MOTHER 3 (GBA) vs. MOTHER 3: Tribute - Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 лют 2022
- A shot-for-shot comparison between the original MOTHER 3 on the Game Boy Advance and our MOTHER 3: Tribute trailer.
Check out 4k screenshots and character renders at mother3tribute.com
Listen to the music:
scruffymusic.bandcamp.com/alb...
TWITTER: / curiomatic
PATREON: / curiomatic
DISCORD: / discord
#Mother3Tribute #Mother3 - Ігри
Seeing this side by side even makes it more impressive as to how well you completely nailed all of the shots. Absolutely beautifully done.
HEY LOOK IT'S THE GUY WHO UPLOADED THE UNDERTALE OST LOOLLLLOLOLOLOLOLOL
@@mika_iran Hey look, a totally original comment.
@@CheddarVG a totally original reply to an original comment
Elu will never live down the fact he'll be known as "the undertale ost guy"
Hey look it’s the guy I beat in squad strike at too many games 😉 what up though
hey look is a buddy
I really like the claymation-ish look of this tribute, it fits the nature of Mother’s art style so perfectly
Reminds me of the link's awakening remake on the switch
@@Tonatact That is true, perhaps this is why it feels like this could be an official product and no one would bat an eye
@@Tonatact I was reminded of the 3DS Mario and Luigi games, though that might just be because I have no experience with the Link's Awakening remake.
@@devonm042690 I could understand how you saw that
Well the mother characters have original clay models so it definitely fits well
My friend was a part of the development team for Crypt of the Necromancer. They had this idea to create a Zelda themed one for fun and realized they were on to something and it would sell. They made a demo and sent it to Nintendo to get their thoughts and blessings to license out the IP. This game was actually created and is out titled Cadence of Hyrule
. Please do the same thing with this! Get the word out.
Please🙏 listen to this man, we need jewels like this more
Problems lie with the (brilliant) fan translation, I think. Unless they want to localize it from the ground up the Nintendo suits won't like it one bit.
Tell your friend he helped to make an amazing game
Maybe they should do this but with Mother 1 or 2, cause they apparently don't want to localize Mother 3
@@JohnDoe-id5ih but mother 1 & 2 are already on the switch so a mother 3 remake would be the best option because i dont think nintendo will release free GBA games on the switch
I love how each and every one of the character's models is EXACTLY how I imagined them. They're very faithful
Woah I don't think I've ever realized just how cinematic the original is
A lot of the visual gags in the original are insanely well done for a game made with such hardware limitations. Guess its true that limitations sometimes bring out true creativity.
@@NoahKPeters Mother 3 has incredibly animated, emotive sprites!
@Manuel Z ♪ buzz off
Incredibly faithful rendition , absolutely beautiful
God I wish that this was a real remake
same
Nintendo doesn't like money lol
Same
Honestly a remake like this would be the best way to get mother 3 outside of japan, if the only things stopping them are things like the magypsies. It wouldn't feel like the same game if they did change that, obviously, but if they did want to release it outside of japan and stuff like that was the only issue, a remake would be an amazing way to bring it over. (Though something tells me they don't want to change anything about the game, so if mother 3 is ever going to come to anywhere outside japan, it'll be a while.)
@@lxcidanalogy8414 There's way more concerning stuff in Mother 3 besides the magypsises
Nintendo doesn’t even realize how much potential the Mother series has. I think it would be super popular with newer gamers today. This just shows it’s potential. Nicely done!
The problem is not with Nintendo, the problem is with the series creator... as he considers his work, the mother series, concluded.
@@Genojo A remake wouldn't hurt tho
@@Genojo Yeah the mother series is a perfect trilogy, that just means that it makes more sense to remaster the trilogy for this day and age.
@@_vair_ The problem remains the same, sadly. I would love to see a remake like the one showed in this video, but the creator of the series is a special guy. And i dont think he would allow nintendo to do so, wich is sad.
@@Genojo Dude never said he was against any future installments, just that he wouldn't be involved as he lost the drive to make them himself. Also...did you just call him retarded?
This could be genuinely pitched to Nintendo. With the amount of people cheering this fantastic tribute on I think it would be possible. The Crypt of the Necrodancer + Zelda crossover was a dream come true, so something as ambitious as this would absolutely light a fire under their asses. Go get 'em.
They should show it to the creator of mother 3 and see what he thinks
@@BlastKetchup the director of Mother 3 has recently expressed interest in a localization from Nintendo, so I don’t think he would be involved in any rerelease but I’m sure he would appreciate it
@@BlastKetchup Itoi is very happy with all the fan creations surrounding the mother series. If you look on his twitter you can see him reposting mother stuff almost every day, including the tweet teasing the original tribute video!
Ooooor they’ll just DMCA and sue them haha 🥲🥲🥲
@@krissydiggs as muddled as their track record with fans attempt at game-reservation Nintendo is, I think they've never struck down or even tried to touch anything Mother 3 related.
The team did a wonderful job at bringing this game to life.
either you are talking about the actual game
or you are thinking a fan made remake is being made
Absolutely 💯
Your Mother 3 videos has really gotten me into the Earthbound series, I started playing the first game 3 days ago and I love it so far :) Keep up the amazing work!
You should play the fangame Mother Cognitive Dissonance when you're done with all 3!
I would actually recommend starting with the 2nd game first (Earthbound) and and playing the 1st as a prequel, since most people don't like mother 1 that much but if you love it then totally do that!
Like some other comments mentioned. If you get discouraged with Mother 1, Earthbound is best to start with.
You should save yourself a lot of trouble and start with earthbound or mother 3. Mother 1 is a good game, but it has some of the worst, most unfair grinding and difficulty spikes I’ve ever seen in an RPG
@@maxfecteau i wouldnt start with mother 3 cuz references/characters from Earthbound
This is the best 2D to 3D translation I’ve ever seen. Hands down. Legit better than any official series or game that’s ever done it. You absolutely NAILED the feel of the original and it still looks amazing and modern. Amazing modelling , textures , and animation
THIS IS INSANE
These people understood the assignment.
Ever since Link's Awakening's remake on Switch, I had imagined a remake of the entire MOTHER trilogy using a claymation-style aesthetic as its base.
Looks like I wasn't the only one ♥
I'd buy it.
i’d buy the collector's edition, digital, physical,....
This is AMAZINGLY well-crafted. The animations, the world, the enemy encounters. These are incredibly well realized!! You guys really captured the essence of Mother series in this. SERIOUSLY THOUGH, this style even as a new IP and spiritual successor would be mind-blowing and something that I'd absolutely want to play!
🥲😐😥😭
The emotional rollercoaster from knowing how awesome this is, to realizing it's not real.
STOP - THIS LOOKS SO AMAZING, YOU'RE GOING TO MAKE US CRY
No crying until the end
@@rebornotherlan you haven't likes enough 🤩👍
@@rebornotherlan Nice, from the old Earthbound commercial.
Finally a tribute that isnt just Unreal with random realistic assets. Beautifully created, great art style.
the fact that it's actually possible to get remakes like this nowadays (like ttyd as an example)
As someone with the gba version, these represent the original fonts and graphics and the atmosphere of playing them on an actual console really well
Literally speechless right now, every time I see this tribute I’m blown away! Amazing job
@Manuel Z self promoter lmao
how does a gust of wind blow you away its not like wind is that strong
Wow. Just... wow! This is amazing!
A blend between zelda links awakening remake and the clay style from original concept art
Beautifully done!
This is literal perfection. I've never wanted a Mother 3 3D remake more than now. This is all I currently need
Was waiting for a side by side comparison like this! Outstanding work on this project, Curiomatic!
Really shows off how incredible you guys hit the tone for every aspect of the game!
@Manuel Z Can you stop posting your sh!t on everyone else’s comments!?
I love how you replicate that stopmotion feel. This is looking beautifully awesome!
These videos made me the happiest I’ve been in a while i love your work so much
haha, I was thinking about making something like this!! thanks again for making this, you've made so many people happy :-]
I really wish what u guys made was a real game lol, its just perfect, its like what people want Nintendo to do to their old games.
This looks so nice! That ending gave me goosebumps lol. To the team making this, I want to say you guys are wonderful.
Absolutely awesome! You all nailed it. Love the creativity behind it.
I like cannot believe this exists. This is so magical. Thank you all so much. Your Smashified videos were very inspiring to me getting into art professionally, and your consistently high quality work never fails to disappoint!
the amount of content in this is insanely impressive. Fantastic work
AHH, MY HEART. THIS IS AMAZING. It literally brought a tear to my eye. Captures the charm and adds to it with the animation. Fantastic work!!!!
Wow this is truly incredible!! You worked your ass off!! Thank you! You are extremely talented!
This is amazing, seeing a side by side comparison makes it all the greater.
This is just too perfect, unfortunatelly, too perfect to be real.
Amazing work, just unbelievable production value.
Outstanding. Never played any of this series's games, but you got me interested haha. Nice work on the content!
Your added elements and items blend together so beautifully that I thought you were recreating the original screen until I saw the comparison video.
If a remake is not possible, I'd love to see a movie like this!
I hope Nintendo hire this team or something! Would love to play something like this!
I hope they won't sue them.
You're assuming Nintendo doesn't completely have their head up their ass like they do these days. Make something new, or even reboot something? Nah, just rerelease a 20 something year old game and charge full price for it.
We'll be lucky if they don't sue them
for Nintendo to be interested in doing the remake of mother 3 they should not release a demo on PC, since for that reason Nintendo blocks fangames, the most advisable thing would be to show the project to Nintendo directly, the easiest thing would be in Nintendo of America. ..I think
@@octaviusmalkova4916 yeah Mario and Zelda are their biggest franchises and they don't even get stuff like this that often
The sound design is incredible with all of the subtle noises and attention to detail with each scene.
this is amazing, you're very talented!
This is amazing! I would buy this day one. Thank you, it was fantastic getting to see this.
Y’know, the Link’s Awakening remake really reminded me of Mother/EarthBound. Specifically, LA’s toy-like ascetics reminded me of the Mother/EarthBound art using clay figures. This also really reminds me of that. Excellent, faithful work!
There are no official 3d Mother assets. The clay renders you are thinking of are don't by a fan.
It’s amazing how you could capture the style of mother and transition it to 3D and not only keep its artistic charm but arguably enhancing it by 1400!
Got legit emotional from how beautifully and lovingly this was made; brilliant work!
This video just shows the amount of care and love put in to this fan trailer. Stuff like the enemy attacks in battles being fully animated, Lucas hugging Boney, and the more cinematic camera angles it all shows the amount of effort put in to this recreation.
Watching this side by side shows how careful the team behind this project was to keep fidelity and respect to the original game. It is mesmerizing to watch, and makes me want a MOTHER 3 remake more than ever now.
I just cannot believe how much this looks straight from Nintendo themselves. It just looks so finely crafted
This looks amazing. Great job. The animations were so good
This is the most faithful recreaction of something that I have ever seen in my entire life! Good job to the creators of this!
I love that it kinda comes off like a claymation. Not sure if I've every personally seen that done in a game. Please correct me if I'm wrong because I'd love to know if any other games have adopted a similar style.
kirby and the rainbow curze goes for claymation right down to having a lower framerate to simulate stop-motion but that's the only other game i can think of with a similar aesthetic 😔
the only point in which i would say i actually like the original game more is on the sunflower fields part, most shadows seem to have been removed (probably for authenticity) and it kind of lacks that magical feeling i think it deserves, i think the clouds should have been made fuzzier (i don't know if that's actually the way to say it) like the original game and what i thought of was a lighting similar to the one seen in the skies of the botw sequel trailer, though that minor problem of course doesn't remove how amazing this project is and i'd say most of the other parts shown are actually a 10/10, my favorite moment was definitely the Claus drago play-fighting, the lighting is just amazing, the textures really give it that clay feel and the music (chords i think?) in that exact moment really make it feel beautiful.
I see what you mean by the fuzzy clouds. In the original, they go kinda...bzzt.
I think the word you're looking for is hazy.
Amé tu tributo/ i really love your job with this, thanks for creating something so beautiful :)
The flying bird cage was one of my favorite parts of the game. Thank you for including it.
This is too good to be legit. Absolutely amazing.
Thank you. That is all.
Speachless... Keep it going. This tribute is on point, congratulations.
I was hoping to see a comparison, always love to see these kind of videos :)
I never caught the shadow at 0:56 the first time I watched it! Much more subtle, yet foreboding!
This is actually unreal
It's actually Unity! (badum tss!)
I like to think that there's a timeline where this rendition exists as a full game, so beautiful!
Amazing work! I' ve never played mother but seeing it like this makes me want to.
You guys must get hired
gorgeous, this is one of my favorite games and it would mix so well with this artstyle.
Part of me feels like they are lying about this not being a game. Imagine they completely finish this, and drop it on the internet with no announcement to avoid a cease and desist from finishing the development.
I wish Nintendo cared this much about their beloved series. This is amazing. Stunning work.
Oh my god. I'm gonna cry. It's soo beautiful. I love that the frame rate for the animations kinda makes it seem like stop motion. It's perfect.
This is absolutely amazing! Well done!
This has raised the bar for fangames. It’s beautiful. Sadly though I’m expecting it to be taken down.
Has it though? While very impressive none of it is actually in a playable state. Its simply a proof of concept fan animation and not an actual fangame, which would've taken the team far more time and effort to develop.
Nintendo doesn't fully or even mostly own mother so they can't take fan projects down without Itoi's go ahead which he would never give
It isnt a fangame sadly
What is the music track? I know it's a combination of songs but is it like an original rendition? If so, is it on your channel? I'd like to listen to it on its own. It's pretty good.
The tracks are available on bandcamp here: scruffymusic.bandcamp.com/album/mother-3-tribute-soundtrack-album
Aww it looks amazing you did such an amazing job😍
You can see all the love that the team put in this, I think this is one of the most beautifuls tribute I've ever seen for anything
The problem with making godlike fake trailers like this is that now I'm completely sold on a game that isn't being made 🙃
Nintendo do be sleeping on this gem.
This is absolutely amazing. Well done!
Dang… this is GOURGEOUS. The art style is perfect, and you even added little animations which perfectly fit the style of the original game, such as the tree falling as an attack.
This tribute is actually super faithful and has a style of its own. Very well done.
I absolutely LOVE this! The attention to detail is amazing for my favorite game of all time!
my god
i love this claymation style you have going on
it's oddly fitting
I never comment on UA-cam videos, because I'm not a crazy person, but I had to here. This is such a stellar example of how to improve upon an older title visually, while absolutely nailing the vibe and artistic integrity of the original. So many people miss the mark, whether it be an official remaster/remake doing almost nothing or completely smearing the vision of the original, or an overproduced fan video that looks like they just found out what Global Illumination and bloom are. But this is a god damned work of art. You killed it. Wish there were more eyes like yours on remaster/remake projects, hope you guys find success whatever you go on to do.
It looks like they had a lot of fun making this. Also, I really like how it looks like claymation with the missing frames.
Phenomenal, truly impressive just how much care went into matching every little detail of the original game, fantastic work.
What a wonderful job you have done here.
This looks so good! I love the stop motion feel to it.
that stop-motion like movement is absolutely gorgeous!
oh, my, god this is in absolute the best remake trailer tribute I have see, this work is simply A M A Z I N G i never played mother series but i wish I can play it now
this is simply beautiful, I have no other words. You have a great talent and things like this deserve a very important appreciation. I hope you continue making this type of videos to upload them or for some work. I wish you the best. Greetings 👋💝✨
THIS LOOKS INCREDIBLE! This couldn't possibly look better, really astounding.
So much beautiful detail was put into this
absolutely beautiful work!
this is as high as quality could possibly go, there is literally nothing more after this.
Ok. You have chosen the best art style for this game. It looks beautiful. Great work!
damn u guys are talented af. This looks so legit that one would think it is an official trailer XD
It's so sad that isn't an actual game. You made a beautiful work with this tribute! Love you!
LITERAL CHILLS DUDE this is so amazing I had to watch it multiple times lol
incredible work. i am in awe.
You make me cry, thanks for this.
This is such an outstandingly good art style, you literally nailed every aspect of the original, absolutely 10/10
Really solid work for whoever animated this.
I know they say this about almost all fan projects, but we seriously need this. Looks so good.