Film Study: So... What's to make of Brock Purdy for the San Francisco 49ers?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 кві 2024
- Check out my movie Channel
/ @jacksonkruegermovies
Check out JKS Clips for podcast clips and Twitch Streams
/ @jksclips5398
Follow me on twitch / jacksonkruegersports
Check out the JKS website www.jacksonkruegersports.com/
Follow me on Twitter @jacksonkrueger / jacksonkrueger
Also follow me on Instagram @jacksonkruegersports / jacksonkruegersports - Спорт
He just has a feel for the game. He understands timing, he understands spacing and leverage. He plays smooth and under control. He can scramble. He’s a flat out gamer. Would have played in the SB in his first 2 years if he didn’t get injured. Sky’s the limit
Coming from a chiefs fan he played better than almost any other QB against our defense in that Super Bowl. Josh Allen is probably the only QB who played much better. But he played light years ahead of Lamar and Tua.
I’m a chiefs fan as well but you could argue that being on the 49ers offense and being under Kyle shannahan. The chiefs have the most to deal with playing San Fran. Against Baltimore it’s pretty much all efforts against Lamar. You can live with with whatever his edwards or Justice hill is going to do.
@@KI-wz7pr I would counter by saying regardless of talent around them Lamar was awful. Purdy is in a better situation, but Allen for example played great in a less than favorable situation where I would argue Lamar made the rest of the ravens offense look worse in that game.
@@jacksonpayne3477 fair point but I’ve seen a history of shannahan being able to protect the Qb. He is able to procure game plans without putting all the weight on the Qb. I think Purdy is very good but I wonder what happens when your rb isn’t the best in the nfl. You don’t have a top scoring defense and shannahan is forced to put him into more shotgun sets and less playaction.
@@KI-wz7pr Idk about "protect the qb" when his offensive lines have always been horrendous pass blockers(28th in the league in 23-24). He was just always able to make the most out of an rb because its a run first scheme
Nobody considers Mosert a top rb but he sure as shit puts up the stats of one in Kyle's system, Elijah Mitchell is in that same boat
@@fate8718 when I say protect the Qb I mean in play style not o line. That’s why I reference play action. Playing Qb with the lead 90% of the time and a strong run game is very favorable because you rarely face defenses that are playing with the advantage. You get a lot of half field reads from bootlegs. Try being in 3rd and 5+ from shotgun when the defense knows you have to throw. Shannahn system is built in avoiding these situations and it’s been perfect because San Fran has had top 5 scoring defenses a lot recently.
At 3:10 his arm *_WAS_* hit, causing the interception. The protection broke down, which was a major problem (especially on the right side of the O-Line last season). And, of course, Kyle called a play over the middle. He usually does. Purdy didn't "can" the play. He went with what was sent in by Kyle.
All quarterbacks play within their team's system.
The critique within the NFL made by some fans and some NFL entertainers is that Brock Purdy is ONLY a byproduct of the Kyle Shanahan system. This opinion is biased and short-sighted.
Why?
Clearly, Brock Purdy is capable of playing off platform and/or outside of Kyle Shanahan's system. He often does it. As you mentioned Shanahan's system isn't perfect. Shanahan makes mistakes too. Brock Purdy is able to play free outside of Shanahan's system when his plays breakdown. Brock Purdy both creates plays and extends plays when they breakdown.
The 49ers winning the Lions playoff game is a DIRECT RESULT of Brock Purdy making something out of nothing.
There's a lot of bias within the NFL for quarterbacks that don't fit the "Superman Quarterback" mold. NFL entertainers have cemented the idea that an NFL quarterbacks job is to carry his entire team. This couldn't be further from the truth.
It isn't the quarterback's job to be a one man team. The "Superman Quarterback" narrative is hurting the NFL. Hopefully, fans will educate themselves about the quarterback position so that NFL entertainers can no longer push false narratives with success.
Brock Purdy is a good quarterback that is still learning, growing and developing his skill sets.
The future is bright for the 49ers. 49ers fans should be happy about it. I know, I am.
Nobody reading all that bullshit. Purdy is a system qb surrounded by a super team.
I agree (as if I wouldn't lol).
The Superman qb narrative exists and will continue to exist because the chiefs just proved that as long as you’ve got a strong defense and a Superman qb you can win a Super Bowl no matter how bad your receiving core is
Big Play QBs make all the highlight videos...and that is what most of the fans see.
But, Big Play QBs rarely go to the SB.
Consistently good players like Brady and Purdy don't make the highlight videos,
But, they win games, win games and win games and go to the SB.
Cam Newton said the Purdy is not a good athlete. Newton, a great athlete, only went to the SB once. While Tom Brady, who was one of the worst athlete in the entire NFL, went to the SB 10 times.
Justin Fields was a Big Play QB, but he was traded for a 6th round pick. Fields only won about 25% of the games he played in. Fields couldn't or wouldn't consistently make the easy little plays to keep his offensive team on the field and the other offensive team on the bench.
You could have posted this exact comment 2 years ago and just replaced Purdy’s name with Jimmy G. I would have thought people would have learned this lesson when he went to the Raiders and played like garbage and got benched. It turns out being surrounded by pro bowl talent can actually make a QB look better than they really are.
Purdy is legit. Frisco fans should be thankful that a 7th round pick bails the braintrust out on the Trey Lance fiasco. Whew.
No he not 😂
@@mr.lucaln7097 He's better than Lamar.
@@billquantrill4960most definitely don’t know ball. 😂 stick to ballet or something
@@mr.lucaln7097 Triggered. Lol.
@@billquantrill4960👍🏽
I'd only put Mahomes, Burrow, and Allen ahead of him.
Jackson, Herbert, Lawrence, Stafford and Stroud are decent arguments but not clearly at this juncture. Prescott, Tua and Cousins one could also argue but those are really questionable. Giving you that I'm guessing you'd argue the Niners would be better with any of those guys on the team.
I wouldn't trade Brock for anyone outside of the top 3 listed here and even then the value goes down in terms of salary cap hit. Only clearly I'd say there are 3 QBs that would be an upgrade but outside of that it's debatable and at the end of the day it really it doesn't matter.
Drew Brees is the comp. If you have a great QB like that you build around him and that's what the 49ers have. Others may be better in some ways but he's got enough to win it all. Mahomes is a problem for the whole league not just the Niners. Less than that every team has questions but at QB for my Niners, that's not a question imho. Best
Purdy over Stroud or Herbert is WILD
@@erikdayne5429 These two are clearly physically way more elite but you have to see what Harbaugh can do with Herbert and Stroud needs to show he can do it again and better but I can see your argument and I did state that. It's just not a guarantee like the other 3 at this point imho and like I've said it doesn't really matter unless a trade were to be actually enacted.
@@justinsugay1149stroud took his team to the playoffs as a rookie lol and the roster wasn’t as talented in a tough afc conference
@@enochangbongy3206 I think Stroud is amazing. He will likely be a top 5 QB and may already be but like Brock critics said they have to wait and see. He'd be a solid gamble but repeating and growing is something that has to be seen. I'm with you that he'll likely get there but it has to be shown.
@@justinsugay1149 Brock is solid but he had one good year in my eyes if the niners had the chance to take those QB You have named they would in a heart beat .
He had a great season regardless of the outcome! To go from Mr Irrelevant to Super Bowl is nothing short of miraculous! And he’s a great kid as well! Hopefully he makes a return trip and finishes the quest for 6! Great job sir!
He's solid. He's not top 5 qb to me. But he's very solid.... I can't fully fault him he's got a super team around him. Except for the O Line. This us the best team he will be once he gets paid I don't know
He not even top 12
I kinda hope the chiefs gotta go through, jets, miami and Houston this year to go to SF; I'd love to have to face off against Kyle's old coordinator, either of the 3, but def the Texans
Purdy v Stroud would be such a good matchup dude
People argue on here like "if your Corolla had a lambo engine it would be faster". Yes of course but if you value price to reliability you wouldn't want to do that. You'd void warranties etc. We'll never fn know. Brock may be a Corolla compared to the Lambos of QBs. But he's reliable and low mileage and has the ability to get better. You act like you can't get from point A to point B because you're driving a Corolla. Thing is his mental processor is elite while the physical is less than, overall it's more than enough. Everything is hypothetical.
In this reality my Niners need to focus on upgrading at CB and offensive line WAY more than they need to worry about QB. It's hard to get that right but we did for the most part (backwards wasting picks on Lance etc but that's another story) and for now it's a waste of mental energy to argue about that particular position and rather one should continue to bolster the rest of the roster for another run. My 2 cents.
People need to chill. It's a team game unless you're one of the top 3 who can elevate the team by that much. Look at Trevor Lawrence. I know he's better than the numbers show but the rest of the team is not good enough and it shows. You have to have a lot go your way to win a superbowl unless you drafted Mahomes or Brady in the last 30 years. There are no guarantees only probabilities and I like my odds with this team as is and would focus on what one can control but that's just me.
Also, just get the Lambo if you can. In the meantime get the right tires, align the suspension properly change your oil etc. That's my analogy. Yes of course I'd rather have a Lambo but we didn't get one yet. So in the meantime let's make what we have run the best it can and look at how that's true. I don't get the intensity of why people are so ready to hate on this kid.
Anyone who ignores (the as important, some argue more important as the skill players) the lack of offensive talent with his bad pass blocking O-line, just sounds like an ignorant passive aggressive Purdy hater.
Can you do a video comparing Tua & Purdy?
They’re pretty similar QBs actually in terms of how they operate. Both have elite anticipation and are very accurate which leads to their success, both also have underrated playmaking abilities as well
Game Manager
Every time someone puts this stupid narrative out I imagine them saying "game manager" in the duh duffus voice.
@@ericred8124a clone of jimmy g
I’m pretty impressed a first year starter can “manage” an offense to a Super Bowl appearance😂
To me, there is Patrick Mahomes, then a sizeable gap downwards, at Demi-God I would put Josh Allen, with Burrow a hair behind him. Then, a really large gap, and clump the rest of the QBs to Good/System/whatever...and you can put your favorite QB here if they are half way decent: Dak, Love, Herbert, Purdy, Lamar Jackson, Hurts, and I am sure I missed someone. Some might say disrespect for Lamar, but I think he fits in their in that system group. I don't think you can plug and play him in Buffalo, KC, etc. No disrespect on any of these dudes, they could all win a super bowl. Then, there is "middling" Cousins, Carr, Lawrence, Mayfield, etc..Lastly, there is hot garbage, you know who they are, whomever can't fit in above. That's just a long winded way of saying the QB world is Mahomes, by a mile, then Allen and Burrow. Then, everybody else in one tier or another. So, Purdy is good =P
Nobody reading all that. But you put Purdy and Lamar in the same category so your automatically wrong
@@mr.lucaln7097 Lamar 2-4 in the playoffs, with normally pretty good teams. Purdy in two years is 4-2, and one of those losses he couldn't throw after he got injured in the beginning of the game. All things being equal, I will take Purdy. Before you come at me with "two mvps" for comparison, Mahomes is 15-3 in the playoffs. Lamar is a good, solid QB. Not hating. But, let's not induct him into the hall of fame just yet.
@@mr.lucaln7097I read all of it. Don't be lazy. Memes aren't everything.
@@BeingButterfly bro wrote an essay about how Purdy is better then Lamar. It was bound to be stupid regardless if I read or not. So shut tf up
I think that it comes down to a long-term strategy with these quarterback assessments. Most quarterbacks are not Patrick Mahomes or Tom Brady. How do you want go win a Super Bowl? Youdo what the Rams did and go all in and winSuper Bowl and then struggle for years. The Eagles Did that and just fell short. Houston Texans have gone all in and will probably win the Super Bowl next year. Problem with Purdy is he’s not as good as CJ Stroud so when they have to pay Stroud it’s not gonna be such a problem. When you have to pay Purdy Kyles strategy will fall apart.
He’s the next Kirk cousins. But with a good coach
And legs
And 9ers still won’t get a right side OL
Brock will only get better. They will win the superbowl this year if they stay healthy
they need a qb..badly
Idk … he looks like newer flashier Jimmy G …. Only time will tell … if you tell me he’s elite … I’d say .. idk 🤷🏿
He’s not and it’s ok to say that. If people don’t want to account for the talent around the QB that’s fine, let them be smooth brains.
Purdy can be effective if he has a lot of talent around him. He’s not good enough to lift up a bad team on his own. He’s probably somewhere around 10-15, slightly above average but not elite.
Purdy is Jimmy G. 2.0
No, he isn't. Not even close. Brock Purdy is legit.
@@BeingButterflyno he not. Both qbs got/get carried by the super team around them. When you screw up the system the. The qb panics and sucks. See the ravens game
Purdy is not Jimmy G. 2.0 he is {Jim G}^2^2^2^2 power. or Jim G X 2 X2 X 2 X2 X2 X2
Exactly my thoughts
@@mr.lucaln7097Then you don't know football. Brock Purdy plays off platform outside of the system a lot. He's the biggest reason the 49ers won the playoff game against the Lions.
The guy only played 25 games
He’s played 6 playoff games and thrown more than 1 TD once
@@erikdayne5429 because they run the ball inside the 5 they don’t play around
@@erikdayne5429very impressive behind a horrible pass blocking O-line huh
🧚♀️
Purdy is staring down his first read every play. He not giving the defense “looks”. When the first read isn’t open he just throws up whoever is closest. Luck is what’s building his success
You never played qb did you? You’re taught to look at your first read then go to your other reads. Ignorant take. Also he doesn’t just stare down his number one. He moves on to the next guy pretty quickly.
@@MrEKOPriest clearly you cannot see. He is staring down Aiyuk his whole route. Notice he also throws a pic to Jack Campbell when his first read is gone. Ignorant take
So, he is lucky enough to get the Superbowl in his 2nd year, and championship games every year, how many QBs has done that?
@@liuboy2077 lucky he’s on a super team right?
@@mr.lucaln7097if luck in a super team is the only factors that are taking teams to a Super Bowl, then doesn’t that say a lot about the NFL according to your logic? This sounds like extreme copium when you factor in that if we follow this logic, QB’s like Allen and Jackson haven’t made a Super Bowl because they are strictly unlucky, which just sounds really silly.