This video was so relatable for me, So I am basically a Muslim and as a child (from age of 4) I use to go in madarsa, every time, if you don't follow the authority figure, let it be teachers, they used to beat the _ out of me and my fellow classmates. And whenever I have the question of why, when, how, they are always silent. After getting fed up from all these things, I left madarsa at my age 10 and went into a school. I am in 12th now with science stream.
I can relate to this video very much . I am in 11th (medical).I am only one who doesn’t believe in god in family. Their superstitions just kills me . I wonder everytime are we living in 21 century . They say what are you gonna do in life without god and god will break you and ruin your future.
Bro...i know your status, soon after sometime you will see that there should be some supreme power who controls everything. I also don't like superstitions but some superstition is good. You are young now, without any practical experience. Your time will also come
@@mastermindgkclassesYes, there maybe a Supreme power controlling us but they won't force us to follow such futile superstitions... The books like Bhagvad Gita can be a life changer for many but we can't say it is from the god... Just keep religion as religion as whenever it is publicized it had created fights
Every parent should watch this. As you rightly said "Teaching what to think as opposed to HOW to think" is the key factor. I have two children and I receive hell from seniors in the family for raising them without religion.
Encourage your children to ask questions. Question about anything including science and religion. Science and Religion both seek to answer queries on nature of our existence and amazing universe. While science uses a reductionist approach, to bring everything to chemical without any evidence by scientists producing life from chemical reactions. Hinduism teaches that we are eternal souls and we are all eternal parts of Lord Krishna, currently encaged in a body. We were all with God in His kingdom once loving and serving Him. However, by envying God and wanting to be a separate independent enjoyer, we leave God out of our own voluntary free will. And out original father being kind while allowing us to be like God (which we all are trying to be by competition) by providing facilities for sustenance and enjoyment also has created concomitant suffering - disease and death of our bodies, so we get an impetus to seek Him and go back to Him to our original home, Kingdom of Krishna. Please read "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" by Swami Prabhupada to know what is spirituality. You may also like to read "The Science of Self Realization" book by Swami Prabhupada, for clarity on any doubts you may have have about spirituality.
Religion is a belief in God, not a Truth by it's own measured definition under God. Yet still, many are having experiences across the world like I have. God Is Real, Jesus Is Real, the Way Is Real ~ A few years ago I repented to God then Prayed for help, "I was until then an Atheist." I then had a dream of Jesus coming before God and he spoke of the Tabernacle in Perfect context, "A word I didn't know existed.", and what I felt from Jesus when I Held him was unlike Anything I've Ever felt before - A Lifetime of Love Every Second - It brought me to Sobbing and it changed my life, Forever. I've had Many experiences since, "Several witnessed". A voice Spoke Clearly into my ear, "Go Visit Your Father Today.", hours before he passed. When I prayed if I could leave this world my body spoke a word Without My Permission I Never Heard Before, "Malarkey". Hours before a major surgery a Bright orb of light Passed across my face. God and Jesus ARE real! Truly Love God & Everyone! I believe Prayer, Following God's laws & Love is the answer, and through that, Truly becoming Humble, Merciful, Welcoming, Giving, Gentle, Respectful, Compassionate, Patient, Kind and Forgiving, To All.
The solution to unanswered questions is more science not religion.when faced with uncertainties or gaps in knowledge, the scientific method, with emphasis on observation, experimentation, and evidence-based reasoning, is a more reliable and systematic approach to acquiring understanding. Science is for the brave and explorers.
people often have this misconception about religion. religion, particularly the reformist ones (abrahamic religions, zoroastrianism, indic religions apart from hinduism, etc). were used by society to unite and govern themselves during pre-liberal times. a time when scientific temperament, scientific approach and logical thought process were in their infancy. sure, mathematics and scientific developments were made, but these scientists still used to attribute both their findings and the unexplained, to the almighty (or various almighties). i believe, today, we have made strides in both scientific temperament and social morality, both. we do not need religion to explain the unexplained, nor do we need religion to tell us right from wrong.
@@V-for-Vendetta01 Please explain what is life as per science? The fact that you are a spirit soul and eternal fragmental part of Lord Krishna, and you have been given a body by Krishna for fulfilling your desires since you left the Krishna's kingdom to be like God, and enjoy independent of God, and you will keep coming back into this world into another mother's womb, repeatedly in a cycle and enjoy and suffer temporary pleasures and pains until you follow a Yoga process as enunciated in Bhagavad Gita, to go back to Him, should immediately swing into action of exploring God, our creator and maintainer who loves us. Please read Bhagavad Gita and follow it to make your life sublime and follow a Yoga process of reconnecting with Lord Krishna such as Bhakti Yoga, to go back to Lord Krishna
@@thegodlogic3844 I don't care for a book that says that performing your duty assigned to you on basis of your Varna is your "dharma". Hinduism is the worst of the bunch. Other religions at least promise equality among every man.
@@V-for-Vendetta01 nah no religion promises equality atleast from within or for person from other religion . Whether Christianity, Islam none have equality. No religion can possibly promise equality wether on caste/class based , gender based and for other religions .Religions nowadays are source of hatred , bloodshed , pseudoscience as they have always been. After start of religion there is only a small possibility that the followers will hold the basics and not indulge in bloodshed in name of religious superiority . There is harmony only for few years after start and spread of religion .
Man I felt so emotional after watching this video🥲 And I'm a full grown man. In this post truth era, I haven't met a single person who shares this types of thinking... I felt like I was alone in a vast ocean of lies and anti-science. It felt so good to hear someone else speak up on this topic. And to see that you have thousands of views and subscribers also felt so relieving... Guess I'm not alone! Thanks youtube for recommending this to me🙏
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower." Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist.. And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?" Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator. 1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge. 2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface. 3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
Loved this - “teach them that everything that happens in the world has a cause and a mechanism for it. And this cause has to be based on some evidence. It’s not true because someone said so or some book says so”
In school, a friend of mine was telling us how he can't eat meat since it's the days of Ganesh festival. I asked him why and he said his parents told him this. I asked him to ask his parents why they said so. Next day he came to me and told me that he just got slapped by his mother for asking that question.
See ....eating meat on any other day is just bad....when u have great sources of nutrition in vegetables then why kill animals for our self greed...that's the simple thing .....so basically our Hindu religion don't teach to be greedy and harm animals just for our selfish moto
Swami Vivekananda was the only sage who openly talked to think rationally and reject all kind of stupidity, superstitious and irrational beliefs and enhance free thinking and creativity.
Science may or may not be dope. But spirituality is bliss! As what science is studying day in and day out is the wonderful Universe created by God. If this universe is so amazing, how amazing would be its creator! So, intelligent people are after the person behind the universe (God) and they have all the bliss! Whereas the exploratory souls who are studying the creation of God, are indeed glorifying and praising Him in an indirect way. Read "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" book by Swami Prabhupada to learn the person behind this amazing Universe and connect with Him through Bhakti Yoga and bliss is yours.
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower." Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist.. And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?" Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator. 1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge. 2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface. 3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
This is very relatable to me too, my parents are orthodox hindus and I am in class 12th pcm. They have always told me about god and the millions of stories about the thousands of of gods in hinduism. One thing that my mother also always instilled in me was critical thinking and that helped me more than anything. Although everyone around me believed wholeheartedly in god, and I would too, when I was a child I would cry in the washroom praying to god when something bad happened, asking the sky for help instead of myself, I quickly realised the god delusion. At an age of 11 or 12 when I didn't even know that a world like atheism existed, I also don't remember exactly when I stopped believing in god. All I know is that a little bit of critical thinking saved me from making dumb irrational decisions in my life based on things in the sky which I am very grateful for.
I used to be very critical about anything and could sense the bullsh!t in those holy books. However, I used to avoid asking any questions ageinst my religion in my mind, as it felt like I was committing thought crime! It may sound weird, but comedy helped me overcome the fear of thinking against religion, I want to give credit to comedians like George Carlin, Ricky Gervais, bill burr, and Louis CK
Some of them could be true. Know that rhe boggest events of today will bw rumours in a thousand years. The whole point is to learn from the History, real or not.
I developed skeptical mindset during my mid-teen age but I loved hearing mythical folkore and lore from my grandmother,I grew hearing these stories so I don't oppose it. Those folkore/lore also contains moral teachings and life lessons. It shaped my childhood.
But don't let it become a trap of false belief system. We can appreciate the knowledge, and the stories, without still believing it to be actually true.
Whoever is reading this, please explore Advaita Vedanta but follow nothing blindly, be it scientism or religion. Remember Descartes' "I think therefore I am".
@@robinroy3436āchāryavān puruṣho vedaḥ (Chhāndogya Upaniṣhad 6.14.2)[v30] “Only through a Guru can you understand the Vedas.” Trying to understand Vedas, Upanishads by your own intellect is mere speculation and of no value. Upanishads which explicitly talk about vedanta has this opinion
@@robinroy3436The Sage Patañjali states: śhrutānumāna-prajñābhyām anya-viṣhayā viśheṣhārthatvāt (Yog Darśhan 1.49) “The knowledge attained by realization from within through the practice of Yog is far superior to theoretical knowledge of the scriptures.” Try next time
Reading all yours comment I guess my parents won at parenting. Being born in Buddhist family, I never believed in such thoughts and just hated why was it compulsory to study about a specific religion in NCERT Hindi textbooks. Never visiting any temple is my family's biggest flex.
3:30 I love your stack analogy because as a former Christian, I was taught from the Bible that our belief in Jesus was our foundation, our rock. That Christ is the "cornerstone" that holds everything in place. And like you said, when that foundation crumbles/cornerstone is removed, everything built on it comes crashing down. There's a lot of work in rebuilding, but it's worth it!
Hi Pranav, I've been watching your content for the last 2 years and I am very much impressed by your talent of not only doing in-depth research but also finding valid sources i.e. finding what research paper is valid or whether it is reliable or not. My request is can you please make a video on how to do research on a topic and how to find reliable articles, journals, and research papers related to it. Most importantly how to find reliable sources. You can make that video on your other channel, what I mean is that that type of video doesn't need to be such a high production quality video as you make on this channel.
thank god i found this channel, i'm 19 and for the first time and i'm learning to be even more questioning than i was before. i have been an aethiest for like 5 years but now i knnow i can hold my ground if someone asks me why i am an aethiest
I really want to thank Anand Srinivas sir from Byju's for teaching me to ask WHY and accept that I DON'T KNOW We need more teachers like him who teaches us HOW to learn more than WHAT to learn.
I actually study science and am religious. But i do not push my beliefs to others. Nor do i follow superstitions without proper reasoning. I balance both my origins and my curiosity
@@superemewarriorbecause they are no less than religious fanatics, I'm neither religious or atheist. ( I don't believe in God atleast in the classic meaning of God )
Why should Religious people have all the fun? While I know it's not ideal, I keep throwing random ideas at my 2 yr old, opposite of what my family instills in him (ex: all Gods are false). I know it's a form of indoctrination too, but I don't want him to be sucked in too deep before he learns to question things by himself!
2 year is too young, but why can't you just tell the child why gods may not be real? Or make them ask the question themselves, instead of reverse-indoctrination?
@@ambiverter I will and Infact I'm quite good at this. But, as you just said, he's too young and I don't want it to be too late and hence I'm putting up the opposite idea in his mind as a possibility.
the most relatable point to all we can agree is that we were always made quiet after we asked any question to our parents which might shake their base, and would rather shout at us instead of accepting their mistake
People say science has been proven wrong, exactly, I would rather believe in something which comes with proofs and can be proved wrong rather than something just sentimental and authoritative... Great Video again ... Science is actually the 'right way of life' .. Science is dope and amazing...
Science keeps changing , the word of god does not need to change because it was perfect the way it was revealed and any change would corrupt it , this is why religion is absolutist and authoritative for it was revealed by Allah with no flaws , and he is the all knowing all powerful , now tell be what should I accept , the scripture with no flaws from Allah or science that has flaws and keeps changing from a human like you ? Who goes to the washroom to relieve himself , after which has to clean himself , was once part of seminal fluid , which if you got on your hand you would want to wash your hand , stay humble
@@kabir4133 The word of god is completely wrong, change doesn't mean anything to truth, science tries to fit into truth, the 'word of God' is literally wrong because there is no word of god.
@@kunalkashelani585thats actually ironic becoz atheists use it the least. They act like they are smart but they are mostly brainwashed by other atheists
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower." Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist.. And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?" Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator. 1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge. 2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface. 3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
I have been there. I was brought up as Hindu, my belief in god started fading away at the age of 13/14 as I started reading works of Bengali rationalist and scientific groups. And I had (and still have at times) the same experience as Rishabh mentioned. On my way to Jolly Grant from Haridwar, my jovial driver suddenly threatened to crash the car behind a tanker moving ahead. This is one of the finest content by Pranav despite its small duration. I feel similar anger and despair with kids being pushed into religion. But Pranav has somehow managed to keep the anger less palpable with his usual sense of humour. Kudos to
I'm from the US, and my parents are fundamentalist Christians. Their generation seems to be the last in the US that's holding on to religion so tightly, and younger generations are leaving because of the internet. It takes time, but it's happening!
The primary objective of education is to equip us with critical and independent thinking skills. Unfortunately, we're taught to work and obey. Not to think.
Cool progressive dikhaneko ajke time leftist islamik jaychand ke a jaher society may self identify vul jate ..thora iq lagao , sab samj ajayega.. dhire dhire kaya hone ja raha .. Europe vi ayse hi khtam ho raha ..avi logo ka hosh aya .@@thevilderblue
I am a Muslim. I didn't totally practised or learnt about Islam in my early teenage. I was hitted by the realisation properly ( get hidayat) in my very early 20s. In this modern scientific generation I still follow and practice Islam( which is not normal nowadays for a younger fellow like me). I choose to follow,learn,think on my own will. Cause it helps me to live, helps me to think unbiased, helps me to keep peace around me, helps me to stay calm, helps me to see the bigger picture.Helps me to know my goal( so called maksad 😅). And I think I am the most unharmful man in the society😌. Like Farhan in Idiots, I wanna say u " u keep ur humongous knowledge (seems u know everything"") and I keep my spiritual logical little belief 💗". And keep learning about Islam BY YOUR OWN.(if u want to , it's ur will 😄). Adding with this don't totally judge Islam by a small portion of people they may do some wrong bad error. My religion never brainwashed me, it always told me think by my own. Ur some points are true because it's a fact some people misinterpreted many things and using for their benefits. Quran always shows the right path but not all the followers. Hope ur perspective will change. Assalamualaikum.
My parents are atheists and I am as well , my grandparents the same . I have never been taught religious thing in my life. Feels good to be free and not believe in anything dumb.
Sir Your Content are really informative and Logical, Compared to other contents and I would thank you for Promoting Rationalism and Science and It's Future of Humanity.👍🏼
This is hilarious. Atheism is itself a religion, atheists do everything that’s considered bad about religion. Soviets were the best example of this, killing people, persecuting people, spreading unscientific things, etc they did all that under atheism. In lack of religion, atheists ALWAYS clutch to some other ideology, yesterday it was communism, today it’s wokeism
Brainwashing and indoctrination are inevitable with children. However we can limit its negative affects by teaching kids how to think and learn to hold nuanced discussions. We could "indoctrinate" kids in a way that doesn't resort to authority , abuse and fear which religions tend to exploit.
the annoyed elder shuts the kid because the elder is uneducated or rather a believer he/she literally doesn't know!! because the one who knows likes to tell others and educate them....
I am atheist since 10th Because of the my habit of asking question; there were many questions unanswered and things happened in my life made me atheist
I never really believed in religion, even when i was very young. I thought how could this universe form, without a superior being? I began to learn about science at a young age, which possibly contributed to my good critical and theoretical thinking. I called myself atheist at 9 or 10.
Please be skeptical about both science and religion and enquire truth using your intelligence. You need to answer below questions about our existence and answers from science or religion or any other source 1) Who has created a facility for male and female uniting and creating a baby which you were when you were born in this life 2) Who has created your wonderful body by design - your eyes, no man-made camera can match, your ears, any man-made hearing aid can match, your brain no man-made memory chip can match or your vital organs which are sustaining you so that you can live and pursue your desires, (who is this benefactor of yours, who loves you?) 3. Who has given you food, water, air for sustenance? - Scientists? Your parents? 3. Where were you before your current birth? 4. Where you will be after death? 5. Why you enjoy - relationships, possessions, power, family, beautiful opposite sex, popularity? Why are you pursuing happiness? 6. Why experience love, hatred, pride, envy, anger etc 7. Why you have disease and death - even you do not want them?
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower." Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist.. And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?" Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator. 1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge. 2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface. 3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
My mom doesn't like the fact that i am an atheist, but she doesn't say or do anything about it. It has been many years since i first told her about my belief, but to this day the fact that she has accepted it (although quite reluctantly) doesn't feel real, especially because mine's a very religious family.
I am a physicst and sorry to say modern science come from newtons principia and eulers work which were by no ways inspired or taken by hindusm these two guys never knew hinudsm the modern science assumes to have a world with a reason and does not relly on God for everything moreover evolution in all sences says that we dont even need god snd entropy causing life logic by jerermy england solidifies it ramanujan was a genius but he was poor and look at his social status back then if he was a brahmin by birth and had strict family if all religion caused problems for him without that he would have lived longer and went uk sooner see kala pani life event also if god exist he cant even tell the momentum and position of a particle at the same time tahts wierd
I left religion as the propaganda it was , and found that the real religion is to erase the ignorance resting in me , actually everything that I pick as the reason for a thing to be true from my perspective, I came to know that, the very base of that perspective is false , the very foundation is false , something trivial , and in the end there's nothing existing to make the belief true which I was expecting to be . And there are umpteen types of beliefs I have been holding so close to me, and thinking why My life was f***ed up ? Probe deep into your deep seated beliefs , my friends, You will find a great relief, and a kind of enthralling adventure in the exploration, This process will reveal you to yourself, Kindly beware , if you have a weak heart 🎉. You're good to begin , from now .
Loved it. I am always apprehensive of people who call themselves Hindu Atheist or teen to 25yearold who make atheism their entire identity and then get confused when posed a hard question by an expert religious charlatan to answer it. I am only an atheist as side effects of being skeptic, nihilist and kommie.
Look for Voyager's picture of Earth, also nicknamed the Pale Blue Dot. To paraphrase Carl Sagan's quote on the Pale Blue Dot: "Thousands of conflicting confident religions stranded on a random pale blue dot in a random galaxy", one galaxy among incomprehensibly more galaxies than there are particles of sand on this blue dot. Now imagine Brahma, Yahweh or whoever just decided one day to give knowledge of "reality" to the people on this blue dot, that too to only some people in some corner of that dot, not all. Even if you don't believe in theism, hindu/christian/etc atheism is as non-sensical as theism. One faith will say earth is the center of universe, another will say it's also flat, another will say it's a flat forest on top of a giant tortoise, yet another will claim there is a karma and consequences of committing sins, another will talk of rebirth; various conflicting beliefs on celestial machinations with or without god/s. Ergo none of those can be true.
7:10 I'm really grateful that my dad always told me to not believe in religious sh*t, my granny and mom are very religious, my dad also does all religious ritual only because of my mom and granny, but he tells me that your generation needs to be very critical and don't follow all these baseless practices, my dad has no problem that I'm atheist, but my mom scolds me when i question the concept of god, because according to her, the god will punish me by frying me in oil😂
I object the whole point in this video... People should not ask why.. Why is more of a philosophical question... By science, we should ask, how... Instill and inculcate the habit of asking 'how'
Although My Scientific Temparent was very low, being not from a science background But The things u mentioned can be think rationally by others too... Those all blind people in the name of god is giving profits to the liabilities of the country... Yes! Those all Preachers are liability... Even the parents are good preachers... and yes, for the values we must taught children about the ethics and moral to be followed and morever monitored (Because even after teaching it, there is minimal effect on the acts) You are the reason a man can think rationally about the world and can have own opinions We have created a ruckus by creating religions
When science says that you are a system of chemical reactions, where does the ethics and moral come about. Do chemicals have ethics and morals? Hindu Religion teaches reasonably that 1. You are an eternal non-material soul and you have been endowed with a body for facilitating fulfillment of your desires which you evidentially are doing on a daily basis 2. You are endowed with five knowledge acquiring senses Jnanendriyas) - eyes (seeing), ears (hearing), nose (smelling), mouth (tasting), and skin(touching) which you are evidentially using on a daily basis 4. You are endowed with you five working senses (Karmendriya), feet (pada) move, the hands (pani) grasp and hold, the rectum (payu) eliminates, the genitals (upastha) procreate and the mouth (vak) speaks 5. You are endowed with vital organs - hearts, kidneys, brains, liver, nervous system etc, which do vital functions by design so that you are sustained 6. You have not endowed yourself with your body evidentially, nor Scientists have endowed you with your body nor your parents have designed your body, because they do not have complete knowledge about your body as we all came out of our respective mother's womb. Scientists are trying to research about the body - a complex system which already exists without their interference or say 7. You have not created the food, air and water that nourish and sustain your body, it has been arranged for you by someone external you 8. So, the endower/designer of our body is distinct from us and this person loves us because he is facilitating the fulfilment of our desires. Much like our parents are our secondary fulfiller of desires as they provision things for us and shower their love for us 9. So, the spiritualists call this endower, our benefactor, who loves us as God. 10. And God our benefactor is invisible to our eyes and need to be searched for by research much like scientists do research. However the research methodology to seek and find our benefactor and lover (God) is through spiritual practice as has been proven to be effective by earlier spiritual practitioners Please read "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" book by Swami Prabhupada, to get a comprehensive logical view of the nature of reality and universe and yourself in relationship to it.
I don't think the problem is that severe or new generation is that susceptible to pseudoscience ( ones in middle class or above and urban ones mostly) , baba ramdev is only considered by older generations and their target market is elderly, aside from many muslim households, most young people in middle or upper class are much less religious and alll that "indoctrination" gradually wears off in teenage to adulthood , only religious young people i met are mostly rural to semi rural areas, nowadays religion is more of a go to for middle aged people in midlife crisis rather than young people, Also from my observation, you cannot teach anyone critical thinking
I agree on the critical thinking part, but we don't really know if the universe was IN FACT made by big bang or not. If a theory is popular it doesn't mean that it's necessarily correct. The facts about origin of the universe are still debated today in science. Likewise, the religions may be wrong too. I'm saying, until we have a "Theory of everything" that can explain each and every natural phenomenon and laws that govern the universe with no doubts (the string theory is one such attempt), we can't entirely disprove that God doesn't exist. At this point i'm so confused myself I don't know what to believe
Just keep a open mind and read many books+ learn from experiences. Think with logic. Say 'I don't know' if you don't. Ignorance is not a sin. But don't let others dictate what you think.
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower." Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist.. And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?" Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator. 1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge. 2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface. 3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
Sai Baba is fake While Hindu deities Now don't count sai baba to be a Hindu diety Bcoz he is worshipped He was a Iranian who hide in Bharat due to bristishers
It is so pathetic that the day it was uploaded, we all watching this video will surely die someday in future, while still there being this BS called 'religion'.. and where globally this bs is growing recently, very saddening. But we are to make the change in our time of being alive, cheers to every subscriber of this wonderful guy Pranav. Keep growing and going!
Why are you considering religion as BS? It is very possible that there are some evidences that made people believe in religions, or at least some distorted facts. In any case, it is okay to have belief in something which is not necessarily disproven by science. Of course, to believe stories that contradict known facts is obviously foolish.
Your videos are always a treat to watch would love to watch a detailed analysis how babas like dhiredendra shastri form a cult starting from ground 0. I know it is difficult and research takes a lot of time but exposing something which has delusional effect on so many people would truly be worth.
How can a Quran which originated around 630 ce gave the explanation of Embryo development stages ? (Our science is developing not developed, still there things are mysterious, unidentified, we're unknown), i agree that, everywhere Scams are there in name of religion, so don't judge depends on people , judge the scope of religion by the actual books, those books says real but humans understandings may varies.
I can so much relate to this video and many older videos of science is dope very well . I have also lived (& still living) in a superstitious family for my whole life till now (I m 22). I had a similar bigoted , extremist and superstitious mind . I had the worldview of reality (ie thiestic ) similar to that of my family. Despite having a logical mind , i had such thoughts because logic of creationism is ingrained very deeply into the minds of kids born in religious families and then all superstition , stories of ghosts and witches, bigotry , pseudoscience , misinterpretation of serious spiritual and philosophical scriptures , misunderstanding of society , communal hatred etc. follows. My own curiosity , want to know things helped - help in this matter didn't come from anyone in my family , school or friends. It is very important for any superstitious person to be exposed to reality from the words of a fine philosopher and speaker (who can explain the chronology of making of your religious mind , remind u of your forgotten childhood , make u feel how stupid it is to assume creation and breakdown your stupidity for u) who can burst that bubble of stupidity , ignorance and false pride otherwise one can be trapped into it for their life. Once the bubble was burst , curious nature of my mind lead to one thing/person from other & i knew the reality as it has always been , not what it was told by my family . There is no creator, there is no god . There is nothing mystical about life on earth. It is a well understood biological and chemical process with function of time. Our complex bodies were not designed by any creator but they are product of a very long period of evolution. Creation of universe , creation of earth , habitabilty of earth , beginning of life , advent of humans - all can't be explained by one word answer - Supernatural God or a Well structured department of many gods . Nothing was planned nowhere , there was no one to plan - it all happened on its own. Everything was a coincidence - it is entirely possible that any of those events whether birth of cosmos or human life may never have happened. But they did and here we are. Answer to everything was based on logics of creationism which were just fallacies , there was no intelligent logic in believing in a creator/god. It seemed very logical then but now i know false logic and fallacies better than most. It really was my renaissance. I had a worldview which i was supposed to have if i were born into a modern , well-read , learned family with open minds and curiosity. It is very frustrating to continue live with people of same mind after one himself has clearity. I know that they will never have their renaissance for i understood their bigotry very well and i know it takes a lot of intellectual exercise and upheavel in all circles of mind to come out of it. I know it will never be possible for them for they have lost their curious nature completely and they know it all. It is frustrating but i continue the act of believer to not look like a rebel but i also register my disinterest many times (not repetitively and always because then the bunch of nasty idiots might feel offended). I can only try to make my disinterest look normal as much as possible but i can never tell them completely what i think of them and their understanding about everything. Trying to reform and change their thoughts out of compassion is a very bad and dangerous idea because that means idiots will know what i think and then that nasty name calling and what not will happen. Having understood my parents, siblings , cousins and the bloody whole extended family, the very expectation of them understanding me is far fetched, stupid, tiring, worthless and dangerous because once they know me i will loose my shield forever.
Don't just parrot padguru one liners without thinking, or else you stand to get ridiculed like him. So do you mean Hindus don't have any beliefs? None at all?
I am a first-time viewer but dude, good one. We need more people like you. Even though these religions are required to be followed by the people who can't grasp the idea of good and evil without a religion.
I am a religious person, and the question is, how do you conclude that a religious person is not skeptical about the world? I mean, we do accept that there are small organisms called bacteria and viruses, radiation, and whatnot. The only difference we have, I think, is the question of existence. Otherwise, like atheism, it is a worldview, except for one thing: religious people believe in eternal life, which can't be proven wrong using any scientific tools. So, if a person believes in a particular religion and expects an eternal life, they behave in a certain manner, and otherwise, they can live as they want. I mean, if not drinking alcohol is not causing them any harm, then why would they question it? What is the use of being skeptical there?
@@lukadoncic9355 i am saying that there is NO scientific evidence for any eternal life(as of now), yet can be proven once you accept to the fundamental principles of that particular religion. for example, prophecies about future and miracles.
@@adilct3467 Why should one if the fundamentals of the said religion don't have evidence behind them. Why is saying 'I don't know' not enough till the time there is evidence?
Hi, just a quick question, since you find an atheist who is not a sceptic is a red flag, do you imply that the logical conclusion of scepticism is atheism?
@@scienceisdope Ok, is that a position you hold impenetrable to scepticism itself? You can always be doubtful or ask why to your own conclusion. Am I right?
@@scienceisdope@scienceisdope I am fine with your agnostic position or asking the question 'why' to the world around you. But here, you take the position of being an atheist. Or, more specifically, how did you conclude atheism is true by asking 'why'?
Ask a highly influenced Atheist: How and why did you come to this earth and where will you go after death? Can science make someone immortal? Why was this universe created?
Why was the universe created? That's a very absurd question, because using the word created preassumes a creation which preassumes a created. And reason is human made quality which cannot be asserted towards a non human thing i.e universe
@@lookintoit4537 osho also said similar thing, osho said: Nietzsche did great service to humanity by saying god is dead but didn't give anything just take away the false hope" buddha give the world meditation which is the solution, to fill this void of meaning through bliss and enlightenment.in this point questioner mind ego dropped and merge with universal consciousness.
@@aishwarykalosia7129 the problem is with too much religions hence war are happening 👍 religion who believes in love and peace is always better and what's athiest won isn't that superiority complex and extreme ego u aren't special or anything if u won aur something
Hey Pranav! All your videos make such good points and you call out all the misleading information, especially in Hinduism (across your channel) and Christianity (in this video). I feel like a lot of people also need to have their eyes opened to all the myths and so-called “facts” from Islam and Christianity.
There is definitely a role for religion in this world. As humans trying to understand the world and reality that we exist in, religion is a good first step. It's when the religion becomes dogmatic that the whole thing falls apart. It is when children are told that God will punish them or reward them for their actions, or fulfill their desires for obedience, that religion falters. I believe that some indoctrination in the form of stories, mythologies, participating in rituals, is inevitable as part of a religious following, but this should necessarily lead to a self guided search at some point, not perpetual subjugation to a purportedly divine being
Support me at: Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_ Nas IO: nas.io/scienceisdope YT Membership: ua-cam.com/channels/g--ENXdDpXh5LyLigolg2g.htmljoin UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support )
If u done begging I would like to tell u that if u hate religion that's totally ok and I respect that,, If u wanna debunk certain con guys who operates in the name of religion that's ok too,, but the moment u cross the line and try to preach and force your atheistic belief (even in indirect ways like this video) then I had to say that it would be hard for me and many Others of your viewers to follow u. Make this a learning channel don't turn this one into A expose, roast and atheistic preaching channel.
@Allinoneanime-fj5tz first of all, thanks for your consideration and tolerance, I myself an agnostic person and I believe in God(not in religions) . But there's no proof of his existence again due to lack pf evidence u can't deny his existence (The character and nature of god is still not known, who knows maybe nature itself is god or whatever) but in my last comment I didn’t talked about proving anything I was just hoping that he Don't hurt religious sentiments ( forceful or videos without concrete reasons). I hope u understood that,, just there’s no evidence or even those being ridiculous doesn’t give us the right to bunk on them (if they are not harming anybody)
@@jjbankai3108 This is my profession and this is how I earn a living. If you think this is begging, then you're also a beggar, begging to your boss at the end of every month.
Society created God to deal with morals (and morals are subjective) and a coping mechanism for death because it sucks when people die. You don't get to see them anymore and that's it. People didn't like this, and went well, "what if we can see them in the stars?" and so that's kinda the whole idea of religion and whatnot. Then people capitalized on it and made it more a business then a nice thing to believe. I personally don't believe in a god and I should have the right to do so. As well as people practicing religion that is their choice as long as they don't put it on other people or cause harm to people.
Don't we should try to know the truth behind all these things despite saying it wrong? I am worshipper of the upnishad. Being a student of acharya Prashant, i am extremely impressed to say that we should belive in science amd philosophy which emaluate from the upnishads and Vedant.
In this channel, you're discussing a topic, namely, science, which you have a strong grasp of. I support your expertise in this area. However, when you delve into another topic, such as religion in relation to science, your understanding appears to be lacking. This lack of understanding is not justified. This is nonsensical. I propose arranging a debate with a well-known scholar to see how long you can sustain with your arguments. It's worth noting that you're also generating income under the guise of discussing religion, which, in essence, seems to be a similar endeavor but in a more concealed manner. My suggestion is to focus on educating people about science, which could potentially lead them to question or leave their religious beliefs. Isn't it as straightforward as that?
Religion is essential for children so that they have some fear of bad deeds. Adults can not always take care of their activities, so things like “God is always watching you and punish you if you do bad deeds” are effective in North India. Upon adolescent and adulthood, they gradually learn about science, if the kid is studious. Otherwise they should remain blinded by religious dogmas. Imagine, the wealth Jains and baniya begin eating meat! Carbon footprint of India will increase steeply. Religion is important to control ignorant people.
@@AlbertEinstein-cs9do Despite the fear of hell, people in the past still committed crimes, possibly even more than today, because the legal system back then was not as well-established as it is now.
There is a video put forth by soch in his youtube channel. He mentioned of an Indian American acting student who came here to experiment as to how much people believe Godmen and their words. He dressed as a Godman and started blabbering words. Few months down the lane many praised him, said he is God sent man and stuff. All thanks to the placebo affect. P. S. : This is a secondary source for me. Please do go find it if u want to verify
Wow! Interesting, the fascination for God or Godmen will continue, until science can show that there is no God, or that Chimpanzee is giving birth to a human baby or chemical reactions can produce lives.
Lol ,ye woi Quran ha Jo kheta ha Maa baap ki iazat karu Mere leye sab se Acha wo ha jisne Apne maa baap ki iazat ki Next Quran said Ailm hasil karna haar muslmaan marad uraat Ka Faraz ha Quran said Apne tamam bachon ke sath bara bar Ka raweya rkhu Quran said Ager tum kouch Khana banao or USki khusbu tumhare parosi tak jae Tu tumhare Faraz ha tum use bhi Khana dena huga Quran said Neighbors se ache raweya se baat karu Quran said Apni ulaad pe kharacha karu Unhe achi tarbeyat do Jhoot na bolo
Do not compare Sanatan Dharma with Abrahamic religions. Sadhguru is not an authority of Hinduism. At least try to read Advait Vedant before making any statements.
@@batmanbabahow long do you wanna have my post to be? A proper plan of living a life Brahmacharya Grihastha Etc... Most books dedicated to philosophies Debates(Shankara digvijay and many more) Epics(itihas) Schools of thought like sankhya vedanta
@@batmanbaba better for you to focus on jee Hinduism ain't your cup of tea The word kama is mistranslated to lust and sex but in truth it also means desire pleasure (not only sexual pleasure) Kamdev is god of love
This video was so relatable for me,
So I am basically a Muslim and as a child (from age of 4) I use to go in madarsa, every time, if you don't follow the authority figure, let it be teachers, they used to beat the _ out of me and my fellow classmates.
And whenever I have the question of why, when, how, they are always silent.
After getting fed up from all these things, I left madarsa at my age 10 and went into a school.
I am in 12th now with science stream.
Same story bro.
@@higgsbozon 🥲 I hope you are doing grate now
Sad fact still billions of Muslims follow their religion blindly!
@@areebaftab5778 On the track to obtain a physics degree in Europe. Thanks to internet (I am 28 now)
@@sunilbabu1818Care about your billion and stop thinking about other's bad.
I can relate to this video very much . I am in 11th (medical).I am only one who doesn’t believe in god in family. Their superstitions just kills me . I wonder everytime are we living in 21 century . They say what are you gonna do in life without god and god will break you and ruin your future.
My friend We are in 21st century because of Jesus. Where do you think advances in science came from our brains? God gave us science.
@@OragansKontsin_TheKretyen14 yeah we are in 21 century because of Jesus. Because without him, we would be living like 1500 billionth century 🤣
Bro...i know your status, soon after sometime you will see that there should be some supreme power who controls everything. I also don't like superstitions but some superstition is good. You are young now, without any practical experience. Your time will also come
@@OragansKontsin_TheKretyen14God gave us science but still can't explain how they made Eva from the Adam... Got me laughing 🤣🤣🤣
@@mastermindgkclassesYes, there maybe a Supreme power controlling us but they won't force us to follow such futile superstitions... The books like Bhagvad Gita can be a life changer for many but we can't say it is from the god... Just keep religion as religion as whenever it is publicized it had created fights
Every parent should watch this. As you rightly said "Teaching what to think as opposed to HOW to think" is the key factor. I have two children and I receive hell from seniors in the family for raising them without religion.
Encourage your children to ask questions. Question about anything including science and religion.
Science and Religion both seek to answer queries on nature of our existence and amazing universe.
While science uses a reductionist approach, to bring everything to chemical without any evidence by scientists producing life from chemical reactions.
Hinduism teaches that we are eternal souls and we are all eternal parts of Lord Krishna, currently encaged in a body.
We were all with God in His kingdom once loving and serving Him. However, by envying God and wanting to be a separate independent enjoyer, we leave God out of our own voluntary free will.
And out original father being kind while allowing us to be like God (which we all are trying to be by competition) by providing facilities for sustenance and enjoyment also has created concomitant suffering - disease and death of our bodies, so we get an impetus to seek Him and go back to Him to our original home, Kingdom of Krishna.
Please read "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" by Swami Prabhupada to know what is spirituality.
You may also like to read "The Science of Self Realization" book by Swami Prabhupada, for clarity on any doubts you may have have about spirituality.
Religion is a belief in God, not a Truth by it's own measured definition under God. Yet still, many are having experiences across the world like I have. God Is Real, Jesus Is Real, the Way Is Real
~
A few years ago I repented to God then Prayed for help, "I was until then an Atheist."
I then had a dream of Jesus coming before God and he spoke of the Tabernacle in Perfect context, "A word I didn't know existed.", and what I felt from Jesus when I Held him was unlike Anything I've Ever felt before - A Lifetime of Love Every Second - It brought me to Sobbing and it changed my life, Forever.
I've had Many experiences since, "Several witnessed".
A voice Spoke Clearly into my ear, "Go Visit Your Father Today.", hours before he passed. When I prayed if I could leave this world my body spoke a word Without My Permission I Never Heard Before, "Malarkey". Hours before a major surgery a Bright orb of light Passed across my face.
God and Jesus ARE real! Truly Love God & Everyone!
I believe Prayer, Following God's laws & Love is the answer, and through that, Truly becoming Humble, Merciful, Welcoming, Giving, Gentle, Respectful, Compassionate, Patient, Kind and Forgiving, To All.
Problms will Come ur way .. But Keep Goinggg ❤❤
because without religion they will be immoral, worshipping their desires instead of worshipping God
The solution to unanswered questions is more science not religion.when faced with uncertainties or gaps in knowledge, the scientific method, with emphasis on observation, experimentation, and evidence-based reasoning, is a more reliable and systematic approach to acquiring understanding.
Science is for the brave and explorers.
people often have this misconception about religion. religion, particularly the reformist ones (abrahamic religions, zoroastrianism, indic religions apart from hinduism, etc). were used by society to unite and govern themselves during pre-liberal times. a time when scientific temperament, scientific approach and logical thought process were in their infancy. sure, mathematics and scientific developments were made, but these scientists still used to attribute both their findings and the unexplained, to the almighty (or various almighties).
i believe, today, we have made strides in both scientific temperament and social morality, both. we do not need religion to explain the unexplained, nor do we need religion to tell us right from wrong.
pin this shit!! well said
@@V-for-Vendetta01 Please explain what is life as per science? The fact that you are a spirit soul and eternal fragmental part of Lord Krishna, and you have been given a body by Krishna for fulfilling your desires since you left the Krishna's kingdom to be like God, and enjoy independent of God, and you will keep coming back into this world into another mother's womb, repeatedly in a cycle and enjoy and suffer temporary pleasures and pains until you follow a Yoga process as enunciated in Bhagavad Gita, to go back to Him, should immediately swing into action of exploring God, our creator and maintainer who loves us. Please read Bhagavad Gita and follow it to make your life sublime and follow a Yoga process of reconnecting with Lord Krishna such as Bhakti Yoga, to go back to Lord Krishna
@@thegodlogic3844 I don't care for a book that says that performing your duty assigned to you on basis of your Varna is your "dharma". Hinduism is the worst of the bunch. Other religions at least promise equality among every man.
@@V-for-Vendetta01 nah no religion promises equality atleast from within or for person from other religion . Whether Christianity, Islam none have equality. No religion can possibly promise equality wether on caste/class based , gender based and for other religions .Religions nowadays are source of hatred , bloodshed , pseudoscience as they have always been. After start of religion there is only a small possibility that the followers will hold the basics and not indulge in bloodshed in name of religious superiority . There is harmony only for few years after start and spread of religion .
Man I felt so emotional after watching this video🥲 And I'm a full grown man.
In this post truth era, I haven't met a single person who shares this types of thinking...
I felt like I was alone in a vast ocean of lies and anti-science. It felt so good to hear someone else speak up on this topic. And to see that you have thousands of views and subscribers also felt so relieving... Guess I'm not alone!
Thanks youtube for recommending this to me🙏
Where do you live? It will be very difficult to be a logical thinker in northern parts of India.
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower."
Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist..
And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"
Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator.
1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge.
2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface.
3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
Loved this - “teach them that everything that happens in the world has a cause and a mechanism for it. And this cause has to be based on some evidence. It’s not true because someone said so or some book says so”
In school, a friend of mine was telling us how he can't eat meat since it's the days of Ganesh festival. I asked him why and he said his parents told him this. I asked him to ask his parents why they said so. Next day he came to me and told me that he just got slapped by his mother for asking that question.
Lol😂
See ....eating meat on any other day is just bad....when u have great sources of nutrition in vegetables then why kill animals for our self greed...that's the simple thing .....so basically our Hindu religion don't teach to be greedy and harm animals just for our selfish moto
Probably fair enough
Ganesh puja stops killing or harming animals so you should not eat meat.
@@TonyStark-vx9qzwhy don't do it whole year??? So illogical myths
Swami Vivekananda was the only sage who openly talked to think rationally and reject all kind of stupidity, superstitious and irrational beliefs and enhance free thinking and creativity.
Science is Hope, Science is Dope 🔥
Good one 👌👍
Science is Dope , Science is Hope ❄
Science may or may not be dope. But spirituality is bliss!
As what science is studying day in and day out is the wonderful Universe created by God.
If this universe is so amazing, how amazing would be its creator!
So, intelligent people are after the person behind the universe (God) and they have all the bliss!
Whereas the exploratory souls who are studying the creation of God, are indeed glorifying and praising Him in an indirect way.
Read "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" book by Swami Prabhupada to learn the person behind this amazing Universe and connect with Him through Bhakti Yoga and bliss is yours.
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower."
Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist..
And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"
Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator.
1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge.
2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface.
3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
This is very relatable to me too, my parents are orthodox hindus and I am in class 12th pcm. They have always told me about god and the millions of stories about the thousands of of gods in hinduism. One thing that my mother also always instilled in me was critical thinking and that helped me more than anything. Although everyone around me believed wholeheartedly in god, and I would too, when I was a child I would cry in the washroom praying to god when something bad happened, asking the sky for help instead of myself, I quickly realised the god delusion. At an age of 11 or 12 when I didn't even know that a world like atheism existed, I also don't remember exactly when I stopped believing in god. All I know is that a little bit of critical thinking saved me from making dumb irrational decisions in my life based on things in the sky which I am very grateful for.
I used to be very critical about anything and could sense the bullsh!t in those holy books. However, I used to avoid asking any questions ageinst my religion in my mind, as it felt like I was committing thought crime! It may sound weird, but comedy helped me overcome the fear of thinking against religion, I want to give credit to comedians like George Carlin, Ricky Gervais, bill burr, and Louis CK
same happened to me
I asked my mom if she thinks if the stories in the bible are real and she told me "Yes." It blows my mind that people can think that way.
Some of them could be true. Know that rhe boggest events of today will bw rumours in a thousand years.
The whole point is to learn from the History, real or not.
I developed skeptical mindset during my mid-teen age but I loved hearing mythical folkore and lore from my grandmother,I grew hearing these stories so I don't oppose it. Those folkore/lore also contains moral teachings and life lessons. It shaped my childhood.
underrated comment.
But don't let it become a trap of false belief system. We can appreciate the knowledge, and the stories, without still believing it to be actually true.
There is nothing wrong with enjoying fiction while remaining a skeptic
Same
Whoever is reading this, please explore Advaita Vedanta but follow nothing blindly, be it scientism or religion. Remember Descartes' "I think therefore I am".
You can't understand Advaita if you have atheistic mindset
Without the love of God
You would never understand vedanta
@@mr.gamerkabir8142andhvakth spotted
@@robinroy3436asshole spotted
@@robinroy3436āchāryavān puruṣho vedaḥ (Chhāndogya Upaniṣhad 6.14.2)[v30]
“Only through a Guru can you understand the Vedas.” Trying to understand Vedas, Upanishads by your own intellect is mere speculation and of no value.
Upanishads which explicitly talk about vedanta has this opinion
@@robinroy3436The Sage Patañjali states:
śhrutānumāna-prajñābhyām anya-viṣhayā viśheṣhārthatvāt (Yog Darśhan 1.49)
“The knowledge attained by realization from within through the practice of Yog is far superior to theoretical knowledge of the scriptures.”
Try next time
Reading all yours comment I guess my parents won at parenting.
Being born in Buddhist family, I never believed in such thoughts and just hated why was it compulsory to study about a specific religion in NCERT Hindi textbooks.
Never visiting any temple is my family's biggest flex.
Man it so good to know there are other families like mine
Buddhism has dogmas as well you know. Your parents are probably not so religious.
"why was it compulsory to study about a specific religion" the "religion" you're talking about is the very culture and core value of this nation.
Which religion?
Not visiting temple is big flex now thats called superiority complex ur not special aur anything buddy
3:30 I love your stack analogy because as a former Christian, I was taught from the Bible that our belief in Jesus was our foundation, our rock. That Christ is the "cornerstone" that holds everything in place. And like you said, when that foundation crumbles/cornerstone is removed, everything built on it comes crashing down. There's a lot of work in rebuilding, but it's worth it!
Hi Pranav, I've been watching your content for the last 2 years and I am very much impressed by your talent of not only doing in-depth research but also finding valid sources i.e. finding what research paper is valid or whether it is reliable or not. My request is can you please make a video on how to do research on a topic and how to find reliable articles, journals, and research papers related to it. Most importantly how to find reliable sources. You can make that video on your other channel, what I mean is that that type of video doesn't need to be such a high production quality video as you make on this channel.
thank god i found this channel, i'm 19 and for the first time and i'm learning to be even more questioning than i was before. i have been an aethiest for like 5 years but now i knnow i can hold my ground if someone asks me why i am an aethiest
Haters will have an orgasm after looking at the thumbnail 😂 they never focus on the real message on purpose keep it up bro waiting for it
Yeah well said.
I just noticed 💀💀
True as hell. 💀💀💀
Nah 👍 it's about choice
I really want to thank Anand Srinivas sir from Byju's for teaching me to ask WHY and accept that I DON'T KNOW
We need more teachers like him who teaches us HOW to learn more than WHAT to learn.
I actually study science and am religious. But i do not push my beliefs to others. Nor do i follow superstitions without proper reasoning. I balance both my origins and my curiosity
same here bro but most of the athiest I faced arent friendly when I thell them that I am a biotechnologist and belive i god.
@@superemewarriorbecause they are no less than religious fanatics, I'm neither religious or atheist. ( I don't believe in God atleast in the classic meaning of God )
@@superemewarriorExactly 💯 I felt the same both in Reality nd Internet
origins?
Rather than saying "I dont know" i prefer to tell my daughter "lets find out why". I am educated too then.
"Two kinds of fools - those who take religion literally,and those who think it has no value"
Third one will be atheists
Those who think it has no value are atheists probably @@mr.gamerkabir8142
😂 you mean the one that worship science but knows nothing about it. @@mr.gamerkabir8142
Why should Religious people have all the fun? While I know it's not ideal, I keep throwing random ideas at my 2 yr old, opposite of what my family instills in him (ex: all Gods are false). I know it's a form of indoctrination too, but I don't want him to be sucked in too deep before he learns to question things by himself!
2 year is too young, but why can't you just tell the child why gods may not be real? Or make them ask the question themselves, instead of reverse-indoctrination?
@@ambiverter I will and Infact I'm quite good at this. But, as you just said, he's too young and I don't want it to be too late and hence I'm putting up the opposite idea in his mind as a possibility.
Eagerly waiting!
Edit: waited.
the most relatable point to all we can agree is that we were always made quiet after we asked any question to our parents which might shake their base, and would rather shout at us instead of accepting their mistake
People say science has been proven wrong, exactly, I would rather believe in something which comes with proofs and can be proved wrong rather than something just sentimental and authoritative... Great Video again ... Science is actually the 'right way of life' .. Science is dope and amazing...
Science keeps changing , the word of god does not need to change because it was perfect the way it was revealed and any change would corrupt it , this is why religion is absolutist and authoritative for it was revealed by Allah with no flaws , and he is the all knowing all powerful , now tell be what should I accept , the scripture with no flaws from Allah or science that has flaws and keeps changing from a human like you ? Who goes to the washroom to relieve himself , after which has to clean himself , was once part of seminal fluid , which if you got on your hand you would want to wash your hand , stay humble
@@kabir4133
The word of god is completely wrong, change doesn't mean anything to truth, science tries to fit into truth, the 'word of God' is literally wrong because there is no word of god.
Idk. But I never found belief in God making sense, even in my childhood
Some people are just a natural at critical thinking.
@@kunalkashelani585thats actually ironic becoz atheists use it the least. They act like they are smart but they are mostly brainwashed by other atheists
yeh@@kunalkashelani585
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower."
Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist..
And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"
Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator.
1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge.
2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface.
3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
I can relate to this
I have been there. I was brought up as Hindu, my belief in god started fading away at the age of 13/14 as I started reading works of Bengali rationalist and scientific groups. And I had (and still have at times) the same experience as Rishabh mentioned. On my way to Jolly Grant from Haridwar, my jovial driver suddenly threatened to crash the car behind a tanker moving ahead.
This is one of the finest content by Pranav despite its small duration. I feel similar anger and despair with kids being pushed into religion. But Pranav has somehow managed to keep the anger less palpable with his usual sense of humour. Kudos to
My friend did you cross check information which you read
Sometimes we think someone to be rationalist and scientific
But in reality they aren't
When I presented my athiest ideas to my family, their reaction simply was 'esa nahi sochte'.
Same ,
😢😢 relatable bhai
I'm from the US, and my parents are fundamentalist Christians. Their generation seems to be the last in the US that's holding on to religion so tightly, and younger generations are leaving because of the internet. It takes time, but it's happening!
'Youŕ' atheist ideas 😂😂😂
The primary objective of education is to equip us with critical and independent thinking skills. Unfortunately, we're taught to work and obey. Not to think.
OK, then prepare for UGC net.
@@Pantheist2602 why?
@@thevilderbluenastik logic se bap ko vi bap na mano fer ..q ki dna test ke Bina bap kon bachhe ka kayse malum ?
Cool progressive dikhaneko ajke time leftist islamik jaychand ke a jaher society may self identify vul jate ..thora iq lagao , sab samj ajayega.. dhire dhire kaya hone ja raha .. Europe vi ayse hi khtam ho raha ..avi logo ka hosh aya .@@thevilderblue
@@Ab-mc2shbad example 😂.
Reminds me of Mahashweta Devi’s Why Why Girl, a story about a tribal girl asking inconvenient questions. She wants answers to everything.
I am a Muslim. I didn't totally practised or learnt about Islam in my early teenage.
I was hitted by the realisation properly ( get hidayat) in my very early 20s.
In this modern scientific generation I still follow and practice Islam( which is not normal nowadays for a younger fellow like me). I choose to follow,learn,think
on my own will.
Cause it helps me to live, helps me to think unbiased, helps me to keep peace around me, helps me to stay calm, helps me to see the bigger picture.Helps me to know my goal( so called maksad 😅).
And I think I am the most unharmful man in the society😌.
Like Farhan in Idiots,
I wanna say u " u keep ur humongous knowledge (seems u know everything"") and I keep my spiritual logical little belief 💗".
And keep learning about Islam
BY YOUR OWN.(if u want to , it's ur will 😄). Adding with this don't totally judge
Islam by a small portion of people they may do some wrong bad error.
My religion never brainwashed me, it always told me think by my own. Ur some points are true because it's a fact some people misinterpreted many things and using for their benefits.
Quran always shows the right path but not all the followers.
Hope ur perspective will change.
Assalamualaikum.
Yes exactly logo se judge mt kro or na madarse se true islam is teaches us to use our mind unbiasely ❤
@@naenaeo so in this religion is not responsible the fake people who preach religion is responsible who make religion a income factory .
My parents are atheists and I am as well , my grandparents the same . I have never been taught religious thing in my life. Feels good to be free and not believe in anything dumb.
Have you explored any philosophy ?
@@ShankarShankar-hb7bi philosophy as in any religious philosophy or general philosophy of knowledge?
@@Oioioioioioi- religions doesn't have philosophy, they have rules , I am taking about philosophies like vedanta , nihilism etc
@@ShankarShankar-hb7bi yeah , stoicism - Be tolerant to others and strict to yourselves 🗿. And you ?
@@Oioioioioioi- Advaita Vedanta - Know your true identity , your soul is god
Sir Your Content are really informative and Logical, Compared to other contents and I would thank you for Promoting Rationalism and Science and It's Future of Humanity.👍🏼
This is hilarious. Atheism is itself a religion, atheists do everything that’s considered bad about religion.
Soviets were the best example of this, killing people, persecuting people, spreading unscientific things, etc they did all that under atheism. In lack of religion, atheists ALWAYS clutch to some other ideology, yesterday it was communism, today it’s wokeism
Bhimta
Nah nothing is future
Just like how many mythological stories are metaphorical stories, but are taken literally
Proud atheist ❤
No need to be proud
Ur from where
@@ananthapadmanabhan6340 i am India
We're proud of our critical thinking, rationale & ability to break free from the religious beliefs set by society@@fintechtelugu6980
And a proud normie
Relatable.
I witnessed crumbling of my knowledge stack as i dared to shake by foundation by critcical thinking.
Love your content! All hail You tube ALGO!
Brainwashing and indoctrination are inevitable with children.
However we can limit its negative affects by teaching kids how to think and learn to hold nuanced discussions. We could "indoctrinate" kids in a way that doesn't resort to authority , abuse and fear which religions tend to exploit.
the annoyed elder shuts the kid because the elder is uneducated or rather a believer he/she literally doesn't know!! because the one who knows likes to tell others and educate them....
I am atheist since 10th
Because of the my habit of asking question; there were many questions unanswered and things happened in my life made me atheist
I never really believed in religion, even when i was very young. I thought how could this universe form, without a superior being? I began to learn about science at a young age, which possibly contributed to my good critical and theoretical thinking. I called myself atheist at 9 or 10.
Please be skeptical about both science and religion and enquire truth using your intelligence.
You need to answer below questions about our existence and answers from science or religion or any other source
1) Who has created a facility for male and female uniting and creating a baby which you were when you were born in this life
2) Who has created your wonderful body by design - your eyes, no man-made camera can match, your ears, any man-made hearing aid can match, your brain no man-made memory chip can match or your vital organs which are sustaining you so that you can live and pursue your desires, (who is this benefactor of yours, who loves you?)
3. Who has given you food, water, air for sustenance? - Scientists? Your parents?
3. Where were you before your current birth?
4. Where you will be after death?
5. Why you enjoy - relationships, possessions, power, family, beautiful opposite sex, popularity? Why are you pursuing happiness?
6. Why experience love, hatred, pride, envy, anger etc
7. Why you have disease and death - even you do not want them?
Me too, but I don't believe in science logic for creation of universe either.
same, but ur L pfp tells me u a snob
@@iamgar6age heh then what
@@xandex69 nothing, I'm still looking for better explanation
An irony is that a bible app ad popped up in the middle of this video😅
umm why have you completely stopped making videos on science topics like earlier? (water memory, james webb telescope, ajinomotoetc.)🤔🤔
he explained that in one of his videos
You are doing God's Work..😉😉
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower."
Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist..
And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"
Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator.
1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge.
2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface.
3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
My mom doesn't like the fact that i am an atheist, but she doesn't say or do anything about it. It has been many years since i first told her about my belief, but to this day the fact that she has accepted it (although quite reluctantly) doesn't feel real, especially because mine's a very religious family.
Im Ex- Atheist when i Understand Engg Whole concept of Morden science is come from Our Ved ..and Ved is beyond the science .. What about Ramanujan
I am a physicst and sorry to say modern science come from newtons principia and eulers work which were by no ways inspired or taken by hindusm these two guys never knew hinudsm the modern science assumes to have a world with a reason and does not relly on God for everything moreover evolution in all sences says that we dont even need god snd entropy causing life logic by jerermy england solidifies it ramanujan was a genius but he was poor and look at his social status back then if he was a brahmin by birth and had strict family if all religion caused problems for him without that he would have lived longer and went uk sooner see kala pani life event also if god exist he cant even tell the momentum and position of a particle at the same time tahts wierd
I left religion as the propaganda it was ,
and found that the real religion is to erase the ignorance resting in me , actually everything that I pick as the reason for a thing to be true from my perspective, I came to know that, the very base of that perspective is false , the very foundation is false , something trivial , and in the end there's nothing existing to make the belief true which I was expecting to be .
And there are umpteen types of beliefs I have been holding so close to me, and thinking why My life was f***ed up ?
Probe deep into your deep seated beliefs , my friends,
You will find a great relief, and a kind of enthralling adventure in the exploration,
This process will reveal you to yourself,
Kindly beware , if you have a weak heart 🎉.
You're good to begin , from now .
This is a very very important video for this generation. Thanks for putting this out. It's spot on. 👌
Loved it. I am always apprehensive of people who call themselves Hindu Atheist or teen to 25yearold who make atheism their entire identity and then get confused when posed a hard question by an expert religious charlatan to answer it. I am only an atheist as side effects of being skeptic, nihilist and kommie.
Being commie is the worst of all. Communism and N*zism, 2 sides of the same coin. And that coin needs to be banned
I am an irreligious Hindu , question me.
Question for me??
Look for Voyager's picture of Earth, also nicknamed the Pale Blue Dot. To paraphrase Carl Sagan's quote on the Pale Blue Dot: "Thousands of conflicting confident religions stranded on a random pale blue dot in a random galaxy", one galaxy among incomprehensibly more galaxies than there are particles of sand on this blue dot.
Now imagine Brahma, Yahweh or whoever just decided one day to give knowledge of "reality" to the people on this blue dot, that too to only some people in some corner of that dot, not all. Even if you don't believe in theism, hindu/christian/etc atheism is as non-sensical as theism. One faith will say earth is the center of universe, another will say it's also flat, another will say it's a flat forest on top of a giant tortoise, yet another will claim there is a karma and consequences of committing sins, another will talk of rebirth; various conflicting beliefs on celestial machinations with or without god/s. Ergo none of those can be true.
I just hope it doesn’t get struck down a must watch video in today’s diaspora
7:10 I'm really grateful that my dad always told me to not believe in religious sh*t, my granny and mom are very religious, my dad also does all religious ritual only because of my mom and granny, but he tells me that your generation needs to be very critical and don't follow all these baseless practices, my dad has no problem that I'm atheist, but my mom scolds me when i question the concept of god, because according to her, the god will punish me by frying me in oil😂
Ruthless god isnt it? And they say god is all loving!
I object the whole point in this video... People should not ask why.. Why is more of a philosophical question... By science, we should ask, how... Instill and inculcate the habit of asking 'how'
Although My Scientific Temparent was very low, being not from a science background
But The things u mentioned can be think rationally by others too...
Those all blind people in the name of god is giving profits to the liabilities of the country... Yes! Those all Preachers are liability... Even the parents are good preachers... and yes, for the values we must taught children about the ethics and moral to be followed and morever monitored (Because even after teaching it, there is minimal effect on the acts)
You are the reason a man can think rationally about the world and can have own opinions
We have created a ruckus by creating religions
When science says that you are a system of chemical reactions, where does the ethics and moral come about. Do chemicals have ethics and morals?
Hindu Religion teaches reasonably that
1. You are an eternal non-material soul and you have been endowed with a body for facilitating fulfillment of your desires which you evidentially are doing on a daily basis
2. You are endowed with five knowledge acquiring senses Jnanendriyas) - eyes (seeing), ears (hearing), nose (smelling), mouth (tasting), and skin(touching) which you are evidentially using on a daily basis
4. You are endowed with you five working senses (Karmendriya), feet (pada) move, the hands (pani) grasp and hold, the rectum (payu) eliminates, the genitals (upastha) procreate and the mouth (vak) speaks
5. You are endowed with vital organs - hearts, kidneys, brains, liver, nervous system etc, which do vital functions by design so that you are sustained
6. You have not endowed yourself with your body evidentially, nor Scientists have endowed you with your body nor your parents have designed your body, because they do not have complete knowledge about your body as we all came out of our respective mother's womb. Scientists are trying to research about the body - a complex system which already exists without their interference or say
7. You have not created the food, air and water that nourish and sustain your body, it has been arranged for you by someone external you
8. So, the endower/designer of our body is distinct from us and this person loves us because he is facilitating the fulfilment of our desires. Much like our parents are our secondary fulfiller of desires as they provision things for us and shower their love for us
9. So, the spiritualists call this endower, our benefactor, who loves us as God.
10. And God our benefactor is invisible to our eyes and need to be searched for by research much like scientists do research. However the research methodology to seek and find our benefactor and lover (God) is through spiritual practice as has been proven to be effective by earlier spiritual practitioners
Please read "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" book by Swami Prabhupada, to get a comprehensive logical view of the nature of reality and universe and yourself in relationship to it.
@@thegodlogic3844 shut yo copy paste yappalogy bro
I don't think the problem is that severe or new generation is that susceptible to pseudoscience ( ones in middle class or above and urban ones mostly) , baba ramdev is only considered by older generations and their target market is elderly, aside from many muslim households, most young people in middle or upper class are much less religious and alll that "indoctrination" gradually wears off in teenage to adulthood , only religious young people i met are mostly rural to semi rural areas, nowadays religion is more of a go to for middle aged people in midlife crisis rather than young people,
Also from my observation, you cannot teach anyone critical thinking
This skill can be learned in adult life as well.
I feel more critical now than before
Yeah it's very difficult because since childhood religious beliefs occupied our mind so it took great affort to overcome it.
I agree on the critical thinking part, but we don't really know if the universe was IN FACT made by big bang or not. If a theory is popular it doesn't mean that it's necessarily correct. The facts about origin of the universe are still debated today in science. Likewise, the religions may be wrong too. I'm saying, until we have a "Theory of everything" that can explain each and every natural phenomenon and laws that govern the universe with no doubts (the string theory is one such attempt), we can't entirely disprove that God doesn't exist.
At this point i'm so confused myself I don't know what to believe
Just keep a open mind and read many books+ learn from experiences.
Think with logic.
Say 'I don't know' if you don't. Ignorance is not a sin.
But don't let others dictate what you think.
Beautiful episode. So correctly stated.
Glad to support if just for this video...
Brother I'm not blind follower of my religion. I used follow proper religion from my college days no one in my home compels me to do so even though in Islam there is no compulsion to anyone Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256), which states: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower."
Brother you say everything thing happened in the universe was done by it's own,you take an atom for example individual atoms typically do not move independently on their own accord in a macroscopic sense, as their movement is largely dictated by their interactions with neighboring atoms and external forces. even a atom can't move by it's in this universe you atheist believe that whole universe was created on its own what a thinking why why ., Even with the so called advance technology you get a disclaimer on Google like this -The exact cause or origin of the Big Bang itself remains a subject of scientific inquiry and speculation, as it represents the limit of our current understanding of physics and cosmology. This is you emerged as fine atheist..
And in Quran you have Quran 21:30, which states: "Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"
Quran 51:47 states: "And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander." This verse is often cited to illustrate the power and design of the universe as evidence of a divine Creator.
1.Embryology: Quran 23:12-14 describes the stages of fetal development, which some interpret as being consistent with modern embryological knowledge.
2.Mountains as Pegs: Quran 78:6-7 refers to mountains as pegs, anchoring the Earth's crust, which correlates with the modern understanding of tectonic plates and their role in stabilizing the Earth's surface.
3.Expanding Universe: Quran 51:47 mentions that "We have built the heaven with might, and We it is who make the vast extent (thereof)." Some interpret this as a reference to the expanding universe, which aligns with modern cosmological theories
I really appreciate it....can you please make it with a Hindi voiceover so that the impacts more masses❤
My mother slapped me becoz i said sai baba is a fake god
I said the same
Tho I am a hindu
@@mr.gamerkabir8142
Same
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 every god is fake god for that matters
😂 My engineer dad threatened me he'd leave the family when I criticised his beliefs and said him to be scientific.
Sai Baba is fake
While Hindu deities
Now don't count sai baba to be a Hindu diety Bcoz he is worshipped
He was a Iranian who hide in Bharat due to bristishers
Questions that can't be answered (doubts) are better than Answers that can't be questioned (religion).
It is so pathetic that the day it was uploaded, we all watching this video will surely die someday in future, while still there being this BS called 'religion'.. and where globally this bs is growing recently, very saddening. But we are to make the change in our time of being alive, cheers to every subscriber of this wonderful guy Pranav. Keep growing and going!
Why are you considering religion as BS?
It is very possible that there are some evidences that made people believe in religions, or at least some distorted facts.
In any case, it is okay to have belief in something which is not necessarily disproven by science.
Of course, to believe stories that contradict known facts is obviously foolish.
Your videos are always a treat to watch would love to watch a detailed analysis how babas like dhiredendra shastri form a cult starting from ground 0. I know it is difficult and research takes a lot of time but exposing something which has delusional effect on so many people would truly be worth.
I used to hate you as I grew I appreciate you
It's called enlightenment.
Great content.. well described.. Excellent one!! Wish one whole generation of kids start thinking critically... and there ends the era of all con men.
I am glad that you are not generating more views, the algorithm working well i guess...
Ps- not a hate comment
Yes ,
The more hateful public will come after him
@@Tru79991 he himself is a skeptical
@@rohann3110 it's his way of thinking we have our own
Debunking Stupid things that should be encouraged
@@Tru79991 whats ur age again?
How can a Quran which originated around 630 ce gave the explanation of Embryo development stages ? (Our science is developing not developed, still there things are mysterious, unidentified, we're unknown), i agree that, everywhere
Scams are there in name of religion, so don't judge depends on people , judge the scope of religion by the actual books, those books says real but humans understandings may varies.
Sadhguru clearly said "Don't trust me blindly, think for yourself and use your brain"
So what😂
"Don''t trust me blindly, read the Terms & Conditions yourself and then sign the paper. Trust yourself not me."
What do you mean by Millions of People in India and Abroad don't use their Brains?!
@@batmanbaba Jaggi Vasudev should be given a Small does of Most Potent Form of Mercury,i.e, methyl Mercury
Science ie the only hope, that's why I am agnostic!
Please expose PROJECT SHIVOHAM
I incline myself with carvaka philosophy & i believe critical thinking is absolutely important for everyone.
I can so much relate to this video and many older videos of science is dope very well . I have also lived (& still living) in a superstitious family for my whole life till now (I m 22). I had a similar bigoted , extremist and superstitious mind . I had the worldview of reality (ie thiestic ) similar to that of my family. Despite having a logical mind , i had such thoughts because logic of creationism is ingrained very deeply into the minds of kids born in religious families and then all superstition , stories of ghosts and witches, bigotry , pseudoscience , misinterpretation of serious spiritual and philosophical scriptures , misunderstanding of society , communal hatred etc. follows. My own curiosity , want to know things helped - help in this matter didn't come from anyone in my family , school or friends.
It is very important for any superstitious person to be exposed to reality from the words of a fine philosopher and speaker (who can explain the chronology of making of your religious mind , remind u of your forgotten childhood , make u feel how stupid it is to assume creation and breakdown your stupidity for u) who can burst that bubble of stupidity , ignorance and false pride otherwise one can be trapped into it for their life. Once the bubble was burst , curious nature of my mind lead to one thing/person from other & i knew the reality as it has always been , not what it was told by my family . There is no creator, there is no god . There is nothing mystical about life on earth. It is a well understood biological and chemical process with function of time. Our complex bodies were not designed by any creator but they are product of a very long period of evolution. Creation of universe , creation of earth , habitabilty of earth , beginning of life , advent of humans - all can't be explained by one word answer - Supernatural God or a Well structured department of many gods . Nothing was planned nowhere , there was no one to plan - it all happened on its own. Everything was a coincidence - it is entirely possible that any of those events whether birth of cosmos or human life may never have happened. But they did and here we are. Answer to everything was based on logics of creationism which were just fallacies , there was no intelligent logic in believing in a creator/god. It seemed very logical then but now i know false logic and fallacies better than most. It really was my renaissance. I had a worldview which i was supposed to have if i were born into a modern , well-read , learned family with open minds and curiosity.
It is very frustrating to continue live with people of same mind after one himself has clearity. I know that they will never have their renaissance for i understood their bigotry very well and i know it takes a lot of intellectual exercise and upheavel in all circles of mind to come out of it. I know it will never be possible for them for they have lost their curious nature completely and they know it all. It is frustrating but i continue the act of believer to not look like a rebel but i also register my disinterest many times (not repetitively and always because then the bunch of nasty idiots might feel offended). I can only try to make my disinterest look normal as much as possible but i can never tell them completely what i think of them and their understanding about everything.
Trying to reform and change their thoughts out of compassion is a very bad and dangerous idea because that means idiots will know what i think and then that nasty name calling and what not will happen. Having understood my parents, siblings , cousins and the bloody whole extended family, the very expectation of them understanding me is far fetched, stupid, tiring, worthless and dangerous because once they know me i will loose my shield forever.
Sadhguru roast was epic!!!
Little correction Hindu's are seeker's not believers!!
Don't just parrot padguru one liners without thinking, or else you stand to get ridiculed like him. So do you mean Hindus don't have any beliefs? None at all?
Woah wtf u r gi joe show
But some hindus try to make them their believers
Most common Hindu people don't know anything about Hindu philosophies.They are just believers who shout out jai shreeram
I am a first-time viewer but dude, good one. We need more people like you. Even though these religions are required to be followed by the people who can't grasp the idea of good and evil without a religion.
I am a religious person, and the question is, how do you conclude that a religious person is not skeptical about the world? I mean, we do accept that there are small organisms called bacteria and viruses, radiation, and whatnot. The only difference we have, I think, is the question of existence. Otherwise, like atheism, it is a worldview, except for one thing: religious people believe in eternal life, which can't be proven wrong using any scientific tools.
So, if a person believes in a particular religion and expects an eternal life, they behave in a certain manner, and otherwise, they can live as they want. I mean, if not drinking alcohol is not causing them any harm, then why would they question it? What is the use of being skeptical there?
Pseudoscientist spotted
What's is the evidence for an eternal life? Burden of proof is on the claim that there is a life after death. Not the other way around
@@robinroy3436 I have somehow developed the tolerance to read such fallacious comments. Anyway, I'm not expecting more from you.
@@lukadoncic9355 i am saying that there is NO scientific evidence for any eternal life(as of now), yet can be proven once you accept to the fundamental principles of that particular religion.
for example, prophecies about future and miracles.
@@adilct3467 Why should one if the fundamentals of the said religion don't have evidence behind them. Why is saying 'I don't know' not enough till the time there is evidence?
Hi, just a quick question, since you find an atheist who is not a sceptic is a red flag, do you imply that the logical conclusion of scepticism is atheism?
agnostic atheism, yes
@@scienceisdope Ok, is that a position you hold impenetrable to scepticism itself? You can always be doubtful or ask why to your own conclusion. Am I right?
It's basically saying I don't know. What's the point of asking why to that?
@@scienceisdope@scienceisdope I am fine with your agnostic position or asking the question 'why' to the world around you. But here, you take the position of being an atheist. Or, more specifically, how did you conclude atheism is true by asking 'why'?
Ask a highly influenced Atheist: How and why did you come to this earth and where will you go after death? Can science make someone immortal? Why was this universe created?
Why was the universe created? That's a very absurd question, because using the word created preassumes a creation which preassumes a created. And reason is human made quality which cannot be asserted towards a non human thing i.e universe
@@raktimamchiforthe4thtime445Typical atheist reply who either negates or doesn't know the principle of sufficient reasoning.
Don't know brother. Will keep you in loop when there's evidence
Because I dont have an answer to a question doesn't mean I have to accept your bs. Better have an empty hole than a hole filled with rubbish.
@@lookintoit4537 osho also said similar thing, osho said: Nietzsche did great service to humanity by saying god is dead but didn't give anything just take away the false hope" buddha give the world meditation which is the solution, to fill this void of meaning through bliss and enlightenment.in this point questioner mind ego dropped and merge with universal consciousness.
Bro, please debunk Vastu Shastra… been asking for a long time. 😢
Atheist won ❤
Majority of the world is still religious 😂
@@lopave6 that's why there are wars 😆
@@aishwarykalosia7129reason of Afghanistan vs Pakistan conflict? Any comments.
@@korosensei2930 Right wing extremism by Islamic group TALIBAN
@@aishwarykalosia7129 the problem is with too much religions hence war are happening 👍 religion who believes in love and peace is always better and what's athiest won isn't that superiority complex and extreme ego u aren't special or anything if u won aur something
Hey Pranav! All your videos make such good points and you call out all the misleading information, especially in Hinduism (across your channel) and Christianity (in this video). I feel like a lot of people also need to have their eyes opened to all the myths and so-called “facts” from Islam and Christianity.
The Iron age as come, the bhagwatgeeta speaks truth and it has been proven now. May the Shree Krishna bless us all.
There is definitely a role for religion in this world. As humans trying to understand the world and reality that we exist in, religion is a good first step.
It's when the religion becomes dogmatic that the whole thing falls apart. It is when children are told that God will punish them or reward them for their actions, or fulfill their desires for obedience, that religion falters.
I believe that some indoctrination in the form of stories, mythologies, participating in rituals, is inevitable as part of a religious following, but this should necessarily lead to a self guided search at some point, not perpetual subjugation to a purportedly divine being
Support me at:
Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_
Nas IO: nas.io/scienceisdope
YT Membership: ua-cam.com/channels/g--ENXdDpXh5LyLigolg2g.htmljoin
UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support )
If u done begging I would like to tell u that if u hate religion that's totally ok and I respect that,, If u wanna debunk certain con guys who operates in the name of religion that's ok too,, but the moment u cross the line and try to preach and force your atheistic belief (even in indirect ways like this video) then I had to say that it would be hard for me and many Others of your viewers to follow u. Make this a learning channel don't turn this one into
A expose, roast and atheistic preaching channel.
@@jjbankai3108 No religions hate humanity. Said Bhagat Singh.
@Allinoneanime-fj5tz first of all, thanks for your consideration and tolerance, I myself an agnostic person and I believe in God(not in religions) . But there's no proof of his existence again due to lack pf evidence u can't deny his existence (The character and nature of god is still not known, who knows maybe nature itself is god or whatever) but in my last comment I didn’t talked about proving anything I was just hoping that he Don't hurt religious sentiments ( forceful or videos without concrete reasons). I hope u understood that,, just there’s no evidence or even those being ridiculous doesn’t give us the right to bunk on them (if they are not harming anybody)
Pin this message
@@jjbankai3108 This is my profession and this is how I earn a living. If you think this is begging, then you're also a beggar, begging to your boss at the end of every month.
Society created God to deal with morals (and morals are subjective) and a coping mechanism for death because it sucks when people die. You don't get to see them anymore and that's it. People didn't like this, and went well, "what if we can see them in the stars?" and so that's kinda the whole idea of religion and whatnot. Then people capitalized on it and made it more a business then a nice thing to believe. I personally don't believe in a god and I should have the right to do so. As well as people practicing religion that is their choice as long as they don't put it on other people or cause harm to people.
Don't we should try to know the truth behind all these things despite saying it wrong? I am worshipper of the upnishad. Being a student of acharya Prashant, i am extremely impressed to say that we should belive in science amd philosophy which emaluate from the upnishads and Vedant.
In this channel, you're discussing a topic, namely, science, which you have a strong grasp of. I support your expertise in this area. However, when you delve into another topic, such as religion in relation to science, your understanding appears to be lacking. This lack of understanding is not justified. This is nonsensical. I propose arranging a debate with a well-known scholar to see how long you can sustain with your arguments.
It's worth noting that you're also generating income under the guise of discussing religion, which, in essence, seems to be a similar endeavor but in a more concealed manner. My suggestion is to focus on educating people about science, which could potentially lead them to question or leave their religious beliefs. Isn't it as straightforward as that?
Hi Pranav, your videos are really good. I think we should discuss on J.Krishnamurti’s teachings which are more relevant in the present world
Religion is essential for children so that they have some fear of bad deeds. Adults can not always take care of their activities, so things like “God is always watching you and punish you if you do bad deeds” are effective in North India. Upon adolescent and adulthood, they gradually learn about science, if the kid is studious. Otherwise they should remain blinded by religious dogmas. Imagine, the wealth Jains and baniya begin eating meat! Carbon footprint of India will increase steeply. Religion is important to control ignorant people.
yeah i mean we have a law system that can be used instead like????
@@smellyfut4277there is law for rape but we people still rape but let see if we say rape is bad , you will go to hell , people develop little fear
@@AlbertEinstein-cs9do then teach your people well, because thiests in general still commit crimes
@@AlbertEinstein-cs9do
Despite the fear of hell, people in the past still committed crimes, possibly even more than today, because the legal system back then was not as well-established as it is now.
There is a video put forth by soch in his youtube channel. He mentioned of an Indian American acting student who came here to experiment as to how much people believe Godmen and their words. He dressed as a Godman and started blabbering words. Few months down the lane many praised him, said he is God sent man and stuff. All thanks to the placebo affect.
P. S. : This is a secondary source for me. Please do go find it if u want to verify
Wow! Interesting, the fascination for God or Godmen will continue, until science can show that there is no God, or that Chimpanzee is giving birth to a human baby or chemical reactions can produce lives.
Lol ,ye woi Quran ha Jo kheta ha
Maa baap ki iazat karu
Mere leye sab se Acha wo ha jisne Apne maa baap ki iazat ki
Next Quran said
Ailm hasil karna haar muslmaan marad uraat Ka Faraz ha
Quran said
Apne tamam bachon ke sath bara bar Ka raweya rkhu
Quran said
Ager tum kouch Khana banao or USki khusbu tumhare parosi tak jae Tu tumhare Faraz ha tum use bhi Khana dena huga
Quran said
Neighbors se ache raweya se baat karu
Quran said
Apni ulaad pe kharacha karu
Unhe achi tarbeyat do
Jhoot na bolo
Louie ck in science is dope video is a big surprise!❤
Absolutely brilliant!
You're right we should think critically but country like India where majority live beyond poverty line it's hard to think critically
I have seen many atheists,but all seem to be biased towards Islam
then you have seen wrong people lmao
@@smellyfut4277 I know, all atheists are wrong
@@ubaidu11ah then you are the wrong people lmao
@@smellyfut4277 I'm not an idio- ,sorry atheist
@@ubaidu11ah no lol
One of the best video i seen ever on UA-cam ❤
Practical learning
Do not compare Sanatan Dharma with Abrahamic religions.
Sadhguru is not an authority of Hinduism. At least try to read Advait Vedant before making any statements.
@@batmanbabaPadhle bhai jee hai
@@batmanbabahow long do you wanna have my post to be?
A proper plan of living a life
Brahmacharya
Grihastha
Etc...
Most books dedicated to philosophies
Debates(Shankara digvijay and many more)
Epics(itihas)
Schools of thought like sankhya vedanta
@@batmanbaba better for you to focus on jee
Hinduism ain't your cup of tea
The word kama is mistranslated to lust and sex but in truth it also means desire pleasure (not only sexual pleasure)
Kamdev is god of love
religion is religion. religion is bs. period.
@@batmanbabanothing special, it is philosophical culture which doesn't have to pass a science test.
Will surely teach my child how to be skeptic... And ask questions..