Thank you Robert/IDG for a wonderfully long livestream! Always enjoy your livestreams but it is a real treat to get a long one! Much love from south Louisiana
NGL these types of discussions is what made me made a realise account for ASOIAF 10+ years ago. Now Robert and chat are my go to place to geek out and talk theory. Thanks for the Amazing environment you have established Robert!!
Great stream as usual Robert / IDG , thanks for putting in the long hours for us so often. This felt like a throwback stream / a super long epic livestream like we used to routinely do so often. Very enjoyable , look forward to the next one.
At 03:15:01 I appreciate your response to "which character did GRRM wish he hadn't killed off". I've seen/heard other people speculate and usually decide on either Maester Aemon or Kevan Lannister, and I've never been quite convinced by those arguments. The idea (as you suggested) that he was speaking solely in the context of the book he was currently writing (meaning he was referring to a character he had killed off early in *Winds*) makes a lot of sense to me. If true, all of our speculating would be pointless!
Based on previous evidence a body has to be animated in order to warg into it… you can just warg into a dead animal nor a dead human. It has to be animated first. It would be awesome if wolf/ghost Jon sees his animated corpse and goes into. Supposedly we won’t get a POV from and ice and fire wight.. for a reason. I think it’s not really “them” but Jon can enter his previously occupied but reanimated body and we can then get a pov
3:33 ‘of course he trusts her’ idk if this is necessarily completely true, If we look at the text, Brienne’s lie is the last thing in his chapter, and we hear later from rumours that he went with her, I think this was to purposefully make us think he fell for it but in actuality we aren’t told how Jaime feels at all, he could possibly have trusted her and left but he also could have thought she was acting suspiciously and still gone with her because he was worried about her or because he didn’t want to go home or anything, we have to remember that one, Jaime knows brienne very well, two, she is not a very good liar, it’s likely to me that he would be able to tell that she lied, I also find it interesting that the lie is that the hound is going to hurt Sansa and we know that Jaime knows the hound and earlier in the books he heard about the rumours going round about him and thought about how it didn’t fit with what he thought of the hound
I might need to ask my question in more detail on patreon, anyone know if there's a character limit for questions on there? Because the 200 character limit on UA-cam live comments is really oppressive
The dragon must have 3 heads means: 1 dragon,1 rider and the bond between them is the 3 head ……I always wondered: how com that from all the marriages between Targaryens and other houses,the only time when other families get to bond with dragons is with Laena and Laenor,why never happens before?
the ice wights don't seem nearly as brought back to life as fire wights so I'd think the faceless men would be more against red priests (and qyburn) than the others
Thank you Robert/IDG for a wonderfully long livestream! Always enjoy your livestreams but it is a real treat to get a long one! Much love from south Louisiana
NGL these types of discussions is what made me made a realise account for ASOIAF 10+ years ago. Now Robert and chat are my go to place to geek out and talk theory. Thanks for the Amazing environment you have established Robert!!
What a treat. Almost 4 hrs of Robert.
King Robert, Lord of the Deep Geek
Great stream as usual Robert / IDG , thanks for putting in the long hours for us so often. This felt like a throwback stream / a super long epic livestream like we used to routinely do so often. Very enjoyable , look forward to the next one.
Love the videos! Any chance some day you could do one on Renly's Rainbow Guard?
At 03:15:01 I appreciate your response to "which character did GRRM wish he hadn't killed off". I've seen/heard other people speculate and usually decide on either Maester Aemon or Kevan Lannister, and I've never been quite convinced by those arguments. The idea (as you suggested) that he was speaking solely in the context of the book he was currently writing (meaning he was referring to a character he had killed off early in *Winds*) makes a lot of sense to me. If true, all of our speculating would be pointless!
Has anyone tried putting all the house words together? I always felt like after you learned them all, it would be like it's own little peom or vow.
Based on previous evidence a body has to be animated in order to warg into it… you can just warg into a dead animal nor a dead human. It has to be animated first. It would be awesome if wolf/ghost Jon sees his animated corpse and goes into. Supposedly we won’t get a POV from and ice and fire wight.. for a reason. I think it’s not really “them” but Jon can enter his previously occupied but reanimated body and we can then get a pov
59:52 shit getting real when Robert takes off the glasses
3:33 ‘of course he trusts her’ idk if this is necessarily completely true, If we look at the text, Brienne’s lie is the last thing in his chapter, and we hear later from rumours that he went with her, I think this was to purposefully make us think he fell for it but in actuality we aren’t told how Jaime feels at all, he could possibly have trusted her and left but he also could have thought she was acting suspiciously and still gone with her because he was worried about her or because he didn’t want to go home or anything, we have to remember that one, Jaime knows brienne very well, two, she is not a very good liar, it’s likely to me that he would be able to tell that she lied, I also find it interesting that the lie is that the hound is going to hurt Sansa and we know that Jaime knows the hound and earlier in the books he heard about the rumours going round about him and thought about how it didn’t fit with what he thought of the hound
Excited to watch!
"Gorman Peak" (sp.?)! Great Martin ref. to Mervyn Peake's Gormenghast!
Epic❤
I'm a bit confused wouldn't Daeron be Bloodravens half brother or cousin depending on where you stand about Daerons legitimacy?
I might need to ask my question in more detail on patreon, anyone know if there's a character limit for questions on there? Because the 200 character limit on UA-cam live comments is really oppressive
Patreon questions don't have character limits to my understanding
The dragon must have 3 heads means: 1 dragon,1 rider and the bond between them is the 3 head ……I always wondered: how com that from all the marriages between Targaryens and other houses,the only time when other families get to bond with dragons is with Laena and Laenor,why never happens before?
" something is afoot" great saying... i think grrm uses feet in his stories, in this context x
*baby aegon* 😂😂❤
❤
the ice wights don't seem nearly as brought back to life as fire wights so I'd think the faceless men would be more against red priests (and qyburn) than the others
This was a doozie.
whoa....adg is a babe...who knew
i missed it :(