Have you listened to a least FIFTY? If not, it might be better to withhold such a sweeping judgment. I like Elly's playing a great deal, but I find her first movement a bit LETHARGIC for "Allegro con brio." It's very good, but to me it sounds either TIRED or a bit too CAREFUL. Others have played it with far greater intensity. Have you ever heard BRUCE HUNGERFORD'S recording? Or CLAUDE FRANK'S?
@@hyramesshiramess1035 When was this recorded, if it was when she was in her 80s, it might be somewhat difficult to muster as much 'brio' as in younger years.
Half a century ago, she was estimated often as the best Beethoven player in Japanese criticizm. She equals Backhaus as the succesor of German heritage. Her piano sound itself is so beautiful. I love her accentuation,it is so"ausdrucksvoll". I love her 2nd.movement especially.
And for me she still is the unmatched, unrivalled Beethoven interpreter. Even though, I usually never like to say "that's the one", because I think we need Rubinstein, as we need Ney, as we need Sofronitsky, Gould... and so on. But with Beethoven, Ney is really something else.
@@lunchmind We don't know that she was, the word is thrown around like confetti. All we have is third hand reports (wikipediauses as sources newspaper articles 50 years later!), so on that note, please stop littering with such suggestions. Do you do the same for pianists from the USSR....no, no you don't!
'RIchtet nicht, auf daß ihr nicht gerichtet werdet. Denn wie ihr richtet, so werdet ihr gerichtet werden, und nach dem Maß, mit dem ihr meßt und zuteilt, wird euch zugeteilt werden.' [Matth. 7,1]
By far, this is my favorite interpretation. I find it well-articulated and dynamically sound -- tasteful from beginning to end.
Have you listened to a least FIFTY? If not, it might be better to withhold such a sweeping judgment. I like Elly's playing a great deal, but I find her first movement a bit LETHARGIC for "Allegro con brio." It's very good, but to me it sounds either TIRED or a bit too CAREFUL. Others have played it with far greater intensity. Have you ever heard BRUCE HUNGERFORD'S recording? Or CLAUDE FRANK'S?
@@hyramesshiramess1035 When was this recorded, if it was when she was in her 80s, it might be somewhat difficult to muster as much 'brio' as in younger years.
Half a century ago, she was estimated often as the best Beethoven player in Japanese criticizm. She equals Backhaus as the succesor of German heritage.
Her piano sound itself is so beautiful. I love her accentuation,it is so"ausdrucksvoll".
I love her 2nd.movement especially.
Yes, a true representative of the axis powers. She has no business playing the music of Beethoven.
And for me she still is the unmatched, unrivalled Beethoven interpreter. Even though, I usually never like to say "that's the one", because I think we need Rubinstein, as we need Ney, as we need Sofronitsky, Gould... and so on. But with Beethoven, Ney is really something else.
@@lunchmind Beethoven would agree with her, on music and more.
@@TB-us7el Beethoven wouldn't be that brazenly anti-Semitic
@@lunchmind We don't know that she was, the word is thrown around like confetti. All we have is third hand reports (wikipediauses as sources newspaper articles 50 years later!), so on that note, please stop littering with such suggestions. Do you do the same for pianists from the USSR....no, no you don't!
On an equal footing with Kempff.
와………..
lisez mon commentaire avec la version de Benno Moisewitsch, pour la meme oeuvre...
'Was nützt es dem Menschen, wenn er die ganze Welt gewinnt, aber Schaden leidet an seiner Seele?' [Jesus Christus]
[Mk 8,36]
'RIchtet nicht, auf daß ihr nicht gerichtet werdet. Denn wie ihr richtet, so werdet ihr gerichtet werden, und nach dem Maß, mit dem ihr meßt und zuteilt, wird euch zugeteilt werden.' [Matth. 7,1]
groß
Lo que transmite es tal cual al partido político que perteneció..... horrible
Idiotic comment.
Joe Fallisi
@@voceanima3008 más idiota me parece tu comentario y tu
Kempff, Gieseking?
do you litter in the comments sections of pianists from the USSR with this nonsense....no, thought not.