This was my first introduction to Vocaloid and still makes me want to cry when I hear it. But this is my favorite version. However much I love Vocaloid, especially the Kagamine twins a human portrays the emotion of this song so much better.
To anyone wondering if this is Ciel's character song from Black Butler (I've seen a couple of comments with replies disabled) it's not. Someone made this his character song and the original was sung by Kagamine Len.
Soundless Voice (about Len's View and his feeling after Rin's death) was Originally sung by Kagamine Len and Proof Of Life (about Rin's Feeling) By Kagamine Rin Correct me If i am wrong or made mistakes, Thanks
It's been 8 years, I hope you're doing better now. Especially in this pandemic. For me, the lyrics of Perfectionist Complex and Daughter of White resonated and in my loneliest days that's where I visit to comfort myself. Music is really amazing. Nice to know it wasn't just me finding solace here.
Every freaking soundless voice video I go on, there has to be a comment that involves Valshe being Ciel Phantomhive's voice actor. Hey guess what? Maaya Sakamoto voiced Ciel and she can sing in both English and Japanese. Plus, look up Cloud 9 by Maaya Sakamoto and that's her singing. So just stop with all the voice acting comments!
People this is clearly dang by Valshe, not Ciel's voice actor! Yes their voice may sound similar, but different singers! Guys, this is a fact. Not because I'm a fan of valshe, nor ciel. Ciel does not have a character song. People think it's his character song cause it suits him perfectly. Guys just don't -.-
if Soundless Voice is playing in the background while I'm doing something else, I don't cry. if it is playing and I'm just listening, 30% chance of tears. if I'm watching the video as well, 75% chance. if I'm singing along, 110% chance of tears T.T
I have to admit, I'm cautious about dubs. But the combination or just covers by Valshe and Wotamin are just beautiful to say the least. I was very surprised and happy I watched this. Thanks for posting.
Actually, Valshe is a female trap singer, so she has a very wide range of pitches she can reach. She often does covers for Len, but also many other male and female vocaloids. She's not a vocaloid herself, she just sings for various vocaloids.
I'm tired of one of the twins dying, like everyday I come home from work in the best possible mood, turn on Kagamine Rin and Len.. Within 10 minutes I'm in the corner bawling like an infant. ;-; Why?!
Oh, ok. The world makes sense again. I don't quite understand the story of these songs, and I don't speak Japanese, so i was confused. Thank you for clearing it up for me.
I know what you're talking about. This song is just so....oh how should I put this.....it's heart wrenching, but beautiful at the same time. I too have a twin sister, and I hope that this will never happen, because I would probably do the same thing as Len. So, you are not wierd. It happens to the best of us.
it's the same story, just told in different perspectives. the first one, soundless voice, is Len telling about how he's taking care or Rin, who is ill. proof of life is Rin's side, of how she wants to convey the feelings she cannot say to Len due to her illness. in the end, Rin supposedly dies. I'm not that good at explaining, but that's the main plot. if you find an english sub, the lyrics itself expresses their emotions through this song very beautifully and better than i can
me:laugh away the pain, just laugh away the pain twin brother:hey sis what up? me:*lumps up and hugs brother sobbing*don't let me die in the snow D: bro: O-O ok what the hell happened? me:the kagamines happened bro: oh *both sobbing*
I am adamant. I will not cry. I have stopped crying over Servant of Evil and regret Message, I will- *hears Valshe* waah Len~~ LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNN!!!!! *cries*
![Proof of Life Valshe & Wotamin Ver. [Sub: English] + MP3](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZvIVJ4GnEkk/mqdefault.jpg)
This was my first introduction to Vocaloid and still makes me want to cry when I hear it. But this is my favorite version. However much I love Vocaloid, especially the Kagamine twins a human portrays the emotion of this song so much better.
Me too, I love kagamine twin in vocaloid
To anyone wondering if this is Ciel's character song from Black Butler (I've seen a couple of comments with replies disabled) it's not. Someone made this his character song and the original was sung by Kagamine Len.
yes! that's true.. but Valshe voice nearly same like ciel voice and I love it! sorry for my bad english
Soundless Voice (about Len's View and his feeling after Rin's death) was Originally sung by Kagamine Len and
Proof Of Life (about Rin's Feeling) By Kagamine Rin
Correct me If i am wrong or made mistakes, Thanks
中学生の頃めちゃ聞いてた....今でも大好き
Oh my goodness, I found this song years ago and was searching for it again for the longest time and now how found it. My hear ;;
久しぶりに聞きに来た
この2人ほんとに声がよすぎる
【自分用】
soundless voice
作詞：ひとしずくP 作曲：ひとしずくP 編曲：ひとしずくP・やま△（リメイクver.） 唄：鏡音レン 静寂が 街を包む夜に 降り注ぐ白 かざした手のひらに 触れた瞬間に解けてく 儚いヒトカケラ オトもなく積もる ヒカリを集めて君は笑う 今 どんな オト？ 答えたって君は もう何もキコエナイ 苦シイって言ってくれよ 寂シイって言ってくれよ 迎えに行く どんな処へも･･･ 逝かないでよ 何所へも 置いてかないで･･･ 僕らずっと 二人で一つだろう･･･？ 降り積もる雪とともに 消えてゆく 君を 抱きしめることしかできないよ 叶うなら もう一度だけ 君の声が 聴きたい モウイチド タダイチドダケ･･･ ヨンデヨ･･･ 虚ろって 彷徨う瞳に 映った ヒトシズク 灰色のセカイ 止まったまま雪だけがそっと 降り注ぐ 冷たくなっていくよ 戻らない そのコエ 解け合う事も 許されない 俺のコエを聴いてよ また笑ってよ･･･ 涙さえ 枯れ果て 君のこと トカセナイ･･･ 叶うなら この声 全て奪い去って 愛しい人へと与えてください 君ガイナイセカイに ただ独り 残されるのなら このまま･･･ 一緒に･･･ 朽チテイクヨ アイシテイル ただそれさえ 言えないまま永久に 閉ざされてゆく 君とのセカイ 叫んでも 届かないよ 君のコエはもう･･･ イナイ あああああああああああああああああ 降り積もる雪よ どうか 降り続けてずっと このまま 全て奪い去ってよ 儚い コエのイノチごと 掻き消して スベテ 白く･･･
proof of life
作詞：ひとしずくP 作曲：ひとしずくP
冬を告げる 風の声に 耳を傾け 震える体 隣にいる あなたの息 白くなって寒そう 今年もまた 命は枯れ果て やがて来る春を待ち詫びる 命の連鎖を 聴きながら 芽吹いて往く 光の中で 朽ちて逝く 運命（さだめ）と 分かってなお 強く 息していたいよ 歌っていたい わたしにも 何か残せるといいな わたしが生きた 命の証を… 悲しい歌にはしたくないよ ねえ お願い 今この時だけは 笑っていたいよ… あなたの横で 優しい歌を歌っていたい 幾度目かの冬を越えて やっと気付いた この気持ちは 告げる事はできなかったけど ココロはいつも 繋がっていたよね… 暗くてミエナイヨ… 何もキコエナイヨ… コワイヨ… 苦シイヨ… 寂シイヨ… ナニモカモスベテガ キエテイク中で あなたの笑顔だけが今 消えない… 優しい歌を歌っていてね 孤独なセカイに包まれても ずっと側に居るよ 忘れないでね あなたはいつも 独りじゃないよ 寂しくないよ あなたがいる 抱きしめてくれる 暖かい手で キコエナイけれど 伝わっているよ 触れた指先から 愛シテル…って 悲しい歌にはしたくないよ ねえ お願い 今この時だけは 笑っていたいよ あなたと共に 優しい歌を歌っていたい あなたに捧げたい 惜別の歌 最期に 伝えたいよ ありがとう…
The picture of Len at 4:29 completely broke my heart. I was strong until then, but that was my breaking point.
ฟังแล้วแทบร้องไห้....ไอ้ที่บอกว่า "ฉันอยากจะหัวเราะ" น่ะมันเจ็บปวดเกินไปแล้ว!!!
ธัช จงหมายลักษณ์ ใช่ค่ะน้ำตาคลอเลย มันทำให้เรารู้สึกนึกถึงสิ่งที่เรารักมากแต่กลับมาไม่ได้อีกแล้ว
when i was going through hard times these two songs were like prayers for me.
It's been 8 years, I hope you're doing better now. Especially in this pandemic.
For me, the lyrics of Perfectionist Complex and Daughter of White resonated and in my loneliest days that's where I visit to comfort myself. Music is really amazing. Nice to know it wasn't just me finding solace here.
@@weneedmoreconsideratepeopl4006 I still have struggles but I'm definitely in a better place.
Same here, if it wasn't for vocaloid I might not be here right now writing this...
The strength that these songs gave me keep me on going even today
STOOOOOOOOOOPPPPP NO STOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPP I REFUSE TO CRY THIS IS JUST A DAMN SONG I WILL NOOT CRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i like to listen to this materpiece of a song in rainy days when i feel down.... it cheers me up somehow :)
i love this song so much
I love it too, but... It cheers you up? That strikes me as so weird since it makes me cry
well..it kinda cheers me up xD (i know, it,s weird) i just feel like i have company and support and i,m not alone when i listen to beautiful music :)
I suppose that makes sense
バルシェさんほんま好き
Every freaking soundless voice video I go on, there has to be a comment that involves Valshe being Ciel Phantomhive's voice actor. Hey guess what? Maaya Sakamoto voiced Ciel and she can sing in both English and Japanese. Plus, look up Cloud 9 by Maaya Sakamoto and that's her singing. So just stop with all the voice acting comments!
Even the ones NOT sung by Valshe?! That's just sad -___-
People this is clearly dang by Valshe, not Ciel's voice actor! Yes their voice may sound similar, but different singers! Guys, this is a fact. Not because I'm a fan of valshe, nor ciel. Ciel does not have a character song. People think it's his character song cause it suits him perfectly. Guys just don't -.-
reminds me of my cousin who died just last november from heart cancer. q-q she wanted to make sure she wasnt forgotten before she died...
this version literally breaks my heart whenever is listen to it
神!!!!!////
声が綺麗過ぎる/////
ดูไปร้องไปเลยค่ะT^T ขอบคุณสำหรับซับมากค่ะ//โค้ง
すごくいい声!!ヲタみんとバルシェさん最高ですbb
Valshe!! She's so good. I love her voice
man the lycris dug deep into my heart and i was just about to cry but i held it all in this song is exreamly deep
泣いたわ・・・ｗサイコー！バルシェさん！！
an already heartbreaking pair of songs gets a heartbreaking pair of dubs. just beautiful.
La cantan con tanto sentimiento que me llega justo en el kokoro
que?
2019 and im still here ;w ;
if Soundless Voice is playing in the background while I'm doing something else, I don't cry.
if it is playing and I'm just listening, 30% chance of tears.
if I'm watching the video as well, 75% chance.
if I'm singing along, 110% chance of tears T.T
For ever the best version of Soundless Voice...
I dun wanna cry, i dun wanna cry... AND I CRY 😭😭
Both of their voices are so beautiful ;.;
Never fails to make me cry, no matter how many times I've heard it... T^T
no no thank you i did not need these feels no valshe wotamin why did you break my heart again ;^;
I slept when i heard these It's just so wonderful I want this as my new lullaby xD It makes me cry too :'(
เนื้อหาเพลงซึ้งๆๆฟังแล้วอยากจะร้องไห้ตาม สื่อถึงความรู้สึกเดียวดายมากๆๆTT^TT
This is so beautiful! It brings tears to my eyes!
I love both of their voices!!!! As pairing
goodness gracious!!! I'm actually crying !!!
The voice damn gives me so much peace 💖
I have to admit, I'm cautious about dubs. But the combination or just covers by Valshe and Wotamin are just beautiful to say the least. I was very surprised and happy I watched this. Thanks for posting.
Actually, Valshe is a female trap singer, so she has a very wide range of pitches she can reach. She often does covers for Len, but also many other male and female vocaloids. She's not a vocaloid herself, she just sings for various vocaloids.
Is wotamin is female version of valshe?
@@ulvavictoriaisleanilltyd6270wotamin is a female utaite. She isn’t the same person as Valshe.
หาตั้งนานกว่าจะหาเจอจนได้ ขอบคุณมากเน๊อ !
OMG! I cried watching this video! Its so touching !!!! I LOVE IT!! this is my altime favorite song!
oh by the angel! ;O; my tears wont stop! this song reminds me of Romeo & Cinderella by rin & len!! its both so... *sobs*
its sooo hurt ...oh my god !
and the voices so adorable.....TT_TT
ทั้งเจ็บทั้งเศร้าคะ T[]T
These two are like the mature voices of Len and Rin
แงๆร้องไหเลยอ่ะ
beautiful song... this is so beautiful...
i love Valshe's cover
this reminds me of a friend i had...........he comitted suicide
no. I shall help you rephrase..... I love the scream that Vashle makes!
this is song is the first to make me cry... and sometimes my tear won't stop.
T^T.. *sob*
ไม่ร้อง....เราจะ...ไม่ร้อง จะไม่...
ไม่ไหวแร้ว!!! ทิชชู่อยู่หนายยยย
แง้!!! แค่เพลงแรกก็ปริ่มแล้ว (เสียงท่านวอลสุดอะ T_T)
เพลงต่อมาปุ้บ มันมาเป็นทางรุย ฮือ.......
thanks = ] they blend really well
"ตายด้วยกันเถอะ" นี่เล่นกันแบบนี้เลยเรอะ!!!?=[]=
wow..... your words made tear cover my eyes, so beatifull.... nice poem XD
Miss them :-)
Thanks :) I also meant Valshe ^^
(But I didn't know that before 2 weeks ago)
I'm tired of one of the twins dying, like everyday I come home from work in the best possible mood, turn on Kagamine Rin and Len.. Within 10 minutes I'm in the corner bawling like an infant. ;-;
Why?!
Makes me feel so sad and warm and compassionate inside...and glad that my birthday is September 15. ^^
น้ำตาไหลพราก T^T
(อยากลองฟังแบบต้นฉบับดูจัง)
Beautiful song!
ดราม่าสุดยอดฟังแล้วอินไปกับ MV ซึ้งๆ
QUE NOSTALGIA
AI
EU AMO ESSA MÚSICA
SCRR
I love this song so much I downloaded it n listened to it alot n cried
So sad but also beautiful
น้ำตาไหลเลย
กลั้นน้ำตาสุด ๆ แล้วนะ
พอร้องว่า ตายด้วยกันเถอะ เท่านั้นล่ะ
ไหลพราก เลย T0T+
these both are awesomely great for my manga
I saw your avatar, and then I read your comment.
Poland... Don't cry ToT
D; impossible de ne pas pleurer en l'écoutant.....sa me rappel tant de choses..
นี่มันซับไทยนะเฟ้ยยยย!!!!!
เอาล่ะ!!คนไทยเอ๋ยได้เวลาลุกขึ้นสู้แล้ว เดี๋ยวต่างชาติมันจะเอาพื้นที่เราไปโหมดดด
ถ้าเข้ามาจะชอบไม่ชอบก็ช่วยเขียนหน่อยยย ซักตัวก็ยังดี แค่กอไก่ก็ยังดีเราต้องทวงซับของเราคืนมา
ช่วยหน่อยน้าาา ได้โปรดดดดดดดดดดดด ขอร้องล่ะ>O<
Playing in snow in this outfit is for sure a deathwish...
When I listen those songs and read translates, I cried!! T____T
So their sound are really beautiful
so heartwarming
Oh, ok. The world makes sense again. I don't quite understand the story of these songs, and I don't speak Japanese, so i was confused. Thank you for clearing it up for me.
ok me hiciste llorar PERO TE AMOOOOOOOOO
感動した泣
Valshe is so awesome :O
OMG! This made me cry ;AAAA;
Thank you so much ^_^
LEN'S VOICE
I was crying with this version. T_T
Wotamin has sweet voice!
Match with Valshe's voice~
コメントほとんど読めねww
เสียงของเทพ ชัดๆ OoO
I know what you're talking about. This song is just so....oh how should I put this.....it's heart wrenching, but beautiful at the same time. I too have a twin sister, and I hope that this will never happen, because I would probably do the same thing as Len. So, you are not wierd. It happens to the best of us.
我覺得雪系列(soundless voice & proof of life)是屬於帶著淡淡悲傷卻不失溫柔的感人曲風。
it's the same story, just told in different perspectives.
the first one, soundless voice, is Len telling about how he's taking care or Rin, who is ill. proof of life is Rin's side, of how she wants to convey the feelings she cannot say to Len due to her illness. in the end, Rin supposedly dies.
I'm not that good at explaining, but that's the main plot. if you find an english sub, the lyrics itself expresses their emotions through this song very beautifully and better than i can
I love this song I cried l love run and Len voice
me:laugh away the pain, just laugh away the pain
twin brother:hey sis what up?
me:*lumps up and hugs brother sobbing*don't let me die in the snow D:
bro: O-O ok what the hell happened?
me:the kagamines happened
bro: oh
*both sobbing*
i always feel like crying at the screaming part
ลึกซึ้ง T^T
I love the scream that Len makes
songs make me cry every time
บางครั้ง เราก็แกล้งทำเป็นไม่ได้ยินเสียงของเธอ แต่ในวันที่เสียงนั้นหายไป...
แปลกนะ เรากลับเรียกร้องหามันอีกครั้ง ให้มันอยู่... อย่างที่เคยเป็น
I gots chills when Valshe went "Ahhh!" in the song. Sounds like Len. OnO
first time i found Soundless Voice was from one vid called Ciel Phantomhive's Character Song :)
I am adamant. I will not cry. I have stopped crying over Servant of Evil and regret Message, I will-
*hears Valshe*
waah Len~~ LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNN!!!!! *cries*
WOW, same as Valshe's... lucky you XD
i luv this