The Music Trend That NEEDS TO DIE

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
  • This is the biggest problem with new music. We spoke about albums like Lil Baby’s It’s Only Me and Trippie Redd’s Mansion Musik, and discussed the issues with long albums.
    Listen to our Exclusive Audio Podcast on Spotify:
    go.nfrpodcast.c...
    Listen to our Exclusive Audio Podcast on Apple Podcasts:
    go.nfrpodcast.c...
    Twitter: go.nfrpodcast.c...
    TikTok: go.nfrpodcast.c...
    Instagram: go.nfrpodcast.c...
    #Rap #HipHop

КОМЕНТАРІ • 570

  • @zimbim7317
    @zimbim7317 2 роки тому +425

    Seeing an album that’s 20+ songs makes me feel tired just looking at it

    • @bruh......2005
      @bruh......2005 2 роки тому +26

      Same i can only tolerate that amount of tracks for certain experimental albums. I'm not gonna seat through 20 tracks of a trap album I can already predict how the production and the flows are gonna be (there are exceptions of course, but for most absolutely no)

    • @Fent-
      @Fent- 2 роки тому +11

      @@bruh......2005 I can basically guess your entire music personality off of this comment lol.
      You probably like: Kanye, Tyler the creator, Denzel Curry, asap Rocky, Travis Scott, Kendrick. Maybe playboi carti/Young Thug.
      You probably hate: Drake, Lil Durk, lil baby, Youngboy, Nav, Polo G and most likely call a majority of them “generic trap”

    • @bruh......2005
      @bruh......2005 2 роки тому +31

      @@Fent- Nav and Drake are fine, even overhated at times. But You would never see me hating on Polo G and Durk lol (They are one of the exceptions I was talking about). Those are probably one of the most interesting rappers in the melodic trap scene imo. Making baseless assumptions when you don't really know someone is kinda weird my guy.

    • @yeldarb1880
      @yeldarb1880 2 роки тому +8

      @Fent hiphop isn't the only genre there is

    • @nihonzaki7048
      @nihonzaki7048 Рік тому +2

      There’s only a small handful of artists that can pull off albums like that. Kendrick is one of them I will say for sure

  • @masitherapper
    @masitherapper 2 роки тому +817

    We need more artists like Kendrick Lamar and Tyler, the creator who really create a concept and an atmosphere, now people don't really get into albums, they just expect a popular song but they do not invest their time in an album as an experience outside the music itself.

    • @jaroldinho3923
      @jaroldinho3923 2 роки тому +61

      even if kendrick dropped a 3 hour album, i would listen

    • @jerrykod8307
      @jerrykod8307 2 роки тому +41

      @@jaroldinho3923 yeah cause hes a great artist / you probably meat ride him

    • @jerrykod8307
      @jerrykod8307 2 роки тому +6

      i agree tho, its good that we have some shorter projects that have good songs althroughout such as no thank you by little simz, tos by jermaine, even lyfe by yeat lmao (which i think is his best project yet even though it hardly compares to the first two ive mentioned)

    • @jakeezetci
      @jakeezetci 2 роки тому +12

      there are ton of those artists you just need to look outside mainstream hiphop

    • @aparadeinjune
      @aparadeinjune 2 роки тому

      I got u bro new song on my page⚡️💕

  • @igimaster5872
    @igimaster5872 2 роки тому +271

    fax so many artists now try to make 2 good songs and 30 song long albums rather than 15 song albums entirely comprised of great songs

    • @sithxle7546
      @sithxle7546 2 роки тому +25

      Lil Baby is a prime example of that

    • @silentsage2462
      @silentsage2462 2 роки тому +4

      That will come back. All the best albums have under 15 tracks aside from a couple exceptions (early em, ready to die). Kanye’s early shit had over 15 tracks but had a ton of skits.

    • @jerrykod8307
      @jerrykod8307 2 роки тому +1

      12-15 song albums*

    • @twippie5313
      @twippie5313 2 роки тому +6

      @@sithxle7546 but Lil Baby went 0/20 😂

    • @egotrips4810
      @egotrips4810 2 роки тому +1

      Lil Baby & others should take lessons from Lupe's Drogas Wave, a masterpiece album of 24 songs. Quality > quantity

  • @keiytofficial
    @keiytofficial 2 роки тому +89

    As an 18 year old, it saddens me so much that people around my age don’t care about albums and an album experience. There’s just something beautiful to the concept of being able to put multiple songs together, you can get crazy creative. But people just don’t care about that creativity, and about something unique, and that sucks so much. Makes artists like me, who literally want to make conceptual or great album experiences, so discouraged from doing so.

    • @wealthtelevision6970
      @wealthtelevision6970 Рік тому +1

      I'm 19 and I feel you it's sad

    • @modernmichelangelo
      @modernmichelangelo Рік тому +1

      As a 16 year old myself, I hear you. It seems like the a lot of people of my generation don’t appreciate actual good music.

  • @lqmonade592
    @lqmonade592 2 роки тому +408

    i fully agree about this issue; i'm 15 and i've only recently started listening to full albums, and seeing 20+ song albums really sucks sometimes. if i wanna listen to an album, i don't want it to be a 5 hour experience because, even though that would be awesome, i have school and homework and other responsibilities so i can't just sit down and enjoy and album sometimes

    • @illusionssx
      @illusionssx 2 роки тому +56

      bro you’re 15. i promise you are not too busy

    • @mram7571
      @mram7571 2 роки тому +149

      @@illusionssx 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

    • @imonyoutuberightnow2668
      @imonyoutuberightnow2668 2 роки тому +178

      @@illusionssx bro why are you gatekeeping being busy LMAO

    • @brofiss352
      @brofiss352 2 роки тому +3

      The last classic 20 song plus album was Hoodie szn imo and almost every track is 🔥should have won a Grammy 2018

    • @fin183
      @fin183 2 роки тому +3

      Firstly, I've never seen a 5 hour long album. On average they are about an hour. Also, you can always start listening to an album and come back to it later. They're not like films where you have to watch it from the beginning to know what's going on.

  • @kaiserandvlad
    @kaiserandvlad 2 роки тому +86

    I do want to point out that "long" albums can be deceiving. take Madvillainy as an example: its a 22 song album, but filled with skits, and shorter songs, making it only around 45 minutes - or perfect for a cohesive album experience. this could be a middle ground for having good numbers but still good experiences.

  • @ethancreations4457
    @ethancreations4457 2 роки тому +69

    Regarding classic 20 song projects, I would argue that Faces and The Life of Pablo should be in that conversation. However, I do agree with your general thoughts about the current state of music. It's sad to see so many artists give in to this 20+ song format and sacrifice quality in the process. I'm a firm believer that creating quality albums will yield artists more longevity as opposed to just pushing out as much material as possible. It's the reason why guys like Kendrick can take massive hiatuses and still take the game over when they come back. Meanwhile someone like Dababy is constantly putting out low quality, redundant material, and he's falling off at a historical rate.

  • @egotrips4810
    @egotrips4810 2 роки тому +62

    This is why Lupe is an amazing artist, he's shown he can create masterpieces out of long albums like Drogas Wave (24 songs) or short ones like Drill Music in Zion (10 tracks). Quality over quantity

    • @Spoonkid222
      @Spoonkid222 2 роки тому +8

      and tetsuo and youth! big ol longie but it's kind of a concept album (and a good one at that

    • @marcuscrooze2716
      @marcuscrooze2716 2 роки тому

      trash

    • @robintetris
      @robintetris Рік тому +2

      @@Spoonkid222 tetsuo and youth has some of the best rap songs ever but also some lows in there

  • @Iamarobot69k
    @Iamarobot69k 2 роки тому +85

    streaming is a very double edged sword. For music nerds like me, its incredible because i get access to so much material and i can explore much much easier than ever before. But for the casual music fan, it just encourages comfortability, safe choices and chasing trends. The sad truth is that the number of people who genuinely care about lyrics, meaning, and cohesive albums is much much less than the amount of people who just want to hear something pleasant and move on.

    • @Fent-
      @Fent- 2 роки тому +8

      There’s nothing wrong with wanting to hear a good sounding album sonically, opposed to wanting some conceptual retrospective think piece album to dissect. The latter can be very corny at times, especially the fans it attracts.

  • @paupareets
    @paupareets 2 роки тому +47

    agree, the main problem is that lots of artists don't care about the quality of music as they do about the sales and the money, great podcast btw

  • @shivanshdubby
    @shivanshdubby 2 роки тому +89

    The attention span has decreased every generation so personally i love an album with a runtime of like 30-45mins at max UNLESS IT'S A CONCEPT ALBUM and the 7 song concept was so good too

    • @elvnrae
      @elvnrae 2 роки тому +8

      i think perfect album tracklist lenght should be 8 to 13 (it can be 15 tracks long with interludes etc)

    • @jakopars
      @jakopars 2 роки тому

      Agreed

    • @bruh......2005
      @bruh......2005 2 роки тому +4

      If I see an album with more then 15 (without counting interludes) tracks, depending on the artist I'm not gonna subject myself to it. I feel that's the problem with some trap albums today, too much filler tracks that should've been taken down and deluxe albums that add absolutely nothing to the previous record.

    • @Fent-
      @Fent- 2 роки тому

      @@bruh......2005 there’s no such thing as trap music today. It’s an obsolete genre. I’ve heard niggas call Travis Scott…from Houston Texas….trap music. Like what lol.

    • @khron7
      @khron7 2 роки тому

      @@Fent- some songs on Heroes & Villains are definitely trap

  • @marekbombilaj4201
    @marekbombilaj4201 2 роки тому +19

    The runtime is also really important!
    For example Madvilliany is 21 tracks but only like 40 minutes. On the other hand there are also projects like All eyes on me or Life after death, Speakerboxx/ The love below which are the highest quality as well but are over 2 hours. For me an artist has to be really genius to put out 20+ song album and make it worth a listen. It is also really scary that that are peole who ignore albums as a whole. I personally cant remember something more mind blowing than listening to Illmatic or The College Dropout, The 36 chambers and all these amazing records and I wish that more people will explore the genius of these projects in the future.
    Great video guys, keep up the content!

  • @Ivythecreator
    @Ivythecreator 2 роки тому +27

    A great 24 songs album is Faces by Mac. I only skip San Francisco from time to time.
    But overall it’s a perfect exemple of a well executed long album

    • @shaakzistaken
      @shaakzistaken Рік тому

      I can't get into it, the music is very polarising to just passively listen to. I prefer swimming but is there a way I can get into the album itself?

  • @Soggydogee
    @Soggydogee 2 роки тому +10

    I feel like 20 -30 songs only works for an album experience is if there skits and short instrumentals such as madviallian I feel that listener fatigue also effects this heavily

  • @zionelie8830
    @zionelie8830 Рік тому +5

    Tbh for me it’s the artist and society we live in, everyone begs for they’re favorite artists to drop an album or more music (including me) and when the artist just drops an album they didn’t really try on then ppl don’t listen to the album in a whole. I’m not tired of long albums if the artist actually tries, but I think us as fans need to understand that these ppl are actually human beings that need time to actually come out with something genuine and something that the artists are actually proud of. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

  • @adibchyy
    @adibchyy 2 роки тому +22

    I had this thought exactly. If Donda was stripped down to a minimalist experience zeroing in on a specific theme, it would be a perfect 10. I made a playlist of 12 songs that sufficiently make the point of the album.

  • @MithrandilPlays
    @MithrandilPlays 2 роки тому +6

    "Recent" Masterpiece Albums w/ over ~20 songs:
    2021: Little Simz - SIMBI (19)
    2017: Big KRIT - 4eva Is A Mighty Long Time (22)
    2014: Mac Miller - Faces (25)

    • @liltree8382
      @liltree8382 2 роки тому +1

      All of those are boring

    • @cristobalcarrascovicente
      @cristobalcarrascovicente 2 роки тому

      Simbi kinda has a few interludes bro so it is kinda like 16-17
      Still pretty cohesive and W faces and 4eva

    • @alexraasch26
      @alexraasch26 Рік тому

      Whole Lotta Red

  • @_M41KU_
    @_M41KU_ 2 роки тому +10

    Lil Yachty understood this with “let’s start here”

  • @birdsfly7199
    @birdsfly7199 2 роки тому +4

    Something I’ve always appreciated from XXXTentacion is that he was brief with his music. He understood that time is money and didn’t make the experience a drag. I much rather want more from an artist than to get tired of them.

    • @robintetris
      @robintetris Рік тому +3

      his songs are too short and unfinished

  • @reezyturner051
    @reezyturner051 2 роки тому +3

    We need more diverse production.
    Mainstream rappers will always rap about bullshit but what sets each mainstream rapper apart is production.
    SWITCH UP THE 808 PATTERN! GET WEIRD WITH THE MELODIES! EVERYBODY GOT A GUITAR & A FLUTE, THEN GO GET A HARP AND A ACCORDION!!

    • @prodgrantgambino
      @prodgrantgambino 2 роки тому

      exactly, thats what made the soundcloud era so fire. And then guess what, the weird beats made the artists perform better! People love to say the producers carry but its crazy what a good beat can bring out. People dont understand man. But anyways if you looking for diverse production turn to the current underground.

  • @Soffish583822
    @Soffish583822 2 роки тому +2

    I did my undergrad dissertation on this. Where artists, and labels especially, go wrong, is that they think they can just put out as much content as possible and saturate the playlists for maximum streams and profit. But if the album experience isn't properly considered, then the music reviewers and taste makers won't fuck with it, and the fact is, they're the listeners who will buy the vinyl/shirt/tickets.

  • @compotason142
    @compotason142 2 роки тому +18

    This is why I love 17 by xxxtentacion so much. 11 songs 22 minutes can go through this album so many times and never get bored of it

    • @bruh......2005
      @bruh......2005 2 роки тому +1

      I think X's eps are way better then his albums, but it's also a good example. Even if I didn't like the album atleast it was straight to the point on what it was trynna achieve, it didn't felt dragged out.

    • @Kanyewestbiggestfan123
      @Kanyewestbiggestfan123 2 роки тому +6

      17 is the most boring album I have ever heard

    • @robintetris
      @robintetris Рік тому

      17 is so unfinished

  • @barry4649
    @barry4649 2 роки тому +4

    I never noticed you had such low subscribers man, it’s criminal you don’t have at least 300k, you guys are some of the best on this platform

  • @ketchup8837
    @ketchup8837 2 роки тому +6

    -faces by Mac Miller
    -three sided tape volume one by lil ugly mane
    -man plays the horn by cities Aviv
    -LP! OFFLINE by jpegmafia
    -Whole lotta of red by Carti
    And many others could be considered classics in there own rights

  • @cameronglover2596
    @cameronglover2596 Рік тому +3

    I only recently started really listening to full albums of songs that I liked, and I’ve found some songs I had no idea existed and I’ve heard a lot of albums that were so fulfilling to listen to. Listen to all you can to make sure you’ve found the right music

  • @NikashGanguli
    @NikashGanguli 2 роки тому +5

    this guy disrespected Ok ok off of DONDA, Yatchy and Rooga went insane.

  • @jdenton1337
    @jdenton1337 2 роки тому +9

    Less people listening to albums is WAY more about more people listening to playlists than it is about album quality imo.

  • @R2bball
    @R2bball Рік тому +1

    I like 20 track albums but it has to have versatility. Nobody wants the same production all the way through

  • @thenewyorkhip-hopspot5485
    @thenewyorkhip-hopspot5485 2 роки тому +4

    Wasn’t gonna make a vid on this but y’all inspired me. I felt this way for nearly a year now.

  • @rigussy5287
    @rigussy5287 2 роки тому +10

    It shouldn't matter how long it is as long as it keeps me entertained, stevie wonder kept me entertained me for an hour and 45 minutes but if an artist can only keep me entertained for 30 minutes than that's what they should do

  • @iangarcia1585
    @iangarcia1585 2 роки тому +60

    Alfredo by Freddie Gibbs is a perfect example of a flawless tracklist album. You get 35 minutes of nothing but QUALITY (unlike most of the mediocare artists these days)

    • @user-ss5bu3hc1r
      @user-ss5bu3hc1r 2 роки тому +5

      i think the underground not doing huge numbers helps with their overall quality and respect as they dont have to stuff their albums and get to hold their own vision

    • @iangarcia1585
      @iangarcia1585 2 роки тому +10

      @user-ss5bu3hc1r true, but at the same time, I'm getting so tired of these mainstream casual audiences always ignoring these great albums that are not that big and later complain on how music today isn't as good then it was back then😒

    • @LucinaMeow
      @LucinaMeow 2 роки тому

      @@iangarcia1585 so many great artists that aren't popular and then u have AJR doing numbers. Who are pretty awful artists. Also check out foxtails - fawn

    • @egotrips4810
      @egotrips4810 2 роки тому +3

      Dude I literally finished my first listen on Alfredo, it's amazing. I never heard Freddie before until that Cordae feature, and his verse killed it. Bumped Alfredo soon after and he is fire 👍

    • @frespects9624
      @frespects9624 2 роки тому +1

      @@egotrips4810 listen to all of his back catalog, very good

  • @mitchy_p490
    @mitchy_p490 2 роки тому +6

    got a long day of school today this upload is just what i needed🙏

    • @tariq6319
      @tariq6319 2 роки тому +3

      9:15 pm over here in Germany I'm going to bed after the video :D

    • @mitchy_p490
      @mitchy_p490 2 роки тому

      @@tariq6319 wish i could go to bed😭

    • @paupareets
      @paupareets 2 роки тому

      i feel u bro

  • @Worline8628
    @Worline8628 2 роки тому +3

    As a kid who grew up during the early 2000s, rap albums that were 18-20 tracks were my favorite. It felt like I was getting two songs per dollar spent. I haven't felt that way about albums that length in a long time, though. The first album I purchased was Eminem's MMLP, and the last album I purchased that was that long was Game's R.E.D album in like 2011 lol. Even by 2012 or 2013 when MMLP2 dropped, that one has SO many skips.
    I love streaming, but I do miss when artists were able to do the long run times and have it feel worth it. Without CD sales being the main goal though, I don't think we'll ever have that again, aside from my maybe concept albums.

  • @CF73737
    @CF73737 2 роки тому +3

    Very strongly agree. I’ve not listened to albums bc of their length. They really have to stop

  • @6ftkd959
    @6ftkd959 2 роки тому +8

    Ye needed to feed us though, his 2018 albums and Jesus Is King were very short. Also dropped nothing significant in 2020

    • @enjoi9970
      @enjoi9970 2 роки тому

      Yep, people completely ignore this fact lol

    • @GenuineRSA
      @GenuineRSA Рік тому

      Nah bro, he sacrificed quality over quantity. He could have released a 12 track album and release the fillers as throwaway singles cause there's a lot of tracks that are subpar

  • @brianwhite5142
    @brianwhite5142 2 роки тому +20

    Not hiphop but SOS by SZA has been number one for like 9 weeks with a 23 song album. I think artists can put out a successful long project if the demand is there.

    • @HOLLYWOKEtv
      @HOLLYWOKEtv Рік тому +3

      she hasnt put out a project in like 6 years thats why

  • @vomitingforever5392
    @vomitingforever5392 2 роки тому +2

    I’m split on the length. I don’t come back to albums, i listen to it a few times and add the songs i like to my playlist, so when it’s 20+ songs, i like that it’s a lot for me to choose from, but it’s also very inconvenient and i lose interest halfway through and will have to come back to give some songs another chances

  • @Spectre0799
    @Spectre0799 2 роки тому +44

    For the first 2 months of Donda being out I listened the whole way through 10-20 times

    • @exotic_blitz7747
      @exotic_blitz7747 2 роки тому +10

      let’s be real we did that bc of the rollout and clb rollout n the whole beef. when’s the last time you played donda from front to back?

    • @streyy1740
      @streyy1740 2 роки тому

      @@exotic_blitz7747the only time I played it from front to back is when it dropped in august 2021, no replay value

    • @Spectre0799
      @Spectre0799 2 роки тому

      @@exotic_blitz7747 probably last year. But last year was also probably the last time I listen to any album the whole way through. Got nothing to do with the clb beef I was bumping clb too.

    • @Mo_3n1
      @Mo_3n1 2 роки тому +26

      Donda is painful to listen to the whole way through. Why would someone want 2 hours of songs that have a very similar sound, inconsistent quality, many songs that are 5+ minutes long (despite not needing to be) etc. Donda has plenty of good songs, but as a whole album, I have no plans of listening to it again the whole way through. 808s is my most listened to album of all time tho, love that shit.

    • @johnohrstrom5112
      @johnohrstrom5112 2 роки тому +14

      I've been a huge Kanye fan since he was just a producer on Roc a Fella...
      Bought physical copies of every album he put out physically.
      Donda has like 4 good songs.
      Same for CLB.
      This video speaks to the problems with both albums.

  • @caskey7563
    @caskey7563 2 роки тому +2

    from an audience perspective, I feel in the past decade people have constantly had their attention span decreased. Social media platforms like Instagram, ticktock and even UA-cam seem to have constantly pushed the emphasis on capturing the audience attention within that first 10 seconds. Younger generations are dealing with reels and ticktocks now and if they're bored, they just swipe next. I feel this plays into the consumption of music as well. People don't have the attention span to listen to such long albums.

  • @claytonsmusicreviews1837
    @claytonsmusicreviews1837 2 роки тому +6

    Not a rap album but SOS by SZA will be the next classic album with over 20 songs from years to come!

  • @Andrew.W.19
    @Andrew.W.19 2 роки тому +5

    TikTok generation created a culture of only listening to trendy song vs listening to albums. I bought my niece (14 years old) a record player and LPs to appreciate the artist’s work.

  • @LiL_CraZy-uu9ze
    @LiL_CraZy-uu9ze 2 роки тому +1

    I'm 20 years old and last year King Iso dropped his Get Well Soon album and I have played that album more than 20 times in one year. It is such a great album and I really highly suggest listening to it. It'll really change ur perspective on a lot.

  • @Odel964
    @Odel964 2 роки тому +3

    love the videos boys keep it up when is that top 10 rappers of all time list coming?😄

  • @leobretho7193
    @leobretho7193 2 роки тому +4

    If an album if like longer than 18 songs I end up just listening to it in like 4 song periods over like a couple days rather than just listening to it in full as it releases. I find I have to do this especially in trap albums (lil baby, trippie red etc)

  • @snirdysnird
    @snirdysnird 2 роки тому +8

    I listened to 4eva is a mighty long time by big krit a while back. It is probably the best album from the past couple of years when it comes to having a lengthy tracklist with over 20 songs while having no filler

    • @yesmk000
      @yesmk000 2 роки тому

      what im saying. fav hiphop album since good kid maad city

    • @cristobalcarrascovicente
      @cristobalcarrascovicente 2 роки тому +1

      4eva is good despite the tracklist because it is so damn diverse.
      Like damn,one of the few +20 songs albums that doesn't sound the damn same to me

  • @Sal-zs1ob
    @Sal-zs1ob 2 роки тому +5

    Another problem is that the new generation of rappers can’t rap about anything that isn’t hoes, money and opps. I know the argument is old but it’s still relevant. Most of the new popping rappers can’t hold anyone’s attention on a song that’s 5+ minutes long and instead they all have 2-3 minute long songs where the verse and chorus structure are all the same and then all 20 songs on their albums are that. Same structure, short, same topics. That’s why it gets exhausting listening to them

    • @smaaron_j_46
      @smaaron_j_46 2 роки тому +2

      I think their consumers are much worse. They will shun anything that’s artistic or lyrical, and big up all the synthetic shit they love because they have short attention spans. Really, it’s the industry’s fault.

    • @GaelGamaa
      @GaelGamaa 2 роки тому +4

      This is literally lil baby. He ruined hiphop

  • @fryc0206
    @fryc0206 2 роки тому +3

    i'm 16, and i listen full to an album for the first time like 2 month ago, and now i listen to albums all the time, before that i listen to only playlist with songs i listened before in sm or spotyfy recomendations, my generation is accustomed to listen to singles or hits all the time, i think that is a problem of the audience not from the artist, there are good new albums all the time.
    sorry for the bad english im argentinian

  • @tbsgjack2555
    @tbsgjack2555 2 роки тому +2

    18 and it's only in the past year I've been getting into albums. Even with that, i do get kinda excited seeing an album I'm interested in is like 10 or less tracks...

  • @Dr.electron
    @Dr.electron 2 роки тому +1

    I remember when songs used to br 5 minutes long. Nowadays Long track list and short songs really reflects on how our attention spans are shortened

  • @omar_opt
    @omar_opt 2 роки тому +5

    14:04 Luca came with the analogies. 🥶🥶🥶

  • @dooderman8361
    @dooderman8361 2 роки тому +2

    The truth is from a mainstream standpoint there’s little to no downside to dropping huge albums with filler, the more tracks you add the more streams you get, the hits will still hit no matter how much bloat you add, so if you aren’t releasing for legacy or trying to make perfect albums there’s no reason not to add bloat. Yes when artists are more concise like Tyler, Kendrick, etc their fans really appreciate that, but that doesn’t matter to these other rappers, they are trying to make money and like y’all said people don’t really listen to albums anyways so there’s no point in mainstream artists dropping concise projects unless they want to be the goat. Y’all saying that “you should drop albums with less songs because you need to keep your audience captivated” but you don’t tho, y’all said yourselves people don’t listen to the entire albums so why does it need to be captivating? I’m starting to get more into the album experience so I would enjoy it if artists like trippie would drop a concise album that is really caring about quality, I hope he does that on ALLTY5 but I don’t think that’s going to happen, trippie has had bloat on his albums for a long time now. I think y’all answered your own questions, artists drop bloated track lists because it makes them the most money, and fans are ok with bloated track lists because they don’t listen to full albums anymore, it’s just how it is. If artists want to start dropping concise track lists they will do so, but like y’all showed that doesn’t make them much money most of the time and for most of the mainstream rappers that’s all they care about so I don’t see the mainstream ever going back to concise albums (of course there will always be outliers tho)

  • @javianjohnson8746
    @javianjohnson8746 2 роки тому +3

    Honestly, unless it’s an artist that I’ve been DYING for them to drop, I next to never listen to 20+ albums on release day. That’s wayyy too intimidating of an amount for me to just drop everything and sit through their album for over an hour. Personally I think the sweet spot is between 13-17 songs on a solid album

  • @RetroEternal
    @RetroEternal 2 роки тому +2

    One of the only 20+ song albums I fw is TLOP4 (including deluxe) by Pi’erre Bourne, but that’s because the tape was entirely from the mind and talent of ONE person and every track seamlessly transitioned into the next, creating a uniquely cohesive and hypnotic experience for the listener. Pi’erre is SO underrated as an artist - the melodies of his beats sound simultaneously nostalgic yet futuristic and his layered autotuned singing flows on them perfectly.

    • @sammcmeekin8897
      @sammcmeekin8897 2 роки тому

      there is a lot of great 20+ albums you only fw that?

    • @RetroEternal
      @RetroEternal 2 роки тому

      @@sammcmeekin8897 I should’ve said one of the only ones. I fw TLOP (Kanye), Donda, Dedication 2, & Da Drought 3. But other than those, I can’t think of any other 20+ song albums I fw. Which ones did you have in mind?

  • @farraribeats
    @farraribeats 2 роки тому +4

    Unrelated to Hip Hop but Pink Floyd in my opinion are the masters of knowing what makes an album a masterpiece. All their albums are short listens but really dense and diverse. Dark Side of the Moon was on the billboard top 100 for about 30 years straight and its only 40 minutes long.

    • @thrpotatoasfgfejfidieiidkr7071
      @thrpotatoasfgfejfidieiidkr7071 2 роки тому +1

      Isn't the wall long as hell

    • @farraribeats
      @farraribeats 2 роки тому

      @@thrpotatoasfgfejfidieiidkr7071 Yes that's true that is one of their longer albums but 90% of their catalog are albums that have a 40-50 minute run time. The Wall is still an excellent album nonetheless.

  • @conradcoolerfiend
    @conradcoolerfiend 2 роки тому +1

    great topic guys

  • @Javi1da
    @Javi1da 2 роки тому +5

    I feel like BabyTron has mastered the art of putting out a 20+ song album. Ive listened to Bin Reaper 3 New Testament multiple times all the way through and I love it. Although it has skips, I feel like they are dramatically out weighed by the sheer amount of quality on the record.

  • @lu_mars4768
    @lu_mars4768 2 роки тому +2

    I am 17 rn and before the forever story i never listened to a full album, since then i listen often to a full album (metro jid kendrick...) especially if i try to get into a new artist i am not listening to their best songs anymore.

    • @mablo.9938
      @mablo.9938 2 роки тому +1

      thats really good. It’s impossible to fully comprehend how great for example Kanye is if you only listen to his most streamed songs. You have to listen to his albums and see how he made these genre bending albums.

    • @lu_mars4768
      @lu_mars4768 2 роки тому

      For the last question i want a new album thats max 15 songs

    • @mablo.9938
      @mablo.9938 2 роки тому +1

      @@lu_mars4768 I don’t really know what’s your music taste so I’m going to give you a few options. If you like jid then you should like the new denzel curry album melt my eyes see your future or something more underground like cheat codes. If you prefer trap than you should listen to monster by future.

    • @lu_mars4768
      @lu_mars4768 2 роки тому

      @@mablo.9938 thanks for the recommendation i already wanted to listen to denzel(heard song and like: walkin and bruuuh) , i needed some recommendations (my fac rapper rn: pop smoke, future, the new kendrick album still need to listen to the others)

    • @mablo.9938
      @mablo.9938 2 роки тому +1

      @@lu_mars4768 Yeah the denzel album is great. I don’t really listen to drill so I cant recommend you anything similar but if you still haven’t listened to monster and ds2 by future you should immediately because they are filled with bangers. Kendricks discography is a must listen. Even tho his new album is great he has way better albums. Listen to gkmc, tpab, damn and if you like them listen to section80 and untitled unmastered. And of course kanyes discography is a must listen too. Please try to not think about his recent statements because that can make your album experience worse. Kanye is truly one of the best artists of this generation and you should just listen to his albums in order (he has the most classics out of any rapper) and separate the art from the artist

  • @johngotti333
    @johngotti333 2 роки тому +1

    I love albums, but it has to be a concept somewhere, of course the personal is also part of it, in what season does the album drop, how do you feel right now and so on. Of course. The strategy is also a big point.

  • @SweaterSwagg
    @SweaterSwagg 2 роки тому +1

    Great convo!

  • @docrussojr
    @docrussojr 2 роки тому +4

    The problem isn't the length of the album. There are double albums that are classics. The problem is the quality of music. Artists are clearly stuffing the albums with filler and junk to pad their numbers.

  • @barry4649
    @barry4649 2 роки тому +5

    Lou’s opinion on Donda is a bit harsh, the only songs that should’ve been trimmed are Remote Control, Junya, and Tell The Vision and I think Tell the Vision was there to give money to Pop Smokes family so I forgive him for that. Also, I think Pusha T’s verse from Donda shouldn’t have been cut and Never Abandon Your Family and Life of the Party should’ve been on the original release so therefore it’s not that bloated in my eyes

  • @JETLIFEMUZIK
    @JETLIFEMUZIK Рік тому +1

    Albums have become chores. Listening shouldn’t be a chore.

  • @realityhurtsrcspaced6017
    @realityhurtsrcspaced6017 Рік тому

    i agree wit red jacket right here as a local artist myself truth is aint nobdy listening to a whole album from me since im unknown therfore at any givin momment i could be come a dissapointment to the ears so i understand the logic behind shorter songs and albums like i said before attention spans arent that great anymore and the consumer is wut makes an artist famous so kinda gotta liosten and pay attention to wut they want from u

  • @brandon-ty7lh
    @brandon-ty7lh 2 роки тому +5

    respect to both of you but donda isn’t bloated it’s honestly a modern sounding classic from kanye this will be remembered and appreciated years from now but i love the album, a lot of versatility and love the theme

    • @thrpotatoasfgfejfidieiidkr7071
      @thrpotatoasfgfejfidieiidkr7071 2 роки тому +7

      There are plenty of unnecessary songs in there

    • @KP-ey2cf
      @KP-ey2cf 2 роки тому

      It's bloated for sure, if you took some songs of it , it wouldn't affect it at all

    • @enjoi9970
      @enjoi9970 2 роки тому

      @@thrpotatoasfgfejfidieiidkr7071 I can only think of 1 and it’s an interlude

  • @jorgerodrigues7635
    @jorgerodrigues7635 2 роки тому +1

    I think you could make a video comparing the albums by decades 80’s top 10 vs 90’s top10 or just a tier list with every top10/5 albums from the 80s till 20s

  • @prodbyprontotrn
    @prodbyprontotrn 2 роки тому +2

    Most people are not listening to an entire album in one sitting, so artists are likely pilling more content into albums so they can reach wider ranges of people. There's a higher chance of capturing a fan with one of twenty songs compared to having 12 cohesive tracks. I'd blame social media and the lowering of intention spans.

  • @Javi1da
    @Javi1da 2 роки тому +1

    Yachty’s newest album isn’t even close to his lowest selling album. It sold twice as much first week as Michigan Boy Boat and 5000 more first week than Lil Boat 3. Though Yachty does not do the best first week numbers, his last project showed an improvement

  • @jamesanderson6856
    @jamesanderson6856 2 роки тому +2

    My car journey to work is 35/40 minutes. There’s some albums I can’t even get through there and back😂

  • @lkds923
    @lkds923 2 роки тому +3

    Ok Ok AND Ok Ok part 2 are FIRE

    • @karanveer4901
      @karanveer4901 2 роки тому

      Nah the girls part is trash

    • @lkds923
      @lkds923 2 роки тому +2

      @@karanveer4901 better than yachty by far

  • @calebbell2848
    @calebbell2848 2 роки тому +6

    I love the analytical takes and studies that you two gentleman have on music, it’s so informative as an inspiring artist. If i had to recommend a concise album that is a great listen i’d have to say ‘decide’ by Djo it’s not rap but it’s such an entertaining and beautiful listen

  • @PlayboiCarter1916
    @PlayboiCarter1916 2 роки тому +6

    Album nowadays need to be 12-18 tracks max and under 90 minutes.

    • @KwanDon22
      @KwanDon22 2 роки тому +7

      Even right under 90 minutes is too long. It needs to be an hour or less Or it needs to be very rare if an album goes over an hour. 35-50 minutes is the sweet spot for me

    • @PlayboiCarter1916
      @PlayboiCarter1916 2 роки тому

      @@KwanDon22 agree

    • @cristobalcarrascovicente
      @cristobalcarrascovicente 2 роки тому +1

      I think near 40 minutes is the sweet spot for an album, but it depends on the tracklist

  • @d.k.borelli8267
    @d.k.borelli8267 2 роки тому +2

    I am running Donda from start to finish. I love that record

  • @corbanguiel1592
    @corbanguiel1592 2 роки тому +9

    What about life of Pablo, it’s 20 songs (with saint pablo) and I consider it a classic hands down

    • @corbanguiel1592
      @corbanguiel1592 2 роки тому +2

      Also SZAs album last year was crazy not yet a classic tho

  • @NoahIsThaGOAT
    @NoahIsThaGOAT 2 роки тому +6

    Life After Death also a classic album with over 20 songs

    • @liltree8382
      @liltree8382 2 роки тому

      That’s not fair that was during the golden era of hip hop we are trying to find some from late 2010s early 2020s

    • @NoahIsThaGOAT
      @NoahIsThaGOAT 2 роки тому

      @@liltree8382 XXX by Danny Brown has 20+ songs and it was released in like 2011 so not that long ago and it’s arguably a classic

    • @cristobalcarrascovicente
      @cristobalcarrascovicente 2 роки тому

      Bro,life after death is like 2 decades old
      Name a recent album that people actually agree is a classic despite the +20 songs

    • @NoahIsThaGOAT
      @NoahIsThaGOAT 2 роки тому

      @@cristobalcarrascovicente I mentioned Life After Death because they mentioned All Eyez On Me and I think LAD is better
      The only album I can think of with 20 or more songs in the last couple years is Take Care which has 20

    • @cristobalcarrascovicente
      @cristobalcarrascovicente 2 роки тому

      @@NoahIsThaGOAT tbh I agree with you on the lad>all eyez on me take but I was talking about how recently +20 songs tracklist aren't normally appreciated by everyone, sorry if I was rude

  • @thecollector2464
    @thecollector2464 2 роки тому +1

    I’m 15 and started listening to hip hop around October 2022, first album was Igor. Since then I think I’ve listen to around 75-100 albums.

    • @liltree8382
      @liltree8382 2 роки тому +2

      Igor isn’t hip hop

    • @thecollector2464
      @thecollector2464 2 роки тому +1

      But… it is

    • @Littlekitten_
      @Littlekitten_ Рік тому

      Igor is more experimental and i noticed the younger kids like it because it’s trendy.. when Igor was released in 2019 it didn’t get that same love. I liked that Tyler made a song about a boyfriend

  • @dysonspheretxi
    @dysonspheretxi 2 роки тому +4

    Greydon Square - Type 3: Omniverse is a 30 song masterpiece. It's niche and very underground, but well worth the listen. Not a single miss on there

  • @D4v-o8g
    @D4v-o8g Рік тому +1

    The only good album with 20+ songs that I can think of is 2001 by Dr.Dre.
    That was made 24 years ago in 1999.

  • @TheWolfAndGeneral
    @TheWolfAndGeneral 2 роки тому +1

    The labels are to blame. Corporatization of the music industry is killing it. Greed over art.

  • @Cantpickgoodhandlename
    @Cantpickgoodhandlename 2 роки тому +1

    I feel like it’s slowly becoming less and less of a problem. I personally don’t have too much of a problem with it because I have extreme patience with it. For example I got through indigo in one sitting (over two HOURS). I can’t wait for a change going back to quality though. I’m in my late teens and I’ve listened to over 570 albums. I’m probably not the best example but I still agree

  • @vicjames3256
    @vicjames3256 2 роки тому +1

    I will say with Donda, I created my own 13 track version that is all bangers. But fuck me I'll never listen to that full album as is.
    I did the same with the Carter V.

  • @Christian-tr6fx
    @Christian-tr6fx Рік тому

    With todays societal values, we want music and want it now. In mainstream, if you don’t drop consistently (if you’re not a Drake, Beyoncé, Cole, Kendrick, etc), we may need or want new music but it’s more acceptable as long as it’s quality. All other artists don’t have that luxury, and don’t know when a hit is gonna be a hit. They have to strike, we just hope it’s again, quality.

  • @onealexbond
    @onealexbond 2 роки тому +1

    When NFR finally covers my music, that’s when I know I made it 🔥

  • @KyaPataKya
    @KyaPataKya 2 роки тому +1

    I totally agree with this, I've been saying this exact thing for a long time.... It would have been MBDTF 2.0 if Kanye had cut donda down to roughly 10 or 12 songs.

  • @prodgrantgambino
    @prodgrantgambino 2 роки тому

    Yall might have came in clutch. I am doing a school project arguing that streaming is bad for music. I am 3 minutes in and this video just might be a goldmine

  • @Odel964
    @Odel964 2 роки тому +1

    yall should bring back free smoke but except this time with rappers and debate who's better and why some interesting criterias would be
    Discography
    lyricism
    Features

  • @thedyingseal3526
    @thedyingseal3526 2 роки тому +1

    The Donda deluxe is perfect tracklisting. Ends after 20 songs then has bonus ones in the back you’re not meant to listen to apart of the experience

  • @brettnelson1354
    @brettnelson1354 2 роки тому +2

    Pusha T is the perfect example of quality over quantity with Daytona

  • @xKxngzzz
    @xKxngzzz 2 роки тому +1

    18 should be the MAX anything over is overboard.

  • @JTMusicRankings
    @JTMusicRankings 2 роки тому +1

    Anybody who is reading this
    Albums are the best way to listen to music and become attached to the artist and even the genre itself. There are so many great albums short ones long ones but because of the length people’s attention span is lower than the duration of the albums. The reason some artists do it is the numbers they want to provide more songs to have a high chance for one to go viral.

  • @thenewyorkhip-hopspot5485
    @thenewyorkhip-hopspot5485 2 роки тому +1

    the way I see it is y’all can have these 20-25 songs albums and u can have ur bigger streams but don’t expect ur albums to be on any end of year lists. I think my end of year list vid only had like 1 album over 20 songs bc it was a double disk

  • @Kevin257
    @Kevin257 2 роки тому +2

    I’d prefer a 9-12 track album over 20+ with just fillers

  • @Christian-tr6fx
    @Christian-tr6fx Рік тому

    Another idea is what if it’s label contracts. Yeah as an artist you need to produce this x amount of projects under us, but also this x amount of songs.
    Quantity over creativity honestly is where we’re at right now.

  • @jarrinearthman6171
    @jarrinearthman6171 2 роки тому +1

    Yo the ghost face killah fishscale classic shout-out outta nowhere is why I fuck with this channel these kids know they shit

  • @johnohrstrom5112
    @johnohrstrom5112 2 роки тому +1

    I listen to albums I own.
    I buy a hard copy.
    If you've got an album, I'll listen but if you've got 2 good tracks, I'll stream those tracks.
    You're right, 20 song albums can work, but the quality has to be there.
    If it's a good album, I buy it.
    Period.
    The market reflects consumerism on both sides of the equation.
    Supply and demand.

  • @RKIJSITFAHCWGOR
    @RKIJSITFAHCWGOR 2 роки тому +5

    2001 by Dr. Dre is a perfect f*ckin album 😎🍁

  • @dillonrio7330
    @dillonrio7330 2 роки тому +1

    "You think we're just fucking nerds?" - Anthony 😂💯 Yes, I agree. I really can't stand how long albums have become. I'd rather listen to Daytona or Jay's 4:44 multiple times in a row over one of these recent bloated, generic albums.

  • @OldBayHat
    @OldBayHat 2 роки тому +1

    Didn’t Ant say WLR is a classic, and also WLR is 24 songs, so I’d say WLR is the closest, and how influential it is, it probably is a classic.

  • @forkrunner2208
    @forkrunner2208 2 роки тому +2

    Donda’s length is annoying but it’s still a great experience and uses its length fairly effectively. There were much worse offenders you could’ve put on the thumbnail lol

  • @MarkYeeDaMajor
    @MarkYeeDaMajor 2 роки тому +2

    Big Chris Brown fan. I no longer listen to his albums for this reason. 40/50 songs bruh!? WTF!?

  • @alfred000
    @alfred000 2 роки тому +4

    You guys are my favorite music podcast