings up the subscribe box?
So Arius gets slapped by Nicholas, Alexandria gets sidelined, and German converts are deemed heretics for believing that God and Jesus are not co-eternal.
And yet they adopt the Nicene creed that states that the father begat the son just before the start of time.
Alot of eventual chaos and death for a minor rewording of the same idea.
It's not the same idea, I'm not very well versed in theology but those who are will tell you that the father begetting the son is outside of time. The existence of the son necessitates that there is a father and vice versa, not that the father spawned the son after his own being.
@@giw_jones Jesus: What is this pagan heresy? God is like humans, prophets and angels. They will disagree with you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
It would have helped if the Romans documenting the geograpghical areas of the Suevi also included physical descriptions for indentification purposes since it appears the tribes cannot be defined beyond the two or so mentioned. Being tall really does not tell you much.
Two towns in Flanders called 'Zwevegem' and 'Zwevezele'.
DId the Swabian Language make Galician & Portuguese different from Spanish and Catalan?
Maroboduus was also a Roman educated German like Armenius. I was surprised how he was able to craft what was basically the first Germanic state with a pseudo capital named after himself.
There were a number of Swabian units, Cohorts & Numeri, in northern Britain around Hadrian's Wall, from the 2nd/3rd centuries.
I've never thought of the Romans since leaving school and the only other time more recently is the British Parliament pushing how great Rome is/was by highlighting Rome on new £50 and £100 Gold & Silver coinage 🤔
I'm Brazilian and I tested positive for Haplogroup I-m253 ( my father too), which is found mainly in Nordic men (35% Sweden, 50% Gotland) even more than in Germany (16%). My grandfather came from the North of Portugal (Suebi territory in the past) to Brazil. Paternal Y DNA is passed from father to son over millennia without significant mutations, so you see exactly who your male ancestors were without error. In my case, my male ancestors are Suebi.
Or your grandfather was a sailor.
@@kristofschneider601 that's a possibility
Could be a refugee nazi
Food for thought at any point did the Romans use the term suebi as a derogatory for other German inhabitants at the time??
That is what this video says to me. One single germanic tribe (or coalition of tribes) existing over 5 centuries is simply not possible.
“Which many of us think about regularly”😭💀
I did wonder about their roots hoever another question I had and went unanswered was their relation to the Allamani, who also lived in Suabia and seem to me indistinct from the Suevi.
As far as I'm aware, the Alemanni could well be considered as part of the wider group we call 'Suebi'. They are first mentioned in sources in the 3rd Century, so a little later than some of the other named suebi tribes like the Hermanduri and Langobardi. But the Alemanni definitely seem to have lived in the regions which could be considered to be suebi territory.
@@JustAnotherHistoryChannel - It was an Alamanni count (Burchard) who first established the Duchy of Swabia. Not sure why he chose that name unless the two nations are connected.
The Alamanni are known to have lived in the same region since c. 260 CE and the French name for Germany (Allemagne, also Spanish Alemania, etc.) derives from them.
Wikipedia ("Suebi" entry) says: "In 259/60, one or more groups of Suebi appear to have been the main element in the formation of a new tribal alliance known as the Alemanni who came to occupy the Roman frontier region known as the Agri Decumates, east of the Rhine and south of the Main. The Alamanni were sometimes simply referred to as Suebi by contemporaries, and the region came to be known as Swabia - a name which survives to this day".
@@LuisAldamiz With the constant evolution and mixture of the Germanic peoples its hard to exactly pinpoint things like these, but in line with what The Histories said, I would say the Alemanni are a group that evolved from the Suebi incorporating other tribal groups as well. However it does seem some historians and linguists theorise that the Alemannic language was derived or large in part influenced by the Suebi. With all that in mind I think it's fair to picture the Alemanni as descendants of the Suebi.
Also as for Allemagne and Alemania that is likely because the Alemanni were one of the largest Germanic people groups with the fall of Rome and the rise of Francia, so its likely that the Gallo-Romance people of France and Spain collectively referred to the German peoples as Alemanni. The Alemanni of Swabia were also one of the tribal groups that gradually mixed together with the Saxons, Bavarians, Thuringii, and Franks to form the modern German identity.
@@Francis-qu2iu - Yes, looks like.
My take on the Allemagne denomination is that the French elites thought of themselves as Frankish German, so what was left to the East after the partition would be (especially after the Saxon takeover) "not Francia and only partly Germania", hence Allemania, definitely those Alamani were not part of the Frankish, right?
These ancient disputes continue today in Internet forums, with the French typically claiming the share of the lion of Frankish descent, even if they are so obviously wrong that they speak Vulgar Latin (with very strong German accent but Latin anyhow).
@@JustAnotherHistoryChannelthanks for the great content 🤓
@LuisAldamiz interestingly Alman(ya) and Almanca are Germany/German in Turkish..... interesting reading and listening, certainly, it does demonstrate the vastness and long shadow of influence from the Roman Empire 🤔
Theres also a few other tribes who were suebi like the Sciri, Bucinobantes, and Dulgubini. I don't even know who the last group are. Plus Nemetes, Varisci, Triboce. Who i also don't know anything about.
Great video. Two brief comments.
1. What is called 'Catholicism' didn't exist in the 5th century. What modern Roman Catholics believe is medieval. 'catholic' meant the universal church. Often texts get misquoted in this way.
2. Arianism was a spectrum. The Jesus was created is a position that was abandoned very quickly my most Arians. Most arians were Semi-arian, which was itself a spectrum in roughly 4 categories.
A. The Father created the Son out of his own essence. The Son is co-equal, but not co-eternal.
B. The Father eternally generates the Son (in an unorthodox way). The Son is Co-eternal but not co-equal.
C. Binitarianism. The Father & Son are both co-equal & co-eternal. But the Holy Spirit isn't a person, just a force.
D. Trinitarians who rejected Nicene language who wanted to use biblical language only.
The specific beliefs of individuals are probably impossible to know. But probably The Goths were a mixture of A,B, & C. I doubt there was much of D. Because that party largely caved & eventually excepted Nicene language.
Osterby is not in Southern germany as mentioned in the video. it is in northern germany.
I think he got confused with the area in Denmark with a similar name. As modern Denmark was in what the Romans called Germania, technically, he's right that way, though in a modern sense, yes, he's wrong.
Drinking game : take a shot everytime narrator says Suebi
*dies*
My family is from Swabia which originated the word from suebia
Suebi bloodline can be found in north Spain and north portugal plus in the Hispanic Americas special in Puerto Rico and Cuba in the central mountains with mix ancient Iberians celts bloodlines.The love for freedoms mountains horses and simplicity in the mountains cant be missed.The color of the skin the body structure as well the hot blooded nature in fighting is beyond everything else the pride and honor with in themselves is far genetics from ancient times all this bloodlines can be seen in the Spanish inquisition Christian kingdom brother hood bloodlines the will power to survive conquer and everything else can't be ignored or compare to any other human being in earth.real simple
Who was savage and warlike??
First and foremost the Romans!
Very interesting. Thank you.
Where's the music?