UPDATE: Saucebox have stated that the weight is an average and that they have discontinued this palette and now use lighter pans. I am not sure how you can fit more product in lighter pans but it does mean there will be a round two for this video 😊 EDIT: please don't leave nasty reviews/comments or be rude to the brand. They are being very professional about this situation and we will give them the benefit of the doubt and try this video again with a more current palette.
Likely they were excited for their small brand to be featured in a popular series like this on UA-cam! Giving them the benefit of the doubt, this could have been a manufacturing error or miscommunication somewhere. They probably wanted to be quick and professional with their response to prevent an evie blender type problem. Looking forward to part 2 already!
BEAUTY NEWS this was crazy! Never did I think you would end up with such a deficit for a product! I would probably still buy it though cause those colors are amazing 😱
Such a disappointment that they jipped their customers out of so much product. I hope they have changed their ways, but I'm not sure I'd trust any products that they send you specifically. I mean it could be like another Too Faced situation where they send out a better product to you because of the UA-cam aspect. I'd have to buy it myself from another retailer to make sure it's not a fluke.
it gives me ease that they repress their broken makeup. Some makeup breakers just destroy it and let all the colors combine like mad men. Love u guys xx
Words That is the one of the MAIN reason I've been watching this channel. I just can't stand to see makeup destroyed for NO REASON. It irks me to no end people waste makeup like that!
It would be cool if you measured some products with trial sizes. That way you could compare which one is a better price. Such as glam glow super mud. Oh and I love this series by the way!
This is my go-to quad for bright colours (I don't own many!) & the quality is pretty darn good. I had no idea that they didn't actually hold 4g of product in each shadow - which is so great that you gals do this series!! I still really like this palette, even if it has been discontinued 😔
It doesn't really matter when you think about it. Most people don't care about the weight when considering a purchase, they sort of eyeball it by the pan if it's decent-sized (and these are); if it were advertised as 2,5 grams instead you wouldn't even know the difference. This is more like just a bizarre mistake than them trying to trick anyone (IMO) because the great majority of people doesn't actually care about looking up the weight so it's not worth lying about.
Actually, most people use price per oz or gram as a measure of value. Having an incorrect packaging value means you are telling your customers your product costs more or less than what it actually does. At a 2.5 gram actual weight instead of the 4 advertised per shadow, the palette is about $3/g rather than the $1.88/g advertised. That is a huge difference.
+Fantasticrestofthe day The law is of course that you have to give the correct information. I'm just arguing that most people consider that nearly irrelevant information that they never even bother to look up. Since "panning" is a phenomenon in the beauty community, a lot of the time you get more product than you would ever realistically spend. FInding out the information is incorrect might peeve you simply because it's incorrect, but realistically, if these pans said 2,5 grams instead, I doubt their actual size would be an issue for anyone.
I love this series so much, and I think it's doing really positive things! Keeping companies on their toes is always a good thing, as all it can bring is better products to the consumer. Love you guys, keep it up!
What an eye opener!!! Less bang for your buck! :( Thank you Kat and Hailey for continuing to do this series. I'm trying to think of something to send you for a "Makeup / Breakup / Repress" video.
I watch everything they put out on this channel. I found them through the makeup breakup, but now I'm obsessed with their Beauty News show too. It's actually really awesome - I recommend that everyone check it out. It's especially nice to put an episode on to listen to while you're doing your makeup.
I wonder if the makeup forever eyeshadows contain the appropriate amount now too. They are large pans like these, but they only list that they should contain 2.2 grams. For $21 they better have at least 2.2 grams!
Please do some Milk Makeup! They have such cool formula ideas and for the products that can be broken up I'm super curious. Maybe the quad shadows ("marshmallow cream") or the blur stick or highlighters since those were so freakishly hyped.
We have one product coming from a friend who has visited the US, but besides that Milk does not ship internationally so we won't be doing any future videos on them
An idea for makeup breakup- Take notoriously breakable makeup products or just stuff for makeup breakup generally and do the drop test before destroying them, like dropping them from a height to see how prone to breaking they are...stuff like the skin frosts which supposedly break really easy Just an idea to do before you destroy things maybe...it'd be interesting! Amazing content by the way! :D
Sara Jayne they don't really like to be in the drama from what I can tell and the company could be breaking the law so I don't blame them from steering clear of that mess.
Would love to see you test out some of the products like Benefits Minis. Are they just a luxury sample your paying for or do they really contain a decent amount in a mini package????? So many versions around at holiday times.
Wowsers that's a bit of a shock! I've never looked at the weight etc but I really do now.. when I buy an eyeshadow or palette I'm like...oooo that's more than a MAC shadow or oooo that's not! Haha. Thanks girls x
Wow! Did you contact Saucebox about this? I bought the etude in highschool for a lot of money knowing it was a good value. if I'd learned this 4 years ago I would've been distraught!
Curious if you weighed the product at all to verify the deficit? maybe it's possible the pan is magnetic and screwed up the scale? just a thought, that seems like a huge deal for it to be so off.
It weighed fine with the product in it in the beginning - the product being taken out wouldn't suddenly cause the magnet to screw up the reading. It's still an accurate way to weigh it. They've never encountered a problem with the way they weigh these products.
Saucebox said they now use lighter pans. I would assume that this palette is a mix of older pans and the lighter ones. That doesn't change how much they hold though
I agree! Maybe they thought, the pan weighs x amount and we need x amount of product to weight x amount. It will be interested to see how accurate the revised measurements will be in the new pans.
suggestion for destroying JD GLOW COSMETICS HIGHLIGHTER saw (in totalmakeupjunkie101 video ua-cam.com/video/17BmIFXhY9M/v-deo.html) that they fit 60 grams in a pan really curious if its true or a typo
BEAUTY NEWS ok but thanks for replying ps if there's a pennies or primark in Australia then can u breakup pennies/primark makeup to see if they way the correct amount
UPDATE: Saucebox have stated that the weight is an average and that they have discontinued this palette and now use lighter pans. I am not sure how you can fit more product in lighter pans but it does mean there will be a round two for this video 😊 EDIT: please don't leave nasty reviews/comments or be rude to the brand. They are being very professional about this situation and we will give them the benefit of the doubt and try this video again with a more current palette.
BEAUTY NEWS that was quick!!!
They saw the photo on Instagram when we said we were destroying their palette. I think they were waiting to see the video
Likely they were excited for their small brand to be featured in a popular series like this on UA-cam! Giving them the benefit of the doubt, this could have been a manufacturing error or miscommunication somewhere. They probably wanted to be quick and professional with their response to prevent an evie blender type problem.
Looking forward to part 2 already!
BEAUTY NEWS this was crazy! Never did I think you would end up with such a deficit for a product! I would probably still buy it though cause those colors are amazing 😱
Such a disappointment that they jipped their customers out of so much product. I hope they have changed their ways, but I'm not sure I'd trust any products that they send you specifically. I mean it could be like another Too Faced situation where they send out a better product to you because of the UA-cam aspect. I'd have to buy it myself from another retailer to make sure it's not a fluke.
Does anyone have a 3D printer & can make the girls a BN stamp for repressing?
Jo Wayte I actually do
Jo Wayte you would need so many sizes of pans though and exact measurements
I do tooo
it gives me ease that they repress their broken makeup. Some makeup breakers just destroy it and let all the colors combine like mad men. Love u guys xx
Words That is the one of the MAIN reason I've been watching this channel. I just can't stand to see makeup destroyed for NO REASON. It irks me to no end people waste makeup like that!
can you do the urban decay naked palettes? I think that would be super interesting!
Lourdes Reyna cute life hacks did something with their pallets
It would be cool if you measured some products with trial sizes. That way you could compare which one is a better price. Such as glam glow super mud. Oh and I love this series by the way!
Such a great idea!!!
Ciara Fogle YYYEEEESSSSS!!!!!!!!!
Ciara Fogle or setting sprays! I run out of those like crazy
Ciara Fogle yesss!!!
I dont think it was with trial size but they just did glam glow lol! So weird i find this comment now! XD
Could you destroy the stilla putty highlighter, that would be sooooooo satisfying!
This is my go-to quad for bright colours (I don't own many!) & the quality is pretty darn good. I had no idea that they didn't actually hold 4g of product in each shadow - which is so great that you gals do this series!! I still really like this palette, even if it has been discontinued 😔
Pleas can you do benefit box blush/ bronzers like hoola please??
can you do the storybook cosmetics eye-shadow palette?
Kinda sucks that they contained less than advertised because they look gorgeous and the way the formula looks is very pretty.
It doesn't really matter when you think about it. Most people don't care about the weight when considering a purchase, they sort of eyeball it by the pan if it's decent-sized (and these are); if it were advertised as 2,5 grams instead you wouldn't even know the difference. This is more like just a bizarre mistake than them trying to trick anyone (IMO) because the great majority of people doesn't actually care about looking up the weight so it's not worth lying about.
that makes it completely worth it to the company to cheat their customers. it is against the law for a reason.
Actually, most people use price per oz or gram as a measure of value. Having an incorrect packaging value means you are telling your customers your product costs more or less than what it actually does.
At a 2.5 gram actual weight instead of the 4 advertised per shadow, the palette is about $3/g rather than the $1.88/g advertised. That is a huge difference.
Some people don't care about weight, and some people do. It is often a way to see if the product is worth the money.
+Fantasticrestofthe day The law is of course that you have to give the correct information. I'm just arguing that most people consider that nearly irrelevant information that they never even bother to look up. Since "panning" is a phenomenon in the beauty community, a lot of the time you get more product than you would ever realistically spend. FInding out the information is incorrect might peeve you simply because it's incorrect, but realistically, if these pans said 2,5 grams instead, I doubt their actual size would be an issue for anyone.
Love that Kat matches the two blue eyeshadows!
I gave it a thumbs up RIGHT when I heard that "Illuminati confirmed" joke. Sold.
I love this series so much, and I think it's doing really positive things! Keeping companies on their toes is always a good thing, as all it can bring is better products to the consumer. Love you guys, keep it up!
How many lines in an eyeliner pen guys? 💕💕💕💕💕 love u
Nageena Rehman they couldn't do that cuz everyones' eyeliner is different
What an eye opener!!! Less bang for your buck! :( Thank you Kat and Hailey for continuing to do this series. I'm trying to think of something to send you for a "Makeup / Breakup / Repress" video.
The colours are freaking awesome.
Who else is subscribed just for them breaking the makeup up
I watch everything they put out on this channel. I found them through the makeup breakup, but now I'm obsessed with their Beauty News show too. It's actually really awesome - I recommend that everyone check it out. It's especially nice to put an episode on to listen to while you're doing your makeup.
I started watching them just for that, but ended up being hooked by the news they do
grazemes123 lol who hasn't😂
grazemes123 me🤚🏽🤚🏽
meeee 😂
You guys are just so nice and endearing. You brighten up a day.
I wonder if the makeup forever eyeshadows contain the appropriate amount now too. They are large pans like these, but they only list that they should contain 2.2 grams. For $21 they better have at least 2.2 grams!
Their pans are the same size as these so 2.2g is probably accurate
That's so crazy! I wanted to order from saucebox the other day too. Would you continue to do more saucebox palettes?! I'm so curious!!
I think they will all have the same result
These videos just make me want to destroy all my makeup and repress it because it looks so satisfying 😅
TheBudgetBlog literally trying to talk myself out of doing just that right now! 😅
TheBudgetBlog... I just startede and i love it...Im having a blast.. 😊
Hug from Danmark 🌹
Please do some Milk Makeup! They have such cool formula ideas and for the products that can be broken up I'm super curious. Maybe the quad shadows ("marshmallow cream") or the blur stick or highlighters since those were so freakishly hyped.
We have one product coming from a friend who has visited the US, but besides that Milk does not ship internationally so we won't be doing any future videos on them
An idea for makeup breakup- Take notoriously breakable makeup products or just stuff for makeup breakup generally and do the drop test before destroying them, like dropping them from a height to see how prone to breaking they are...stuff like the skin frosts which supposedly break really easy
Just an idea to do before you destroy things maybe...it'd be interesting!
Amazing content by the way! :D
I love the bashing and slashing of such big pans! Glad you named this Makeup Breakup, Bash and Slash makes it sound like serial killers ha ha ha.
Do you plan on contacting the brand about this? I would.
Oh trust me, they'll find out.
they've probably already seen it.
I was wondering the same thing, it would've made for a very interesting video if they'd asked the company for a response.
Sara Jayne they don't really like to be in the drama from what I can tell and the company could be breaking the law so I don't blame them from steering clear of that mess.
As journalists I would hope that they would at least reach out to the company for their response. It will be interesting to hear.
could you please breakup some ELF products? love from Charlotte, NC USA!!
sarahmariebeauty I was just on a plane leaving from there
Yay 😄
What lipstick are you wearing Kat? It's lovely!
Hailey, your eyeshadow gurl! Tutorial? Or even just a list. ☺
Could you do an eyeliner pen until it runs out please? Xxx love u Guys xxx
Nageena Rehman I love this idea, they could draw a straight line and measure how many cm it goes on for!
Miss Mollie's world YES
We have an eyeliner pen set aside, we just need to find the time to film it x
BEAUTY NEWS I'm so excited, it's probably gonna take ages though 🤔😂
I'm supposed to be studying for finals...
Would love to see you test out some of the products like Benefits Minis. Are they just a luxury sample your paying for or do they really contain a decent amount in a mini package????? So many versions around at holiday times.
WHY IS THIS SO SATISFYING TO WATCH!! 💕💕💕
I can't find the follow-up video. Were you ever able to do one for Saucebox?
Loved the colours they had... even with the deficit I'm still somewhat tempted as none of my pallets have those amazing shade, lol.... TFS guys 💜💜
Wowsers that's a bit of a shock! I've never looked at the weight etc but I really do now.. when I buy an eyeshadow or palette I'm like...oooo that's more than a MAC shadow or oooo that's not! Haha. Thanks girls x
Well. this was surprising. Did they swatch the same after repressiing? I wonder how saucebox will respond to this one xx
It makes me so sad because those colors are SO BEAUTIFUL. Had this turned out better I would have totally purchase the palette.
please do the putty highlighter next. I love your show it kills me but interests me at the same time!!💕💕
love this channel and you ladies! such beautiful ladies with great ideas and perspectives!!
Yay. Favourite morning of the week
you guys should do the shade and light contour palette!
Yasss best thing about a Tuesday ❤️
These videos are so relaxing! ❤️
U 2 are very beautiful ppl I love ur vids keep satisfying me and putting a smile on my face😊😊💕🦄
When are you going to do a round 2?
you should destory putty highlighter like if you want to see that!!!
Awe, I was hoping you would have a before and after swatch to show their quality.
the smashbox lip palette?
The eyeshadow seemed chalky but satisfying to watch as always. Much rather be watching this than preparing for my finals
Often bright shades do look chalky because of the amount and type of pigment they contain. These perform nicely
could you please do nikkietutorial's ofra collab highlighter ?! ❤❤❤
You guys should do the Kylie lip kits/glosses
Wow! Did you contact Saucebox about this? I bought the etude in highschool for a lot of money knowing it was a good value. if I'd learned this 4 years ago I would've been distraught!
Is it dodie yellow though
When you repressed the shadows, they looked exactly like before!
But is it dodie yellow?
What makeup product could you not live without and why? Xx
Izzy King that's easy for me. I have to have mascara! My eyes feel naked without it.
Izzy King brows
Izzy King Nice question! I couldn't live without concealer. 😊
I'd have to say mascara or highlight
You should do a drop test video seeing which make up products are the most easily broken if you drop them
can you destroy the ABH modern renaissance palette
Can you do a Jeffree Star lip?
awesome job as always!!
2:07
MORE LIKE BILL CIPHER
EMIREIGHT
pls somebody know wat I'm talking about
I see it ;)
Curious if you weighed the product at all to verify the deficit? maybe it's possible the pan is magnetic and screwed up the scale? just a thought, that seems like a huge deal for it to be so off.
It weighed fine with the product in it in the beginning - the product being taken out wouldn't suddenly cause the magnet to screw up the reading. It's still an accurate way to weigh it. They've never encountered a problem with the way they weigh these products.
prettypistolx the magnets are inside the packaging, the pans are just normal metal pans.
These are regular eyeshadow pans
It's kinda sad that they discontinued the palette tho. I really loved the colours!
do the huda beauty rose gold palette!!!
Weight deficit aside, those colours 😻
The shadows are beautiful!
break it up 💪
I don't even own makeup but love this series
Great video, love the colors..👍👍
You Are so soooO funny.. 😜😂
Hug from Danmark 🌹
Can you do a Bobbi Brown highlighter brick?
Don't blame me if I'm wrong, but can't you sue the company if you don't get the promised amount?
No, but I believe they can be fined for it
love this channel!!!!!
please do modern Renaissance pallate!!
The name of your purple lipstick !!!!!! - - *-*
I think you should include the re-panned weight so one and know how much product they can expect to lose when re-panning
We don't recommend re-pressing unless you have broken products... there is no reason to do it otherwise, so the amount lost shouldn't be an issue
Sneaky buggers - that is outrageous!
Is it possible that the palette was preused?
No. It was sent from an online store and was untouched
Came down to the comment section and thought the majority of comments would be on her beautiful manicure.
LOVE this!!!
See how much product is in the Diorskin Airflash foundation
We have filmed that! It will be coming up soon x
Great, looking forward to it :)
I found the song so aesthetic
I find it interesting the re empty pans have different weights.
We thought that was strange too. We reweighed them to make sure
I find it odd the empty pans have such different weights. Maybe that's the issue?
Saucebox said they now use lighter pans. I would assume that this palette is a mix of older pans and the lighter ones. That doesn't change how much they hold though
I agree! Maybe they thought, the pan weighs x amount and we need x amount of product to weight x amount. It will be interested to see how accurate the revised measurements will be in the new pans.
this video is like you are 5 years old and you just destroyed your mums make up but you know how to fix it.
Woo-hoo!!! ❤
Wowwwwww 👏🏻👏🏻😱😱😱👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Wowwww I would be furious if I had bought this palette.
my friends bought me the sweet peach pallete for my birthday today and i dropped it and smashed done of the shades :(
Ruby Tyler repress what's left
yeah i might
but you can't get rubbing alcohol in the uk
Look on amazon they might have it
thanks i will
Ahh that sucks that there's less product in each pan 😩
Wow, I never heard of that brand before, that's pretty strange outcome
you guys should do something different like eat or drink
This is a beauty channel so we tend to stick to beauty products :)
It looks really creamy though not flakey at all!
The eyeshadows seem a lil chalky
starts at 1:10 :)
it's already in the description box
BEAUTY NEWS ok, but this way mobile users can just look at my comment and click on the time stamp to go directly to that point :)))
You should weigh them after you're repressed them so that you can see how much weight the alcohol adds
But that is pointless because the alcohol dries out completely within a day or two
Nice
suggestion for destroying JD GLOW COSMETICS HIGHLIGHTER saw (in totalmakeupjunkie101 video ua-cam.com/video/17BmIFXhY9M/v-deo.html) that they fit 60 grams in a pan really curious if its true or a typo
#beautynewsfam 💖💖
Plz do a makeup breakup for Clare's makeup like if u agree
We don't have any Clare's makeup in Australia
BEAUTY NEWS ok but thanks for replying ps if there's a pennies or primark in Australia then can u breakup pennies/primark makeup to see if they way the correct amount
Sorry for the rudeness... Love you
Am I the only one bothered that they use a paper towel that has a pattern?😂😂
I have no idea why that would personally bother you x
I don't know! Its probably because I'm so used to smooth eyeshadows that the texture throws me off 😅