Even the sentences in the US are lax as far as I can see. And Canada, The UK and, as I I learn more about global law, I see that most of Europe, have SHOCKINGLY SHORT SENTENCES!! I agree They are out of line with the idea of punishment being a serious diversion from criminal activity. I agree. Seems the jaw hasn't caught up with modern psychology. It has become pretty clear that people usually do not commit things like murder by accident, just one time, ever. Violent crime generally stems from a maladaptive view of the world, and ways if reducing pain, which operates throughout one's life. If someone is able to kill dispassionately once, and shows a marked lack of distress and remorse, it is most likely a result of a faulty gene pattern and it will happen again. It's not a choice or a mistake. Killing and dominating is a way of resolving pain..
It has been often proved that punishment is ineffective! Yes, criminals must be kept from the regular population but bad treatment in prison is not the answer imo.
@@bthomsonif you kill wantonly you have forfeited your right to live amongst others AND your right to comfort ..you bleeding heart liberals care more about criminals than their victims
Beyond punishment for bad behaviour though, I believe consequences should be dealt with a cool and rational mind, not one filled with revenge, as that makes us equally vindictive.
No, I don’t believe it at all. The idea that people just snap one day goes against tens of decades of the latest and most scientific and psychological studies of the brains and what causes reactions, and also the thousands of studies, if not more, on personality disorders. A person does not wake up one day and become a psychopath or other top tier personality disorder. There needs to be a series of behaviors and a significant time period since very early childhood. Now if you are referring to a psychotic break, with the word, Psychotic, not having any relation to Psychopath, you would need to have already have a mental health disorder, but without any history at all, this would be impossible, outside of a brain trauma, or sometimes it is even seen in a cancerous brain tumor.
Sounds like these German psychologists proclaiming that there is really no such thing as evil may be trying to assuage their own sense of historical guilt.
Why is it we are always looking for answers(yes I know it's in our nature,we are curious by nature) but sometimes there are just no answers.. Life is one crazy journey,please stay safe & take care🤘🏻🤘🏻
The harm and self destruction caused by nasty , unfit , cruel parents is obvious everywhere, leading to the destruction of others ! How can rehabilitation ever be attempted when so much harm has been done ! And the vicious circle continues !
The devil is real. The biggest lie is to make you believe he doesn't exist. "he is the father of lies" says the Bible. He only came to " kill and destroy." BUT JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR, HE IS THE KING!! HE IS GOD! AND HE IS ALMIGHTY!
I totally agree. All the study of the brain got already told us man has disorder desires. And not all of our thoughts are our own. This is part of the problem. These psychologists don’t believe evil exist. Evil is real in our pride or in our temptations to think only of ourselves or think we are smarter than we actually are. Know more than our Creator and do not seek to know who Jesus really is and who we really are. There really is no other way around it. Also not the Jesus we were taught (handed down-for good or bad) but as we grow continue a seeking understanding and relationship. It is pride or giving in to temptation. God sees the heart we can never truly know in the end but we can have an idea if we face ourselves and then seek our true identity and worth not what others say we are. This is very hard but worthwhile.
@@alanalycan3986 indeed. Nevertheless, do you also agree that hope is real and people can see it if they want? I also think that people like him don't seem to have had much guidance, encouragement and love.... :((
The Hope part is hard and this was confusing for me when I encountered a lot of psychotherapy because I became in despair that my rage and some of the bad intrusive thoughts were all mine to be responsible for and convinced I was evil. Believing we were in a battle (spiritual) and that some of these thoughts were temptations on my emotions and thoughts were so helpful to realize that God had not given up on me but that evil was real and I could choose but also needed God’s help but bad thoughts can come from the devil not just me. It helped me immensely with despair. I was Christian my whole life but went thru a lot and often fought difficult thoughts and emotions that in therapy I was told were all part of me. This was confusing and also what my perpetrators wanted me to believe and I believe evil wants us to believe and despair of too. To believe we don’t have a choice and therefore no hope
I want to contribute my opinion in this Nature/Nurture and Psychopathy Question. Something never mentioned is Parental and Environmental Influences from Conception until Birth.
I think the last ten years or so (in the US, at least) have proven that radicalization absolutely CAN occur completely online: the reinforcing interactions of the group are carried on with people online instead of face-to-face.
I agree that children should be taken away from bad parents. I think that with the money experiment that whatever they gave and put in the envelope for the other person that they themselves should be given that envelope and receive what they had given to the other person.
Radicalisation occurs when people realise society isn't perfect and they can't find an offramp to deal with problems in society. In order to combat extremism, we must be honest about social issues and provide hope that these issues may be resolved peacefully.
The dictator game would also be a good indicator of a persons political persuasion. My first thought is to share the money equally, because the other person and I are in the same situation, we don't know what's ahead and we both need to survive. If I caught a grouse in the wild, and another person did not, and we were both needing food, I would share the grouse equally. If the other person had two grouse, I would keep my grouse all for myself.
Literally nobody mentioned I*rael until you came along. The documentary is focusing on the individual human psychology, and you are focusing on the sociological problems.
These individuals who were abandoned and mistreated by their mothers were abandoned and mistreated by their fathers, first. The fathers that got a female pregnant and then abandoned her and the child to a life of bare survival in a harsh world, alone. These self-centered men, too, must bear their share of the guilt.
I’ve also been saying that for a while like we are two different species - human-kind And human-evil! I’m starting to think everyone who bullies at school needs a psych evaluation & fmri of the brain before they leave school or these behaviours worsen trouble is half the psychiatrists are also narcissistic bullies who deny the crimes victims have endured! I was not loved by my mother as a child put in boarding school I turned to saving others mostly animals but also peole in distress I became a super Empath so o don’t believe this explanation of his early childhood rejection is the cause at all I believe it’s genetics! Nature v nurture perhaps! I’ve attracted a lot of narcissists who treated me the same But I became the tots opposite of all those people!
Society I believe should come back to when it was closer. Caring for the other. Looking out for eachother. Stepping in to help. If Breivick had someone to love him, outside of hus family, I believe he would have not resorted to killing. The Lord Jesus is teaching us these things.
Absolutely agree 😔😔😔 we can still lead by example 🙏 I myself am sociable with my neighbors & helpful. If we all reach out in our communities - we CAN bring communities together again 🙏 hold a garden party, hand post some nice cards, gift some home grown vegetables to neighbors etc ☺️
I agree. I also agree that he hast to make choice to see the love and not reject it. Some people are offered love, and they choose to reject it over and over it happens.
At around 19 minutes, that researcher talks about “cocktails” of contributing factors. In the substance abuse category, the two substances considered in the study were alcohol and cannabis. No mention of hard drugs (along with alcohol, the substances that are actually associated with erratic and violent behaviour. 🤦♂️ A “researcher” who is that hopelessly hypnotised by societal biases is not going to figure out anything useful about violence. ffs. 🤦♂️
Justifications are sought when Inconsistency presents itself within the guardrails. It's poor to relegate dependency on extremism as rational cowardice.
Trying to understand evil, I get. Positing people _may not_ be responsible for their evil acts is a bridge too far. If a person understands right from wrong, and is not insane at the time of the criminal act, then they are responsible.
Demons can latch on to Children in their childhood if there is abuse. That will manifest into their adult life as addiction, crime, anger, depression, mental illness....get them help from a Catholic priest to pray over them daily 😔 have them baptized, their home blessed, saged. Teach them DECERNMENT 🙏 (And yes , of course medical counselling help too )
A shark is evil, a dolphin is not. A raptor is evil, a parrot is not. A Rottweiler is evil, a collie is not. Evil is inherited. It’s in the genes & some unlucky children inherited those genes. Just like eye color, height, skin and hair color and texture etc. it’s not complicated!
Why is a shark evil and a dolphin isn't raptor you need to go back to school animals aren't evil they kill to eat and defend themselves humans are the bad species
@@ThePrimot Yea, I have. Plenty of times. Stayed with them last year for 3 months. Not saying all rich people are nice, but you meet plenty of mean poor people too, right?
"Evil" does not exist. Neither does"good".They are theoretical constructs that change with the values of a society. As a religious construct it undermines the value of women.
A lot of our values are socially constructed but there’s some objective morality going on even if it’s just rooted biology. You’re stuck on an island with someone and they can either share their ice cream with you or eat your face. One option is objectively bad.
@@Atlas_Redux My rules? 😂 Sure bud. If you even mention things from the Bible then you know good and well the concept of evil and good from the Bible. Troll elsewhere. 🤫
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Tell you one thing, placing a killer back into society is insane, and this happens way to often.
Bible is must powerful book 📖 to read
Monsters look like normal people..that’s how they get the opportunity
The punishments for crimes should be as harsh as the crimes. If their is no punishment for bad behavior it will continue and even grow.
Even the sentences in the US are lax as far as I can see. And Canada, The UK and, as I I learn more about global law, I see that most of Europe, have SHOCKINGLY SHORT SENTENCES!! I agree
They are out of line with the idea of punishment being a serious diversion from criminal activity. I agree. Seems the jaw hasn't caught up with modern psychology. It has become pretty clear that people usually do not commit things like murder by accident, just one time, ever. Violent crime generally stems from a maladaptive view of the world, and ways if reducing pain, which operates throughout one's life. If someone is able to kill dispassionately once, and shows a marked lack of distress and remorse, it is most likely a result of a faulty gene pattern and it will happen again. It's not a choice or a mistake. Killing and dominating is a way of resolving pain..
It has been often proved that punishment is ineffective! Yes, criminals must be kept from the regular population but bad treatment in prison is not the answer imo.
What do u think of the research done on positive reinforcement instead of punishment..?
@@bthomsonif you kill wantonly you have forfeited your right to live amongst others AND your right to comfort ..you bleeding heart liberals care more about criminals than their victims
Beyond punishment for bad behaviour though, I believe consequences should be dealt with a cool and rational mind, not one filled with revenge, as that makes us equally vindictive.
Oh but every child, wanted or not, MUST be born!! How insane
Sometimes I wonder if we’re all just one bad day away from entering our own villain arcs.
I believe it
Definitely can see it
No, I don’t believe it at all. The idea that people just snap one day goes against tens of decades of the latest and most scientific and psychological studies of the brains and what causes reactions, and also the thousands of studies, if not more, on personality disorders. A person does not wake up one day and become a psychopath or other top tier personality disorder. There needs to be a series of behaviors and a significant time period since very early childhood.
Now if you are referring to a psychotic break, with the word, Psychotic, not having any relation to Psychopath, you would need to have already have a mental health disorder, but without any history at all, this would be impossible, outside of a brain trauma, or sometimes it is even seen in a cancerous brain tumor.
I think so
Yep
Sounds like these German psychologists proclaiming that there is really no such thing as evil may be trying to assuage their own sense of historical guilt.
Why is it we are always looking for answers(yes I know it's in our nature,we are curious by nature) but sometimes there are just no answers..
Life is one crazy journey,please stay safe & take care🤘🏻🤘🏻
The harm and self destruction caused by nasty , unfit , cruel parents is obvious everywhere, leading to the destruction of others ! How can rehabilitation ever be attempted when so much harm has been done ! And the vicious circle continues !
The devil is real.
The biggest lie is to make you believe he doesn't exist.
"he is the father of lies" says the Bible. He only came to " kill and destroy."
BUT JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR, HE IS THE KING!! HE IS GOD! AND HE IS ALMIGHTY!
It's frightening that he has fooled so many 😢 but thankfully not all
I totally agree. All the study of the brain got already told us man has disorder desires. And not all of our thoughts are our own. This is part of the problem. These psychologists don’t believe evil exist. Evil is real in our pride or in our temptations to think only of ourselves or think we are smarter than we actually are. Know more than our Creator and do not seek to know who Jesus really is and who we really are. There really is no other way around it. Also not the Jesus we were taught (handed down-for good or bad) but as we grow continue a seeking understanding and relationship. It is pride or giving in to temptation. God sees the heart we can never truly know in the end but we can have an idea if we face ourselves and then seek our true identity and worth not what others say we are. This is very hard but worthwhile.
@@alanalycan3986 indeed.
Nevertheless, do you also agree that hope is real and people can see it if they want?
I also think that people like him don't seem to have had much guidance, encouragement and love.... :((
The Hope part is hard and this was confusing for me when I encountered a lot of psychotherapy because I became in despair that my rage and some of the bad intrusive thoughts were all mine to be responsible for and convinced I was evil. Believing we were in a battle (spiritual) and that some of these thoughts were temptations on my emotions and thoughts were so helpful to realize that God had not given up on me but that evil was real and I could choose but also needed God’s help but bad thoughts can come from the devil not just me. It helped me immensely with despair. I was Christian my whole life but went thru a lot and often fought difficult thoughts and emotions that in therapy I was told were all part of me. This was confusing and also what my perpetrators wanted me to believe and I believe evil wants us to believe and despair of too. To believe we don’t have a choice and therefore no hope
@@andreeaburian1408I do agree 😕
I want to contribute my opinion in this Nature/Nurture and Psychopathy Question. Something never mentioned is Parental and Environmental Influences from Conception until Birth.
I think the last ten years or so (in the US, at least) have proven that radicalization absolutely CAN occur completely online: the reinforcing interactions of the group are carried on with people online instead of face-to-face.
I agree that children should be taken away from bad parents. I think that with the money experiment that whatever they gave and put in the envelope for the other person that they themselves should be given that envelope and receive what they had given to the other person.
Radicalisation occurs when people realise society isn't perfect and they can't find an offramp to deal with problems in society. In order to combat extremism, we must be honest about social issues and provide hope that these issues may be resolved peacefully.
Ben Carson is a very smart man and one cool cucumber. Super impressive how calm and rational he is!! 👏😁🤩
The dictator game would also be a good indicator of a persons political persuasion. My first thought is to share the money equally, because the other person and I are in the same situation, we don't know what's ahead and we both need to survive. If I caught a grouse in the wild, and another person did not, and we were both needing food, I would share the grouse equally. If the other person had two grouse, I would keep my grouse all for myself.
Anders was not protected and loved from the beginning. Authorities should have removed him
A blue and white flag and a six pointed star has had some astonishing results recently
not just recently, for about 76 years
BS
@@tredjesongen I know, "Israel has a right to defe...." whatever
You guys are evil. God gave Israel to the Jews and they were attacked first.
Literally nobody mentioned I*rael until you came along. The documentary is focusing on the individual human psychology, and you are focusing on the sociological problems.
"often spending entire days on the internet", guess I'm a serial killer now.
These individuals who were abandoned and mistreated by their mothers were abandoned and mistreated by their fathers, first. The fathers that got a female pregnant and then abandoned her and the child to a life of bare survival in a harsh world, alone. These self-centered men, too, must bear their share of the guilt.
Seems like the human race is spltting in two those that have a heart, and those who don't..
I’ve also been saying that for a while like we are two different species - human-kind
And human-evil!
I’m starting to think everyone who bullies at school needs a psych evaluation & fmri of the brain before they leave school or these behaviours worsen trouble is half the psychiatrists are also narcissistic bullies who deny the crimes victims have endured! I was not loved by my mother as a child put in boarding school I turned to saving others mostly animals but also peole in distress I became a super Empath so o don’t believe this explanation of his early childhood rejection is the cause at all I believe it’s genetics! Nature v nurture perhaps! I’ve attracted a lot of narcissists who treated me the same But I became the tots opposite of all those people!
Society I believe should come back to when it was closer. Caring for the other. Looking out for eachother. Stepping in to help.
If Breivick had someone to love him, outside of hus family, I believe he would have not resorted to killing.
The Lord Jesus is teaching us these things.
Absolutely agree 😔😔😔 we can still lead by example 🙏 I myself am sociable with my neighbors & helpful. If we all reach out in our communities - we CAN bring communities together again 🙏 hold a garden party, hand post some nice cards, gift some home grown vegetables to neighbors etc ☺️
I agree. I also agree that he hast to make choice to see the love and not reject it. Some people are offered love, and they choose to reject it over and over it happens.
@@jennifernagely5097 so true :(
Lots of love
@@alanalycan3986 love that you do that
13:59 Mind blown!
At around 19 minutes, that researcher talks about “cocktails” of contributing factors. In the substance abuse category, the two substances considered in the study were alcohol and cannabis. No mention of hard drugs (along with alcohol, the substances that are actually associated with erratic and violent behaviour. 🤦♂️ A “researcher” who is that hopelessly hypnotised by societal biases is not going to figure out anything useful about violence. ffs. 🤦♂️
Justifications are sought when Inconsistency presents itself within the guardrails.
It's poor to relegate dependency on extremism as rational cowardice.
Trying to understand evil, I get. Positing people _may not_ be responsible for their evil acts is a bridge too far. If a person understands right from wrong, and is not insane at the time of the criminal act, then they are responsible.
Will anybody ever answer this question ?
It's been here since the Garden of Eden.
@realstories What year was this documentary made please? Thank you! 😊
I'd email them (in the description box) or ask thru their FB or IG ;)
@@Publicist-AlexRosen Great idea, thank you!
Demons can latch on to Children in their childhood if there is abuse. That will manifest into their adult life as addiction, crime, anger, depression, mental illness....get them help from a Catholic priest to pray over them daily 😔 have them baptized, their home blessed, saged. Teach them DECERNMENT 🙏
(And yes , of course medical counselling help too )
look up "jimmy akin it's always demons". praying for you
There is no such thing as demons
Stay away from the Catholics. Now theres some demonic stuff.
It's mostly genetics.
Upbringing,learnt behaviour as well as genetics or as in psychopaths there are findings of a genuinely different brain.
A shark is evil, a dolphin is not. A raptor is evil, a parrot is not. A Rottweiler is evil, a collie is not. Evil is inherited. It’s in the genes & some unlucky children inherited those genes. Just like eye color, height, skin and hair color and texture etc. it’s not complicated!
Why is a shark evil and a dolphin isn't raptor you need to go back to school animals aren't evil they kill to eat and defend themselves humans are the bad species
Dr. Evil...
And this is why abortion rights are SO important.
All rich people are evil.
That's gibberish.
@@rickmorty7284 no, it’s not. You ever meet a nice, caring, rich person?… that’s because there aren’t any.
@@ThePrimot Yea, I have. Plenty of times. Stayed with them last year for 3 months.
Not saying all rich people are nice, but you meet plenty of mean poor people too, right?
"Evil" does not exist. Neither does"good".They are theoretical constructs that change with the values of a society. As a religious construct it undermines the value of women.
That makes absolutely no sense.
In my beliefs and in the words of the Bible, Evil and Good very much do exist. What does being a woman have to do with it, may I ask?
A lot of our values are socially constructed but there’s some objective morality going on even if it’s just rooted biology. You’re stuck on an island with someone and they can either share their ice cream with you or eat your face. One option is objectively bad.
@@RLFinTX According to the Bible, a woman is not allowed to preach or teach. You're already breaking your own rules by not being silent here.
@@Atlas_Redux My rules? 😂 Sure bud. If you even mention things from the Bible then you know good and well the concept of evil and good from the Bible. Troll elsewhere. 🤫