Tastefully done video. No robot voice. No intrusive music. No hideous thumbnail. Concise script. Subscribed. One suggestion. Make all the visuals full screened.
Really appreciate that you don't add obnoxious "epic" music to your videos and opt for more ambient music to enhance the sense of "gazing into the past"
Because quite cleverly creators have noticed that a lot of us listen going to sleep and if we listen and fall asleep it's a win win because you get sleep and they get more money because if you're not on premium the videos play all the way through ads and all
Something different on a UA-cam history channel? Actually a LOT right here. Dark maps with abstract materials and only the most pertinent details for one. Low volume ambient music aimed at deepening your attention without drawing attention to itself is another. And, finally, crisp writing delivered with voice actor quality speech. Oh, and supporting graphics moving in and out like thoughts. This is a triumph in so, so many ways. Outstanding! Brilliant actually.
This is a well-done, reasoned piece. It begins, however, with a mischaracterization of Herodotus’ reference to the Phoenicians’ origins. The narrator claims Herodotus believed that they had emigrated from southern Arabia (near present day Yemen) or East African coast (near present day Eritrea). Herodotus did NOT claim to believe that this origin story was true or likely correct. He merely relayed this theory in “The Histories,” while expressing his doubts of its validity.
There's a costal city in Oman called Sur which is famous for its ship building history, does that remind you of anything? Sur, is the same name of the most important kan'ani (Phoenician) city Sur (Tyre in English) and there has been some findings of kan'ani (Phoenician) script in Oman. I don't think that is a coincidence. The idea that Phoenicians came from Arabia isn't as hard to believe as you think.
There's also claim of phoenician inscriptions all over the Mediterranean seas reaching up to Ireland. Could be some phoenicians who reached the area. Not that they came from here. @yuzan3607
With the almost mesmerizing music in the back, a professional voice and a very well presented video, im shocked that this channel doesnt have more subscribers. Fantastic video!
Very well done. Very informative. This is much better than the History chanel which is so absured with its historians adding their worthless and most of the time inaccuracies. Thank you. Keep up the good work.
Perseus, the great "Greek" hero, was Canaanite/Phoenician, as was Cadmus, who founded Boetia and Thebes. Pretty sure Mycenea was a Phoenician outpost as well.
How can you say this info is historically accurate when the narrator says all of this info is “believed to be” ! Short of speculation! Study from the peoples of those lands, not European colonizers who benefit from misinformation…
Love these videos. I'm very new to this channel and appreciate you addressing some of the more fringe (but plausible) theories about ancient societies. I'd love it if we could get a list of sources that you use for your videos. I'm always on the lookout for more books and articles to read about topics like this!
@@vanbalzup6481 That's why I asked for sources. Fringe wasn't an insult. Sometimes, unpopular theories are correct. I was just differentiating between plausible and implausible theories. For example, the Phoenicians coming from Dilmun (Bahrain) is plausible. The Phoenicians getting their seafaring abilities from aliens is implausible.
If someone feels the necessity to correct the video I wish they would explain and show their sources of knowledge. How they learned this all important jewel of information.
Great video though a suggestion would be to put your sources in the description. In part to legitimize the video itself, but Also to aid in further reading
Cannanites/hyksos were Caucasian semetics possibly like proto celt Scythians they mixed with local semetics when they came into Canaan … the Hyksos/cannanite /sumerians were the Caucasians that brought the blue eyed gene into the levant .. meanwhile the Scythians/aryans spread the blue eyes gene around Iran Russia and Germany … phonecians weren’t from Arabia… if you look hard enough you will see the Carthaginians depict themselves and Roman’s slightly similar except Carthaginians have red and brown hair meanwhile Roman’s have both brown blown and red hair…
@@lo-fihi-ki5699 Phoenician remains not only show genetic relation to Arabia but so is their culture. Greco-Roman historians also have said the Phoenicians are from the Erythean sea near around Arabia....
its maybe not so helpful to display phoenician 'empire' as big purple clouds on the map and more useful to simply have points on the map where their cities were. they certainly werent known for farming LOL especially in much of north africa where the hinterland berbers and such remained virtually uncontacted by the phoenicians
You are right, the purple was intended to show areas of Phoenician influence and trade activity but perhaps does come off looking a bit like a traditional empire! I will add a note to the description
they made dye from murex shellfish but we're not the inventors. The Minoans produced the dye in large quantities for export long before the Mycenaens took over Crete and it is likely the Phonecians came to Med trade in general. wonderful narrative thanks for your effort!
🍌THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age in which God is saving man from the imminent destruction of this old world" (The transformation of a person's disposition is not a change of behavior, or a feigned external change or a temporary change produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a real transformation of disposition that brings about a change in behavior. The transformation of disposition means that you have understood and experienced the truth, and that truth has become your life. Now that your disposition has changed, you not only understand the truth, but you also act on it. You are able to let go of the things you felt like doing the other day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. This is a transformation of disposition, and it is also the process of transforming your disposition. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. Only after experiencing all this can a person partially understand his own nature. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. In this process, you will understand some things about yourself, and you will realize that you are very impure, harbor too many personal motives, and have too many desires while fulfilling your duties. Once you have understood the meaning of these things, you will be able to approach God in prayer and truly repent; in this way, you will be cleansed of impurities. The more one's corrupt disposition is refined, the more the disposition of their life will change.) Almighty God said The TRANSFORMATION of a PERSON'S DISPOSITION is NOT a CHANGE of BEHAVIOR, or a FELT EXTERNAL CHANGE or TEMPORARY DIFFERENCE produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a REAL CHANGE of DISPOSITION which CAUSES a CHANGE in BEHAVIOR. Such a change in behavior is not the same as changes manifested in a person's outward behaviors and actions. The TRANSFORMATION of the DISPOSITION MEANS that YOU have UNDERSTOOD and EXPERIENCED the TRUTH, and the TRUTH has BECOME YOUR LIFE.🌷 In the PAST, you UNDERSTOOD the TRUTH of this matter, BUT you did NOT put it into PRACTICE; the truth is only doctrine to you that is not practiced. NOW that your DISPOSITION has CHANGED, you not only UNDERSTAND the TRUTH, but you also ACT ACCORDING to IT. You are LETTING GO of the THINGS you LOVED to do back in the day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. 🙏🌷 You are now ABLE to GIVE UP THINGS that you COULDN'T GIVE UP back in the day. This is DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION, and it is also the PROCESS of your DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION.🌷 It may sound simple, but in REALITY, ANYONE in the MIDDLE of this PROCESS has to ENDURE a LOT of SUFFERING, OVERCOME their FLESH, and LEAVE the FLESH ASPECTS of NATURE. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. 🙏☀️ Only AFTER EXPERIENCING ALL of this can a person partially understand his own nature. HAVING a little UNDERSTANDING about it, however, does NOT mean IMMEDIATELY being able to CHANGE a PERSON; MAN must ENDURE SUFFERINGS in the PROCESS. 🙏 Also, can you immediately start practicing after gaining some understanding of something? You cannot immediately start a practice. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. Sometimes, people are not ready to go through it, saying, "Why can't I do it that way? Do I have to do it this way?" Others say, "If you believe in God, then you should do it this way is true." WHEN people REACH a CERTAIN POINT where they have gone through SEVERAL TRIALS and ENDED up UNDERSTANDING WITH GOD'S will and some TRUTH, then they will be HAPPY no matter what and ready to act ACCORDING to TRUE PRINCIPLES. In the beginning, people were reluctant to practice the truth. Take conscientious fulfillment of duties as an example: You have a little understanding of fulfilling duties and being faithful to God, and you also understand the related truths, but when will you fully devote yourself to God? When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. Some people may correct you, others may criticize you. All eyes will be on you, and only then will you begin to realize that you are in the wrong and that the truth is that you have done something bad, that the lack of devotion to fulfilling your duty is unacceptable, and you should not be rash and careless. The HOLY SPIRIT will ENLIGHTEN you FROM WITHIN, and rebuke you when you sin. IN this PROCESS, you will UNDERSTAND some THINGS ABOUT YOURSELF, and YOU will REALIZE that you are VERY IMPURE, HARBOR too MANY PERSONAL MOTIVES, and have too MANY DESIRES while FULFILLING your DUTIES. ONCE you have UNDERSTOOD the MEANING of these THINGS, you will be ABLE to APPROACH GOD in PRAYER and TRULY REPENT; in this WAY, you WILL be CLEANSED of IMPURITIES. ☀️🙏 If, in this way, you often seek the truth to solve your own practical problems, you will gradually tread the right path of faith. The MORE one's CORRUPT DISPOSITION is PURIFIED, the MORE the DISPOSITION of their LIFE will CHANGE. 🙏 From "Should Know About Changing a Person's Disposition" Fulfillment in (Ezekiel 2: 9-10) and in (Revelation 19: 9,13) 📥Calling and leading everyone to His lowered Kingdom or Church because it is still standing on earth in the holy place in the air/ youtube "THE CHURCH OF ALMIGHTY GOD 💐 this is the fulfillment of what He said to Peter 2,000 years ago, recorded in (Matthew 16:18'19). This is the the only Church of each one of our spirit that we must listen to or eat and drink like how we eat, dress and sleep every day so that He can guide us and change us by rejecting the evil attached by satan so as to be perfect, having attained eternal life that will enter the coming replacement of the New Heaven and New Earth. 💌
Does anybody know much about the nation of Ebla? Their kingdom seems to have been north east of Phoenicia. I am wondering if Ebla ever occupied Phoenici, of vice versa? Info online is limited. As i understand Ebla was mainly destroyed by Hittites, perhaps thats why that area is marked as Hittite on this video? This content is fantastic and informative
Is the spelling Beirut as Beruit in this video intentional or not? Other place names, like Tyre, appear to be the modern English version, so why is Beirut not spelled in the usual way?
I give you credit for doing something. And there's a couple of interesting bits of information in the video, but overall I hope this is not how the history of the Phoenicians is being taught in our universities, there or here. The quote by Aristotle was telling, and shows the corrupt techniques haven't changed much. Who knew what's going on in the western world today had its origins so far back. I bet they didn't call them ngos though. Also the point about the Phoenicians building and piloting and crewing the Persian ships is one that's often overlooked, and helps explain Alexander's wrath at the city not capitulating. He had pretty much had enough of that, much in the same way the Romans would deal with the thrice invading Carthaginians. Also I'm pretty sure the Greeks and Romans were pretty good at recognizing human sacrifice when they saw it and child sacrifice, and the archeology in this case as well as in Britain seems to be bearing out the veracity of their writings. No doubt they were a fascinating culture, hell bent on colonization and the use of proxy armies to do their killing. Their ambitions let them to invade and battle with the Greeks and Italians on their own shores for centuries, and eventually they just ran out of luck and people to die for them.
You got lots of missinformations in your post 1. Persian fleet on mediterranean had 3 battle groups, one made of Phoenicians, other of Egyptians and third of Aegean Greeks. Greeks cities in Asia minor were Persian allies and gave both land army (hoplites) and navies for the persian military machine 2. Macedonians were also Persian allies during Greco-Persian wars. Macedonians conquered both Sparta and Athens, both Spartans and the Atheninians hated Alexander and didn't gave their armies to fight for Alexanders campaign. Ancient world was centered around city states as political realities, not ethnic groups as we have today 3. Romans practiced human sacrifices, see what happened after Cannae 4. Italics and Greeks participated in Punic ethnogenesis, they immigrated to Carthage for centuries and assimilated themselves into Punics. After Roman conquest of Southern Italy mass of Brutinians fled to Carthage. Hannibals army was made mostly of people from the Italian penisula, both Padanian Gauls and Italics, after Cannae almost all of southern Italy deflected to Hannibal. You re looking at the ancient world from a modern day perspective which is decieving.
@@ivandicivan4189 Well the funny thing is, I was actually doing the exact opposite and somehow you missed that. Most of the revisionism surrounding the Carthaginians is occuring in modern times. I never mentioned anything about their particular ethnicities, I'm quite aware that their general makeup was similar to other Mediterranean groups, Greco/Italic. You can look at Phoenician coffins and Roman busts of Hannibal Barca to see that with your own eyes. My observation that Alexander's anger at the Phoenicians for building the ships of his enemies must have been boiling stands. I'm well aware that the Persian navy and army in general was made up of many peoples most of whom joined either because they were conquered or the great fear of having their territories raped and destroyed. Including Greek polities. I never commented on the latter and the former is useful information you've added to what I said about the ships, but doesn't alter the veracity of my comment. Ethnogenesis? That sounds like you're the one confusing and transposing modern ideas on ancient ones. Italy was invaded and colonized for 700 years or more? And became the target of Alexander's generals after his death. They learned and then they got really really good at fighting back. You never hear much about the pre-roman invasions colonization and "ethnogenesis" in Italy. The Gauls came through and had a time long before Caesar took revenge. As for human sacrifice the majority of scholars agree that that was rarely ever practiced in any organized form by the Greeks or Romans, and the Romans in particular were completely against it as a society.
@@vincentcarrano5121 You claimed that alexander destroyed Tyre out of revenge, which makes no sense becuse during Greco-persian wars Macedonians were allies of Persia, and persian admiral was a king of Sidon. Phoenicians of Sidon were competitors of Tyrians and provided ships for Alexander during his siege of Tyre. Italics were fighting each others for centuries and some of the fiercest wars Romans fought were against the Samnites. Cisalpine Gauls have politically nothing to do with transalpine ones, and were assimilated by Romans anyway. The fact that someone is Gaul, or Italic, or Numidian, or whatever, means little to nothing in political sense since ancient people lived in the city states and tribes which acted for their own interest, and there is where their allegiance lied, to the city state or tribe, not to the macro-group. Romans scrificed vestal virgins after defeat at Cannae. It was a time of great desparation, you can compare that to similar cases in Carthage, like invasion of Agatocles for example-most of scholars who believe in existance of those sacrifices believe it was a practice which occured in times of a great crisis and not everyday practice.
Thank you for this very interesting video! I didn't know the old stories about the possible origins of the Phonecian peoples. This was excellent! God be with you out there, everybody. ✝️ :)
Another great video. Supposedly, guys are obsessed with the Romans. Well, I'm obsessed with the Near Eastern polities and empires. Phoenicia is at the top of my list. Anyone here ever been to Tyre? I'd love to see it one day!
I really like the narration and presentation style of this video and find the topic interesting, but I've made a point of not watching any educational videos that don't include full citations ever since I realized how many myths get spread around on UA-cam. I skimmed through the video enough to see that you include citations when quoting sources directly and for certain points, but I'd really encourage you to include a bibliography in the description (or a pinned comment or companion doc if the list is too long) and end of video as you do with music credits, if not on-screen citations throughout the entire video wherever you'd include a citation in an essay (which I'm starting to include in my own videos); it's not a huge additional effort to create a list of the sources you use during the research process (and in-text citations only take slightly more effort than that), and is super important not only to avoid plagiarism, but also for maintaining a chain of sources so that people can trace where claims originally came from if they want to (which is also why in-text citations are better, since people can check specific claims, but even a simple bibliography is better than nothing). I'm subscribing, I really hope to see a bibliography in your next video!
Pertaining to himan sacrifice, archeological evidence does show that the Phoenicians did in fact practice himan sacrifice. One specific deity (Murdok) and other Baal forms of worship required such practice. When Carthage was besieged, there were over hundreds of child sacrifices made to support the war. The remains are still there. Also littered across the canaan land are evidence of such practice. The archetecture of the sacrifical altars of some also points out that live child sacrifices were used to produce certain sounds. It is indeed a greusome part of history
Tastefully done video.
No robot voice.
No intrusive music.
No hideous thumbnail.
Concise script.
Subscribed.
One suggestion.
Make all the visuals full screened.
It gives it a museum aesthetic though, I like it
So good !
bollocks
Also, no attempt to be funny/meme images flashing on screen
the "merchant"
ages old
Really appreciate that you don't add obnoxious "epic" music to your videos and opt for more ambient music to enhance the sense of "gazing into the past"
Because quite cleverly creators have noticed that a lot of us listen going to sleep and if we listen and fall asleep it's a win win because you get sleep and they get more money because if you're not on premium the videos play all the way through ads and all
His voice and the music are so calming and perfect for talking about an ancient civilisation.
@@brandonhinrichs4393smart!
Yeah, that’s epic!
i thot the same thing
Something different on a UA-cam history channel? Actually a LOT right here. Dark maps with abstract materials and only the most pertinent details for one. Low volume ambient music aimed at deepening your attention without drawing attention to itself is another. And, finally, crisp writing delivered with voice actor quality speech. Oh, and supporting graphics moving in and out like thoughts. This is a triumph in so, so many ways. Outstanding! Brilliant actually.
Shout out to the Phoenicians on this day. May Lebanon know peace once more.
😬
You realize lebanon is...was the home of hezzballah...a proxy terrorist group...good riddence
That would require a new crusade
@@Akaeus war isn't peace 🙄. This isn't even fun anymore. You all are just idiots.
They will if and when they kick Hezbollah out and stop attacking Israel.
I spent a summer doing research on these people and it’s great to see them get more and more recognition in the historical communities.
did you end up traveling for your research ?
@@ncgibrahim3242 man, I wish! It was 2020 when I had the time to read everything in my library.
Absolutely beautiful graphics. So refreshing.
Yeah the style and music really makes it
Highly accurate in a field of constant error and speculation
Well done
This is an excellent history lesson. Never doubt the value of your contribution to online learning. Thank you.
Super quality video! Love the colors and style of the map and the calming voice with soft music.
Absolutely terrific video mate 👏
The Phoenician civilization is truly fascinating and intriguing, thanks!
What the hell terrific !
We still have much to learn about these courageous sailors, merchants and craftsmen
Just commenting to boost this video into the algorithm
Damn you right.
I fully respond hehe
Same !
💥💥This video is trash!!! 🤦🏻The Phoenicians had dark skin. They were African not European...smh😮😮😮
It worked; you summoned me.
Beirut**
great video, cheers from Lebanon
Amazing work as always 🙌
Excellent historical documentary, Thank you for sharing!
This is a well-done, reasoned piece. It begins, however, with a mischaracterization of Herodotus’ reference to the Phoenicians’ origins. The narrator claims Herodotus believed that they had emigrated from southern Arabia (near present day Yemen) or East African coast (near present day Eritrea). Herodotus did NOT claim to believe that this origin story was true or likely correct. He merely relayed this theory in “The Histories,” while expressing his doubts of its validity.
There's a costal city in Oman called Sur which is famous for its ship building history, does that remind you of anything? Sur, is the same name of the most important kan'ani (Phoenician) city Sur (Tyre in English) and there has been some findings of kan'ani (Phoenician) script in Oman. I don't think that is a coincidence. The idea that Phoenicians came from Arabia isn't as hard to believe as you think.
There's also claim of phoenician inscriptions all over the Mediterranean seas reaching up to Ireland. Could be some phoenicians who reached the area. Not that they came from here. @yuzan3607
@@yuzan3607doesn't prove anything
@@yuzan3607and yet trade between too different nations will also produce those exact same details.
With the almost mesmerizing music in the back, a professional voice and a very well presented video, im shocked that this channel doesnt have more subscribers. Fantastic video!
honestly one of the best vids ive seen on an ancient civ. perfect length/visuals/soundscape
People from Phoenix are called Phoenicians
🤣🤣🤣 Louis CK
I laughed, expecting it to be a joke, then laughed harder when I found it to be true
That's because the Phoenicians founded Phoenix Arizona. They were tyred of being stereotyped as sailors
@@nickdarr7328 the more you know
Or meth addicts
easily my fav history channel. so ambient i love it
why did i found this channel until now! this content is great!
Another great video, from a sadly underrated channel! Keep up the good work! Always look forward to your uploads!
Really appreciate your editing skills! Did a great job highlighting dates and events.
Excuse me, you forgot Malta in your map! We where a Phoenician colony as well! Actually we where one of the first
Add Cyprus to it,
W-E-R-E
@@fightback397 yeah, aim polishing my proof reading.😝
@@ataboyboyboy8895
Ok , than try spelling first : I'm = i am , not " aim " .
@@fightback397*then
Very well done. Very informative. This is much better than the History chanel which is so absured with its historians adding their worthless and most of the time inaccuracies.
Thank you. Keep up the good work.
Subscribed. Production quality is excellent and minimalistic
Wow a history video with a pleasant and well speaking narrator. Very rare
Perseus, the great "Greek" hero, was Canaanite/Phoenician, as was Cadmus, who founded Boetia and Thebes. Pretty sure Mycenea was a Phoenician outpost as well.
The best clear, concise and historically accurate information on the Phonecians I've seen. Thank you.
How can you say this info is historically accurate when the narrator says all of this info is “believed to be” ! Short of speculation! Study from the peoples of those lands, not European colonizers who benefit from misinformation…
This is great. Keep them coming 👌
Subscribed, not to monotone and I didn’t fall asleep listening! Thank you!
love your narration
Thanks for that. Most informative indeed!
Love your narration!! 😁
Amazing video. Very informative. Thank you! Subscribed🎉
Love these videos. I'm very new to this channel and appreciate you addressing some of the more fringe (but plausible) theories about ancient societies. I'd love it if we could get a list of sources that you use for your videos. I'm always on the lookout for more books and articles to read about topics like this!
Fringe for you buddy. Do more research.
@@vanbalzup6481+1 - too many people running around with their old programming
@@vanbalzup6481 That's why I asked for sources. Fringe wasn't an insult. Sometimes, unpopular theories are correct. I was just differentiating between plausible and implausible theories. For example, the Phoenicians coming from Dilmun (Bahrain) is plausible. The Phoenicians getting their seafaring abilities from aliens is implausible.
Good channel. Well thought out and informative. Subbed keep it up!
Well organized, considered and assembled. I greatly benefited from the information that you shared with me. Thank you.
Great historical channel. Thanks!
immediate subscribing because of that professional but soothing voice. Excellent video
Awesome work. Subscribed!
Great video, I'm leaving a comment to support your channel.
great vid loved it
Mate please keep this up, you videos are *chefs kiss* amazing!
Very enjoyable presentation!
One of the best videos on my people i have seen. Excellent work
Very good doc as always
This is such high quality content, I hope that your channel grows.
Please please make more regarding this time period
True masterpiece brother, well done!
Just great content !
Thank you for your video. Very well documented.
This is really great. Sometimes zoom out on the map to hemisphere/globe size though for us geographically challenged people. Really learned a lot.
Well done. The purple reminds me of my byzantine days MTW2. Awesome video design and images.
Would it be possible for you to put some of the sources you use in the description please? For further reading. Thank you
this blew mind , i can't thank you enough , it explains everything i have felt or known deep inside , its hard to explain.
I comfirms everything you felt inside?
Thank you for this ❤️
And so well made. Thank you
Loved this. Such a fascinating culture and period of time
Great video.
Thank you for posting.
I’m enjoying these longer length videos.
This is so much better than so many similar channels with their overwhelming "background music".
Great Video
Very enjoyable video. Thank you.
Another phenomenal video! It’s only a matter of time before this channel has millions of followers.
Great video, happy to have stumbled on this video.
Great topic
Incredible and captivating documentary. Thank u.
If someone feels the necessity to correct the video I wish they would explain and show their sources of knowledge. How they learned this all important jewel of information.
Very well made video, you have a new subscriber in me!
Excellent video, folks would have a much better idea of who and where we are today if they would just absorb a basic knowledge of history.
Well narrated and produced. Thanks.
A fine video indeed
Incredibly well researched and edited!💯
I’m completely hooked on your ancient history documentaries. Keep them coming!
Great video though a suggestion would be to put your sources in the description. In part to legitimize the video itself, but Also to aid in further reading
Awesome video keep up the great work!🎉
Cannanites/hyksos were Caucasian semetics possibly like proto celt Scythians they mixed with local semetics when they came into Canaan … the Hyksos/cannanite /sumerians were the Caucasians that brought the blue eyed gene into the levant .. meanwhile the Scythians/aryans spread the blue eyes gene around Iran Russia and Germany … phonecians weren’t from Arabia… if you look hard enough you will see the Carthaginians depict themselves and Roman’s slightly similar except Carthaginians have red and brown hair meanwhile Roman’s have both brown blown and red hair…
@@lo-fihi-ki5699 Phoenician Language is ANCIENT HELLENIC GREEK. Greeks were the Maritime Sailors. They travelled the World
@@lo-fihi-ki5699The Kyksos aka Hyksos left Greek aka Phoenician Inscriptions in Egypt..HEBREW IS GREEK WITH A MASK ON. Banned Book by Joseph Yehuda
@@Kikap6001 Phoenician language is nothing like Hellenic greek, its completely Semetic...
@@lo-fihi-ki5699 Phoenician remains not only show genetic relation to Arabia but so is their culture. Greco-Roman historians also have said the Phoenicians are from the Erythean sea near around Arabia....
Wonderful presentation of a great period of history 👍 a great time for traveling adventures. Thx. 🌍✌️🌎
its maybe not so helpful to display phoenician 'empire' as big purple clouds on the map and more useful to simply have points on the map where their cities were. they certainly werent known for farming LOL especially in much of north africa where the hinterland berbers and such remained virtually uncontacted by the phoenicians
Someone doesn’t understand what a spirit influences lol
You are right, the purple was intended to show areas of Phoenician influence and trade activity but perhaps does come off looking a bit like a traditional empire! I will add a note to the description
they made dye from murex shellfish but we're not the inventors. The Minoans produced the dye in large quantities for export long before the Mycenaens took over Crete and it is likely the Phonecians came to Med trade in general. wonderful narrative thanks for your effort!
They are the Berbers
Aramaeans, that's why you find Barbary Apes in Gibraltar, Gabriel's Altar, because the Barbary represents THOTH or TRUTH
Phoenicians started out with crappy land for farming and ranching.... since most of the country was hilly and mountainous ⛰️
fantastic video, thank you
great video
🍌THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age in which God is saving man from the imminent destruction of this old world"
(The transformation of a person's disposition is not a change of behavior, or a feigned external change or a temporary change produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a real transformation of disposition that brings about a change in behavior. The transformation of disposition means that you have understood and experienced the truth, and that truth has become your life. Now that your disposition has changed, you not only understand the truth, but you also act on it. You are able to let go of the things you felt like doing the other day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. This is a transformation of disposition, and it is also the process of transforming your disposition. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. Only after experiencing all this can a person partially understand his own nature. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. In this process, you will understand some things about yourself, and you will realize that you are very impure, harbor too many personal motives, and have too many desires while fulfilling your duties. Once you have understood the meaning of these things, you will be able to approach God in prayer and truly repent; in this way, you will be cleansed of impurities. The more one's corrupt disposition is refined, the more the disposition of their life will change.)
Almighty God said
The TRANSFORMATION of a PERSON'S DISPOSITION is NOT a CHANGE of BEHAVIOR, or a FELT EXTERNAL CHANGE or TEMPORARY DIFFERENCE produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a REAL CHANGE of DISPOSITION which CAUSES a CHANGE in BEHAVIOR. Such a change in behavior is not the same as changes manifested in a person's outward behaviors and actions. The TRANSFORMATION of the DISPOSITION MEANS that YOU have UNDERSTOOD and EXPERIENCED the TRUTH, and the TRUTH has BECOME YOUR LIFE.🌷
In the PAST, you UNDERSTOOD the TRUTH of this matter, BUT you did NOT put it into PRACTICE; the truth is only doctrine to you that is not practiced. NOW that your DISPOSITION has CHANGED, you not only UNDERSTAND the TRUTH, but you also ACT ACCORDING to IT. You are LETTING GO of the THINGS you LOVED to do back in the day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. 🙏🌷
You are now ABLE to GIVE UP THINGS that you COULDN'T GIVE UP back in the day. This is DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION, and it is also the PROCESS of your DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION.🌷
It may sound simple, but in REALITY, ANYONE in the MIDDLE of this PROCESS has to ENDURE a LOT of SUFFERING, OVERCOME their FLESH, and LEAVE the FLESH ASPECTS of NATURE. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. 🙏☀️
Only AFTER EXPERIENCING ALL of this can a person partially understand his own nature.
HAVING a little UNDERSTANDING about it, however, does NOT mean IMMEDIATELY being able to CHANGE a PERSON; MAN must ENDURE SUFFERINGS in the PROCESS. 🙏
Also, can you immediately start practicing after gaining some understanding of something? You cannot immediately start a practice. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. Sometimes, people are not ready to go through it, saying, "Why can't I do it that way? Do I have to do it this way?" Others say, "If you believe in God, then you should do it this way is true."
WHEN people REACH a CERTAIN POINT where they have gone through SEVERAL TRIALS and ENDED up UNDERSTANDING WITH GOD'S will and some TRUTH, then they will be HAPPY no matter what and ready to act ACCORDING to TRUE PRINCIPLES. In the beginning, people were reluctant to practice the truth. Take conscientious fulfillment of duties as an example: You have a little understanding of fulfilling duties and being faithful to God, and you also understand the related truths, but when will you fully devote yourself to God? When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. Some people may correct you, others may criticize you. All eyes will be on you, and only then will you begin to realize that you are in the wrong and that the truth is that you have done something bad, that the lack of devotion to fulfilling your duty is unacceptable, and you should not be rash and careless. The HOLY SPIRIT will ENLIGHTEN you FROM WITHIN, and rebuke you when you sin. IN this PROCESS, you will UNDERSTAND some THINGS ABOUT YOURSELF, and YOU will REALIZE that you are VERY IMPURE, HARBOR too MANY PERSONAL MOTIVES, and have too MANY DESIRES while FULFILLING your DUTIES. ONCE you have UNDERSTOOD the MEANING of these THINGS, you will be ABLE to APPROACH GOD in PRAYER and TRULY REPENT; in this WAY, you WILL be CLEANSED of IMPURITIES. ☀️🙏
If, in this way, you often seek the truth to solve your own practical problems, you will gradually tread the right path of faith. The MORE one's CORRUPT DISPOSITION is PURIFIED, the MORE the DISPOSITION of their LIFE will CHANGE. 🙏
From "Should Know About Changing a Person's Disposition"
Fulfillment in (Ezekiel 2: 9-10) and in (Revelation 19: 9,13)
📥Calling and leading everyone to His lowered Kingdom or Church because it is still standing on earth in the holy place in the air/ youtube "THE CHURCH OF ALMIGHTY GOD 💐 this is the fulfillment of what He said to Peter 2,000 years ago, recorded in (Matthew 16:18'19).
This is the the only Church of each one of our spirit that we must listen to or eat and drink like how we eat, dress and sleep every day so that He can guide us and change us by rejecting the evil attached by satan so as to be perfect,
having attained eternal life that will enter the coming replacement of the New Heaven and New Earth. 💌
this is fascinating! thanks for this .
A history youtube video without any hideous AI images!
Does anybody know much about the nation of Ebla? Their kingdom seems to have been north east of Phoenicia. I am wondering if Ebla ever occupied Phoenici, of vice versa? Info online is limited. As i understand Ebla was mainly destroyed by Hittites, perhaps thats why that area is marked as Hittite on this video? This content is fantastic and informative
Is the spelling Beirut as Beruit in this video intentional or not?
Other place names, like Tyre, appear to be the modern English version, so why is Beirut not spelled in the usual way?
I think he just kept making the same spelling mistake. AFAIK it’s always been “Beirut”.
Pretty good UA-cam & Eats sesh id give this vid an 8/10
Great content, thank u for covering more than Egypt and Rome.
Many ads. Compelling production due to high values. Good to stream this one.
I give you credit for doing something. And there's a couple of interesting bits of information in the video, but overall I hope this is not how the history of the Phoenicians is being taught in our universities, there or here. The quote by Aristotle was telling, and shows the corrupt techniques haven't changed much. Who knew what's going on in the western world today had its origins so far back. I bet they didn't call them ngos though. Also the point about the Phoenicians building and piloting and crewing the Persian ships is one that's often overlooked, and helps explain Alexander's wrath at the city not capitulating. He had pretty much had enough of that, much in the same way the Romans would deal with the thrice invading Carthaginians. Also I'm pretty sure the Greeks and Romans were pretty good at recognizing human sacrifice when they saw it and child sacrifice, and the archeology in this case as well as in Britain seems to be bearing out the veracity of their writings. No doubt they were a fascinating culture, hell bent on colonization and the use of proxy armies to do their killing. Their ambitions let them to invade and battle with the Greeks and Italians on their own shores for centuries, and eventually they just ran out of luck and people to die for them.
You got lots of missinformations in your post
1. Persian fleet on mediterranean had 3 battle groups, one made of Phoenicians, other of Egyptians and third of Aegean Greeks.
Greeks cities in Asia minor were Persian allies and gave both land army (hoplites) and navies for the persian military machine
2. Macedonians were also Persian allies during Greco-Persian wars. Macedonians conquered both Sparta and Athens, both Spartans and the Atheninians hated Alexander and didn't gave their armies to fight for Alexanders campaign.
Ancient world was centered around city states as political realities, not ethnic groups as we have today
3. Romans practiced human sacrifices, see what happened after Cannae
4. Italics and Greeks participated in Punic ethnogenesis, they immigrated to Carthage for centuries and assimilated themselves into Punics. After Roman conquest of Southern Italy mass of Brutinians fled to Carthage.
Hannibals army was made mostly of people from the Italian penisula, both Padanian Gauls and Italics, after Cannae almost all of southern Italy deflected to Hannibal. You re looking at the ancient world from a modern day perspective which is decieving.
@@ivandicivan4189 Well the funny thing is, I was actually doing the exact opposite and somehow you missed that. Most of the revisionism surrounding the Carthaginians is occuring in modern times. I never mentioned anything about their particular ethnicities, I'm quite aware that their general makeup was similar to other Mediterranean groups, Greco/Italic. You can look at Phoenician coffins and Roman busts of Hannibal Barca to see that with your own eyes. My observation that Alexander's anger at the Phoenicians for building the ships of his enemies must have been boiling stands. I'm well aware that the Persian navy and army in general was made up of many peoples most of whom joined either because they were conquered or the great fear of having their territories raped and destroyed. Including Greek polities. I never commented on the latter and the former is useful information you've added to what I said about the ships, but doesn't alter the veracity of my comment. Ethnogenesis? That sounds like you're the one confusing and transposing modern ideas on ancient ones. Italy was invaded and colonized for 700 years or more? And became the target of Alexander's generals after his death. They learned and then they got really really good at fighting back. You never hear much about the pre-roman invasions colonization and "ethnogenesis" in Italy. The Gauls came through and had a time long before Caesar took revenge. As for human sacrifice the majority of scholars agree that that was rarely ever practiced in any organized form by the Greeks or Romans, and the Romans in particular were completely against it as a society.
@@vincentcarrano5121 You claimed that alexander destroyed Tyre out of revenge, which makes no sense becuse during Greco-persian wars Macedonians were allies of Persia, and persian admiral was a king of Sidon. Phoenicians of Sidon were competitors of Tyrians and provided ships for Alexander during his siege of Tyre.
Italics were fighting each others for centuries and some of the fiercest wars Romans fought were against the Samnites.
Cisalpine Gauls have politically nothing to do with transalpine ones, and were assimilated by Romans anyway.
The fact that someone is Gaul, or Italic, or Numidian, or whatever, means little to nothing in political sense since ancient people lived in the city states and tribes which acted for their own interest, and there is where their allegiance lied, to the city state or tribe, not to the macro-group.
Romans scrificed vestal virgins after defeat at Cannae. It was a time of great desparation, you can compare that to similar cases in Carthage, like invasion of Agatocles for example-most of scholars who believe in existance of those sacrifices believe it was a practice which occured in times of a great crisis and not everyday practice.
Well done, good narrative!
Wow they're such an ancient people at the same time it feels like I know them so well but we really don't this is so cool
Thank you for this very interesting video! I didn't know the old stories about the possible origins of the Phonecian peoples. This was excellent!
God be with you out there, everybody. ✝️ :)
Another great video. Supposedly, guys are obsessed with the Romans. Well, I'm obsessed with the Near Eastern polities and empires. Phoenicia is at the top of my list. Anyone here ever been to Tyre? I'd love to see it one day!
Caesar: The Romans are descended from the Phoenicians and the Greeks.
Wow you’re different from everyone else aren’t you
It's a beautiful place, good shawarma
el imperio romano tuvo presencia en el medio oriente
Been there many times. Love it there
Great vidéo ❤
I'm surprised this channel doesn't have more viewers yet.
Thanks so much for posting
I listen to a lot of these type vids on yt and I always hear 'venetians' and I'm like damn those Italians sure got about 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
I really like the narration and presentation style of this video and find the topic interesting, but I've made a point of not watching any educational videos that don't include full citations ever since I realized how many myths get spread around on UA-cam. I skimmed through the video enough to see that you include citations when quoting sources directly and for certain points, but I'd really encourage you to include a bibliography in the description (or a pinned comment or companion doc if the list is too long) and end of video as you do with music credits, if not on-screen citations throughout the entire video wherever you'd include a citation in an essay (which I'm starting to include in my own videos); it's not a huge additional effort to create a list of the sources you use during the research process (and in-text citations only take slightly more effort than that), and is super important not only to avoid plagiarism, but also for maintaining a chain of sources so that people can trace where claims originally came from if they want to (which is also why in-text citations are better, since people can check specific claims, but even a simple bibliography is better than nothing). I'm subscribing, I really hope to see a bibliography in your next video!
Excellent work 🏆
Pertaining to himan sacrifice, archeological evidence does show that the Phoenicians did in fact practice himan sacrifice. One specific deity (Murdok) and other Baal forms of worship required such practice. When Carthage was besieged, there were over hundreds of child sacrifices made to support the war. The remains are still there. Also littered across the canaan land are evidence of such practice. The archetecture of the sacrifical altars of some also points out that live child sacrifices were used to produce certain sounds.
It is indeed a greusome part of history
Just like their caanite ancestors, makes sense why the Lord destroyed them, and reduced them to history
gross reality
Romans done it too. And Greeks before them
nothing has changed ..just the costumes
phoenicians + druids?
Yeah it’s pretty clear they practiced it, same with some other cultures.
This guy should have a million subs. Bravo..