Tying the Sika Comparadun with Davie McPhail

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 38

  • @ross1458
    @ross1458 Рік тому +3

    Had to have a MRI on my back. This dropped minutes before they slid me back in the tube. I replayed it in my mind while in the "coffin" and all the noise that goes with it. Was so relaxed I fell asleep. So thank you.

    • @DavieMcPhail
      @DavieMcPhail  Рік тому +1

      Hi Ross,
      I hope your back gets better soon as I do know what it's like though I ended up going to a chiropractor which I have to say has been the best thing I ever did as it sorted out the pain for me...
      All the very best Davie

    • @ross1458
      @ross1458 Рік тому

      @@DavieMcPhail Thanks. I am going to have to have surgery. But I’m ready. Wading has become a problem and painful. The upside is I’ll be out of action for 6 to 8 weeks so lots of time to tie flies. And watch all your videos over again.

  • @freddysflyz
    @freddysflyz Рік тому +1

    Always a pleasure to watch you tie Davie! Thanks for sharing!

  • @paulbridgers3820
    @paulbridgers3820 Рік тому +4

    Another great looking fly, everything you tie is a work of art.thanks for sharing.

  • @donaloflynn3922
    @donaloflynn3922 Рік тому +1

    Thanks Davie. Another lovely tied fly.

  • @Georgeolddrones
    @Georgeolddrones Рік тому +2

    Brilliant work ,thanks Davie another great video 👍🎣🪰

  • @conorlinehan4434
    @conorlinehan4434 Рік тому +1

    I learned to measure the hair bulk on the hook before cutting. Brilliant.

    • @conorlinehan4434
      @conorlinehan4434 Рік тому +1

      Will be tying these in this fashion, I like it a lot. Great work as always.

  • @MikeFoust-by9nv
    @MikeFoust-by9nv Рік тому +1

    Nice fly! Will be tying some tomorrow. Thanks Davie!

  • @JohnAmidon-c6r
    @JohnAmidon-c6r Рік тому +1

    Interesting technique, thanks for the idea! 😊

  • @burtonbrocious171
    @burtonbrocious171 Рік тому +1

    Well tied and well designed dry fly davie a sure winner 😊

  • @lasse1187
    @lasse1187 Рік тому +1

    Really nice pattern that thx for sharing Davie

  • @ceesbouma2776
    @ceesbouma2776 Рік тому +1

    Again very nice and good materials 👍🏻

  • @grahamwebb3546
    @grahamwebb3546 Рік тому +1

    Lovely looking fly.

  • @mazman8343
    @mazman8343 Рік тому +1

    Great job Davie🙏👍

  • @RedFeatherAngler
    @RedFeatherAngler Рік тому +1

    Fabulous tie, Davie. I find that a sparser wing tends to get eaten more, but it could just be what I am confident presenting, always quartering downstream to the rising fish. They see the fly before the leader..
    Al Caucci and Bob Nastasi designed this fly to perfectly mimic mayfly duns from below while being durable and somewhat easy to tie. It is a fabulous fly, one that can stand up to multiple fish without damage.

    • @ross1458
      @ross1458 Рік тому

      Don't want to start a fight, but they based the Compara dun on Fran Betters Haystack.

    • @RedFeatherAngler
      @RedFeatherAngler Рік тому +1

      @@ross1458 You are 100% correct. They took an existing design and modified it. Along these same lines, the tail was modified from a clump of deer hair into individual tails.

    • @ross1458
      @ross1458 Рік тому

      @@RedFeatherAngler yep. Mr Better’s wasn’t the best tyer I’ve ever seen but he was an innovator. Many of his designs were “rough”. I tie my Haystacks with groundhog hair. Much neater and floats well in broken water. On C&R waters it’s the Comparadun by a mile.

  • @glenndotter5065
    @glenndotter5065 Рік тому +1

    Great pattern Davie!

  • @ricellinson
    @ricellinson Рік тому +3

    Quick question, where do you get your materials from? Love your videos

    • @DavieMcPhail
      @DavieMcPhail  Рік тому +1

      Hi @ricellinson,
      Over the years I have bought materials from many places from my local tackle shop to game fairs..Most recently I have bought from Glasgow Angling Centre,Fulling Mill, Cookshill Tackle, Premier Angling in Ireland and Ebay...I'm glad you enjoy the videos..
      All the very best Davie..

  • @NLFlyFisher
    @NLFlyFisher Рік тому +1

    Hey davie, I have a question and I figured you'd be the man to ask. I bought some synthetic dubbing but the fibres are very long and I find it unusable, do you have any advice to make it useable?

    • @DavieMcPhail
      @DavieMcPhail  Рік тому

      Hi @NLFlyFisher,
      I would cut it to a length of about an inch and a half long or so as it will make it easier to dub though make sure you mix it well..The other way is to blend it with a softer dubbing like rabbit or even wool as this makes a good dubbing as well..
      All the very best Davie

    • @NLFlyFisher
      @NLFlyFisher Рік тому

      @@DavieMcPhail thanks Davie I'll give it a shot!

    • @jeffwilliams5252
      @jeffwilliams5252 Рік тому

      “Newfoundland Fly Tying Group” going once… going twice… . Great job Davie!

  • @aurelienlinnenkamp9885
    @aurelienlinnenkamp9885 Рік тому +1

    Really bravo. So nice clap clap clap clap....🎉

  • @stevegoodchild409
    @stevegoodchild409 Рік тому

    Top draw fly again davie, well done , it’s competition for that favourite dynamite harry - would it be possible to blend your own dubbing mix do you think .?

  • @jamienoon2668
    @jamienoon2668 Рік тому +1

    how long do you tie for in a sitting?

    • @DavieMcPhail
      @DavieMcPhail  Рік тому

      Hi Jamie,
      I would normally tye for at least 6 to 8 hours a day depending on the flies I was tying though many a time I would tye a little longer to get an order finished..I have stopped taking orders now so I only tye to suit myself and my UA-cam channel..
      All the very best Davie

  • @dominiqueleblanc2193
    @dominiqueleblanc2193 Рік тому

    Another masterpiece. Dohiku also makes a nice short shank hook also. What time of the year is best to fish this fly?

  • @albertosgubin1109
    @albertosgubin1109 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful.....from Italia...

  • @kuttycrew
    @kuttycrew Рік тому +1

    Beauty Davie.

  • @АлександрНовиков-ч2в5л

    👍💪

  • @mortenthenorwegian2875
    @mortenthenorwegian2875 Рік тому +1

  • @MyPancho1
    @MyPancho1 Рік тому +1

    Fishy fly