Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
The Most Catastrophic Battle of the Clone Wars - Battle of Atraken Explained
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 гру 2016
- Follow Star Wars Reading Club on Twitter: @SWReadingClub
The Non-Canon Expert describes how the Battle of Atraken became the most catastrophic battle of the Clone Wars due to the destruction that it produced in regard to Atraken's population and the planet itself.
![Why this Battle was the Most DEPRESSING of the Entire Clone Wars [It Was All For Nothing]](/img/n.gif)
Atreken and it's less capable moon Atrecan't. Poor planet
Hi everyone, I just wanted to give a huge thank you for the amazing support and great comments on yesterday's Rogue One review. My brother and I both appreciate it very much. I am still on a pretty big high from the movie, so I think it's fair to say that there will be some Rogue One related videos starting tomorrow. Thank you again and I hope you enjoy the video!
Star Wars Reading Club I really liked Rogue one, i feel like it made me believe in the new movies after the massive disappointment that The force awakens left within me.
Jesper Kristensen I liked the force awakened, but I understand why it came out to a lot as a disappointment, and I'm glad rogue one really brought that great atmosphere that hasn't been felt since empire strikes backs
Star Wars Reading Club I just saw the video and the movie... I adored it! It was so fantastic
john Calderon: I think that The force awakens is over all pretty okay, i just don't think that it's a good Star Wars movie.
I think it's because they try to project that it's a sequel ( which it technically is) but there are just too many simularities to A new hope for me to call it a full on sequel. But Rogue one definately gave me a hope that Episode VIII could be something great if not amazing.
Star Wars Reading Club I love your videos, also a request, Who are those Imperial Officers from the beginning A New Hope. One was going to shoot R2-D2 and C-3PO's escape pod from Tanntumn 4. You know, "There goes another one, hold your fire there aren't any life forms"
Does anyone else think it's funny that the Clone Wars devastated the countless worlds, but the GAR was only about 10 million strong and the war only lasted about three years? Just odd to me. Either I can't grasp galactic warfare or Sidious just liked watching it all burn.
IgnemFeram01 never underestimate the power of high power laser weapons and WMD style bombs
IgnemFeram01 I always took the "200,000 units with a million more on the way" statement by the kaminoans as being 1 unit= 1 battalion (666 clones). That seems a bit more reasonable to wage a galactic war to me.
I have a harder time grasping that the GAR measured at only 10 million strong. The Empire at it's height supposedly comprised about 60 million inhabited worlds. Separatist resources would also make production of millions of battledroids a very simple task, so one would expect the Republic to ramp up it's own ranks to counter.
"In this video expose"
Clayton Cortina *grand admiral thrawn in background*
I didn't know about the Battle of Atraken, but wasn't the Battle of Jabiim more devastating? Thousands upon thousands of clone troopers died, dozens of padawans were killed, Obi-Wan was captured, chemical weapons were unleashed, the planet became a desolate mudball, and the native population felt betrayed by the republic and joined the CIS. It was also one of the very first operations by the GAR, and was a massive blow to their manpower and morale.
Some how this battle reminds me of World War I. Like the trenching, the gas, etc.
RBMN Fan5049 battle of the Somme
+Will Roberts Sure or Verdun.
especially the lack of real military experience the BEF had, which explains a lot of these long sieges, mainly lack of experience & resulting poor planning.
Hey non-canon expert. Quick question a while ago you made a video detailing what happened to padewans who failed their trials. So I was wondering what happened to these individuals when order 66 was activated
501st comment
Star Wars Legacy hah nice
Star Wars Legacy funny
Star Wars Legacy, 66th comment.
Star Wars Legacy 69th comment
l
o
Is there a reason why most planets in star wars have such low population numbers?
its like how most people live in cities instead of villages out in the country.
Because the writers are bad at figuring out numbers. 1million for a planet is hilariously low
Beijing alone has a population of 11.1million people. More planets should = more population, not less.
I thought the battle of Jabiim was the most catastrophic
THE ANGRY COMMISAR fuck off
No, the battle of Jabiim had the highest casualties. In this case, it is an entire planet that gets "destroyed"
oh alright
Great video I am new to the channel but it is awesome and I am really enjoying your channel! But I would really enjoy a video on the blue shadow virus I think it would be very interesting and people would enjoy it as well! Keep up the good work 👍🏼
an epic and awesome war
Wicked awesome vid!!!!!!!!!
A population of 1,000,000 for a planet is tiny. That entire planet has the same population as the CITY I live in. That's just insane to me
They were probably not indigenous either. They were probably people who moved there to set up mining settlements.
1 mil on one planet? man that must be a small one
Most planets in the outer rim were considered colonies, so a large colony would have over a million people.
Where as if you looked at a core world like coruscant, or Byss, or any others, they numbered near the trillions upon trillions.
And then you have the rim worlds like Alderaan where it was more like Earth with about 5 billion.
It all depends on what part of the galaxy you are in.
However I will agree that some numbers seem way too low, but in some cases they're about right.
I mean the empire had 25000 star destroyers, and each had 30000 people on them just as crew. and that's just the star destroyers, the Death Star 1 have like 1-2 million people on it! So we know the empire have close to at least a trillion soldiers, if not about another 6 or 7 trillion.
In general, numbers are weird in star wars.
Makes you wonder if Sidious knew how to use Battle Meditation, or if that knowledge was lost in the days the Old Republic. Then again, I guess he really didn't need to know how to use it since he controlled both sides of the war.
Commenting for Support.
What the heck are these casualties? For being one of the worst battles only 900k civilians and around 20k clone casualties... Stalingrad took millions and millions of troop and civilian casualties, and this was for one city, not to mention an entire planet
Death Troopers can actually aim and hit their target. Unlike the stormtroopers who can't hit the side of a barn.
Nice vid
So dark
Wait I don't understand, someone PLEASE answer this question: How long after episode 2 and before episode 3 did the clone wars movie take place? Someone please answer me, I've been dying to know.
were there any force sensitive mandalorians or Jedi who were mandalorian
Which was the best general in the Army of the Republic
Darth Sidius Darth. Vader
Who's Nick Rastoo?
Nick rostu was a once-normal civilian on mace windus homeworld that got captured and brainwashed by mace's brother. I might be forgetting or misremembering stuff though, its been a long time since i learned this info, so i'll have to double check. Be back in a bit
+Cody Evett OK thanks
IceStride Some guy
What happened to General Veers?
Stephen Sheehan He did something
...Thanks, that had been bothering me for years. I'm glad to hear he went on to bigger and better things.
Stephen Sheehan No problem!
Worst battles of any war are pointless ones and this is no exception
what ep did this happen
Do a theory what if Snoke is Mace Windu!
You can't say anything to make that credible.
Sometimes I wonder who the real bad guys were in the Clone Wars...
Well I guess one could argue with Palpatine's influence in secret he added to the destructive force on the side of the Republic
Palpatine.
EVERYBODY WAS BEING PLAYED BY PALPATINE, SO TECHNICALLY NOBODY WAS EVIL HERE. AS FOR INTENTIONS YOU COULD POINT OUT THE GREEDY MEGACORPS WHERE MUCH MORE TRANSPARENTLY EVIL, BECAUSE THEY JUST TOOK WHATEVER & DAMN THE COST. BUT THE CIS WAS ONLY CREATED BECAUSE OF REPUBLIC CORRUPTION THAT ALLOWED THIS IN THE FIRST PLACE.
What happend to those who escaped
YA ALL TEN SECONDS OF IT IN THE NEXT HELLHOLE.
Show the comic
Where can I read this?
Tyler Marshall a book
What was the population of the entire galaxy?
Alex Hernandez good question. I'm guessing somewhere in the quadrillions.
I heard somewhere it was about 100 trillion during the Clone Wars.
1 million? So more people died in World War 1 then the destruction of Atraken? Okay.
Geetsly already did a video on this three months ago xD
I just think it's funny and I got nothing against it. I'm surprised nobody else made another video before this. I actually liked him making this video as it added more facts and I learned a little bit more. It goes into more depth of the fighting on a smaller scale.
If not for me...
For my brother that sounds just like meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
303rd comment
(Also, didn't you do a video on this before?)
He did Jabiim which is the most deadly battle.
You cant just have 3 vids called "the deadliest", "the bloodiest" and "the most catastrophic"...click bait tittles
These are some questionable numbers
66
Pretty fucked up, seems like there was no good vs evil in the clone wars just loyalty to your government. 2:40 Sad seeing those creatures drinking out the river lol, you know they died right after x(.
If droids are computers cranked up to the hardest cheat difficulty and bread for war, wouldn't their aim be almost perfect making them the deadliest shots of the any army? Shooting is alot of math in real life, something computers dominate. I would Imagine if Star Wars was semi realistic, you would never be able to go toe to toe with a droid army, rather urban, on open fields in frontal assaults, Their Anti Air defense should have a 95% hit ratio, their fighters should be scary deadly, each droid infantry would have processed aim, target trajectory, factors, and fired a perfect shot in miliseconds. I am confused as to why they act the way they do in the movies, from the child like incompetence, to piss poor aim. It doesnt make sense. Those were the Star Wars movies you got see in theaters when I was growing up.
Now as an adult, All this lore is fascinating to me, because I never took the movies serious with how huge of a joke it wanted to be. All this added lore almost grounds star wars in a realistic manner, and the clone war movies need to be remade, and their existing ones burned, Then make 3 more movies in the clone wars era..rated R, gritty, gory, dark, I want a saving private ryan combat scene shots movie, but star wars.
I think the end of Rogue one with Vader, hearing him breathe in the dark, and come out like that...that! THAT! Was what we needed. Just give us one series of movies made for adults. Where I dont have to look at bumbling droids and comic relief because something PG rated bad happened.
Droid starfighters were formidable, and capable of speed and manuvers that would kill human pilots.
As far as their ground troops and the "Deadly aim of a machine", remember, good AI is mad expensive. but when they were made, they were deadly. such as the IG-Magna guards, and Commando droids.
B1 battledroids are so terrible, because they are also dirt cheap. and are produced in the quadrillions.
canon or legends?
.
So it's the seperatists fault and who cares a million out of trillion needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few
comment!
Something tells me that this is just poorly written lore. A good estimate of the Republic's fighting power during the Battle of Atraken is 60,000 (the Star Wars Wookipedia mentions they had only one infantry division and a few spacecraft). After 11 months of fighting, especially one that devastates a planet's population as this did, both sides would be completely eliminated, with most of the Republic space crews and Clone Troopers dying from starvation.
10th
Hey, if you’re not 100% sure you’re going to Heaven, then please reply🙏🏻✝️
Were there any gay people in legends
Yes
To the people who think Rouge One is 'anti-Trump' it matters a lot I would guess. To reasonable people it shouldn't. There are gay people in real life. In a galaxy with trillions of people there will be a few.
Old glory There was no room in Star Wars for girls using lightsabers, that changed. And I think it's for the better.
luke lee Aayla is sexy and attractive. Women were always gonna be in Star Wars, you just didn't know about them till episode II and III
Old glory Same with gays. There was a gay Mandalorian couple.