Valshe adds so much emotion to this song and with wotamin their voice just melt together so perfectly it make me cry every time i listen to this version....very heartfelt but painful
this is such a sad song, rin leaving a kind song as a proof of her life...but rin-san u dont have to leave one everyone will always remember u, u already made a difference to the world
Just remembering: this is the second song of 3. The last song of the serie is Endless Wedge by Len. He sings about how he will miss her now that she died, but that he'll still move on. It's really beautiful...
i love how the twins are able to show what "loving" and truly caring for someone is like. I love how they keep wishing and praying to be together with the other twin again if given another chance when they die.... I HATE how either one of them or BOTH actually has to die in most of their videos. T_T I HATE how they NEVER fail to choke me up with tears each time I watch/listen to their songs (TAT)
Found this song through Valshe's Soundless Voice. I didn't think this one would be as good, so didn't bother with it for a few weeks. Huge mistake! This one has just as many feels if not more than Soundless Voice. More of a positive message as well :)
@AnimeCutie9898 Rin is sick and Len was taking care of her from a long time, then they go out to get a fresh air, and then Rin died. She didn't die from the cold. Poor Len... I aways cry when Valshe starts to sing Soundless Voice here...
While i don't usually enjoy other people doing the vocaloids songs, this is just so beautiful! I luv the actual rin version just as much and living up to rin is quite a feat in my eyes. This is amazing! thx for the pv
DAMMIT KAGAMINE TWINS, WHY ARE YOUR SONGS SO DAMN SAD? every time i hear this i cry! it doesn't help that valshe and wotamin have amazing voices and it makes more tears flow than normal. :'I
No matter how many times I watch this video, I cry. Over and over again. Because I know my life is ending, and I don't know how to face it. Everyday I'd have a panic attack before sleeping, worrying that I won't wake up the next day. The upcoming day, I'd worry about the same thing. I understand how Rin wants to leave some proof to she lived, how she was alive. This is too sad for words. Just, pure pure sadness.
If you watched Soundless voice you would know tht Rin was the one who died, here it kind of explains how she died from rusting (since shes a vocaloid lol) and this song is her reflection and how she doesnt want to be forgotten, she wants to be remembered. she wanted to make a differance to the world.
I thought Len's version was sad, being very lonely when she dies. But this was just as sad, not being afraid of your own death, but that you won't be able to see your loved one anymore. In the end, I thought she'd say I love you, but then I heard thank you which made me unable to compress my tears no longer.
Every time I hear this song, I feel like crying. One of the girls in my class died in horrific car crash in Feburary, she was only turning 13 this year. I wasn't her friend, in fact, I thought I hated her. But now that she's gone, I regret all the things I said and thought about her. This song reminds me of her, because she was way too young to die. I know only the good die young, but it still sucks. I see her as Rin in this aspect, Rin dies way more than Len. Life is too short.
@SinoviVaatell Valshe more often sings as Len, the male Kagamine... however, she can sing as Rin as well, and has done it. Her range is amazing. In this song, Valshe is singing the backing vocals that are kind of hard to hear. I'm pretty sure they are lines from Soundless Voice, which Valshe does a wonderful, tear jerking cover of.. Watamin is singing the main song here, which is Rin's side.
Ahhhhh It is Linked to the Soundless voice...SO HEART BREAKING AHHHH, I learned piano for soundless voice, I have to learn the violin to this...yet I cant play the violin...So more Piano?
at 2:10, she falls and cracks her head on the ice. =) but she doesn't die, she just becomes deaf, blind, and mute [which is pretty close ^^;;]. at least, that's what I heard. I thought she died when i listened to Soundless Voice, Len's point of view song. XD
This was one of my first Vocaloid songs, so it's very special to me. Also that the lyrics are happy, but make you cry. >.< Valshe and Wotamin FOREVER!!!!
@yuiphantomhive1 Actually, it's quite different. Romeo and Juliet were two star-crossed lovers that ended up committing suicide together. This set of songs, consisting of Proof of Life and Soundless Voice, tells the story of a girl who is sick (Rin), who ends up dying from this sickness. She wants to sing a happy song with Len one last time, not a sad song. Len wants to hear Rin's voice one last time, and wishes he could give his voice to her. He dies to be with her. :)
@kankuro876 No many Nico dubbers such as Valshe dub Various Vocaloids not just 1 Vocaloid ^-^ Since Valshe dubbed "Just be Friends" which was originally sang by Megurine Luka :D
Here's my understanding of this song and Soundless Voice: Rin got some kind of illness and began losing her hearing and vision. Len wanted to help but he couldn't do anything but watch her wither. Rin wanted to leave proof that she had lived and did not want Len to be sad when she died. Finally the illness killed her and Len wanted to die with her and lost the will to live. He asked the snow to keep falling so he would die from the cold. Again, that's my understanding, if you have a different i
![~Soundless Voice & Proof of Life~ [Valshe & Wotamin - TH sub]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/O_uKZyNIyi8/mqdefault.jpg)
![~Soundless Voice & Proof of Life~ [Valshe & Wotamin - TH sub]](/img/tr.png)
"I don't want to sing a sad song" Well you sure are singing one right now and it's a hella good one, it's already making me sob like a little sissy.
*Says she doesn't want to sing a sad song. Sings a song that gets sadder and sadder.*
You lied to me!
Valshe adds so much emotion to this song and with wotamin their voice just melt together so perfectly it make me cry every time i listen to this version....very heartfelt but painful
i could hear soundless voice playing in parts of the song and i started singing it. adds so much more sadness to this song
this is such a sad song, rin leaving a kind song as a proof of her life...but rin-san u dont have to leave one everyone will always remember u, u already made a difference to the world
I can't believe this song has 10 years. I remember I used to listen it when I was at middle school.
Just remembering: this is the second song of 3. The last song of the serie is Endless Wedge by Len. He sings about how he will miss her now that she died, but that he'll still move on. It's really beautiful...
never mind me I'm just crying my eyes out right here omg
i love how the twins are able to show what "loving" and truly caring for someone is like. I love how they keep wishing and praying to be together with the other twin again if given another chance when they die.... I HATE how either one of them or BOTH actually has to die in most of their videos. T_T I HATE how they NEVER fail to choke me up with tears each time I watch/listen to their songs (TAT)
No words can explain how beautiful this is!
Found this song through Valshe's Soundless Voice. I didn't think this one would be as good, so didn't bother with it for a few weeks. Huge mistake! This one has just as many feels if not more than Soundless Voice. More of a positive message as well :)
Omgg i found it the same way xD
+Bailey Johnson try listening to endless wedge, (the third song after soundless voice) it hit me so hard in the kokoro
Julianne Esquela I had no idea there was a third song!! Thank you so much for letting me know :D
Oh yay, after watching Kokoro, I made a wonderful choice to click this one next so my soul can shatter more *kills myself*
KuroiAiren5 What song is this Kokoro? I need to know for... Feels reasons
This is exactly what I wanted their voices to sound like. Beautiful!
im already crying listening to this for who know how many times over the years TT^TT endless wedge is about to make it worse omfg
i know that feels dude TT^TT)/
I always get chills whenever I listen to this. It's so emotional and beautiful!😭
She didn't die of rusting...in here, she had a terminal illness, incurable...
._.
I like Wotamin's voice.And Valshe's voice,too.
This song reminds me of an anime called "Your Lie in April" way too much and I just can't. ;-;
+Cora Kirihanassa i love that anime so much ^^
;-;
Aaaaah you're right ç_ç From now on I'll cry even mooore-
Yes!!!! and reminds me of Ban And Elaine From The seven deadly sins..and my Ciel
godammit
I am literally in tears right now...jeez i feel silly for crying at a song, but it's just so sad!! Beautiful!
This is one of my favorite japanese songs featuring vocaloid as well as my idols Valshe and Wotamin
Always makes me cry like a baby hard to see the letters trying to see through the tears TT.TT
This song brings UNEXPECTED EMOTIONZ TO MY HEART :O
@AnimeCutie9898
Rin is sick and Len was taking care of her from a long time, then they go out to get a fresh air, and then Rin died. She didn't die from the cold.
Poor Len... I aways cry when Valshe starts to sing Soundless Voice here...
i love this song..
it makes me cry everytime I listen to it..
it reminds me of someone.
私はいつも無条件にあなたを愛して
Such a beautiful song...how didn't I find this until now...
I love vocaloid songs, they always have a story to tell you in their songs.
This is so pretty! I love your voice and the emotion I heard inside of it! It's really great.
매년 겨울마다 들어줘야된다 ㅜ 이 갬성 너무 좋음
While i don't usually enjoy other people doing the vocaloids songs, this is just so beautiful! I luv the actual rin version just as much and living up to rin is quite a feat in my eyes. This is amazing! thx for the pv
omg Wotamin's voice gave me goosebumps from the soft and tenderness. OMG!!
My heart always starts pounding when I hear this song.
DAMMIT KAGAMINE TWINS, WHY ARE YOUR SONGS SO DAMN SAD? every time i hear this i cry! it doesn't help that valshe and wotamin have amazing voices and it makes more tears flow than normal. :'I
No matter how many times I watch this video, I cry. Over and over again. Because I know my life is ending, and I don't know how to face it. Everyday I'd have a panic attack before sleeping, worrying that I won't wake up the next day. The upcoming day, I'd worry about the same thing. I understand how Rin wants to leave some proof to she lived, how she was alive. This is too sad for words. Just, pure pure sadness.
Damn, it's been a while since I cried at a Vocaloid song. The last one was Message Of Regret, but this one...;-; The tears won't stop.
oh god every time I listen to these two songs I just HAVE to cry T.T
This song is soo sad and happy at the same time
hahahahAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I JUST LOVE TO SUFFER :) :):):):):)
hahahahahaha I just love making my favorite characters suffer.
my no 1song from Valshe....still make me cry each time playing on my computer..T^T...
I could hug-attack you right now.
I adore this song and am in your debt for translating it for us.
Wow... that's all I have to say, it's too beautiful for words.
This song made me cry....
T_T Such a sad song... It made me cry a lot...
Muy bella versión,es de las pocas de ese tiempo que realmente valían la pena escuchar
Tis is sooo touching... :'(
both if their voice sound gd together!
I cried for real. I mean it. I practically started sobbing!
Vocaloid unites good composers with good singers. This song is one perfect example.
4:46, wow, that duet part is out of this world
Great, you just made me cry.
My condolences, youtuber.
goosebumps all over to the end of the video TT TT
If you watched Soundless voice you would know tht Rin was the one who died, here it kind of explains how she died from rusting (since shes a vocaloid lol) and this song is her reflection and how she doesnt want to be forgotten, she wants to be remembered. she wanted to make a differance to the world.
I thought Len's version was sad, being very lonely when she dies. But this was just as sad, not being afraid of your own death, but that you won't be able to see your loved one anymore. In the end, I thought she'd say I love you, but then I heard thank you which made me unable to compress my tears no longer.
@KazehanaAyame Yeah! I love her version of soundless voice!!!!!!
thanks, i was doubting if it was wotamin who sings this version
@Midnight08 glad 2 help *still wiping away tears*
I would love to hear Clear and Nero sing this... ;A; So beautiful
tsss... what a nice song made me drop my manly tears ...
I love the humming part 2:11-2:23 XD great work! XD I think you and valshe are both famous in the internet! XD :P
This hurts my heart.
when you said that i just got teary eyes
This is making me bawl my eyes out.
Oh god, when I heard the chorus of Soundless Voice in there I nearly cried ;A;
Speaks to the heart
whaaaa stop making me cry vocaloid songs and human voices D':
simply beautiful.....
@SinoviVaatell I have both this, and Valshe's Soundless Voice right in a row on my MP3 player. They never fail to make me cry. ;A;
whoa, the plant at the end, that reminded me of hello planet!
Every time I hear this song, I feel like crying. One of the girls in my class died in horrific car crash in Feburary, she was only turning 13 this year. I wasn't her friend, in fact, I thought I hated her. But now that she's gone, I regret all the things I said and thought about her. This song reminds me of her, because she was way too young to die. I know only the good die young, but it still sucks. I see her as Rin in this aspect, Rin dies way more than Len. Life is too short.
I cried. Again.
@SinoviVaatell Valshe more often sings as Len, the male Kagamine... however, she can sing as Rin as well, and has done it. Her range is amazing. In this song, Valshe is singing the backing vocals that are kind of hard to hear. I'm pretty sure they are lines from Soundless Voice, which Valshe does a wonderful, tear jerking cover of.. Watamin is singing the main song here, which is Rin's side.
oh god listening to this then to soundless voice is so asdhflakjsfh im literally sitting here trying to refrain from making the tissues die.
Fuck I'm crying again!Valshe,why do you have to be THAT good!!!???Wotamin is really good,too.Love that pairing!
This song is so AWESOME that no one ever thought of pressing the dislike button XD
I returned to listen to a sad song
I believe I just found what the Kagamine's would sound like if they were human. ~
I cried a lot.
arggh!!! when my tears were about to fall, it paused for the buffer!! -__-
Ahhhhh It is Linked to the Soundless voice...SO HEART BREAKING AHHHH, I learned piano for soundless voice, I have to learn the violin to this...yet I cant play the violin...So more Piano?
at 2:10, she falls and cracks her head on the ice. =) but she doesn't die, she just becomes deaf, blind, and mute [which is pretty close ^^;;]. at least, that's what I heard. I thought she died when i listened to Soundless Voice, Len's point of view song. XD
No kidding? My first vocaloid song was also Love is War XD Do NOT regret finding that song and all the others that I started listening to after :D
Oh my gosh you too?! TT3TT The first time I saw this I was bawling.
This was one of my first Vocaloid songs, so it's very special to me. Also that the lyrics are happy, but make you cry. >.< Valshe and Wotamin FOREVER!!!!
The sadness rose when rin asks if len is singing a kind song and you hear soundless voice while she is singing.
Jordan Taylor that's exactly what I love about hitoshizuku song, the overlapping lyric was so beautifully arranged.
I want this played at my funeral.
I thought I was the only one who cried listening
This is what I expect the angels to sound like..
Love this! It's so cute!
Awwww - so amazing!
I'm cry in 3:03 :'( Thank you!!
GOD... i wanna cry!
So.... So sad. I'm crying right now. ;-;
I tried not to cry there.
And its soo sad she's saying to be happy and not to be sad she died :'(
Aaa 14 years!!
This is beautiful. I cried. ;_;
:') what a beautiful song.
@yuiphantomhive1 Actually, it's quite different. Romeo and Juliet were two star-crossed lovers that ended up committing suicide together. This set of songs, consisting of Proof of Life and Soundless Voice, tells the story of a girl who is sick (Rin), who ends up dying from this sickness. She wants to sing a happy song with Len one last time, not a sad song. Len wants to hear Rin's voice one last time, and wishes he could give his voice to her. He dies to be with her. :)
@kankuro876 No many Nico dubbers such as Valshe dub Various Vocaloids not just 1 Vocaloid ^-^ Since Valshe dubbed "Just be Friends" which was originally sang by Megurine Luka :D
Here's my understanding of this song and Soundless Voice: Rin got some kind of illness and began losing her hearing and vision. Len wanted to help but he couldn't do anything but watch her wither. Rin wanted to leave proof that she had lived and did not want Len to be sad when she died. Finally the illness killed her and Len wanted to die with her and lost the will to live. He asked the snow to keep falling so he would die from the cold. Again, that's my understanding, if you have a different i
Still love it :) (from 2011)
Listened to Soundless Voice with subs just before this. >_> Sooooo sad......
@IcyMysticWarrior No, this is by a different producer. It's just that's a common cord progression in Japanese music. :)